An interesting review. I'm 72 years old and my swing speed is 80-82 mph. About 2 years ago, I set out to find the best ball for my game. I listened to a bunch of podcasts and read a lot of articles on the "best ball for slow swing speeds." I wound up testing the Callaway Supersoft, Srixon Softfeel, Titleist ProV1, Titleist AVX, Noodle Long and Soft, Precept Laddie Extreme, Cut Grey, Kirkland Signature and a few others. In the end, I liked the feel of the softer balls but found almost no difference in performance except that I have the impression that the Kirkland doesn't go as far as the others and the Titleist AVX might go a bit further (or it might be my imagination). Now, I use the AVX if the fairway is wide and there's no water. Otherwise, I use the cheapest ball I can buy, which is the Precept or the Noodle. I really believe that unless you're good enough to consistently hit the ball where you want to hit it, it just doesn't make any difference.
So I agree with some of this. I would actually make the argument that if you are not very good and you miss hit the golf ball a lot, you want something with softer compression to offer more forgiveness. If you are hitting a firmer golf ball like the AVX or the pro v1, Miss hits are going to punish you a lot more than soft golf balls are.
@@GolfBallAddictI’ve recently hit 85,86 and pretty much avg 89 been golfing 2 years. I’ve noticed all balls go the same distance for me 🤷🏽♂️ I avg 280 with 3 wood don’t use driver lol but for me the best ball I’ve noticed is Titleist it’s the only ball the checks for me every thing else gives me roll
My favorite of all time was on a top flight golf ball. I honestly was laughing so hard I thought I was going to be in tears. I expect certain followings to be really passionate about their golf balls, but never have I had a negative comment to that degree on a top flight. You just never know what you're going to see on here 😂
Kirkland blew it this year and last year was way better. You want the worlds best sleeper? Spalding SD Tour 3 piece urethane ball for 14 bucks on line. Ignore the hit job by the spy's. I play it to a 5 hdcp.
Strike ball correctly you get good results regardless how expensive or cheap the ball is. Make poor contact you get poor result how expensive or poor golf ball is.
Agree whole heartedly. Whenever I've had a special round it has been with something I just pulled out of my bag without a second thought!@@bobbradford6838
Absolutely no reason for a casual golfer to pay premium for golf balls. Play generics or play the ones you find. I'm a 6 handicap, I just want consistency. Found balls are not consistent. I'd rather have balls that are all the same, so I know what I'll get out of with every swing, chip or putt. A new box of Kirkland's, Vice, Pro Staff or other balls in range are fine for me.
I understand that thought process. And I'm sure it's true to some degree. But you do need to be careful. It's kind of like I mentioned in the video. The amount of people who have been a die-hard golf ball fan and have switched once I do a fitting for them would baffle you. A lot of people think that a golf ball fitting would be someone who is unsure what to play. That does happen from time to time, however a lot of my fittings come from guys who just played the same thing for 20 years and I convinced them to do the fitting just to give them closure. Most of them agree to it and I would say a good 60% of people end up switching. My point in that is that a lot of people are playing golf balls they really like and they think are giving them the max performance, but it just ends up all being hype in their head bringing false confidence.
@GolfBallAddict I understand and agree with you 💯 but I'm someone who let's just say is a shit golfer I'm work 40 hrs a week and I really don't have money to spend so I try to go cheap as I can but at same time I try to stick with a name brand I can't see spending 30 50 or 60 dollars on something I will just end up losing in the water or trees I play the Bridgestone e6 I found a place where I can get them for 21.99 a dozen but you really have me interested in the precept laddie now
@albertmcreynolds7143 bro go to academy and buy ufo balls. Let's you keep the same ball for consistency and they are 1 dollar per ball. If you aren't concerned about getting absolute peak performance then it's great. I'm not a great golfer and I can't really tell the difference between balls so I just buy those
@@albertmcreynolds7143 I'm going to give you the best ball you have ever played for 14 bucks a dozen. A tour quality 3 piece TPU Urethane ball that any tour pro would use. Spalding SD Tour Golf ball on rock bottom golf. Not the X model but the one in the gold box. You will buy more.
Appreciate the list. agree on Kirkland. Balls today have a vast options for all abilities. Much more so than when I grew up (age 57 now) One must decide what is their top reasons for a ball of choice. For me as a 3-4 hcp, that is short game trust, putting/feel, distance is not my top item but has to be a factor of not a dog. 98-102 SS. Tried them all. Still revert back to ProV1. TP5 is solid, Tour response is good. Vice Pro plus is very playable and I have played it recently. Note: I practice only with ProV in my short game (75% of my practice time). That is key to me of whatever ball people play is to use it practicing where it can matter most. Note: yesterday travel group is best shot format. I chipped in for birdie on par 3 we missed green. 244 par 4 I hit 5 wood to about 20 yards made up and down with 3 foot putt. ProV1. But I practice those constantly and it pays off.
I disagree. The quality of the Kirkland ball is awful. No one ball is like the other. This is why a tour ball is so much better and why you pay $55-$60 for a dozen of Titleist Golf balls than the cheaper ones, its the quality and consistency ball for ball, that is what you are paying for.
I am almost 80 years young. Swing speed around 90 when I am warmed up. I love the Bridgestone e12 contact however, I don't think any golf ball is worth over $25 per dozen. The manufacturers are making a killing on their golf balls. So I only buy the e12 when its marked down 20% or more at walmart or on line. Most of my balls are obtained via the lost ball situation. Its cheap, like me.😊
Have you tried something like the vice tour? They are around $25 per dozen and have a little bit of a firmer feel. I definitely feel you sir. I'm all about value myself. 😃
You’d be surprised to see the amount of older gentlemen and slow swing speed players playing these tour rated balls. I always cringe when I ask a golfer what ball they play and instantly know the compression is way beyond their swing. Great vid.
Completely agree. I am in the same boat now. I have a lot of guys who swing 75 mph who are arguing with me on the channel about how the pro v1x is the right ball for them. Not saying I don't believe them, but I am requiring some pretty hard evidence 😂
I think most golfers don’t understand compression and what that number means to your swing. My driver speed is on par with yours (95-100). I only use DTC balls (Sugar, Snell, Vice or OnCore) and they must be 3 piece urethane covers with 80-85 compression, that gets me the most distance but still enough stopping power on the green. Currently using an old box of new Snell MTB Prime after using all of my Prime 3.0’s. I will reorder the 3.0’s after the 2 dozen MTB’s are gone.
I would definitely agree with you when it comes to the compression. Compression doesn't quite mean what it used to but it's still very important when it comes to the golf ball fitting. Definitely give the new Snell 3.0 as a try they are awesome
Good information thanks. I'm an 18 handicapper, slow swing speed and I recently decided it's time to move up to a 3-piece ball. I've been searching in the budget 3-piece zone (sorry Titleist I'm not paying $60 a dozen). I had bought into all the marketing that slow swing speed players need soft balls and the 3-piece balls are a bit harder and outside of the traditional soft zone of 2-piece balls. That's one of the things that's held me back. MyGolfSpy ball test crew swears up and down that slow swing speed players should not be so concerned about low-compression balls. I finally bit the bullet and went with MaxFli Tour ball (85 compression). They are well-reviewed and the multi box (4) discount gets the price point down to a reasonable range (high 20's a dozen). It's early in my on-course use but wow I can really see how it sticks to a green if you strike an approach shot decent.
There's definitely a lot of opinions on golf ball compression. A couple of things to keep in mind here: For slow swingers I do still recommend lower compression golf balls, however that term is kind of relative. I still want to know how good of a player you are and how well you strike the iron. There are low compression golf balls that are three piece. Srixon q star tour, wright and ditson, oncore elixir, vice air, Chrome soft, just to name a few off the top of my head. For me the biggest question is how consistently you're striking the iron. The main difference I have found between firmer golf balls and softer golf balls is that when you Miss hit the softer golf balls, they forgive you so much more.
Man, I was channeling you throughout this video. I guessed 4 out of 5! I've tested these myself except the Kirkland and that may be why I didn't get that one, way off my radar I guess. Anyway, my experiences with these are very similar to yours. Keep posting great content a huge thumbs up on this one. You are in my "top five" channels my friend and I appreciate all the hard work you put in week to week.
I'm 75 and have been playing the Bridgestone e12 lately. I found one some weeks back, played it, and loved the hard to quantify feel at impact. I also loved the straight shots I hit and decided this was the way to go so, if it's working, don't fix it.
I will be making a video about it soon. But yes I am so thankful. I really appreciate everyone who's been here for the Long haul. This wouldn't have been possible without you guys 😁💯🙏
I've seen a lot of other testing that came out much different from yours on the Kirkland. A few yards shorter with more spin, but the biggest complaint was the durability. Problem for most golfers, myself included is that golf is way too expensive and most of us actually suck pretty badly at the game. Price of a cheap round of golf in my area is $50+. If you want a morning tee time on the weekend, break out $75 at a minimum. Ball price matters, especially when you might only hit it once or twice before you send it swimming or camping. I understand that we might not be playing our best golf with that ball, but most of us only get to play once or twice a month & hardly ever play our best golf anyway. Add the price of 10 lost golf balls at $3 each, then you're adding another $30 to a round that already cost $50+. Add a beer or 3 and before you know it your round of golf cost $100-$150. It's not dying on a hill for a golf ball. It's simple economics and saving money where I can allows me to play more golf if I can actually find the time.
So I agree with everything you just said. There's only one flaw in what you mentioned, the reason I created this channel was so that we could find the best performing golf balls for the money. It's one of the main target goals of the channel. With that being said, there are many many golf balls we have tested that are actually cheaper than the Kirkland that performed twice as good. I understand value matters, and I'm in that same boat. I refuse to spend more than $35 a dozen for golf balls. However the Kirkland is my 93rd ranked golf ball. The Wilson zip on the other hand, is my number two ranked golf ball and it's a dollar a golf ball. So what I really want all my viewers to understand is yes I understand you need value, but that doesn't mean you have to play a dog water golf ball.
@@GolfBallAddict I've never even seen that ball, but at that price, based on your recommendation, I just ordered 2 doz from Amazon for $29.97. Glad to see Wilson making a golf comeback. Them along with MacGregor were the kings of golf when I was a kid and working as a caddy, only with clubs, not balls. Titleist was king of golf balls back then too.
