What If Anakin Skywalker CONVINCED MACE WINDU To Arrest Palpatine
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 сер 2023
- Thoughts on todays fan fiction? I hope you enjoy, and have a great day!💚💙
#darthvader #starwars #anakin #anakinskywalker #revengeofthesith #clonewars #ahsoka #starwarswhatif #georgelucas - Розваги
I like some of these twists and they are often more logical than what happened in the real material.
Glad you enjoy!
Mace Windu is actually Jules from Pulp Fiction. He’s a killer, not a Jedi
They had to twist Anakin Skywalker, and only had 3 movies.
Movie one should have had him as a teenager already, then something happens to show he's the chosen one. Along with a slave back story.
Then you have 2 movies to make him evil
Same.
@@thestarwarsgalaxyDo you think Mace Windu really died
You're quickly becoming one of my favorite storytellers.
I absolutely LOVE stories where Anakin and Windu develop a bond, or at least mutual respect.
I agree with this wholeheartedly
As it should have been if sidious didn't have claws into Anakin!
They did try to arrest him, but he attacked them first, he never attempted to talk himself out the situation.
That's one area where the novelization was much better at explaining things. Palpatine actually selectively records the encounter in a way that implies the Jedi are either persecuting him for religious beliefs or are actually there to try and kill him from the start, leaving out any incitement on his part to make himself look like the villain.
I love when stories highlight that the Empire has all but risen at this point. Things would have been bad if Sidious was arrested or killed in the Chancellor's office because being a Sith isn't exactly a crime.
Being a Sith isn't a crime.
Double-dealing and orchestrating a war from both sides, though...
@@VestedUTuberIt's treason, then
Actually, in the original timeline, being a Sith was a crime. Darth Bane: Path of Destruction states that the senate had declared the Sith an illegal organization after the Jedi Civil War in ~4000 BBY, and that law was still around in 1000 BBY, as that's when the novel takes place. We have no sources stating that law was removed between 1000 BBY and 19 BBY, so it can be assumed to still be on the books.
@@VestedUTuber It actually was a crime to be a Sith in the original timeline.
@@jamesleduke873 It was pointed out in ROTS novel when the Jedi came to arrest him that being a Sith was legal.
Couldn't palp just yell execute order 66 in the senate hall then use the confusion to escape as all hell breaks loose.
Palpatine had an emergency order of he was arrested for the recording to be played.
This was a great fan fiction, im so excited for Ashoka and i think in honor of the Ashoka show you should do “what if Sabine was force sensitive”
I want to see if she actually is force sensitive. Super excited for the show!
@@thestarwarsgalaxyin the last trailer they put out Ahsoka says some things that make it seem like she is so ….
I'll just watch the show instead of listening to rumors about Sabine Wren.
"Let me put these handcuffs... um... OK, we need another plan."
The DARTH JAH JAH started to dance
Your use of the RotS novel is greatly appreciated
Awesome story! And very believable. Also like the insert from the novelization about the transcript. Recognized it immediately.
Love that. I love putting stuff from the novels in these, glad you recognized it!
@@thestarwarsgalaxy Picked it up in New Mexico, I think it was, back in the early 2000's, just to pass the time after a hard day's driving. Really started me down the path that some would say is....unnatural....
What if Anakin convinced the council to grant him the rank of a master claiming hes work in the CLONE WARS,SAVING THE CHANCELLOR,CAPTURE OF BARRIS OFFE PLUS THE HYPROCICY OF THE COUNCIL WITH DOOKU N ASHOKA ETC
Just leave out the part where he's constantly uses the darkside
@@okwayz4438But didn't Windu use it, too? Yet he's on the council.
@@WorldWalker128 Windu uses the dark side in a matter that he wouldn't fall to the dark side
@YourLocalSoxFan20 but palp still uses the darkside so why can mace windu use the darkside (for whatever reason it doesn't matter what the reason is) why can't anakin if they stick to that they should tell mace if he continues to use the darkside he will loose his seat. Ohhh what if anakin made mace give up his seat on the council due to his darkside uses and Yoda agrees?
