Is Workout Volume Actually Killing Your Gains? (Athlean-X Response)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 3 тис.

  • @JeffNippard
    @JeffNippard  5 років тому +579

    Whats up guys! Just a quick heads up there are a ton of sales going on this weekend from me and my sponsors if you want to take advantage! I'll throw some links below. Hope you guys enjoy the video!
    ‣ Training programs and the new nutrition guide (30-50% off): jeffnippard.com
    ‣ MASS Research Review subscription (Save 30+%) : bit.ly/jeffMASS
    ‣ Rise Gym Gear (Win a free home gym!): rise.ca/jeff
    ‣ PEScience Supplements (30% off using code JEFF): pescience.com/discount/jeff
    Hope everyone has an awesome weekend! Peace!

    • @cactus9277
      @cactus9277 5 років тому +4

      Hey Jeff, Do you know of any studies on the effect of hydration on long term growth? My roommate was a power lifter and he claimed drinking tons (~1Gl/day) of water is what got him out of a hard plateau.

    • @ahmadbrkam4350
      @ahmadbrkam4350 5 років тому +1

      One last question if I did like really high volume per week but I did all the recovery work needed and basically recovered every workout in the same or next day (theoriticly ) wouldnt it be better for gains? Like does alot of volume still affect the gains if I am recovering properly?

    • @Zetsuke4
      @Zetsuke4 5 років тому

      This is the kind of thing I want to see

    • @ahmadbrkam4350
      @ahmadbrkam4350 5 років тому

      @Spoon are you saying I should just do 1 set to failure? That just getting a small pump it wont make me grow
      Like 3 sets maybe

    • @timothycain8639
      @timothycain8639 5 років тому

      Its crazy you posted this vid when you did because I was just considering my training volume as being potentially too high

  • @angelosorio98
    @angelosorio98 5 років тому +15446

    Jeff makes a lot of good point but Jeff also makes good points. I think Jeff is right

    • @satvikdubey6238
      @satvikdubey6238 5 років тому +358

      You too make some good points my man.😂👏👏

    • @isaquesevero4369
      @isaquesevero4369 5 років тому +373

      the arguments that Jeff made where better than the ones that Jeff made , so i think Jeff wins

    • @jessejive117
      @jessejive117 5 років тому +18

      Angel Osorio That’s because you have no idea what you’re talking about.

    • @angelosorio98
      @angelosorio98 5 років тому +188

      Jesse Collins I bet you’re fun at parties

    • @jessejive117
      @jessejive117 5 років тому +37

      Angel Osorio I thought it was obvious, but I was joking too. I guess you didn’t get the joke, therefore I’M the party pooper lol

  • @kevinivan91
    @kevinivan91 4 роки тому +2800

    me: enters gym
    both jeffs: you are killing your gains

  • @MetalDavidRulez
    @MetalDavidRulez 5 років тому +2159

    After spending the past 3 years watching everyone give different advice and opinions, I’ve realised that all you need is good form and whatever you feel works for you.

    • @damianfourie6333
      @damianfourie6333 4 роки тому +241

      Sphane 100% every study will have a counter study. Do what you enjoy and stay consistent

    • @yasarkaplan7425
      @yasarkaplan7425 4 роки тому +52

      @@damianfourie6333 well said, everbody is different and everyone's body reacts different to different things. Just do whatever you feel is best for you

    • @davidec.4021
      @davidec.4021 4 роки тому +74

      Thank you. I was trying to write down my first program for myself and i was freaking out because everything was starting to contradict everything else. I’ll give it a try and then see for myself. Cheers!

    • @MrMarsAlien
      @MrMarsAlien 4 роки тому +30

      @@davidec.4021 I'm the same man. Always trying to optimize everything to perfection but sometimes it gets to that "analysis paralysis" point where it's better to just break through and do it because there are no insight gains left to gain atm lmao But after working a bit optimization will once again become needed so it's all about walking that line of not overdoing it. Good luck!

    • @omerfawadrauf7369
      @omerfawadrauf7369 4 роки тому +11

      Agreed. Workout. Have fun. Push yourself. 👍

  • @hyperhampster5660
    @hyperhampster5660 5 років тому +2114

    Watching this made me want to do face pulls while eating a kiwi.

  • @bongothom
    @bongothom 5 років тому +3558

    Coffee is good, coffee is bad. Eggs are bad, eggs are not bad. Volume is necessary, volume is killing your gains....
    I'd like to see a scientific study on the accuracy of scientific research.

    • @elginefu8270
      @elginefu8270 5 років тому +21

      Kong fu panda wugui quotes

    • @Arronturknell
      @Arronturknell 5 років тому +26

      Right LOL variability(Variables) is something almost everyone in 7th grade learned (someone with a working bran in school learned).

    • @bongothom
      @bongothom 5 років тому +154

      @@Arronturknell variables do indeed vary. Conclusions are conclusive. It is the variability of the conclusive conclusions which I question. If a scientific study concludes something is bad, but another study contradicts the first, then we have contradictory facts which is a contradiction. It's all very confusing

    • @yassinbaraka
      @yassinbaraka 5 років тому +51

      @@bongothom Your comment gave me a headache

    • @Konton0178
      @Konton0178 5 років тому +53

      Basically: You lift you get gains, listen to your body there are no excuses.

  • @nikolaibelinski2609
    @nikolaibelinski2609 4 роки тому +914

    Jeff Cav: "GAINS are killing your Gains!!"
    Jeff Nipp: "according to a 2013 report by Barbos et Al, making Gains will best optimise your Gains"

    • @naxotogo
      @naxotogo 4 роки тому +5

      in all honesty, id like to see an update on the research.

    • @philipmeisterl
      @philipmeisterl 4 роки тому +9

      Nikolai Belinski i wouldnt realy too much on cavelier. Hes by now very useless / fake natty/ defenetly not very high know how for powerlifting or bodybuilding hes not a researcher and it defenetly shows i think hes pretty much proven to be a fraud

    • @ireallyhatemakingupnamesfo1758
      @ireallyhatemakingupnamesfo1758 4 роки тому +3

      Gains are killing your gains

    • @nargi
      @nargi 4 роки тому +7

      naxotogo vegan gains also cites studies and it proves nothing. cherry picking info from a single study proves absolutely
      nothing. nippard is an expert on nothing, except perhaps tren.

