earth is one of the reasons why i love fourever you and he is doing what the script tells him to do. And how can you watch BL and think they are too gay?? Tf they shouldn't watch BL
It makes me laugh when people say he cries too much. It’s not his choice it’s up to the director and how the character is written, he is often chosen for these roles as not many young actors can cry with real tears and emotions.
How can a gay actor be too gay to act on a bl? We demanded change on how gay, bi, pan actors were treated in the bl industry, and some fans are taking us back to square one. Most of the time, we criticize actors for being homophobic and we intend to forget fans who are homophobic and femephobia
First of all BL actors kissing are already gay. Technically, it's gay. But they can call it however and we r fans willing to accept it, but then kissing same sex doesn't give them a reason to judge a real gay man. So petty! Can we just love and support our peers!?!?
Unfortunately the bl fan space is extremely homophobic. It's quiet scary. Alot of fans fetishise gay relationships in shows and ships but with openly attack any actor who is accused of or is openly gay
I watch Forever You because of him and I fall in love with other CP too 😆 All of his co-worker's chemistry in that series is really amazing. I don't understand why people hate him , may be they are jealous of his beauty 🫢 I hope Earth didn't listen to his haters and stay slay .
Im so glad in 2025 we are getting more and more feminine men in BL series cus thats how the real world is… not all gays are masculine and not all gays are feminine 🧚🏼♀️✨
I've seen mean comments about him in many fourever you shorts especially from Johan north fans. People are so mean and toxic especially with their so called suggestions. Suggestions and critic are good but not when it involves bullying
Every time I think that I want more BL actors to come out and openly represent the lgbt community, I see videos like these and truly understand why they stay in the closet. Cooheart is soo slay and such a bundle of joy idk how people can hate him. All he does is mind his own business. People need to leave him alone and how can someone be too gay to play a gay character… like what? These the type of fans that make you hate people 😭 cooheart 4 ever ❤
This entire video has made me sooo mad 😡 I think he’s a good actor. Why are they mad…they’ve aged and he still looks great either as a male or female. I’m soo sick and tired of small minded people.
Cooheart is amazing. He shouldn't be treated this way. He is so pretty and confident about who he is. I wish i was him sometimes, and i love watching him act. People need to stop hating
I really think we need more fem representation in BL. And to everyone who has ever thought that an actor (Cooheart or anyone else) is "too gay" , "too feminine", "too girly" etc to be in a BL - say hello to your deeply seeded homophobia. And the same holds true for any statement that goes "I like so&so but he's too ______" If you've watched his channel and his interviews etc - Cooheart is all business - I deeply admire his ability to stay true to who he is despite everything that's been thrown at him. Just because you watch BL doesn't mean you know, or understand the lives of actual LGBTQIA folk. And you certainly do not support them; which brings up the uncomfortable reality of gay fetishization.
honestly if you look at the famous BL pairs(except Domundi pairs) its mostly two straight looking guys,Fans just honestly hate any hint of feminity which is quite ironic considering the audience is mostly woman,they just wanna see two straight man kissing,they hate representation
What Domundi are doing are not good either. To me they're forcing even their manly artists to dress and act feminine. Also babyfying Nat. Not to mention the many problematic age gaps with the ships... Nunew style before Domundi is not feminine at all so is Namping style. And now they're starting to feminize JJ. Domundi obsession with feminizing their 'bottoms' and making the 'tops' manly butches is sht. The best factory regarding BL is idolfactory. BillyBabe , PoomSaint etc they never use the manly top/ feminine bottom cliche bs. Also what 'straight ' ?? It's actually more homophobic if you feminized gay characters like they're not men anymore just because they're gay?? This problem with Cooheart is another problem and problem with Domundi feminizing their artists is another. Both bad
@@miguelmandujano13 thats honestly what is marketable among the audience unfortunately,two hot men to fantasize about. If any actor comes out queer they start being mean or being weird about them
How they can hate a person just for these things 😭 We are not ugly, we just born in a judgmental society😢 How someone can hate such a pure soul he is a cutie ☺️
It's tiring how in this comment session they are still some throwing stones at him. If you don't like his acting then don't watch him, it's not compulsory to,if you don't have anything positive to say about someone then just shut up and walk away. He's not perfect,yeah, nobody is
The ironic part is that fem/openly queer bl actors get hate but the stem/butch gl actors like lux, ying, emi, etc get extremely praised or fans take it normally without making fuss. Is it because both y have different audiences?
Some series I only watch is because he's in them. Folks gonna hate but bet they can't do his job. He's unapologetically him. If you don't like him don't watch but leave your negative hateful jealous comments to yourself.
It kinda made me a little mad when they say Earth isn't a good actor. I think Earth is acting his role out quite perfectly. I mean, how can you blam the actor for acting out exactly how his script was written? That's just like blaming my microwave for making my food warmer than it was. Earth is feminine, beautiful no doubt. But basing on his appearance, his role can be quite limited. So I don't think he can be too picky with his character, yet he nailed all his characters that was given to him. And about Santa, even when in GMM, we all can see that Santa loves Ticktok dancing. He invited everyone! So when 2 tiktok dance-lover get together, I'm not surprised that they will do lots of what they both enjoy. Those internet trolls shouldn't be call "fans". They're just trash who has no life and is just jealous of other people's success. Cowards who lashed out of fear when they see courage standing above them.
Although I’ve personally never been that keen on Earth’s acting (among many others in this industry), mostly because of him playing too many similar roles and in dramas I didn’t like anyway, I admire that he stays true to himself even though he always seems to be getting the short end of the stick in every situation he’s in concerning the BL sphere. The way he’s being treated… it literally reeks of homophobia from left, right and center. Like how can a gay person be too gay to play a gay role?? Omg, make it make sense people, smh.