Very interesting. But you definitely need to test the latest versions of the balls. I just turned 83, have played for over 62 years, have a 16-17 handicap I hope to lower. Obviously swing speed has declined with age. And I still play forged blades with weak lofts (34 degree 7 iron). I get carry of 190-200 and total distance of about 210-220 with an occasional 235 with my driver, so last year moved up to the 5800-6200 tees in order to have second shots into the par 4s of 110-160 yards. Also replaced my 3,4 and 5 irons with a 7 wood and 9 wood. So I have become very interested in finding a ball that will give me 5 or 10 yards more distance on drives. But like many mid-handicappers I often miss a green short or to either side and face a pitch or chip with a wedge. Make a lot of use of my 60 degree lob wedge for 20 to 50 yard pitches. Have no trouble hitting it high on to the green. But for either a full approach shot with anything from a pitching wedge to a 6 iron, and for those LW pitches, I would like to also find a ball that has a lot of greenside spin so that my shots won't roll off firm fast greens. More distance on drives, yet better stopping with irons and wedges. That's asking a lot. Usually you can get one or the other, not both. I am a member at the PGA Super Store in Rockville, Maryland, and have taken advantage of their practice bays with overhead Foresight launch monitors to test literally dozens of different balls for hours, from the Wilson Duo and Callway Super Soft all the way up to the Pro V1X left dash. Played with them as well. And I have also closely studied the results of the My Golf Spy ball tests for lower swing speeds. Call me a weirdo golf nerd. Lately I have found that the Wilson Triad is a pretty good all around choice. Compared it with the latest Callaway Super Soft is, which is improved, gives good distance on drives, but you definitely loose 1000 rpm or more spin on wedge shots. If you rub one of them, you can feel they have a much "stickier" surface than any tour ball, no doubt to increase friction and spin, but still. I would agree with you that when I have looked at the data with many other balls, at my swing speed I definitely do not get max distance from either the Titleist ProV1 or V1x or left dash V1x, and also do not get max distance from the Bridgestone balls for swing speeds under 105, either the RX or RXS. It takes using the launch monitor to tell that, since mid-handicappers like me simply don't produce sufficiently precise and consistent results out on the course on which to base a determination.
That is quite a lot of great information. Thank you for taking the time to post it. I agree with most of what you said. That's awesome that you get to hit in their bays and get some really good data from it. There are a lot of guys that would love to have that information
I really enjoy these videos. As a retired 74 year old losing swing speed, I’ve been trying a lot of balls. Agree with your assessments and didn’t like the Supersoft even at my swing speed . Not very forgiving. I’ve tried all the mid- 3 piece urethane balls and like the Q-Star Tour. The ball I’ve had the best luck with is the Bridgestone TreSoft. Unfortunately hard to find in the US. Meijer has stopped selling them. Still advertised on the Australian Bridgestone website. Similar to E6. Recently trying the Maxfli Tour S and Wilson Zip as I’m looking for a replacement for the Treosoft when they run out. Trying the Zio based on your video.
@@GolfBallAddict Wilson Zip wasn’t as good for me as I expected. Not bad and comparable type ball at 50 compression to my gamer. I was Looking for more distance as an 80 mph senior so I switched to a 12 degree driver and started re-testing balls. I got the best results with the Maxfli Tour S. It even out performed my old standby Bridgestone TreoSoft. I tested several balls with GPS on two different courses. They were urethane mid price and two piece lower price. The much cheaper TreoSoft was second but now is only available in Australia. That is what started me looking for a new ball. I love the Q Star Tour but driver distance was lacking by a lot. Best around the greens and accurate. I was very surprised the Maxfli Tour S performed the way it did. Long and forgiving with all clubs. Not as good around the greens for a urethane ball but rollout not bad. I’ll continue using Treosoft but will phase Maxfli Tour S in. Occasionally I use Q Star tour on shorter holes.
Nailed it! I agree with what you have presented here. And I very much like how you have said that two piece balls can be better for average and even well above average golfers than many if not most urethane covered golf balls. Most golfers aren’t going to shoot lower scores because they played a golf ball that spins more on wedges and partial wedges. They are going to shoot lower scores by playing a golf ball that goes a little further, and curves a little less in the air, like many two piece golf balls.
That is the case for many golfers. Including myself even. I've played some of my best rounds with balls like the Wilson zip and the Snell get sum. Every time I try a three or four piece tour ball it seems like I just don't play as well. Miss hits punish me and I get way more side spend on drives
Excellent and well thought review however I believe a lot of players pick their golf ball by popularity and not what performs best for them. I personally play the Callaway Supersoft because I love the feel and control on the greens. I personally prefer an orange ball because I can see it easier. The durability is amazing and I've played three rounds withe the same ball and the distance stayed consistent. I definitely agree that the Kirkland is not a good ball except for gaining strokes on your score but if it works for you as a golfer then stick with it. Again, golfers need to pick a ball that suits their game! I am a 60 year old with a 85-90 mph swing with a 9 handicap and I've changed my ball numerous times over the past 30 years to suit my game and swing. Same thing goes for my clubs, I have Taylormade, PXG, Ping and a Titleist in my bag because I find what works best for me not some PGA tour player who's getting paid and professionally fitted for his or her clubs. Life is short (just like most of my approach shots) so play more golf and have fun!
When I played in highschool we were given pro v1s for the last ten years that’s all I’ve played and I’ve experienced the unforgiving nature of them. However I never realized how in forgiving they were till I started playing som softer options I finally settled on the callaway chrome soft and I feel I’m a lot less stressed if I don’t hit it just right.
heads up, i think your image for golfers that use the tp5 is off. i am pretty sure scottie doesn't use tp5. i think he uses a prov. That being said. love the wilson zip core, been loving that recommendation and recommended it to a coworker!
Thank you for the heads up. Team Taylormade doesn't have a picture for who uses their balls exclusively. However it makes you wonder why more of them aren't playing it... I am so glad it worked out for you! 😀
@@GolfBallAddict you would think they would want to share stuff like who uses their ball, unless they don’t have much to share?? It also makes me wonder how much do pros give up for contracts. Like are they leaving wins on the table for a paycheck with their club deals?
I’ve always been a play what I find guy, but realizing I need to play the same ball. I love the Chrome Soft and just bought my first balls in years. Also love the 360 Triple Track.
The Chrome soft / Chrome tour is definitely the best tour AAA golf ball I've tested. I love that this year they still kept the Chrome soft for loyalist as well as people who love a much softer feel. That 360 triple track looks really good. The Chrome tour I tested a couple months ago had one and I love the look
I'm a disabled golfer, and my go-to ball is the old Titleist DT-Trusoft. I(I never lose balls) I use the Supersoft on cold Spring Days and cold Fall days. They work well for my 70MPH swing.
Yes those golf balls do wonderful on colder days. I remember those old true soft golf balls. I heard the 2024 version is a little bit better as well, so can't wait to do a retest
How about providing a chart on your web site showing the top 3 balls for the swing speed ranges of 65 to 75 mph, 75 to 85 and 85 to 95? I'd like to see a comparison. Perhaps you could break the selected ball out by 2 piece vs. 3 piece. Please share a link if you already have this and I just didn't see it. Thank you. I love your common sense approach.
Really liked this video! I've been golfing (trying to golf) since I was a kid. Trying all different balls and clubs. I have found that the Noodle Long & Soft is a pretty good ball for me. I also like the Srixon. Have you done any testing on the Noodle line? I would be interested in seeing you review of them.
Ive only been praying for 5 months i started in April this year and always chose the cheaper balls because of course i was gonna lose a lot of balls while playing, but i played a whole round with the pro v1 yesterday August 25th and shot 95, and i have been using I've tried Calloway and because i know i haven't developed a great swing yet but always shoot around 105 to 115. So far my best round taking 10 to 20 strokes off my game has been Pro V1. I'm not great and i know it but i play for results of getting better and will surely look for more forgiven balls.
140-145 ball speed for driver, slice sometimes and would like some forgiveness (15 hcp). I play the AVX but not sure it makes sense. What are some you’d recommend I check out? Thank you!!
I would still stay with the two piece since the golf balls have advanced in technology so much and they will help get you to the single digit category. Like I said before check out that video I think you'll like it 😁
I am probably a below average golfer with a slower swing speed. Yet I play the Bridgestone BRX. I know that they do not maximize distance but they have a urethane cover so are very durable and they STAY on line. Plus I’ve been able to get them at $39 most of the time. The e6 has too little spin around the greens. Just my opinion FWIW
So I have a slower swing speed but my smash factor on all the clubs is in the 1.4 range. As a perfectly average golfer, I lose maybe a ball or two a round. MyGolfSpy’s ball test found low compression was less important. I play a 3 piece (Snell when I have them, Supersoft when not) and recently tried TM tour stripe. I definitely think feel around the green is most important and I like soft “feel.” Do you think a Chromesoft is worth it? When do you think it’s time to “move up” to a 4 piece ball?
So I do disagree with the lower compression argument, but that's for a different day. Let me try to answer your question the best I can. To start off, yes the Chrome soft would be a good ball. It's lower compression allows for tour like feel for people who have average swing speeds. So it's definitely worth a try. I also love the vice ProAir for this too. Little bit better of a value. As far as when to move up to a four-piece golf ball, it kind of depends because all four piece golf balls are different and have different compressions. But in my experience, I would say about 85% of 4-Piece golf balls are even too firm for me to compress at 98 mph. Four piece territory is usually 105 mph or greater.
Thays why 90% of average golfers will never get better. They're not open to the idea of other options and not just golf balls. You wouldn't believe how may average golfers play with blades!!
Oh it blows my mind. And an absolutely makes me sick to my stomach. I have so many coworkers and Friends who are trying to get better and shoot below 90, and they're buying these $1,700 unforgiving blades. Honestly I'm at a point where I don't care how good I get I don't see myself ever getting blades. I'll take the forgiveness all day everyday
Not just play them but I always see comments of "you suck and only hit a 8i x distance because your playing game improvement" like are they legal? Yes. Then leave people alone man if you want more distance buy those irons if you want the blade feel buy those but don't criticize others for buying what fits them lol golf egos are a wild thing lol
I am new to golf. This is my second season. I was happy to see a list of balls I don't need to rush to try out. But the Costco balls, that is different for me. I just don't want to care if I lose a ball. Costco balls are cheap to learn on imo. Do you have another balls as good and cheap to learn this game on. I swing slow and am +50 years old.
Great question and I sure do. The cut red golf balls are a dollar a piece and are available at Walmart and target. The Wilson zip, my number two ranked golf ball, is also around a dollar a golf ball and available at Walmart and Amazon And honestly I know this one sounds weird. But the top flight XL distance can be either at a dollar golf ball or even a little cheaper and it's not bad for a beginner. I actually had pretty decent results with it Another great option is the maxfli soft fli. And finally off the top of my head, the Pinnacle soft. All these are great options and are about a dollar a golf ball
Great video as always! Played with a 115 swing speed player who played the Kirkland ball. I had a couple extra Chrome Tour's and gave to him as I only swing 85 and couldn't use them. What a difference he felt. I even saw MGS said Kirkland is the worst ball in golf this week. Looking forward to when/if you do the SpeedSoft vs Q Star Tour review. Those are the 2 balls I have in bag and am having a very hard time settling on one. Yoru help would be greatly appreciated.