    • @kw8959
      @kw8959 4 роки тому

      @@philipmeisterl ua-cam.com/video/39YvjFRiGac/v-deo.html

  • @amishshark3549
    @amishshark3549 5 років тому +2874

    *Avengers Endgame is the most ambitious crossover in history*
    Jeff: hold my kiwis

    • @nickvoelker7180
      @nickvoelker7180 5 років тому +67

      "hold my kiwis" could be taken in a couple of ways...

    • @amishshark3549
      @amishshark3549 5 років тому +7

      @@nickvoelker7180 lmao

    • @petedawson5875
      @petedawson5875 5 років тому +31

      Amish Shark other Jeff: hold my resistance band but use external rotation

    • @Stingerbillion
      @Stingerbillion 5 років тому +1

      You are right....most "ambitious" garbage i've ever seen.

    • @Moiez101
      @Moiez101 5 років тому +1

      @@petedawson5875 lmao dont kill me broo

  • @olivermoller1127
    @olivermoller1127 5 років тому +684

    Jeff has a Jeff on each side just to avoid muscle imbalances

    • @nikolaibelinski2609
      @nikolaibelinski2609 4 роки тому +4

      FUUCK I laughed HARD at that 😂😂😂

    • @ashwanikumar-gv6ir
      @ashwanikumar-gv6ir 4 роки тому +4

      Do you mean jeff seid has both cavaliere and nipparrd to avoid muscle imbalance.

  • @shafiq1113
    @shafiq1113 5 років тому +3687

    Jeff: I have hot girlfriend,
    Jeff: I have Jessie

  • @PatrickReynoldsfit
    @PatrickReynoldsfit 5 років тому +3842

    Me: *breathes*
    Both jeffs: You are killing your gains

  • @Firmly_grasp_it
    @Firmly_grasp_it 5 років тому +1908

    A Jeff Nippard, and Jeff cavaliere collab would break UA-cam..... even more than it’s already broken

    • @Moh-cs5ck
      @Moh-cs5ck 5 років тому +3

      Wtf yesss

    • @rickybeckley7495
      @rickybeckley7495 5 років тому +55

      Athleanx jeff hinted at the fact he doesnt like this type of video style. He believes studies do not show the big picture and these types of videos are boring

    • @rickybeckley7495
      @rickybeckley7495 5 років тому +4

      Here's the link ua-cam.com/video/a9_JPgwW9nw/v-deo.html

    • @Summerbrah
      @Summerbrah 5 років тому +23

      @@rickybeckley7495 but they are not boring Jeff is wrong there

    • @MrUseless247
      @MrUseless247 5 років тому +1

      So many people want Jeff Cavalier to do a collab with ' so and so'. What I can remember he only has a couple, and they were personal friends of his. I don't see him doing a collab video anytime soon. And when he does, it won't be with someone he doesn't know, personally.

  • @bushidofreakz
    @bushidofreakz 5 років тому +546

    JeffXJeff is that one collab that we need, and deserve

    • @alainerookkitsunev5605
      @alainerookkitsunev5605 4 роки тому +49

      Imagine them designing a workout routine together... The government woud probrably steal the workout plan to create supersoldiers lol.

    • @maestro69hz
      @maestro69hz 4 роки тому +10

      China will steal it

  • @raghuware2469
    @raghuware2469 5 років тому +3231

    When the two smartest kids gets different answer...

    • @chongtak
      @chongtak 5 років тому +142

      I don't know who is right but at least one comes with a study.

    • @shahrukhhassan9599
      @shahrukhhassan9599 5 років тому +1

      😂😂

    • @DavidByrne85
      @DavidByrne85 5 років тому +113

      @@chongtak Nippard always comes with studies, Cavaliere just comes with pet theories based on play time with his toy skeleton.

    • @MrCharlieCosmo
      @MrCharlieCosmo 5 років тому +470

      Just his pet theories, and multiple degrees, and lifetime of experience.....

    • @shahrukhhassan9599
      @shahrukhhassan9599 5 років тому +285

      Might I just add to @@MrCharlieCosmo's comment: "a lifetime of experience coaching athletes performing at an elite level."

  • @WithTheBears
    @WithTheBears 4 роки тому +265

    I believe Jeff C's main point was that people were too focused on getting in all these sets and saving effort to do that. Basically you should be too exhausted to perform an outrageous amount of sets.

    • @tysontntjones3769
      @tysontntjones3769 4 роки тому +38

      Exactly. That's what he means by 3 sets of 12 is killing gains. He explained it well yet many don't understand

    • @vardhanharsha15
      @vardhanharsha15 3 роки тому +16

      @@tysontntjones3769 People don't watch his full video and either just go by his title or cherry pick from what he says

    • @thechosenone7875
      @thechosenone7875 3 роки тому +15

      @@vardhanharsha15 yes. It was pretty simple. Yes volume does have importance, but the effort is what dictates the results. If you’re able to do the amount of weight for an easy number of reps each set it’s not gonna do anything

    • @robmen1402
      @robmen1402 2 роки тому +1

      Yeah I see people that are not even advanced, more than likely only been working out for a year or two and they're out there doing 12 sets or more for chest in one day. How? How can you do that many sets and put real effort into them? At that point you're just doing a bunch of junk volume that is prob not doing much of anything.

    • @robmen1402
      @robmen1402 2 роки тому

      @@thechosenone7875 That's a problem and most of these influencers are always saying do this exercise for reps of 10 to 12 or 8 to 12 so they end up picking a weight that they can do 20 reps with if they did them to failure, lol. This is why I always go 8 reps where I know by 8 I'm pretty much on the verge of failure at that 8th rep. Better to go heavier and do 6 to 8 reps that way you know that you're getting close to failure. Your'e uncomfortable, feeling it.

  • @vinaykumarsingh5360
    @vinaykumarsingh5360 4 роки тому +133

    Whenever i come up with my new workout routine there is always some scientific evidence prove it wrong. Anyways i am going to pizza hut.

