The sigh after some of these songs hits hard. Pearson doing it at the end of Old Scout's Lament really fucked me up. There's a theory that Pearson was another rat, and the fact that the song weighed heavy on him implies heavy guilt.
@@rykerthemans5867 they did. They aren't voice actors they scted this out like the rest of the game. No different than avatar or planet of the apes. They sat around a fake campfire, enjoying their friends company and sang...❤
@rykerthemans5867 it's great. Also, most games are made this way now. GTA 4, 5? and 6. God Of War, TLOU1&2, Hogwarts Legacy, Horizon Zero Dawn and Forbidden West, Spider-Man 1&2 and Miles Morales... I mean ALLLOOOOOT. The vaaaaast majority of games are all Performance Capture. They do things in the booth, but 95% is with their fellow actors, doing the actions themselves. Like in RDR2, the way the characters walk are all their respective actors walk. Reloading guns, crouch walking, picking up food and supplies, EVERY cutscene, even Javier playing guitar was Performance Capture. Gabriel Sloyer played the guitar (with the little balls on his fingers for Motion Detection, INCREDIBLY IMPRESSIVE) and sang. The party's when you get sean back, and later when you find and return jack. All real🤟🏻 No Performance Captured game has done it better than Rockstar with Red Dead Redemption 2. Best game of all time🙏🏻🤟🏻
i grew up reading Lucky Luke comics with my dad, every comic ends with Luke riding into the sunset singing Poor Lonesome Cowboy, when i heard this in game i got goosebumps and teared up a little bit, thank you Rockstar for letting me relive a bit of my childhood
This will be his track in Rdr3 before they kill him of course but literally putting this in a death scene, man that would be a mega oof even more than Unshaken
I ain’t got no father x3 To buy the clothes I wear I’m a poor lonesome cowboy x3 A long way from home I ain’t got no mother x3 To mend the clothes I wear I’m a poor lonesome cowboy x3 A long way from home I ain’t got no brother x3 To drive the steers with me I’m poor lonesome cowboy x3 A long way from home
Yup I imagine Jack growing up with all those colourful wild people and at the end, before he knows it, he ends up all alone in what it looks like a desert now The contrast eats the soul
Damn this song hits so close to me. I lost both my mother and my father before I was 30 years old. No brothers or sisters. Only two aunts and four cousins which I haven’t seen for about ten years or so. It’s just me, my dog and an old Ford pickup truck….. It’s so strange, we was a big family when I was young. But drugs and alcohol sealed the fates of most of my family. I was the lucky one and turned away from those vices.
@tommyanderson1040 there is a song by Nick Shoulders called "Blue Endless HIghway" that mentions "nobody but my truck and me", check it out. You'll prob like that too.
I lost both parents at 30 6 of us lived in the apartment when i was a kid 4 died and 1 left All alone now 😂 It feels as if it was never real, and I just made it up out of boredom in a dark room
Jack marston is just depressing to play as. His life was taken away from him because a old man wanted profit. I’m really hoping he became a writer and stopped following his fathers mistake to repeat because the antagonistic lines he makes in the game just make me upset on what Ross made of him.
@ProGamer absolutely not, there's huge inconsistences that break this idea, such as the existence of new york and california in RDR universe instead of liberty city and the state of san andreas, among others. plus gta is in a completely different tone than red dead other than IV. You do not know what you're talking about
This song is for Arthur Morgan. A man who has been willing to risk his life for the gang for decades, and ran with only one goal to achieve the dreams of both Dutch and gang members, regardless of big things, small things, or even dirty things. In addition, he has lived for the safety of his colleagues, whether he did good or evil, and eventually saved his colleagues who could be saved by his death, showing the more profound character of a human being in the world between good and evil.
my friend, I'm moving to another continent soon, on my own, all by myself. I was playing some red dead enjoying my last weeks at home, with my mother, my family, my videogames and the life I had so far and I heard this song in the background at the camp, and it touched me. I'm already getting emotional imagining myself listening to this when I'm all alone and thousands of miles from home. your hard work to get this song in high quality is very much appreciated, I thank you a lot for this
Beautiful, wow... Thank you so much. It's really humbling to know that I helped you so much! I hope you find what you are looking for in life! where are you going to? If you don't mind me asking?
