DAWAH MAN vs DR HAIFAA YOUNIS: CAN MUSLIM WOMEN GIVE DAWAH ONLINE?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 жов 2024
- Muslim brother Dawah Man says Muslim women shouldn't be online giving dawah, Muslim sister Dr Haifaa Younis says the opposite! Who is right and who is wrong?
Book a one to one consultation - calendly.com/t...
FREE MINI SERIES - mailchi.mp/c1c...
JOIN THE FREE MUSLIM FELLOWSHIP TELEGRAM GROUP - t.me/+-7yv9Dwc...
Donate To The Channel - ko-fi.com/them...
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @themuslimmum
Check out my Amazon page for Islamic products for all occasions - www.amazon.co....
Islamic Dawah Merch; live your deen in everything you do (t-shirts, hoodies, hats, tops, leggings, joggers/sweat pants, baby clothes, journals, mugs, backpacks, etc) - the-muslim-mum...
Check Out My Halal Amazon Product Recommendations;
Kids Prayer Mats (2-Set Blue & Pink Gift):
USA - amzn.to/3Ipw38x
UK - amzn.to/429nR3v
4 Pieces Portable Travel Prayer Mat with Compass, Waterproof Prayer Rug, Muslim Travel Prayer Mat:
USA - amzn.to/42Jd1SK
UK - amzn.to/3N2QgUi
Muslim Prayer Rug, 99 Prayer Beads and Prayer Cap Included (For Men & Women):
USA - amzn.to/3oe1XxX
UK - amzn.to/43plDho
Sahih al-Bukhari: (All Volumes in One Book) English Text Only:
USA - amzn.to/3MDU7XK
UK - amzn.to/3C3uHg5
The Qur'an: With a Phrase-by-Phrase English Translation:
USA - amzn.to/3MCW0nx
UK - amzn.to/3WDGzPB
Quran in English: Clear, Pure, Easy to Read, in Modern English:
USA - amzn.to/3MowX6G
UK - amzn.to/45DzrGL
Mens Muslim Islamic Prayer Cap / Kufi:
USA - amzn.to/41Jatmo
UK - amzn.to/3qh15cF
Men's Muslim Prayer Kufi Hat, Islam Embroidery Cap:
USA - amzn.to/3Wnis7G
UK - amzn.to/42jeNJg
Kufi Hats For Muslim Men:
USA - amzn.to/3od3swu
UK - amzn.to/3WDPDny
10 Large Tasbih (99 Prayer Beads / Allah & Mohammed Rosary:
USA - amzn.to/41NLYo0
UK - amzn.to/3N3e62n
2 Pcs Instant Hijab For Women Muslim (Lightweight Head Scarf With Long Soft Hijab Shawl Wrap):
USA - amzn.to/43ablSi
UK - amzn.to/43y6cmZ
Girls One Piece Floral Hijab Modest Fashion (Islamic Long Shawl Head Wrap For Kids With Scarf):
USA - amzn.to/3BCKd2n
UK - amzn.to/3C9laUJ
Women’s Muslim Nikab Burka (Overhead Jilbab Long Hijab):
USA - amzn.to/42R1scq
UK - amzn.to/42n1fg4
Asalamalekum everyone.
If you enjoyed this video, please consider supporting me and my channel by liking and subscribing.
If you want to contribute to help me continue to make more videos and improve the quality of my content, you can send a donation via - ko-fi.com/themuslimmum
JOIN THE FREE MUSLIM FELLOWSHIP TELEGRAM GROUP - t.me/+-7yv9DwcMFg4Mjg0
Sister, may Allah bless you. Please reconsider this opinion of yours. You going online can be a fitna, even if you’re giving dawah since people can focus on you speaking. There is no need for Muslim women to make videos giving dawah, repost videos of scholars and post beneficial reminders. May Allah bless you again
I would take Dr Haifa million times over Dawah Man. I think she's a wonderful orator and a blessing
But women is not recommended to do dawah bro , Stay in your home don't displayed your adornments just like the former times of ignorance verse clearly mentioned in Qur'an why shouldn't obey this ???
@@Sheikh_Nishad_Hyder1948 she is past the age o marriage and isnt desirable to men so it isn't bad.
24:60
وَٱلْقَوَٰعِدُ مِنَ ٱلنِّسَآءِ ٱلَّـٰتِى لَا يَرْجُونَ نِكَاحًۭا فَلَيْسَ عَلَيْهِنَّ جُنَاحٌ أَن يَضَعْنَ ثِيَابَهُنَّ غَيْرَ مُتَبَرِّجَـٰتٍۭ بِزِينَةٍۢ ۖ وَأَن يَسْتَعْفِفْنَ خَيْرٌۭ لَّهُنَّ ۗ وَٱللَّهُ سَمِيعٌ عَلِيمٌۭ ٦٠
As for elderly women past the age of marriage, there is no blame on them if they take off their ˹outer˺ garments, without revealing their adornments. But it is better for them if they avoid this ˹altogether˺. And Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing.
- Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran
@@Sheikh_Nishad_Hyder1948 hazrat ayesha was a scholar! Islam allows women to become a scholar what's the problem?
@@amnanisar7696 u are comparing Aisha ra with today women ?
The superiority of Aisha to other women is like the superiority of Tharid to other food
- Sahih Bukhari 5418
So pliz dont compare
@@Sheikh_Nishad_Hyder1948 comparing huh???? Who's comparing!?? I'm just giving the example that it's allowed!!
I think I understand the concept of what Brother Dawah was saying but I think if you look at Islamic history and look at the Sunnah then there has been cases of female voices such as Aisha(RA) also females should hear female voices regarding certain aspects of the deen, it just naturally comes across better when it comes from someone you can relate too.
Ditto
any woman of today who compares herself to ayesha is a fool.
@BigBroSadiq no one can compare
Very very true ✔️✔️✔️
Hazrat Ayesha r.z !
Hazrat khadijah r.z !
Muslim women warriors !
Fatimah Al-Fihri !
These men should think before saying anything, because you'll have daughters as well, you cannot just say whatever you want, especially when islam has allowed it, "a woman's job is birthing children, a woman's job is to stay at home, a woman's job is to obey her husband, a woman's job is to be patient and listen to their husbands if they won't they'll be in hellfire" Astaghfirullah, may Allah guide these men and keep them away from good women of the ummah. Our purpose is to obey ALLAH (SWT) no one except him, he is before ANYTHING. So nobody's opinion matters, I'm sick now listening to these men treating women like maids and baby making machines who don't have dreams and desires, astaghfirullah this is so heartbreaking. May Allah protect all of us and give us good partners, the slaves of Allah not the slaves to their moods and nafs, Aameen.
Edit : Wallahi people have started a fight and calling me a feminist for saying "we should obey Allah" seriously astaghfirullah may Allah guide these. Whatever I've said isn't against a gender it's against those men who are being discussed here and the video, who are treating women like maids and trash, if people are offended listening to facts, i feel sorry for you, JazzakAllah
May Allah SWT guide us all. Ameen
Sister you have NO IDEA WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT . And you just contradicted yourself by saying “our purpose is to obey Allah swt.” Yeah so does Allah swt not tell you to obey your husband?????” The Prophet (saw) said, moltte, “sujood is impermissible to anyone else but Allah but if it was, I’d command the women to do sujood to their husbands.”
But again, you’re washed by the Western #ZionistAgenda like other Western women. Women like you either end up getting divorced cuz your husbands can’t put up with it or you end up marrying #Simps who compromise the Qur’an and sunnah for the happiness of their wives. And women usually abandon these #Simps too cuz they eventually realize that “I want him to take charge..” Or….. they make a slave out of him.
You have no idea what you’re saying cuz you don’t know what true hijaab is.
"These men"
When you speak like that you show your feminism and misandry.
No muslim men are against women giving dawah except the Wahabis so call them out and not "these men"
Check your misandry
It's not just the companion ladies ra many good example ladies ra in the Quran
Anything wrong with that they said?
She is in full hijab without any make up and in her 60s .
Allah tells women to observe hijab so we can participate in society. The whole concept of hijab is to allow us to participate without harassment.
Muslim men with a problem with Muslim women online, then why are you watching their videos? Let the Muslim woman watch Muslim women. Let Muslim men watch Muslim men. But they cannot keep the separation. They have to watch the Muslim women. What about lowering their gaze or turning away. If you think men are so weak when the woman are fully covered, advise the men to not watch. Why are you talking to the women?
Because men are maintainers of women, thats why he has the right to tell you that. Theres no such thing as "just leave it for the sisters" unless it has to do with female problem(periods etc) then we leave it for the sisters.
@@vortexlight8387 You are the maintainers of your wives and daughters. Not other men's wives and daughters. Take care of your house and leave the non-mahram alone.
@@ViolettaVie if their dad or husband does not do it, then other muslim men have to forbid evil and enjoy good, which includes them telling you to not be online, and stay at home.
@@vortexlight8387 You enjoin good and forbid wrong by talking to their husbands and fathers, not talking to the women.
Aside from that women are absolutely allowed to be online. If you do not like that then that is your problem. You are the one on this channel, watching these women and giving them views. You cannot help yourself, can you? You just have to watch them and then tell them they are doing wrong. While you could be on another channel watching men. But you don't want to do that. Your nafs can't handle actually observing hijab, can it?
@@ViolettaVie actually no, because the fact that shes online means her husband or father agrees with it. so you have to address what is public not what is private.
also saying "you are here watching this channel" is the same as saying "women shudnt wear hijab, men shud just not look at them" but in fact you do have to wear hijab.(i.e not being online)
also, non-muslim men are also looking at you when they refuse to lower their gaze. so its all still fitnah that you are spreading.
There’s a dress code women have to observe when with mahrams, and a stricter dress code when with non-mahrams, this implies that women existing in a public setting is perfectly fine since the outlined rules are how to behave in these situations.
It doesn’t make sense to say “here’s how you should present yourself in public, but you can’t be in public”
I agree with this 100%.
