Did God Create Earth And Universe At The Same Time?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 лис 2024
  • / sciencereason ... Did God Create Earth And Universe At The Same Time?" This is a clip from The Atheist Experience #648 ("Interview with UA-cam celeb AronRa. Matt chats with AronRa, who goes after those pesky creationists via UA-cam.") with Matt Dillahunty and AronRa: blip.tv/file/33...
    ---
    Please SUBSCRIBE to Science & Reason:
    • / ffreethinker
    • / sciencetv
    • / best0fscience
    • / rationalhumanism
    ---
    What is The Atheist Experience?
    The Atheist Experience is a weekly cable access television show in Austin, Texas geared at an atheist and non-atheist audience. The Atheist Experience is produced by the Atheist Community of Austin (ACA), a nonprofit educational corporation to develop and support the atheist community, to provide opportunities for socializing and friendship, to promote secular viewpoints, to encourage positive atheist culture, to defend the first amendment principle of state-church separation, to oppose discrimination against atheists and to work with other organizations in pursuit of common goals.
    • www.Atheist-Exp...
    • www.Atheist-Com...
    • www.NonProphets...
    Watch The Atheist Experience live:
    • Ustream: tinyurl.com/TAE...
    • Channel Austin: tinyurl.com/TAE...
    (Sundays 4:30 to 6:00 pm CST / 22:30-24:00 UTC)
    Support the ACA (donations/membership):
    • www.Atheist-Com...
    • www.Atheist-Com...
    • Blog: AtheistExperien...
    • Wiki: www.IronChariot...
    • DVDs: atheist-communi...
    • Blip.tv: atheistexperien...
    • Cartoons: Atheist-Communi...
    • E-mail: tv@atheist-community.org
    .

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,9 тис.

  • @gevorgrate
    @gevorgrate 9 років тому +75

    10 billion year gap.

    • @daverobertson623
      @daverobertson623 9 років тому +16

      gevorgrate - yup ...math fail! Intelligent guy though, we'll call it a slip

    • @genessab
      @genessab 8 років тому +1

      +Dave Robertson on his own channel after he corrected himselfn

    • @halden3014
      @halden3014 5 років тому +1

      that bothered me too...

    • @kentonbaird1723
      @kentonbaird1723 5 років тому +3

      You people focus very hard on a simple verbal error.

    • @TheRealLucifer_Morningstar
      @TheRealLucifer_Morningstar 4 роки тому

      Good catch.

  • @davids11131113
    @davids11131113 10 років тому +156

    The bible is one of the earliest examples of comic books.

    • @noodles00p
      @noodles00p 10 років тому +4

      davids11131113 Needs more grappling hook.

    • @RainingArtillery
      @RainingArtillery 10 років тому +3

      *****
      You have to imagine them. The comic book is so old it relies on good ol' imagination for sounds.

    • @noodles00p
      @noodles00p 10 років тому +3

      ***** "Meanwhile, at the Hall of Justice.."
      We can use WHALES!

    • @daviddrahmann4209
      @daviddrahmann4209 9 років тому +1

      ***** hard to tell the bad guys from the good guys

    • @noodles00p
      @noodles00p 9 років тому +1

      David Drahmann It's essentially all villains, those who are deemed the "good guys" are basically akin to the Suicide Squad facing off against the Legion of Doom.

  • @RandalColling
    @RandalColling 6 років тому +16

    I really like how Aron Ra spends the time to explain his view in plain speak as to help the callers understand. Matt's great too.

  • @TemplarX2
    @TemplarX2 10 років тому +41

    1:30 Correction: 10 billion year gap not 1 billion.

    • @TemplarX2
      @TemplarX2 10 років тому +4

      *****
      Why wouldn't they be smart? It's an honest mathematical mistake. He had his basic inputs right. It's not a mistake out of ignorance, more out of negligence.

    • @boom-headshot2654
      @boom-headshot2654 10 років тому +9

      *****
      You base a persons intellect and sum up their entire persona just by their looks? How superficial and arrogant can you get? I'm still amazed people like you are able to convince a woman to reproduce.

    • @davids11131113
      @davids11131113 10 років тому +2

      ***** Why would any intelligent person care what people who believe in invisible magical creator beings think about them?

    • @myelectroncloud
      @myelectroncloud 10 років тому

      ***** I didn't realise that judging a person by there appearance was an accurate conclusion of their level of intelligence and intellect. Should I renounce my atheism because a person in clerical attire must be more clever than I since they're in touch with an entity that knows everything?

    • @Defcom96
      @Defcom96 10 років тому

      ***** aww the good old sin of prejudice,something that religious people just cant live without!

  • @SocietyPages
    @SocietyPages 11 років тому +46

    Surely Aron's hair is proof of the super-natural.

    • @MrCountrycuz
      @MrCountrycuz 6 років тому +3

      And the fact of a beautiful Asian lady falling in love and marrying Aron is Proof of a miracle.

