John went from being absolutely terrified of this game to having fun with the killer and doing small shuffles around him. You know what that is? ...Growth.
@@kbednarc_ I think its good too. He has fun/sprinkles salt on everyone in my experience. I hate it when Twitch streamers only interact with subs, and are rude to followers, or straight up ignore them.
"This seems drastic considering nothing has happened yet." *Boyfriend has been impaled with a screwdriver, and a an unidentified window has been smashed.*
God I love this 'Still scary?' videos, its arguably my favorite thing John's come up with! It's fun seeing his earlier reactions and compare them to now
Don’t let this series end! Maybe once a month you go back and play a game you played in the old days! We really enjoy it, I like your commentary on its relevance today versus when you originally played it, your original intro then into your new video, so rad! Also if people are saying “this is old you’ve already played it” they’re idiots and they can kick rocks.
John: "I feel like that's a bit much, considering nothing's happened yet." *Completely ignoring the fact that poor, drunk Jack was dead and somehow stuck in the fence by a screwdriver of all things*
To be honest, Billy seems like the most normal human being around here (lulz at Billy the Kid by the way). More than his parents repeating each other's sentences to the exact word and offering to "feel free to let him do whatever he likes". Definitely more than Jack "drinking and smashing mailboxes I'm so cool bro". And definitely, ABSOLUTELY more than Sarah, entrusted with a house and child, deciding to invite a complete stranger and feed the kid cereals for dinner just to raid the liquor cabinet. Honestly, what's wrong with her? Worst babysitter ever! :D
34:30 Kid even calls not-Michael Myers "the boogeyman". Which they did in Halloween. Never noticed that before, nice touch (probably bc I never saw the ending before lol)
I'm honestly so emotional over you having 500k now, I found you through your Outlast 2 play through that Beaver mentioned in one of his videos and have been here every day ever since. I've struggled with depression through college but your videos have always been a safe and happy place for me. You work so hard and absolutely deserve it--can't wait for the 1 million celebration :) p.s: YAY BABYSITTER BLOODBATH
I give this game a -3/10 because the game isn't about you sitting on babies and using their blood to bathe yourself in, bringing about the new age of the Red One to terrorize the mortals of this planet.
_Our boy John has grown so much!_ Babysitter bloodbath. That brings back memories. Especially Johns _Screams!_ John really has become more harshly critical over the years. And can really face some good horror now. I thought it was a really scary game. It was nice that it wasn't a cheesy jumpscare fest, slender clone or Jeff the killer game. It played like old movies and I guess modern slasher flicks still follow the same structure. Lol. I say it's aged well. Not the greatest but the devs really improved their craft since then.
33:22 Amazing AI, he just teleports outside the door for you after you fill the gas tank instead of staying behind you ready to stab, what a nice babysitter killer! XD
man you missed one of the best parts of this game! If you turn on the old radio you get this creepy radio message about a psycho who escaped a local mental hospital and to stay inside
@@meowskit Yes. *Clears throat* It's about a dating couple that heads out with the car in the middle of the night. They make out inside their car near a forest or something when the radio says a criminal escaped nearby their area. They hear a sound and boyfriend investigates while girlfriend stays behind in the car. She hears scraping noises and eventually the boyfriend returns all panicked, starting the car and leaving immediately. When they return home they find a butcher hook buried inside the side of the car, making them realise they escaped death.
It's been great watching you do these. I loved this one too. I still can't get over how different the production values are between this video and the old one. It doesn't feel like it was that long ago. I guess it's a sign I'm getting old lol. Thanks for the video John.
John i love you but that old haircut was tragic babe Edit: john is beautiful and can be or do whatever he wants. buzzsaw louie must be in a cult since he knows so much about piercings and cults😑
Anyone watching in 2022, here's some trivia; Puppet Combo made a paperback novel version of this game! It was written by Regina Watts, and It's available on Amazon and it's pretty decent. The killer gets more backstory and theres a lot of fun gore.
@LunarShimmer Doesn't matter if their That Scary or good, it's just that they are "elephants in the room" In other words, their tremendous popularity have made them "stick out", that can be good.......or bad.