Please explain this more... I want to know If I got it right
Dawahboy is not trained in fiqh or usool ul fiqh. He just saying what his scholars are telling him or regurgitating statements by his circle. If you are trained alim who has studies various topics over the years. Then you would have a broader scope and understanding.
Its funny those have the harshest language and love to call out this individual and that individuals. Meanwhile the country their ulamas are from is changing radically at a alarming rate.
Will keep quite and make excuses for the leadership of the country, but talk down sister who are actually doing good work and benefitting the ummah.
Dr Haifa is a great example in modern times for Muslim women . She went into gynaecology and she teaches Islam with the most pleasing manners . She studied Islam
In Jeddah. She’s a hafizah. She’s very humble about it all . And she set up her own online institute taught by women for women only .
She may make mistakes but don’t we all? To say she should effectively be disregarded shut up and stay at
Home is highly offensive. This mentality of women shut up in the home is not from
Islam. Don’t mix culture and Islam. Hijab is worn so women can be a part of society whilst maintaining their modesty and loyalty to Allah
Now I agree with the niqab or a physical barrier . But not everyone believes this is necessary . If she has understanding from scholars this is not a requirement that’s the belief she is following . There is no need to be abusive . Rather those boys and men who disagree better you watch the male daees . You have a few amazing ones and many bad apples amongst them .
Women online barely have any to follow or relate to . And most men cannot fathom women’s issues. The ones I have seen lack Islamic knowledge and just bring their red pill arguments onto the table rather than Islamic knowledge .
I prefer male scholars who have studied for decades to self made daees because most have good manners and understand us .
I can’t think of any female daees online that I would listen to. Dr Haifa is a recent one I discovered , she’s a gem.
Mother of believers would answer questions from behind the veil. They are better than all you combined. So how can some sister all of a sudden show her face for dawah? It’s just fitna and not in shariah. I don’t know why it is hard to give lessons to sisters offline or more in a private setting.
The face is not awrah. And giving rulings behind a screen were specified for the Prophet SAW wives.
every rule in the Quran is general, unless there is another Ayah, Hadith or an Ijma by the Salaf which makes it specific. This is why when Allah made it impermissible for the wives of the Prophet(Pbuh) to remarry after his death, he revealed another Ayah about this being permissible for the other women. There is many Ayat and Ahadith which were directed towards someone specific, but even the Prophet(pbuh) or the Sahaba used that as a general rule. Also the whole woman is Awrah. The Prophet(Pbuh) said in an authentic Hadith" The woman is indeed 'awrah; when she goes out, the Shaitan is hopeful because of her, and the closest she is to the face of Allah when she is in the middle of her room" Sahih Ibn Hibbān by Abu Hātim ibn Hibbān (hadith 5599)
Sahih Ibn Khuzaima by Ibn Khuzaima (hadith 1591) @@ahabarhossain773
@hssded when the Prophet pbuh said the "whole woman is awrah" he did not mean that every part of her body should be covered. Nor did it mean she should never go out of the house. The Prophet pbuh also allowed women to go to the mosque even if their house were better for them. We see in other Hadith that the wives of the Prophet pbuh were outside alone without their veil on and he didn't say anything despite Umar RA seeing them. Not to mention the fact that non mahram women readily interacted with the Prophet SAW both in and outside the home. Not to mention the fact that women after the passing away of the Prophet pbuh were very active in the affairs of society both in AND outside the home.
@hssded what do you mean every ruling in the Qur'an is general? There are multiple Qur'anic ayats that refer to specific people. This ayat specifically refers to the Prophet SAW wives. Even then, sometimes his wives did go outside the home. There are many ayats which specifically to refer to the Prophet Muhammad pbuh himself or his adopted son or the Sahaba or Zainab RA. This is why whenever read an ayat from the Qur'an it is important to note the context it was revealed in to truly understand the meaning of it. Never once, even after this did the Prophet pbuh forbid women from going outside of the house. Yes, he recommended women to stay in their homes as much as possible but he did not forbid them.
@@ahabarhossain773 This is a Fikh principle derived of the fact that Allah adressed people specifically but this was always general and even adapted by the Prophet(Pbuh) in a general way, unless there was counter evidence making it specific. Just dont speak without knowledge, scholars from early on have always defined this Ayat as applying for all women, because they are to follow the example of the women of the believers. You are a jahil, dont talk without knowledge. Literally just open the Tafsir of Ibn Kathir about this Ayah, it's not that hard.
Wallahi that’s exactly what I call a Muslim mother subanallah the children would truly be blessed in the house Inshallah to have a mother like our wonderful elderly mother of ours dr haifa subanallah I believe she can educate the Muslims women very well inshallah. I love the knowledge and wisdom Allah blesses her with. Subanallah I remember many years ago listening to a short talk of hers about the messenger of God’s subanallah bought me to tears, I instantly fell in love with the knowledge I noticed Allah has blessed her with the inspiration I felt from a short talk was really effective and left me wondering in amazement subanallah. I soo much had this desire in my heart to share this short video with all the Muslims and non Muslims.