@@aw2584what do you mean "with this attitude you'll be fighting to go back in a month or two"? you don't know me nor my situation. that was A MOMENT where i felt touched by the song, it doesnt mean that I'm weak and even less that i have everything in brazil. this indeed was disrespectful and salty of you
@@spikey288 I've had this game since release and literally just now I saw this happen in game. What a beautiful game this is, this scene is so unnecessary and adds zero to the story but it was so wholesome I couldn't believe it
Doubt. Given, well, his entire life basically, I doubt he has a very high opinion of the US army or the government in general. And given his upbringing and the time period it's doubtful there's any public record of him that would get him put on the draft rolls.
the original song has two extra parts: I ain't got no sister, To go and play with me. I ain't got no sweetheart, To sit and talk with me. (maybe you can sing it in your head, what is that, an extra 40 seconds?
So glad I heard this before I was headed out from camp to Valentine for a shot of whiskey! I stayed around hoping they would sing again but no.. now I'm here !
When I heard this for the first time in the game, I had just finished the camp request where Abigail asks for 5 dollars to buy Jack new clothes, and this song reminded me of Jack in the end of RDR1. No mother, father, or brothers to help him along his life.
2022 has bin a tough year lost both my parents dont speak to any family recovering from alcoholisim and homelessnes. This hits hard but RDR2 always is there to get me trough the pain 💪❤️
I genuinely, with all my heart, believe Red Dead Redemption 2 will be better than GTA 6. The family feel to the gang, the comradery, the singing, the dancing, the drinking, the ups and downs of it all, is all too real...Something I feel Jason and Lucia simply won't have.
I know the tune by the name of "Go tell aunt rhody" and I used to play a lot on the violin with some friends years ago. When I first saw this on the game, it brought me so much memories. Its so good when a game makes you fell like that
I usually don't share things like this but recently I've felt so bad and worthless just thinking of nothing good but this is one of the songs I really find comforting
Almost started tearing up during this, i was playing missions in the last chapter where arthur is alive. Seeing the entire gang start falling apart while listening to this hurts
“I ain’t got no brother I ain’t got no brother I ain’t got no brother to play Red Dead Online wit me I’m a poor lonesome Outlaw poor lonesome Outlaw poor lonesome Outlaw who hopes the new update is fixes everything” 😂🤣💀 thank you for putting this up this song is smooth
This is why I'm staying in chapter 2 John can wait in Valentine for me all he wants I'm creating an alternative save. I I was mixing tonics to sell. Then I heard the song from afar I sat down and listened to it makes me wish Arthur could joined and sang along to.
I ain't got no father, I ain't got no father, I ain't got no father, To buy the clothes I wear. I'm a poor lonesome cowboy, (3x) And a long ways from home. I ain't got no mother, (3x) To mend the clothes I wear. I'm a poor lonesome cowboy, (3x) And a long ways from home. I ain't got no brother, (3x) To drive the steers with me. I'm a poor lonesome cowboy, (3x) And a long ways from home. *Deep breath*
Thank you for this my friend. I’ve been listening to the audio people recorded in the game, but they’re not as refined as this one. Where did it come from?
@@urbexventure i saw a few instrumental versions of songs. But it takes a really long time to actually go through all the files, find the right omes, name them, post ect. So im not going to do it. I will however help you do it if you would like.. Let me know if this is something you would like to do and ill give you an email to contact me on.
@@KalmanfMusicChannel At the moment I only have the game for the PlayStation 4, but I will definitely buy it for my PC in the near future! Once I've bought the game for the PC, I'll just get back to you!
Mama's dont let your babies grow up to be cowboy's
EHHH Waylon 🤌🫡
Outlaws*
karen's little chuckle while singing "i ain't got no mother". it's little details like this that make the game so good. so subtle but so good
The deep breathe at the end means a lot. Despite all the shit, they trudge on. Helping and leaning on each other. A family in all but name.