Played with a buddy this past weekend. He was excited to try the KS balls he just got. It was the first time all summer i was out driving him and it was by 15 to 20 yards. That spinny property kills distance for KS balls.
Typical 19 HDCP'r: "I PLAY DEEZ BALLZ CUZ TIGER DOES" 😅 Odd that the Callway Supersoft makes this list but the Chrome Soft, made it to your top 10! I play A LOT of those Bridgestone Tourballs and Prov1s because that's what I find hunting for my recycled Wilson Prostaffs in the woods LOL.
I mean you find them everywhere. It's crazy to me that if you find a ball in the woods there's a 50% chance it's a pro v1. Especially with over 150 different golf ball makers
I give the Pro v1’s away too. Just wish someone was giving me Maxfli Tour S’s back or the MF Tour but there aren’t too many to be found in my area as the nearest Dick’s is an hour away.
I just found this channel and I’m quite pleasantly surprised! I’ve played Titleist since the days of the old Tour Professional and Tour Balata and the ProV1 from when it debuted with a slight detour to (wonky) Chrome Tour & Z-star! Still play the pro v1 but I got a deal (in the UK) on Tour Golds & new Z star and having JUST turned 65 but still playing to a decent level, when they’re starting to run out I’ll have to be looking for a new ball! My wife plays & loves her supersofts, she suffers from RA so I might have to look for another ball for her! I’m the golf tech geek not her! Edit to add, I tried the kirkland 2.0 and it WAS rubbish! I wouldn’t even use it as a Winter ball! Gave the rest away to my son in law who is starting golf!
✳️ I discovered the Taylormade Soft Response a great ball for the price in the mid price range ✅ it’s a 3 piece low compression ball at 50 suitable for most players who swing it less than 100mph for the driver ✳️
I think any ball that sells for more than $30/dozen is overrated. Every ball should sell for around $1/ball...period...especially for the millions of mid-to-high handicappers who lose balls a lot more often than the really good golfers.
I've hit a lot of golf balls in my day. This is great info. Titleist does make a good ball but way over priced and overrated . I actually really like that Bridgestone e6 soft.
Thank you very much. I appreciate you taking the time to comment and watch. I'm getting ready to test the new Bridgestone lineup and I've heard really good things. Hoping they make a jump 😃
Im a mid HC and i want to play a urethane cover golf ball ! Im currently playing the chrome soft. What are your thoughts on the new chrome tour ? Sounds like I might have to check out the Vice Pro line ?
Definitely check out my top 20 golf ball list. I do like the Chrome tour but I think the Chrome soft has a better performance overall. Will need to be tested for sure. The vice line is definitely worth a shot
I always played 2 piece balls because that's what the "Internet" says I should play because I have a slow swing speed (~85mph w/driver) and high handicap (21). A few months ago I found a ProV1 on the 5th hole and decided to play it the rest of the round. I had some of the longest and best hits I've ever had. So I decided to buy a dozen and I feel like I play a lot better with them. I'm getting more distance, accuracy, and getting the ball to stop on the green. My local shop sells used, excellent condition, ProV1s for $15/dozen. So I'm going to stick with them since I play better with them and they're cheaper than most 2 piece balls out there.
I'll have to definitely take your word for it. I would encourage somehow to try a golf ball fitting. I mean if it isn't broke don't fix it, but it wouldn't be the first time someone has swore up and down to me that they played better with the Pro V1 and then after the fitting was done they found four or five golf balls that give them better numbers. It never hurts to try it just to see if something performs a little better Thank you so much for your feedback though, as well as watching and commenting. It helps the video and channel a lot 😁😃
I get the best overall performance from the rest of my Project A golf balls but I hear the tour response is not as good and they upped the price quite a bit. I received a free box of Titleist tour speed and loved them for the distance but could not hold the firm greens. I might look into the Srixon's next. The Q Star Tour might be right for me at age 65. Thanks for your perspective from the average golfer point of view.
Anytime. Thank you so much for taking the time to watch and comment. It means the world to me. That's not the first time I've heard that people like the project a better. I wish I could have done a direct comparison
Great question. Here are some of my thoughts without testing it for myself: I am sure it works. It makes sense from a science standpoint. However, I am also worried that some will use it as an excuse. Most average players probably wont notice minor imbalances. I will definitely be doing a test of my own soon!
I somewhat agree with some on your list, but I do believe that if you "think" the ball you play is the best ball for you then that is 90% of the battle won, confidence when u stand over a ball means a lot more then it is given credit for IMO.
I definitely agree with you on the confidence. However that's why I recommend ball fitting so much. My thing is, you can be playing the worst golf ball on the planet and be confident in it. I was playing the tp5 back in the day and thought I was hot stuff because I was playing a five-layer ball with tons of spin. However it wasn't until I lost my final one on the course and had to switch to a Duo soft to just finish the round. When I all of a sudden got 20 yards more distance, and pard 4 of the 5 last holes, that's when I knew something was up. That kind of propelled me to start the channel also.
Pretty solid list. I think TP5s and ProV1s definitely dont work for the average golfer but are fantastic if you’re single digit or below. I was surprised at Supersoft because I feel for value and performance they are great for the average golfer. Same with Kirklands, hard to beat for the value. 😂
Thank you very much. I agree with you on the tour balls for sure. See the thing is, we are about 4 years in and I reviewed over $120 golf balls. What I am trying to now preach, is that we have tested many golf balls that are cheaper and perform better than both the Callaway super soft and the Kirkland signature. Yes the price on those golf balls are a good value, but like I said I have ones I've tested that are cheaper and go farther and spin more Thanks so much for taking the time to watch and comment. It means a lot 😃
I agree about the pro v1. I never seem to get them going I did a Titleist ball fitting at golf show and was advised the pro v1x would be better for me as it spins more and id get a higher flight. I'm working my way through my 2 dozen Kirkland signature V2 at the moment and I've been very happy with them. Probably won't try the V3 after watching this
I have a friend that I play with regularly and he swears on the ProV1. He has only broken 100 a couple of times and I cannot get him off of the ProV1 for the same reason you mentioned in this video. I just want him to try something else to see if he likes it better or if it plays better because I want his game to improve and I'm wondering if the ProV1 is slowing down his gains. He absolutely will not even entertain the idea.
There are people like that. Please recommend this video to him. I know it's hard for people when they like something and they don't like change, but at least do a golf ball fitting. You never know you the worst case scenario you just stick with what you have but you might find you like something better
Genuine question, you said all Taylormade balls, what’s your opinion on Noodles? As a beginner golfer these are my go to for cheap balls, since I generally lose them quickly haha
Golfball is not overrated if you get what you need from it.. I can't find any other golf ball that gives me the feeling if I clip this correctly it's going to stop beside the pin other than a pro v then the putter feel to match ..it's a win ,win for me! It's all personal choice but never overrated..⛳️
Because tens of thousands of people play it. Yet it has been proven not only by the human test, ergo me, and also by robotic testing, today's golfer, that it is just a mediocre golf ball that spends way too much and loses way too much distance. For the same price, actually a little cheaper, you could be playing a golf ball that is top five in distance and forgiveness. Just because something is cheap doesn't mean it can't be overrated.
Overtime I've learned them just from having to say them over and over on the channel. But my goodness it's like the Nike balls back in the day. Every year they came out with five new names and it was impossible to identify them.
I love wilson. I took a look at their new blades and even though I can't hit them I absolutely adore them. I almost want to get really good at golf just so I can buy them LOL
I emailed Wilson a few months ago asking why the Zip was removed from their website, and their response was because it's been discontinued. I think they just had a lot of stock is why walmart and amazon still sell them. My local walmart was out of them for about a year, but they have them now.
You're right, they are marketing geniuses! Many want to FEEL like a Tour Pro so they buy them even though it doesn't suit their gamee at all. I'm a 19 handicap and I play the Taylor Made Soft Response the majority of the time. I also really like Srixon balls! Not sure if they really suit my game but I like the Softfeel and QStar.
If you like that soft response be sure to check out the speed soft as well. I have really good results with that. Also love the take. All the golf balls you mentioned have at least tested good or better. So I think you're on a great track
Hello. Love the Channel! I just started playing golf less than two years ago (Long-time Tournament tennis player). I assume my swing speed is in the low to mid 80s. I have been using the Callaway SuperSoft and I'm reasonable happy. Two quick questions - How do I know which year they were manufactured? Also... I have a box of the ERC Soft that I have never used. Might they be a better option? Thanks!
The ERC is a good option but keep in mind it is for a little bit advanced player. If you find yourself shooting in the 80s it's a good ball but if you're still shooting 90s to 100s I would stick to two piece. As far as being able to tell the model, it's all about the alignment tool. Go on calloway's website to see what the current alignment tool looks like and compare it to what you have. From there you can kind of Google and see which model for each year and what they had
I'd get a kick out of you reviewing golf balls which are not USGA conforming ....MG Senior, Polara, Bandit, etc...Might not be in your wheel house but, would still enjoy a non partial review...Personally, I love the MG Senior ball...
I have no problem reviewing golf balls that are not USGA approved. For average golfers, who cares? I have a couple of those you mentioned ready to be tested just haven't done them yet
The PRO V1 is definitely overrated. I personally like the Callaway Supersoft, I like the spin it produces with my irons, I put a lot of spin on my iron shots. What ball would you recommend for 6 HCP with speed 100-110?
Right now, I loved the vice pro Plus, Snell 4.0, Mizuno tour x, oncore Vero X2, and maxfli tour x for that swing speed. All worth a try and all not going to break the bank
I find it ironic that the super soft by Callaway are supposed to be higher handicap friendly, but you find a lot of them in the woods. I'm not a low handicapper. I can't hit the pro v1 or x to save my ass.
LOL it's definitely a golf ball for higher handicaps, however for the people who are spraying multiple balls into the woods in the round, I would recommend more like a top flight probably. The XL is long and straight and they're only like 50 cents of golf ball lol
I agree with you, kirkland golf balls I never like and titleist over priced. I tried the Wright and ditson and even with slower swing speed they still got good distance. Next one I going to try is the legato golf ball.
I switched to the Wilson Zip after watching this show carefully. I’m 73, hit a proV about 200-215 off the tee. I’m out there 220-230 with the Wilson consistently, like I was hitting it 10 years ago. I love the feel of compressing the ball again. Plus I bought two dozen on Amazon for $30 all in.
63 y/o, swing speed low 90s, and 14 hdcp. I play some Kirkland driven by price. I don’t see a drop in distance, but hate them in the short game- too hard. My go to Chrome soft, also like some Bridgesetones and Taylor Made.
