@@HariKrishnanK-gv8lx bro thinma niranja lokam alla Allahu srishtichath. nanmayum thinmayum cheyyan choice ulla world aanu srishtichath. athil thinma athikarikkam, chelappo nanma athikarikkam. oru period off time ethiyal avrde deeds nu anusarichollath ororutharkk kodukkum. And ippo Allahu aa thinma cheyyunnath ethirthal pne avde choice illa manushyan. angane vannal pne avde good deeds nu reward kodukkunnathil arthamilla
@@HariKrishnanK-gv8lxgood argument. but njn paranjath why there have to be a "possibility" to do evil. ex: madyam illatha oru place il njn madyabikkilla ennu parayanath is neither good nor bad. but njn madyabikkilla ennath oru good deed aavanamenkil there must have a "possibility" to drink. meaning evil cheyyanmennilla good enthanu define cheyyan. evil cheyyanulla possibility mathi
കുട്ടികളുടെ അസ്ഥി flexible ആണു. അതുകൊണ്ട് ചെറിയ വീഴ്ചകൾ ഒക്കെ അസ്ഥി ഒടിയാതെ അത് തരണം ചെയ്യാൻ കഴിയും. ഇത് പടച്ചവൻ കുട്ടികളിൽ ചെയ്തു വെച്ചിരിക്കുന്ന ഒരു കാര്യമാണ്. അപ്പോ നിരീശ്വര വാദികൾ അതിനെ law of nature എന്ന് പറയും. അതുപോലെ തന്നെയാണ് പൊള്ളൽ ഏൽകുന്ന കാര്യം. ഇനി കാര്യമായി പൊള്ളൽ ഏൽക്കാത്ത വിധം ആയിരുന്നു കുട്ടികളുടെ ശരീരം എങ്കിൽ അതും law of nature ആയേനെ.
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, "By the One in Whose Hand my soul is! If you do not commit sins, Allah would replace you with a people who would commit sins and seek forgiveness from Allah; and Allah will certainly forgive them."
Considering the points discussed, one might argue that paradise would be a dull and stagnant place, lacking opportunities for growth or acts of goodness, since there is no presence of evil to overcome. How would you respond to this?
Paradise is entirely different from Dunya. Evil and suffering exist ചെയ്യുക എന്ന ലക്ഷ്യത്തിന് അല്ലല്ലോ Paradise. Its only for our enjoyment. A payment for our good deeds.
Good question We didn’t say suffering of innocents is inherently good , it’s a means to some necessary Goods , once it’s purpose is fulfilled it’s no longer required , just like we see at the end of a fantastic movie “They lived happily ever after “ Heaven is not an alternative to this world, it’s a continuation so the effects and memories of the evil and how they tackled them remains and Hopefully that would in increase the sweetness of the eternal bliss
God's omnipotence does not preclude him from inducing a state of eternal bliss in his creations, if he so wishes. Inducing such a state of eternal bliss is not a logical contradiction, for him to not be able to do such a thing. Paradise is exactly the place where Allah grants eternal bliss because that is his will. The Earth on the other hand, has been willed by God to be a place of test. A test inherently requires the relative framework of Victory and failure, of Goodness and evil, of Suffering and bliss to have any meaning. Thus the very nature of deriving bliss by attempting to alleviate the suffering of others in the world is rendered redundant by Allah in the structure of the afterlife. There is no meaning in such endeavours anymore, since the window of opportunities, as well as the window of committing mistakes have been exhausted. It is the time and place to reap the benefits of what we have sowed. And Allah grants our fill without an iota of injustice, and he causes that state to prevail.
Sahih Muslim 2749 Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) having said: By Him in Whose Hand is my life, if you were not to commit sin, Allah would sweep you out of existence and He would replace (you by) those people who would commit sin and seek forgiveness from Allah, and He would have pardoned them.
No response to natural evil, simply said it is necessary, dont think it is satisfying. 2.why would anyone need free will over goodness. 3. Free will can be given between two moral acts also without the requirement of evil, If you say free will is complete only with evil in this world,, and when we say god can restrict evil act after choosing it,,,You said if god restricts the evil act when someone does it, then eventually no one will do it. Then why does god create reward and punishment for the acts human does? And if someone doesn't do any evil or immoral act , then is it because of the fear of hell and free will is not fully free in that sense too? ....... what u need is the capacity of free will without actualizing the evil or wrong act. It can be accomplished in that way with god restricting the act.
