You did let him talk a bit so your not too bad. Just let people finish their points, before interjecting. I don't agree with his Talmud stuff but he is right on Zionism.
@@jakenewfield thanks, I will watch it all. despite of what people say in comments I think you did a good job as an interviewer in spite of your difference in opinion of your guest. I worked in a public radio for years and made many interviews myself, it's not very easy.
defending israel is defending the indefensible. The amount of vids out there that shows their politicians and population saying and doing nasty things since the regime existed is mind blowing! Traditional western media outlets really tried so hard to under report and hide all of that for so many years and just tells you the paycheck is huge.
Jake you are a terrible interviewer, let the man talk. Edit: After seeing the purpose of his channel and the full video, I get why he interviews like this, His goal is to challenge the views of the people he interviews in order to understand them. Which is fair I guess.
Honestly he's okay, and he seems to be letting him talk (at least from what I saw in this segment). Piers Morgan sometimes interupt people after he asks his own question, he doesn't even let them breath.
When idiot listen to minority Rabbi who represents less than 1% of Jews and idiot says this Rabbi is taught by God, Jewish people across the globe spit laugh their Matzah soup into their computer screens.
What a respectful knowledgable Rabbi. As a Muslim he earned my highest respect. He explained exactly the difference between Judaism and Zionism. A point I tried to make to so many people but they failed to understand but this Rabbi explained it perfectly. Judaism isn’t Zionist and making this point clear reduced antisemitism around the world because Israel doesn’t represent all the Jews neither do they represent the true meaning of Judaism. God bless your soul Rabbi.
You’re not wrong. With respect, in my opinion, Zionism and Judaism are intertwined with pretty much all Ashkenazi and I can’t speak for Sephardic but I’m sure it’s the same. I think Israel should exist hence I’m a Zionist I guess.
@@Mikehartman4747 no one said that Jews shouldn’t have a land even though it’s weird to take people from all over the world with different traditions and languages and backgrounds because they share a religion! But this land should never be build at someone else’s expense
@@davidsher5483why? Everyone think they can criticize Islam and Muslims on every platform and all over the world! And Israel is a freaking country not even a religion it should be criticized
Facts. As Muslims we have no issues with the Jews. Its zionism. And zionism (which is a form of political and extremist Judaism) as with Islamic extremism and Hindutva along with Nazism are all dangerous for the human race.
What language did we speak? Hebrew. When? I don't know. Thats the problem jake. You refuse to be educated by the people you bring on. Why have them on if you refuse to humble yourself.
This Rabbi represents a tiny percentage of Jews. There might be 50,000 of these lunatics in the world today. 98/100 Rabbis would call everything this man said false and they would back it up with Torah, Talmud and Maimonides. Jews are not pacifists. Never were and never will be. If we were, we'd be long dead. We are fighters and we don't put our lives in the hands of God. We put our lives in our own hands. Shalom. Am Israel Chai!
@@Thegabub Modern day Zionists dont have to know a day thing about Jewish/Levantine/Palestinian history to be a Zionist. its an irrational position. Nothing has to matter.
@greybushMEproductions 1- The Basic Law states that the right to national self-determination in Palestine "is unique to the Jewish People" 2- The Jews around the world had no common culture or language for thousands of years. 3- The state you support claims that it is a country to people who are already citizens to other countries and had never set foot or had any cultural relation to this nationality. Here are your 3 facts.
I'd give the man a chance. He still let's the Rabbi talk and also, who else is interviewing people like this Rabbi? I think you're looking at a young, immature truth seeker, not one of those funded, little Shapiros. Just my thought for the moment
Shhh, you silly person! you're obviously too old to really get the whole social media thing, huh? Jake can set the format any way he wants! Its his channel! I guess you're thinking of a Larry King thing or something, right grandma?
@@keereekeeCalm down there child it's about listening and asking questions waiting on answers it's a interview?? No need to throw a temper tantrum child do u need a baba???
Are you for real? The host is not debating him. He is asking for clarification of terms that the rabbi is using -- often incorrectly! -- in mounting his argument. If you have read anything by Shapiro, you will see he uses this tactic there too. Many of the the deceptive tactics Shapiro (no, I will not use the title "rabbi") uses involve substituting two different English terms for a single Hebrew word. The different meanings of the English terms can then be used to construct a false contradiction that does not in fact inhere in the Hebrew term. It is the fact that he tends to do this primarily with biblical Hebrew terms to construct an intentionally deceptive polemic that cause me to seriously question his legitimacy as a "rabbi." A simple example: am/עם means both "a people" and "a nation," and by extension an "ethnicity," (though the latter, even in English, is of recent academic coinage). "Am Israel"/עם ישראל refers to the totality of Jewish people, the nation associated with them and includes nuances underscored by the modern concept of ethnicity. By substituting the words "Jews," "Nation" and "ethnicity" for the single Jewish term, Shapiro is able to construct a false contradiction as these words in English intersect only in a limited sense, and can even be all three mutually exclusive. Shapiro is, in short, a bad actor and an intellectual impostor. He does, however, have great appeal for rabid anti-semites and not a few self-loathing, textually illiterate Jews. Imagine him without the beard, the rabbi schtick, in a corduroy jacket with elbow patches holding office hours as a professor in a left leaning sociology department underwritten by Qatar or Saudia Arabia or even the Muslim Brotherhood, and you've already seen deeper into who this man really is and what he stands for. There is only one word to describe this man -- shanda! שאנדע!!!