Thank you so much for your comment and for watching. I would recommend the same thing I said in the video, feel free to check out the top 10. I promise you can find something better than that Kirkland
Bridgestone E6 soft was awesome! I’ve tried almost all the Bridgestone after, didn’t like any. Love the channel, I’ve tried a lot of golf balls because of the channel. Really like Vice pro and Chrome Soft!
I haven’t done much research into balls, but I like playing chrome softs, I actually have a fairly high swing speed, but i’m also an inconsistent striker. I’m wondering if I made a mistake now trying a box of supersofts. I haven’t put them into play yet.
Thank you so much for your comment and for watching. Don't worry, it is never a mistake to try out a golf ball. The worst thing that could happen is you don't like them. With that being said, I do think you will overcompress them a little bit. You might lose some driver distance but you'll love the feel and forgiveness with the irons. It's a give and take. I too love Chrome softs. They're one of the most fastest, best forgiving tour balls I've tested.
I am a golf ball snob. Titleist Pro-V1 and Pro-V1x. Taylor Made TP5 and TP5X. Occasionally I will find Titleist with a members initials. I like to give them back in the locker room.
First time watching your videos. I gave up on the prov's years ago. I'm in my 50's and also a 9 handicap with a 101 driver swing speed. I actually have enjoyed the Wilson Duo's. Cheaper and just as good as most other balls. The only other ball I tested myself was better for my sing was Vice Pro's.
There's a good chance you might be losing a little bit of distance off the driver with the Wilson Duo, however for the majority of your other clubs you're probably doing just fine. If you love that feel, which I understand why you do because Wilson golf balls feel phenomenal, then just stick with it. I've heard people tell me the Wilson triad is a great three-piece model but I didn't have very much luck when I tested it the first time
@@GolfBallAddict The put-off for me is the price of the Triad. I thought it was ok as I liked the new Duo 2.5's better. And for the price why not. If Wilson didn't do the buy 2 get 1 free from their Staff ball earlier this year, I would have bought several dozen of Vice Pro soft's. I either will play the Wilson or Vice, depending on who has good sales at the end of the year.... :)
😂😂😂😂I was ok until you turned on supersoft. Played that as a beginner and helped me get my handicap down. I only out grew the ball when I was approaching a single figure handicap. For me it was long off the tee and ok on approach shots. Hence, continued to play it. Tried Kirkland recently, might be ok with pitching shots but, lost loads of distance off the tee and with irons. It’s fine for tough courses where I don’t mind losing balls.
The super soft is fine. But my goodness I'm just tired of finding a gazillion of them at work. No lie at one point I had over a hundred of them that I found from work and only a matter of a couple months. Insane 😂
Recent tests by Club Champion of the Kirkland 3.0 ball for those with a 115-120 SS found it to be very much like the ProV1. It may be great for the higher SS golfers but not for your speed or slower.
That's good to know! It doesn't surprise me with how firm it is, but I still think it's a huge mistake from kirkland. The majority of their market is budget golfers who swing average swing speed. In order to get that type of swing speed at 115 to 120 mph you are talking about a very select group of individuals. I think it limits their market too much, but hey that's just my two cents.
The most engineered piece of tech created to date is the tire that why I usually go with Bridgestone I just assume they put insane energy into their designs
Oh absolutely. Keep in mind that tiger woods loved their engineering so much when they were making the Nike balls that he just stuck with them even after Nike quit.
Yes my swing is same 95 mph avg and Handicap is currently 8.4. The balls I dont care for are the Mizuno RB Tour balls. Srixons lack pop for my swing speed. I love all the new 3 Callaway Ball Line. I have used the Chrome Tour X, Chrome Tour and the new Chrome Soft are all great. Titleist ProV1 and ProV1X are great, but I feel I sacrifice some distance compared to all the new Callaway Balls. I have mixed emotions on the Taylor Made. Used to be my go to ball. I do like the new TP5 but dont love it. Agree Bridgestone Balls are not very good. That new green dot thing is lame and looks bad on a ball. Never tried the new Wilson balls or MaxFli Balls. I am finding recently that I am preferring the softer feeling golf balls
Vice Pro Plus is my ball of choice. Great soft feel, great distance and the feel with my pitch shots is great. Forgiving ball with performance of more expensive balls. My launch monitor shows better numbers than the ProV1
Appreciate you sharing your feedback. I didn't have much luck with the Triad but I have had dozens of people asking for a re-review after they had the opposite results. I cannot wait to retest it now.
lol, found a Taylor made in the rough a couple feet from the fairway last weekend, gave it a go, figured out that the previous guy didn’t lose it, he just left it like a giant turd because it was terrible. Felt like I was hitting a perfectly round rock. I’m a 12 hc with driver swing speed 108.
I try a lot of balls, most I find! For me, a 71 year old mid handicapper the Taylor Made Tour Response Strip is the ball. The paint stripe in the middle seem to allow the ball to stay straight. The Pro V1, Wilson Staff, New Callaway Tour are all good performers. I keep going back to the TM TR. Play what you love! Good stuff Nick! Thanks
over the last year, me and my 88mph driver speed have tried chrome soft, tour soft, snell black, and tp5. not a bit of difference between any of them, except price.
10 hcp, 80 mph swing speed. i play a callaway supersoft/chromesoft. ive tried a a couple tour level balls, tp5 prov1 etc but they all.seem a bit firm to me? plus, the cost is outrageous.
I have 4 dozen Kirks and after watching my best drives go a 150 yes and then drop like a rock I switched balls. Still trying to find the best ball for me😢
Every time i find a kirkland golf ball i usually throw it back in the hazard or pack it to save for someone else whos prolly gonna lose it after 3 stokes. I like costco but not that much to be a brand idiot 😂
It's funny, people at work now know how much I dislike it, so every time someone leaves one in a cart, which feels like a hundred times a day. They try to give it to me and I throw it in the garbage LOL
I *really* wanted to like the Kirkland ball, but it gets marked and cut so quickly, any benefit in price is soon forgotten. Bridgestone balls I've found to be as good as any, YMMV.
@@MichaelParker-zs5ylI used to belong to a club where a lot of members did not support the club, in the pro shop or in the restaurant. It is now bankrupt.
An interesting review. I'm 72 years old and my swing speed is 80-82 mph. About 2 years ago, I set out to find the best ball for my game. I listened to a bunch of podcasts and read a lot of articles on the "best ball for slow swing speeds." I wound up testing the Callaway Supersoft, Srixon Softfeel, Titleist ProV1, Titleist AVX, Noodle Long and Soft, Precept Laddie Extreme, Cut Grey, Kirkland Signature and a few others. In the end, I liked the feel of the softer balls but found almost no difference in performance except that I have the impression that the Kirkland doesn't go as far as the others and the Titleist AVX might go a bit further (or it might be my imagination). Now, I use the AVX if the fairway is wide and there's no water. Otherwise, I use the cheapest ball I can buy, which is the Precept or the Noodle. I really believe that unless you're good enough to consistently hit the ball where you want to hit it, it just doesn't make any difference.
The Supersoft is an excellent option for you. Consider the Snell 2.0 as well.
So I agree with some of this. I would actually make the argument that if you are not very good and you miss hit the golf ball a lot, you want something with softer compression to offer more forgiveness. If you are hitting a firmer golf ball like the AVX or the pro v1, Miss hits are going to punish you a lot more than soft golf balls are.
I am older than you are and like Titleist ok, but found the Vice Tour to be as good.
I think the AVX travels further too
@@GolfBallAddictI’ve recently hit 85,86 and pretty much avg 89 been golfing 2 years. I’ve noticed all balls go the same distance for me 🤷🏽♂️ I avg 280 with 3 wood don’t use driver lol but for me the best ball I’ve noticed is Titleist it’s the only ball the checks for me every thing else gives me roll
Why would any sane person make profane and ugly comments because someone did not like a certain golf ball?
They're not sane. They're subhuman with no brains or class. I couldn't believe my ears when Nick mentioned that.
My favorite of all time was on a top flight golf ball. I honestly was laughing so hard I thought I was going to be in tears. I expect certain followings to be really passionate about their golf balls, but never have I had a negative comment to that degree on a top flight. You just never know what you're going to see on here 😂
What about top flight plus? Feels like a rock but always liked them for some reason, very bouncy for sure.
@@GolfBallAddict😂😂😂 Classic
Kirkland blew it this year and last year was way better. You want the worlds best sleeper? Spalding SD Tour 3 piece urethane ball for 14 bucks on line. Ignore the hit job by the spy's. I play it to a 5 hdcp.
I just play whatever golf balls I find. Suits me fine. :)
Strike ball correctly you get good results regardless how expensive or cheap the ball is. Make poor contact you get poor result how expensive or poor golf ball is.
Agree whole heartedly. Whenever I've had a special round it has been with something I just pulled out of my bag without a second thought!@@bobbradford6838
@@bobbradford6838 Wrong, but you go with that.
Absolutely no reason for a casual golfer to pay premium for golf balls. Play generics or play the ones you find. I'm a 6 handicap, I just want consistency. Found balls are not consistent. I'd rather have balls that are all the same, so I know what I'll get out of with every swing, chip or putt. A new box of Kirkland's, Vice, Pro Staff or other balls in range are fine for me.
@@nvjohansson9741 Agreed
I'm starting to believe that it really doesn't matter what anyone on UA-cam has to say it all comes down to what we like..
I understand that thought process. And I'm sure it's true to some degree. But you do need to be careful. It's kind of like I mentioned in the video.
The amount of people who have been a die-hard golf ball fan and have switched once I do a fitting for them would baffle you. A lot of people think that a golf ball fitting would be someone who is unsure what to play. That does happen from time to time, however a lot of my fittings come from guys who just played the same thing for 20 years and I convinced them to do the fitting just to give them closure. Most of them agree to it and I would say a good 60% of people end up switching.
My point in that is that a lot of people are playing golf balls they really like and they think are giving them the max performance, but it just ends up all being hype in their head bringing false confidence.
@GolfBallAddict I understand and agree with you 💯 but I'm someone who let's just say is a shit golfer I'm work 40 hrs a week and I really don't have money to spend so I try to go cheap as I can but at same time I try to stick with a name brand I can't see spending 30 50 or 60 dollars on something I will just end up losing in the water or trees I play the Bridgestone e6 I found a place where I can get them for 21.99 a dozen but you really have me interested in the precept laddie now
@albertmcreynolds7143 bro go to academy and buy ufo balls. Let's you keep the same ball for consistency and they are 1 dollar per ball. If you aren't concerned about getting absolute peak performance then it's great. I'm not a great golfer and I can't really tell the difference between balls so I just buy those
@@albertmcreynolds7143 I'm going to give you the best ball you have ever played for 14 bucks a dozen. A tour quality 3 piece TPU Urethane ball that any tour pro would use. Spalding SD Tour Golf ball on rock bottom golf. Not the X model but the one in the gold box. You will buy more.