That's why I like Sammy , who supported Earth in his choices, same with Bourn Prem and Santa. They never mocked him. Same way I could never forget about Perth, Title,Mean being mean to him,, it's tough for me to accept someone who targeted a person for being feminin . He was oldest on love by chance set ,Thai culture respect elders but here 17 and 18 year olds were laughing at his cries. I don't get how cooheart forgave them all
He’s an easy target! I applaud him for being himself. I don’t care for his acting because it’s too juvenile. It’s the same type of character that doesn’t show any range. He needs to stop crying as it’s a huge turnoff. The studio needs to give him a decent part that’s older and more mature. I would like to see him pull it off. Maybe not pair him with anyone. I like Pond but I felt like they don’t go together. Pond is so much more mature and Earth can’t keep up. My opinion.
Most BL fans if not all are kpop stans and they found a paradise in this industry where they get to fantasize about these men. Most of them are raging homophobic people. Then on the other side there are also queer people who hate on femme men. It's sickening how the growth of BL as a genre could mean something for the community, yet we're seeing on a daily basis how most of the consumers are against the community in the first place and most actors that are openly queer are treated like garbage both by viewers and the people behind the scenes. I want to add, if Gun wasn't popular and under gmmtv (and if he expressed himself like how he does now, from the begging) I fear he would suffer the exact same type of scrutiny cooheart faces. I see many people pretending to love some femme actors with the whole "slay queen" performative support, but when it's time to show up for them it's crickets. It's sad really. And I pray coohert prospers. I pray he hits big one day.
Yeah I have seen a clip long bach where this actor was bullied by actors who played Ae, Tin, Gun, kla, Technic and many n he said something painful and this actor was in verge of crying
Earth is a beautiful soul he is who he is and I respect him for it - I believe he is a great actor and gives everything to his role, he does not get the recognition he deserves. As for him being bullied of course he is it’s so obvious that it breaks my heart - I’ve watched other actors treat him appallingly and get away with it but he always seems to never fights back and try’s to keep his dignity. I wish him the best and hope he keeps brave and dignified as always in the face of diversity Be brave baby boy Love from Australia ❤️❤️
I don't think anyone have the right to neglect anybody I am Nigeria girl and I think you guys who come out to neglect people should look at yourself what you're going to give birth to before you start body shaming other people child sex life is a choice!
Some people do not need a reason, to be mean or nasty. They just do it. Kudos to Earth for not losing his cheerful nature. At least he is being honest about himself and not trying to fool people. His co-actors and production house need to show him the same respect that they give to others and not look down on him for his choices... P.S. So far he is the reason I watched Forever You, and then watched some of his other series...
The bullying he experience during Love By Chance makes me not like Perth Mean Plan and other pf his co star... I still don't like them as a person and as an actor .
Many people defend them and tell earth is friendly behave with them so why we make fuse about past.but still i don't forget that incident😔i hope one day that people get thier karama back
I don’t understand why people are so so mean. If it is his character remind you again character and suppose to cry why are you criticizing him. Why don’t you yell at the director and producers and the person who got this story wow
How can they say he is too gay he was just doing his job. I love him so much from the start n in fourever u. He did a great job. Hey Earth if u r watching this video n this commet. Don't be discourage keep doing what u love know that You r an talented n pretty one. We love You ❤❤❤❤❤
This very sad. I love fem men. They look beautiful and are brave & true to themselves. I think the production company should take more responsibility to cast younger actors in roles that have less intimacy until they become of age and the fans should become less homophobic & support the lgbt community more.
Earth is a very talented actor. The fact that he takes on roles of characters younger in age than he is shows his versatility. I am an avid admirer and supporter ❤
Well I am not a fan but have to accept that he is beautiful. I generally don't like his acting in all of the series.. Fourever you also did the same for me. His work choosing isn't good. He should opt for other dynamic roles ...other than that I have no concern for any of his personal matters or styling
I enjoy watching series with Cooheart in them and only decided to watch Fourever You because of him. Does he confuse my lesbian brain when I see him dressing very feminine yeah but so does every pretty guy. His courage to be true to himself is so impressive.
I love Cooheart so so so much but the only thing I will say is the Santa thing from 2021 where Santa was a minor…. I know they were both encouraged to spark buzz for their couple but still kinda weird. It’s probably not his fault tho let’s be honest but I would’ve said no
But the age of concent in thailand is 17 so santa was already considered an adult at that time. The decision was in Santa's own hands so who dare to opposed him when he got the talent to actually play the roll and do what he can to get famous in the industry? By law he had the right decide
@@doyouknowwatermelon8892 Santa’s age made some of the fan service uncomfortable. As a mother of a son of the same age, i would have had a problem with my underage child participating in fan service at all, but with a man (referring to age, not gender) even more concerning. Of course, we are not privy to the agreements/conversations behind this, so inappropriate to me based on my limited knowledge.
@@shenadarling50 i know nothing about Max and Nat, but if same situation, i’d find inappropriate. I don’t have a problem with Earth being feminine. This doesn’t factor in for me. Santa being 17 doing fan service with an adult the issue, though i admit to enjoy their dance videos.
@shenadarling50 Max was getting hate and ☠️ threats on twitter everyday. Some people still can't stand them till today. Also, Max had strong boundaries when it came to Nat and was more of a big brother to Nat. But I get where you're coming from.
He is the reason I got into Thai BL. His authenticity and fluidity in style and life. HE and others like him are the REASON for equality. If you "can't stand" or "loath" Cooheart and other actors like him then WTF are you doing being into BL. If you are straight and ONLY want exstream masculine characters then that's kink and NOT advocacy. I LOVE his new pairing. They have so much chemistry and good vibe. Look, there are SO many BLs out there that you can absolutely skip his shows if you want. DO NOT trash talk and bitch about something you had every opportunity to skip. If I don't like and actor or the plot doesn't interest me I DON'T WATCH. And I certainly don't go around hating on a cast member.