10:42 he's concentrating/ listening intently. You must have been watching a different interview. Be thankful he invited such a well informed and eloquent guest. In addition , the sound and visuals are very good (more than one camera angle etc)
@@ahmarfarooki No it is not. But if you want to hear another JEW who is also ANTI NAZI ZIONIST listen to Mike Peled. He absolutely destroys Jake (willfully blind zionist). Mike clearly states, "The state of Israel is a CRIME". He wrote The General's Son and he also states clearly (when he lived in Israel) that the death of his niece is ISRAEL's FAULT! ua-cam.com/video/fNlBACOUX6g/v-deo.html
The Rabbi has a very good grasp of societal framing. Most people lack an ability to engage on more than one or two logical planes, but he describes his ethic well. The host was being a little bit of jerk who seemed he could not quite grasp what was being said.
Rabbi "when did we speak Hebrew" Newfield " a while ago i don't know" "for thousands of years Jews have not speaking Hebrew" "they had no flag, they had no national anthem, land language or culture" scorecard Pope +1 , Jake -2 Rabbi +5 Netanyahu -100000000000000000000
@@matijamatt693 there's no conclusion, apart from the ongoing obvious reality that Israel justifies a European expansive colonial genocidal project by using Judaism as its moral support system, while simultaneously ignoring and undermining the chief credo's of Judaism. or do you just want a simple equation? ok then zionism = anti-semitism
Common sense! LOL. What facts? I must have missed them. The fact that God will protect Jews from radical Islamists terrorist so long as they pray to God? Please, tell me all the facts that make common sense to you Abdul. I bet you can't name one common sense fact this lunatic mentioned.
I am appreciative that youtube algorithms bring me this wisdom. Knows my heart. I am 61 years old born in the United States of America and the plight of the Palestinians has been heavy on my heart my entire life. In fact, when I was young I would tell people I wanted to make it big so I could help all the refugees. Unfortunately I have not made it big but seeing what is happening in the music industry perhaps it's a good thing I did not. There is still hope that I will live to see these atrocities end and the Palestinians lives begin renewed.
I’m Greek Orthodox born In Gaza and my family lived in Gaza for generations. I can assure you isrl treated us much better than msl ever did. Infact it’s a religious duty for mslms for wage wr on isrl . Don’t believe their propaganda
Noor means light btw for who doesn’t know, and it is true god bless this noble descent rabbi, and all Jews who suffer so much when they speak for justice
He's wrong on a small technicality but generally he is right. Abrogation (نسخ) is a term in Islam that refers to how the rules change. Between Islam and Judaism, some rules are the same and others are overwritten. It's even mentioned in Surat Al Baqarah verse 106.
@ the verse u used is completely wrong. Whatever a verse do Naskh is „whatever an ayah we erase“. This refers to the verses that were forgotten, therefore Allah also mentions in multiple places in the quran that he will replace it with a better one. No changing from judaism. Islam has its own sharia.
@@Abu3ilmsince Mohammed was illiterate, the Quran wasn't written for over 100 years after his death. Most of the notes used were piecemeal and written by scribes. A lot of what Mohammed knew came from his family's worship of a Moon god and what he heard from Rabbis and Christian preachers who's sermins came from the Torah. .
Not really. He's quite insane and ignores Torah and Talmud. Jews don't pray to God to save them from Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran, we have Israel and ourselves for that. Thanks!
At 6.45 or so, the Rabbi hits the nail on the head: it's about so-called nation-states, a concept developed in the 18t/19th Centuries. No nation-State has ever confined itself to one religion.
This interviewer’s ignorance, and inability to understand and listen are frustrating. But to call the Rabbi “anti-Israel” makes the ignorance and framing deliberate. What a fascinating guest.
The word antisemitic holds very little to no importance anymore, considering its a cheap copout tactic commonly used by israelis to absolve themselves of any blame
Mind Begs the Question: ▪︎If Nazis escaped ▪︎Embed in another Nation,Religion ▪︎Rename their Political Movement ▪︎Can't be recognized ▪︎Can be recognized by Matching Policies ▪︎Superior Race ideology,Dehumanization,Starvation,Concentration Camps,Gassing (White Phosphorus),Pogroms,Ethnic Cleansing,etc?
Former Nazis where put in all kinds of positions of power. maybe not directly Israel, but we took them in for NASA, some in west Germany government, high positions in NATO and the EU too.
Respectfully, 2 things are wrong here that should be addressed. Number 1 is you have to give your guests a platform to speak without the interruptions. Make physical notes or mental notes to address after the point is made. Number 2 is that the video needs to be relabeled. This isn't an "anti-Israel rabbi", this is just a standard rabbi or standard Jew since anybody worth their salt knows that Israel is not supposed to exist, knows that the jews have been in exile for 3,200 years and knows that they're forbidden from returning to the land until the mashiach brings them into the land. So, no, this isn't an anti-Israel Jew. The jews WANT Israel.. we also want to observe God's law and word so, going there right now is forbidden. Who doesn't know this?
According to Islam. The children of Israel enjoy a special status in the Islamic holy book, the Quran (2:47 and 2:122). However, Muslim scholars point out that this status did not confer upon Israelites any racial superiority, and was only valid so long as the Israelites maintain their covenant with God.
What modern jews won't tell you is that the Israelites got deported and bred out of existence in 721BC by the Akkadians. Jews are the descendants of the judean elite that got deported to Babylon, they're not Israelites. Modern Ashkenazi jews have eastern European DNA and are not Semitic, have no relation to ancient Israelites(or jews) and had never been to the middle east before 1917.