@@albertmcreynolds7143 it’s what’s good for your game everyone’s different
Appreciate the list. agree on Kirkland. Balls today have a vast options for all abilities. Much more so than when I grew up (age 57 now) One must decide what is their top reasons for a ball of choice. For me as a 3-4 hcp, that is short game trust, putting/feel, distance is not my top item but has to be a factor of not a dog. 98-102 SS. Tried them all. Still revert back to ProV1. TP5 is solid, Tour response is good. Vice Pro plus is very playable and I have played it recently. Note: I practice only with ProV in my short game (75% of my practice time). That is key to me of whatever ball people play is to use it practicing where it can matter most. Note: yesterday travel group is best shot format. I chipped in for birdie on par 3 we missed green. 244 par 4 I hit 5 wood to about 20 yards made up and down with 3 foot putt. ProV1. But I practice those constantly and it pays off.
Great take here. Love the feedback and couldn't agree more. Consistency is key and it sounds like you've got that baby really dialed in 😁
I disagree. The quality of the Kirkland ball is awful. No one ball is like the other. This is why a tour ball is so much better and why you pay $55-$60 for a dozen of Titleist Golf balls than the cheaper ones, its the quality and consistency ball for ball, that is what you are paying for.
@@digger11000my agreement was for the channel owner saying was Kirkland balls are not good.
@@digger11000 They got you sucked in didn't they.
I am almost 80 years young. Swing speed around 90 when I am warmed up. I love the Bridgestone e12 contact however, I don't think any golf ball is worth over $25 per dozen. The manufacturers are making a killing on their golf balls. So I only buy the e12 when its marked down 20% or more at walmart or on line. Most of my balls are obtained via the lost ball situation. Its cheap, like me.😊
Have you tried something like the vice tour? They are around $25 per dozen and have a little bit of a firmer feel.
I definitely feel you sir. I'm all about value myself. 😃
You’d be surprised to see the amount of older gentlemen and slow swing speed players playing these tour rated balls. I always cringe when I ask a golfer what ball they play and instantly know the compression is way beyond their swing. Great vid.
Completely agree. I am in the same boat now. I have a lot of guys who swing 75 mph who are arguing with me on the channel about how the pro v1x is the right ball for them. Not saying I don't believe them, but I am requiring some pretty hard evidence 😂
I think most golfers don’t understand compression and what that number means to your swing. My driver speed is on par with yours (95-100). I only use DTC balls (Sugar, Snell, Vice or OnCore) and they must be 3 piece urethane covers with 80-85 compression, that gets me the most distance but still enough stopping power on the green. Currently using an old box of new Snell MTB Prime after using all of my Prime 3.0’s. I will reorder the 3.0’s after the 2 dozen MTB’s are gone.
I would definitely agree with you when it comes to the compression. Compression doesn't quite mean what it used to but it's still very important when it comes to the golf ball fitting. Definitely give the new Snell 3.0 as a try they are awesome
Good information thanks. I'm an 18 handicapper, slow swing speed and I recently decided it's time to move up to a 3-piece ball. I've been searching in the budget 3-piece zone (sorry Titleist I'm not paying $60 a dozen). I had bought into all the marketing that slow swing speed players need soft balls and the 3-piece balls are a bit harder and outside of the traditional soft zone of 2-piece balls. That's one of the things that's held me back. MyGolfSpy ball test crew swears up and down that slow swing speed players should not be so concerned about low-compression balls. I finally bit the bullet and went with MaxFli Tour ball (85 compression). They are well-reviewed and the multi box (4) discount gets the price point down to a reasonable range (high 20's a dozen). It's early in my on-course use but wow I can really see how it sticks to a green if you strike an approach shot decent.
There's definitely a lot of opinions on golf ball compression. A couple of things to keep in mind here:
For slow swingers I do still recommend lower compression golf balls, however that term is kind of relative. I still want to know how good of a player you are and how well you strike the iron. There are low compression golf balls that are three piece. Srixon q star tour, wright and ditson, oncore elixir, vice air, Chrome soft, just to name a few off the top of my head.
For me the biggest question is how consistently you're striking the iron. The main difference I have found between firmer golf balls and softer golf balls is that when you Miss hit the softer golf balls, they forgive you so much more.
Man, I was channeling you throughout this video. I guessed 4 out of 5! I've tested these myself except the Kirkland and that may be why I didn't get that one, way off my radar I guess. Anyway, my experiences with these are very similar to yours. Keep posting great content a huge thumbs up on this one. You are in my "top five" channels my friend and I appreciate all the hard work you put in week to week.
Thank you so much for your kind words. They mean the world to me. It appears you share a very similar tasting golf balls that I do.
@@GolfBallAddict My top three are Wilson Staff Model, Duo Soft, and Vice Pro.
I'm 75 and have been playing the Bridgestone e12 lately. I found one some weeks back, played it, and loved the hard to quantify feel at impact. I also loved the straight shots I hit and decided this was the way to go so, if it's working, don't fix it.
I agree 100%. If you like the way the golf balls coming off the club and you enjoy how it performs, then keep using it.
Seems like subs have doubled since the beginning of this year 😎 glad this one’s gotten the views it deserves bro
I will be making a video about it soon. But yes I am so thankful. I really appreciate everyone who's been here for the Long haul. This wouldn't have been possible without you guys 😁💯🙏
Pro V1,,,, the emperors new clothes. (You probably need to be old like me to understand that one)
LOL I love the reference. I definitely have met a couple of people that that applies to 100%.
Do you remember playing the Balata balls?
I've seen a lot of other testing that came out much different from yours on the Kirkland. A few yards shorter with more spin, but the biggest complaint was the durability. Problem for most golfers, myself included is that golf is way too expensive and most of us actually suck pretty badly at the game. Price of a cheap round of golf in my area is $50+. If you want a morning tee time on the weekend, break out $75 at a minimum. Ball price matters, especially when you might only hit it once or twice before you send it swimming or camping. I understand that we might not be playing our best golf with that ball, but most of us only get to play once or twice a month & hardly ever play our best golf anyway. Add the price of 10 lost golf balls at $3 each, then you're adding another $30 to a round that already cost $50+. Add a beer or 3 and before you know it your round of golf cost $100-$150. It's not dying on a hill for a golf ball. It's simple economics and saving money where I can allows me to play more golf if I can actually find the time.
So I agree with everything you just said. There's only one flaw in what you mentioned, the reason I created this channel was so that we could find the best performing golf balls for the money. It's one of the main target goals of the channel.
With that being said, there are many many golf balls we have tested that are actually cheaper than the Kirkland that performed twice as good. I understand value matters, and I'm in that same boat. I refuse to spend more than $35 a dozen for golf balls. However the Kirkland is my 93rd ranked golf ball. The Wilson zip on the other hand, is my number two ranked golf ball and it's a dollar a golf ball.
So what I really want all my viewers to understand is yes I understand you need value, but that doesn't mean you have to play a dog water golf ball.
@@GolfBallAddict I've never even seen that ball, but at that price, based on your recommendation, I just ordered 2 doz from Amazon for $29.97. Glad to see Wilson making a golf comeback. Them along with MacGregor were the kings of golf when I was a kid and working as a caddy, only with clubs, not balls. Titleist was king of golf balls back then too.
@@Barneyrubble241 ooooo I'm gonna order some too lol
Very interesting. But you definitely need to test the latest versions of the balls. I just turned 83, have played for over 62 years, have a 16-17 handicap I hope to lower. Obviously swing speed has declined with age. And I still play forged blades with weak lofts (34 degree 7 iron). I get carry of 190-200 and total distance of about 210-220 with an occasional 235 with my driver, so last year moved up to the 5800-6200 tees in order to have second shots into the par 4s of 110-160 yards. Also replaced my 3,4 and 5 irons with a 7 wood and 9 wood. So I have become very interested in finding a ball that will give me 5 or 10 yards more distance on drives. But like many mid-handicappers I often miss a green short or to either side and face a pitch or chip with a wedge. Make a lot of use of my 60 degree lob wedge for 20 to 50 yard pitches. Have no trouble hitting it high on to the green. But for either a full approach shot with anything from a pitching wedge to a 6 iron, and for those LW pitches, I would like to also find a ball that has a lot of greenside spin so that my shots won't roll off firm fast greens. More distance on drives, yet better stopping with irons and wedges. That's asking a lot. Usually you can get one or the other, not both.
I am a member at the PGA Super Store in Rockville, Maryland, and have taken advantage of their practice bays with overhead Foresight launch monitors to test literally dozens of different balls for hours, from the Wilson Duo and Callway Super Soft all the way up to the Pro V1X left dash. Played with them as well. And I have also closely studied the results of the My Golf Spy ball tests for lower swing speeds. Call me a weirdo golf nerd. Lately I have found that the Wilson Triad is a pretty good all around choice. Compared it with the latest Callaway Super Soft is, which is improved, gives good distance on drives, but you definitely loose 1000 rpm or more spin on wedge shots. If you rub one of them, you can feel they have a much "stickier" surface than any tour ball, no doubt to increase friction and spin, but still. I would agree with you that when I have looked at the data with many other balls, at my swing speed I definitely do not get max distance from either the Titleist ProV1 or V1x or left dash V1x, and also do not get max distance from the Bridgestone balls for swing speeds under 105, either the RX or RXS. It takes using the launch monitor to tell that, since mid-handicappers like me simply don't produce sufficiently precise and consistent results out on the course on which to base a determination.
That is quite a lot of great information. Thank you for taking the time to post it.
I agree with most of what you said. That's awesome that you get to hit in their bays and get some really good data from it. There are a lot of guys that would love to have that information
"The difference between a $1 dollar golf ball and a $3 dollar golf ball --------- is $2 dollars" Leslie Nielsen
Lol you have already made a friend on the channel and me for the comment and the Leslie Nielsen reference 😁😂
I really enjoy these videos. As a retired 74 year old losing swing speed, I’ve been trying a lot of balls. Agree with your assessments and didn’t like the Supersoft even at my swing speed . Not very forgiving. I’ve tried all the mid- 3 piece urethane balls and like the Q-Star Tour. The ball I’ve had the best luck with is the Bridgestone TreSoft. Unfortunately hard to find in the US. Meijer has stopped selling them. Still advertised on the Australian Bridgestone website. Similar to E6. Recently trying the Maxfli Tour S and Wilson Zip as I’m looking for a replacement for the Treosoft when they run out. Trying the Zio based on your video.
