***** yes.....exactly. That's what I want people to see. The're some video shows lists of songs that was the worst line distribution when the lines were divided equally to their position. Wtf is wrong with that?? When I watch this video and read the comments about it is fair, I felt relieve
@@lugoche1369 Sorry but if you wanna make a statement to lift up your bias at least be sure t is true , Wendy plays 4 instruments , She is the best rapper She covered Irene s rap part better than Irene herself She is the most beautiful without makeup She can speak English , French , Spanish , Japanese , Thai She has the best facial expressions Only Wendy & Seulgi who have really amazing stage presence & give 100% energy on stage
SM-"Lets add a new member to RV!" Fans-"GOD NO WHY, wait shes actually adorable and talented nvm we will keep her." (YERIPROTECTIONSQUAD) SM-"lol sike she gets no lines." Fans-"?????????"
Im a bit sad that Yeri cant get enough lines. But accept it yall one of these nights is a vocal song so its obvious seulgi and wendy would get the highest lines. Its the meaning of the song that matters. Dont worry our girl Yerim-ah will shine some day.
To me, it doesn't really matter who got the most line...This song suits Wendy and Seulgi's voice the most. Even if you give the line to Yeri or Irene, they might not be able to sing it as well as the main and lead vocals. Whoever distributed lines to the members have to consider this. The song doesn't really represent anything. Irene and Yeri have the least line but they have the most exposure to the media and public since both of them were the MCs for music show. And Joy was on We Got Married...does it matter tho? Do Wendy and Seulgi fans ever complained about this? I understand that they are your bias but it is pretty reasonable for the vocals to get more line, and Yeri and Irene are the centers for most of dance. Have you seen Wendy dance in the center for chorus? NO...so why not let them do what they are supposed to. As a Wendy stan, I never complain about how she is never the center...Those who complain Yeri gets little line, look at Twice. Half of the member get even less line and less attention.
abby chen i whole heartedly agree with you, but i dont think we should bring twice into this, theyre a completely different group under a completely different company.
@@abyvo But when it all comes down in the end Wendy is better than the other 4 then Seulgi is better than the other 3. While yes Joy technique isn't the best but. She is a better vocalist than Irene & Joy. I know I'm responded late.
i'm glad wendy got to showcase her talents with a song like this....irene and yeri get so much attention already for their looks and already have MC jobs while wendy is getting the short end of the stick despite her musical and variety skills....
I understand that they got mc jobs,but i really would prefer to be recognised for my talent rather than my looks if i were in a girl group...besides,yeri really isnt that popular.There are so many people who still don't think she should be in red velvet,but SM gives her no space to prove them wrong
Im not exactly sure how Wendy gets the short end. She sings almost 50% of every one of their songs. And actually attention isnt always good. Yeri has been bashed for being "ugly" multiple time, and because of the short line distribution also called a bad singer. Irene has also been called one of the "useless" members. They are constantly under scrutiny and although I love RV i fear if they do not showcase their members more they may leave because of the nastiness of others.
Stop complaining ya'll, Seulgi and Wendy are Vocals, of course they would sing most of the song since it's a ballad, i can almost tell the song was made for both of them, Irene and Yeri have a high pitched voice, it just can't match Ballads that well. And Joy, her voice is Ok, so she received the part she deserved in my opinion. I still feel bad for Yeri, i hope she gets to shine somehow.
+Inna Zhang I love Yeri as much as the other members.I get her part in the group by trying to bring the age gap down by a bit, but just that seems.. not enough.i hope she gets to be at least the Variety Queen of the group.
It's a comeback. Why have a comeback if the song doesn't fit all the members. Why be a group then. Like yeri is last on my bias list and Seulgi is first yet I'm still pretty pissed.
+Inna Zhang She gets the higher parts along with Joy. Since their voices are high pitched while Seulgi and Wendy are more comfortable with the lower pitched. So their voices harmonize well together. I think they added her for a better reason cause I doubt SM would be stupid enough to add another member when they already debuted for no reason when they know that the new member is going to get bashed. But the group did become brighter and now joy has like a member around her age to talk plus they get along pretty well. She improved a lot though since Dumb Dumb she has became more confident in her voice
+Exo & ME I guess the result of the chart shows. Personally, I do think it's a tone down comeback compared to previous comeback. But I do understand that this is their velvet side, and I love the Red & Velvet concept too. Hopefully more people will pay attention to velvet side too, and SM don't give up on this unique concept!