    • @thripper5332
      @thripper5332 4 роки тому +12

      what matters is progressive overload WHILE maintaining perfect form, do this consistently and you will get results, there is studies of more studies proving wrong other studies, as long as you get the fundamentals right you don't need to know all of this, a lot of this ultra specialized information is meant for professional bodybuilders not for most people that just wants to be fit/muscular look good, fitness on youtube has been talked about ad infinitum to the point almost every single aspect of lifting is already covered, to keep the channel alive these guys need to be making videos like these.

    • @davo7512
      @davo7512 3 роки тому

      WRONG

    • @user-kk4bq7mb8u
      @user-kk4bq7mb8u 3 роки тому +1

      Wait til you hear what science has to say about THAT

  • @kamikazeneko9070
    @kamikazeneko9070 5 років тому +713

    I want to see a fusion with the both jeffs into super saiyan jeff.

    • @imadeyoureadthis1
      @imadeyoureadthis1 5 років тому +28

      His name is Jeff CAVAPPARD.

    • @SaikouENT
      @SaikouENT 5 років тому +4

      A Fusion of two Jeffs is . . . Jeff. 🤣

    • @botten4187
      @botten4187 5 років тому +4

      Jeffception

    • @adoniscreed4031
      @adoniscreed4031 5 років тому +1

      Super Ffej

    • @JJHewable
      @JJHewable 5 років тому +2

      Holy freakin frick you just blew my freakin mind!!

  • @DrSwole
    @DrSwole 5 років тому +787

    Jeff Nippard + Athlean X. My life is complete

    • @hypertrophyguy1325
      @hypertrophyguy1325 5 років тому +16

      Ask Dr. Swole a collab between the two would be insane

    • @DrSwole
      @DrSwole 5 років тому

      Hypertrophy Guy yeah 🤯

    • @aerobiks9882
      @aerobiks9882 5 років тому +7

      Swollab

    • @DrSwole
      @DrSwole 5 років тому +3

      JustSomeGuy ahahah that is amazing. Legit gonna use that on my channel for interviews

    • @oceansheart23
      @oceansheart23 5 років тому

      Complicated*

  • @callumjames3531
    @callumjames3531 4 роки тому +59

    At this point I don’t even know if my gains are alive or dead

  • @winkypanda5130
    @winkypanda5130 5 років тому +585

    Not first, Never last,
    But when its jeff calling,
    I come fast.

    • @danielcalma2138
      @danielcalma2138 5 років тому

      Gold

    • @mattl7424
      @mattl7424 5 років тому +6

      BlahBlahBlah Blah sounds pretty gay

    • @PEACEBRINGER200
      @PEACEBRINGER200 5 років тому

      PAUSE

    • @susie7336
      @susie7336 5 років тому

      BlahBlahBlah Blah 🤢

    • @cheath6596
      @cheath6596 5 років тому +1

      @@BobSmith-wn2sc you should seek pharmaceutical assistance for your premature ejaculations...

  • @BlackSaiyan24
    @BlackSaiyan24 5 років тому +382

    I’ve seen the word “Jeff” so many times in the comments it looks weird to me now

  • @AldosWorldTV
    @AldosWorldTV 4 роки тому +204

    What do u mean 5 sets tho? Like I walk into the gym to do chest, I do bench press for 5 sets & walk out the gym? Im confused

    • @geecee1990
      @geecee1990 4 роки тому +24

      Exactly what I was thinking. only 5 sets?

    • @omarjalal8531
      @omarjalal8531 4 роки тому +18

      He means for every exercise

    • @ballaking1000
      @ballaking1000 4 роки тому +108

      Omar Jalal That’s not what he meant as well... Different exercises can work the same muscles, what he meant was “per muscle group”- NOT per exercise.

    • @mrtechsoldiertm3280
      @mrtechsoldiertm3280 4 роки тому +27

      I do 4 exercises on biceps and 4 sets each per bicep workout , so according to him I do 2 exercises for 5 sets which will take hardly 15 minutes and go back home?

    • @almightyfoxxiexclusive4046
      @almightyfoxxiexclusive4046 4 роки тому +5

      Facts what does this even mean give us answers

  • @danielcalma2138
    @danielcalma2138 5 років тому +277

    Notification said Nippard, thumbnail showed Cavalier. Had to do a quadruple take to make sure it wasn't my sleep deprivation messing with me

    • @denisflorian2431
      @denisflorian2431 5 років тому +22

      NOT SLEEPING KILLS YOUR GAINS

    • @MrDitkovich
      @MrDitkovich 5 років тому +5

      @@denisflorian2431 WHY BREATHING IS KILLING YOUR GAINS!! (FIX THIS)

    • @Abhiṣeka03
      @Abhiṣeka03 5 років тому +2

      @@MrDitkovich Existing is killing your gains.

    • @Hadi-dh4yh
      @Hadi-dh4yh 5 років тому +1

      @daniel i pulled an all nighter and all dayer to fix my sleeping schedule

    • @lostinsauce4515
      @lostinsauce4515 5 років тому +1

      @@MrDitkovich COMMENTING ON UA-cam VIDEOS IS KILLING YOUR GAINS! (HERES WHY)

  • @AxeKick80
    @AxeKick80 5 років тому +485

    I swear Jeff Cav’s tombstone will say “Being dead is killing my gains (BODY 6 FEET DOWN!)”

    • @logwind
      @logwind 4 роки тому +1

      lol

    • @itruthseek
      @itruthseek 4 роки тому +1

      i was gonna say lol

    • @emersonherrera4939
      @emersonherrera4939 4 роки тому +1

      😩😓😩😩😩🙄

    • @liamm9069
      @liamm9069 4 роки тому +11

      "Now when lowering the casket, and take note of the angle of my lower back here, it's vital to slow the eccentric to maximise time under tension"

    • @vladm5920
      @vladm5920 4 роки тому +2

      No, it will say “This is Jeff Cavalier from ATHLEAN-X.COM” and THEN it will say that..