1. Why is “ natural “ things are evil.. do they have free will to change it to good?? 2.because that is the base a test, “ who is good in deeds” for that you need freewill good and evil 3. Consider like this there is no evil , one is lesser good ( you identify as evil) and one is greater good 4. “Choosing” hell or heaven itself is free will dude , free will does mean ability to choose 5 . If you are not doing wrong how do you distinguish a person who does good ??
@sarifmuhammed 1. Do u agree evil exist in this world ?, then what is the explanation for evil occurring in this world which is not caused by will ,but happened naturally. 2. Why would a omniscient being put a test for ? and why would he put anyone to heaven or hell based on it And what kind of test of it ? Is god checking the quality of a person by his decision, then the qualities are predefined by god only, or if he is checking what is his choices in this world,,, then again how is that a big deal , because if given another chance that choices could change. 3. I mentioned 3rd point to the free will defense made by apologetics .. that there won't be free will if god allow only good , to that I made the response u can have free will with good alone. 4. You are not choosing hell or heaven directly , it is decided by the tests score as apologists say. This too I was responding to another response...... 5. Why u need to distinguish ? and if the person is having free will , even the person who does good can do wrong at any time , if he can't then he is not free ....
@@christhomas7091 1. I do agree that “evil” in this world is something which human intentionally do, eg: earthquake, is not evil, it is a natural process to shape the world we see, there is nothing evil in die in earthquake, but bombing and killing is evil, since there is intention/free will behind it. 2. Test for us to acknowledge and know why I am in that position, Eg: college give you test, not for the benefit of college instead to benefit and assess yourself. 3. It should be distinguishable and judge able, else there is no test, whether you call it evil, or absence of Good, or lesser good does not matter. 4. Yes, it is test, you may fail or pass in a n exam, based on your choices , that is upto you to choose which one you want 5. No, we follow virtue ethics, there, intention matters than consequences , and GOD is well aware about your intention and actions, which is well distinguishable to GOD to judge, and give justice, no other normative ethics has that scenario
@sarifmuhammed someone dying in earthquake is not evil ? Then what is it good or just an event... or u don't consider any horrific event as evil if it is not caused by will, then no question Rest all are not good response to the points I raised
@@christhomas7091 it is not , why it is evil? If that is evil , killing for food is also evil, do you agree? Survival itself is evil, you are killing millions of bacterias while bathing and brushing your teeth, is that evil? intention and freewill matters in “evil” dude.
Masha Allah..
ഈ subject ഇൽ ഇത്ര broad and convincing explanation ആദ്യമായി യാണ് കേൾക്കുന്നത്..
Well said.
True
Alhamdulillah
രണ്ടുപേരും തീ കട്ടയാ ആണ്
മാഷാ അല്ലാഹ് ബർക്കത്ത് ചെയ്യട്ടെ
അമീൻ
Aameen
Clear and logical explanation
Wow... Wonderful conclusion 🙌🏻
Masha Allah 😍. Great job , most convincing explanation on this particular subject.
❤TEAM UA❤
Good words ❤
എത്ര കൃത്യം എന്നാലും നിരീശ്വരവാദികൾ വന്നു എല്ലാത്തിന്റെയും അടിയിൽ വന്നു മോങ്ങും ദൈവം ഉണ്ടായിരുന്നേൽ ഇവിടെ തിന്മ ഉണ്ടാവുമായിരുന്നോ എന്നു
@@HariKrishnanK-gv8lxvideo onnude kaanuu mister
@@HariKrishnanK-gv8lx 1000 years munp Islamic philosophers um theologiansum ithin best Answers koduthu kainjaayi athaan innum ningale vilamubunnath.