  • @Ericwvb2
    @Ericwvb2 9 років тому +73

    Day one: God creates heaven and earth, and light and dark.
    Day two: God creates the firmament.
    Day three: God creates land in the water, then plants.
    Day four: God creates the sun and moon; then, as an afterthought, he creates the other stars.
    If there is no sun or stars until day 4, 1) where does the light come from (a surgeon's head mounted light?) and 2) how do we have "days" without a sun?

    • @CondemnedGuy
      @CondemnedGuy 9 років тому +21

      Magic

    • @ouroborosi
      @ouroborosi 9 років тому +4

      +Eric van Bezooijen If i had to defend where the light came from if was a christian i would say..
      that the night and day on the first day was an allegorical for good and evil.
      it's the only way this bullshit will make sense.
      (there plants on earth that have to to with light for a while each year.)

    • @AnkurRoy-bi9yz
      @AnkurRoy-bi9yz 9 років тому +11

      +Eric van Bezooijen Also, the Universe is about 14.5 Billion years old but the Earth is only 4.6 There is a gap of about 10 Billion years. Hence, the heavens and the Earth were not created on day one.

    • @amonraatenra5268
      @amonraatenra5268 9 років тому

      Ankur Roy Sadly I believe that you are a foolish in your interpretations of what is written and how it correlates to the reality you live in.
      The concept of linear perception or time has been speeding up from the beginning of the expansion.
      To say something is an exact age based upon molecular decay is a foolishness.
      As the matter spreads out to form the universe from it's singular point of creation it's molecular decay rate has been accelerating.
      This is the nature of the universe in general concerning the bending of space and time when dealing with gravitational / matter physics.
      So time or your enfeebled perception of the concept of time is irrelevant.
      You should know this already, those laws of physics that speak of matter and gravity being related.
      Einstein's gravitational theory.
      images.search.yahoo.com/yhs/search;_ylt=AwrB8o6GY0ZWURAA47c2nIlQ;_ylu=X3oDMTBsZ29xY3ZzBHNlYwNzZWFyY2gEc2xrA2J1dHRvbg--;_ylc=X1MDMTM1MTE5NTcwMgRfcgMyBGJjawM4cnFhNDNsYXQyOHFmJTI2YiUzRDMlMjZzJTNEcDYEZnIDeWhzLWlyeS1mdWxseWhvc3RlZF8wMDMEZ3ByaWQDWV9SWUZCcUdUZktTdEJvTWIzX204QQRtdGVzdGlkA251bGwEbl9zdWdnAzEwBG9yaWdpbgNpbWFnZXMuc2VhcmNoLnlhaG9vLmNvbQRwb3MDMQRwcXN0cgNFPQRwcXN0cmwDMgRxc3RybAMxMgRxdWVyeQNlPW1jIHNxdWFyZWQEdF9zdG1wAzE0NDc0NTYyNTAEdnRlc3RpZANudWxs?gprid=Y_RYFBqGTfKStBoMb3_m8A&pvid=Qg8HujY5LjGN6UQdVdEjTw4MNTAuMQAAAACMJJo4&p=e%3Dmc+squared&fr=yhs-iry-fullyhosted_003&fr2=sa-gp-images.search.yahoo.com&ei=UTF-8&n=60&x=wrt&type=csp_installertech_15_26&hsimp=yhs-fullyhosted_003&hspart=iry
      Expansion from the singularity or reverse black hole point in time would be an accelerating process of molecular decay.
      If you know the actual physics of this universe.
      As far as the "Heaven" authorship of a book, and the "Earth" or firmament of standards they were created in a day.
      I think you do not know how to read the book myself personally or the evils documented inside of it.
      If you read the bible like a demented foolish child, then that shall be what you become.
      Judges 2:13
      And they forsook the LORD, and served Baal and Ashtaroth.

    • @indignant99
      @indignant99 9 років тому

      +Ankur Roy
      Yeah, and AronRa said One (1) Billion. Duhhh... Brain Fart in Math.

  • @vilkoskorlich259
    @vilkoskorlich259 5 років тому +9

    This is ironic. I just had this same argument with a high school kid this morning who kept insisting that the world is too complex to be anything other than intelligently designed. I used the same argument heard here. If God has this ability to create such complex things than God must also be complex and must have also been designed. He lost me when I got into self-awareness and how could God have this ability without being a biological entity. Evolution is not an "accident." Evolution is nothing more than an on-going chain of reactions. One thing we know about nature is that is always adjusts itself accordingly. It might take tens of thousands of years, but eventually it adjusts.

  • @LEV1ATHYN
    @LEV1ATHYN 14 років тому +4

    Man, Aron is the man. It's so awesome that he's co-hosting now. I hope this partnership continues indefinitely.

  • @HEARTS-OF-SPACE
    @HEARTS-OF-SPACE 10 років тому +21

    Lol, I love enabling captions! When AronRa said "Bhagavad Gita", the caption text read, "buggy buggy to". The second time he said it, it displayed "bug-eyed gator".