So how are women going to connect to role models?
I forwarded this to my wife and she benefits so much Hamdou’Allah
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته ❤
A beautiful video Muslim mom. May Allah bless you Ameen. I’m also very happy that my dear and cherished sister, the Healed Sister was on here. I absolutely love and psychologically benefit from her videos, especially because she’s a single mother who’s a business woman as well, is young, and went through a marriage that could have been better if Allah decreed. I share all of those things with her and resonate so much with her Alhamdulillah, and also because I come from a traumatic childhood as well. And I wear niqab exactly how she wears it as well Alhamdulillah.
mashallah sister you're doing an amazing job keep it up .Haters will hate you are not committing haram .
Alalh grant you good understanding and baqarah in your endeavours. x
Ameen
Why did Allah command the wives of prophet to teach behind the veils? So that the men can't see them
If thats the case for those noble men and women, whab about today's Muslims who are more prone to fitna and have lesser iman and taqwa compared to the sahabas?
What about those you look at now.. coming out and vlogging giving opinion have children and going out and pretending having a good knowledge
The women are teaching behind a veil though so what’s the issue?
@@HishSwish and who are you..veiled or not she have no knowledge for saying whats right and wrong .she will make people go lost..all these young girls think they have knowledge ..they dont ..and thats dangerous for someone like that give dawah or telling people whats right and wrong .she have children what is she doing on youtube ..this is something new ..you bring more shit into islam than curing people from the virus inside this ummah .you make the virus become more and more.. islam came as stranger and goes as stranger
@@HishSwish I can't see the veil in Dr haifaa
And this channel owners veil is incomplete
And also lol, the veil mentioned in the Qur'an is a screen, complete covering (not niqab)
@@HishSwishthe veil was a curtain not clothing
I am tired of seeing men tell us that we’re not oppressed, but say we’re not allowed to be anywhere except home unless we’re in niqab and “needed” but men are allowed to be loud and give dawah and be public… like, do men not get lusted after? It’s okay for men to be in public and around non mahrams but women can’t? Men have dress codes too, men have rules of engagement as well, and women do too. Women are allowed to be knowledgeable and spread Islam and literally forcing them not to, is the opposite of what you preach when you say women aren’t oppressed.
Frankly I need men to SHUT UP about our hijab 😭
As if it's not hard enough already. Every time a man says it aggressively it makes me want to NOT start it. It's having the opposite effect from what they think it is.
@@Iamsylvie.30 exactly!! They act like they’re doing everything 100% correctly and know everything that’s right and wrong as if they’re scholars… but I know if they were girls they’d feel the same as us
exactly. the purpose of hijab for women is so women can actively participate in the deen and dawah of islam WHILE being modestly covered. you see brothers giving dawah on the streets to girls but they say women cant even give dawah on social MEDIA? the sin is not upon the woman if a man sees her while she’s being modest
Is not men that tell u this but Allah so fear Allah sister. We Just rule by what Allah and the prophet Said May Allah guide us all
In short, it is all about your intention just like DR haifa said if you spread knowledge and get upset or mad if you dont get enough views then you should Rethink you intentions because ur main intention is to spread information to please allah.
Dr haifaa is like the dawah grandma where she explains and teaches for the deen. Us women have a certain time to feel young, the beauty and all but once she reaches that certain age i don't see why not, she can do her dawah because who's going to look at her in that type of way.
Lol trust me. Trust me. As a man that has to deal with an extremely high libido. If given the opportunity I would do anyone. I dont see this lady in that way but I have seen older women as attractive. Im not proud of it. But It is what it is and its my biggest test in this dunya. Its something I struggle with on a daily basis. I'm not even on social media because of it. So trust me. Women dont understand how difficult it is as a man to deal with these levels. Gym twice a day just about keeps the edge off.
@@jamal22958 but you are a rare case. The vast majority of men don’t look at older women in that way or the temptation is very little.
@@jamal22958maybe from someone's body, but someone's face??? Come on now
@@jamal22958 We do try to understand. Just like how we deal with our emotions and men don't really understand it. I think we should all empathize and respect one another. 🤔☺
These are sisters who have fear of Allah there hearts are soft and they don’t judge others like so many Muslim “dawah” groups are doing recently
He annoys me and I am a man of Islam.
Aisha (RA) gave dawah because there was a need for the knowledge she received from our prophet since it was the beginning of this umma and there where many marters who died on the battlefield and it's not the option she would choose to do but may Allah bless her she stepped up with takwah
Excellent point! BārakAllāhu feek.
I think these sisters that go online need to stop comparing themselves to 'Āisha (radiyAllāhu 'anhā)
@@SO-tm9oyits not an excellent point since there was plenty of sahabas alive.
You need to bring evidence that SO MANY sahabas dies and there was no one to give dawah except women.
Bring forth your evidence or shut up
Not true at all. Brint your evidence for the deaths you claim
Imam Malik ra Daughtrr gave dawah and was teaching the muslims hadith.