@@HariKrishnanK-gv8lx bro thinma niranja lokam alla Allahu srishtichath.
nanmayum thinmayum cheyyan choice ulla world aanu srishtichath. athil thinma athikarikkam, chelappo nanma athikarikkam. oru period off time ethiyal avrde deeds nu anusarichollath ororutharkk kodukkum. And ippo Allahu aa thinma cheyyunnath ethirthal pne avde choice illa manushyan. angane vannal pne avde good deeds nu reward kodukkunnathil arthamilla
@@HariKrishnanK-gv8lx ക്ലബ് ഹൗസിൽ Sunni voice എന്നൊരു റൂമുണ്ട് താങ്കൾക്ക് സ്വാഗതം. അവിടെ കയറിയിരുന്ന് എന്തു സംശയങ്ങളും ചോദിക്കാം.
@@HariKrishnanK-gv8lxgood argument. but njn paranjath why there have to be a "possibility" to do evil. ex: madyam illatha oru place il njn madyabikkilla ennu parayanath is neither good nor bad. but njn madyabikkilla ennath oru good deed aavanamenkil there must have a "possibility" to drink. meaning evil cheyyanmennilla good enthanu define cheyyan. evil cheyyanulla possibility mathi
Very convincing ❤❤❤
കുട്ടികളുടെ അസ്ഥി flexible ആണു. അതുകൊണ്ട് ചെറിയ വീഴ്ചകൾ ഒക്കെ അസ്ഥി ഒടിയാതെ അത് തരണം ചെയ്യാൻ കഴിയും. ഇത് പടച്ചവൻ കുട്ടികളിൽ ചെയ്തു വെച്ചിരിക്കുന്ന ഒരു കാര്യമാണ്. അപ്പോ നിരീശ്വര വാദികൾ അതിനെ law of nature എന്ന് പറയും. അതുപോലെ തന്നെയാണ് പൊള്ളൽ ഏൽകുന്ന കാര്യം. ഇനി കാര്യമായി പൊള്ളൽ ഏൽക്കാത്ത വിധം ആയിരുന്നു കുട്ടികളുടെ ശരീരം എങ്കിൽ അതും law of nature ആയേനെ.
Mind-blowing explanation. 👌
Great ❤️. Samad 🤝 Shanu
و عليكم سَّلاَمُ وَرَحْمَةُ اللّٰهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ*
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, "By the One in Whose Hand my soul is! If you do not commit sins, Allah would replace you with a people who would commit sins and seek forgiveness from Allah; and Allah will certainly forgive them."
Great narration and definitions
Subahanallah ❤
Shanukaa 💕
Masha Allah ❤
Masha allah❤
❤
Masha allah
Very clister and clear
നല്ല അവതരണം❤❤
Good explanation
Good one
👍
Considering the points discussed, one might argue that paradise would be a dull and stagnant place, lacking opportunities for growth or acts of goodness, since there is no presence of evil to overcome. How would you respond to this?
Paradise is entirely different from Dunya.
Evil and suffering exist ചെയ്യുക എന്ന ലക്ഷ്യത്തിന് അല്ലല്ലോ Paradise. Its only for our enjoyment. A payment for our good deeds.
Good question
We didn’t say suffering of innocents is inherently good , it’s a means to some necessary Goods , once it’s purpose is fulfilled it’s no longer required , just like we see at the end of a fantastic movie “They lived happily ever after “
Heaven is not an alternative to this world, it’s a continuation so the effects and memories of the evil and how they tackled them remains and Hopefully that would in increase the sweetness of the eternal bliss
Jazakallah khair❤
God's omnipotence does not preclude him from inducing a state of eternal bliss in his creations, if he so wishes. Inducing such a state of eternal bliss is not a logical contradiction, for him to not be able to do such a thing. Paradise is exactly the place where Allah grants eternal bliss because that is his will. The Earth on the other hand, has been willed by God to be a place of test. A test inherently requires the relative framework of Victory and failure, of Goodness and evil, of Suffering and bliss to have any meaning. Thus the very nature of deriving bliss by attempting to alleviate the suffering of others in the world is rendered redundant by Allah in the structure of the afterlife. There is no meaning in such endeavours anymore, since the window of opportunities, as well as the window of committing mistakes have been exhausted. It is the time and place to reap the benefits of what we have sowed. And Allah grants our fill without an iota of injustice, and he causes that state to prevail.
