Rabbi Responds to the Growing Popularity of Atheism

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 57

  • @rutbrea8796
    @rutbrea8796 Місяць тому +16

    I have a brother who is an atheist, and he says that he believes in science. He is disgusted at me because I believe in the Eternal God. I have been given enough evidence for my faith. I didn't deserve it, but my Eternal God decided to show a couple of things that nothing in this world can. Baruch HaShem!!!

    • @Michael-NYC
      @Michael-NYC Місяць тому +3

      Your brother is not an atheist. An atheist is one who doesn’t believe in anything at all.
      If he believes in science… well yeah he’s not an atheist.
      Perhaps using that mindset that comfort zone due to inner struggles that is so uncomfortable for him, he’ll rather just use these atheistic tools to smooth the pain.
      Please understand when I say this, not knowing your brother, I speak from experience with a personal friend.

    • @pamelakoretsky9909
      @pamelakoretsky9909 Місяць тому +5

      ​@@Michael-NYCno an atheist is literaaly a person who does not believe in the existence of God.

    • @JohnSmith-ej6qx
      @JohnSmith-ej6qx Місяць тому

      I reckon these so called atheists go home, close their doors and say
      "Sorry Lord. I was just showing off in front of my mates"

    • @Michael-NYC
      @Michael-NYC Місяць тому +3

      @@pamelakoretsky9909 thank you for the definition and clarification. Shana Tova

    • @tropicalnofruit1419
      @tropicalnofruit1419 Місяць тому +1

      As a previous atheist, I feel like that may be an issue that’s never resolved. I’ll tell you know though, he prays when he needs it, I hated the idea of ה׳ but couldn’t stop if I needed it. Be good to him, he doesn’t know what he’s missing. I hope he sees the infinite soon.

  • @Bruce-ph9nq
    @Bruce-ph9nq Місяць тому +6

    I have no desire to proclaim atheism. I live rather quietly with it. The cause of my atheism is based on the metaphysical axioms of existence and consciousness. An axiom is a primary fact that can’t be reduced to smaller parts. Existence exists. If nothing existed, there would be nothing to be conscious of. In order for there to be consciousness, something has to exist to be conscious of. A consciousness, divine or human, that precedes anything to be conscious of is a contradiction. So far, I have found no way to resolve this contradiction except to evade it or abandon it and accept that existence is metaphysically primary. Existence has always existed and always will exist. I say this in a welcoming spirit and not intended to be antagonizing to anyone.

    • @simontrober7487
      @simontrober7487 Місяць тому

      Most atheists just go about their daily life. Some atheists shout and scream about it. Same for vegans.

    • @simontrober7487
      @simontrober7487 Місяць тому

      ​@stu1037 Most religions don't proselytise. Christians and Muslims seem to be on every major street corner but I don't see the others.
      Anyone however can take their value system into the Voting Booth, that should be no issue. When they make an case for their position it just can't be from an 'authority figure'' that others don't recognise e.g. from God, a book.

    • @djnofly
      @djnofly 5 днів тому

      @@simontrober7487 Most? What is your sample size? Who have you surveyed? How is this? All people who see a lie about something... Don't like it.

  • @LRS-u8p
    @LRS-u8p Місяць тому +3

    This is life changing ! I need to hear this a few times.

  • @rutbrea8796
    @rutbrea8796 Місяць тому +3

    To be created out of a need is what I always believe. HaShem Elohim Tzevaot needed to have a family. Just being God is not enough. He has needs, and we are His need ❤️ ♥️ 💜

  • @ricsancho
    @ricsancho Місяць тому

    Great full for finally understanding the bottom line of many things in life with Torah 🎊 🎉
    And I just started listening/learning from Jewish teachings a couple of years back.
    Absolutely I want all of us to be One with G-d.

  • @Marta...8877
    @Marta...8877 Місяць тому +4

    😂 "no my dust"

  • @lucyfoster8624
    @lucyfoster8624 Місяць тому +1

    God is the giver and we are the receiver. He wants our gratitude. The reason we are here is to fulfill that purpose, which is the only purpose. The rest is insidential, so make the rest righteous.

  • @jbmyerov
    @jbmyerov Місяць тому +5

    It is perfectly possible to be a committed Jew and also to be what would technically be called an atheist. We don’t believe that G-d exists in the same way as a rock exists. The Jewish concept of God’s existence is not like what other major religions claim for themselves. People get all worked up about atheism and believing in God or not, but it usually has little to do with Judaism or Jewish life. For those who want to insist they don’t believe in G-d, the proper answer is “Good. Now go and study.”