  • @ElvizNation
    @ElvizNation 5 років тому +152

    I think Jeff makes more sense then Jeff

  • @fatigamaximatotal7862
    @fatigamaximatotal7862 5 років тому +195

    I saw the tittle and got scared that Jeff was declaring war against Jeff
    They got us in the first half not gonna lie

    • @j.9970
      @j.9970 4 роки тому +1

      You had me at “tittle”

  • @jinlee7827
    @jinlee7827 5 років тому +54

    Saw the thumbnail and thought this was a collab, I was so hyped for a second

  • @mislavsprajc669
    @mislavsprajc669 4 роки тому +132

    Is there footage of the rodents lifting?

  • @flakyolly
    @flakyolly 5 років тому +188

    I appreciate that your default tone of voice is conversational and not screaming

    • @frantisekfojt8688
      @frantisekfojt8688 4 роки тому +12

      The reason I preffer Jeff over Jeff

    • @Ones_Complement
      @Ones_Complement 4 роки тому +6

      @@frantisekfojt8688 It's the italian in him.

    • @Adham-vz2nw
      @Adham-vz2nw 4 роки тому +1

      flakyolly Gotta watch Greg Doucette

    • @fengmagicgadget2987
      @fengmagicgadget2987 3 роки тому +1

      Greg doucette reference 🤣🤣. Btw his screaming voice is a character, it's not his real voice

  • @Farazk434
    @Farazk434 5 років тому +92

    Last time I was this early there was only 1 Jeff on a channel

  • @JuanitaMichelle
    @JuanitaMichelle 4 роки тому +31

    Volume killed my gains when my calorie and carb intake was too low, especially when I worked out before I ate. As far as over training, I never do that. Lol so I think I’m safe there. I also agree with the point that focusing only on volume increase, but neglecting the effectiveness of each rep, will result in loss as opposed to gains.

  • @kevindelima5713
    @kevindelima5713 5 років тому +43

    I thought this was a collab and never have I clicked faster

  • @gonzacollao
    @gonzacollao 5 років тому +122

    Jeff v Jeff: Dawn of Buffstice

  • @freeminded7
    @freeminded7 5 років тому +49

    I’ve made way more progress focusing on staying in the 1-4 reps from failure range and focusing more on volume than I ever did being mainly intensity focused. Joints feel way better, muscles are more balance, and size steadily increases year after year. I couldn’t imagine growing on 5 sets of anything without just focusing on powerlifting.

    • @aakashpoudel8191
      @aakashpoudel8191 4 роки тому

      @@thinkbeforeyoureact2988 Of what weight?

    • @aboveaura4817
      @aboveaura4817 3 роки тому +7

      @@thinkbeforeyoureact2988 Bruh that's insane. You're wasting time and effort, I'd call it torture at this point.

    • @wallyosmond9204
      @wallyosmond9204 2 роки тому +5

      Feel this comment. I've recently been trying to get smarter with my program and holding back from failure is a weird thing. It's the opposite of no pain no gain. It feels like I'm just playing with the weights not working out but I'm stronger than ever.

    • @harveyquinn3535
      @harveyquinn3535 2 роки тому

      Volume as in one particular training session or volume as in more sessions per week? What’s your routine bro

    • @greenlitlleman
      @greenlitlleman 2 роки тому

      Really depends on your genetics a lot. I gained 12 kg in my first year in the gym, doing only 1-2 sets of four-six basic exercises. No one believes me when I share this fact, lol. Later I found out that I have a gene that makes my muscles more likely to receive damage from exercise. And it's true, I can do just one set and still hurt the next day, even though most other people wouldn't feel anything from such a low volume.

  • @shivagp9923
    @shivagp9923 5 років тому +19

    Is it just me or are Jeff's videos so satisfying to watch

  • @cranjismcbasketball2118
    @cranjismcbasketball2118 5 років тому +64

    This is Scott Herman... Both Jeff's ahhhhh wickid REHHHHTAHHHHHTED!

  • @arualtucliist7149
    @arualtucliist7149 4 роки тому +160

    Jeff: Performs cable chest fly
    Jeff: Upset about internal rotation

    • @defaultcamo3154
      @defaultcamo3154 4 роки тому

      this joke is underated

    • @iwantlee9510
      @iwantlee9510 4 роки тому +7

      You are wrong. Jeff Cavalier is not against internal rotation duriing chest work. He has stared many times that the chest internally rotated the shoulder, and that you need to internally rotate to target the chest the most.

    • @arualtucliist7149
      @arualtucliist7149 4 роки тому +4

      @@iwantlee9510 True, but not with elevation above the shoulders. Nippard was doing the flies with his hands around face level.

    • @fengmagicgadget2987
      @fengmagicgadget2987 3 роки тому

      Idiots 🤣

    • @tolstoyhardie3696
      @tolstoyhardie3696 3 роки тому

      @@arualtucliist7149 yeah Cav would of done that ex with an underhand grip right?

  • @yannickp.2430
    @yannickp.2430 5 років тому +73

    "The great battle of the jeffs"
    - 2019, colorized

  • @DeiNostri
    @DeiNostri 4 роки тому +14

    My experience is that high volume training have been the best thing I have ever tried. 10 45minute workouts a week, mixed with the 100 reps a day was the most effective thing I have ever done. It results in looong rest periods. One workout 5 o clock in the morning, the rest after work for three months made me grow fast. The ideas Jeff describes is pretty much grounded in the same idea.

  • @Sub7Fitness
    @Sub7Fitness 5 років тому +106

    Only three seasons a week training in a split (ppl) style likely is what lead to these poor results.
    Jeff’s point is mostly that many people care so much about volume they forget about overload.

    • @XxMVPxDawg
      @XxMVPxDawg 5 років тому +17

      Their are also many individuals who care so much about progressing in weight and getting stronger that their form goes to shit.

    • @Zooom-s5f
      @Zooom-s5f 5 років тому

      @@XxMVPxDawg well, those are ho dont give time body to rest.

    • @XxMVPxDawg
      @XxMVPxDawg 5 років тому

      @@Zooom-s5f Not necessarily. They can get plenty of rest and still be fixated on trying to get stronger each and every time.