The Sahaba weren't equal in knowledge, in fact they were really reluctant in giving answers, since there wasn't internet to google Fatawa like today. Aisha(r.a.) was one of the major Fukaha in Madina, so if there was a disagreement among the lesser Sahaba, they would ask her opinion because the Prophet(Pbuh) taught her a lot of Ahadith which others didn't know@@khairt1731
@khairt1731 I think YOU are the one that needs to shut up because NONE of these sisters that give da'wah are qualified to do so. Don't bring me Western secular degrees or any of that diluted rubbish, either. If they REALLY had correct knowledge, they would NEVER go online 'giving da'wah' and be a cause of fitnah for millions of Muslim and non-Muslim men!
You need to go and learn the Deen the proper way instead of trying to spread falsehood and newly invented practices!
My sincere advice. Take it or leave it!
Dawah boy is a classic jahil
@AnabolicMutantyes he is
assalamu allikaum sister I’m a revert Muslim keep up the great work
This is an interesting topic. What Imran said was not entirely wrong. Women don't have to go out and give dawah like men do in the religion, which is nice since some of us don't have the desire to do so anyway. However, there is nothing wrong with a woman teaching other women the deen through social media, as long as, it is strictly deen (no makeup tutorials) and she is fully covered. The technology today makes it so she doesn't have to show herself clearly through filters and lighting, as well as, distorting the voice and lowering the pitch, so that no one will know what her true voice sounds like. You can be completely anonymous online, and with shorts, giving dawah wouldn't consume much of your time at all, so you can still fulfill your duties as a wife and mother at home.
Lets go to the scholars for this question and see what they say. Thats they're job isnt it. Instead of us coming with our own opinions out of our pockets
@@SaltySultana... the ones on UA-cam. Why even have scholars if we are just gonna come to our own conclusion
Verily this deen is for the sincere 😊
Dawah man please stay at home
We need u at home
I think u are flag bearer of feminist movement
Dont be too hatred bro
One correction there is no “4 schools in OUR DEEN” the DEEN is what was complete at the passing of the prophet (saw) The schools and they are not 4 by the way but I assume you mean 4 was historically forced on people, mostly (actually they were not even schools to begin with, except maybe Maliki ), anyway that’s a misconception but they were peoples understanding regardless & which all you can take from that at the end of the day is people’s discussions/efforts research etc (ijtihad) to get to the DEEN (revelation only) which is not binding at all (however useful) as we were not ordered to take other than wahy.
- Just a ‘minor’ point here in this discussion I guess. Still we must make a night and day distinction.
May Allah grant us all unity upon the haqq we are nothing more than brothers/sisters and servants to Allah azza wa jall and we all err and now I must go and be bothered by my errors now, bb.
I agree with what brother Dawah Man said. But in regards to purpose or intention of Dawah, it should solely be for seeking pleasure of Allah (SWT) by the ways of our beloved Prophet Muhammad (SAW).
And whoever strives only strives for [the benefit of] himself/herself. Indeed, Allah is free from need of the worlds. (Surah Al Ankabut; Verse 6)
I don't trust this girl. Not at all. Her dress has nothing to do with a "niqab". Makeup & removing eyebrow ain't in our tawheed. Our Prophet ﷺ curse women that does it. Who is she? What is her name? Aisha (ra) did give Dawah to sahaba. That time was in need. Many sahaba wasn't muslem. This have nothing to with Dawah. Pure fasad. People need to address this & give warning message about type like her.
@@Zakarialebde"many sahabas wasnt muslis"
The wahabis got you confused and misguided.
By definition a sahaba is a muslim.
@@khairt1731 was Khaled ibn Walid muslem? Seriously. Subhan Allah the internet these days. Why don't this girl (Muslim mom) go out in the street & make Dawah to stranger men as she does here? She is a fasad & has nothing to with Dawah. Do some research.
Do you need to have a hook nose to do Dawah? Pretty much 90% of them have the hook and I wonder what it’s all about
@@LiClan the question is.. Will this girl do the same Dawah on the streets for stranger men!
it doesn't matter what brothers say sister are going to do what they want anyway I don't know why brothers waste their time. but men and women of today should never compare themselves to the sahaba they were allowed certain things based on their virtues. it was Narrated from ayesha
Narrated `Aisha:
Had Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) known what the women were doing, he would have forbidden them from going to the mosque as the women of Bani Israel had been forbidden. Yahya bin Sa`id (a sub-narrator) asked `Amra (another sub-narrator), "Were the women of Bani Israel forbidden?" She replied "Yes."
(sahih bukhari)
so his wife ayesha acknowledged that after the death of the nabi female servants of Allah began doing haram things that they didn't do while he was living. however Allah says
"Allah will judge between you on the Day of Judgment concerning the matters in which ye differ."
i don't disagree with sisters talking to each other helping each other being mothers wives and good Muslim citizens and so on giving each other support but i think Muslims in general men and women shouldn't talk about Islamic knowledge without actual Islamic training. all 4 imams agree a Muslim should not speak about Islam without first learning the religion through an actual teacher who gave them permission meaning their not self taught. in the words of imam malik
Imam Malik said: "I did not start to give lecture in Fiqh and Hadith until I was declared eligible to do so by 70 teachers of Hadith and Fiqh."
sisters who are qualified to speak should be the only ones online teaching others about Islam. everyone else should be quiet and speak about life issues and so on men included and understand it's forbidden to speak about Islam without knowledge. if we are going to use the 4 imams as examples we can't only use whats in our favor. most people ask their intentions of talking online anyway really they want money or followers. i can promise you these sisters online talking can't explain the salah or it's fiqh properly same with fasting or wudu.