Thank you so much for your feedback and your assessment. Please let me know how you end up liking the zip. 😃
@@GolfBallAddict Wilson Zip wasn’t as good for me as I expected. Not bad and comparable type ball at 50 compression to my gamer. I was Looking for more distance as an 80 mph senior so I switched to a 12 degree driver and started re-testing balls. I got the best results with the Maxfli Tour S. It even out performed my old standby Bridgestone TreoSoft. I tested several balls with GPS on two different courses. They were urethane mid price and two piece lower price. The much cheaper TreoSoft was second but now is only available in Australia. That is what started me looking for a new ball. I love the Q Star Tour but driver distance was lacking by a lot. Best around the greens and accurate. I was very surprised the Maxfli Tour S performed the way it did. Long and forgiving with all clubs. Not as good around the greens for a urethane ball but rollout not bad. I’ll continue using Treosoft but will phase Maxfli Tour S in. Occasionally I use Q Star tour on shorter holes.
Nailed it! I agree with what you have presented here. And I very much like how you have said that two piece balls can be better for average and even well above average golfers than many if not most urethane covered golf balls. Most golfers aren’t going to shoot lower scores because they played a golf ball that spins more on wedges and partial wedges. They are going to shoot lower scores by playing a golf ball that goes a little further, and curves a little less in the air, like many two piece golf balls.
That is the case for many golfers. Including myself even. I've played some of my best rounds with balls like the Wilson zip and the Snell get sum. Every time I try a three or four piece tour ball it seems like I just don't play as well. Miss hits punish me and I get way more side spend on drives
Excellent and well thought review however I believe a lot of players pick their golf ball by popularity and not what performs best for them. I personally play the Callaway Supersoft because I love the feel and control on the greens. I personally prefer an orange ball because I can see it easier. The durability is amazing and I've played three rounds withe the same ball and the distance stayed consistent. I definitely agree that the Kirkland is not a good ball except for gaining strokes on your score but if it works for you as a golfer then stick with it. Again, golfers need to pick a ball that suits their game! I am a 60 year old with a 85-90 mph swing with a 9 handicap and I've changed my ball numerous times over the past 30 years to suit my game and swing. Same thing goes for my clubs, I have Taylormade, PXG, Ping and a Titleist in my bag because I find what works best for me not some PGA tour player who's getting paid and professionally fitted for his or her clubs. Life is short (just like most of my approach shots) so play more golf and have fun!
Good stuff. 😃
Loved this approach. You covered a lot of ground. Thanks for your enthusiasm and “outside the box thinking”.
Thank you very much. Appreciate the love and the loyalty when watching videos.
When I played in highschool we were given pro v1s for the last ten years that’s all I’ve played and I’ve experienced the unforgiving nature of them. However I never realized how in forgiving they were till I started playing som softer options I finally settled on the callaway chrome soft and I feel I’m a lot less stressed if I don’t hit it just right.
Chrome soft is much more forgiving. Agree 100%
heads up, i think your image for golfers that use the tp5 is off. i am pretty sure scottie doesn't use tp5. i think he uses a prov.
That being said. love the wilson zip core, been loving that recommendation and recommended it to a coworker!
Thank you for the heads up. Team Taylormade doesn't have a picture for who uses their balls exclusively. However it makes you wonder why more of them aren't playing it...
I am so glad it worked out for you! 😀
@@GolfBallAddict you would think they would want to share stuff like who uses their ball, unless they don’t have much to share?? It also makes me wonder how much do pros give up for contracts. Like are they leaving wins on the table for a paycheck with their club deals?
Played ProV1’s and TP5’s… but I’ve been playing the Vice Pro/Pro Plus and I love them.
Especially the new 2024 models. I was absolutely blown away at how amazing they performed
I’ve always been a play what I find guy, but realizing I need to play the same ball. I love the Chrome Soft and just bought my first balls in years. Also love the 360 Triple Track.
The Chrome soft / Chrome tour is definitely the best tour AAA golf ball I've tested. I love that this year they still kept the Chrome soft for loyalist as well as people who love a much softer feel.
That 360 triple track looks really good. The Chrome tour I tested a couple months ago had one and I love the look
I'm a disabled golfer, and my go-to ball is the old Titleist DT-Trusoft. I(I never lose balls) I use the Supersoft on cold Spring Days and cold Fall days. They work well for my 70MPH swing.
Yes those golf balls do wonderful on colder days. I remember those old true soft golf balls.
I heard the 2024 version is a little bit better as well, so can't wait to do a retest
How about providing a chart on your web site showing the top 3 balls for the swing speed ranges of 65 to 75 mph, 75 to 85 and 85 to 95? I'd like to see a comparison. Perhaps you could break the selected ball out by 2 piece vs. 3 piece. Please share a link if you already have this and I just didn't see it. Thank you. I love your common sense approach.
I'll probably eventually just make videos on this stuff. Probably later in the year
Really liked this video! I've been golfing (trying to golf) since I was a kid. Trying all different balls and clubs. I have found that the Noodle Long & Soft is a pretty good ball for me. I also like the Srixon. Have you done any testing on the Noodle line? I would be interested in seeing you review of them.
The Noodle tested ok for me but there are plenty of people who love them. I really enjoy the Srixon Soft feel and the Wilson Duo Soft
I can’t wait to get my swing speed checked and begin my process of finding the right golf ball for me using your channel as a guide.
Hey that's awesome. As soon as you get it checked shoot me an email and we'll get some recommendations
Ive only been praying for 5 months i started in April this year and always chose the cheaper balls because of course i was gonna lose a lot of balls while playing, but i played a whole round with the pro v1 yesterday August 25th and shot 95, and i have been using I've tried Calloway and because i know i haven't developed a great swing yet but always shoot around 105 to 115. So far my best round taking 10 to 20 strokes off my game has been Pro V1. I'm not great and i know it but i play for results of getting better and will surely look for more forgiven balls.
I'm glad you pick the game up and are enjoying it. I wish you the best of luck out there and hope you always have low scores and great times.
140-145 ball speed for driver, slice sometimes and would like some forgiveness (15 hcp). I play the AVX but not sure it makes sense. What are some you’d recommend I check out? Thank you!!
I would still stay with the two piece since the golf balls have advanced in technology so much and they will help get you to the single digit category. Like I said before check out that video I think you'll like it 😁
I am probably a below average golfer with a slower swing speed. Yet I play the Bridgestone BRX. I know that they do not maximize distance but they have a urethane cover so are very durable and they STAY on line. Plus I’ve been able to get them at $39 most of the time. The e6 has too little spin around the greens. Just my opinion FWIW
I would recommend checking out some of my reviews on the channel. There are Urethane golf balls that can help your distance
So I have a slower swing speed but my smash factor on all the clubs is in the 1.4 range. As a perfectly average golfer, I lose maybe a ball or two a round. MyGolfSpy’s ball test found low compression was less important. I play a 3 piece (Snell when I have them, Supersoft when not) and recently tried TM tour stripe. I definitely think feel around the green is most important and I like soft “feel.” Do you think a Chromesoft is worth it? When do you think it’s time to “move up” to a 4 piece ball?
So I do disagree with the lower compression argument, but that's for a different day. Let me try to answer your question the best I can.
To start off, yes the Chrome soft would be a good ball. It's lower compression allows for tour like feel for people who have average swing speeds. So it's definitely worth a try. I also love the vice ProAir for this too. Little bit better of a value.
As far as when to move up to a four-piece golf ball, it kind of depends because all four piece golf balls are different and have different compressions. But in my experience, I would say about 85% of 4-Piece golf balls are even too firm for me to compress at 98 mph. Four piece territory is usually 105 mph or greater.
Thays why 90% of average golfers will never get better. They're not open to the idea of other options and not just golf balls. You wouldn't believe how may average golfers play with blades!!
Oh it blows my mind. And an absolutely makes me sick to my stomach. I have so many coworkers and Friends who are trying to get better and shoot below 90, and they're buying these $1,700 unforgiving blades. Honestly I'm at a point where I don't care how good I get I don't see myself ever getting blades. I'll take the forgiveness all day everyday
Not just play them but I always see comments of "you suck and only hit a 8i x distance because your playing game improvement" like are they legal? Yes. Then leave people alone man if you want more distance buy those irons if you want the blade feel buy those but don't criticize others for buying what fits them lol golf egos are a wild thing lol
Have you rated the Wilson Staff Duo Soft for us grumpy old 75 mph guys? Longer than others IMHO.
I have. It's an amazing golf ball and the feedback from consumers has been nothing short of incredible.
I am new to golf. This is my second season. I was happy to see a list of balls I don't need to rush to try out. But the Costco balls, that is different for me. I just don't want to care if I lose a ball. Costco balls are cheap to learn on imo. Do you have another balls as good and cheap to learn this game on. I swing slow and am +50 years old.
Great question and I sure do.
The cut red golf balls are a dollar a piece and are available at Walmart and target.
The Wilson zip, my number two ranked golf ball, is also around a dollar a golf ball and available at Walmart and Amazon
And honestly I know this one sounds weird. But the top flight XL distance can be either at a dollar golf ball or even a little cheaper and it's not bad for a beginner. I actually had pretty decent results with it
Another great option is the maxfli soft fli.
And finally off the top of my head, the Pinnacle soft.
All these are great options and are about a dollar a golf ball
Great video as always! Played with a 115 swing speed player who played the Kirkland ball. I had a couple extra Chrome Tour's and gave to him as I only swing 85 and couldn't use them. What a difference he felt. I even saw MGS said Kirkland is the worst ball in golf this week. Looking forward to when/if you do the SpeedSoft vs Q Star Tour review. Those are the 2 balls I have in bag and am having a very hard time settling on one. Yoru help would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you so much for the feedback. That's actually a really good comparison. Wouldn't mind doing that myself.
@@GolfBallAddict I'd like to see that one too.
Played with a buddy this past weekend. He was excited to try the KS balls he just got. It was the first time all summer i was out driving him and it was by 15 to 20 yards. That spinny property kills distance for KS balls.
Same result I got. Absolute massive amounts of distance lost from both the V2 and the V3 with the kirkland.
Typical 19 HDCP'r: "I PLAY DEEZ BALLZ CUZ TIGER DOES" 😅 Odd that the Callway Supersoft makes this list but the Chrome Soft, made it to your top 10! I play A LOT of those Bridgestone Tourballs and Prov1s because that's what I find hunting for my recycled Wilson Prostaffs in the woods LOL.
Lol for sure. I love the old Chrome soft. The new one will take a big hit
I have had ProV1's in my bag because they are the ones I most find in the trees. I give them away. It's like hitting a stone.
I mean you find them everywhere. It's crazy to me that if you find a ball in the woods there's a 50% chance it's a pro v1. Especially with over 150 different golf ball makers
@@GolfBallAddict As you say, the power of marketing.
I give the Pro v1’s away too. Just wish someone was giving me Maxfli Tour S’s back or the MF Tour but there aren’t too many to be found in my area as the nearest Dick’s is an hour away.