    • @ericmishima
      @ericmishima 6 років тому +1

      HEΛRTS OF SPΛCE lol ya know that actually helps me remember how to pronounce it

    • @elainejohnson6955
      @elainejohnson6955 4 роки тому

      That is hysterical, thanx!

  • @mushroomfat
    @mushroomfat 8 років тому +25

    1:20 Im pretty sure he meant 10 billion and i wish he corrected himself because the scale of time between the universe pop and earth pop helps put things into perspective

    • @vshah1010
      @vshah1010 8 років тому

      incorrect math

    • @aaronvenia6193
      @aaronvenia6193 7 років тому +1

      One could say that they are experts in logic and reasonable thinking, as opposed to someone like me who rambles and gets distracted. Speaking of, did I tell you how I got these scars?

    • @rajacali5925
      @rajacali5925 6 років тому

      He wasn't wrong mate.that guy he obviously knows what he talking about.get ur facts right before pointing finger at other. Universe is 13.8 billion years old which makes it almost 14 billions

    • @petyrkowalski9887
      @petyrkowalski9887 6 років тому +1

      He clearly meant 10billion...a slip of the tongue

    • @KodyXXVll
      @KodyXXVll 5 років тому

      @@rajacali5925 Wow you're an even bigger idiot. He said the universe was 14 billion years old and the earth is only 4 billion years old, then he said that means there's a one billion year gap between the creation of the two. That's very wrong. there's a 10 billion year gap. And not even matt dillahunty caught the mistake apparently. what a bunch of cucks

  • @richpack5927
    @richpack5927 7 років тому +9

    aron screwed up, he said there is a billion year Gap between The big bang and the formation of earth, when there is a 9 billion year Gap.

  • @donaldcook2484
    @donaldcook2484 2 роки тому +4

    Aron and Matt are unbelievably knowledgeable and intelligent!! Impossible to beat them at reality!!

  • @TheYankeesUnited
    @TheYankeesUnited 7 років тому +10

    who's the guy with Matt? he should be on more often. i havnt found any vids of him besides 2010.

    • @EdMcCornhole
      @EdMcCornhole 5 років тому +5

      He looks like a reverend preacher for "Motorhead"

    • @MrRainrunner
      @MrRainrunner 3 роки тому

      Aron Ra.

  • @instereovideos
    @instereovideos 12 років тому +1

    The two best hosts ever, Matt and Death-Metal Matt.

  • @Soldier4USA2005
    @Soldier4USA2005 12 років тому +2

    Aron Ra is awesome.
    His ability to construct proper arguments with solid knowledge, is just amazing.

  • @deanmoncaster
    @deanmoncaster 5 років тому +4

    These two are like the best of their type

  • @Icemanactual
    @Icemanactual 10 років тому +6

    Some of these people asking questions sound so unintelligent. I mean holy hell...the ladies first question made no sense and then when she gets an answer she says "....o-k?"

  • @Yewon2001
    @Yewon2001 10 років тому +17

    I love Aron Ra!

  • @MissBrri
    @MissBrri 11 років тому +1

    Agreed, I was a hard-core Christian. After years of devotion, I never once felt the "presence" of god.
    All religion does is try to scare or control you. "Do this or you're going to hell!"

  • @SPADES6o6
    @SPADES6o6 11 років тому +1

    thank you for your comment, made me feel a little better because the things your saying is written in the bible thousands of years ago

  • @deanmoncaster
    @deanmoncaster 4 роки тому +4

    God has existed forever. Yet the earth is 6000 years old. What did he do before he created the earth?

    • @dangerouslevelsofsobriety1503
      @dangerouslevelsofsobriety1503 2 роки тому

      The Bible doesn't say the earth is 6,000 years old, that conclusion is only found by taking the word "day" in Genesis to refer to a 24 hour day. Which it isn't.

    • @deanmoncaster
      @deanmoncaster 2 роки тому +1

      @@dangerouslevelsofsobriety1503 you tell that to the Bible scholars that worked it out. That's the joy of the Bible, so open to interpretation that it's useless.

  • @GodEqualstheSquaRootof-1
    @GodEqualstheSquaRootof-1 7 років тому +13

    Creationists are evidence that we have common ancestors to Neanderthals.

    • @jahrta
      @jahrta 6 років тому +2

      The Neanderthals had a better concept of reality and logic

    • @jilliansmith7123
      @jilliansmith7123 6 років тому

      The Neanderthals had larger brains than ours. How about creationists are evidence that humans are social animals and take care of each other--even the lame, the halt, and the mentally deficient...hence our "success" at reaching 7.6 billion of us right now?

  • @faithfail
    @faithfail 7 років тому +14

    the problem is these guys are too smart for most callers, and while I am happy they don't dumb down their vernacular to the level of these uneducated people, but I think most of what they say floes over their heads.

    • @ravenwda007
      @ravenwda007 7 років тому +1

      Not mine. I get it crystal clear. They do a great job.

    • @ysf-psfx
      @ysf-psfx 5 років тому +1

      Thought the same thing about most of the episodes of this show. Tracy seems to be a little better at getting through to people, even though she's extremely smart too.