I have a legitimate question. I'm going to preface the question by stating it's not to attack or offend any bl actors or bl fans, I am just genuinely curious. According to the video the "effeminate" bl actors who like to dress in a feminine way or act in a feminine way get hate for it. On one side, the perceived haters are claiming the actors are not manly enough and the other side thinks those peoples way of thinking is homophobic. So my hypothetical question is, how "feminine" is too feminine? Like, if one of the bl actors wanted to transition would they still get the hype and support they are getting for being themselves? It's easy to say yes, because they would still be part of lgbtq, but their place in the community doesn't change just the gender they prefer to be. So by that logic, they are no longer actors of same sex dramas. How would that be navigated? I've seen how "fans" get when bl actors get near a female or had "dating scandal" (I hate that phrase, they're dating, that's not scandalous. It's normal.) And I've seen how far fans support really goes until their faves do something they don't like, like having a different bl partner. I'm just really curious of how others perceive this notion. Manly or feminine is obviously a touchy topic but no one mentions the actors who are actually transgender in the industry. Which brings the next issue- is that because of looks? Pretty/cute privilege. Does any of it matter at all as long as the person is found to be pleasing to look at by the masses?
How can a femme man be too femme? I'm femme, I've been femme since I was a very small child, it's my nature, it wasn't something I learned to be, I wasn't groomed to be femme by others. Being trans isn't the same as being femme and though some femme men will transition most won't, they are still men. You raise some very good questions in your post, particularly by pointing out that one's sex isn't the same as one's gender.
I get that some of earth's characters or roles are not pleasing and all but fans are just going tooo faarr... Like way way too far. Why do y'all watch bl series if y'all not going to respect queer actors? The double standard in the bl industry is literally on the next level.
Everybody has to put his own house in order first,and before you judge any Person,you have to walk in their shoes first ,to understand what kind of hard work it is to be an actor or musician and how many hardships they have to endure !!! - All these haters should be ashamed of a hole in the earth !
I honestly think that most the jobs earth is given is because of his femininity Due to bl kinda harsh but True “hate for hyperfeminine/ feminine in general gays. They are not gonna make a show that revolves around a feminine character so instead they fit him in where they best can and the next best thing to them is babyish. I feel like they try to mask the femininity with innocence to make him more marketable to bl fans. Although many fans like manly and masculine gays that would seem straight in real life there is one exception. The innocent sensitive uke which is likes by a large sum of the yaoi/bl fanbase. The biggest issue though is that this characteristic is more based off look, with a soft personality but more from a place of unintentional softness and not exactly feminine personality. That is why it doesn’t really work for earth because he is feminine through and through. From his mannerisms to the way he talks even the way he appears to people. So to be real as much as it sucks I don’t think he will ever get to reach his highest potential unless there is a push of feminine characters in bls.
Netziens are a nightmare and they shouldn't really be taken seriously - i feel a bit sorry for Earth, but i love that he lives his life honestly, to hell with the haters!
Cooheart is a great actor. Bashers can bash. This is why I watch BL because of them giving a feminine guy a lead role. This is what makes BL more realistic. ❤
You know what screw them who cares I love cooheart he is the great actor are people that jelous of earth he is so pretty and he embrace his sexuality The only reason why i started watching fourever you was because of earth This breaks my heart to hear this i will always love earth
I love Earth. Seen three series with him and his chemistry with his costar is so good every single time. He always make me cry when he do emotional scenes. I love him now in Fourever you. He and Pond was so amazing together❤️🔥
BL fandoms that get toxic just baffle me. They want to see their ships showing lots of affection in public, and are terribly upset when popular pairs decide to work with different partners. Yet, when an actor is in an actual romantic relationship with his costar, people are upset that they are queer irl. They want the fantasy of their idols being in a ship, but the reality of queer actors is denied or worse, ridiculed. Seems the fandoms want their ships together forever, but not actually together outside the parameters of fan service.
Watching BL, GL series.. Shipping the actors.. And criticising an actor who is openly gay.. Guys this is bullshit, extreme duality.. I watch both BL and GL and supporting each and every kind of love.. Coolheart is fantastic actor.. He should be known for that.. Not for his orientation..
Please stop including perth no more he didn't contribute in that bullying. Perth and cooheart have been friends since they follow each other on insta and have real life interaction in 2024😢
Wish i could remember which BL introduced me to Earth, but I decided then and there, he was the most adorable guy. I like Forever you and actually find as a main character, he really wasn't in it enough. Also, it felt like the director focused the character arc on North and Johan, which is great, but where did hill and Ter get off to? Would I like to see Earth in a more mature role, yes, but that doesn't stop me from watching his stuff and following him on IG and Threads. Give him a break ya'll, he doesn't write or direct his shows, put the criticism on the ones who actually tell the actors what to do. Cooheart, is always one of my favorate bL actors.
If anything I wish that writers would realise that when you go off to Uni unless you have lived in a small village you are worldly , you don’t act like you’re 10 and acting so shocked at flirting give me a break guys, most of us go to Uni to have relationships, drink and get away from overbearing parents…oh and ofc to learn lol
@shenadarling50 I don't hate him but sure he act almost similar in all the bls I have watched of him till now ( crying mostly). As an actor i think he should discover different characters rather than stick to one.
A great majority of BL fans are cis gender teen girls or girls in their twenties who like watching straight actors with Mr Universe bodies with pretty faces. BL actors who don't meet their standards will get hate from them. Saint Suppapong and Cooheart and Bas Hasanat Piniwat are my favorite BL actors.