    • @Zooom-s5f
      @Zooom-s5f 5 років тому

      @@XxMVPxDawg and how this work 4 you? You lift 50 in bench press and your 1 rep max it's 700?

    • @jameswilsonmusic7749
      @jameswilsonmusic7749 5 років тому +3

      I'm not shocked the 1x frequency per week PPL gave poor results.
      But yes.
      Recently I have applied the 80 20 rule to my training. Cut the fluff and put an emphasis on intensity and I can see where the benefit lies

  • @mabz132
    @mabz132 5 років тому +28

    Jeff and Jeff coming together is like a Marvel DC crossover

  • @jeremyhannah3008
    @jeremyhannah3008 5 років тому +9

    I think this is an excellent response. A good example of referencing another piece of work and utilizing it to make your own point. Respect is key for earning respect. Both Jeffs are good sources of information to draw from.

  • @Farazk434
    @Farazk434 5 років тому +127

    Jeff and Jeff?! What is this, a crossover episode?

    • @reziik6904
      @reziik6904 5 років тому +6

      Doggy doggy what now?

    • @imadeyoureadthis1
      @imadeyoureadthis1 5 років тому +3

      Jeff and Jeff in the same room? What is this a crossover episode? *From those that don't know this is a pun from a show on Netflix called bojack horseman*

    • @katianna7306
      @katianna7306 5 років тому +1

      Mr peanut butter

    • @kodykernan6917
      @kodykernan6917 5 років тому +3

      Erica! How are you looking so gorgeous? Im furious!

    • @LinkEX
      @LinkEX 5 років тому

      @@imadeyoureadthis1 It's not a reference, not a pun.
      A pun is a play on words, i.e. something with a double meaning by changing the words. OP just exchanged the names.

  • @edge3220
    @edge3220 5 років тому +21

    People focus too much on numbers and never train on listening to the body. Since breaking away from how things look on paper I've made good progress really trying to perceive my body's response to lifting. The perception was subtle at first, but it became more and more noticeable as time went on.

  • @caribbeanman
    @caribbeanman 4 роки тому +6

    Totally satisfying seeing interaction between the 2 Jeffs

  • @n0ah4177
    @n0ah4177 5 років тому +36

    We need Dr.Gregg’s opinion on this

  • @ErdemBey2
    @ErdemBey2 5 років тому +55

    If you want your kid has muscles and not killing his own gains name him “Jeff”

    • @jorgemaldonado5174
      @jorgemaldonado5174 5 років тому +3

      So if you call him Jeff Jeff you are going to have the strongest man in the Arnold classic?

    • @ErdemBey2
      @ErdemBey2 5 років тому +2

      Exactly

    • @kylemaximusmith
      @kylemaximusmith 5 років тому +2

      I’m changing my child’s name

    • @ErdemBey2
      @ErdemBey2 5 років тому +1

      Kyle Smith good job bro.

  • @BADGUY82661
    @BADGUY82661 4 роки тому +34

    Here’s a question. This video mentions “losing gains” with increased sets; actually losing chest size. Was strength accounted for as a variable? Or, simply how cut those individuals are? Size and density is entirely different and is something to consider. I’m curious to hear your thoughts on this. Thank you.

  • @wulfser2556
    @wulfser2556 5 років тому +193

    Someone's gonna end up with an internally rotated shoulder

    • @goldjh1069
      @goldjh1069 5 років тому +29

      @Thor Odinson Let me rephrase for him "Uh oh, someone's gonna end up with a
      rotator cuff injury"

    • @TheMcStormy
      @TheMcStormy 5 років тому

      Omg Iaughed out loud

    • @pandahsykes602
      @pandahsykes602 5 років тому

      Thor Odinson woah hope this is /s there mang

    • @dakotalee9980
      @dakotalee9980 5 років тому

      And an impinged nerve

  • @EmbraceTheInevitable
    @EmbraceTheInevitable 5 років тому +20

    Am I the only one impressed by Jeff’s force skills every time he brings up a study page?

  • @haloguru2552
    @haloguru2552 4 роки тому +23

    One thing I've learned since I started lifting is a lot of times the numbers can be deceiving. At least for me, I find it most important to get in tune with and listen to what your body is telling you. You'll know if you overtrained, if you didn't eat enough, etc. Listen to your body and adjust accordingly.

  • @g_gockel
    @g_gockel 5 років тому +119

    This feels like my parents arguing

    • @TheFizzjunior
      @TheFizzjunior 4 роки тому +3

      Your parents are really into statistical analysis and extrapolating theoretical data

    • @Kaddywompous
      @Kaddywompous 4 роки тому +1

      Why do so many people think they were disagreeing??

  • @thattannerguy856
    @thattannerguy856 4 роки тому +14

    Personally been lifting for 5 years. Recently upped both training frequency and number of sets, leaving little if any in the tank. Biceps grew 3.5cm in about 3 months!

    • @ottomayn7056
      @ottomayn7056 4 роки тому

      So can you please explain me your workout, cause im confused. For example how many sets and reps you do for your chest, how many exercises do you do and how many times you train your chest a week?

    • @michaelcoryer7555
      @michaelcoryer7555 2 роки тому

      How often do you workout a specific muscle per week? For biceps or triceps? 2-3?

    • @jimdent351
      @jimdent351 2 роки тому

      @@michaelcoryer7555 The steroids did him in.

  • @ArtmMaker
    @ArtmMaker 5 років тому +16

    personally as a science and sports guy this is my man everything makes sense explain everything does not try to make you think that everything you do is stupid and is all in all a really good teacher

  • @codypena8301
    @codypena8301 5 років тому +9

    This is some crazy Jeff-ception going on here. I support

  • @RedgraveStrength
    @RedgraveStrength 5 років тому +16

    I've seen a ton of information on building more muscle and the main thing I've seen is doing more volume only works to a certain point. You have to add weight to the bar and get stronger for reps. If you're doing 200 lbs for a set of 10 on bench and can progress to 300 for 10, you've built more muscle and got stronger.
    Using this approach with myself and my clients to progress while keeping intensity high works very well.
    Everytime I've tried the higher volume thing with myself and my clients, even while using the volume landmarks of 10-20 sets per body part per week, we always run into issues with recovery and things start breaking down. It definitely seems like moderate volume in the 5-10 set range with a focus on intensity seems to give the best gains overall.
    What do you guys think? What has given you the best gains in muscle and strength?