Protective jellousy something lacking in the Men ( Dayoooth )
Then we also have those who think the intention is correct and they are doing it for the sake of Allaah. Then they follow their own opinions and do not ask the scholars and all of this is done with no understanding of the religion .
May Allaah protect us all and protect our daughters wives from this fitna . Aameen
This is a misconception. Dayooth means letting your wife sleep with someone literally. I think you mean lack of gheerah perhaps? And regardless most think that the face is not awrah
Yes For the sake of Allah provided it allow in the Quran And Hadith.😊
They all use our mother A’isha r.A, okay was there a need for A’isha to teach at that time , YES, there were narrations that only A’isha knew and she knew majoirty, of the hadiths regarding the things the prophet saw did in privacy.
So lets ask a question, why didn’t any other wives of the prophet saw teach?
What about all the wives of the tabi’een and the at-tabi’eeen?
Surely the wives of the four madhabs have more rights to teach ?
Bring the female teachers of Al-islam from classical history?
I think there is a clear difference between the teaching of our mother A’isha R.A of there being a NEED for her to teach v.s nowadays there being a WANT to teach
A woman should only be allowed to Go on UA-cam to listen to by her husband it is what Allah has told us wohman
I love Dr Haifa. She is an inspiration. I
Alhamuillah our ulama have spoken about this issue
You would challenge your brother to commit freemixing and be around fitnah??????
What are you yapping?
Women can’t stay at home all the time they need to get out and get exercise and they also sometimes have to do grocery shopping or do other things or run errands considering they have their own money
@@SaltySultana... Nowhere in my comments, I said that we should mix with men I never said that read my comment again please
Those are considered necessity. To go to the store, to seek knowledge, to travel with a Mahram. All of that is fine if done within the parameters of Islam. This however is not
@@cyberspace7208 excuse me ? Woman can’t stay at home all the time it’s not the 1950s so unless they are sick they don’t need to stay home
@GlimmerNGlow567 No one said that a woman can never go out. But it's Allah himself who ordered women to not go out alot and to remain in their homes unless for a need. The Scholars are clear on these needs, she needs to shop, she needs to seek knowledge, she needs to visit someone, go to the doctor, or work due to a need to work (or other is best that she doesn't especially if it causes her to be alone with men) and she can go out sometimes for enjoyment, all within the boundaries of Islam. The less she goes out, the better.
The God of the 1950s, is the God of 2023 and He is the God of time and His law is forever.
@@cyberspace7208 women are allowed to go out per guidelines of Allah however they do they need to get out and get air and food clothes bare minimum period
Women need to see women frankly
Not if they corrupt each other
But i thought women werent supposed to look at men so if we dont have female speakers, who do we listen to
Women should do dawah
Seriously?! people like dawah man, ali dawah et al, behave like big self righteous flag bearer of islam to undermine the work of our learned scholars and teachers now?!.
Sayda Aisha and Sayda Fatima were teaching Hadith to men! Some long beards know nothing about Islam!
Do not lie on the mothers of the believers, Allah will ask you about this.
@@cyberspace7208 Your ignorance calls for me to be named a liar!! Go READ then come and talk to me!
@@nl1011 Do not lie on the mothers of the believers.
What about hijabi influencers publicly supporting LGBTQ and promoting divorces..... Feminism.. Healed sister dont understand what we says.. If she look around..
Name one hijabi promoting LGBT ?
@@MH-bf4uu Blair Imani
Btw for the guy in the video men aren’t allowed to wear bracelets bc it imitates women and I recently found out that wearing beaded bracelets are called shamballa bracelets or whatever and it comes from the Buddhist religion and stuff so do ur research on that. And for the women, ur hand showed in the video when u lifted it up, and ur shoulder when u talk to the sister, u should blur it or make sure to cover up beforehand so u don’t have to worry.
Bro u did the opposite what they r trying to teach you
They just said let them be and here u r again pointing fingers
Best is to look at ur own deeds
And leave the SISTER matter to sisters !
@@myquest1856it's not about pointing fingers when they're only trying to help spread of awareness of such sins.
@@myquest1856 I’m not pointing fingers. I’m advising in case they don’t know. I didn’t know until recently that those beaded bracelets were from the Buddhist religion. And I said to do research bc I don’t want people to JUST take my word for it but for them to see the evidence themselves. And I was warning the sister bc exposing the awrah is haram and I don’t want her to get sins from the non mehrams watching.
@@Altair-El-Haddad thank you!!