LOL. Tell that to the Moroccans, Greeks, Russians, Austrians and Norwegians! Who drove all the Jews out of their countries! BTW, there are about 500 Jews in Norway. Ethnically speaking Jews are Jews, that's why when we take DNA tests, it comes back and says we are Jewish!
@ yes some places have more than others- some hasidic can say they are more jewish than others still jews are unconquerable, not a race like WW2 tried to convince people and polarize the world vs judaism.
@@richardparker7121 Nope, not many at all in Norway, but far more than in Iraq Syria, Gaza, West Bank, Jordan and Lebanon. combined! I think there are about 37 Jews spread throughout that latter group of fantastic places to live. I could be off by 2 or 3, or even as many as 10, not entirely sure
@@greybushMEproductionsare you just blatantly making thing up? It takes less than 5 seconds in google to confirm over 400,000 Jews live in settlements in the West Bank alone.
To clarify: abrogation doesn't mean the God gave the same laws from the Bible to Muhammad peace be upon him. Abrogation refers to the replacement of a previous religious ruling with a new one. The previous one was acceptable at the previous time, but now a new law is given by God which is the law from now on. Not necessarily the same as saying "God took the Laws from the Bible and gave them to Muhammad peace be upon him". Verses were abrogated even within the Prophet's lifetime and it doesn't necessarily refer to the Bible vs Quran. It's more so referring to the Quran verses being abrogated throughout the Prophet's lifetime. In the last year of the Prophet's (peace be upon him) life, the abger Gabriel instructed the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) to recite the whole Quran from start to finish multiple times. This meant that at the time of the Prophet's (peace be upon him) death, the whole Quran was confirmed as the complete word of God, verified through Gabriel (AS), and this complete Quran had been memorized and written down WITHIN the Prophet's (peace be upon him) lifetime. Hope that helps.
This is Jake guy that i come across on youtube turned out to be a novice. Dude stfu, let your guest finish his thoughts. You’re not listening, thats why you cant’t seem to grasp what he’s saying even though what he’s saying are facts.
When the teacher speaks it’s better to listen and learn than to chirp and chatter. This wise man taught me something in this clip and I’m grateful for it.
Forget about American jews who are referred to citizens of Israel, our politicians' campaigns based on who loves Israel more than the other rather than their allegiance to America 🇺🇸
Trump telling Americans jews that Netanyahu is their prime minister is wild it’s like saying to Muslim Americans that the king of Saudi Arabia is your king or telling American christians that the pope is their ruler I don’t think American jews accept that maybe American AIPAC jews but not regular people.
A very thoughtful theologian who is clearly in a different intellectual league than the person interviewing him. Even if I didn't agree with his politics, I very much respect that he's morally consistent and fights to see his faith/identity as a responsibility rather than a privilege or entitlement. I'm eager to read more of his writings.
Am I the only one cringing over the fact that Jake has so much trouble comprehending sn in depth explanation. He just stares with this dazed confused look. Smart guy explaining something to him is new. Omg I can't 😂😂😂
Agree with the rabbi. There is no single nation for any other religion or race. For example, India is not the country for all indian, or even all hindu.
8:30 The jews also have this thing called the abrogation. Moses pbuh took the sharia(law) from the previos prophets and things got changed and added and it became the Torah. Abrogation has been going on since Adam, the first prophet.
@@ronaldtoran4332the torah existed because the torah was dent down by the same god all prophets n muslims worshipped. even moses worshipped one god alone just like the muslims. moses himself was one
@@FarhanMehmood LOL Moses was Muslim? That' funny considering Islam didn't exist during the time of Moses! Hard to be a Muslim before the creation of Islam.
I'm in the UK from the UK. I would hate it if everyone here was a white Christian diversity is a good thing. I drive a foreign car, eat foreign food, listen to foreign music, and wear foreign clothes. Water non-indigenous plants. Without diversity, life would be boring.
It may be more enlightening to ask clarifying or expanding questions if you want to explore the topic or his perspective. Once you hear his whole position you can disagree and question parts but it didn't seem like you were interested to hear him out and it sounds like he has a lot to teach
Torah supports Zionism 100%. In the book of Ezekiel it discusses gathering all the Jews in the Diaspora and bringing them back to their homes in Israel! Jews are not and never were pacifists and nothing in Judaism requires Jews be pacifist. Quite the opposite is true. Judaism requires that you kill whoever seeks to kill you! The Talmud states, "If someone comes to kill you, rise early to kill him first" (Sanhedrin 72a). This principle underscores the moral and halachic legitimacy in Judaism of preemptive and defensive actions against existential threats.
Ngl man if you were pro-Israel and I expect learned on its history, you would’ve known that Hebrew was largely a ceremonial/religious language while Yiddish and Aramaic were spoken. Hell, literally the most famous Jewish man, Christ, spoke Aramaic. Hebrew as a viable modern language didn’t exist before the modern establishment of Israel, and was adapted from its historical origin by a Jewish nationalist who immigrated to PaIestine and designed it into a language suited for modern use during the creation of Israel. All of this is pretty easily accessible information on a couple of google searches. I’m literally a Muslim dawg you should be the one knowing this
Yup you can’t convert to being Italian, Spanish, German, etc simple and concise way to refute the race or nationality argument. It’s mind boggling the arrogance to think bc your religion tells you that you’re the chosen one, you’re now a nationality and ethnically related people. Despite where you and your family are from
The host doesn’t even know what rights non-Jewish citizens have or have not. ”You can be in the Knesset, there are Arabs in the Knesset…” But as the rabbi states: they do not have SELFDETERMINATION
@rachael_grey that is what most people have, most people don't want destruction of Israel either. It is opposition of its expansion aka greater Israel project.