    • @nizargaabour9814
      @nizargaabour9814 4 роки тому

      To me even reaching more than 15 sets means I am not working hard enough and I kinda plateau, I need less sets and more weight!

  • @user-cx7te6pl2h
    @user-cx7te6pl2h 5 років тому +3

    I love how these videos are humble and detailed

  • @pronk201208
    @pronk201208 5 років тому +13

    Hey Jeff, my professor just touched on volume in my exercise physiology course. He said there are many studies showing that 1 set taken to 100% MVC promotes the same protein synthesis as multiple sets (like the most common 3 or 4). This in turn causes the same amount of hypertrophy. I plan on doing some research on this myself, but I was curious if you have seen any of this literature while looking on PubMed or other databases for studies?

    • @TommyQR2
      @TommyQR2 4 роки тому +1

      Maybe this is the same, as the PITT Force training method (or simply P.I.T.) as promoted by the German bodybuilder Peter Bears. I´ve tried it myself for 6 months. 1 set for each body part, 20 reps with a weight that you normaly could do only 8 reps with. You rest a short period (seconds) between every rep to get fresh blood in your muscle and by-products out of it.
      I´ve experienced no difference rgd. hypertrophy or strength comparing to a classical training style. Training will be a bit shorter (but not too much, as you still need warm up sets and the working set takes you up to 5 minutes), but soreness is better und you can train more often per week.

    • @robmen1402
      @robmen1402 2 роки тому +1

      There is literature on this, the conclusion is that one doesn't do more hypertrophy then the other, except for one paper I heard about that is kinda new that showed that higher volume made a bit more hypertrophy gains. But when you look at the number it could be chocked up as marginal at best in my opinion. So the only thing left if they both work is, what are the pros of going high intensity very low sets like 1 to 2? You're less time in the gym, way less time. More time for slow steady cardio, time for other hobbies, work, family. Gym rats that love being in the gym almost every day for 2 hours or more are the ones that just will not except that high intensity low volume is just as good.

  • @martinmartinese7325
    @martinmartinese7325 5 років тому +63

    Let s solve this Vegan Gains style :
    Jeff vs Jeff MMA fight with guest referee Eric Bugenhagen aka Rick Del Stick aka Sticky Ricky with Alan Roberts and James from shredded sports science at the commentary.

  • @mitchellalexander1581
    @mitchellalexander1581 4 роки тому +3

    It's so good to see the great Jeffs supporting eachother in thier excellent search for bodily truths

  • @josephsmth646
    @josephsmth646 5 років тому +82

    Title should have been "Bro Jeff shares thoughts on Goat Jeff".

  • @rayray117
    @rayray117 4 роки тому +12

    Just blew my mind that there both called Jeff lol and I been watching them for years 😂

  • @shahrukhhassan9599
    @shahrukhhassan9599 5 років тому

    A respectful response. Just what was missing in the online fitness community. Acknowledging the other's valid points and then presenting your counter-argument. Unlike throwing f-bombs every 10 seconds and calling the other's pov "bullsh*t". Nice.
    PS - the comment section 😂😂

  • @kcopara1
    @kcopara1 5 років тому +6

    I need to do a proper video on this. The first mistake was the scientists used the wrong periodization scheme. Studies done on D1 track athletes undergoing weight-training have shown that the periodization scheme they used does not favor the high volume group. Block training would have been better for the high volume group not DUP or WUP. Also, the lack of dietary control throws this study out the window. How do they (scientists) know if the participants were consuming the proper amount of protein knowing how resistance training suppresses appetite on some people? Moreover, it is rather ironic that the scientists are baffled by the plateau at 12 weeks when one of the works they cited (among 3 with 2 studies not being cited in the current study) earlier during the study answered why the plateau occurs but I see jeff didn't catch it either since they haven't read that much yet~ @kele.chi_opara

  • @Muhonry
    @Muhonry 4 роки тому +11

    When using the term “sets” how many repetitions do you have in mind? Are they sets to failure? And are you meaning say five sets possibly per exercise or per body part total? This is just because I have a hard time wrapping my head around the idea of only working five sets of say 5 to 12 reps of only one exercise and calling it quits for the day!

    • @healthydog1
      @healthydog1 4 роки тому

      Muhonry he explains everything you just asked.

    • @TexboyGamer
      @TexboyGamer 4 роки тому +2

      kevin morgan no he didnt

    • @healthydog1
      @healthydog1 4 роки тому

      TexBoy watch again little buddy

    • @TexboyGamer
      @TexboyGamer 4 роки тому +3

      kevin morgan listen prick. He answers the first part, but I haven’t seen where he says if it should only be 5 sets per body part. Time stamp me if it’s so obvious

    • @justinz9225
      @justinz9225 4 роки тому

      kevin morgan he really didn’t clarify. Does a pull-up and a bent leg row both count for biceps, for instance? Lots of exercises will fall under a pull day, but work things in different ways. His way of categorizing x sets per body part per week is extremely unclear. Because I do 10-12 sets on most workout days, across various exercises, but I know he’s not suggesting one pull day per week, right?

  • @Bebopin-69
    @Bebopin-69 5 років тому +2

    Haha this brings us back to big Mike Mentzer. He had a very simple and logical HIT approach. If you really want to find out what works for you you have to put the time in the research of your body. For instance:
    1-work heavy with form paramount
    2-Start with one set of 5. Not 5 sets of 8. Just one set.
    3-after a while if it does not show results, you cant really do less, you can only do more,
    4-add a set, and so on
    5-you should not do even one more rep than it is necessary to trigger growth. This will be the threshold, and it will change over time.
    RIP Mike

  • @markgoodson6977
    @markgoodson6977 4 роки тому +6

    Scenario 3 is basically the Dorian Yates training style. Definitely worked for him, of course due in part to, let's say, a more advanced supplement program. I've toyed with that one in the past and honestly felt I got the most out of my workouts, but they only lasted about 30 minutes. I'm accustomed to about an hour moving quickly with little rest and heavy weights to failure or near failure so the short sessions mentally left me feeling I was not doing enough. Years of the standard Bro workout has made making changes difficult.