    • @deanmoncaster
      @deanmoncaster 4 роки тому

      Flows

  • @gunz300
    @gunz300 12 років тому +2

    Wow, that was a FANTASTIC explanation. Bravo my friend.

  • @SinceretheGhost
    @SinceretheGhost 12 років тому

    I wish it was these two all the time. Matt can verbally shred the callers, and AronRa can calmly and gracefully drop knowledge on them.

  • @artwdog
    @artwdog 10 років тому +5

    not 1, 10.

  • @OG213LA
    @OG213LA 7 років тому +4

    I like the guy with the long hair! He tells them straight out!

  • @keanankinman1508
    @keanankinman1508 8 років тому +4

    (I've been thinking about this for a decent few hours...and I killed myself.)
    If God created the Universe, then that shows God existed before the time of the Universe, but, you cannot say God existed before the Universe because time was created when the Universe was made, so, there was no technical before, but God created the Universe, which is already shown wrong by time, so, does that mean God came to existence at the same time as the Universe? That wouldn't be right because God created the Universe. So, either God created a Universe to create the Universe(Which is shown wrong here and makes no sense), God came to existence at the same time as the Universe, (Which means he didn't create the Universe) or God just created what is in the Universe instead of creating the Universe.(Which means he didn't create the Universe) I'm still trying to work this out, by the way.

    • @keanankinman1508
      @keanankinman1508 8 років тому +1

      Let's just say, there was also no where God could have been, he literally couldn't have existed to create the Universe not only because of time, but also because of the fact there was no place he could have been, unless the Multiverse Theory is true, which means there were several Big Bangs which throws God out of the picture. Damn my mind is fucked...

    • @gregorypdearth
      @gregorypdearth 8 років тому +1

      That is where the convenient self-defined terms come into apologetics. Take 'transcendent' for example. All that means is 'beyond' regarding our universe. It is a neat little word that gives their god a place to be (and indeed his own independent time line) when creating universes. No multiverse is necessary when you can just make up existence-states like 'transcendent.'
      But you are right about that multiverse hypothesis. It is like 'transcendence' as it represents the concept that a universe can be a container unto itself and thus there are ways to exist outside that container. If we then define the multiverse as infinite, such that there are an infinite number of containers (universes), then it is no surprise that our universe would exist... it would eventually have to exist, thus removing the necessity for an intentional creation.
      But this is all hypothetical nonsense (potentially). The universe is not nearly as finely tuned as people assert. Rather, if it is tuned for anything it is to create black holes and voids hostile to life (the vast majority of the universe falls into one of those two categories). Rather, if there is a multiverse, there are inevitably universes BETTER suited for life than ours. The problem is that we imagine life as we know it, and cannot typically imagine the completely different form life could take if physical laws, the very structure of the cosmos, or even the existence of matter were completely different.
      The thing about the big bang is that it ONLY describes an expansion event. In some models T=0 at the big bang (meaning time started there), but that is only from our perspective. The expansion of the cosmos creates a nice "arrow of time" (as Hawking put it) against which we can measure events relative to each other. But that arrow can just as easily be conceptually extended back before the big bang event. The problem is that we haven't a clue about even the existence of anything prior to the big bang (other than the singularity itself), and thus don't have any events to plot to make that extension meaningful.
      But there is nothing inherently wrong with just saying time is eternal, extending infinitely before and after the big bang event. Before the big bang, the singularity wasn't doing anything. It spontaneously started expanding at some point due to a random quantum fluctuation, since the infinite density/energy of that state is unstable. It had to eventually start expanding as it could not indefinitely remain compacted. But since nothing was happening before that event (the singularity was just existing, with no defining events), making T=0 is just a logical place to start.
      So thus you can even have a single universe, with an infinite timeline, extending before and after the big bang event and still no god required to change it from a singularity state to an expanding cosmos barely suitable for life. The possibility of the multiverse makes the anthropic question even easier to answer, but regardless, we are here because we developed barely able to survive the conditions of the universe around us. It doesn't have to be a mystery.

    • @keanankinman1508
      @keanankinman1508 8 років тому +1

      Gregory Dearth Hm. Yes, I can definitely agree with, all of that.

    • @Jamie-Russell-CME
      @Jamie-Russell-CME 8 років тому

      +Gregory Dearth
      yeah, okay buddy. And how many orders of magnitude is it less fine tuned? As to the level of fined tuned - ness the average "people" presume. (in which you are in such a position to declare)