Dawho blames ladies for he's sick feelings it's not the ladies problem it is his problem in society and in the hereafter
@@SaltySultana... accountable for what he's sick problems
you'll be accountable for the backbiting @@070uu
Bro dont judge someone too quick and easily?
We dont follow anything blindly like you ??
@@SaltySultana... you should go and live in a zoo cage on your own Muslim ladies are dress moderately Islamic even if she's not Muslim not dressed up like many parts of the world you look at them as a sister in humanity explaining something to you or whatever The companions ra do not carry your filthy feelings in them towards there sisters ra at there Times or any lady
The Prophet(pbuh) said: "The woman is indeed 'awrah; when she goes out, the Shaitan is hopeful because of her. Then the closest she is to the face of Allah when she is in the middle of her room" Sahih Ibn Hibbān by Abu Hātim ibn Hibbān (hadith 5599)
Sahih Ibn Khuzaima by Ibn Khuzaima (hadith 1591)
Being a Muslim girl who read hadith and everything I realised there is no way girls can tell everyone what is right what is wrong in Islam I mean being a teacher online it's like no no no if you want yes you can do for girls or line only girls like video call something anything to where only girls are allowed and I will support her until doing all lying and going where you will see so many men together with women nooo
And accepted 4 different things said here by other sisters
Deen is different said by other sister because of we have 4 imam ,i think she followed Imam not Qur'an and sunnah
That is why i call myself
Ahle Sunnah wal Jamaat
There are thousands of women teaching online in the privacy of their home to only women. There is no need to create UA-cam channels and tik tok channels under the name of dawah and expose your self to millions of men.
Problems with women giving dawah
(Firstly I'm not saying that I'm against women giving dawah, but sisters their are some conditions we've to follow, Ayesha raziAllahuanha was herself the one who gave us so many narrations of Prophet ﷺ)
•Women exposing their faces while giving dawah (while Allah says in Quran surah an Nur to hide our adornments and cover our faces in ayah 31)
•many women coming up to give dawah in colorful abayas- the purpose of abaya is to hide beauty and beautifying it isn't helping the purpose
•Women having jokes or not talking like we are supposed to talk in front of na mehrams (like yk they all use kind voices and it's common sense afc that they have to like everyone has to but what if a na mehram sees it?)
I don't support the guy shown when he says that women don't have to give dawah, WOMEN SHOULD GIVE DAWAH but to their mehrams and same goes for men, though for example their is a video of Sheikh and women watches it then okay and same way if a women asks a doubt to men of knowledge then he can reply them, and just reply to the point nothing excess and vice versa
But when women (who are said to protect their awrah) come up with thor videos then they're disobeying Allāh...give offline dawah to other sisters and your mehrams and online you can share through texts.
I reminded you what Allāh said whether you follow it or not it's your choice but remember you don't have to disobey Allah to please people or just win against them
There is a difference of opinion as to whether it is wajib for a woman to cover her face. Dr. Haifaa Yunis and other scholars is a well seasoned scholar who has done her research and has came to an understanding that is different from yours, and as she said you are entitled to respect for your fish just as you do. And Allah knows best.
If a man especially religious men says, dont do.. Then there is a reason..
Religious men?😂 god is much important then your religion men
Are you ok? You see someone with a beard and assume they are well versed in fiqh?
@@MH-bf4uu oh liberal woke
Its haram. Freemixing is more haram.
Where does it say that, and why not for men
If she is with a mahram, I see no problem with women advising other women
Why do you need a mahram if you are talking to women? Makes no sense
السلام عليك ورحمة الله وبركاته
The brother haven’t talked about voice being awrah. Also he came with proofs from the Quran and the sunnah. Have we forgot that we are Muslim and that will always bring our dispute back to the Quran and the sunnah ?
Unfortunately all I see in this video is emotional argument, no proof but still people saying there is ikhtilāf in fiqh….
Allahu al-musta’ān
I don’t believe it’s awrah. The majority of the scholars don’t either . We are only advised not to speak with a gently enticing voice with men, speak harshly or matter of fact manner .
We aren’t to sing or recite Quran in front of them without a need , they have male qari to listen to.
But regular speaking with need, we can . Allah didn’t make us to be mute and invisible
@@luluah1198 again I to don’t believe women voice is ‘awrah but you still didn’t answer what I said. I mean what you sisters are doing is da’wah in public, is this allowed in Islam ? For women to come out and do this ? All I know from the salaf is that women would stay in their houses and speak behind a veil and not going out and do da’wah.
@@luluah1198 and to be honest with you myself I believed that it would be great if women did da’wah to sister online but the question is is it allowed.
@@mohameddaoud7018with all due respect to ur question , acc to most scholars it is permissible. As long as the sister is not spreading any kind of fitnah . And moreover the healed sister has already said a lot . Don't uh think she is right ? And every muslim women cannot stay home .eg a Muslim woman being a dr that treats women only , a teacher that teaches women only , a tailor ,a designer and many other things are there where Muslim women need to work .... don't uh agree with this all . I hope brother uh not gonna call me feminist for this now .