  • @Wolf-es1el
    @Wolf-es1el 5 років тому +213

    When u go through the comment section and see that most of the people have profile pictures of their bodies

    • @Zooom-s5f
      @Zooom-s5f 5 років тому

      Ballons

    • @roidnerd2501
      @roidnerd2501 5 років тому +2

      Yeah and 90 percent of them have kids gains and need to stop being delusional, it's just funny they make 5 pounds of muscle gains but still look like shit

    • @PanosPitsi
      @PanosPitsi 5 років тому +10

      @@roidnerd2501 I mean what's the point of working out if you don't get to show of, it's like buying an expensive car and locking it in the basement.

    • @papaspaulding
      @papaspaulding 5 років тому

      mine too....im on a brutal cut

    • @SaturdayNightSlamMaster1980
      @SaturdayNightSlamMaster1980 5 років тому

      Yes.

  • @coreydavidson5392
    @coreydavidson5392 3 роки тому

    We're really lucky to have Jeffs to guide us.

  • @billytalent5104
    @billytalent5104 5 років тому +17

    Saw both OP Jeffsof Fitness industry and clicked it A.S.A.P

  • @andreaferro8818
    @andreaferro8818 4 роки тому +28

    3:24 that's the sickest burn I've ever heard

  • @n0etii
    @n0etii 4 роки тому

    Yo jeff! just wanted to say that the study you referenced in this video got taken down due to inconsistencies in their data. love the channel, keep it up!

  • @bjornbuijing6387
    @bjornbuijing6387 5 років тому +51

    A rodent study on resistance exercises? Why isn't there a video on this and how did they get the rodents to count sets??? ;-)

    • @daynecoyne7314
      @daynecoyne7314 5 років тому +3

      I thought the same thing. The record definitely skipped when I heard that.

    • @ErebosGR
      @ErebosGR 5 років тому +2

      inb4 fanarts of swole rats

  • @maniacablator
    @maniacablator 5 років тому +3

    It would be interesting to see what Bro Jeff has to say.

  • @whyargon
    @whyargon 4 роки тому +2

    What you said at the end was so important, and took me ages to figure out myself - I wish I learnt that sooner. The fact that going almost to faliure (leaving a few reps left) will not reduce your gains that significantly compared to fully going to failure. It will however allow you to go to the gym more times per week (since you're less sore), as well as the rest of your workout not being impacted from soreness (I started off each fullbody workout with 4 sets all to faliure bench with dropsetting, and I'd be so sore that my other exercises would suffer), ultimately improving gains.

    • @robmen1402
      @robmen1402 2 роки тому

      You're not suppose to do all your sets to failure with high intensity, lol. Only your last set per body part. Every set with drop sets to failure is way too much, maigai.

  • @canedubioza4603
    @canedubioza4603 4 роки тому +8

    4:49, this is interesting. I am kind of beginner, so i am wondering what happens with the rest of exercises we perform at the gym which are slightly hitting the same muscles?
    So, if i do 15 sets of bench press a week and 15 sets of dips per week, in that case I am gonna activate the chest 30 times per week?
    Does anyone have any thoughts on this? Thanks in advance!

    • @allfatherfitness535
      @allfatherfitness535 4 роки тому

      Only count direct compound movements for these set parameters if you hit chest two times a week and bench (direct chest compound) for 10 sets each time and then you do dips (indirect chest movement meaning dips are actually made for the triceps more) then you’re doing perfect but if you’re doing any more than that it’s going to have negative effects but regardless it all falls on your ability to train and physical parameters of hypertrophy and your ability to recover if you recover fast you want more intensity but if you recover slow you want less intensity and more volume you have to find a happy medium between these two structures based on your own experience but on my own personal rule of thumb train like a beast to be a beast

    • @allfatherfitness535
      @allfatherfitness535 4 роки тому +1

      I’m currently scripting a video based upon both this Jeff the other Jeff and Greg doucettes videos and giving my thoughts on this and I’ll throw a better explanation of your question and my response in there to clear it up

    • @kw8959
      @kw8959 4 роки тому

      ua-cam.com/video/39YvjFRiGac/v-deo.html watch this video. Its gonna help you get better results. Trust me.

  • @ohwen
    @ohwen Рік тому +5

    Rip the group that had to do 20 sets to failure each workout for 6 months 😭😭

  • @DKSorg
    @DKSorg 2 роки тому

    #RussianCompound #Spartan300 Powerlifting, Shows, Model, Weight Lifting, Sports ....
    - What are your Goals?
    - What is your Current condition?
    - Do you have Injuries?
    - Body Recomp after Surgery?
    Once you can SET your level of conditioning.... Determine your Path.... Your can focus on your goals.
    Both Jeff & Jeff are great for various reasons and if you bounce ideas from one to the Other...
    You will have a such a great resource of knowledge, you will be able to start making great informed choices as a noob or someone getting back into it.

  • @czarnylfernando17
    @czarnylfernando17 5 років тому +13

    Finally nippard responds to cavalier
    I know everyone is waiting for this

    • @paulschuebel5487
      @paulschuebel5487 4 роки тому

      But one can only imagine if this inception were taken one step further...

    • @iwantlee9510
      @iwantlee9510 4 роки тому

      Nippard is wrong though.

  • @juhaiverpasague8392
    @juhaiverpasague8392 4 роки тому +12

    I don't wanna go to gym right now cause i'm confused😂😂

  • @bazbarlow
    @bazbarlow 4 роки тому

    I’m glad I’ve found this channel. Actual science instead of bro science.
    I’m 33 and have been training on and off since I was about 17. Now I’m getting older I’m looking to maximise my gains by training as smart as I can since my newbie advantage gains are long behind me! These videos really do help.
    I’ve tweaked my plan after watching this to cut down on volume (I always thought I was doing too much) and I’m going to focus on gradual weight increments in the 6-12 rep range rather than always shooting for 12. I’m happy to hit a higher weight week on week now even if I just manage 6 reps per set.