I just found this channel and I’m quite pleasantly surprised! I’ve played Titleist since the days of the old Tour Professional and Tour Balata and the ProV1 from when it debuted with a slight detour to (wonky) Chrome Tour & Z-star! Still play the pro v1 but I got a deal (in the UK) on Tour Golds & new Z star and having JUST turned 65 but still playing to a decent level, when they’re starting to run out I’ll have to be looking for a new ball! My wife plays & loves her supersofts, she suffers from RA so I might have to look for another ball for her! I’m the golf tech geek not her! Edit to add, I tried the kirkland 2.0 and it WAS rubbish! I wouldn’t even use it as a Winter ball! Gave the rest away to my son in law who is starting golf!
LOL awesome. Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience 😃
✳️ I discovered the Taylormade Soft Response a great ball for the price in the mid price range ✅ it’s a 3 piece low compression ball at 50 suitable for most players who swing it less than 100mph for the driver ✳️
That's a good golf ball but I wish the numbers have performed a little bit better.
I think any ball that sells for more than $30/dozen is overrated. Every ball should sell for around $1/ball...period...especially for the millions of mid-to-high handicappers who lose balls a lot more often than the really good golfers.
That's a completely reasonable take. It's one of the reasons I made the channel.
I've hit a lot of golf balls in my day. This is great info. Titleist does make a good ball but way over priced and overrated . I actually really like that Bridgestone e6 soft.
Thank you very much. I appreciate you taking the time to comment and watch.
I'm getting ready to test the new Bridgestone lineup and I've heard really good things. Hoping they make a jump 😃
Im a mid HC and i want to play a urethane cover golf ball ! Im currently playing the chrome soft. What are your thoughts on the new chrome tour ? Sounds like I might have to check out the Vice Pro line ?
Definitely check out my top 20 golf ball list.
I do like the Chrome tour but I think the Chrome soft has a better performance overall. Will need to be tested for sure. The vice line is definitely worth a shot
@GolfBallAddict Thanks ! Will do. 🏌♂️
I always played 2 piece balls because that's what the "Internet" says I should play because I have a slow swing speed (~85mph w/driver) and high handicap (21). A few months ago I found a ProV1 on the 5th hole and decided to play it the rest of the round. I had some of the longest and best hits I've ever had. So I decided to buy a dozen and I feel like I play a lot better with them. I'm getting more distance, accuracy, and getting the ball to stop on the green. My local shop sells used, excellent condition, ProV1s for $15/dozen. So I'm going to stick with them since I play better with them and they're cheaper than most 2 piece balls out there.
I'll have to definitely take your word for it. I would encourage somehow to try a golf ball fitting. I mean if it isn't broke don't fix it, but it wouldn't be the first time someone has swore up and down to me that they played better with the Pro V1 and then after the fitting was done they found four or five golf balls that give them better numbers. It never hurts to try it just to see if something performs a little better
Thank you so much for your feedback though, as well as watching and commenting. It helps the video and channel a lot 😁😃
I get the best overall performance from the rest of my Project A golf balls but I hear the tour response is not as good and they upped the price quite a bit. I received a free box of Titleist tour speed and loved them for the distance but could not hold the firm greens. I might look into the Srixon's next. The Q Star Tour might be right for me at age 65. Thanks for your perspective from the average golfer point of view.
Anytime. Thank you so much for taking the time to watch and comment. It means the world to me.
That's not the first time I've heard that people like the project a better. I wish I could have done a direct comparison
New to the channel do you tink the float test Bryson does has merit?
Great question. Here are some of my thoughts without testing it for myself:
I am sure it works. It makes sense from a science standpoint.
However, I am also worried that some will use it as an excuse. Most average players probably wont notice minor imbalances.
I will definitely be doing a test of my own soon!
I greatly appreciate your honesty and after hearing your review I’ll definitely think twice before just buying Pro-Vs
It's always worth a try to see if anything else fits your needs. Fitting is key.
Thank you so much!😁
I somewhat agree with some on your list, but I do believe that if you "think" the ball you play is the best ball for you then that is 90% of the battle won, confidence when u stand over a ball means a lot more then it is given credit for IMO.
I definitely agree with you on the confidence. However that's why I recommend ball fitting so much.
My thing is, you can be playing the worst golf ball on the planet and be confident in it. I was playing the tp5 back in the day and thought I was hot stuff because I was playing a five-layer ball with tons of spin. However it wasn't until I lost my final one on the course and had to switch to a Duo soft to just finish the round. When I all of a sudden got 20 yards more distance, and pard 4 of the 5 last holes, that's when I knew something was up. That kind of propelled me to start the channel also.
Pretty solid list. I think TP5s and ProV1s definitely dont work for the average golfer but are fantastic if you’re single digit or below. I was surprised at Supersoft because I feel for value and performance they are great for the average golfer. Same with Kirklands, hard to beat for the value. 😂
Thank you very much. I agree with you on the tour balls for sure.
See the thing is, we are about 4 years in and I reviewed over $120 golf balls. What I am trying to now preach, is that we have tested many golf balls that are cheaper and perform better than both the Callaway super soft and the Kirkland signature. Yes the price on those golf balls are a good value, but like I said I have ones I've tested that are cheaper and go farther and spin more
Thanks so much for taking the time to watch and comment. It means a lot 😃
I agree about the pro v1. I never seem to get them going
I did a Titleist ball fitting at golf show and was advised the pro v1x would be better for me as it spins more and id get a higher flight.
I'm working my way through my 2 dozen Kirkland signature V2 at the moment and I've been very happy with them. Probably won't try the V3 after watching this
I just can't handle the lack of forgiveness from the vx.
I have a friend that I play with regularly and he swears on the ProV1. He has only broken 100 a couple of times and I cannot get him off of the ProV1 for the same reason you mentioned in this video. I just want him to try something else to see if he likes it better or if it plays better because I want his game to improve and I'm wondering if the ProV1 is slowing down his gains. He absolutely will not even entertain the idea.
There are people like that. Please recommend this video to him. I know it's hard for people when they like something and they don't like change, but at least do a golf ball fitting. You never know you the worst case scenario you just stick with what you have but you might find you like something better
Just because they have great vodka and cheap hot dogs, doesn’t mean they have great golf balls.
LOL nothing quite hits like a $1.50 hot dog and drink combo
Genuine question, you said all Taylormade balls, what’s your opinion on Noodles? As a beginner golfer these are my go to for cheap balls, since I generally lose them quickly haha
They are ok. I prefer the Precept Laddie or the Pinnacle though.
@@GolfBallAddict cool! I give those a shot, thank you!
So which ball do you suggest for a 9 handicapper 66 year old with a 91mph ?
I would check out some of my recent reviews. Vice air, wright and ditson, legato, etc
I absolutely love playing the tp5x. What's interesting is last weekend I tried the srixon z star for 36 holes and I was incredibly impressed.
I absolutely love the z-star line. Really excited to try the new models.
Golfball is not overrated if you get what you need from it.. I can't find any other golf ball that gives me the feeling if I clip this correctly it's going to stop beside the pin other than a pro v then the putter feel to match ..it's a win ,win for me! It's all personal choice but never overrated..⛳️
@birdieboy Finally someone with a sensible comment using their ball of choice for the correct reasons.
How can a ball (Kirkland) that costs $1.13 ea. be overrated? Makes no sense to me.
Because tens of thousands of people play it. Yet it has been proven not only by the human test, ergo me, and also by robotic testing, today's golfer, that it is just a mediocre golf ball that spends way too much and loses way too much distance. For the same price, actually a little cheaper, you could be playing a golf ball that is top five in distance and forgiveness.
Just because something is cheap doesn't mean it can't be overrated.
Can’t stand Bridgestone Ball names Either,Too confusing !!!
Overtime I've learned them just from having to say them over and over on the channel. But my goodness it's like the Nike balls back in the day. Every year they came out with five new names and it was impossible to identify them.
You’re simply the Best Ball Critic,Analysts Period !!❤️
@@GolfBallAddict Marketing Depts Suspect ,polite Word!!!
Will always be a WILSON guy. I hope they will still be making the ZIP well into 2025.😸
Look at their website I love the zip too and I don't see it on there looks like the revamped the value balls selection
@@Niftte Some Walmart's carry the ZIP.😸
I love wilson. I took a look at their new blades and even though I can't hit them I absolutely adore them. I almost want to get really good at golf just so I can buy them LOL
I emailed Wilson a few months ago asking why the Zip was removed from their website, and their response was because it's been discontinued. I think they just had a lot of stock is why walmart and amazon still sell them. My local walmart was out of them for about a year, but they have them now.
You're right, they are marketing geniuses! Many want to FEEL like a Tour Pro so they buy them even though it doesn't suit their gamee at all. I'm a 19 handicap and I play the Taylor Made Soft Response the majority of the time. I also really like Srixon balls! Not sure if they really suit my game but I like the Softfeel and QStar.
If you like that soft response be sure to check out the speed soft as well. I have really good results with that.
Also love the take. All the golf balls you mentioned have at least tested good or better. So I think you're on a great track
Hello. Love the Channel! I just started playing golf less than two years ago (Long-time Tournament tennis player). I assume my swing speed is in the low to mid 80s. I have been using the Callaway SuperSoft and I'm reasonable happy. Two quick questions - How do I know which year they were manufactured? Also... I have a box of the ERC Soft that I have never used. Might they be a better option? Thanks!
The ERC is a good option but keep in mind it is for a little bit advanced player. If you find yourself shooting in the 80s it's a good ball but if you're still shooting 90s to 100s I would stick to two piece.
As far as being able to tell the model, it's all about the alignment tool. Go on calloway's website to see what the current alignment tool looks like and compare it to what you have. From there you can kind of Google and see which model for each year and what they had
I d say try the Wilson duo soft the red ones
What about the Maxfli tour? I’ve played them for years and I really like them.
Great timing. That's actually the golf balls were testing right now. Just did the tour the other day and the tour s. The x model is coming up next
I'd get a kick out of you reviewing golf balls which are not USGA conforming ....MG Senior, Polara, Bandit, etc...Might not be in your wheel house but, would still enjoy a non partial review...Personally, I love the MG Senior ball...
I have no problem reviewing golf balls that are not USGA approved. For average golfers, who cares? I have a couple of those you mentioned ready to be tested just haven't done them yet
The PRO V1 is definitely overrated. I personally like the Callaway Supersoft, I like the spin it produces with my irons, I put a lot of spin on my iron shots. What ball would you recommend for 6 HCP with speed 100-110?
Right now, I loved the vice pro Plus, Snell 4.0, Mizuno tour x, oncore Vero X2, and maxfli tour x for that swing speed. All worth a try and all not going to break the bank
Taylor Made distance plus spins good for me and I get good distance too, the three piece Callaway ERC Soft is also a great balls .