Inflection is key
@@Lamadamadingdonn Both of you are true chads
The sigh after some of these songs hits hard. Pearson doing it at the end of Old Scout's Lament really fucked me up. There's a theory that Pearson was another rat, and the fact that the song weighed heavy on him implies heavy guilt.
But he wouldn't fight in WW1
@@jacoboakes6896wait what?!
When I played, Arthur just humms to the song.... this game is so detailed holy
With my Arthur he hums on the “I ain’t got no……” parts and sings the “I’m a poor lonesome cowboy” parts.
@@ChocolatePiazza he forgot the rest of the words lmao
I think it's effected by alcohol amount and moral. The game his LITTERED with little secret details and intricacies
I think that he doesn’t like to sing this part because he doesn’t have father and mother really.
@@ChocolatePiazzathats cause arthur slowly learns the lyrics! Isnt that cool
0:42 that chuckle Karen does makes it so realistic like they really sang it at a camp
Gonna hold your hand when I say this
@@streamsnipe4079 he meant the voice actors singing it at a camp.
@@rykerthemans5867 they did. They aren't voice actors they scted this out like the rest of the game. No different than avatar or planet of the apes. They sat around a fake campfire, enjoying their friends company and sang...❤
@@brandonpowell3254 thats really cool! i didnt know that. Thank you for correcting me,
@rykerthemans5867 it's great. Also, most games are made this way now. GTA 4, 5? and 6. God Of War, TLOU1&2, Hogwarts Legacy, Horizon Zero Dawn and Forbidden West, Spider-Man 1&2 and Miles Morales... I mean ALLLOOOOOT. The vaaaaast majority of games are all Performance Capture. They do things in the booth, but 95% is with their fellow actors, doing the actions themselves.
Like in RDR2, the way the characters walk are all their respective actors walk. Reloading guns, crouch walking, picking up food and supplies, EVERY cutscene, even Javier playing guitar was Performance Capture. Gabriel Sloyer played the guitar (with the little balls on his fingers for Motion Detection, INCREDIBLY IMPRESSIVE) and sang. The party's when you get sean back, and later when you find and return jack. All real🤟🏻
No Performance Captured game has done it better than Rockstar with Red Dead Redemption 2. Best game of all time🙏🏻🤟🏻
i grew up reading Lucky Luke comics with my dad, every comic ends with Luke riding into the sunset singing Poor Lonesome Cowboy, when i heard this in game i got goosebumps and teared up a little bit, thank you Rockstar for letting me relive a bit of my childhood
Same thing I was thinking
@@hotcosby4249 Chads
I remember the calamity Jane one very vividly, shame gave those away at school. Would like to a revisit them again
you know lucky luke it's belgian
i had the same youth, my father died 5 years ago and this brought many memories flooding back
This should be jacks theme in red dead 1 at the end 💀
:(
Oh god that some dark shit
It's realy made for him
this and deadmans gun 😢
This will be his track in Rdr3 before they kill him of course
but literally putting this in a death scene, man that would be a mega oof even more than Unshaken
0:43
The little chuckle Karen does is sad
It's funny cuz most of these hang members don't have parents anymore
after that im gonna antagonize karen instead of greet
I was already antagonizing since chapter 6 but I will antagonize her in every chapter.
@@zhongxina2967why?
I ain’t got no father x3
To buy the clothes I wear
I’m a poor lonesome cowboy x3
A long way from home
I ain’t got no mother x3
To mend the clothes I wear
I’m a poor lonesome cowboy x3
A long way from home
I ain’t got no brother x3
To drive the steers with me
I’m poor lonesome cowboy x3
A long way from home
I read the x3 as a face😭
This is the saddest, rootinest, tootinest campfire song in the whole game
Yup I imagine Jack growing up with all those colourful wild people and at the end, before he knows it, he ends up all alone in what it looks like a desert now
The contrast eats the soul
Damn this song hits so close to me. I lost both my mother and my father before I was 30 years old. No brothers or sisters. Only two aunts and four cousins which I haven’t seen for about ten years or so. It’s just me, my dog and an old Ford pickup truck….. It’s so strange, we was a big family when I was young. But drugs and alcohol sealed the fates of most of my family. I was the lucky one and turned away from those vices.