Watch the full interview here: ua-cam.com/video/StyCnFMGfrQ/v-deo.html
The JEWS were called by YWY to be the best among us. But now they have become the enemy of humanity.
Did you know that Hitler nearest people were Swedish zionists.
You did let him talk a bit so your not too bad. Just let people finish their points, before interjecting. I don't agree with his Talmud stuff but he is right on Zionism.
@@jakenewfield thanks, I will watch it all. despite of what people say in comments I think you did a good job as an interviewer in spite of your difference in opinion of your guest. I worked in a public radio for years and made many interviews myself, it's not very easy.
defending israel is defending the indefensible. The amount of vids out there that shows their politicians and population saying and doing nasty things since the regime existed is mind blowing! Traditional western media outlets really tried so hard to under report and hide all of that for so many years and just tells you the paycheck is huge.
This rabbi not only makes undeniable arguments against Zionism, he commands my respect for Judaism
Bingo!
Great comment
@vanessac1965 are you Jewish?
Ageeed. And many of usjews feel this way, it's not just him, far from it
He makes me understand that self hatred is a losers game. Hes a a fool.
The Jews who stand against Zionism renew my faith in humanity
Same thought.
Nah, those people are morons.
And mine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Me2
... I CARE NOT NO MORE NO MORE
Jake you are a terrible interviewer, let the man talk.
Edit: After seeing the purpose of his channel and the full video, I get why he interviews like this, His goal is to challenge the views of the people he interviews in order to understand them. Which is fair I guess.
He's been taking tips from Piers Morgan
He didn't shut up talking
He's a zionist that how they work even against and especially a rabbi who's anti israel
Its hard to let someone talk when they are dismantling your insane worldview fact by fact
Honestly he's okay, and he seems to be letting him talk (at least from what I saw in this segment). Piers Morgan sometimes interupt people after he asks his own question, he doesn't even let them breath.
When boy taught by Rabbi Shmuley meets man taught by word of God.
ROFL 😂
When idiot listen to minority Rabbi who represents less than 1% of Jews and idiot says this Rabbi is taught by God, Jewish people across the globe spit laugh their Matzah soup into their computer screens.
Bwahahah wow
What's his daughters job again??? 😂😂😂
"Taught", by word of God? I don't think so.
What a respectful knowledgable Rabbi. As a Muslim he earned my highest respect. He explained exactly the difference between Judaism and Zionism. A point I tried to make to so many people but they failed to understand but this Rabbi explained it perfectly. Judaism isn’t Zionist and making this point clear reduced antisemitism around the world because Israel doesn’t represent all the Jews neither do they represent the true meaning of Judaism. God bless your soul Rabbi.
As a muslim, you have no business commenting. It would be the same as if i said Shiites are right or Sunnis are right, not being a muslim.
You’re not wrong. With respect, in my opinion, Zionism and Judaism are intertwined with pretty much all Ashkenazi and I can’t speak for Sephardic but I’m sure it’s the same. I think Israel should exist hence I’m a Zionist I guess.
@@Mikehartman4747 no one said that Jews shouldn’t have a land even though it’s weird to take people from all over the world with different traditions and languages and backgrounds because they share a religion! But this land should never be build at someone else’s expense
@@davidsher5483why? Everyone think they can criticize Islam and Muslims on every platform and all over the world! And Israel is a freaking country not even a religion it should be criticized
Facts. As Muslims we have no issues with the Jews. Its zionism. And zionism (which is a form of political and extremist Judaism) as with Islamic extremism and Hindutva along with Nazism are all dangerous for the human race.
What language did we speak?
Hebrew.
When?
I don't know.
Thats the problem jake. You refuse to be educated by the people you bring on. Why have them on if you refuse to humble yourself.
Also, the fact that he doesn't know when Hebrew was spoken, as a self-proclaimed zionists/israeli savior is quite embarrassing.
So true
This Rabbi represents a tiny percentage of Jews. There might be 50,000 of these lunatics in the world today. 98/100 Rabbis would call everything this man said false and they would back it up with Torah, Talmud and Maimonides. Jews are not pacifists. Never were and never will be. If we were, we'd be long dead. We are fighters and we don't put our lives in the hands of God. We put our lives in our own hands.
Shalom. Am Israel Chai!
@@Thegabub Modern day Zionists dont have to know a day thing about Jewish/Levantine/Palestinian history to be a Zionist. its an irrational position. Nothing has to matter.
Well said
I don't understand why they call him anti. Israel
He's a stating of facts
Which facts? List three if you can.
@greybushMEproductions jews can not have Israel until messiah arrives jews are to roam,Zionism is unholy.
Is-not-real is a racistisch country.
Is-not-real is a occupied country.
Is-not-real is a illegal country.@@greybushMEproductions
@greybushMEproductions
1- The Basic Law states that the right to national self-determination in Palestine "is unique to the Jewish People"
2- The Jews around the world had no common culture or language for thousands of years.
3- The state you support claims that it is a country to people who are already citizens to other countries and had never set foot or had any cultural relation to this nationality.
Here are your 3 facts.
@@greybushMEproductionsgo ahead refute what was stated in the video. I'm here to learn
You’re a bad interviewer and you don’t have the mental capacity to understand his words 🤣
Zionism defeats you. Cry and cope
The rabbi is just taking shit. Pretending Jews didn't speak Hebrew. What nonsense.