I'm really glad that Wendy got the most lines in this song. It really suits her voice. And people need to stop complaining about the non-vocal line not getting enough lines. They do not have fantastic voices. They can carry a pitch but they do not have the musicianship that the vocal line has. That's the way it works.
Please just stop complaining here. The song fits Wendy and Seulgi well and since they are main and lead vocalists of fhe group so. It's time for Wendy to shine, Irene and Joy had had an amazing rap lines in Ice Cream Cake. Joy is good and her parts fit her here, Yeri is a sub rapper and she needs to practice more to improve her vocal. SM knows what to do with their product, let them be... Besides my bias is Irene, and to the second place definitely it's Seulgi ^^
+Nhi Nguyễn Tbh, Irene is my bias too but I think nobody in RV is good at rapping (or in SM in general) so I really hope Irene gets more singing lines. In some of the songs The Red, Irene shows good vocals, so I hope she will get a chance to show that in title songs.
It's Wendy turn to shine. Wendy is probably the least popular (my bias). I mean, Yeri and Irene are known for the mc of music shows. Joy is on WGM, and Seulgi has been on many variety shows and is mostly in the center when performing on stage because she's the main/lead dance. I love all the members though, but I'm glad that Wendy got many lines.
I'm agree with this comment, I'm Wendy bias too and yes, this comeback suited her + her voice to shine more...hope she get the recognition she deserves. 😄😊
Actually when Wendy was on Masked Singer she got a lot of recognition as a vocalist but she still hasn't been recognized for her other incredible talents.
+Tippany Kwon Their singing is fine, Yuri improved a lot between Dumb Dumb and now, its just combared to Wendy, and Seulgi their lighter voices sound weak, and Joy's voice naturally sound strong so she's able to compete. There were a lot of lines in this song that the 2 could have handeled.
well it about time we can hear Wendy sing now. because when ice cream cake came out and dumb dumb she didn't really have lines to sing. so I'm glad. RV fighting
dumb dumb? She really did get her voice heard. Wendy has such a powerful voice, so she will always get recognition. For ICC she was the backing vocal for the raps, so please respect the distribution that was given because it really is equal. Joy is always in the middle, in vocals, raping, and dancing, so no one really notices her tbh which is really sad because she deserves way better, Seulgi will also always get recognition through vocals and dancing, Irene will get recognition through mostly her visuals and dancing, and Yeri will be praised through her vocal, rapping, and dancing colour, autotune-like voice and even her dancing. Please respect all of them, everyone. Not just to tis comment from a year ago.
@@casandrap.2648 most of Wendy's lines are only adlibs and not the actual line distribution. If you set aside her adlibs she'd only get minimal amount of lines.
@@casandrap.2648 Dont get it twisted okay ? Yeri is not even praised to begin with , She is always under hate , Wendy never gets recognition she has lines & no thing more than that no centre or screen time Joy is one of the most popular members SM is pushing her alot as an actress , She gets alot of screen time & decent amount of centre time , Not to mention her promotions + She got the most lines in both DD & ICC actual lines not back vocal or adlips This is Wendy s only chance to shine so let her shine
gosh. I saw this in my notification and started to think "huh? line distribution? you mean some sort of color-coded lyrics?" and felt so disappointed because you usually create unique stuffs. I HAVE NEVER BEEN SO WRONG.
Some things I would like to say: I love that Wendy gets to showcase her vocal talents in this song, and it's beautiful as a whole. When it comes to live performances, they're almost always doing something, all of them. Irene dances solo at one point, and Yeri and Seulgi dance together at another, as well as the overall movement throughout the song. Other than the base movements, Wendy doesn't do this. I feel like this was a lovely comeback, and in great contrast to Dumb Dumb (which I also adored
Considering their positions, this is VERY fair. But Wendy had 74(?) seconds, some of that I feel should have been given to Joy as Joy is part of the vocal line and the song fits her voice
It's fair tbh. She's getting lesser line in the previous comeback... She's the main vocalist. She's not even in the centre while performing... So giving her most lines is a good way to cover up things she didn't get.
I really like this video. It's kind of helping me with the lyric at the same time I know about their line and how many part they have in this song. It may seems Irene and joy have little part here. but remembering that they re rapper in the group I think it sort of right.
