Yeah she was the best judge in my opinion because most of her criticisms were constructive and made sense. Plus she was in destiny’s child since she was really young, she knows about the industry and everything
Kelly did make Little Mix from the beginning she kept saying how they should be in a girl group and then when they were deciding she wanted to put them together and they took a chance and now they are one of the biggest bands right now
I think Louis still said yes to Perrie. He thought the performance was too safe but he wasn't denying she was a good singer. The only member who got a no was Jesy (from Gary)
I feel like when its half and half like that where 2 say yes and 2 say no there should be like a tie breaker where the audience decides yes or no or the host of the show.
I thought that meg was very good and deserved a chance. All I think she needed was a bit of confidence and she'd be there. I think that girl group Indigo Rose were very good, deserved a yes and deserved a chance to go through and progress as well. I was quite surprised Louis gave Perrie Edwards a no. I thought she was really good and look at her now. She's in Little Mix and doing very well.
I agree, the first girl did not ready for (this time) competition. She was only a seed, she needs to be grown - at least to be a sprout - before she could put herself out to a sunny day. A seed in a the blazing sun day? ppfff..... Those heat will burn her will. Louis said she not ready, he didn't say she can't be a contestant.
Not really honey, she has an OPINION and a passion. Yes sometimes she takes something close to heart and becomes passionate/emotional but usually she's restrained and logical.
Kelly yelling at them about the 16 yr old but also yelling about the 17 yr old. Kelly don't like your opinion then Kelly will tell ya. I can see why Kelly left. Tulsia had a point, she's allowed an opinion without being talked down to. I liked Nicole better with these 3 anyway I wasn't sad she left.
Kelly did make Little Mix from the beginning she kept saying how they should be in a girl group and then when they were deciding she wanted to put them together and they took a chance and now they are one of the biggest bands right now
@@kevinlongman007 they only credit Kelly when talking about who really put them together though. Kelly did all the talking when it came to forming them when they were individuals on Xfactor auditions
@@CorCor89 I'm not sure why Tulisa was chosen to mentor the groups when Kelly was a member of a far bigger group than N Dubz ever were! Tulisa should have had the girls and Kelly the groups. But Little Mix would still have won anyway.
Kelly is a one of the only ones who actually knows what she's speaking on when it comes to judging tbh
Yeah she was the best judge in my opinion because most of her criticisms were constructive and made sense. Plus she was in destiny’s child since she was really young, she knows about the industry and everything
Kelly knew immediately the talent that Perrie had, she's now one of the more talented female vocalists of this generation
So people were saying tha Tulisa made Little Mix, but she said no to Perrie in first place. Kelly was the one trying to put all those girls together.
Actually Tulisa said yes, cause you need 3 yes's to get through so if Louis said no then Tulisa said yes
kelly put all the girls together and the judges agreed with her then tulisa was chosen to be their mentor and apologised to perrie
Kelly made Little Mix, Tulisa was their mentor.
Jed Martins what's a mentor I am only 10
Anddd fast forward from Perrie's time in this video to now, and she's in one of the most popular girl bands, Little Mix.
Asian Rachel THE biggest girl band in the world, actually 😃😃👌🏻
Yes it Took 2 yrs for voice to get there in the run with plenty vocal coachingp
Kelly did make Little Mix from the beginning she kept saying how they should be in a girl group and then when they were deciding she wanted to put them together and they took a chance and now they are one of the biggest bands right now
To be fair loui said no to Nial Horan AND Perrie so even though he has a lot of experiance i do understand how they all disagree at times
He also said no to Harry Styles, saying he was too young
He always says no to young age to middle aged female auditions
No Cheryl said no to Niall Horan
I think Louis still said yes to Perrie. He thought the performance was too safe but he wasn't denying she was a good singer.
The only member who got a no was Jesy (from Gary)
Wtf? Perrie is freaking awesome!
Perrie!! Her voice was so amazing even here
PERRIE!!!! My baby Perrie! 😍😍😍😍
Louis said "How dare she?" ahaha when Cowell treated me like an idiot he didn't get so upset....wow!
haha Perrie Edwards!! She's really incredible!!!
The first and the third audition had very nice vocal. What was Louis thinking???
It's perrie frm little mix!.
No,i felt that the first girl was great! Why do they just be so picky? She's going and i think she's great!
Judges are not in harmony,i just love Gary
I feel like when its half and half like that where 2 say yes and 2 say no there should be like a tie breaker where the audience decides yes or no or the host of the show.