This game is one of my favorite videos of yours. I've probably watched the original LP a dozen times by now because it's a mix of campiness and tense moments. Revisiting old playthroughs was a great idea, since so many of us have been with you for a long time. You're one of few UA-camrs that I never grew out of watching. I keep coming back because you're genuine and try different things to make your channel better. You deserve way more than 500k subs.
Still Scary is such an original series idea and super entertaining too; really brings back memories. Thanks for the many uploads too John, but don't overwork yourself
That "Let's get fucked up!" in the stereotypical teenage girl voice is what we'll feature at his funeral with the slideshow of all his other endeavors.
I love how when I watched John play this for the first time, him being spooked made me so tense and spooked watching it, but now his spook threshold has increased it's a much nicer experience. Really shows how the UA-camr can influence the person watching
Oh my god I just finished watching your old playthrough of Babysitter Bloodbath and thought, "Maybe John should replay this game as well", my prayers have been answered! I remember first finding your channel through Babysitter Bloodbath, glad to see how far you and your channel has come!
God where does the time go. I remember first discovering your channel a little over 5 years and binge watching your videos with my then girlfriend. Glad I'm still here! ❤️
*boyfriend gets hella murdered.* *power is cut.* *glass shatters, indicating the murderer has invaded the home.* but climbing down a hatch "seems like drastic measures since nothing is happening" lmao. Just kidding of course, your videos and commentary are my favorite of any UA-cam gamer! This game brings me back, watched when it first came out !
I still watch the old playthrough all the time! One of my favorite parts was when the kid says "I'm hungry" and John replies "well go make yourself a sandwich " omg I love this series
I really loved this short series and am so happy you are at 500,000 (even though I think you deserve so much more) this was one of my favorite games you have played!
I loved seeing your playthrough of this the first time around, and it's even more fun seeing you play it now. Still gets me when you run into him around a corner and it seems like he pops up outta nowhere. Congrats on 500k!!! I've been watching your videos since 2017; I'm pretty sure the first video of yours I watched was you playing a kittyhorrorshow game. Looking forward to all the hilarious content you put out in the future!
Stakes are high, John's run out of ammo, he doesn't have an axe, and he's in a small space with the killer...and what does John say? "LeT's UsE tHe WhiSkY. SeE iF hE SLiPs On iT." "DoEs AnYbOdY hAvE a BaNaNa PeEl?" SUCH A BAD TIME TO MAKE A JOKE BUT I CRACKED. UP.
Probably my favorite you’ve ever played, but I really enjoyed the weird Christmas Santa clause on another planet one. Lol whatever it’s called by puppet combo
I watched your older playthroughs of the games you covered this weekend at least twice but sometimes three or more. It was so great to see you revisit them and I really hope you make this an on going series!
![Most disturbing horror game of the year? [Bloodwash]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/O3USeDps27Q/mqdefault.jpg)
Meanwhile, Jill sits patiently by the phone wondering how your date with Jack went.
Except, if you call her back she tells Sarah to stop calling her so much XD
@@suicune95 jack and jill went up the hill
@@lua5185 jack and Jill went up the hill
So he could lick her candy
But alot of shock and a mouthful of cock
Becuase jill real name was randy
its been a hot minute since i watched blast damn.
@@brodyupton9155 so what?maybe Jack's fine with that
John went from being absolutely terrified of this game to having fun with the killer and doing small shuffles around him. You know what that is? ...Growth.
But what type of growth
His hair grew
johns wolfe pack is the true nine year old army, the comments are always hard to read on an intellectual level
The real "killer" is the friends we made along the w-no wait
He's a man now 😏
It always gets me when John calls the antagonists "stupid idiot." Also loved the salt from 5 years ago from not recognizing the movie on.
"stupid idiot"
as opposed to what? a smart idiot?
@@pheenixgryphon7857 oh man he's even more salty on Twitch. I started following his live streams. Him roasting chat is the best.
@@kbednarc_ I think its good too. He has fun/sprinkles salt on everyone in my experience. I hate it when Twitch streamers only interact with subs, and are rude to followers, or straight up ignore them.
@@suraventri2544 and it's only fair if someone is roasting him that he gets to roast back. It's funny watching people bait him.
Mm aged salt. Great for any dish served in a bloodbath.