Perfect, the main vocal Wendy then the lead vocal Seulgi. Joy and Irene rapper/vocal get the most of the rest, and Yeri still has time for her voice to grow and improve
when i was listening to this song, i thought wendy and seulgi have about equal lines but seulgi got like just half of wendy's. i'm not complaning though, i'm just surprised.
tbvh im just very happy that wendy finally got her chance to shine in this comeback !! in the past few title tracks, i felt that as a main vocal, wendy did not have parts that show her full potential :( on a side note, i love joy's voice here omg 💖
+jacqueline costa Wendy is the main vocal and she fits this song perfectly along with others. Its very insulting to the rest of the group if you downgrade them to "Wendy's back-up singers" when its not true.
+surfnsunandfun lmao i'm joking. i know about wendy's vocal capacity and i think she's the best vocalist on k-pop. but i also think joy and seulgi deserved more lines on this song bc it fits them well, too.
+Pay Tonnn lmao I knew it. If you wanna see fat, check their recent Cool Hot Sweet Love performance on Inkigayo. She has the most defined abs. Think before you say that.
I think this is pretty good. It's truly a beautiful song that fits Joy's voice really good. Irene and Yeri got small parts here, but Irene got many lines on 'Dumb Dumb' while Seulgi and Wendy got like 2-3 parts plus adlibs. And Yeri always have been the leftie :/
You did a great job on this. This is my first time watching one of your line distribuion videos and I visually you did a great job. Thumbs up. It'd be nice if you could do his a lot more.
thank you granting my request. yeri and irene are good singers but ofcourse not all songs are in favor with their voice. in order for fans to hear their babies more pls listen to the whole album of redvelvet to show our support
This distribution seems appropriate for a ballad. Wendy is the main singer, so of course she would get the most lines. Seulgi and Joy have GREAT singing voices, too (Seulgi's voice is my favorite), so they get to sing the most after Wendy. Irene is the main rapper, so it makes sense she wouldn't sing as much on a ballad. IMO, Yeri has a slightly stronger singing voice than Irene, but I'm guessing she still got the smallest amount of lines because people are still getting used to her.
Not everyone is gonna get equal lines cause not everyones voice is suited for certain parts. Can you imagine how bad songs would be if every member were to get equal parts just because?
I'm not a ReVel fan so I'm not trying to defend anyone... but if Irene/Yeri were going to get such little lines, shouldn't it be up to the composer/songwriter to add more lines that those two are capable of singing? Small simple lines work well for ballads too and there could have been more of that for Irene/Yeri. Just my thoughts ^^ Beautiful song, still.
Irene is more of a rapper. Be glad she actually hv more than one lines. Rather than other groups where other 3 main/lead vocalist get most line while the rest 3 get 1. Be thankful n furthermore those that get one arent even rappers
+bee.syrup Although Irene is considered a rapper cause her tone and short vocal range, she is not bad at singing. Like in 'Cool World' you can see her improvement. Maybe SM put her and Joy to rap to have a 'rap line'
+Crystal Cervantes Um yes. Joy has a stable voice. And Seulgi is just as good, that's why she's lead vocalist. And that's why all three of them got to have their own track on the album.
LMAO! Wendy's on another level. Don't get it twisted! Wendy's way more versatile and has a richer voice. Songs like this really suits her the most. Seulgi is really good, but she's no Wendy.
i do think that the uri tashi mana can be split between yeri and irene but that's it ig. the rest of the song either doesn't suit their vocal capacity or their voice colors.
Honestly I don't mind Wendy singing the whole song. She is the only main vocalist anyway. She's also the most underrated one in the group. She deserves it imo.
This comeback for Yeri : Her face blur in the album cover, least scene in a MV, least line in album well, at least they give her a couple dance with Seulgi 😧 I still love this song
Will you do CLC - High Heels live compilation,where the dance keep changing at Seungyeon and Seunghee's part at the end after 'All night long~'? I hope you make it,thanks ^^
wendy and seulgi fit this song best same with joy, they are vocal line and get most singing time for a reason. Yeri is my bias (same with joy) but her voice doesn't rlly fit with songs like this
I know it's probably never going to happen, but ever since Wish Tree, I want a Seulgi and Yeri duet. I feel like their voices fit really well, with Yeri's higher voice and Seulgi, well she can control her voice a bit more so it could fit well with a lot. Maybe SM Station?
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Wendy is main vocal. There isn't any reason for she has fewer parts than anyone.
***** yes.....exactly. That's what I want people to see. The're some video shows lists of songs that was the worst line distribution when the lines were divided equally to their position. Wtf is wrong with that?? When I watch this video and read the comments about it is fair, I felt relieve
Only vocals, Wendy is the best in vocals, no much better than other members, ONLY VOCALS.