I'd give the man a chance. He still let's the Rabbi talk and also, who else is interviewing people like this Rabbi? I think you're looking at a young, immature truth seeker, not one of those funded, little Shapiros. Just my thought for the moment
@@abadran8174 Yeah, after watching the video he is not too bad.
Jake is not a bad interviewer. Jake is not confused. Jake acts naive to cover up that he is a racist Zionist apologist. He’s not fooling anyone
He's pro human and a non Zionist rabbi.
never capitalize israel or zionism. They don't deserve it. Only capitalize Jews and Judaism.
Well, most rabbis were not and are not Zionists since the modern Jewish renewal jeopardizes his job.
"Pro human". No such thing. Let's stop inventing words.
You cannot be the host and try to debate him at the same time 🙄
Shhh, you silly person! you're obviously too old to really get the whole social media thing, huh? Jake can set the format any way he wants! Its his channel! I guess you're thinking of a Larry King thing or something, right grandma?
@@keereekeeCalm down there child it's about listening and asking questions waiting on answers it's a interview?? No need to throw a temper tantrum child do u need a baba???
@@keereekee 🤡
@keereekee you must be some silly old person because social media makes it open to criticism
Are you for real? The host is not debating him. He is asking for clarification of terms that the rabbi is using -- often incorrectly! -- in mounting his argument. If you have read anything by Shapiro, you will see he uses this tactic there too. Many of the the deceptive tactics Shapiro (no, I will not use the title "rabbi") uses involve substituting two different English terms for a single Hebrew word. The different meanings of the English terms can then be used to construct a false contradiction that does not in fact inhere in the Hebrew term. It is the fact that he tends to do this primarily with biblical Hebrew terms to construct an intentionally deceptive polemic that cause me to seriously question his legitimacy as a "rabbi." A simple example: am/עם means both "a people" and "a nation," and by extension an "ethnicity," (though the latter, even in English, is of recent academic coinage). "Am Israel"/עם ישראל refers to the totality of Jewish people, the nation associated with them and includes nuances underscored by the modern concept of ethnicity. By substituting the words "Jews," "Nation" and "ethnicity" for the single Jewish term, Shapiro is able to construct a false contradiction as these words in English intersect only in a limited sense, and can even be all three mutually exclusive. Shapiro is, in short, a bad actor and an intellectual impostor. He does, however, have great appeal for rabid anti-semites and not a few self-loathing, textually illiterate Jews. Imagine him without the beard, the rabbi schtick, in a corduroy jacket with elbow patches holding office hours as a professor in a left leaning sociology department underwritten by Qatar or Saudia Arabia or even the Muslim Brotherhood, and you've already seen deeper into who this man really is and what he stands for. There is only one word to describe this man -- shanda! שאנדע!!!
Being impatient as an interviewer is one of the worst qualities to have btw, genuinely saying this not being rude. Listen, actually hear him first
10:42 he's concentrating/ listening intently. You must have been watching a different interview. Be thankful he invited such a well informed and eloquent guest. In addition , the sound and visuals are very good (more than one camera angle etc)
The interviewer acted like an argumentative teenager having a conversation with a teacher, trying to argue instead of learn
There is no "Jewish state" only occupied Palestine
Jews who are against zionism are some of the greatest human beings to walk the earth.
It might just be a show.
@@ahmarfarooki it is not a show, or else you will have a hard time convincing people as a muslim, you don't align with ISIS.
Indeed
@@ahmarfarooki uhhh go read abit. these are fundamentals of theology
@@ahmarfarooki No it is not. But if you want to hear another JEW who is also ANTI NAZI ZIONIST listen to Mike Peled. He absolutely destroys Jake (willfully blind zionist). Mike clearly states, "The state of Israel is a CRIME". He wrote The General's Son and he also states clearly (when he lived in Israel) that the death of his niece is ISRAEL's FAULT! ua-cam.com/video/fNlBACOUX6g/v-deo.html
Judaism is a religion, not an Ethnicity.
For some people... They get confused over the identity of Ashkenazi and how long that identity is aligned with Judaism..
@@bravoalley228and 1000s of berbers from north Africa converted to judaïsm
It means whatever is convenient for them and benefits them in any particular argument
Judaism is the religion of the Jewish people. We were exiled 2000 years ago. A lot can happen over that amount of time.
It’s both. It pops up on dna test and there’s been multiple studies on Jews (especially askenazis).
The Rabbi has a very good grasp of societal framing. Most people lack an ability to engage on more than one or two logical planes, but he describes his ethic well. The host was being a little bit of jerk who seemed he could not quite grasp what was being said.
At 1:54 Jake cuts and edits the clip preventing the Rabbi from explaining further.
This is a true Jew who Muslims love!! ❤
He is a true Jew. Through and through.
Yes the one who denied is god
Cos he tells the truth
@@allanpigon9913 How does he deny God?
@supergroovy8346 is it true that Isiah 53 gospel is forbidden to read by Judaism .
Jake squirming and looking uncomfortable. LOL.
I noticed too lmao
"B b b but i thought we were a ethnicity"😩😩😩
I 💙💜 Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro. He’s such a breath of fresh air in these difficult times.
Who will protect the Jews when Israel is destroyed? You going to rely on Hezbollah and Hamas for that? Maybe Iran?
Cooked.
Anti Zionist rabbi- 1
Jake newfield- 0
Rabbi "when did we speak Hebrew"
Newfield " a while ago i don't know"
"for thousands of years Jews have not speaking Hebrew"
"they had no flag, they had no national anthem, land language or culture"
scorecard Pope +1 , Jake -2 Rabbi +5 Netanyahu -100000000000000000000
So what's the conclusion?