I have always liked Earth especially since LBC and UWMA. I recall seeing that clip of LBC cast bullying him and no way was that OK. He had to ask for help from the host, that’s how bad it was. OFC he had to shrug it off, I mean how else is he going to be able to continue in the industry? It is laughable that those who watch BL demand that the actors have to fit a certain type, expect CP and when we actually have a proud and open entertainer from the LGBQT+ committee it’s too much. What is worse is that we have many in the BL industry who are homophobic. I will call it as it is, portraying roles aka getting paid, fame and endorsements and being so disrespectful to actual LGBQT+ community. That is so wrong on so many levels. I am of the believe that you do not have to be straight, gay whatever to portray a role relative to sexual orientation. BUT you have to respect the role and what it represents.
If you want manly BL’s go watch them. Let Cooheart alone. He’s beautiful! He’s authentic. Stop being hateful. Just don’t watch him if you don’t like him. Keep your mouth shut! If those other actors really bullied him you should be ashamed of yourself.
Personally I find the cutesy stuff in Fourever you a bit cringe, Earth seems to be over compensating. But thats not just him, i find the actor who plays North is also a bit much in the overly cute scenes as well - but the acting in other parts of the drama is fine or good. TBH, the script and direction of the show is a bit lacking, but it still has some charm.
But PP is highly praised and is the top of the top, it also depends on connection and how your agency present you to the media, if coming from high profile agency, they are very picky in role and queer persona, and balance it out to the public
PP is highly praised because he's not in a ship with a tall hot masculine hunk of a man. BL fans hate when that happens because it destroys their fantasy of two masculine men being in a relationship together. But in their minds, they could still "turn" those actors. That's why so many of them insist that everyone in BL is gay for pay only. They WISH for it to be the case. But it isn't. Statistically it's impossible for everyone in BL to be straight. And no, feminine and gay isn't the same thing. Feminine guys can be attracted to women and masculine guys can be attracted to men. But many BL fans feel threatened by beautiful feminine looking or acting men. Especially if they can pull a hot guy. Oftentimes, I read comments like "why is he prettier than me", "why is his twerking better than mine", "why does he have a small waist and curvy butt and I don't". And these are the "nice" people saying that. The mean people and trolls and haters will just start to bully them and make up fake stories about them or their partners. To sum it up, the BL fan community is full of bigots, homophobes and sexists. Many are watching it the same way straight men are watching lesbian porn. They want the fantasy but not the reality. And since PP is marketed as a solo artist, they perceive him as a harmless bestie they hang out with and not as competition.
So all the post about gay marriage on the gmmtv or mindytv network was a fluke. They really dnt support?!?! Leave him alone. I hope he stands up for himself and dont let those affect him. He has a good heart, just alittle extra that people cant handle.
So people are saying he is too gay to act on a gay series. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 I laughed so much that my tummy hurts... these people have gone nuts... bonkers No wonder internet asks us if we are human sometimes.... may be the bots think this individual is too human to be human 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lets be completely honest, theres one reason and one reason only that Cooheart gets attached so much and it is nothing to do with his acting. Unfortunately both the BL industry and fans are extremely homophobic. The simple fact that Top/Bottom is always a conversation regarding new actors or ships shows how homophobic fans are. Theyre literally fetishising queer relationships and as soon as theyre called out they play the victim
The irony is staggering. It's disheartening to see people bullying the actor in the comments while the video itself is discussing the very same issue. It's a clear example of tone-deafness and a lack of self-awareness. The BL community, like any other, should strive to be inclusive, respectful, and welcoming. Unfortunately, homophobia seems to be a norm here too.
1.STOP USING UNDERAGE ACTORS!. 2. cooheart should take himself outside of similar character roles. It honestly looks like he plays the same role. It will stifle his career growth. This is a legitimate criticism. And someone should tell that to him/his team. Maybe he should even try a character in a none bl series. Or a movie. He needs range!
earth is one of the reasons why i love fourever you and he is doing what the script tells him to do. And how can you watch BL and think they are too gay?? Tf they shouldn't watch BL
Like I'm surprised
It makes me laugh when people say he cries too much. It’s not his choice it’s up to the director and how the character is written, he is often chosen for these roles as not many young actors can cry with real tears and emotions.
Totally agree
How can a gay actor be too gay to act on a bl? We demanded change on how gay, bi, pan actors were treated in the bl industry, and some fans are taking us back to square one. Most of the time, we criticize actors for being homophobic and we intend to forget fans who are homophobic and femephobia
First of all BL actors kissing are already gay. Technically, it's gay. But they can call it however and we r fans willing to accept it, but then kissing same sex doesn't give them a reason to judge a real gay man. So petty! Can we just love and support our peers!?!?
Unfortunately the bl fan space is extremely homophobic. It's quiet scary. Alot of fans fetishise gay relationships in shows and ships but with openly attack any actor who is accused of or is openly gay
I watch Forever You because of him and I fall in love with other CP too 😆 All of his co-worker's chemistry in that series is really amazing. I don't understand why people hate him , may be they are jealous of his beauty 🫢
I hope Earth didn't listen to his haters and stay slay .
Why everyone hate him 😢🤧😫 he is such a cutie 💓 🫠😌😮💨✨️
Im so glad in 2025 we are getting more and more feminine men in BL series cus thats how the real world is… not all gays are masculine and not all gays are feminine 🧚🏼♀️✨
They ALL need to leave Cooheart alone.
Agreed.
For me he is excellent and he he is his true self and for this you must be strong....what he is, in my opinion.
!!
Earth please ignore the bullies. There is too much hate in this world
I still haven’t forgot about how he was bullied on LIVE by Perth, Mean, and other actors 😢
Me too😢now i see earth is still friend with them but evey time i see them i remember that bully video😢i hope one day they all get thier karama back
😢😢😢😢😢
What when did this happen?