Tutoriales Conichi ɞ Stop bashing Wendy please. Go watch some MV with untalented peoples
LucyGoche Fuck off bitch. Wendy shits on the other red velvet members with her superior vocals.
@@lugoche1369 Sorry but if you wanna make a statement to lift up your bias at least be sure t is true ,
Wendy plays 4 instruments ,
She is the best rapper She covered Irene s rap part better than Irene herself
She is the most beautiful without makeup
She can speak English , French , Spanish , Japanese , Thai
She has the best facial expressions
Only Wendy & Seulgi who have really amazing stage presence & give 100% energy on stage
wendy ft Red Velvet
i thought tthe same
+Multi-Hapa yes same
isnt wendy is also red velvet?😅
yess trueeee
+octaviera d i know but i think she/he commented that because wendy sings half of this song
SM-"Lets add a new member to RV!"
Fans-"GOD NO WHY, wait shes actually adorable and talented nvm we will keep her."
(YERIPROTECTIONSQUAD)
SM-"lol sike she gets no lines."
Fans-"?????????"
trueeee
She got more in Russian Roulette!!
Im a bit sad that Yeri cant get enough lines. But accept it yall one of these nights is a vocal song so its obvious seulgi and wendy would get the highest lines. Its the meaning of the song that matters. Dont worry our girl Yerim-ah will shine some day.
And then there's Irene.
@@kaiseix and rookie, and rbb is like songs that starts with a R are Yeri songs
To me, it doesn't really matter who got the most line...This song suits Wendy and Seulgi's voice the most. Even if you give the line to Yeri or Irene, they might not be able to sing it as well as the main and lead vocals. Whoever distributed lines to the members have to consider this. The song doesn't really represent anything. Irene and Yeri have the least line but they have the most exposure to the media and public since both of them were the MCs for music show. And Joy was on We Got Married...does it matter tho? Do Wendy and Seulgi fans ever complained about this? I understand that they are your bias but it is pretty reasonable for the vocals to get more line, and Yeri and Irene are the centers for most of dance. Have you seen Wendy dance in the center for chorus? NO...so why not let them do what they are supposed to. As a Wendy stan, I never complain about how she is never the center...Those who complain Yeri gets little line, look at Twice. Half of the member get even less line and less attention.
abby chen i whole heartedly agree with you, but i dont think we should bring twice into this, theyre a completely different group under a completely different company.
Yeri actually does not get that much center now, But I do agree with you
abby chen Just because other people might have bigger problems (twice), it doesn’t mean that their problems don’t matter anymore (red velvet)
The line distribution represents their vocal ability ranking. (I'm an RV stan so I know.)
It's totally true tho plus yeri and Irene got soloish dance parts so it makes up for a little bit of the lack of lines
@@abyvo But when it all comes down in the end Wendy is better than the other 4 then Seulgi is better than the other 3. While yes Joy technique isn't the best but. She is a better vocalist than Irene & Joy. I know I'm responded late.
@Akata Ts she is literally said that?
except yeri, she's a better vocalist that irene, who tends to be a bit flat.
iM a ReDvElVeT sTaN sO I KnOw girl shut up were like all red velvet stans
i'm glad wendy got to showcase her talents with a song like this....irene and yeri get so much attention already for their looks and already have MC jobs while wendy is getting the short end of the stick despite her musical and variety skills....
I honestly think SM is still holding Wendy back, even with her recent collaboration with Eric Nam. Her vocals are capable of so much more
I understand that they got mc jobs,but i really would prefer to be recognised for my talent rather than my looks if i were in a girl group...besides,yeri really isnt that popular.There are so many people who still don't think she should be in red velvet,but SM gives her no space to prove them wrong
+Laces I feel like the main vocalists in their company never really get weekly part-time schedules
A lot of people think yeri is ugly
Im not exactly sure how Wendy gets the short end. She sings almost 50% of every one of their songs. And actually attention isnt always good. Yeri has been bashed for being "ugly" multiple time, and because of the short line distribution also called a bad singer. Irene has also been called one of the "useless" members. They are constantly under scrutiny and although I love RV i fear if they do not showcase their members more they may leave because of the nastiness of others.
Stop complaining ya'll, Seulgi and Wendy are Vocals, of course they would sing most of the song since it's a ballad, i can almost tell the song was made for both of them, Irene and Yeri have a high pitched voice, it just can't match Ballads that well. And Joy, her voice is Ok, so she received the part she deserved in my opinion.
I still feel bad for Yeri, i hope she gets to shine somehow.
+Eliezer Ricardo Sometimes I wonder why they even brought her into the group, when they give her no time to shine.
