Inkscape vs. Illustrator: Battle of the Vector Graphics Software

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 88

  • @Burak-df4gw
    @Burak-df4gw Рік тому +121

    Inkscape sounds like Blender from 3d world :D These open source softwares make me excited and proud. I feel power of open source communities! :)

    • @envatotuts
      @envatotuts  Рік тому +11

      Couldn't agree more!

    • @cekuhnen
      @cekuhnen Рік тому +6

      @@envatotutswirh the difference that Blender is commercial grade now.
      Inkscape still lacks polish and tools.
      For example live clipping / masking / Boolean’s it lacks.
      But it really matured lately

    • @inkscapepanda
      @inkscapepanda 7 місяців тому +2

      @@cekuhnen It has all of those tools, the only issue is that they are quite hidden.

  • @RayOfSunlight984
    @RayOfSunlight984 Рік тому +43

    Main Difference here:
    Adobe Ilustrator: Rental, requires a strong computer to run, only run if your job demands it
    Affinity Designer: Pay once, and the copy is yours.
    Inkscape: Free as In freedoom, can run on weaker computers.
    Inkscape 1.3 now has the shapebuilder tool and a lot more :D

    • @inv5879
      @inv5879 7 місяців тому

      Forgot to mention that Adobe inspie on us.

    • @jdrsant0s
      @jdrsant0s 3 місяці тому +2

      And one more difference, btw, Inkscape respect my rights as artist/author. Not the case with Adobe!

  • @DaviesMediaDesign
    @DaviesMediaDesign Рік тому +66

    Inkscape has definitely been closing the gap, especially with Inkscape 1.3 just being released.

    • @atishpanja6048
      @atishpanja6048 Рік тому +3

      Big fan..love to watch your videos

    • @iflotaichi
      @iflotaichi Рік тому +3

      agreed, too bad it's not stable enough for illustration heavy and or tablet workflows.

    • @MohamedArafathCanada
      @MohamedArafathCanada 7 місяців тому

  • @fanialivio2522
    @fanialivio2522 Рік тому +27

    Inkscape is a very powerful and complete vector software once you understand the logic behind it. I've been using it professionnally for several years now and it keeps improving at each new release.

  • @ekids.bassment
    @ekids.bassment Рік тому +49

    I started with Illustrator many decades ago, now I use Inkscape and I love it. I try to avoid anything Adobe, it's not a good company.

    • @mddrk
      @mddrk 11 місяців тому +3

      Yeah, the problem for me is that they are very expensive. I could afford maybe one program but all of them are just overpriced. I was thinking about adobe illutrator and inkscape, adobe seems easier to learn but I am not sure

    • @lojithv1
      @lojithv1 2 місяці тому +1

      Same here

    • @ProPrintDesign
      @ProPrintDesign 2 місяці тому +1

      That’s why I’m here. Bye Adobe

  • @GraphicdesignforFree
    @GraphicdesignforFree Рік тому +27

    Inkscape now also has a Shape Builder tool :)

  • @paulbruce3439
    @paulbruce3439 9 місяців тому +7

    I use both, also CMYK is currently being worked for Inkscape, overhauling the code and making it cleaner when this is released this truly will give a fantastic reason to use Inkscape 👍 even more

    • @okirooju3787
      @okirooju3787 6 місяців тому

      Martin Owens, an Inkscape Features designer, just posted an update concerning color on his UA-cam the other day. Things are definitely looking up.

  • @hasibmahadi8858
    @hasibmahadi8858 Рік тому +29

    Inkscape is soon going to introduce shape builder, the development version 1.3 already has it. Again trace bitmap is far more developed now. The bitmap feature you showed is from the previous versions.

    • @PDD555
      @PDD555 Рік тому +3

      Happily that feature is here! I'm really glad they added the feature, it has never been easier to do logos

  • @bkgraphs1810
    @bkgraphs1810 Рік тому +14

    Adobe Illustrator, CorelDraw, Affinity Designer and Inkscape each has its own big advantages. That's why it's hard to choose when you know it. Would be better if you just pick one and work on it

  • @sl5154
    @sl5154 3 місяці тому +1

    A really cool feature of Inkscape is that you can save a lot of swatches in their colour order or colour palettes that you prefer, then put it as your swatches colours on the bottom of the page to be so easy to pick. Then save it as a template and make it a default template so everytime you open Inkscape uour own swatches appear on the bottom list of colours.