Wait you mean Perth who's paired with Santa now? That Perth? 😯
Ooh sorry for him yet all are under the same industry BL 😂😂😂
I will keep supporting him! He’s so cute too. I hated the bullying that happened during Love By Chance!
I honestly watch Fourever You for CooHeart and Pond personally.
I've seen mean comments about him in many fourever you shorts especially from Johan north fans. People are so mean and toxic especially with their so called suggestions. Suggestions and critic are good but not when it involves bullying
Every time I think that I want more BL actors to come out and openly represent the lgbt community, I see videos like these and truly understand why they stay in the closet. Cooheart is soo slay and such a bundle of joy idk how people can hate him. All he does is mind his own business. People need to leave him alone and how can someone be too gay to play a gay character… like what? These the type of fans that make you hate people 😭 cooheart 4 ever ❤
He's too gay to act in a BL series is wild💀
That's annoying!
This entire video has made me sooo mad 😡
I think he’s a good actor. Why are they mad…they’ve aged and he still looks great either as a male or female.
I’m soo sick and tired of small minded people.
He is beautiful inside and out I for 100% support him
Cooheart is amazing. He shouldn't be treated this way. He is so pretty and confident about who he is. I wish i was him sometimes, and i love watching him act. People need to stop hating
I really think we need more fem representation in BL.
And to everyone who has ever thought that an actor (Cooheart or anyone else) is "too gay" , "too feminine", "too girly" etc to be in a BL - say hello to your deeply seeded homophobia. And the same holds true for any statement that goes "I like so&so but he's too ______"
If you've watched his channel and his interviews etc - Cooheart is all business - I deeply admire his ability to stay true to who he is despite everything that's been thrown at him.
Just because you watch BL doesn't mean you know, or understand the lives of actual LGBTQIA folk. And you certainly do not support them; which brings up the uncomfortable reality of gay fetishization.
honestly if you look at the famous BL pairs(except Domundi pairs) its mostly two straight looking guys,Fans just honestly hate any hint of feminity which is quite ironic considering the audience is mostly woman,they just wanna see two straight man kissing,they hate representation
I say gmmtv, to be honest. Most pairs are two straight guys
What Domundi are doing are not good either. To me they're forcing even their manly artists to dress and act feminine. Also babyfying Nat. Not to mention the many problematic age gaps with the ships... Nunew style before Domundi is not feminine at all so is Namping style. And now they're starting to feminize JJ. Domundi obsession with feminizing their 'bottoms' and making the 'tops' manly butches is sht. The best factory regarding BL is idolfactory. BillyBabe , PoomSaint etc they never use the manly top/ feminine bottom cliche bs. Also what 'straight ' ?? It's actually more homophobic if you feminized gay characters like they're not men anymore just because they're gay?? This problem with Cooheart is another problem and problem with Domundi feminizing their artists is another. Both bad
@@miguelmandujano13 thats honestly what is marketable among the audience unfortunately,two hot men to fantasize about. If any actor comes out queer they start being mean or being weird about them
How they can hate a person just for these things 😭
We are not ugly, we just born in a judgmental society😢
How someone can hate such a pure soul he is a cutie ☺️
Always love my angel, cooheart❤❤
He is just a normal person trying to make a living and his life is better than those who are talking nonsense.
It's tiring how in this comment session they are still some throwing stones at him.
If you don't like his acting then don't watch him, it's not compulsory to,if you don't have anything positive to say about someone then just shut up and walk away.
He's not perfect,yeah, nobody is
The ironic part is that fem/openly queer bl actors get hate but the stem/butch gl actors like lux, ying, emi, etc get extremely praised or fans take it normally without making fuss.
Is it because both y have different audiences?
Some series I only watch is because he's in them. Folks gonna hate but bet they can't do his job. He's unapologetically him. If you don't like him don't watch but leave your negative hateful jealous comments to yourself.
It kinda made me a little mad when they say Earth isn't a good actor. I think Earth is acting his role out quite perfectly. I mean, how can you blam the actor for acting out exactly how his script was written? That's just like blaming my microwave for making my food warmer than it was. Earth is feminine, beautiful no doubt. But basing on his appearance, his role can be quite limited. So I don't think he can be too picky with his character, yet he nailed all his characters that was given to him. And about Santa, even when in GMM, we all can see that Santa loves Ticktok dancing. He invited everyone! So when 2 tiktok dance-lover get together, I'm not surprised that they will do lots of what they both enjoy.
Those internet trolls shouldn't be call "fans". They're just trash who has no life and is just jealous of other people's success. Cowards who lashed out of fear when they see courage standing above them.
Although I’ve personally never been that keen on Earth’s acting (among many others in this industry), mostly because of him playing too many similar roles and in dramas I didn’t like anyway, I admire that he stays true to himself even though he always seems to be getting the short end of the stick in every situation he’s in concerning the BL sphere. The way he’s being treated… it literally reeks of homophobia from left, right and center. Like how can a gay person be too gay to play a gay role?? Omg, make it make sense people, smh.
That's why I like Sammy , who supported Earth in his choices, same with Bourn Prem and Santa. They never mocked him. Same way I could never forget about Perth, Title,Mean being mean to him,, it's tough for me to accept someone who targeted a person for being feminin . He was oldest on love by chance set ,Thai culture respect elders but here 17 and 18 year olds were laughing at his cries. I don't get how cooheart forgave them all
He’s an easy target! I applaud him for being himself. I don’t care for his acting because it’s too juvenile. It’s the same type of character that doesn’t show any range. He needs to stop crying as it’s a huge turnoff. The studio needs to give him a decent part that’s older and more mature. I would like to see him pull it off. Maybe not pair him with anyone. I like Pond but I felt like they don’t go together. Pond is so much more mature and Earth can’t keep up. My opinion.