+Inna Zhang I love Yeri as much as the other members.I get her part in the group by trying to bring the age gap down by a bit, but just that seems.. not enough.i hope she gets to be at least the Variety Queen of the group.
It's a comeback. Why have a comeback if the song doesn't fit all the members. Why be a group then. Like yeri is last on my bias list and Seulgi is first yet I'm still pretty pissed.
+Eliezer Ricardo i think our precious maknae shined the most in their song cool hot sweet love. she looks stunning
+Inna Zhang She gets the higher parts along with Joy. Since their voices are high pitched while Seulgi and Wendy are more comfortable with the lower pitched. So their voices harmonize well together. I think they added her for a better reason cause I doubt SM would be stupid enough to add another member when they already debuted for no reason when they know that the new member is going to get bashed. But the group did become brighter and now joy has like a member around her age to talk plus they get along pretty well. She improved a lot though since Dumb Dumb she has became more confident in her voice
dang wendy you go girl! glad to see joy getting more lines too
this song is so freaking addicting .. I love it
I kept playing all the versions on repeat. It's so good. In my opinion it's their best song yet!
정연지 ikr and people keep on saying it's a failure
+Exo & ME I guess the result of the chart shows. Personally, I do think it's a tone down comeback compared to previous comeback. But I do understand that this is their velvet side, and I love the Red & Velvet concept too. Hopefully more people will pay attention to velvet side too, and SM don't give up on this unique concept!
Thomas Qiliang yeah...I also like kinda upbeat songs but this song is really good in my opinion
+Exo & ME agree!
Wendy is literally slaying this comeback with both her amazing vocals and visuals! So glad she's finally getting the lines she deserves
ikr :)
Yes! Wendy's the best!
I'm OK with this! :) Irene and Seulgi are my biases, and I recognize that they all have different strengths and weaknesses.
I thought Wendy and Seulgi got equal line but well this proved me wrong.
Me toooo !!!!!
We shld stop complaining. Its time for wendy to shine. Its time for her to be appreaciated
+flwrboy Im not complaining, I love wendy! But I'm just surprised my guess can be wrong 100%.
+Jessica Tiong 👌🏻
why is everyone surprised that the main vocalist got the most lines like... that's her job. maybe if she started rapping then i'd be surprised.
wendy is the main vocal that's why
wendy is tha main vocal so yeah
okay bUT WENDY SLAYED
Yes she did! This song would not be as good with less Wendy!! She owned this song!!
I'm really glad that Wendy got the most lines in this song. It really suits her voice. And people need to stop complaining about the non-vocal line not getting enough lines. They do not have fantastic voices. They can carry a pitch but they do not have the musicianship that the vocal line has. That's the way it works.
Please just stop complaining here. The song fits Wendy and Seulgi well and since they are main and lead vocalists of fhe group so.
It's time for Wendy to shine, Irene and Joy had had an amazing rap lines in Ice Cream Cake. Joy is good and her parts fit her here, Yeri is a sub rapper and she needs to practice more to improve her vocal. SM knows what to do with their product, let them be...
Besides my bias is Irene, and to the second place definitely it's Seulgi ^^
+Nhi Nguyễn Tbh, Irene is my bias too but I think nobody in RV is good at rapping (or in SM in general) so I really hope Irene gets more singing lines. In some of the songs The Red, Irene shows good vocals, so I hope she will get a chance to show that in title songs.
It's Wendy turn to shine. Wendy is probably the least popular (my bias). I mean, Yeri and Irene are known for the mc of music shows. Joy is on WGM, and Seulgi has been on many variety shows and is mostly in the center when performing on stage because she's the main/lead dance. I love all the members though, but I'm glad that Wendy got many lines.
I'm agree with this comment, I'm Wendy bias too and yes, this comeback suited her + her voice to shine more...hope she get the recognition she deserves. 😄😊
Actually when Wendy was on Masked Singer she got a lot of recognition as a vocalist but she still hasn't been recognized for her other incredible talents.
+Crystal Cervantes I agree with that, she's so dorky adorable on variety shows and from her academic accolades, we can knew that she's smart. 😊
+Tracy Moofin Yes. She's probably the kkab member tho XD
+Crystal Cervantes Trueee! I really loved her on masked singer, and how Sungjae knew it was her!
I wish Irene and Yeri got more lines tho...
They'll have to improve their singing first but if u watch their performances on music shows, Irene and Yeri stand at the center often.
+Tippany Kwon but yeri stands to the far right most of the performance..