    • @envatotuts
      @envatotuts  3 місяці тому

      Hi!
      That’s an awesome tip! Customizing swatches and saving them as a template can really streamline your workflow in Inkscape. Thanks for sharing that great feature!
      Cheers!

  • @scottvandevondervoort9467
    @scottvandevondervoort9467 Рік тому +9

    Inkscape has a Shape builder tool now in update 1.3 🎉

  • @lomaasama2269
    @lomaasama2269 Рік тому +6

    Why didn't I know that this channel gives very useful tutorials!! 😭

  • @koshisunuwarrai
    @koshisunuwarrai Рік тому +7

    the answer vary person to person, depending on how comfortable the individual feel with the tool.

  • @rgbcom
    @rgbcom Рік тому +7

    Great video. I’ll dump AI and try Inkscape.

  • @virtualstudio5847
    @virtualstudio5847 Рік тому +18

    INKSCAPE INKSCAPE INKSCAPE all the way. AI cannot compete with the latest version of Inkscape and it also has a very large plugin and extension repository. INKSCAPE DRAW FREELY will always be FREE . And Gimp has left Photoshop in dust many years ago.

  • @healthfitness1383
    @healthfitness1383 Рік тому +8

    I prefer Inkscape to Illustrator

    • @softwarelivre2389
      @softwarelivre2389 Рік тому +2

      Same. Inkscape is really lightweight, so it won'g lag on my machines, even the weaker ones. It also frees you from "vendor lock-in", because if Adobe wants to make Illustrator's subscription cost 200% higher, there's little you can do about it, while Inkscape remains free, libre and open source, so you can even fork it and change the code if you want to.

  • @IainNitro
    @IainNitro 3 місяці тому +1

    Great video. Found it informative. I would like to see your take on Affinity Designer vs Illustrator. I use all three currently as I am in school pursuing my BA in Graphics and Media to be completed this December (2024).

    • @envatotuts
      @envatotuts  3 місяці тому

      Hi!
      We’re glad you found the video informative. A comparison between Affinity Designer and Illustrator sounds like a great idea! We'll definitely consider that for future content. Congrats on pursuing your BA in Graphics and Media, and best of luck with your studies!
      Cheers!

  • @AnandK-iz8cf
    @AnandK-iz8cf 3 місяці тому +1

    Inkscape is best for beginners and thank you for comparing both softwares and that comparison was excellent thank you

    • @envatotuts
      @envatotuts  3 місяці тому +1

      Hi!
      It’s great to hear that you found the comparison helpful. Inkscape is indeed a fantastic choice for beginners. Happy designing!
      Cheers!

  • @bat3ch
    @bat3ch Рік тому +8

    why dont you ever show corel draw?

    • @envatotuts
      @envatotuts  Рік тому +5

      If there's enough demand for it, we will look into adding more content on it. Is there something in particular you're wanting to learn?

    • @qsfrankfurt9513
      @qsfrankfurt9513 Рік тому +3

      ​@@envatotutsCorelDraw is years ahead of Illustrator in many things. I don't know why people still want to do things on Illustrator when it requires many steps more than CorelDraw and the result is the same.

    • @goliviaff
      @goliviaff Рік тому

      ​@@envatotuts We want advance tutorial. ✨

    • @Sultanul
      @Sultanul Рік тому

      @@qsfrankfurt9513 coreldraw free??

  • @billps34
    @billps34 10 місяців тому +7

    Inkscape has a Shape Builder tool now.

  • @injusticemobile2962
    @injusticemobile2962 Рік тому +1

    I cant create guilloche patter in illustrator can you suggest me any software for guilloche design

  • @techofe-anopensourcebasedd5822

    Now looking for GIMP vs PS of the raster gfx software 🤔

  • @teklife
    @teklife Рік тому +7

    inkscape, support free and open source software

  • @bobotube76
    @bobotube76 Рік тому +8

    In CorelDraw there was more functionality and possibilities, when in Illustrator there was no idea to put them yet.

