VFX Artists React 101: Rings of Power, Birdman, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 тра 2024
- Our videos are made possible by our amazing website subscribers. Consider joining us! ► corridordigital.com/
Sam and Niko are joined by VFX Supervisor Ara Khanikian of Rodeo FX to break down some of the best (and worst) visual effects in some of your favorite Hollywood films!
Learn more about Rodeo FX ► www.rodeofx.com/
Rodeo FX Instagram ► rodeofx_fil...
Follow us on Instagram ►
/ corridordigital
OUR GEAR, SOFTWARE & PARTNERS ►
Puget Systems Computers: bit.ly/PC_Puget_Workstations
Lighting by Aputure: bit.ly/CORRIDOR_LIGHTS
Our Go-To Gear: bhpho.to/3r0wEnt
ActionVFX: bit.ly/TheBest_ActionVFX
Cinema4D: bit.ly/Try_Cinema4D
Nuke by The Foundry: bit.ly/Nuke_Compositing
Simulations in Houdini: bit.ly/HoudiniSims
Octane Render by OTOY: bit.ly/Octane_Wrender
MUSIC ►
Epidemic: bit.ly/Corridor_Music click this link for a free month!
CHAPTERS ►
00:00 Welcome to VFX Artists React!
00:53 The Rings of Power
08:18 Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
12:06 CorridorDigital.com
12:23 Birdman
17:55 Thanks For Watching! - Розваги
Love to see an episode of Invisible CGI, where we have no idea what we're looking at totally fooled us, as it looks so natural or inconsequential.
Agreed 😊
These guys once did a react to Gone Girl and theres so much invisible CG in that
That'd just be endless David Fincher movies
Mindhunter
@@riazuddin4920 Came here to suggest this one too :)
Sorry if this has been requested before but I'd love to see a Sound Effect/Designer Artists React special. Maybe with a guest who works on sound design in films who can put a spotlight on the process, provide insights, give us their top sound effects and generally tell us how sound and visual effects work together on a scene. There are so many amazing sounds in cinema that deserve some attention. To name my favourites:
- The pod race in Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace (1999)
- The alien appears scene in Alien (1979)
- The beach scene in Saving Private Ryan (1998)
- The bombing raid in Unbroken (2014)
- The Balrog (specifically its roar. It's like a hot furnace) in LOTR (2001)
Love your content guys!
I will always push for an audio designer reacts!
Now I really want this, what a great idea
i would LOOOOOVE a sound design episode!!
This is such a good idea. I’d love to see Foley Artists react as well honestly!!!
yesssss
Eternal Sunshine has some of my favorite Cinematography and use of VFX of all time, glad these guys are finally taking a look at it!
you might want to check older episodes, they already went through a few other scenes in that movie
Very telling that the “simple” stitches at 13:54 impress the artists the most. Awesome stuff. And fully in service of the story and enabling the director to achieve what he was looking for.
Can you explain what happened? I didn’t understand any of it lol
@@meekofortin14 I couldn't tell what the hell I was supposed to be seeing either! lol I'm so glad it wasn't just me 😅🤦♂
Don't get it. Isn't that one shot? Or did the shot jump from 1 camera to the other because mirrors?
@@meekofortin14 Look at the top of the screen. They expertly stitched from one shot to another right in the middle. As the guest was explaining, they would sometimes switch out certain parts of the actor's performance with a stitch, just picking and choosing which moments they liked of each take. They used her passing the frame as almost a wipe cut.
Usually actors play multiple shots of same scene. And in post they can use parts of each but with cuts noticeable by different angles. In these cases they did that but "stitched" in a way that is seems it's just one take from same camera
Oh man! Birdman! HELL YES! We studied this film in film school because of how crazy it was made. The cuts are the FINEST, CLEANEST cuts I have ever seen. So incredible to watch.
P
Did u watch irreversible?
@@pavan_kumar556 oh! no? Any good?
@@JoseLopez-dx3ef Q
@@ericmorrison278 It's incredible, but also severely messed up
If i had to guess what the most clever usage of hidden shots in a movie is, I would always choose Birdman
Facts
Russian Arc would have to have a shout I would have thought
What about all the hidden cuts in your favorite movies that you haven’t even noticed yet? :D
@@CarletonTorpin Oh yeah. I should probably look more into that
The Revenant but also 1917 would be good examples as well!