Why keep a lock on your liquor cabinet if you’re going to give your kid the key?
I don't think Billy was supposed to have it. Billy's just a little sneak.
Billy is a stupid asshole.
@@areizagan - When isn't Billy being just that?
Screw you Billy!
they said "feel free to do whatever he wants" you can imagine what kind of parents they are
"This seems drastic considering nothing has happened yet."
*Boyfriend has been impaled with a screwdriver, and a an unidentified window has been smashed.*
Be honest we all forgot about him lol
Nothing happened to *her*
Random dude she *just* met, hadn't even bonked yet.
Plus, not her windows in her house.
Did somebody say *Drastic?* 😏😏😏
Remember when John used to fear quit certain games and come back on a new day with a new shirt/jacket in the same video?
I was Ur 100 like 🤗
Really? Which games
@@HammyZam most of his older ones, like his first Babysitter Bloodbath video. A few others but it's been so long I can't remember.
@句丹句句と 尺ヨ尸卞丹尺 facts
Não
I like how 5 years later, this still makes people jump.
lol i jumped the second time he found Jill
Especially someone like John.
it's how loud the noise's are man.
@@orateusdijin6557 And how quiet everything else is, so youre just always a liiiittle bit on edge haha
@@reeba4824 rightt!! And this game is like 4yrs old i think; And it's still scary asf.
The killer was cool cat all along. Trying to teach the kids about why it's important to lock your doors.
Scott Newsom Jr Oh no
COOL CAT LOVES TO BOOGIE WOOGIE
Cool Cat loves aaaaaallllll kiiiids
HELLO THIS IS COOL CAT
God I love this 'Still scary?' videos, its arguably my favorite thing John's come up with! It's fun seeing his earlier reactions and compare them to now
I don't really like them, but mostly because I've watched the original playthroughs many times over
KEEP CRITICAL DANGIT
This was one of the first videos I saw on your channel. It really brings me back.
ultimaT same
Omg same! I’m pretty sure it was the first video I ever saw from his, and ah it brings back so many memories!
same
Same
Same! This was nostalgic as fuck
First I couldn't put my finger on why this was so familiar
"Drinking, smashing mail boxes, and tipping cows" What a keeper!
The First horror game John played where he "fear quit" for the first time and it was utterly hilarious lol hard to believe it was 5 years ago
He definitely did a fear quit or two in his original "White Day" playthrough which was recorded 7 years ago.
Don’t let this series end! Maybe once a month you go back and play a game you played in the old days! We really enjoy it, I like your commentary on its relevance today versus when you originally played it, your original intro then into your new video, so rad! Also if people are saying “this is old you’ve already played it” they’re idiots and they can kick rocks.
Idk cus if he does that then he might eventually run out of old games to play for that
@@Sacr3dHam There'll always be new old games to play ;p
Bbrruuuhhh. Im so dead at the way she was bangin on the door😭😭😂
atnat “let me innnnn” 😂😂😂
Anybody have a time stamp? I’m trying to find it again to get a good laugh but I can’t find it
Elizabeth 17:56
m.ua-cam.com/video/t31bgrKP5SI/v-deo.html
Slapslapslapslapslapslapslapslap
John: "I feel like that's a bit much, considering nothing's happened yet." *Completely ignoring the fact that poor, drunk Jack was dead and somehow stuck in the fence by a screwdriver of all things*
Nothing happened to *her*
Not like Jack was her bf. They didn't even boink yet.
I love myself some home invasion horror games!
Admiral Kizaru same
Then you'll love the many invasions of Poland.
Im curious if Billy's parents ever moved after they found out what happen that night. Lol
To be honest, Billy seems like the most normal human being around here (lulz at Billy the Kid by the way).
More than his parents repeating each other's sentences to the exact word and offering to "feel free to let him do whatever he likes".
Definitely more than Jack "drinking and smashing mailboxes I'm so cool bro".
And definitely, ABSOLUTELY more than Sarah, entrusted with a house and child, deciding to invite a complete stranger and feed the kid cereals for dinner just to raid the liquor cabinet. Honestly, what's wrong with her? Worst babysitter ever! :D
34:30
Kid even calls not-Michael Myers "the boogeyman". Which they did in Halloween. Never noticed that before, nice touch (probably bc I never saw the ending before lol)
This was actually a Halloween fan game before so yeah that was intentional.