After Palpatine killed 3 Jedi Masters for coming to arrest him(not kill him), how was it going to be "Cold Blood" if Mace decided to follow through with Killing Sheev. Remember, while the Jedi DID ignite their Lightsabers, the Chancellor attacked 1st. Also, I do understand Palps was unarmed, but only after Mace Kicked him and Sidious dropped his saber as he fell to the floor. He did not give up willingly and attempted to fry Mace he said "You are Under Arrest, my lord." While it is not the Jedi way, killing Go For Papa Palpatine at that moment would not be in Cold Blood IMO considering what transpired in his office after the Jedi attempted to Arrest him.
Yeah, shouldn’t have put that line in there
Everybody's a critic
This scenario is incomplete. Arresting Palpatine before he could initiate order 66 means that Rex and his clones never crashed the ship, and Ahsoka made it back to Coruscant with Maul who could easily testify to Palpatine’s many crimes.
True
It would make a cool scene if that happened. Would maul agree to testify? Also what would happen to maul/what would he do afterwards
Maul wouldn’t testify just to see the Jedi burn. He hates Obi-Wan more then Sidious
@@TheUncivilizedNation I doubt that very much.
@@TheUncivilizedNationcertainly not at the end. I think it was very clear at his death that he had come to terms with his past grudges with Kenobi.
Love this. ^^
Though an opportunity was missed.
Something that would've given this more depth.
Am gonna quote a line from Star War's Episode 3: Revenge Of The Sith.
Mace ~ If what you've told me is true you will have gained my trust.
So then during the Jedi Council meeting following the event's that took place in the office, Mace could've said the following to all Jedi present either physically or by hologram.
Mace ~ Anakin has gained my trust.
With the weight Mace carries in the Jedi Council just imagine how impactful that would've been and he would be keeping his word to Anakin which would've immensely helped Anakin with his trust issues toward the Jedi Council and by extention Mace himself.
either your mouth is 1mm away from the mic or my headphones are loud
If Windu kills Palpatine, no order 66, Padme doesn't die, No Death Star, No destruction of Aldrean, no trillions killed and etc!
That my actually happen actual remember madam Ada did know about order 66 and could blame the jedi for killing palps unjustly and do it
@@thepharoah3248 I became one with the force after reading this
@@technicaldragon4607 I’m sorry I can’t spell plaps right hand man name
All i see here are the cons
How about some of the positives?
@@lavish263team5 Nate Gunray survives - that's a net positive. He will definitely start another blockade and deploy troops until victory is achieved.
This was an absolute amazing video dude. Was on edge right up to the trial! That heroic moment of Anakin's really showed his true personality.
Bruh Anakin legit pointed out that palpatine is a massive manipulator and then proceeds to try and manipulate Anakin more. 😂
what if anakin did not kill a single jedi on Order 66
That was another terrifically great and sensationally spectacular alternate history take on starwars. As Sidious always forgets the little people or details once he has used and discarded them and was deliciously ironic to see his former sins in respect of the naboo crisis and before being his downfall.
Great 'what-if' video dude.
Now granted there were many factors that contributed to Anakin turning to the Dark Side and becoming a Sith Lord, but I've always personally believed that one of BIGGEST reason was simply because Master Mace Windu NEVER trusted Anakin. Not only that, but going SOLELY by what we saw on-screen in the Prequel Trilogy my opinion has always been that it seemed like Mace Windu actually WANTED Anakin to fail as a Jedi.
And I've personally always thought that was COMPLETELY the wrong approach for Mace to take towards Anakin, because like Anakin Mace had a natural affinity for the Dark Side.
TRUE, Mace Windu had the training and practice and experience to harness the Dark Side WITHOUT letting it corrupt him and ALSO remain true to the Jedi Order, but I've always felt that Mace, in his ARROGANCE, didn't even CONSIDER the fact that with proper training Anakin could do the same thing.