+Tippany Kwon Their singing is fine, Yuri improved a lot between Dumb Dumb and now, its just combared to Wendy, and Seulgi their lighter voices sound weak, and Joy's voice naturally sound strong so she's able to compete. There were a lot of lines in this song that the 2 could have handeled.
+Bina Bunnie Yeri*
I understand Yeri but... Irene??
I'm actually happy that Wendy got a lot of lines this time. She really got to show off her talent!
She always shows off her talent
well it about time we can hear Wendy sing now. because when ice cream cake came out and dumb dumb she didn't really have lines to sing. so I'm glad. RV fighting
dumb dumb? She really did get her voice heard. Wendy has such a powerful voice, so she will always get recognition. For ICC she was the backing vocal for the raps, so please respect the distribution that was given because it really is equal. Joy is always in the middle, in vocals, raping, and dancing, so no one really notices her tbh which is really sad because she deserves way better, Seulgi will also always get recognition through vocals and dancing, Irene will get recognition through mostly her visuals and dancing, and Yeri will be praised through her vocal, rapping, and dancing colour, autotune-like voice and even her dancing. Please respect all of them, everyone. Not just to tis comment from a year ago.
Cassie S Joy had the most lines in both RR and ICC
@@casandrap.2648 most of Wendy's lines are only adlibs and not the actual line distribution. If you set aside her adlibs she'd only get minimal amount of lines.
@@casandrap.2648 Dont get it twisted okay ? Yeri is not even praised to begin with , She is always under hate ,
Wendy never gets recognition she has lines & no thing more than that no centre or screen time
Joy is one of the most popular members SM is pushing her alot as an actress , She gets alot of screen time & decent amount of centre time , Not to mention her promotions + She got the most lines in both DD & ICC actual lines not back vocal or adlips
This is Wendy s only chance to shine so let her shine
gosh. I saw this in my notification and started to think "huh? line distribution? you mean some sort of color-coded lyrics?" and felt so disappointed because you usually create unique stuffs. I HAVE NEVER BEEN SO WRONG.
Some things I would like to say:
I love that Wendy gets to showcase her vocal talents in this song, and it's beautiful as a whole.
When it comes to live performances, they're almost always doing something, all of them. Irene dances solo at one point, and Yeri and Seulgi dance together at another, as well as the overall movement throughout the song. Other than the base movements, Wendy doesn't do this.
I feel like this was a lovely comeback, and in great contrast to Dumb Dumb (which I also adored
someone finally said it!!!!
sobbing for Wendy- this comeback rly finally showed her greatness off so much and I can't even-
Considering their positions, this is VERY fair. But Wendy had 74(?) seconds, some of that I feel should have been given to Joy as Joy is part of the vocal line and the song fits her voice
It's fair tbh. She's getting lesser line in the previous comeback... She's the main vocalist. She's not even in the centre while performing... So giving her most lines is a good way to cover up things she didn't get.
Ryan Daniel True.
MiaKkookie Joy got most lines ICC era already.
Ryan Daniel True x3
+Ryan Daniel Wendy got tons of lines and singing time dumb dumb because of her amazing God given as-libs
Great video !! Can you do Rainbow Whoo Lines distribution??
Yes please
+Fan K-POP this!
yes!!
yesyesyess
yes yes yes pleaseee
i seriously appreciate your video formatting and design, its so aesthetically pleasing.
That Layout is so incredible... Thanks for the video!
our wendy, as expected, leading the song :3
PLEASE DO MORE OF THESE VIDEOS I LOVE THEM SO MUCH
#LetYeriSing2k16
#LetYeriSing2k16
#LetYeriSing2k16
#LetYeriSing2k16
#LetYeriSing2k16
#LetYeriSing2k16
thank you for blessing us with the most beautiful line distribution format on all of youtube ;;
editing makes me want to cry because it's so amazing
once again great video quality, so satisfying to watch.
other youtubers are making line distribution videos now too, but yours are still by far the best. i hope you get to keep making them!
Always amazes me how original, visually-appealing, and creative Kpopper's videos are.
Great video for a great song :)
Keep up the quality content !
This takes forever to do. Kudos for all of the effort you put in for the timing and editing for this.
i am ok with it tho, hehe. the song is so comforting! their voices are so beautiful ;_;
Really like the graphics & setup of this video. Please do more! :D
Your editing is so amazing! :) I love the little leaderboard on the side that shifts as the song progressed ^^
I really like this video. It's kind of helping me with the lyric at the same time I know about their line and how many part they have in this song. It may seems Irene and joy have little part here. but remembering that they re rapper in the group I think it sort of right.