Good stuff. Thank you so much for taking the time to watch the video and share your feedback with others 😁
I find it ironic that the super soft by Callaway are supposed to be higher handicap friendly, but you find a lot of them in the woods. I'm not a low handicapper. I can't hit the pro v1 or x to save my ass.
LOL it's definitely a golf ball for higher handicaps, however for the people who are spraying multiple balls into the woods in the round, I would recommend more like a top flight probably. The XL is long and straight and they're only like 50 cents of golf ball lol
I can’t remember when I bought ProV1. With a 12 HDCP, I’m not good enough to get the best out of that ball.
Absolutely. I'm in the same boat and I am around an 8 handicap. Most of the time I can get a decent hit but boy if I miss hit it I'm in trouble
I agree with you, kirkland golf balls I never like and titleist over priced. I tried the Wright and ditson and even with slower swing speed they still got good distance. Next one I going to try is the legato golf ball.
Thank you so much for sharing your feedback. That's awesome I'm so glad you like the wright and ditson. Please let me know how you like the legato.
I switched to the Wilson Zip after watching this show carefully. I’m 73, hit a proV about 200-215 off the tee. I’m out there 220-230 with the Wilson consistently, like I was hitting it 10 years ago. I love the feel of compressing the ball again. Plus I bought two dozen on Amazon for $30 all in.
That's awesome. There have been so many people that love the Wilson zip. It's hard not to give it such amazing praise consistently
Then what is the best ball for a slower swing speed?
Wilson zip, Snell get sum or 2.0. Pinnacle soft and rush are really good. Maxfli straight fli and soft fli as well
Yep, that list is a great starting point for slow swing speeds. Good job on your posts! @@GolfBallAddict Yep,
63 y/o, swing speed low 90s, and 14 hdcp. I play some Kirkland driven by price. I don’t see a drop in distance, but hate them in the short game- too hard. My go to Chrome soft, also like some Bridgesetones and Taylor Made.
Thank you so much for your comment and for watching. I would recommend the same thing I said in the video, feel free to check out the top 10. I promise you can find something better than that Kirkland
Bridgestone E6 soft was awesome! I’ve tried almost all the Bridgestone after, didn’t like any. Love the channel, I’ve tried a lot of golf balls because of the channel. Really like Vice pro and Chrome Soft!
Thank you very much for taking the time to comment and for your kind words. They mean the world to me 😃
I haven’t done much research into balls, but I like playing chrome softs, I actually have a fairly high swing speed, but i’m also an inconsistent striker. I’m wondering if I made a mistake now trying a box of supersofts. I haven’t put them into play yet.
Thank you so much for your comment and for watching.
Don't worry, it is never a mistake to try out a golf ball. The worst thing that could happen is you don't like them.
With that being said, I do think you will overcompress them a little bit. You might lose some driver distance but you'll love the feel and forgiveness with the irons. It's a give and take.
I too love Chrome softs. They're one of the most fastest, best forgiving tour balls I've tested.
I am a golf ball snob. Titleist Pro-V1 and Pro-V1x. Taylor Made TP5 and TP5X. Occasionally I will find Titleist with a members initials. I like to give them back in the locker room.
That's nice of you. Not too many people would do that
First time watching your videos. I gave up on the prov's years ago. I'm in my 50's and also a 9 handicap with a 101 driver swing speed. I actually have enjoyed the Wilson Duo's. Cheaper and just as good as most other balls. The only other ball I tested myself was better for my sing was Vice Pro's.
There's a good chance you might be losing a little bit of distance off the driver with the Wilson Duo, however for the majority of your other clubs you're probably doing just fine. If you love that feel, which I understand why you do because Wilson golf balls feel phenomenal, then just stick with it. I've heard people tell me the Wilson triad is a great three-piece model but I didn't have very much luck when I tested it the first time
@@GolfBallAddict The put-off for me is the price of the Triad. I thought it was ok as I liked the new Duo 2.5's better. And for the price why not. If Wilson didn't do the buy 2 get 1 free from their Staff ball earlier this year, I would have bought several dozen of Vice Pro soft's. I either will play the Wilson or Vice, depending on who has good sales at the end of the year.... :)
😂😂😂😂I was ok until you turned on supersoft. Played that as a beginner and helped me get my handicap down. I only out grew the ball when I was approaching a single figure handicap. For me it was long off the tee and ok on approach shots. Hence, continued to play it.
Tried Kirkland recently, might be ok with pitching shots but, lost loads of distance off the tee and with irons.
It’s fine for tough courses where I don’t mind losing balls.
The super soft is fine. But my goodness I'm just tired of finding a gazillion of them at work. No lie at one point I had over a hundred of them that I found from work and only a matter of a couple months. Insane 😂
Recent tests by Club Champion of the Kirkland 3.0 ball for those with a 115-120 SS found it to be very much like the ProV1. It may be great for the higher SS golfers but not for your speed or slower.
That's good to know! It doesn't surprise me with how firm it is, but I still think it's a huge mistake from kirkland. The majority of their market is budget golfers who swing average swing speed. In order to get that type of swing speed at 115 to 120 mph you are talking about a very select group of individuals. I think it limits their market too much, but hey that's just my two cents.
Great...at last some common sense. So many have sold their souls to marketing. Keep up the good work.
Thank you very much. I appreciate the kind comment
The most engineered piece of tech created to date is the tire that why I usually go with Bridgestone I just assume they put insane energy into their designs
Oh absolutely. Keep in mind that tiger woods loved their engineering so much when they were making the Nike balls that he just stuck with them even after Nike quit.
Yes my swing is same 95 mph avg and Handicap is currently 8.4. The balls I dont care for are the Mizuno RB Tour balls. Srixons lack pop for my swing speed. I love all the new 3 Callaway Ball Line. I have used the Chrome Tour X, Chrome Tour and the new Chrome Soft are all great. Titleist ProV1 and ProV1X are great, but I feel I sacrifice some distance compared to all the new Callaway Balls. I have mixed emotions on the Taylor Made. Used to be my go to ball. I do like the new TP5 but dont love it. Agree Bridgestone Balls are not very good. That new green dot thing is lame and looks bad on a ball. Never tried the new Wilson balls or MaxFli Balls. I am finding recently that I am preferring the softer feeling golf balls
I too am a big callaway fan. Love the improvements they have made over the last two years.
@@GolfBallAddict Yes same here. They have done a great job
Vice Pro Plus is my ball of choice. Great soft feel, great distance and the feel with my pitch shots is great. Forgiving ball with performance of more expensive balls. My launch monitor shows better numbers than the ProV1
Completely agree with all of that. It's one of my favorites of 2024 so far
Right now I'm liking the srixon q star tour . Lost some yardage on my drives but iron play is golden.
That means you probably have a faster swing speed, but I one hundred percent agree with you about the iron play. *chefs kiss*
We got a Costco last year, so I bought the 2 dozen pack and it didn’t take long to learn that was a mistake
Yeah I'm not really sure what they're trying to do with their golf balls. I don't think they do either
Love the Wilson Triad - 3 pc cast urethane, great distance and soft/spinny around the green. Perfect ball for me.
Appreciate you sharing your feedback. I didn't have much luck with the Triad but I have had dozens of people asking for a re-review after they had the opposite results. I cannot wait to retest it now.
My favorite is the Bridgestone e6 (29 y.o with 82mph 7iron swing speed)
The e6 performs really well for me. I like it also. We have a similar swing speed
saying what others think but not afraid to put it on video! great video
Thank you very much for the kind feedback. Appreciate you so much
Have you done OnCore golf ball?
Sure have. I have done the whole lineup except for the Vero XP
lol, found a Taylor made in the rough a couple feet from the fairway last weekend, gave it a go, figured out that the previous guy didn’t lose it, he just left it like a giant turd because it was terrible. Felt like I was hitting a perfectly round rock. I’m a 12 hc with driver swing speed 108.
Lol. Yeah TaylorMade has a very specific "feel" just like Titleist does. I just am not in love with it.
I’m older golfer, 60, I swing the club 110-125.
Other than cheap balls, the only place on the course where balls matter too much is around the greens.
Holy cow. You are driving the ball 300-350 yards at 60 years old? that's awesome!
I try a lot of balls, most I find! For me, a 71 year old mid handicapper the Taylor Made Tour Response Strip is the ball. The paint stripe in the middle seem to allow the ball to stay straight. The Pro V1, Wilson Staff, New Callaway Tour are all good performers. I keep going back to the TM TR. Play what you love! Good stuff Nick! Thanks
Thank you so much for sharing your feedback and your experiences. We really appreciate it! 😁😃
I'm in love with the 2022/23 Wilson Staff Model ball
Love the Wilson staff. Can't wait to retest
over the last year, me and my 88mph driver speed have tried chrome soft, tour soft, snell black, and tp5. not a bit of difference between any of them, except price.
Is this a course test or is this with a launch monitor and data?
@@GolfBallAddict on the golf course over a 12 month or so time frame.
Nice video. Golf ball addict rocks!
Thank you so much. 💵🔥💯💲⛳🏌️♂️😁💰🏎️
10 hcp, 80 mph swing speed. i play a callaway supersoft/chromesoft. ive tried a a couple tour level balls, tp5 prov1 etc but they all.seem a bit firm to me? plus, the cost is outrageous.
Chromesoft is a great tour ball for mid swingers. I had really good results. I agree on the pricing. It has gotten insane.
I am a big fan of the TM SpeedSoft Ink. Good feel and distance. And the price is decent.
I am too. There's been so much positive feedback from my viewers on that golf ball. I absolutely love it
I have 4 dozen Kirks and after watching my best drives go a 150 yes and then drop like a rock I switched balls. Still trying to find the best ball for me😢
Hey that's okay. It happens. Please stick around on the channel and I promise you'll find something you like 😁
Every time i find a kirkland golf ball i usually throw it back in the hazard or pack it to save for someone else whos prolly gonna lose it after 3 stokes. I like costco but not that much to be a brand idiot 😂
It's funny, people at work now know how much I dislike it, so every time someone leaves one in a cart, which feels like a hundred times a day. They try to give it to me and I throw it in the garbage LOL
I *really* wanted to like the Kirkland ball, but it gets marked and cut so quickly, any benefit in price is soon forgotten. Bridgestone balls I've found to be as good as any, YMMV.
The 2024 Bridgestone lineup should be getting a review soon. I've had lots of reports of the new ones being even better than the old ones
By the way, you do not support your local Pro Shop buying the Kirkland’s.
This is actually a really great point that I think is underrated. A lot of people, including myself, don't think about this.
I'd rather not support my club pro. £50k retainer, free shop, contributes nothing.
@@MichaelParker-zs5ylI used to belong to a club where a lot of members did not support the club, in the pro shop or in the restaurant. It is now bankrupt.