So I like your 'what-if' scenario here, where Mace Windu actually LISTENED to Anakin, and instead of essentially MURDERING an unarmed and defeated Supreme Chancellor Palpatine (AKA Darth Sidious) actually adhered to the Jedi Code and Ideology and instead took Palpatine into custody.
But regardless of my opinion, again great video.
that obi won pic you used has so much side eye!!! Also I feel like this is one of the most logical stories I've heard in a while, like this all seems more realistic than the movies as far as character decisions go
being a Sith was a crime in the republic
An epic battle of the senate, the Jedi versus Palpatine in the Senate chamber in Sue’s after learning that Chancellor Palpatine was a Sith Lord, all alarms after he straight down the three Jedi
Awesome as usual, brother. Your stories are way better than the original plot from George Lucas. You deserve to be the writer of Star Wars instead of the trash that Disney is doing.
Nooo George is superior. He created the stories out of thin air, I need all of his vision to create my own! But I very much appreciate your comment!
Absolutely agreed, mr galaxy. George Lucas is superior, but your work is excessively awesome in all the best ways, dearly unknown friend.
@@thestarwarsgalaxyit’s definitely easier to improve on an already complete story than it is to make it from scratch
Everyone has personal beef with Disney star wars, i understand but still, first time we get to see a Cross guard saber. the plot is horrible but I appreciate the sabers
These story twists are excellent. I've listened to a few and they're great!!!
Another great video as usual
Great story mate, nice job! 🤘
Great story I love Anakin cutting Sidious in half
I love how often you include plo koon.
2:26 uh oh!
Loved this, you have real talent
Awesome dude keep up the good work...these all kick ass🤘🤘🤘
One of the best Star Wars theories I’ve ever watched
I haven’t noticed that your stories often address lot line of Yoda, realizing that Jedi order need to allow. Attachments. However, I don’t think that would happen in this situation. Because not enough negative stuff to make Yoda realize things were wrong they still found the Sith Lord and the war ended.
Yoda when talking to Anakin realized he was in a relationship as him having to hide it made him vulnerable to palpys manipulations
This is the chosen one fulfilling his destiny. Imagine how strong he would have gotten
4:38
Obi-Wan: What is the status of Palpetine?
Windu: He's been placed under arrest.
Anakin: You could say he's been... disarmed.
You gotta love light sabres, you can remove an arm and they won’t breed out ☠
Man need more subs for all this work
Omg that was loud and surprising lol
Bro sounds like he's shoving the mic down his trought
Yeah I swallowed it. Help. Jk, fixing it
A skyalker and solo ledgends and cannon free 4 all (in their prime) ( vader, luke , ben sky ,cad,cole,anakin,mara,leia,cadeus,ren,etc
There’s just something I find so funny about Palpatine basically going “oh fuck it” after realising he’s lost all credibility 🤣
What if Windu and the other Jedi Masters carried their own secret recording devices when arresting the chancellor?
The great mistake of the jedi masters was trying to arrest Palpatine without any proof of guilt. If just they informed the senate of the death of General Grievous and wait for the response of Palpatine as a chancillor and return the powers gained during the war, they will be able to act on it.
So Palpatine was right when he talked with Anaking at the opera; "all who gain power are afraid to lose it, even the jedi".
@@miguelpantoja2294 True. But I think the Jedi still would have been able to find enough evidence of Palpatine's treachery of colluding with the Separatists especially if they can get the Separatist leaders to testify against him.
The Star Wars galaxy make what if qui gon jinn was grandmaster after killing Darth Maul for killing Kenobi, and the rest well, you can do it maybe because he is grandmaster he trains Anakin along with Dooku he and qui gon free anakin’s mother earlier so that he can know she is safe and then years pass, and Anakin Skywalker has trained and it’s granted access to the restricted Jedi archives thanks to his master qui gon because he knows anakin skywalker is the chosen one. He needs to know more knowledge, and become much more stronger and powerful. Eventually he finds out Anakin is in love with Padme, so he allows anakin to be with her.