Flight of the Navigator from 1986 was one of the first movies to feature CGI chrome objects, image based lighting and morphing. Also, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory looks like CGI with the squirrel attack but they really trained squirrels to attack a stuntwoman.
Honestly training a team of literal attack squirrels is pretty on brand
I see you watched Captain D's episode on navigator too haha
It's cool that Ara is so confident in the shots. They really do look phenomenal.
Eternal Sunshine is such an incredible movie.
It's one of my all time favorites, can't watch without crying
Yea still one of my favourites, the way they capture dream like state, and the realism of the real word, so you can feel the distinction without exposition. Also Joel is just fantastically acted the whole cast did so well to capture a very realistic vibe of their characters, which makes the dreams and music all the more surreal.
Eternal Sunshine and Birdman are both so good. If you haven't seen Birdman it's a great watch and an experience you won't get from most other films. The cinematography is great, the writing is funny, it has this manic energy that's captivating, and it's such a unique experience.
Love this film
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind is my favorite film. I've seen it several times. But this is the first time I realized that when that fence disappears, it's in the middle of the street, and the characters are in a new location.
There’s a 25th anniversary edition DVD of Star Trek: The Motion Picture that Paramount gave to a special effects studio to RESTORE the effects they had planned for originally during production, but ran out of money to shoot. It got so well that I had a hard time distinguishing where the restored effects began and ended. We’ve all seen effects added to a story that didn’t need it, but I’d never seen effects that were originally planned restored to the story. I think you guys works love it.
ANOTHER BANGER EPISODE! Guests such as Are Khanikian are the ideal guests. The level of knowledge all 3 of you bring is just fun to watch
Absolutely, and if you close your eyes and listen to him speak the dude sounds exactly like Prince Oberyn from GoT
I wonder if, when filming Birdman, Michael Keaton ever imagined he would be playing Batman again?
Eternal Sunshine is my favorite movie with some great overlooked VFX. I’m stoked to watch this.
You put Steven Seagal into John Wick.
You put Adam West into the new batman film.
You put Tom Holland into the spiderverse.
You put back superman's mustache.
Please please please put Ugly Sonic into the Sonic films. :D
Recommendation: For a classic VFX shot, have a look at Danny Kaye's ON THE DOUBLE. In the beginning, it looks like a simple split screen, but one character breaks the split and it's not immediately noticeable how it was done. It's pretty cool!
I think y'all would enjoy reviewing a movie called Velocipastor. It's a brilliant deconstruction of bad movie tropes and has some truly jaw dropping vfx.
I love your show btw, thank you for doing what you do.
PLEASE do Velocipastor! The fire VFX in the opening scene is one of the best I've ever seen.
Man that movie still gives me nightmares. THE "vfx shot" really surprised me 😅😁
Dude it is so weird I just read this, I just watched that movie an hour ago and it was awesome.
It reminded me of Kung Fury, just legendary vfx in a indie flick
It could have easily been an intentionally bad movie like sharknado which are boring and obnoxious, good bad movies have to be done earnestly as RLM have explained many times haha
This was the most mind boggling episode in a long time, I can't believe how damn hard so many of these shots would have been to do. And so glad to see you guys react to Birdman! One of the best movies of all time imo.
I watched James and the giant peach the other day and thought there was some great effects in that, especially the rhino storm at the start and end of the movie.
Also the live action version of the little prince had shots that I thought were impressive for their time where he’s walking around a tiny planet, also a sequence with a motion controlled plane prop at the very start
Sometimes they’re so impressed w something and I have absolutely no idea what’s actually going on but wow I love these breakdowns so much
I watched The Borrowers (1997) with my kids last night and was impressed by a lot of the shots, especially the one where the four inch tall Borrower girl walks down a dark corridor with a birthday candle for a torch - and the flame is the correct scale!
I think you guys might enjoy picking apart some of the effects in the ghost rider films! Particularly the scene in the second movie of his jacket bubbling
My favorite part is when Guyladriel says to Elrond, "You're a wizard, Harry."
The cinematographer that set up the go pros on the rig while capturing those flying shots should have got a raise for the amount of time and work they saved in the future. Not even mentioning how much better the shot turned out by having all that authentic scene information to use.