You comment got me teared up , i really wish you the best in your life and i hope you find a women to start a new family with
Good luck king
@tommyanderson1040 there is a song by Nick Shoulders called "Blue Endless HIghway" that mentions "nobody but my truck and me", check it out. You'll prob like that too.
Hope you and your dog are staying warm this winter❤
Hope you're in a good place one year on
I lost both parents at 30
6 of us lived in the apartment when i was a kid 4 died and 1 left
All alone now 😂
It feels as if it was never real, and I just made it up out of boredom in a dark room
This song really feels like a song about Jack Marston
Jack marston is just depressing to play as. His life was taken away from him because a old man wanted profit.
I’m really hoping he became a writer and stopped following his fathers mistake to repeat because the antagonistic lines he makes in the game just make me upset on what Ross made of him.
@ProGamer not canon. gta and rdr are not the same universe
@ProGamer absolutely not, there's huge inconsistences that break this idea, such as the existence of new york and california in RDR universe instead of liberty city and the state of san andreas, among others. plus gta is in a completely different tone than red dead other than IV. You do not know what you're talking about
@@blake2521 I can totally see Jack enlisting for WW1 and lay down his life in a trench somewhere in the Belgian Argonnes.
Back then you can't be enlisted in the military if you owned a farm back in 1917, and since he did I don't think they would accept him@@Exodon2020
It’s a good thing your doing for the outlaw community
🥃🔥
who just searched this up because you were in your camp and heard this
Howdy
Yes
Me
On 2nd playthrough. Definitely hit harder
It was quite fitting too cause they started singing while Dutch was talking around a campfire that they need to hold onto hope and their dreams!
This song is for Arthur Morgan.
A man who has been willing to risk his life for the gang for decades, and ran with only one goal to achieve the dreams of both Dutch and gang members, regardless of big things, small things, or even dirty things.
In addition, he has lived for the safety of his colleagues, whether he did good or evil, and eventually saved his colleagues who could be saved by his death, showing the more profound character of a human being in the world between good and evil.
That's an interesting way to look at it, but I always thought of this as Jack's song, for obvious resons💔
my friend, I'm moving to another continent soon, on my own, all by myself. I was playing some red dead enjoying my last weeks at home, with my mother, my family, my videogames and the life I had so far and I heard this song in the background at the camp, and it touched me. I'm already getting emotional imagining myself listening to this when I'm all alone and thousands of miles from home. your hard work to get this song in high quality is very much appreciated, I thank you a lot for this
Beautiful, wow... Thank you so much. It's really humbling to know that I helped you so much! I hope you find what you are looking for in life! where are you going to? If you don't mind me asking?
not a problem at all! I'm from Brazil and I'm moving to Portugal as soon as I finish my driving school, which takes a few months here
@@MortMausoleum I wish you all the strength and luck in the world, and your absolutely right this song is incredibly touching
@@aw2584what do you mean "with this attitude you'll be fighting to go back in a month or two"? you don't know me nor my situation. that was A MOMENT where i felt touched by the song, it doesnt mean that I'm weak and even less that i have everything in brazil. this indeed was disrespectful and salty of you
@@MortMausoleum I wish you all the luck in the world friend .
Still don't know which version I prefer, the one where Arthur joins in or just the duet of Pearson and Karen
To me the one with Arthur is definetely better. He has a low voice so it really makes the song feel...idk full
@@nonstop7408 yeah I like it too, but I also love the gentleness of Pearson and Karen's voices together, without the bass.
@@spikey288 I've had this game since release and literally just now I saw this happen in game. What a beautiful game this is, this scene is so unnecessary and adds zero to the story but it was so wholesome I couldn't believe it
@@zh2266 I'd say it adds quite a bit to the story actually, but yeah, it's really beautiful.