That title sounds like a Lifetime movie
Roland Mendoza LMAO
All Lifetime movies are the same.
Tails is disappointed in your recent decisions I said "Title" lol
I said "All Lifetime movies are the same" lol
Tails is disappointed in your recent decisions thank you now let's enjoy this cheesy goodness...
Remember way back when John would record these lets plays on VHS?
VeronicasTouch did he? That sounds cool
Dr Strangelove totally
VeronicasTouch yall joke but my other favorite LPer started off by recording his playthrough on vhs
@@KOTEBANAROT who
@@KOTEBANAROT drop their user op
I'm honestly so emotional over you having 500k now, I found you through your Outlast 2 play through that Beaver mentioned in one of his videos and have been here every day ever since. I've struggled with depression through college but your videos have always been a safe and happy place for me. You work so hard and absolutely deserve it--can't wait for the 1 million celebration :)
p.s: YAY BABYSITTER BLOODBATH
I give this game a -3/10 because the game isn't about you sitting on babies and using their blood to bathe yourself in, bringing about the new age of the Red One to terrorize the mortals of this planet.
Ryan Leatigaga I can't wait for someone to get r/wooooshed
dqnkie happens a lot with me, unfortunately
Is this the first instance of a cursed comment?
This comment made me have Bloodborne flashbacks
0/10 misleading title
Is Jeffs step-brother still funny in 2019?
_nasal voice_ "I'm Jeff's stepbrother, _boy._ "
Tbh I still go back and watch that video time to time just to see John lose his shit lol
@@InkHyaena What video is that? I'd like to go watch it!
*John sneezes*
Bless you, you sweet, sassy man. Congratulations on your subscriber achievement!
Is this comment supposed to be funny?
John is absolutely a sweet sassy boy
Oh wow, Puppet Combo has come such a long way. So glad they managed to still release games over the years.
Even Michael Myers is scared of this shit
GLAD YOU'RE PLAYING THE WINNER OF THE TWITTER POLL. I've been excited (((:
Funny enough, this game was actually a Halloween fan game before they had to change it to Babysitter Bloodbath due to copyright issues.
_Our boy John has grown so much!_
Babysitter bloodbath. That brings back memories. Especially Johns _Screams!_ John really has become more harshly critical over the years. And can really face some good horror now. I thought it was a really scary game. It was nice that it wasn't a cheesy jumpscare fest, slender clone or Jeff the killer game.
It played like old movies and I guess modern slasher flicks still follow the same structure. Lol. I say it's aged well. Not the greatest but the devs really improved their craft since then.
18:51 “considering nothing’s happened yet” JACK JUST GOT IMPALED, but other than that EVERYTHING IS FINE
PuppetCombo be making one the best horror indie games in the decade!! John should deff play Night Shift!
YES. I WAS HOPING TO SEE THIS ONE AGAIN!
Now I need Markiplier to play this again
Definitely keep this series running. I think it's a total hit with everyone. And this game genuinely scared you! Haven't seen that in a bit
33:22 Amazing AI, he just teleports outside the door for you after you fill the gas tank instead of staying behind you ready to stab, what a nice babysitter killer! XD
😂😂
in the end, the universe conspired for you to do what that 5 year-old comment said "now try killing him with the axe"
*Hears her boyfriend scream as if he just got murdered*
"What happened to the lights?"
Lt. Breaker: Kid is still alive
Sarah: But Jack.....
Sarah: I'M SORRY ABOUT YOUR BOYFRIEND
...
...
...
GAY CONFIRMED
1:27
I love the sneeze edit
man you missed one of the best parts of this game! If you turn on the old radio you get this creepy radio message about a psycho who escaped a local mental hospital and to stay inside
I vaguely remember him doing that in the old playthrough.
Oh, like the story about the man with the hook.
@@Nexils hook. .. ma n ?
@@meowskit Yes. *Clears throat* It's about a dating couple that heads out with the car in the middle of the night.
They make out inside their car near a forest or something when the radio says a criminal escaped nearby their area. They hear a sound and boyfriend investigates while girlfriend stays behind in the car.