Damn the consistency of these guys is a beast level.
I've said it before, but I'll say it again; i think it would be really great if you guys checked out some of the old practical and optical effects from the old toho Godzilla movies
I would love to see a TV show that was on the air for a long time and how the effects changed, like Supernatural, or Stargate where the technology of the effects changed over the 15 years it was on TV
I love how that Rings of Power shot is so normal and uninteresting if you don't know about VFX, but if you're into it, it's mindblowing.
Just like the Steppenwolf puddle shot or the Avatar hand shot
I really wanna see more VFX Breakdowns of The Expanse. The show is so good
Yes please!
Birdman is my favorite movie of all time.
Hearing these insights into how it was made was priceless. Thank you, Corridor, and THANK YOU, Ara!
Been really stressed lately but now I get to watch vfx artists react and not worry about my stress for a few minutes
That moment where you're watching a new UA-cam video, then immediately switch over when you see the new Corridor Crew react video...😁 that's just how much I love you guys.
I look forward to this show every Saturday! Thank you so much
I've watched Birdman many times and those hidden stitches have taken me out, I had no idea, incredible work
That last Michael Keaton flying breakdown blew my mind. 🤯
I think it's cool when you guys have guests who were a part of creating movies. It gives a lot more insight on how things work.
I would be interesting to see some more breakdowns of CGI of older movies. And one movie from my childhood that jumps to mind is: Evolution (2001).
There's some stuff in Eragon about the dragon that I'd be curious to hear you talk about. Pretty rough movie, but I remember a story where they spent all their budget on the dragon and I remember it looking pretty good. (just anything with dragons I'm down for.) Also saw a great making of Dragonslayer 1981 recently and figured you guys would have a lot of fun talking about that.
I watched Dragonheart recently, which is ...fine... but to have a nearly fully CGI main character in 1996 was a big achievement. It's not perfect obviously, but it's a talking, expressive, dynamic dragon voiced by Sean Connery. I'd be interested in hearing about that one too.
I would love to see an episode featuring Korean cinema. Like the sky replacement from Parasite, the robot from space sweepers, the zombies in Train to Busan.
A cool alternative would be a look into how live sports overlays and VFX works, like the overlays on a football field, or replacing advertisements on the boards of a hockey game for the live broadcast.
My suggestion is not a movie, so I know this could be a challenge. But the official video clip for Up and Up by Cold Play is amazing in terms of rotoscoping, compositing, and color grading... Great episode as always, thank you for this amazing content.
It would definitely be great to see more music videos analyzed, as some seem to have a lot of SFX & editing detail put into them?
As a recommendation: the directors of the Matrix movies made Jupiter Ascending, which isn't their best, but its VFX and art design is very cool! Would love to see a breakdown:)
Also, this was an awesome episode, I'm very glad that you've revisited this mad perspective shot magic from Rings of Power, thank you for that!
i’ve been following this channel for years and i eventually want to work for corridor with my musical abilities but i gotta say.. Niko awkward laughing is just something i never fail to notice.
Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind is so nice with all those in camera effects and real elbow grease vfx. love it.
For the next Bollywood/Tollywood episode I'd love to see an interview with V. Srinivas Mohan, VFX supervisor on some films you've covered (RRR, Bahubali, Enthiran, Eega). He'd have some insight on how large scale effects have been pulled off over the years with the kind of budgets Indian filmmakers work with and their larger than life ambitions. Pete Draper from Makuta VFX could also be great for the same, and both of them have acknowledged your videos before!
I've never been this early 🤯
This really shows you the difference between a UA-cam special effects artist and an actual professional special effects artists.
Niko just flopping over and saying “my creativity is on vacation, please just subscribe” reminds of that cat that was in a box on top of a rocking stool that tipped over, and the cat just stayed in the box on the floor as though nothing happened. It gave up for a minute. That’s entirely fine. We all gotta do that from time to time.
Would love a special on the VFX of Doctor Who.
Ah Rings of Power , let me pass forward.
The fire in rings of power is some of the realest I've ever seen
I’d love a sports - themed episode. So much goofy CGI used for baseballs especially, but when you contrast it against well done shots it sticks out that much more.
When are we getting a Star Trek focused Episode? Decades of VFX history to explore
@@thesteveruss agreed 😊
You should ask why did they used Chat GPT 3 to create the fanfiction plot of RoP?