This must be his signature move💀
Yeah
Hands of sith lords are my speciality!
the sub count does not do justice for the channel THE VIDEO WAS SOOO GOOD
Grand Master Plo Koon ❤️
I like Master Plo Koon. But I believe Mace Windu would be a good Grandmaster of the Jedi Order.
Grand Master Nameless Youngling!
Aniken being like you are right master when do he was too dangerous to be kept alive we have to destroy him and kill him so the Sith will never return. You’re right we have to kill in the dark Seth
Part 2: the ahsoka adventurers. Part 3: the return of the apprentice. Part 4: the gordian chiss( think Alexander the great and the gordian knot) part 5: the vong insurgency. Part 6: the rise of the federated galactic Republic. What do you think????.
Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
We all know the one thing sidious doesn't have up his sleeves
HANDS!
what if the true recordings were shown to the senate
Every time Palpatine was walking by clone soldiers he should have been yelling Execute Order 66.
I love these stories you do man! Always so many different ways it could of all gone....and I love hearing every single one of them!!!! Keep it up!!!!
The original is placed for us to see the Dark Side of theForce can manipulate
Based story
I would love to see it play out like this. If only there was some kind of clone wars type "what if?" show. I just want this for anakin.
If you do think about it Anakin could’ve been more logical with his reasoning of he must live
I mean he could’ve been like “you can’t, he must stand trial
Master think about this if you kill him you’ll turn the entire Jedi order against the republic
They don’t care that he’s a Sith Lord and most of the Galaxy doesn’t even know what that is
The very fact you’ve attacked him is enough to convict you so let’s stop for a moment
We have evidence to prove that he’s both a Sith Lord and that he orchestrated the clone wars from the very beginning we can use that against him but we can’t kill him Sith Lord or not he’s still a man and deserves a trial”
Only complaint with the story is that restraints would not work if you cut his hands off because the natural taper of your forearms means handcuffs would fall off without hands
I thought about that too and figured they were elbow cuffs or something
handcuffs are adjustable and they could just hold them on with the force
What if the Separatist Council saved Padme Amidala?
Oh, I would love to see a lot of video about that the separatist mean to say Padme ohohh
"meanwhile at the jedi temple mace windu and the other council members aside from Kenobi and-" your thoughts probably //shit what was the name again, oh right// "-Plokun" this and as well as the follow up to the name sounded veeery unsure xD
Bro I loooove your content but you NEEEED a new mic bro, you make the speakers on all my stuff sound like they are blown out
My bad!!! Getting a new one
What if all Jedi wore body cams?
Very entertaining what if. Thanks for the awesome content.
Asoka captured maul that would have changed some things in my opinion as well instead of gunray maul fighting sidious one last time in Senate building would have been interesting
I love all of these stories but im unsure if I like the idea of Sidious just saying "F*ck it!" and attacking everyone at once, sure he was the sith and a very powerful one at that, aswell as patient, I could see him just allowing himself to be taken and just biding his time until either he became one with the force or something. other than that it was fun
Dude sorry for not complementing your most recent excellent video in my previous comment. As always did not disappoint. You truly excel in constantly delivering high quality star wars content to the fans for us to enjoy. On behalf of all star wars fans I/we thank you. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
19:24 you can only
Use force lightning from finger tips and sidious had his cut off as he can’t shoot lightning out of thin air it has to leave your body
Is that really a specific rule? How do you know? I always assumed the reason we dont see Vader do it is because he would fry his robotic hands. Why cant he just shoot stumpy lighting out of his stumps?