    • @hisbullahkhan
      @hisbullahkhan Рік тому +2

      Ur right, CorelDraw has more usable tools, plus it is more compatible than inkscape...

    • @COREL_1127
      @COREL_1127 Рік тому +1

      plus in CorelDraw you can set 1 tool for one key shortcut without using Alt or ctrl or shift

  • @Vancha112
    @Vancha112 Рік тому +2

    So, inkscape for everything, and illustrator if you really need to export for printing? Nice ^^

  • @feignenthusiasm
    @feignenthusiasm Рік тому +4

    Inkscape is the best ❤️

  • @Solarsystemrdffdfyyhh
    @Solarsystemrdffdfyyhh Рік тому +3

    1.3 came out and for the price you pay I have to say Inkscape all the way. Converting the rgb to cmyk ehh can be worked out. I can’t overlook the stuff you can do now with 1.3

  • @JV-pu8kx
    @JV-pu8kx 2 місяці тому

    Another difference: maximum number of nodes/control points for a shape. Illustrator maxes at 32,000. Inkscape's maximum is much higher. I am exporting from QGIS (opensource map making) and one of the polygons has over 100,000 points. Inkscape will work with the polygon without issue, while Illustrator throws up its hands at it.

    • @envatotuts
      @envatotuts  2 місяці тому

      Hi there! Thanks for sharing that insight! It's great to see the strengths of each software highlighted, especially for specific tasks like exporting from QGIS. Inkscape definitely shines in handling complex shapes!
      Cheers! 😊

  • @nitin_4352
    @nitin_4352 10 місяців тому +3

    inkspace you are awesome

  • @commonwunder
    @commonwunder Рік тому +3

    Brushes, brushes, brushes... for professionals, that's the real deal breaker. How good are the brushes?
    That a paid-for-package like Affinity Designer doesn't have true vector brushes... is near criminal.

    • @jdrsant0s
      @jdrsant0s 3 місяці тому

      In Inkscape is very easy to create your own vector brushes. Find some tutorials here on UA-cam.

  • @denniszammit7134
    @denniszammit7134 19 днів тому

    Hello. thanks for your guidance. i am a student and in physics i have several diagrams made up of straight lines, arrows, text (l1 letter or number). During my lessons I would need to fastly sketch these diagrams free hand with a pencil. than when i go home, i would need to draw them neatly one by one on my notes using the PC. Presently i'm using microsoft word as the notes are all in words. however this is extremely time consuming and a waste fo time too. Can you please guide me if I can scan my pencil hand drawn simple diagram and some software can convert it to PC neat diagram with all straight lines, round curves, text incorporated in the exact place as the scan and colours similar to the scan. Your expertise is really appreciated. Thanks a lot in advance. - Dennis from Malta

    • @envatotuts
      @envatotuts  19 днів тому

      Hi Dennis, thanks for sharing your situation! For your needs, software like Inkscape or Adobe Illustrator can work great. While neither automatically converts hand-drawn diagrams into polished vector graphics perfectly, you can use trace tools to speed up the process. Here's a suggestion:
      Scan or photograph your sketches.
      Import the image into Inkscape (free) or Illustrator (paid).
      Use the "Trace Bitmap" tool in Inkscape or "Image Trace" in Illustrator to convert the hand-drawn lines into editable vectors.
      Clean up and adjust text, lines, and shapes as needed.
      For diagrams with precise elements like arrows and text, you might need some manual adjustments, but this process saves time compared to starting from scratch.
      Hope this helps, and good luck with your studies! Cheers!

  • @joeldiaz141
    @joeldiaz141 25 днів тому

    I'm just gonna be honest. I can't even believe Inkscape is free. Its soo good and especially with 1.4 out now the gap has seriously closed between Inkscape and Adobe Illustrator. I hope it continues to be free!

    • @envatotuts
      @envatotuts  25 днів тому

      Hi! Totally agree-Inkscape has come a long way, and version 1.4 is impressive! It’s amazing what a free tool can achieve. Cheers!

  • @randsipe224
    @randsipe224 Рік тому +3

    Ai file formats don’t play well with laser systems, svg works well there.