Be a weird question to ask for a show that focuses on vfx🧐🧐🧐🧐
I would love to see you all talk about the effects in Brazil (1985)! I enjoy seeing old school effects and hearing you talk about how you might do it today.
Some of the vfx is just some damn creative minds doing problem solving. Love the conversations.
Finally eternal Sunshine made it 😊
They've definitely talked about it before
With star wars day recently, I would love for you guys to look at star wars the clone wars and get your insights and thoughts on that series and some of the current star wars animations.
I love all of these episodes so much! The Eternal Sunshine segment made me realize that I’d love to see a 2-team competition video where you both have to film the same scene, but one team does it with cg effects and the other team has to try to do it practically.
Or maybe a vfx artists react where your people try to trick you with the effects they use on short clips that they each make?
Either way, keep up the great stuff!
I’d point you in the direction of our collaboration video with Adam Savage where competed to see who could do a better blood spatter effect. “Slicing Adam Savage’s Nose”
@@chasecmorgan I love that one!
This might be your best video yet.
It's exactly what CGI is all about.
Absolutely mind-blowing.
Rings of Power: I loved it when Gandalf told the Not-Hobbits, "I am Iron Man".
I'm surprised they didn't notice all of the obvious feathering around the Stranger's cloak. Even when watching it for the first time, it was totally jarring and noticeable to me.
Also the complete lack of ambient occlusion on the log when his head moves close to it in that second scene they look at.
These episodes are always so fun to watch.
I think that a really good film to react to is everything everywhere all at once because it has some really interesting VFX but also a surprising amount of stunning practical effects.
Luckily for Mr. Khanikian, Corridor managed to extract from Rings of Power the few elements worth discussing, as otherwise the production value compared to cost was abysmal and frankly not worth mentioning.
Yeah, it might suck story wise but it has some great VFX
What are your views on whether women should be allowed to speak in public?
@@LuisSierra42 I agree, except that "some" seems insufficient given the investment. Besides, not mentioning the story, even some of the VFX appears at best mediocre measured against today's standards.
There's definite issues with RoP, but visuals (and music) aren't one of them!
Eternal Sunshine and Birdman. Ultimate Legend
Man!
These were some crazy effects!
Including the hand behind Jim's head!
I care so little about the Rings of Woke, I don't even care about how good the vfx were.
this gotta be an exhausting way to view art lol
@@jdrummerdd 13 minutes out and you have responded to so many comments already.
@@A_Random_Ghost 2 to be exact lol, what a crazy thing to do
@@jdrummerdd Interesting.
😢you poor thing
With all the cool stuff going into Rings of Power from the artists and tech, it still manages to look like something a fan shot in their garden. All the money sunk into that show is a travesty.
Cannot unsee the fact that the trees to the left of the Rings of Power shot are cut off and not moving
The opening shot of the movie "21" is a shot that still drives me crazy. It was 2008, way before drones were widely used, but it starts with a helicopter shot, and moves to a close up of Jim Sturgess riding his bike on a bridge. If it's VFX, it fooled me. It has all the hallmarks of a practical shot, like even a slight camera shake like most other movies of the time that do similar shots with a helicopter. I can't figure out how they would have done it without a modern drone.
It's been driving me crazy for 15 years!
It's a shame Rings of Power was so bad, it had so much potential for VFX artists.
The show is not _that_ bad. Only the writing's bad and everything else is pretty good. And it's not like the VFXartists' potential ended since there's a season 2 in the future.
what does that even mean lol, whatever you think of the show it has incredible fx work.
Well, I'm sure the staff were Payed well and other roles are now open to them so.. The liking of the show is subjective.
@@ferro1398 And the costumes, the attitudes, the dialogue, the acting and the total disrespect of Tolkiens work.
@@ferro1398 No, it's bad. People don't usually watch LoTR for eye candy, it's not a Marvel corporate product.
The rings of power one of the worst shows I’ve ever seen
Interesting thing about fire: With HDR, this all goes out the window. My daughter took a photo of a car fire the other morning with her iPhone, and the fire was fluorescent orange and detailed with a yellow core. The truck was white, and it was full daylight. Some of that detail was very likely the built-in Apple AI processing (not a big fan of that because it invents detail, like painting grass over pavement in my past experience), but much was presumably HDR. Nothing was over-exposed. It looked unreal because of how orange the flame was. Tons of thick oily smoke behind it as well.