@@matijamatt693 there's no conclusion, apart from the ongoing obvious reality that Israel justifies a European expansive colonial genocidal project by using Judaism as its moral support system, while simultaneously ignoring and undermining the chief credo's of Judaism.
or do you just want a simple equation? ok then
zionism = anti-semitism
Dumb comment
This rabbi is fantastic. Commonsense and fact based arguement.
Common sense! LOL. What facts? I must have missed them. The fact that God will protect Jews from radical Islamists terrorist so long as they pray to God? Please, tell me all the facts that make common sense to you Abdul. I bet you can't name one common sense fact this lunatic mentioned.
I am appreciative that youtube algorithms bring me this wisdom. Knows my heart. I am 61 years old born in the United States of America and the plight of the Palestinians has been heavy on my heart my entire life. In fact, when I was young I would tell people I wanted to make it big so I could help all the refugees. Unfortunately I have not made it big but seeing what is happening in the music industry perhaps it's a good thing I did not. There is still hope that I will live to see these atrocities end and the Palestinians lives begin renewed.
Perhaps in another life I was a Palestinian.
@@RosieRoserules Gaza looks good to me. They are making great strides now. Any minute Palestine will be free.
I’m Greek Orthodox born In Gaza and my family lived in Gaza for generations. I can assure you isrl treated us much better than msl ever did. Infact it’s a religious duty for mslms for wage wr on isrl . Don’t believe their propaganda
both groups are bad on either side of this. @@Qeewee8500
This is a real rabbi. You can see the Nur in his face.
Believer in Allah and the last day follower of the Prophets
Noor means light btw for who doesn’t know, and it is true
god bless this noble descent rabbi, and all Jews who suffer so much when they speak for justice
That’s what I was thinking too . I thought it was just me
@@lionman5577 If you reject Mohammad صلى الله عليه وسلم, you are not a mo-min.
Indeed! The ppl of the book God fearing
"when did Jews speak Hebrew:"
A while ago, i don't know 💀💀💀
The statement about islam, claiming that the prophet took the torah is false.
Never do we claim such a thing.
He's wrong on a small technicality but generally he is right. Abrogation (نسخ) is a term in Islam that refers to how the rules change. Between Islam and Judaism, some rules are the same and others are overwritten. It's even mentioned in Surat Al Baqarah verse 106.
@ the verse u used is completely wrong. Whatever a verse do Naskh is „whatever an ayah we erase“. This refers to the verses that were forgotten, therefore Allah also mentions in multiple places in the quran that he will replace it with a better one. No changing from judaism. Islam has its own sharia.
@ nah u made the claim, bring ur proof
@@Abu3ilmsince Mohammed was illiterate, the Quran wasn't written for over 100 years after his death. Most of the notes used were piecemeal and written by scribes. A lot of what Mohammed knew came from his family's worship of a Moon god and what he heard from Rabbis and Christian preachers who's sermins came from the Torah. .
ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AE_(%D8%A5%D8%B3%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%85)#:~:text=%D9%81%D9%8A%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A5%D8%B3%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%85%D8%8C%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AE%D9%8F%20%D9%87%D9%88%20%D8%B1%D9%81%D8%B9,%D9%81%D9%8A%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A5%D8%B3%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%85%3A%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B1%D8%A2%D9%86%20%D8%A3%D9%88%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AD%D8%AF%D9%8A%D8%AB.
www.islamweb.net/ar/fatwa/59239/%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A5%D8%B3%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%85-%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AE-%D8%B3%D8%A7%D8%A6%D8%B1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B4%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%A6%D8%B9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%82%D8%A9-%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%8A%D9%87
wow what an intelligent Rabbi
Not really. He's quite insane and ignores Torah and Talmud. Jews don't pray to God to save them from Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran, we have Israel and ourselves for that. Thanks!
At 6.45 or so, the Rabbi hits the nail on the head: it's about so-called nation-states, a concept developed in the 18t/19th Centuries. No nation-State has ever confined itself to one religion.
LOL. Israel is 20% Muslim. What religion is Israel confined to?
As the Rabbi says: and they are 2nd class citizens, in other words, treated as Goyim.
@@greybushMEproductions Typical Zionist sophistry: so Muslims have equal rights as Jews in Israel? Sure, and pigs fly...
@@greybushMEproductions The Rabbi literally explains This!!
@@nataliekhanyola5669Does he? What does he explain?
Man, the interviewer interrupts so much. Let the man speak!
This interviewer’s ignorance, and inability to understand and listen are frustrating. But to call the Rabbi “anti-Israel” makes the ignorance and framing deliberate.
What a fascinating guest.
“A while ago” = thousands of years
Lmao 😂
I respect this Rabbi. A righteous and dignified man revealing the truth . I hope I haven't said anything Antisemitic.
The word antisemitic holds very little to no importance anymore, considering its a cheap copout tactic commonly used by israelis to absolve themselves of any blame
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If Nazis escaped
▪︎Embed in another Nation,Religion
▪︎Rename their Political Movement
▪︎Can't be recognized
▪︎Can be recognized by Matching Policies
▪︎Superior Race ideology,Dehumanization,Starvation,Concentration Camps,Gassing (White Phosphorus),Pogroms,Ethnic Cleansing,etc?
Former Nazis where put in all kinds of positions of power. maybe not directly Israel, but we took them in for NASA, some in west Germany government, high positions in NATO and the EU too.