4 years ago, this is the 1st line distribution i saw, still beautiful and creative
Perfect, the main vocal Wendy then the lead vocal Seulgi. Joy and Irene rapper/vocal get the most of the rest, and Yeri still has time for her voice to grow and improve
OH MY GIRL LIAR LIAR LINE DISTRIBUTION
yes
YES PLEASE OMG
godbless ive been waiting to hear wendy's gorgeous voice more
Was waiting for this!
this whole video is such a good idea! love it
when i was listening to this song, i thought wendy and seulgi have about equal lines but seulgi got like just half of wendy's. i'm not complaning though, i'm just surprised.
Nice format and quality wow!! Thanks for the video I love Wendy but I feel bad for Yeri and Irene they need lines too..
At first I see the thumbnail I just curious about the distributiin, but I'm more attract with the video you made, it's cool!!!! 😻😻😻
So awesome. Thanks for all of your great videos! Keep it up. Red Velvet is magical, no doubt about it #Seulgiislyfe
Omygosh I'm such a fan and then you credited some to me omygosh
tbvh im just very happy that wendy finally got her chance to shine in this comeback !! in the past few title tracks, i felt that as a main vocal, wendy did not have parts that show her full potential :(
on a side note, i love joy's voice here omg 💖
I actually really like Yeri's voice in this song
her part is my most fav in this song
Nice video :)) yasss I'm very happy. WENDY !!!!
i was waiting for this
Wendy and her back-up singers.
+jacqueline costa Wendy is the main vocal and she fits this song perfectly along with others. Its very insulting to the rest of the group if you downgrade them to "Wendy's back-up singers" when its not true.
+surfnsunandfun lmao i'm joking. i know about wendy's vocal capacity and i think she's the best vocalist on k-pop. but i also think joy and seulgi deserved more lines on this song bc it fits them well, too.
+Pay Tonnn What's that supposed to mean?
+Pay Tonnn lmao I knew it. If you wanna see fat, check their recent Cool Hot Sweet Love performance on Inkigayo. She has the most defined abs. Think before you say that.
+Pay Tonnn Sorry you got dragged :)
I think this is pretty good. It's truly a beautiful song that fits Joy's voice really good. Irene and Yeri got small parts here, but Irene got many lines on 'Dumb Dumb' while Seulgi and Wendy got like 2-3 parts plus adlibs. And Yeri always have been the leftie :/
YOUR VIDEOS ARE ALWAYS SO ON POINT! I ALWAYS LOOK FORWARD TO YOUR VIDEOS AND THANKS FOR MAKING THEM ~ Keep up the good work!
yeay! thank you for this video❤
Great work mate! No surprise to see Wendy up there :D
Irene and Yeri my two biases ouch! Although I do appreciate how great Wendy sounds in this!!
You did a great job on this. This is my first time watching one of your line distribuion videos and I visually you did a great job. Thumbs up. It'd be nice if you could do his a lot more.
thank you granting my request. yeri and irene are good singers but ofcourse not all songs are in favor with their voice. in order for fans to hear their babies more pls listen to the whole album of redvelvet to show our support
I LOVE YOUR VIDEO AF ALL!! BECAUSE COMPLETE WITH LYRICS,COLOR CODED,PICT,VIDEO MV. I LOVE YOUR VIDEO SO MUCH 😍😍😍
thanks for the video 😍 reaaaaally enjoyed it 😝👏🏻
i love wendy
oh my god your videos never fail to amaze me ^^ i'll be waiting for your next video~
maybe since wendy and seulgi didn't get that much lines in dumb dumb, they let them have this song
Wendy actually had the most lines in Dumb Dumb.
@@haileyketchen3804 But most of it was just adlibs
Nice video! Your videos are always amazing and well elaborated. Great job! 😁👏👏👌👍
thank you, always amazing videos 💜
This distribution seems appropriate for a ballad. Wendy is the main singer, so of course she would get the most lines. Seulgi and Joy have GREAT singing voices, too (Seulgi's voice is my favorite), so they get to sing the most after Wendy. Irene is the main rapper, so it makes sense she wouldn't sing as much on a ballad. IMO, Yeri has a slightly stronger singing voice than Irene, but I'm guessing she still got the smallest amount of lines because people are still getting used to her.
i love how much wendy owns this song. she sounds so good
irene and yeri actually have beautiful voices yall just dont appreciate them
Not everyone is gonna get equal lines cause not everyones voice is suited for certain parts. Can you imagine how bad songs would be if every member were to get equal parts just because?