Exactly he needs to choose some better powerful stories and character
Most BL fans if not all are kpop stans and they found a paradise in this industry where they get to fantasize about these men. Most of them are raging homophobic people. Then on the other side there are also queer people who hate on femme men. It's sickening how the growth of BL as a genre could mean something for the community, yet we're seeing on a daily basis how most of the consumers are against the community in the first place and most actors that are openly queer are treated like garbage both by viewers and the people behind the scenes.
I want to add, if Gun wasn't popular and under gmmtv (and if he expressed himself like how he does now, from the begging) I fear he would suffer the exact same type of scrutiny cooheart faces. I see many people pretending to love some femme actors with the whole "slay queen" performative support, but when it's time to show up for them it's crickets.
It's sad really. And I pray coohert prospers. I pray he hits big one day.
also those toxic fujoshi who watch bl only for nc scene and hate on the actor if their partner change
Yeah I have seen a clip long bach where this actor was bullied by actors who played Ae, Tin, Gun, kla, Technic and many n he said something painful and this actor was in verge of crying
I love cool heart 💖💖
Earth is a beautiful soul he is who he is and I respect him for it - I believe he is a great actor and gives everything to his role, he does not get the recognition he deserves.
As for him being bullied of course he is it’s so obvious that it breaks my heart - I’ve watched other actors treat him appallingly and get away with it but he always seems to never fights back and try’s to keep his dignity.
I wish him the best and hope he keeps brave and dignified as always in the face of diversity
Be brave baby boy
Love from Australia ❤️❤️
I love how confident he is ❤ he is diva and who deserves whole world love
I have never seen him getting bullied by fans, i always seen people are appreciating him on the comment... 😢
why would someone bully him like its not even good. And he is also one of my favorite actors. I love Coohearth
I don't think anyone have the right to neglect anybody I am Nigeria girl and I think you guys who come out to neglect people should look at yourself what you're going to give birth to before you start body shaming other people child sex life is a choice!
“He’s too gay to act in a BL series”
Sorry… WHAT
Какая глупость, снимают гейство,и тут же гея ругают. Позор тем кто двуличие проявляет
Earth ❤❤❤❤❤
Some people do not need a reason, to be mean or nasty. They just do it. Kudos to Earth for not losing his cheerful nature. At least he is being honest about himself and not trying to fool people. His co-actors and production house need to show him the same respect that they give to others and not look down on him for his choices... P.S. So far he is the reason I watched Forever You, and then watched some of his other series...
The bullying he experience during Love By Chance makes me not like Perth Mean Plan and other pf his co star... I still don't like them as a person and as an actor
.
Many people defend them and tell earth is friendly behave with them so why we make fuse about past.but still i don't forget that incident😔i hope one day that people get thier karama back
@@AnanyaJose1742what happened
I love earth and always will😊
Cooearth you are one of my favorites dear, you are who you are, i love you ❤
I don’t understand why people are so so mean. If it is his character remind you again character and suppose to cry why are you criticizing him. Why don’t you yell at the director and producers and the person who got this story wow
How can they say he is too gay he was just doing his job. I love him so much from the start n in fourever u. He did a great job. Hey Earth if u r watching this video n this commet. Don't be discourage keep doing what u love know that You r an talented n pretty one. We love You ❤❤❤❤❤
This very sad. I love fem men. They look beautiful and are brave & true to themselves. I think the production company should take more responsibility to cast younger actors in roles that have less intimacy until they become of age and the fans should become less homophobic & support the lgbt community more.
Can anyone tell me who were the two actors pulling cooheart legs in that live ?
Wanna make sure if it was Perth
People are actually blind after watching straight guys playing gay characters...he plays the real thing!
He is too gay to be in a bl. Really? But it is true that he basically plays the same roles
If they don't like Earth they shouldn't watch his drama but criticizing him for being himself is wrong.
Earth is a very talented actor. The fact that he takes on roles of characters younger in age than he is shows his versatility. I am an avid admirer and supporter ❤
Well I am not a fan but have to accept that he is beautiful.
I generally don't like his acting in all of the series..
Fourever you also did the same for me.
His work choosing isn't good.
He should opt for other dynamic roles ...other than that I have no concern for any of his personal matters or styling
I enjoy watching series with Cooheart in them and only decided to watch Fourever You because of him. Does he confuse my lesbian brain when I see him dressing very feminine yeah but so does every pretty guy. His courage to be true to himself is so impressive.
I love Cooheart so so so much but the only thing I will say is the Santa thing from 2021 where Santa was a minor…. I know they were both encouraged to spark buzz for their couple but still kinda weird. It’s probably not his fault tho let’s be honest but I would’ve said no
But the age of concent in thailand is 17 so santa was already considered an adult at that time. The decision was in Santa's own hands so who dare to opposed him when he got the talent to actually play the roll and do what he can to get famous in the industry? By law he had the right decide
@@doyouknowwatermelon8892 Santa’s age made some of the fan service uncomfortable. As a mother of a son of the same age, i would have had a problem with my underage child participating in fan service at all, but with a man (referring to age, not gender) even more concerning. Of course, we are not privy to the agreements/conversations behind this, so inappropriate to me based on my limited knowledge.
So what's your opinion on Max and Nat. They were in a similar situation but nobody talks about double standards man double standards
@@shenadarling50 i know nothing about Max and Nat, but if same situation, i’d find inappropriate. I don’t have a problem with Earth being feminine. This doesn’t factor in for me. Santa being 17 doing fan service with an adult the issue, though i admit to enjoy their dance videos.
@shenadarling50 Max was getting hate and ☠️ threats on twitter everyday. Some people still can't stand them till today. Also, Max had strong boundaries when it came to Nat and was more of a big brother to Nat. But I get where you're coming from.