In a second photo she took of that, the clouds in the sky were completely blown out, but the fire was still orange.
Hey guys, I love this series so much and appreciate all the work you've done. I learned so much about filmmaking and VFX and knowing how this works and the clever tricks that are used made me love movies as a whole so much more.
As a suggestion: There is an old german movie "The Adventures of Baron Munchausen" from 1943 (insane, I know!). I watched this movie as a kid and for nostalgia rewatched it recently. I was so surprised to see how well the special effects in this hold up, especially considering it's age. I doubt that there are crazy mind-bending effects in it, but i liked how the effects of an 80 year old movie hold up better than some modern ones.
Can you make a episode with a subscriber as a guest? The subscriber could bring some scenes that you all could talk about
thats what the comments are for, brown noser.
Rings of power had awesome visuals and music ngl just the rest was bad
Man hearing renowned vfx supervisors say that they watch this show is just so cool to me!
You should do a Stuntmen React (or bring in the sword guy who's name I keep forgetting) for Mask of Zorro. I think it's a highly underrated movie with some really quality stunt work.
I'd love to see a visual effect video where you do the same shot in an hour, a day, and a week to show the impact of time and budget.
Great episode as always, lifting the veil for us a bit to reveal the magic lurking beneath
Birdman's cinematographer was Emmanuel Lubezki, Mexican Legend, he always works with Cuarón and Iñarritu, you can watch his work in Revenant with that beautiful lightning or in Cuaron's Children of Men
Congrats! Im not a vfxs, but a movie vfxs lover , I have learned a lot here, realize all the stuff a vfxs should know about physics and light. Absolutely love this !!
I'm sure you've done Jason And The Argonauts before but I've just been watching it again, and its still better sfx than a lot of films today. Can we give it some more love, please? It's a ridiculous feat of creativity and ingenuity
There is an old Star Wars parody of "Cops" called "Troopers". A co worker of mine showed it to me and I was really impressed with some of the effects this small team was able to pull off for the time it was made. Super funny clip with some references to a New Hope.
I feel like when it comes to VFX, if you make it look easy to the average viewer, you're doing it right... but when those who know what could be done and/or even guess it wrong and learn something from it, all parties benefit. I love this industry!
The first big explosion in the hurtlocker is pretty amazing and worth covering I think
Corridor is going to need an entire season just to cover the D&D movie. I watched a vid of someone counting the seconds during fight scenes to show the fight choreography followed the 6-second combat round structure of the D&D game. There is *so* much to talk about in that movie.
You need to take a look at the stunts and special effects in the low budget action movie, Free Fire. It's basically a giant shoot out in a warehouse between two gangs set in the 70s. They have practical effects of one guy getting set on fire that looks incredible and another guy having his face run over by a van. In the behind the scenes they show how they rigged up the van to run over the actors face. When they went to shoot no one trusted the rig to work without hurting the actor so the director laid down on the ground and let the van run over his face to prove it was safe. The movie's also just an awesome hilarious blast to watch! I highly recommend it!
You guys should make a series where you list the TOP 3 MOVIES with the best graphics for each decade, starting from 100 yrs ago
Amazing episode, love the shot breakdowns they showed onscreen
It's really interesting to hear him say he had to swipe between the CG scene and set scene. That is old-school, hand drawn animation technique being used in modern graphics rendering.
@2:47 you can see the border of the composite; track the netted fabric on the ground and you'll see that it kind of "melts" on the edge of the plate.
Being creative always put out the best!
Rings of Power is back on the show! Heck yeah!!
This guy is a true master of his craft!
Noticed in the 4:42 composite bit, that huge wizard man has a strand/clump of hair that is animated on top of his head that gave away that he was composited. And then they fooled the audience by not showing her feet too.
Oh My Renders!! Thats amazing work in Birdman.
Having been a VFX Editor for a studio that mainly did Compositing, I got to watch the progress of them doing a performance stitch from different points in the same take and melding them together in the movie Dead for a Dollar.
Love your work, please do an episode celebrating your favourite 'long takes' or 'one-shotters'. There's a long history of perfecting the one shotter