I'm not a ReVel fan so I'm not trying to defend anyone... but if Irene/Yeri were going to get such little lines, shouldn't it be up to the composer/songwriter to add more lines that those two are capable of singing? Small simple lines work well for ballads too and there could have been more of that for Irene/Yeri. Just my thoughts ^^ Beautiful song, still.
+bee.syrup Sadly those were the small simple lines.
Irene is more of a rapper. Be glad she actually hv more than one lines. Rather than other groups where other 3 main/lead vocalist get most line while the rest 3 get 1. Be thankful n furthermore those that get one arent even rappers
+bee.syrup Although Irene is considered a rapper cause her tone and short vocal range, she is not bad at singing. Like in 'Cool World' you can see her improvement. Maybe SM put her and Joy to rap to have a 'rap line'
Nah. Wendy and Seulgi deserved the most lines on a song like this with Joy following up behind them. Come on now!
The line distribution represents their vocal ability,I'm a Red Velvet stan since 2017 so i know
I live your videos so much! such high quality
Wow really it's cool this is why I loves your channel
Yeri and Irene aren't vocalists which is why they didn't get many parts. But, Seulgi and Joy should've gotten a bit more.
Wendy is the main vocal though,isn't she?
Katelyn Hoang Of course she is but Seulgi and Joy are just as capable of her parts.
+세리 not really no
+Crystal Cervantes Um yes. Joy has a stable voice. And Seulgi is just as good, that's why she's lead vocalist. And that's why all three of them got to have their own track on the album.
LMAO! Wendy's on another level. Don't get it twisted! Wendy's way more versatile and has a richer voice. Songs like this really suits her the most. Seulgi is really good, but she's no Wendy.
I'm so glad that Wendy get many lines that she deserve.
this is amazing
Why the hell didn't i discover this channel before XD :D !!!
i do think that the uri tashi mana can be split between yeri and irene but that's it ig. the rest of the song either doesn't suit their vocal capacity or their voice colors.
you never fail to make such great videos!!
Omg yes!!! Can you do fiestar's mirror please? Thanks
+Onika Pink I want it too ! :D
+Onika Pink nah it's really distributed well and equally
Michael Fernandez
so? i want to see
Onika Pink TBH, I would rather have a video that's like the T-ARA 'So Crazy' outifts video, but that's after all their main performances.
Can you do Astro related video? e.g. JinJin's hair colour or Line Distribution for Hide and Seek
this!!
yes please
Yesss
Honestly I don't mind Wendy singing the whole song. She is the only main vocalist anyway. She's also the most underrated one in the group. She deserves it imo.
and besides that, her voice really fit this type of song.
I agree with you sooooooooooooo much!! Wendy's the best!
I think through each comeback she's slowly getting more lines. Im sure Yeri will dominate when she gets older :)
Yeri is slowly shaping up to become Taemin 2.0
Getting ready for Yeri to slay all the haters and pull a taemin on us
DId you guys hear her singing Almost is never enough?
well Yeri SLAYED on Cool Hot Sweet Love :p
ReddVazquez Defintely though I was a little worried about the elegant and femenine dance, but she did it perfectly
Can you do this with Mamamoo's You're the Best please? Thanks~~
Yes please
+Shella Gisela Yaaaas
The whole time I was like Yeri, Yeri, Yeri, YERI WHERE ARE YOU UGHH😂😂
You should do this for Liar Liar by Oh My Girl! I really enjoy these
Yeri and Irene need more lines I love the vocals in this though. Thanks for the video
This comeback for Yeri : Her face blur in the album cover, least scene in a MV, least line in album
well, at least they give her a couple dance with Seulgi 😧
I still love this song
Do you know why her face is blurred out in the album cover?
Probably theres a story and meaning behind this album & MV & song. Someone needs to release a theory!
Will you do CLC - High Heels live compilation,where the dance keep changing at Seungyeon and Seunghee's part at the end after 'All night long~'? I hope you make it,thanks ^^
First time I saw line distribution with lyrics
I like your video..amazing
wendy and seulgi fit this song best same with joy, they are vocal line and get most singing time for a reason. Yeri is my bias (same with joy) but her voice doesn't rlly fit with songs like this
I know it's probably never going to happen, but ever since Wish Tree, I want a Seulgi and Yeri duet. I feel like their voices fit really well, with Yeri's higher voice and Seulgi, well she can control her voice a bit more so it could fit well with a lot. Maybe SM Station?