He is the reason I got into Thai BL. His authenticity and fluidity in style and life. HE and others like him are the REASON for equality. If you "can't stand" or "loath" Cooheart and other actors like him then WTF are you doing being into BL. If you are straight and ONLY want exstream masculine characters then that's kink and NOT advocacy.
I LOVE his new pairing. They have so much chemistry and good vibe.
Look, there are SO many BLs out there that you can absolutely skip his shows if you want. DO NOT trash talk and bitch about something you had every opportunity to skip. If I don't like and actor or the plot doesn't interest me I DON'T WATCH. And I certainly don't go around hating on a cast member.
I've watched everything he's been in because of him, I love him, his personality and everything, how could anyone hate my pookie bear
I have a legitimate question. I'm going to preface the question by stating it's not to attack or offend any bl actors or bl fans, I am just genuinely curious. According to the video the "effeminate" bl actors who like to dress in a feminine way or act in a feminine way get hate for it. On one side, the perceived haters are claiming the actors are not manly enough and the other side thinks those peoples way of thinking is homophobic. So my hypothetical question is, how "feminine" is too feminine? Like, if one of the bl actors wanted to transition would they still get the hype and support they are getting for being themselves? It's easy to say yes, because they would still be part of lgbtq, but their place in the community doesn't change just the gender they prefer to be. So by that logic, they are no longer actors of same sex dramas. How would that be navigated? I've seen how "fans" get when bl actors get near a female or had "dating scandal" (I hate that phrase, they're dating, that's not scandalous. It's normal.) And I've seen how far fans support really goes until their faves do something they don't like, like having a different bl partner. I'm just really curious of how others perceive this notion. Manly or feminine is obviously a touchy topic but no one mentions the actors who are actually transgender in the industry. Which brings the next issue- is that because of looks? Pretty/cute privilege. Does any of it matter at all as long as the person is found to be pleasing to look at by the masses?
How can a femme man be too femme? I'm femme, I've been femme since I was a very small child, it's my nature, it wasn't something I learned to be, I wasn't groomed to be femme by others. Being trans isn't the same as being femme and though some femme men will transition most won't, they are still men. You raise some very good questions in your post, particularly by pointing out that one's sex isn't the same as one's gender.
I love you Cooheart. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤.
I love him the way he is is cute
He is an amazing actor🤍🤍🤍
I get that some of earth's characters or roles are not pleasing and all but fans are just going tooo faarr... Like way way too far.
Why do y'all watch bl series if y'all not going to respect queer actors?
The double standard in the bl industry is literally on the next level.
Everybody has to put his own house in order first,and before you judge any Person,you have to walk in their shoes first ,to understand what kind of hard work it is to be an actor or musician and how many hardships they have to endure !!! - All these haters should be ashamed of a hole in the earth !
He gets bullied because he is awesome, beautiful, talented, and a queen who slays....basically everything they are not and want to be😂😂❤❤❤
I LOVE Cooheart he is amazing ❤
I honestly think that most the jobs earth is given is because of his femininity Due to bl kinda harsh but True “hate for hyperfeminine/ feminine in general gays. They are not gonna make a show that revolves around a feminine character so instead they fit him in where they best can and the next best thing to them is babyish. I feel like they try to mask the femininity with innocence to make him more marketable to bl fans. Although many fans like manly and masculine gays that would seem straight in real life there is one exception. The innocent sensitive uke which is likes by a large sum of the yaoi/bl fanbase. The biggest issue though is that this characteristic is more based off look, with a soft personality but more from a place of unintentional softness and not exactly feminine personality. That is why it doesn’t really work for earth because he is feminine through and through. From his mannerisms to the way he talks even the way he appears to people. So to be real as much as it sucks I don’t think he will ever get to reach his highest potential unless there is a push of feminine characters in bls.
I love you earth❤❤
Ridiculous, when will this stop. Where was
The director and other adults involved with the drama series should
intervene.
Netziens are a nightmare and they shouldn't really be taken seriously - i feel a bit sorry for Earth, but i love that he lives his life honestly, to hell with the haters!
Cooheart is so cute❤❤❤
And for those haters always think about how many people you have destroyed their lives online with your tongue
I don't think anyone has the right to neglect they follow human
Cooheart is a great actor. Bashers can bash. This is why I watch BL because of them giving a feminine guy a lead role. This is what makes BL more realistic. ❤
You know what screw them who cares
I love cooheart he is the great actor are people that jelous of earth he is so pretty and he embrace his sexuality
The only reason why i started watching fourever you was because of earth
This breaks my heart to hear this i will always love earth
#TEAMCOOHEART WHO'S WITH ME ON THAT?
Cooheart ❤❤❤❤❤
He need s steady partner to protect him ijs❤❤❤
I love Earth. Seen three series with him and his chemistry with his costar is so good every single time. He always make me cry when he do emotional scenes. I love him now in Fourever you. He and Pond was so amazing together❤️🔥
BL fandoms that get toxic just baffle me. They want to see their ships showing lots of affection in public, and are terribly upset when popular pairs decide to work with different partners. Yet, when an actor is in an actual romantic relationship with his costar, people are upset that they are queer irl. They want the fantasy of their idols being in a ship, but the reality of queer actors is denied or worse, ridiculed. Seems the fandoms want their ships together forever, but not actually together outside the parameters of fan service.
Too many fans want ships they can control, puppet boys not actual people.
Watching BL, GL series.. Shipping the actors.. And criticising an actor who is openly gay.. Guys this is bullshit, extreme duality.. I watch both BL and GL and supporting each and every kind of love.. Coolheart is fantastic actor.. He should be known for that.. Not for his orientation..