    • @sl5154
      @sl5154 3 місяці тому

      Rename any ai file to pdf and then it can be easily opened on Inkscape as well.

  • @Mdibrahim-sg3sl
    @Mdibrahim-sg3sl 11 місяців тому +3

    Inkscape can open .Ai file .
    But with a small trick .
    First you will need to rename the .Ai file to .pdf.
    After that inkscape will recognize this pdf and can open the file in an editable environment. Then you'll just need to save the file in a regular inkscape SVG file to continue working on it.

    • @okirooju3787
      @okirooju3787 6 місяців тому

      Oh wow! Thanks for the tip.

    • @jdrsant0s
      @jdrsant0s 3 місяці тому

      This is not necessary for Inkscape 1.3+ . It opens .ai files on the "open file" dialog. On early versions, if I remember well, you can "import" .ai files too.

  • @efrend.2361
    @efrend.2361 Рік тому +1

    Affinity and CorelDraw 👊🏻

    • @sl5154
      @sl5154 3 місяці тому

      Inkscape wins both. ❤

    • @ignat81
      @ignat81 16 днів тому

      ​@@sl5154Why do you think Inkscape better than Coreldraw?

  • @galaxiapixel
    @galaxiapixel Рік тому +1

    Inkscape is the best for mayor works

  • @jppalm3944
    @jppalm3944 Рік тому +4

    Adobe requires cloud internet access.
    I dont use internet dependent software anymore.
    Stopped using autocad also.

  • @vijayarajan-bt5fk
    @vijayarajan-bt5fk 11 місяців тому +2

    Inkscape my choice

  • @delbrey1966
    @delbrey1966 11 місяців тому +4

    Adobe software was good when they were selling a permanent license for single owners, this monthly license is a trick to make more money. Everybody can't pay that so inkscape is a better solution for independent graphics designer like me

  • @rajendrameena150
    @rajendrameena150 Рік тому +4

    Overall explanation- Inkscape for Generalist and Illustrator is for specialist.

    • @Schattengewaechs99
      @Schattengewaechs99 10 місяців тому +2

      What sort of specialist, and why?

    • @jdrsant0s
      @jdrsant0s 3 місяці тому

      I know at least a full hand of professional specialists using Inkscape. Some of them are here offering Inkscape tutorials for everybody.

  • @GraphicDesignStudio
    @GraphicDesignStudio Рік тому +1

    Inkscape won the battle.

  • @justadesigner6864
    @justadesigner6864 2 місяці тому

    The only thing in which Inkscape surpasses Illustrator is the free price ... I respect inkscape but I love illustrator

  • @svoboda2410
    @svoboda2410 11 місяців тому +1

    Inscape for sure.

  • @Mdibrahim-sg3sl
    @Mdibrahim-sg3sl 11 місяців тому +2

    Inkscape can run on a Linux GUI version that is running via a terminal emulator named termux on a arm64 based Android system with around 4GB of ram 😂 . It means inkscape can even run on a Android phone with decent performance!
    In this scenario Adobe illustrator can't ever beat inkscape...

  • @sl5154
    @sl5154 3 місяці тому

    Inkscape is awesome 😎

    • @envatotuts
      @envatotuts  3 місяці тому

      You're awesome 💚😎

  • @Gray-Today
    @Gray-Today Рік тому +1

    If you like rentware, there is only one choice.

  • @snakepliskin2432
    @snakepliskin2432 Рік тому +2

    Inkscape is ok but the UI is a cluttered mess

  • @mstrsrvr
    @mstrsrvr Рік тому +1

    considering time of development and funding, Illustrated should be far, far ahead of Inkscape regarding features.

    • @sl5154
      @sl5154 3 місяці тому +1

      Not really. You just need to be a Inkscape pro to do the same job at the same speed. For printing SVG files are better than AI. There are features on Inkscape that there are not on illustrator as well. So perhaps the advantage of Adobe are the other products, not illustrator. Photoshop against Photopea might be different, but Inkscape and Illustrator professionally are the same.

  • @randomac-fq9ez
    @randomac-fq9ez 2 місяці тому

    Inkscape, Adobe Illustrator? Nope.. they aren't my choice. I use scratch vector WAY back in the day