  • @inuyasha
    @inuyasha 5 років тому +71

    I'd trust Jeff Cavaliere on this one.

  • @xxrookyxx
    @xxrookyxx 5 років тому +6

    Are "gains" strength or aesthetic? Or both. People seem to consider gains mainly aesthetic it seems to me

  • @karlclifford1176
    @karlclifford1176 4 роки тому

    My first time watching this dude. He sounded just as Intelligent and knowledgeable as Jeff cavalier. Spoke super well and clearly and he’s in fantastic shape. Subscribed.

    • @justindankert7725
      @justindankert7725 4 роки тому

      Don't even compare him to athlean x. Athlean X puts out a lot of bad content and the rest is just average. Look up "Curlean-X" on youtube.
      (for actually good channels barbellmedicine, starting strength, enkiri elite fitness, alan thrall and Renaissance Periodization are reccomended)

  • @rhejamphi
    @rhejamphi 4 роки тому +23

    4:06 how the heck do you get rodents to do workout sets? They just glossed over this assuming we all know how this happens.

    • @matthewclark7952
      @matthewclark7952 4 роки тому

      Yeah and does it even translate to humans?

    • @billreal8692
      @billreal8692 4 роки тому +1

      Omg you have me rolling. I can't stop laughing.

    • @quert45
      @quert45 4 роки тому

      You should read the article and go through the references

    • @rhejamphi
      @rhejamphi 4 роки тому

      @@quert45 yeah probably. But JC seems to do his homework pretty well.

  • @robertrowe1761
    @robertrowe1761 5 років тому +10

    Nobody:
    Jeff and Jeff: YOU ARE KILLING YOUR GAINS

  • @JuantonZz
    @JuantonZz 2 роки тому

    Jeff can you please answer this for me?
    I've been missing one part to apply all the workout volume knowledge to tweak my routine.
    When you say 10-20 working sets/ muscle/ week:
    Do you mean like the whole muscle group(ex: triceps) ? Or per individual head(lateral. long, medial)?
    HELP PLEASE.
    Love your content so much. I literally tell everyone to look you up. Quality work you're doing. Never stop please.

  • @mgln94562
    @mgln94562 5 років тому +6

    Really appreciate this information. Clears up a lot of confusion I had when it came to volume. Thanks Jeff.

    • @elka7823
      @elka7823 5 років тому

      Marcel Galindo its bs

    • @mgln94562
      @mgln94562 5 років тому

      El Ka I really appreciate your opinion!

  • @Theone99123
    @Theone99123 5 років тому +82

    The study is so bad since the 20 sets were taken to failure !
    It is flawed and i would not take it seriously

    • @Theone99123
      @Theone99123 5 років тому +50

      @Thor Odinson We know that going to failure on every set is bad for you and it will make you lose strength and not progress

    • @Stadics
      @Stadics 5 років тому +23

      That's not a flaw of the study whatsoever. In academia we call this limitations, and they are inevitable if you wan't to study anything specific enough.

    • @spuZDK
      @spuZDK 5 років тому +13

      I tried Jeff's program and saw little to no gains, then I tried Mountain Dog and Chris Jones programs and saw alot more growth! and their training style is higher volume. 20+, RPE 9-10 - It's so individual how you respond to either low or high volume.

    • @kcopara1
      @kcopara1 5 років тому +8

      @Thor Odinson lol no going to failure often is NOT how to build muscle.

    • @Theone99123
      @Theone99123 5 років тому

      @@spuZDK Yes we know higher volume tend to give you a lot of gains as long as you stay at rpe 8-9 for most of the sets

  • @laurentfournier9071
    @laurentfournier9071 5 років тому

    Great video and a good summary of what Mike Israetel mentioned a while ago with MEV (Minimum Effective Volume) and MRV (Maximum Recoverable Volume).

  • @RGV2300
    @RGV2300 5 років тому +10

    Doing 0 sets, which can be the lowest amount of sets you can do, actually gives you the best gains.

  • @isaacchrisman7528
    @isaacchrisman7528 5 років тому +8

    When you recommend those set ranges for muscle groups how do compound movements where the muscle group doesn’t lag fit in? Do they count to the set quantity recommendations?

  • @guillaumevantieghem480
    @guillaumevantieghem480 7 місяців тому

    @JeffNippard I love your content. Jeff Chevalier, Mike and you have given me so much insight regarding training! Thank you!

  • @junit7590
    @junit7590 5 років тому +3

    Hi guys, Jeff here, just wanted to lend my support to Jeff's argument and dispute Jeff's point

  • @nickprouten7762
    @nickprouten7762 3 роки тому +4

    So when you’re referring to sets in training should we be thinking of that 10-20 weekly set range as per muscle group or per individual muscle - for example “hamstring and quads” for 10- sets each or 10 - 20 for your legs over all.
    Thanks for your insight

  • @williamprescott6432
    @williamprescott6432 Рік тому

    Option 5- 1 heavy Chest day/wk 5/6 reps 3-4 sets, 1 lighter weight chest workout 10-12 reps x 6-7 sets. Same for pull and leg days. This is the style not many people mention but it works the best for medium to advanced lifters

  • @TheRealEffluence
    @TheRealEffluence 5 років тому +17

    "The goal is to choke your chicken as frequently as possible" -Jeff Nippard.

    • @-TK-
      @-TK- 5 років тому

      Most will follow this advice cuz its DDD this month

  • @BonDraper
    @BonDraper 5 років тому +11

    has anyone else notice a strong trend lately on people making vids about jeff cavalier or in response to his content.

  • @nataliew9211
    @nataliew9211 5 років тому +2

    Solid video, thanks Jeff! Very helpful & informative. Really respect the work that goes into your content. Been watching and learning from both Jeffs for years now!! 💪🏼

  • @bigsleepy3211
    @bigsleepy3211 5 років тому +7

    Tfw you see the thumbnail from the notification bar and think this is the biggest anime collab of 2k19. Great vid as always though