She hears scraping noises and eventually the boyfriend returns all panicked, starting the car and leaving immediately.
When they return home they find a butcher hook buried inside the side of the car, making them realise they escaped death.
Nexils no it’s a nod to halloween but ya Ik what your talking about when you say that
"I'm still salty about it 5 years later" This is why I love your playthroughs John
Dude your hair from back in the day is still scary
I will cook you something
Cereal pouring noise intensifies
It's been great watching you do these. I loved this one too. I still can't get over how different the production values are between this video and the old one. It doesn't feel like it was that long ago. I guess it's a sign I'm getting old lol. Thanks for the video John.
Love your videos John I like you revisiting these games
Will the real Jesus please stand up? lol I had to say that.
Jesus approves of you John, that means you should stop holding out on us.
mykarmapolice I’m laying down currently although I am capable of standing
Tails is disappointed in your recent decisions yes I indeed approve of my favorite youtuber John Wolfe
the real jesus Lol
I’m sorry but John getting jump scared while in the middle of sassing a game will always be funny to me 😂
19:23 clearly shows that Babysitter Bloodbath passes the scary test.
I'd love to see Cry Of Fear revisited.
I think he may of revisited that on stream 2ish years back. Or not. Please dont beat me if I'm wrong.
@@BDSL Yeah, I think you're right. It was something of a Halloween Stream, but he didn't post them on his stream channel.
Now I'm really looking forward to the replay of Nighttime Visitor.
yes! we’ve all been waiting for this! thank you john!
At 29:30 when he was walking around the killer and it couldn't get a hit in I drool with laughter pure Gold that was awesome gameplay.
I was literally sitting here bored scrolling through recommended trying to find something to watch and looky here at what just popped up
I hope you’re having a good day John! I love your content. You make my day better💖💖
Rigs the meme he deserves way more recognition!!
gabriela I agree whole heartedly!!! I got my boyfriend to watch him and he loves him!
@@rigs5223 cute Monomi/Usami profile pic
@@cjnewman7550 thank you !!!!
John i love you but that old haircut was tragic babe
Edit: john is beautiful and can be or do whatever he wants. buzzsaw louie must be in a cult since he knows so much about piercings and cults😑
Beronica Garcia -1 to self confidence for John.
The Mohawk was great.
He looks like a wrestler
That hair cut was 🤢😫🤮
Renny Ren A certain Irishman, perhaps? 😂😂😂
Anyone watching in 2022, here's some trivia; Puppet Combo made a paperback novel version of this game! It was written by Regina Watts, and It's available on Amazon and it's pretty decent. The killer gets more backstory and theres a lot of fun gore.
You still need to do two big elephants in the room:
Slender
FNAF
they were never _really_ that scary though
Or he can try Silent Hill again
Springy87 he killed it with silent hill. theres really no reason to visit it. amnesia tho...
@LunarShimmer Doesn't matter if their That Scary or good, it's just that they are "elephants in the room" In other words, their tremendous popularity have made them "stick out", that can be good.......or bad.
Or Penumbra!
This game is one of my favorite videos of yours. I've probably watched the original LP a dozen times by now because it's a mix of campiness and tense moments. Revisiting old playthroughs was a great idea, since so many of us have been with you for a long time. You're one of few UA-camrs that I never grew out of watching. I keep coming back because you're genuine and try different things to make your channel better. You deserve way more than 500k subs.
This series is fire. Again. Do more.
Still Scary is such an original series idea and super entertaining too; really brings back memories. Thanks for the many uploads too John, but don't overwork yourself
That "Let's get fucked up!" in the stereotypical teenage girl voice is what we'll feature at his funeral with the slideshow of all his other endeavors.
22:12 Nice to see John jump. I haven't seen that in awhile.
This is the last video I'll get to see for a few months. 😭 Don't do to much awesome stuff while I'm gone. I'll probably watch all of what I missed.
Where you going?
@@SmashingSnow Basic training. Oklahoma here I come!
@@kroethedragon8520 Good luck
@@SmashingSnow thanks man. I'll miss everyone. Comments are always funny.
Good luck, man. John and the rest of us, his fans, will be here when ya get back.