    • @gregorypdearth
      @gregorypdearth 8 років тому +1

      jamie Russell Compared to what? There is not an objective basis to make a measurement of 'magnitude.' I reject fine tuning altogether as nonsense based on a biased perspective of egotistical sentient humans interpreting the universe around them as somehow made for them without a shred of evidence. So I obviously cannot tell you how much 'less' fine tuned it is if I don't regard it as being finely tuned at all.
      Rather, I think of our existence as a statistical probability in a universe as vast as ours. Given the sheer number of planetary star systems out there, it is statistically inevitable that SOME planet SOMEWHERE would have the conditions necessary for SOME form of intelligent life compatible with THAT particular system. We are the lucky winners of that lottery. But the more we learn about life the more we find that it can survive in a wide range of conditions, meaning it might not be that rare anyway.
      The other thing to consider is the perspective that life is only as we know it. We haven't any other examples to compare life to than what developed on our tiny blue dot. For all we know, life can develop in completely unique ways in conditions WE consider inhospitable.
      This humility extends the concept to even different universe configurations. Why it is that we think life requires 3 dimensions of space and one of time is entirely egotistical and narrow-minded. There is no reason to rule out the possibility of some different type of life form in a universe with, say, 5 dimensions of space and two arrows of time, with more anti-matter than matter, and with various physical constants that either are different than the values in our universe or are completely unique, with no analogy to our universe whatsoever. Whereas we think of gravity as a feature of the universe, another being in another universe might have a completely different type of force, different ways that energy interacts, so different that we cannot even imagine what they could be.
      Lacking any information about life developing or failing to on other planets, let alone in other universes, making a calculation of the finely tuned universe is completely baseless. It is like the water in a puddle becoming conscious and pondering how it is that the hole it is in fits it so perfectly.
      It is a meaningless exercise derived from an egotistical assertion of purpose and intent, as a means to imbue existence with metaphysical meaning.

  • @kidi1232
    @kidi1232 12 років тому +1

    excellent explanation!
    I think the "look at book X, why do you think yours is better? because your father believed in it?"

  • @versioncity1
    @versioncity1 12 років тому

    the logic of that last paragraph is almost beyond words. That people just take this sort of thinking for granted just highlights how primitive we actually are.

  • @bradm6287
    @bradm6287 9 років тому +7

    God create the universe, Earth and me a week ago. All of you exist to fill my world. You were given memories and direction only fort the purpose of serving my will, even though we may never meet,.

    • @SuperNemx
      @SuperNemx 9 років тому +4

      You are truly the main character of the universe, Brad M.

    • @DjNotNicesNucka
      @DjNotNicesNucka 6 років тому

      Brad M yea right solipsist

    • @Detson404
      @Detson404 6 років тому +1

      I always knew I was a NPC.

    • @justsomeguy2825
      @justsomeguy2825 5 років тому

      No, I'm the center of the universe, because I'm concious right now, and you're a dream sprite.

  • @jamescunningham4418
    @jamescunningham4418 7 років тому +5

    Earff!

    • @ummmummm563
      @ummmummm563 7 років тому

      James Cunningham well, Louisiana

  • @iREPda609
    @iREPda609 10 років тому +13

    It sucks that Aron Ra is a feminist now :(

    • @7gamex
      @7gamex 10 років тому +11

      What's wrong with that?

    • @iREPda609
      @iREPda609 10 років тому +5

      ***** That's like asking whats wrong with religion...

    • @7gamex
      @7gamex 10 років тому +13

      iREPda609
      No, it really isn't. What's wrong with Aron Ra being a feminist?

    • @davids11131113
      @davids11131113 10 років тому +3

      I just don't accept their assertion that 'only women can solve problems', that just seems very simplistic and silly. I'd disagree with Hitchens and Ra if that is their position.

    • @7gamex
      @7gamex 10 років тому +16

      davids11131113
      I highly doubt that that is their position...

  • @automateTec
    @automateTec 11 років тому

    Verse 3. “Then God said, "Let there be light"; and there was light.” It is easy to imagine the dark smoke parting at His command like throwing open the curtains in the morning.
    Verse 4. “And God saw the light, that it was good; and God divided the light from the darkness.” Again, from the earth’s perspective, our day and night division is caused by the rotation of the planet.
    Verse 5. “God called the light Day, and the darkness He called Night. So the evening and the morning were the first day.”

  • @lancethrustworthy
    @lancethrustworthy 10 років тому +1

    Good one! You left us wanting more.

  • @xsilentbulletsx
    @xsilentbulletsx 10 років тому +1

    first video im watching with AronRa and glad to see another well spoken individual making clear points.

  • @DPoole-hu6vj
    @DPoole-hu6vj 11 років тому

    How are people restricting your right to pray and worship?

  • @automateTec
    @automateTec 11 років тому

    Verse 1. “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.” One verse to describe the formation of our uni verse: the start of time and creation of all space and matter.
    Verse 2. “The earth was without form, and void; and darkness was on the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God was hovering over the face of the waters.” A brand new water planet enshrouded in darkness and the Spirit of God (power!) moving (motion) above the water. (Note the 5 aspects of the universe taught by science.)

  • @KJC63
    @KJC63 12 років тому

    Ronald Eldon Wyatt (1933 - August 4, 1999) was an adventurer and former nurse anaesthetist noted for advocating the Durupınar site as the site of Noah's Ark, among other Bible-related pseudoarchaeology. His claims were dismissed by scientists, historians, biblical scholars, and even by leaders in his own Seventh-day Adventist Church, but his work continues to have a following among some fundamentalists and evangelicals.