Please stop including perth no more he didn't contribute in that bullying. Perth and cooheart have been friends since they follow each other on insta and have real life interaction in 2024😢
Wish i could remember which BL introduced me to Earth, but I decided then and there, he was the most adorable guy. I like Forever you and actually find as a main character, he really wasn't in it enough. Also, it felt like the director focused the character arc on North and Johan, which is great, but where did hill and Ter get off to? Would I like to see Earth in a more mature role, yes, but that doesn't stop me from watching his stuff and following him on IG and Threads. Give him a break ya'll, he doesn't write or direct his shows, put the criticism on the ones who actually tell the actors what to do. Cooheart, is always one of my favorate bL actors.
Don't hate her she good
If anything I wish that writers would realise that when you go off to Uni unless you have lived in a small village you are worldly , you don’t act like you’re 10 and acting so shocked at flirting give me a break guys, most of us go to Uni to have relationships, drink and get away from overbearing parents…oh and ofc to learn lol
I love you so much coolheart❤❤😊
I agree with what they are saying but not with the way they are saying .
What do you agree with exactly lol. Just say u hate the dude and go😅
@shenadarling50 I don't hate him but sure he act almost similar in all the bls I have watched of him till now ( crying mostly). As an actor i think he should discover different characters rather than stick to one.
A great majority of BL fans are cis gender teen girls or girls in their twenties who like watching straight actors with Mr Universe bodies with pretty faces. BL actors who don't meet their standards will get hate from them. Saint Suppapong and Cooheart and Bas Hasanat Piniwat are my favorite BL actors.
I have always liked Earth especially since LBC and UWMA. I recall seeing that clip of LBC cast bullying him and no way was that OK. He had to ask for help from the host, that’s how bad it was. OFC he had to shrug it off, I mean how else is he going to be able to continue in the industry? It is laughable that those who watch BL demand that the actors have to fit a certain type, expect CP and when we actually have a proud and open entertainer from the LGBQT+ committee it’s too much. What is worse is that we have many in the BL industry who are homophobic. I will call it as it is, portraying roles aka getting paid, fame and endorsements and being so disrespectful to actual LGBQT+ community. That is so wrong on so many levels. I am of the believe that you do not have to be straight, gay whatever to portray a role relative to sexual orientation. BUT you have to respect the role and what it represents.
It is because of them being bullied that why some leave bl industry
If you want manly BL’s go watch them. Let Cooheart alone. He’s beautiful! He’s authentic. Stop being hateful. Just don’t watch him if you don’t like him. Keep your mouth shut! If those other actors really bullied him you should be ashamed of yourself.
Personally I find the cutesy stuff in Fourever you a bit cringe, Earth seems to be over compensating. But thats not just him, i find the actor who plays North is also a bit much in the overly cute scenes as well - but the acting in other parts of the drama is fine or good. TBH, the script and direction of the show is a bit lacking, but it still has some charm.
But PP is highly praised and is the top of the top, it also depends on connection and how your agency present you to the media, if coming from high profile agency, they are very picky in role and queer persona, and balance it out to the public
PP is highly praised because he's not in a ship with a tall hot masculine hunk of a man. BL fans hate when that happens because it destroys their fantasy of two masculine men being in a relationship together. But in their minds, they could still "turn" those actors.
That's why so many of them insist that everyone in BL is gay for pay only. They WISH for it to be the case. But it isn't. Statistically it's impossible for everyone in BL to be straight. And no, feminine and gay isn't the same thing. Feminine guys can be attracted to women and masculine guys can be attracted to men.
But many BL fans feel threatened by beautiful feminine looking or acting men. Especially if they can pull a hot guy. Oftentimes, I read comments like "why is he prettier than me", "why is his twerking better than mine", "why does he have a small waist and curvy butt and I don't". And these are the "nice" people saying that. The mean people and trolls and haters will just start to bully them and make up fake stories about them or their partners.
To sum it up, the BL fan community is full of bigots, homophobes and sexists. Many are watching it the same way straight men are watching lesbian porn. They want the fantasy but not the reality.
And since PP is marketed as a solo artist, they perceive him as a harmless bestie they hang out with and not as competition.
So all the post about gay marriage on the gmmtv or mindytv network was a fluke. They really dnt support?!?! Leave him alone. I hope he stands up for himself and dont let those affect him. He has a good heart, just alittle extra that people cant handle.
Every problem, they blaming Cooheart
So people are saying he is too gay to act on a gay series. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I laughed so much that my tummy hurts... these people have gone nuts... bonkers
No wonder internet asks us if we are human sometimes.... may be the bots think this individual is too human to be human 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Best part of Fourever You was the scenes with Ter and North they were great together…haters piss off!
Wow.. 😮😮
Lets be completely honest, theres one reason and one reason only that Cooheart gets attached so much and it is nothing to do with his acting. Unfortunately both the BL industry and fans are extremely homophobic. The simple fact that Top/Bottom is always a conversation regarding new actors or ships shows how homophobic fans are. Theyre literally fetishising queer relationships and as soon as theyre called out they play the victim
I'm one of his fans.nearing 30 and looking 16 🫰😘😘😘😘😘😘
The irony is staggering. It's disheartening to see people bullying the actor in the comments while the video itself is discussing the very same issue. It's a clear example of tone-deafness and a lack of self-awareness.
The BL community, like any other, should strive to be inclusive, respectful, and welcoming. Unfortunately, homophobia seems to be a norm here too.
1.STOP USING UNDERAGE ACTORS!.
2. cooheart should take himself outside of similar character roles. It honestly looks like he plays the same role. It will stifle his career growth. This is a legitimate criticism. And someone should tell that to him/his team. Maybe he should even try a character in a none bl series. Or a movie. He needs range!
Are of consent in thailand is 15. They are not underage.