This is my favorite Puppet Combo game honestly I love it
I still want John to play more old games like this it’s actually really fun watching him replay these old games
John 5 Years ago: Billy, you little shit!
John: You Little Shit!
Good Times, Good Times.
Why do I find John saying "big mood" so humorous?
Puppet combo is a fun developer,and your voice interaction makes the game funnier.
26:30 it's little moments like this that make my day!
I love how when I watched John play this for the first time, him being spooked made me so tense and spooked watching it, but now his spook threshold has increased it's a much nicer experience. Really shows how the UA-camr can influence the person watching
"Nothing is stopping you kid"
But your holding out on us John 👀👀👀
Oh my god I just finished watching your old playthrough of Babysitter Bloodbath and thought, "Maybe John should replay this game as well", my prayers have been answered! I remember first finding your channel through Babysitter Bloodbath, glad to see how far you and your channel has come!
John's absolute saltiness when he's walking around whilst the killer is slashing at him makes me laugh so hard
God where does the time go. I remember first discovering your channel a little over 5 years and binge watching your videos with my then girlfriend. Glad I'm still here! ❤️
*boyfriend gets hella murdered.* *power is cut.* *glass shatters, indicating the murderer has invaded the home.* but climbing down a hatch "seems like drastic measures since nothing is happening" lmao. Just kidding of course, your videos and commentary are my favorite of any UA-cam gamer! This game brings me back, watched when it first came out !
I still watch the old playthrough all the time! One of my favorite parts was when the kid says "I'm hungry" and John replies "well go make yourself a sandwich " omg I love this series
''when was the last time you had a shower sarah'' I felt this so hard as I am a Sarah :D!!
29:37 best UA-cam content ever
Spent a few hours watching your old videos and then you posted a new one! Hell yeah!
Billy is hungry and wants you to feed him.
Years later Billy hears something else saying Feed me Billy!
lol
🎉🎊AH CONGRATS ON 500K🎊🎉
That scene with the split camera is super cool
Man, I couldn't stop laughing at how John was berating Jack. I even spit my drink out from laughing so hard
Kid- Cereal for dinner?!
John- just wait until college, kid.
Still one of my favourite videos of yours. A classic!
I really loved this short series and am so happy you are at 500,000 (even though I think you deserve so much more) this was one of my favorite games you have played!
This game will never not be scary.
The death scream was just “AAAAAAAAAAAOOOOOOOW!”
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS VID!!!
I loved seeing your playthrough of this the first time around, and it's even more fun seeing you play it now. Still gets me when you run into him around a corner and it seems like he pops up outta nowhere. Congrats on 500k!!! I've been watching your videos since 2017; I'm pretty sure the first video of yours I watched was you playing a kittyhorrorshow game. Looking forward to all the hilarious content you put out in the future!
"Attack of the Giant Leeches" That movie sounds like it SUCKS!
Get it?
Leeches suck blood...
A Vampire would've laughed.
Stakes are high, John's run out of ammo, he doesn't have an axe, and he's in a small space with the killer...and what does John say?
"LeT's UsE tHe WhiSkY. SeE iF hE SLiPs On iT."
"DoEs AnYbOdY hAvE a BaNaNa PeEl?"
SUCH A BAD TIME TO MAKE A JOKE BUT I CRACKED. UP.
I've been looking forward to you returning to Babysitter Bloodbath!
woah i didnt know you watched john too! lmao
It's cool how much variety Puppet Combo offers as far as games they've made in this style.
Deciding to watch this at midnight has been the worst mistake I’ve ever made
Probably my favorite you’ve ever played, but I really enjoyed the weird Christmas Santa clause on another planet one. Lol whatever it’s called by puppet combo
“Marie kondo would have a fit with you” 😹
congrats on 500k well deserved and i love this series
*_John Wolfe's fanbase, still Guys?_*
I watched your older playthroughs of the games you covered this weekend at least twice but sometimes three or more. It was so great to see you revisit them and I really hope you make this an on going series!
Not just 5 years, but also around 430k subscribers later ;)
It's so crazy being here for the first 1000 subs and how you've changed over these years. Congrats man you deserve all of it.
Cool to see you re-doing these games!! Was really hoping to see this one re-done. Bet you aren't game to re-do the original Welcome To The Game...