    • @keithnicholas
      @keithnicholas Місяць тому

      isn't that just Jewish culture then? rather than Jewish Religion?

    • @jbmyerov
      @jbmyerov Місяць тому +2

      @@keithnicholas No, it does not have to be. You can still study Torah, appreciate Gemara, daven and participate in shul, and, yes, explore the vast riches of secular Yiddishkeit. I see Judaism as a doing religion, and through doing we get to think over all of these questions, doubts, arguments, and opinions. Individually, we are all in different places with our beliefs, but collectively we are the same as we always have been.

  • @mikeunknown9072
    @mikeunknown9072 Місяць тому +1

    Religion opened my mind to reality and made me to become “ atheist “.

  • @darrenlewis7001
    @darrenlewis7001 Місяць тому

    I'm an Aluminate' that teaches One Humanitarian Truth Under God and a prophet of God's New World's Testament. The reason I teach 1 true belief about God and Jesus is because there is so many religions and sects of the various religions that religion looks like what it will become more and more; a bunch of man made philosophies about God's word. And this confusion will cause more and more people to walk away from God and the behavior of the world will degrade more and more leading to more sin, wickedness and human suffering. Any persons purpose is to use whatever talents and strengths God has given them to better humanity. As the Bhagavad Gita says "serve the welfare of the world.

  • @baddbeliever
    @baddbeliever Місяць тому

    I finally get rabbi Friedmans idea that God needs us. He doesn't need us to exist
    but he needs "us-to"...(fill in the blank)

  • @djnofly
    @djnofly 5 днів тому

    A am an atheist. Please. Tell me more about how I am a fanatic? Yes. I believe there is no god. I hope that we are able to have our beliefs and allow others to believe what we want. I believe in science, that we need to work together, that we need to have faith in each other. I do not have faith in god.
    I think that your speech is debatable and some of the jokes or insights are mean and lack context. I think it is fair that you have the right to be safe and worship the way you want. I know that none of us are safe. I will leave you with this comment.
    I know there is tyranny, hate, and war because people have agendas and argue us vs. them. Do not divide diverse thought because "First they came". I suggest that finding what you love about people who are different because they are your neighbors, they will stand with you, and speeches that divide us is societal suicide.

  • @rebeccacastillo4789
    @rebeccacastillo4789 Місяць тому

    Thank you Rabbi Friedman ❤

  • @ArtorGrael
    @ArtorGrael Місяць тому

    The proliferation of atheism is about politics. About communism AND GLOBALISM.

  • @k.k.5046
    @k.k.5046 Місяць тому

    G-d of Israel vs Atheists

  • @Imanuel-poetry
    @Imanuel-poetry 23 дні тому

    CONDESCENDING

  • @stms.africa4690
    @stms.africa4690 Місяць тому

    Isn't Torah "absolute".... your really quite duplicicious

  • @mdevorah6833
    @mdevorah6833 Місяць тому

    Athesliests do not believe in a human god, Neither do I.

  • @spiralofhope
    @spiralofhope 16 днів тому +1

    aah yes, basic ignorance about gnostic verses agnostic

  • @gregattanasio3185
    @gregattanasio3185 Місяць тому +3

    I say this to both Muslim and Jewish faiths..
    NO JESUS
    NO PEACE.
    KMOW JESUS
    KNOW PEACE.
    THE WHOLE BIBLE PROCLAIMS THE RISEN SAVIOR.. PEACE TO ALL.
    My many friends of the Torah, told me JESUS, JUST A FAIRY TALE.
    Today , many BELIEVE

    • @pamelakoretsky9909
      @pamelakoretsky9909 Місяць тому

      Funny...Jesus has been the excuse for 2000 years of the exact opposite of peace agianst any who do not believe. You have much in common with extremist Muslims in that respect.

    • @armidaainsworth8843
      @armidaainsworth8843 Місяць тому +1

      Not true....gd forbidds😂human sacrifice and virgin birth is a myth. Many problems with jc and nt

    • @pamelakoretsky9909
      @pamelakoretsky9909 Місяць тому

      @@gregattanasio3185 you sound like an extremist Muslim.