  • @Wreckit_wreckit
    @Wreckit_wreckit 11 років тому

    2 Timothy 2:15 says Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.

  • @juniorvaifanua6625
    @juniorvaifanua6625 5 років тому +1

    "Earflings, take me to your leader..."

  • @WunHungLo99
    @WunHungLo99 5 років тому

    I like this chilled Ra. 9 years of dealing with deluded theists has clearly turned him into a short tempered grumpy man when dealing with the same mad arguments again and again, hardly surprising tbh.

  • @raviept
    @raviept 12 років тому

    Honestly, it's refreshing to listen to the opinion of AronRa. The guy clearly knows what he is talking about and he is honestly trying to make people understand some important aspects about this whole discussion. He is trying to catch flies with honey, not vinegar.

  • @linkforever92
    @linkforever92 11 років тому

    “I wish it need not have happened in my time," said Frodo.
    "So do I," said Gandalf, "and so do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.”
    ― J.R.R. Tolkien, The Fellowship of the Ring

  • @TheLordOfTheSporks
    @TheLordOfTheSporks 11 років тому

    I'm not the dunce here. I never said I don't consider reflected light as light. I said it was wrong to label the moon as "a light", since it doesn't emit any, unlike the sun. You reflect light also - should I call you "a light" then?
    Why do you assume that when it says "light" in Genesis is referring to the cosmic microwave background radiation, when we first discovered it less than a hundred years ago? How do you propose they knew about it?

  • @areeweblind
    @areeweblind 11 років тому +1

    Man, what I wouldn't give to have AronRa's voice or one that deep and cool.

    • @gregdawe2786
      @gregdawe2786 11 років тому

      ***** but they still have wonderfully sounding voices which no doubt can be linked in some way to their success. boy you really escalated that guys comment quickly

  • @alvagoldbook2
    @alvagoldbook2 11 років тому

    Technical correction. The earth is 4.5 billion years old, and the universe is 13.81 billion years old, meaning that the universe was already 9 billion years old when the earth was formed.

  • @terilw
    @terilw 2 роки тому

    I wonder if the caller hung up.. She went silent while Matt and Aron were talking..

  • @redryan20000
    @redryan20000 12 років тому

    how can you know that god is perfect if you yourself admit to being imperfect? Doesn't that sort of make you question whether you are right in believing in god?

  • @Cornwalas2
    @Cornwalas2 7 років тому +2

    hopefully that kid was paying attention and not smoking a blunt or something..

  • @craze1701
    @craze1701 12 років тому

    Just because someone doesn't fall for what you believe in, doesn't make them bad. You have to think before you express yourself.

  • @TheTvidi
    @TheTvidi 12 років тому

    Who created God? Where did he come from? Why he decided to create human?

  • @raviept
    @raviept 12 років тому

    What kind of dataing are you referring to? Because, if you are interested in any kind of scientific research, the best thing you can do is to read books on the area or, better, read some of the original scientific papers on the subject. If you want to understand something, then don't expect information to come to you. This is a general advice, since i'm not really interested in any dating process whatsoever, so don't ask me to remove your doubts.

  • @VANEPS7
    @VANEPS7 11 років тому

    When the story was written people did not know that the earth was formed over ten billion years after the universe, hence the genesis myth telling that the earth and the universe were formed virtually simultaneously which we later learned wasn't even close.

  • @V1ralB1ack
    @V1ralB1ack 11 років тому

    Honor thy father and mother.
    - Exodus 20:12
    If any man come to me, and hate not his father and mother, and
    wife, and children, and brethren, and sisters, yea, and his own
    life also, he cannot be my disciple.
    - Luke 14:26
    Would you like more? I'd also like to point out in genesis god creates everything in 6 days but that raises more problems. Why does god use time if time is a human creation? Humans use days to measure the rotation around the sun. What was god doing before genesis?

  • @starlaminde8436
    @starlaminde8436 Рік тому

    Sitting at that desk are two extremely important influences in my life.

  • @jkovert
    @jkovert 11 років тому

    Actually, my information comes directly from the text.
    When reading the Bible (or any written material, for that matter), one must consider:
    Type of literature, cultural context, date and place of writing, information about the recipients/audience, historical setting, literary clues/references within the text, etc.
    In other words, context.

  • @Ine7tia
    @Ine7tia 12 років тому

    Don't forget about not telling the vast majority of the rest of the world, and punishing them because you didn't let them know.

  • @ickybiker
    @ickybiker 12 років тому

    In addition to AronRa's comment about the 4 days (it was 3 actually, but who's counting?) to create the earth and one day for the sun and stars, It's also interesting that god said "let there be light, and there was light" and "god divided the light from the darkness" on the first day, (implying a sun and rotating earth) yet the things that make light (sun and stars) weren't created until the 4th day?
    So god worked for 3 days with a flashlight?