👍🏼
💎
All eyes on reasi
🔥🔥
Sahih Muslim 2749
Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) having said:
By Him in Whose Hand is my life, if you were not to commit sin, Allah would sweep you out of existence and He would replace (you by) those people who would commit sin and seek forgiveness from Allah, and He would have pardoned them.
❤👍🏻
❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉
എന്ത് കൊണ്ടാണ് പ്രായ പൂർത്തിയാവാത്ത കുഞ്ഞു കുട്ടികൾ ക്രൂരമായി പരീക്ഷപ്പെടുന്നത് ?....????, അതിലൂടെ എന്ത് മെസേജ് ആണ് ദൈവത്തിന് നൽകാനുള്ളത്....?
വീഡിയോ കണ്ട ശേഷം കമന്റ് ചെയ്യുക - വിഡിയോയിൽ അതാണ് ചർച്ച ചെയ്യുന്നത്
No response to natural evil, simply said it is necessary, dont think it is satisfying.
2.why would anyone need free will over goodness.
3. Free will can be given between two moral acts also without the requirement of evil,
If you say free will is complete only with evil in this world,,
and when we say god can restrict evil act after choosing it,,,You said if god restricts the evil act when someone does it, then eventually no one will do it. Then why does god create reward and punishment for the acts human does? And if someone doesn't do any evil or immoral act , then is it because of the fear of hell and free will is not fully free in that sense too? .......
what u need is the capacity of free will without actualizing the evil or wrong act. It can be accomplished in that way with god restricting the act.
1. Why is “ natural “ things are evil.. do they have free will to change it to
good??
2.because that is the base a test, “ who is good in deeds” for that you need freewill good and evil
3. Consider like this there is no evil , one is lesser good ( you identify as evil) and one is greater good
4. “Choosing” hell or heaven itself is free will dude , free will does mean ability to choose
5 . If you are not doing wrong how do you distinguish a person who does good ??
@sarifmuhammed
1. Do u agree evil exist in this world ?, then what is the explanation for evil occurring in this world which is not caused by will ,but happened naturally.
2. Why would a omniscient being put a test for ? and why would he put anyone to heaven or hell based on it
And what kind of test of it ? Is god checking the quality of a person by his decision, then the qualities are predefined by god only, or if he is checking what is his choices in this world,,, then again how is that a big deal , because if given another chance that choices could change.
3. I mentioned 3rd point to the free will defense made by apologetics .. that there won't be free will if god allow only good , to that I made the response u can have free will with good alone.
4. You are not choosing hell or heaven directly , it is decided by the tests score as apologists say. This too I was responding to another response......
5. Why u need to distinguish ? and if the person is having free will , even the person who does good can do wrong at any time , if he can't then he is not free ....
@@christhomas7091 1. I do agree that “evil” in this world is something which human intentionally do, eg: earthquake, is not evil, it is a natural process to shape the world we see, there is nothing evil in die in earthquake, but bombing and killing is evil, since there is intention/free will behind it.
2. Test for us to acknowledge and know why I am in that position, Eg: college give you test, not for the benefit of college instead to benefit and assess yourself.
3. It should be distinguishable and judge able, else there is no test, whether you call it evil, or absence of Good, or lesser good does not matter.
4. Yes, it is test, you may fail or pass in a n exam, based on your choices , that is upto you to choose which one you want
5. No, we follow virtue ethics, there, intention matters than consequences , and GOD is well aware about your intention and actions, which is well distinguishable to GOD to judge, and give justice, no other normative ethics has that scenario
@sarifmuhammed someone dying in earthquake is not evil ? Then what is it good or just an event... or u don't consider any horrific event as evil if it is not caused by will, then no question
Rest all are not good response to the points I raised
@@christhomas7091 it is not , why it is evil? If that is evil , killing for food is also evil, do you agree? Survival itself is evil, you are killing millions of bacterias while bathing and brushing your teeth, is that evil?
intention and freewill matters in “evil” dude.
ദൈവം ഉണ്ടായിരുന്നു എങ്കിൽ എന്തുകൊണ്ട് മണ്ടൻ നാസ്തികർ ഉണ്ടായി😢
😂
almighty god give problems but can't solve it. 😂 When questioned - its for teach our will😂
👍👍👍
❤❤
❤
❤
❤❤