Yeah that would be a good idea. I mean getting 3 yeses to get through makes sense seen as though more Judges have said yes than not.
Tulisa was deffo the worst judge. And Louis wasn't that great either
hahaha what happen to the judges??but one thing can make me happy to watching tulisa she's beautiful!
PERRIE IS FREAKIG AMAZING!!!!! hoe can he don't like her o.o
PERRIE? NONONONONO
Who is the judge second to the left when you are looking at the stage from the performers POV?>
Tulisa
Poor tulisa... :P
I know everyone always hates on her!
narnia narnia she was my favorite judge of all time
fuck tulisa, and louis. tweedle dee and tweedle dum
This type of shit that happens everyday...💀☠️💀
Tulisa is such a slapper
Tulisa needs to relax. She acts like she is some type super star but the only reason people know her is from this showy
I thought that meg was very good and deserved a chance. All I think she needed was a bit of confidence and she'd be there. I think that girl group Indigo Rose were very good, deserved a yes and deserved a chance to go through and progress as well. I was quite surprised Louis gave Perrie Edwards a no. I thought she was really good and look at her now. She's in Little Mix and doing very well.
Funny judge....
Gary Barlow and Kelly Rowland over Louis Walsh and Tulisa any day (even though I love Tulisa too) 😍🥰
Lol they fought over Perrie. They didn't include the performance of LM at the Rock week.
perrie is famous now because of little mix
Watch again, and I love Louis.
oh,,the drama..who would want to argue with Kelly?
Darryl Portra no one wins against kelly lmfao
I'm like Louis, wth are you on about man
PERRIE OMG. Tulisa tho 😂😂
Tulisa x
its like tulisa v louis gary and kelly lol and she wont back down either
To be honest they all made terrible decisions and critiques throughout this season. Even Louie who had been doing it for years
This was like the worst mix of judges
I agree, the first girl did not ready for (this time) competition. She was only a seed, she needs to be grown - at least to be a sprout - before she could put herself out to a sunny day. A seed in a the blazing sun day? ppfff..... Those heat will burn her will. Louis said she not ready, he didn't say she can't be a contestant.
Louis would have got it by now
louis shushing kelly? nope i wont take it
Kelly=Tulisa
I can see why Louis didn't like P!
Who’s P?
The judges keep argueing like wtf they all needa start agreeing
lol
Tuff day Louie but I’m with you !
lol.. loui shouldn't be judging what under ware he puts on for the day... i say FIRE HIM..
Kelly >>> Tulisa
paerrie looooooooool
anybody was good there sorry
This just proves tulisa was a terrible judge of talent
Kelly Rowland always appears so aggressive
Shut up
Smh
You are right,she is super aggressive,
@@beatrice-pg1jl and Louis didn’t come across aggressive to you during the first audition no? Smh
Kelly has a temper.
Not really honey, she has an OPINION and a passion. Yes sometimes she takes something close to heart and becomes passionate/emotional but usually she's restrained and logical.
racist.
And clearly you are prejudiced.
KELLY ROWLAND WITHOUT MAKE-UP= NOTHING
you don’t know what you’re talking about, she is gorgeous
Kelly Roland was such a dreadful judge thank goodness they kicked her out
And brought her to the USA x factor and no she judges the Voice in Australia
She was 1 of 2 on the panel who actually had talent (hint: it’s not Tulisa or Louis) and she had common sense and sensible critique.
I’m guessing Kelly Rowland and Nicole Scherzinger were probably very similar personally.
Kelly yelling at them about the 16 yr old but also yelling about the 17 yr old. Kelly don't like your opinion then Kelly will tell ya. I can see why Kelly left. Tulsia had a point, she's allowed an opinion without being talked down to.
I liked Nicole better with these 3 anyway I wasn't sad she left.
i love destiny child..but kelly? nope...
Perrie is awful on her own , but amazing in Little Mix
Kelly did make Little Mix from the beginning she kept saying how they should be in a girl group and then when they were deciding she wanted to put them together and they took a chance and now they are one of the biggest bands right now
therez norris kelly came from the best, that's why she always knows what's the best. Aye
therez norris But Kelly was not their mentor Tulisa was.
@@kevinlongman007 they only credit Kelly when talking about who really put them together though. Kelly did all the talking when it came to forming them when they were individuals on Xfactor auditions
@@CorCor89 I'm not sure why Tulisa was chosen to mentor the groups when Kelly was a member of a far bigger group than N Dubz ever were! Tulisa should have had the girls and Kelly the groups. But Little Mix would still have won anyway.