  • @PhysicsNerd25
    @PhysicsNerd25 12 років тому

    So AronRa mentions the Bhagvad Gita, and I'm not sure if anyone else has brought this up, but the Gita is actually an extract from the Mahabharat NOT a stand alone book and anyone who thinks that it is valid and consistant on it's own is quite misguided. That being said, the Mahabharat itself takes the form of a story being told and my understanding that it is not and never was intended to be a historical account of anything. I could be wrong.

  • @deanmoncaster
    @deanmoncaster 5 років тому +1

    A billion year gap between the big bang and the formation of the earth.... You meant ten billion aaron! We also think that the universe could be older just we cannot see it!

  • @joestfrancois
    @joestfrancois 12 років тому

    Gr800sofire wrote "Why don't you investigate why professors at prestigious universities have been fired because, after a careful look at the facts they could no longer support evolution theory."
    Uh, could you provide any names of these people? If there are less than like 1000 then it is not a significant amount. You would think they would start an organization of ex-educators against evolution or something if it happened often at all.

  • @Kurvok
    @Kurvok 10 років тому +1

    The actually translation is circle thats why. See people more or less theist change little part , meaing of word or taking whole half paragraph out cause thay know it disproves their beliefs

  • @TheTvidi
    @TheTvidi 12 років тому

    I know that. I was asking who/or what made God. And where did it come, creationists likes to say, that someone had to made matter, so there has to be higher power to do it.

  • @SinceretheGhost
    @SinceretheGhost 12 років тому

    I can understand how people can say they should be used as a "guide", as a way to give the people their books but...even as just guides they can cause, and have caused, serious issues because people use the things they say to create laws on the basis of what the books say.

  • @donkeysausages
    @donkeysausages 12 років тому

    On the left is AaronRa (I assume this is who you meant) - a link to his channel is in the video description (youtube/AaronRa) along with some other cool channels. On the right is Matt Dillahunty.

  • @evangelosnitsopoulos5897
    @evangelosnitsopoulos5897 7 років тому +2

    ...video like this may open -- blind eyes off stubborn creationists.....

  • @MrDunsapy
    @MrDunsapy 12 років тому

    @MegaJay79 Actually archaeology now found a lot of evidence of King David. The City of David was discovered under Jerusalem, and is a tourist destination now. Also from his Son Solomon.
    A stone erected to pay tribute to King Hazael of Syria, and a record of his victories over Israel, was uncovered during excavations in the biblical city of Dan in 1993.
    The stone mentions the name "House of David."

  • @FrankLightheart
    @FrankLightheart 11 років тому

    Matt has a habit of dominating the conversation, but not when Ra is around.

  • @madwonko
    @madwonko 11 років тому

    I did not make the claim that the modern understanding of Doppler effect is faulty. Anyone that would disprove it certainly would qualify for the Nobel price. Until then your supposition is groundless and unproven.

  • @w.astephenson280
    @w.astephenson280 11 років тому

    "Sea plants adapt." Dude you just agreed with evolution. Those plants still need radiation which they get through thermal vents.

  • @iNoticetheseThings
    @iNoticetheseThings 11 років тому

    AronRa should be made a regular co-host. He is so brilliant and speaks with such clarity. He and Matt look like they could be cousins. If I were a back-boneless buffoon with no moral guidance of my own, I would probably worship them.

  • @munstrumridcully
    @munstrumridcully 12 років тому

    you didn't specify which quote you wanted.
    "Let everyone see that you are considerate in all you do. Remember, the Lord is coming soon" Philippians 4:5

  • @Penningtontj
    @Penningtontj 12 років тому

    Not just in a dead language, but several dead languages or forms of languages that would become archaic relatively quickly.

  • @munstrumridcully
    @munstrumridcully 12 років тому

    wow, the verse says specifically "never rebuilt" it was, and the island of tyre is no desolate rock, look it up on a geography site, not a theist apolgist site that isn't even about geography.
    as i say, the text is clear, yet theists have to find some interperetation that fits their view.
    if the verse says, "you will never be rebuilt", about tyre, the island city, and it was rebuilt, then the verse is wrong. period. it didn't say"PART of you will bever be rebuilt"

  • @hglundahl
    @hglundahl 4 роки тому

    1:40 A ten billion year gap, actually ... or nine billion year, depending on whether you place universe at 13 or 14 billion years ago.
    Obviously, I place both heaven (all of the universe above earth) and earth at 5199 BC, some parts of universe being four days younger than earth, like the celestial bodies ... I don't have a problem with Ecclesiasticus (Sirach) 18:1 or Genesis 1:1 or Mark 10:6. I think the caller has.

  • @jmisic
    @jmisic 13 років тому

    The thing is that I heard a very bright physicist that Dellahunty recommended listening too. He said the same thing, which made me very confused. He said that there was a billion year gap between the big bang and the «creation« of the earth. My math says 10 billion though. Please clarify if someone understands this

  • @kyleventer7061
    @kyleventer7061 11 років тому

    When you see a painting on a wall? Have you ever seen the artist who painted it? Just because you have not seen the artist doesn't mean he does not exist.The very existence of the painting is proof of the existence of its painter. In the very same way the very existence of creation is proof of the existence of its Creator". Anyways, y'all have a wonderful time agreeing with each other I am going for a surf and enjoying Gods Amazing Creation.