The interviewer seems to know nothing but pushes back zioni propaganda
where was the clash? he just educated you bro
'When did we speak Hebrew? ......'A while ago...I don't know!......God help us!
Respectfully, 2 things are wrong here that should be addressed. Number 1 is you have to give your guests a platform to speak without the interruptions. Make physical notes or mental notes to address after the point is made.
Number 2 is that the video needs to be relabeled. This isn't an "anti-Israel rabbi", this is just a standard rabbi or standard Jew since anybody worth their salt knows that Israel is not supposed to exist, knows that the jews have been in exile for 3,200 years and knows that they're forbidden from returning to the land until the mashiach brings them into the land.
So, no, this isn't an anti-Israel Jew. The jews WANT Israel.. we also want to observe God's law and word so, going there right now is forbidden. Who doesn't know this?
Correction: The Rabbi is anti Zionism
I am a Muslim and I respect this Rabbi.
According to Islam. The children of Israel enjoy a special status in the Islamic holy book, the Quran (2:47 and 2:122). However, Muslim scholars point out that this status did not confer upon Israelites any racial superiority, and was only valid so long as the Israelites maintain their covenant with God.
What modern jews won't tell you is that the Israelites got deported and bred out of existence in 721BC by the Akkadians. Jews are the descendants of the judean elite that got deported to Babylon, they're not Israelites.
Modern Ashkenazi jews have eastern European DNA and are not Semitic, have no relation to ancient Israelites(or jews) and had never been to the middle east before 1917.
And they broke their covenant and no longer the chosen ones. They also lost the land.
False
Brother Jews are ethnically Moroccans, Greek, Russians, Austrians, and Norweiggian
ITS still based on faith
LOL. Tell that to the Moroccans, Greeks, Russians, Austrians and Norwegians! Who drove all the Jews out of their countries! BTW, there are about 500 Jews in Norway. Ethnically speaking Jews are Jews, that's why when we take DNA tests, it comes back and says we are Jewish!
I don’t think they have that many in Norway tbh…lol
@ yes some places have more than others- some hasidic can say they are more jewish than others
still jews are unconquerable, not a race like WW2 tried to convince people and polarize the world vs judaism.
@@richardparker7121 Nope, not many at all in Norway, but far more than in Iraq Syria, Gaza, West Bank, Jordan and Lebanon. combined! I think there are about 37 Jews spread throughout that latter group of fantastic places to live. I could be off by 2 or 3, or even as many as 10, not entirely sure
@@greybushMEproductionsare you just blatantly making thing up? It takes less than 5 seconds in google to confirm over 400,000 Jews live in settlements in the West Bank alone.
What a rude host. Always interrupting and asking off tangent questions. Let him finish talking for crying out loud
You should listen to the Rabbi. Humble yourself
This highly intelligent Rabbi states the fact clearly
But unfortunately the interviewer is either clueless dumb
Or purposely ignoring the fact!!!
To clarify: abrogation doesn't mean the God gave the same laws from the Bible to Muhammad peace be upon him. Abrogation refers to the replacement of a previous religious ruling with a new one. The previous one was acceptable at the previous time, but now a new law is given by God which is the law from now on. Not necessarily the same as saying "God took the Laws from the Bible and gave them to Muhammad peace be upon him". Verses were abrogated even within the Prophet's lifetime and it doesn't necessarily refer to the Bible vs Quran. It's more so referring to the Quran verses being abrogated throughout the Prophet's lifetime. In the last year of the Prophet's (peace be upon him) life, the abger Gabriel instructed the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) to recite the whole Quran from start to finish multiple times. This meant that at the time of the Prophet's (peace be upon him) death, the whole Quran was confirmed as the complete word of God, verified through Gabriel (AS), and this complete Quran had been memorized and written down WITHIN the Prophet's (peace be upon him) lifetime.
Hope that helps.
This is the chiller “Clash” in history 😊
Thank you sir for speaking the truth 👏
This Rabbi is so knowledgeable. He just needs people to understand him.
This is Jake guy that i come across on youtube turned out to be a novice. Dude stfu, let your guest finish his thoughts. You’re not listening, thats why you cant’t seem to grasp what he’s saying even though what he’s saying are facts.
I genuinely have so much respect for the Jews that stand against the Zionist entity, it shows true sincerity
When the teacher speaks it’s better to listen and learn than to chirp and chatter. This wise man taught me something in this clip and I’m grateful for it.
Forget about American jews who are referred to citizens of Israel, our politicians' campaigns based on who loves Israel more than the other rather than their allegiance to America 🇺🇸
My guy, let him talk!!
Trump telling Americans jews that Netanyahu is their prime minister is wild it’s like saying to Muslim Americans that the king of Saudi Arabia is your king or telling American christians that the pope is their ruler I don’t think American jews accept that maybe American AIPAC jews but not regular people.
I never thought about it. This Rabbi makes so much sense.
Ignorance is perpetuated by the youth
Sending love to the Rabbi more voices such as his are greatly needed in this dystopian world ❤
This Rabbi is the only Jew in this interview
A very thoughtful theologian who is clearly in a different intellectual league than the person interviewing him. Even if I didn't agree with his politics, I very much respect that he's morally consistent and fights to see his faith/identity as a responsibility rather than a privilege or entitlement. I'm eager to read more of his writings.
Am I the only one cringing over the fact that Jake has so much trouble comprehending sn in depth explanation. He just stares with this dazed confused look. Smart guy explaining something to him is new. Omg I can't 😂😂😂
as a palestinian hat's off to you man
LOL. You guys love Hitler.