Here is what militaries and governments due in that situation, it's used normally for officers and nco"s who die in combat, Ahsoka would be "posthumously" awarded the rank of jedi knight, whether she accepts it and comes back woukd be mist lukely up to her, its done also with retirement sometimes so unless their actually changing the rules for making master's the rule remains whole
Ahsoka would receive an award with rank and two tiny lightsaber just big enough for paper weights, just kidding she would mist likely be given her lightsaber back or told to keep them if their still in her possession
Vat if general grives joind de jedai
- I was trained in our Jedi arts by Master Yoda!
How did Anakin go from " not the Jedi way" to killing 100 Jedi even kids the same day.
I understand he wanted to save padme and learn the dark side for the power to do so, but would he kill a bunch of children to do that?
Does the dark side really twist you so much?
Short answer: yes, the dark side completely screws with someone. I would highly recommend checking out the ROTS novel, it perfectly describes his turn.
There is one glaring flaw in your story. Anakin cut off Sidious' hands. How would handcuffs work?
He said on his forearms
@@edyoung44 you are right, so he did. I'm still not sure the cuffs would have worked, however. They still could slip off.
What if yoda Trained anakin
I read that kind of story already. And if Anakin did learn from Yoda , I believe that Anakin will hardly turn to the dark side with Yoda guiding him in the true ways of the force.
What if Plo Koon went to kashyyyk
Or if Kiadi himself went to kashyyk
@@havesomeculture Wookies would murder both of them. Good relations with master Yoda they have.
Since order 66 didn’t happen, what happened to Maul?
What if Ezra took on palaptine proposal to join his parents
Death
Guy with 100000 m word
So basically Mace was right all along. Sidious was always too dangerous to be left alive.
When they went in the office to arrest him that's not what they said
Palpatine could've rigged the recording and screwed it all up to look like a soon-to-be victim.
Isn't the movie different from the novel anyway?
Star Wars without Sidious and Vader is just Star.
In my opinion he still won’t turn to the dark side
What if anakin skywalker forced mace windu to give up his seat due to using the darkside with the argument how can a darkside user be a jedi jedi are beings who follow the light not the dark
what if anakin was born female
Well I highly doubt anything would change except for his appearance
@@furious_pie466 I look it up and a female anakin anaka wouldn't fall to the Darkside of the force and would know if she was pregnant with Luke and Leia and wouldn't fall for old Palpatine crap
14:25 his crime is being a separatist
What’s wrong with the volume bro
What about Ahsoka and Maul?
Brilliant even if u would have let anakin die i would have been okay with it! I always thought killing sidious was a dumb thing cause the sith think like that! like that is what they expect ! so doin it falls into their plan!
Man, your on to something here; but fix your mic input, please.
While the video is good I think your mouth was a bit too close to the mic or something 😂
Oh no… dang it 😂 😭
It really says something about the fragile writing of the prequels that the slightest change upends everything.
What about Ahsoka and Maul for proof
What if Dooku sent Jango Fett to kill Darth Maul after Qui Gon’s death?
Having played the old Bounty Hunter game back in the day, I very much like this idea!
@@TravelersProd I feel like Jango would barely lose to Maul, and then Dooku would easily finish the job.
@@DarthSenateiousIdk, maul was injured at that point. Now maul uninjured with his youth and his legs, all his power and connection to the force, maul would destroy the bounty hunter.
@@beentheredonethat5908yeah
yo
Yo
Holy shit that recoding was cringe.
Honestly, I think Anakin should have died when the building collapsed. It would have been made a far better ending. Especially since it would have been his desire to protect the people he cared most about that gave him the power to do so. That could have been a great way to introduce the idea of how powerful attachments could make a jedi.
Dude how sensitive is your mic, sounds like an Xbox 360 mic
Pretty sure it was on the wrong input for this video. My bad!
@@thestarwarsgalaxyit’s alright, it was just so sudden when I played the video that it startled me tbh 😅
First
w ur mom
Jewish franchises
please move away from the microphone, you're peaking a lot
Jesus, take the mic out of your mouth.