  • @gloriaday8572
    @gloriaday8572 11 років тому

    It's not a critical-thinking. It's just some thoughts of encouragement. To bring lost souls to God. Believe it or not, that's your decision. No one is forcing you to believe. But you can say all you want but just spread before regretting it later. A story about a man who died after rejecting the gospel & now he's in hell already. There are many testimonies have been spread around the world...sending out God's messages to warn people to be ready!

  • @foiran
    @foiran 11 років тому

    Listing to that silly twit's opening question really makes one realise that we are dealing with a bunch of people who haven't managed to develop, in any sense, other than the physical, past infancy; fills me with despair.

  • @Haywerth
    @Haywerth 13 років тому

    @jmisic you said in part "...is there not a ten billion year gap?"
    No. Aron said in part "So we have about a billion year gap between what would be the Big Bang and the formation of the Earth and the Solar System." The key word is "formation." The Earth and Solar System didn't just pop into existence a billion years after the Big Bang. Rather, they BEGAN TO FORM a billion years after the Big Bang and its formation was complete after about 10-20 million years.

  • @jameswest8280
    @jameswest8280 6 років тому

    Aron made one mistake. He said the time between the big bang and the formation of the Earth was one billion years, it was closer to nine billion years. Not trying to be critical, just trying to set the record straight.

  • @automateTec
    @automateTec 11 років тому

    Exodus 20:11 “For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea, and all that is in them, and rested the seventh day...”

  • @MichaelMeridius
    @MichaelMeridius 11 років тому +1

    Ten BILLION year difference between the Universe and earth :)

  • @jahrta
    @jahrta 6 років тому +2

    1:34 I think you meant ten billion 😉

  • @anothga
    @anothga 11 років тому

    So, if I write new scripture, totally unrelated to any existing religion, and put some science in it, will the claims in it be automatically correct?

  • @colinjava8447
    @colinjava8447 7 років тому +2

    More wise words from Aron Ra probably falling on deaf ears though.

  • @MrJDylka
    @MrJDylka 12 років тому

    Here's the difference. You can check their work. All science is published and available for anyone to challenge. Want to become a household name overnight? Disprove an established scientific theory (ie, evolution, gravitation, etc).

  • @SlatheTheSpaceMarine
    @SlatheTheSpaceMarine 11 років тому

    Captain Kirk said "what does god need with a space ship?" - Matt Dillahunty

  • @TheLordOfTheSporks
    @TheLordOfTheSporks 11 років тому

    That's funny, because Genesis says God created light, land and plants before the sun...
    And let's not forget the whole deal about the "firmament" that "divides waters from waters". To claim that the creation account in Genesis is even remotely supported by evidence is completely nuts.

  • @kyleventer7061
    @kyleventer7061 11 років тому

    One last thought to leave ya with because I have had my fill of empty vessels for one day. If you do not believe in anything, who is it that you serve? What, if any, is our purpose on this earth? Are we simply drifting through life and then we die? Or is there a greater battle raging in front of our very eyes for the hearts and minds of mankind? My being cannot accept that there is no Creator, no purpose, for without that purpose we are essentially void of reason, mystery and substance.

  • @robertlongwill8856
    @robertlongwill8856 5 років тому

    aron ra was wrong. he stated that the universe is 1 billion years older than the earth. in reality it is 10 billion years older than earth according to the timeline

  • @petyrkowalski9887
    @petyrkowalski9887 6 років тому

    Its actually about a 10 billion year gap between the big bang and the appearance of the earth which formed from the accretion disc around the sun due to gravity.

  • @joestfrancois
    @joestfrancois 12 років тому

    YaOkRight wrote "Do you know what Orbs,poltergeists and ectoplasm are? They are spiritual forces - spirits are real as GOD is a spirit and he has created an army of spirits -all plays out for his glory."
    You sound pretty certain, how do you know this?

  • @Juxtaroberto
    @Juxtaroberto 12 років тому

    LOL no. The other guy answered why we don't carbon date dinosaur bones, but the reason we don't carbon date mollusks is that they live in the sea, and the sea is a sink for carbon, so most of the carbon 14 in them has already decayed and it would yield a false reading.

  • @VIIflegias
    @VIIflegias 12 років тому

    but you think you need to be saved. why? from what?

  • @gabrielesimionato1210
    @gabrielesimionato1210 6 років тому

    1:40 did AronRa mean 10 billion years?

  • @AnonyStoner420
    @AnonyStoner420 11 років тому

    Who was that captivating man with the flowing hair. I must know he's amazing.

  • @avedic
    @avedic 11 років тому

    Faith? I don't have faith in him or anything. Why would I do that?

  • @quinngir
    @quinngir 12 років тому

    Thankfully it's illegal to do so in schools supported by the government. Private schools, on the other hand, can teach whatever they want.