Glad to hear this rabbi speak. The US media and the government only like to show Rabbi Shmuley.
This Rabi is a good man. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Guess what Jake. You can challenge someone even after hearing them make their point without interruption.
This rabbi talks sense, and is knowledgable, intelligent and a good person.
Does the Torah give legitimacy to establish a state for the Jewish? Please provide the reference from the Torah.
Agree with the rabbi. There is no single nation for any other religion or race. For example, India is not the country for all indian, or even all hindu.
8:30 The jews also have this thing called the abrogation. Moses pbuh took the sharia(law) from the previos prophets and things got changed and added and it became the Torah.
Abrogation has been going on since Adam, the first prophet.
LOL. The Torah existed before Islam did.
@@ronaldtoran4332was prophet Adam pbuh jewish?
@@ronaldtoran4332The Torah IS islam. We believe in every book of Ellah. You're a little ign0rant huh.
@@ronaldtoran4332the torah existed because the torah was dent down by the same god all prophets n muslims worshipped. even moses worshipped one god alone just like the muslims. moses himself was one
@@FarhanMehmood LOL Moses was Muslim? That' funny considering Islam didn't exist during the time of Moses! Hard to be a Muslim before the creation of Islam.
I'm in the UK from the UK. I would hate it if everyone here was a white Christian diversity is a good thing. I drive a foreign car, eat foreign food, listen to foreign music, and wear foreign clothes. Water non-indigenous plants. Without diversity, life would be boring.
Clear from the rabbi - calmly exposes the holes in zionism and Isreal being completely separate from Judaism - unless hes an antisemite of course 😅
Thanks for sharing this Jake. It is nice to see you want people of opposing views in your channel.
Thank you for watching!
Dude! Let him finish at least 1 sentence!!
You're worse than Kanye West 😂
Huge respect to this very knowledgeable, clear minded Rabbi..he is very intelligent..moreover a real human
It may be more enlightening to ask clarifying or expanding questions if you want to explore the topic or his perspective. Once you hear his whole position you can disagree and question parts but it didn't seem like you were interested to hear him out and it sounds like he has a lot to teach
At 1:55 you cut off his answer why?
The interviewer cant hide his bias so he has to interrupt. It's pathetic.
The two camera angles are meant to show the host's control over his guest
What do you mean?
The host is so ignorant. Let chap speak. Jheeze
These are the Jews of Allah. Shalom rabbi and May God almighty bless you, safeguard you, and love you ♥️
This is nice. Thank you, Rabbi. The Torah is more important than nation-states and far older than them.
Torah supports Zionism 100%. In the book of Ezekiel it discusses gathering all the Jews in the Diaspora and bringing them back to their homes in Israel! Jews are not and never were pacifists and nothing in Judaism requires Jews be pacifist. Quite the opposite is true. Judaism requires that you kill whoever seeks to kill you! The Talmud states, "If someone comes to kill you, rise early to kill him first" (Sanhedrin 72a). This principle underscores the moral and halachic legitimacy in Judaism of preemptive and defensive actions against existential threats.
This intelligent rabbi should be the king of Jews ❤
jake you should stop interrupting so much, let the rabbi finish his thoughts
Ngl man if you were pro-Israel and I expect learned on its history, you would’ve known that Hebrew was largely a ceremonial/religious language while Yiddish and Aramaic were spoken. Hell, literally the most famous Jewish man, Christ, spoke Aramaic. Hebrew as a viable modern language didn’t exist before the modern establishment of Israel, and was adapted from its historical origin by a Jewish nationalist who immigrated to PaIestine and designed it into a language suited for modern use during the creation of Israel. All of this is pretty easily accessible information on a couple of google searches. I’m literally a Muslim dawg you should be the one knowing this
THIS is the Judaism I know!
This young dude is the duмbesт clown of all times
The only CLASH I see is in the young man/interviewers head not against/with the Rabbi.
Rabbi is absolutely right. Spitting only facts. At the same time what a onrespectful interviewer
Yup you can’t convert to being Italian, Spanish, German, etc simple and concise way to refute the race or nationality argument. It’s mind boggling the arrogance to think bc your religion tells you that you’re the chosen one, you’re now a nationality and ethnically related people. Despite where you and your family are from
Thank you for giving this wonderful Rabbi a platform. May God bless you brother 🙏
Who is this kid who doesn't listen and has his thoughts rushing to his simple ideas and not learn from simple concepts being explained?
The host doesn’t even know what rights non-Jewish citizens have or have not. ”You can be in the Knesset, there are Arabs in the Knesset…” But as the rabbi states: they do not have SELFDETERMINATION
The interviewer needs to learn the difference between an interview and a debate
Brilliant. To be fair though the host doesn’t exactly ‘clash’ with the Rabbi. He merely questioned him
He stated many times his not anti Israel
He needs the clicks! Sad but true
He is clearly antizionist.
He says that his problem with israel is that it claims to represent all the jews but he doesnt have a problem with existance of israel itself
@reconscout2238 He has a serious problem with Israel's racism, injustice, and attitude of ethnosuperiority.
@rachael_grey that is what most people have, most people don't want destruction of Israel either. It is opposition of its expansion aka greater Israel project.
Bozo interviewing an intellectual!
The interviewer keeps interrupting.
What a beautiful explanation of Judaism. Very decent style of explaining.
What a horrible horrible interviewer. Thx to the rabbi i could finish the video.
Respect. Love to my Jewish brothers and sisters.