    • @stuartlewis7860
      @stuartlewis7860 Місяць тому

      There is no peace in the World unfortunately. Neither Jesus or anything or anyone else has brought or delivered Peace. Truth!

  • @impendingprophecies6211
    @impendingprophecies6211 Місяць тому +2

    Yes, those Who reject God and his Holy scriptures. They
    Are the atheists of this world. Spirit of the antichrist rules in them. But also when people reject JESUS CHRIST THE MESSIAH . ISAIAH IN THE 9 CHAPTER SPOKE UNTO US A CHILD IS BORN.... REJECTING GOD'S SON JESUS IS ALSO BRINGS TERRIBLE CONSEQUENCES..JESUS SPOKE THESE WORDS. HE WHOBELIEVES IN THE SON HAS EVERLASTING LIFE. AND HE WHO DOES NOT BELIEVE THE SON SHALL NOT SEE LIFE BUT THE WRATH OF GOD ABIDES ON HIMSELF.. rabbi

    • @goodnessgraciousitellya5004
      @goodnessgraciousitellya5004 Місяць тому

      😂

    • @1BestCookie
      @1BestCookie Місяць тому

      That kind of God is very cruel to his people who he created to banish them to Hell even if they tried their best to live a moral life because they didn't call him by the right name or believe a certain story. What did he put u into this world for? He could have kept you in heaven where your eyes are not blocked by materialism and you can see him and not deny him. Why did he create you in this world at all if he knew you are bound to be a sinner here because he is more hidden in this world? Mabe he has a mission for you in this world to make it better and a more just and Godly place, instead of always being preoccupied by what kind of afterlife you will have, for the perfect belief you can stay in heaven. You have no need for a body, before or after death.

  • @infiniti28160
    @infiniti28160 Місяць тому

    the crux of Nachash, the serpent in the garden of eden. Isaiah 5:20 Buddhism is your path to reality. and will show industry and trade is behind the whole game.

    • @pamelakoretsky9909
      @pamelakoretsky9909 Місяць тому +1

      Isaiah doesn't say or mean what you think it does.

    • @infiniti28160
      @infiniti28160 Місяць тому

      @@pamelakoretsky9909 So you can read and i cant? Your comprehension is better than mine? When god made one rule not to eat from the tree of knowledge, one rule alone, only a fool that is ungrateful and bored would twist the story to say god lied. As i wrote above, be a buddhist you will find answers for the paradox
      What shall we say in regard to the question: "Why do the divinities that are invoked require the worshipper to be just, although they themselves when entreated consent to perform unjust acts?" In reply to this I am uncertain in respect to what is meant by "performing unjust acts," as the same definition may not appear right both to us and to the gods. We, on the one hand, looking to that which is least significant, consider the things that are present, the momentary life, what it is and how it originates. The beings superior to us, let me say, know for certain the whole life of the soul and all its former lives; and if they bring on a retribution from the supplication of those who invoke them, they do not increase it beyond what is just. On the contrary, they aim at the sins impressed upon the soul in former lifetimes, which men do not perceive, and so imagine that is unjust that they fall into the misfortunes which they suffer.
      Iamblichus -- The Egyptian Mysteries

    • @pamelakoretsky9909
      @pamelakoretsky9909 Місяць тому

      @@infiniti28160 ill stop with your leading question. Yes. I test in the top 3 percentile for comprehension and retention. So......

    • @infiniti28160
      @infiniti28160 Місяць тому

      @@pamelakoretsky9909 Im not leading any question, but pointing out a difference of perceptions. Where the christian understands this to be original sin, rabinnic judaism turns it around saying it what god desired. If it is the rabinnic understanding of a returning to what is called the land of israel so a meshiach can rule the world, where is the rectification of gods rule upon earth? As you claim to be top 3 percent in comprehensive skills and retention, this is a piece of cake for you to answer.

  • @johnadams8902
    @johnadams8902 Місяць тому +1

    Rabbi Yaron Reuven has done several videos concerning the Rabbi speaking. I would suggest anyone reading this post to look at those videos.

    • @leongreen5332
      @leongreen5332 Місяць тому

      Rabbi Yaron Reuven is bitter, jealous man.

  • @augex015
    @augex015 Місяць тому

    boring

  • @NicholasMascarenhas
    @NicholasMascarenhas Місяць тому

    I AM FROM INDIA , WILLING TO FIGHT WITH HIM , STUDIED THE HOLY TORAH FROM MANY YEARS ...........