@@spikey288 by adds zero to the story I mean the overall narrative stays the exact same whether you come across this song or not.
The sigh at the end makes you realise the shit the gang went through and the huge bond they share
It’s crazy how good this game is, so many things that make it my favourite game of all time.
100%
Agreed.
Just imagine jack singing this in a trench with all his friends as they fight in ww1
lol, I'm a hedge BF1 fanboy! I can imagine this with ease.
I really think that could make a good rdr3
😭
Doubt. Given, well, his entire life basically, I doubt he has a very high opinion of the US army or the government in general. And given his upbringing and the time period it's doubtful there's any public record of him that would get him put on the draft rolls.
Imagine thinking jack would fight in ww1😂
this is my favorite campfire song.
This song makes me feel a damn near inexplicable sadness
literally cried first time i heard this in the game
i wish this is longer!
the original song has two extra parts:
I ain't got no sister,
To go and play with me.
I ain't got no sweetheart,
To sit and talk with me.
(maybe you can sing it in your head, what is that, an extra 40 seconds?
This is my drinking alone theme :)
Don´t hesitate brother! Life can turn at any moment but sometimes we have to steer a little bit into that direction.
It’s insane that this gang still feels like family…all those years later
Poor Jack. I dont think i could stay at brechers hope if i was him, too many memories
So glad I heard this before I was headed out from camp to Valentine for a shot of whiskey! I stayed around hoping they would sing again but no.. now I'm here !
Thank you so much for this.
I feel like as I grow older this song will hit a lot harder
Did it ?
When I heard this for the first time in the game, I had just finished the camp request where Abigail asks for 5 dollars to buy Jack new clothes, and this song reminded me of Jack in the end of RDR1. No mother, father, or brothers to help him along his life.
I don’t even know why this song is so beautiful to me. I’m not even a yank, it just feels right
That deep breath, in the end, reflects the difficult situation the gang is
2022 has bin a tough year lost both my parents dont speak to any family recovering from alcoholisim and homelessnes. This hits hard but RDR2 always is there to get me trough the pain 💪❤️
Relatable
Finally someone uploaded the clean game file version! :D
Now if only there was a vers that included Arthur's singing too
thank u for uploading this, this has been one of the only things to calm me down rn
I genuinely, with all my heart, believe Red Dead Redemption 2 will be better than GTA 6. The family feel to the gang, the comradery, the singing, the dancing, the drinking, the ups and downs of it all, is all too real...Something I feel Jason and Lucia simply won't have.
Most relatable song by far, my mom passed away last month, my dad might be going to jail, and my brother is quite a while away
at least the pain is here and you aren’t anticipating the bad anymore because it already happened
how you doing brother
please someone add this to spotify
I know the tune by the name of "Go tell aunt rhody" and I used to play a lot on the violin with some friends years ago. When I first saw this on the game, it brought me so much memories. Its so good when a game makes you fell like that
I can imagine this song playing when John in rdr1 peeks through the door way, which Ross is on the other side of.
Nah I cried enough I'd like to have eyes when rdr3 comes out one day
I usually don't share things like this but recently I've felt so bad and worthless just thinking of nothing good but this is one of the songs I really find comforting
Thank you sir
I love now and forever RDR2
You're a god damn hero.
the guitar made me burst out into tears for no reason
sir, I'm very thankful that you uploaded this!
rode through the grizzlies to this and a tear fell down my face
Everyone thinks this is jacks theme but clearly this is every gang members theme, they're all poor cowboys
I need a 10 hour version of this
Damn i feel bad for the vanderlind gang members:(
Almost cry here
Jo Armeniox’s vocal talents are astonishing
Karen is such a underrated character 💔
Almost started tearing up during this, i was playing missions in the last chapter where arthur is alive. Seeing the entire gang start falling apart while listening to this hurts
rd2 is a masterpiece
Thank you for this good sir.
Just got through the main story on my playthrough and I already miss the campfires and unity of the gang, I know John misses it❤️
The Red Dead Redemption duology is my favorite story of all time
“I ain’t got no brother I ain’t got no brother I ain’t got no brother to play Red Dead Online wit me I’m a poor lonesome Outlaw poor lonesome Outlaw poor lonesome Outlaw who hopes the new update is fixes everything” 😂🤣💀 thank you for putting this up this song is smooth
Pearson voice is beautiful.
Is it Pearson or John cuz I can't tell Thier voices apart
It's beautiful and sad as hell. That sigh at the end gets me😢
Pearson really has great voice. He be hitting them notes
Go tell Aunt Rhody, go tell Aunt Rho---
_OH WAIT, wrong song!_
REvil guy hu? 😉
The last breath. I can't take It.
Legendary
This is perfect for Jack Marston
The quality is so amazing, thank you for this. Are there versions of these campfire songs with Arthur's singing as well that's also this high-quality?
I didn't find his voice track in the files, find it and I'll add it :)
@@KalmanfMusicChannel ah, that's too bad. I don't really know how to even go about looking for those files, unfortunately.
When I hear this, I feel like a camera is zooming in slowly in my face
literally describing jack's life
Thank you sir for this
This is art..
i love the Campsfire songs, this game is so beautiful
This is why I'm staying in chapter 2 John can wait in Valentine for me all he wants I'm creating an alternative save. I I was mixing tonics to sell. Then I heard the song from afar I sat down and listened to it makes me wish Arthur could joined and sang along to.
amazing
After 5 years
What a song
never thought id cry over a damn video game
Thank you 🙏
Heard this one ingame for the first time today
Beautiful song
Jeez
Took me 2 years to find it in camp
Worth it
I ain't got no father,
I ain't got no father,
I ain't got no father,
To buy the clothes I wear.
I'm a poor lonesome cowboy, (3x)
And a long ways from home.
I ain't got no mother, (3x)
To mend the clothes I wear.
I'm a poor lonesome cowboy, (3x)
And a long ways from home.
I ain't got no brother, (3x)
To drive the steers with me.
I'm a poor lonesome cowboy, (3x)
And a long ways from home.
*Deep breath*
we can all copy paste
me listening to this stitching a hole in my pants with no idea how to do so
Arthur was a poor lonesome cowboy 😢
This music is a reference to Jack at the end if rdr1 lmao not Arthur
Yeah because he totally didn’t run a gang with like 20 people in it
@T Dog I’d agree if you were able to have followers in camp. It gets lonely talking to your horse lol.
Nah Arthur died knowing he had a brother and that was John so he wasn’t alone
Thank you for this my friend. I’ve been listening to the audio people recorded in the game, but they’re not as refined as this one. Where did it come from?
In the description 😊
@@KalmanfMusicChannel Appreciate your work. Thank you again. I don’t think Rockstar will release this officially
@@KalmanfMusicChannel Would it work for you to datamine the instrumental songs from the game
@@urbexventure i saw a few instrumental versions of songs. But it takes a really long time to actually go through all the files, find the right omes, name them, post ect. So im not going to do it. I will however help you do it if you would like.. Let me know if this is something you would like to do and ill give you an email to contact me on.
@@KalmanfMusicChannel At the moment I only have the game for the PlayStation 4, but I will definitely buy it for my PC in the near future! Once I've bought the game for the PC, I'll just get back to you!
Thank a lot sir.
Currently in an Crisis stabilization unit I'm hurtin real bad
I will sing this to my children
this game is a fucking masterpiece!!
Just moved down south left my family up north. This song is hitting different now.
HOW IS THIS NOT ON SPOTIFY
This is my morning song
it sounds so strange without Arthur's voice
I feel that sigh everytime
This is Jack Marston theme song in 1914
Remembers me "Go Tell Aunt Rody"
Babg bang unlucky arthur
cover of go tell aunt rhody!! sounds amazing, i got the game for nearly 2 years and this is the first time hearing it, strange
Beginning reminds me a little of Leaves From the Vine
same here old friend...
Does anyone know what cords Javier plays, I really want to sing this in my local bar
That's very touching... I searching for this long time. Thanks for uploading 🙏