Jahil boy would be attacking Aicha (RA) if he lived during that time
You will be accountable for this comment on the day of judgement. Be careful.
@@Altair-El-Haddad with good rewards, insha'Allah.
Appreciate your concern looking out for a brother Masha'Allah. If only jahil boy would adopt your approach.
3:42 is real..
Sisters its not the voice it's the way its said.
Thank you for sharing!
You're welcome
Is this sister from Glasgow, Scotland?
Subhan Allah.. That have nothing to do with fellow one of the 4 school's. Fellow the Sunnah that it. Aisha did her job because it was a need that time. Most sahaba was not muslems. Sisters has nothing to do online in my opinion.. Definitely not a sister using makeup & remove her eyebrows. That pure fasad. Our Prophet ﷺ will never ever allow it. This sisters dress has nothing to with a niqab. Embarrassing to see this kind of change & worst of all.. Men that enjoying sisters online. Muslim mum..i advise you.. Stop using makeup & change your eyebrow. You making huge fasad to younger sister. Your beauty is only for your husband not online guys. You husband need to step up as a man. Yes you are basically selling you self publicly. Allahu al musta'an.
Dawah man in every aspect. Our victory in our Deen is through men. That the iza Allah gave us. Subhan Allah what the West have done to these girls & boys. Click bait for views & money.
this is haqq. These feminists will see what following a Kufr Western ideology brings them in the Akhira.
@@hssded this girl is a huge fasad. Just look almos only men comment on her & a bunch of guy's asking for her marriage & beauty. No one know who she is what her name & so on. Red flag when seeing hijab with makeup & removing eyebrow. No way on Earth those girl knows their Tawheed.
@@SaltySultana... you people are so embarrassing are you listening to what she is saying or are you looking at every inch of her face in the perverted Manor and looking to who to talk about it
I thought women werent supposed to look at men so why are these guys online then? If we can't listen to women or men, how are we supposed to get knowledge. If guys cant handle a wonen in full hijab because of their weakness, then look away or scroll on
The lengths some sisters would go to justify their nafs.
Provide evidence on your side and don't act like a jaahil. Study fiqh
Sisters talk to women but behind curtains.
Allahu Akbar Sister
The amount of women giving dawah on the Internet nowdays shouldn't be allowed...most women show their faces and many of them wear ridiculous makeup...
How do you know? Should you not be lowering your gaze?
@@MH-bf4uu it's all over the Internet and I can see things. I don't wait and watch their stuff but I can see the amount of women giving dawah on the internet when scroll on yt. It's not the street where I can just low my gaze all the time. When you scroll you see things. If you don't see such women on the Internet then you are the ignorant one
@@SaltySultana... they literally Preach islam to people. What are you talking about
Women shouldn't be looking at men either so if we dont have female speakers how do we get knowledge. If you cant handle a woman in full hijab, look away, scroll past
@@theecologist10 From the beginning it is always the men who preached islam. If we talk about Women of Islam, even the mothers of the believer including aisha (ra) who was the greatest woman islamic scholar never gave a sermon or preached islam. Learn islamic from the trusted scholars not just from any muslim.
Knowledge is power. Perhaps learn to take beating from your training partner (bjj).
I think it's good your dawah but I think a husband at some point will break and affect him. Especially if the world knows who he is.
So enjoy the videos and having your voice heard.
So dont say what is wrong
Women should definitely not be doing dawah on social media unless with full niqab - Haifa may be an exception because she is elderly
I mean you have make up on age your eyebrows cut I mean there's clear dalel about that but I can't argue with anything else
Looking a bit intensely for someone who's meant to lower thier gaze
Dawah conman needs to get offline and get a real job. He’s a disgrace.
Who’s “Dawah Man”?
Dawah with men is the best , that’s why we don’t have female prophets.
Stop embarrassing yourself 😂 dawah and being prophet aren't the same , there's only prophet men cuz they had an actual struggle in real life and war 😂not you UA-cam kids
Because they had to lead wars
That doesn’t mean women shouldn’t be allowed to speak
There is no hijab in quran there is jilbab in quran jilbab is not what you are wearing.
whatever he is saying, is absolutely with sincere intension to keep the family intact and happy but he needs to revisit his choice of words he is using to make a point. In these days talking about "obeying to please your spouse" is a no no.
Whys that "no no"? Feminism got to your head
@@SaltySultana...Firstly relax. Secondly understand that the English word obey has negative connotations. Let's use the Arabic words instead. I wish you would use empathy skills to understand where people are coming from
no.
This brother or Shaik is belongs to Tabligiee Jamat ( I call BOX Muslim), they criticize all good work
Dawah Man is a wahabi/pseudo-salafi not tableeg jamat
@@khairt1731 Dawn man is on the haqq. Does not follow stupid debondii innovations
He is from from the tablighi jamaat he is a salafi
Rabee Madkhali actually called for the execution of tableeghi jaam'at members in 90s I wouldn't trust those jahils follow the way of the salaf, not modern day salafi club which is now multiple sects fighting eachother
Tabligis doing best effort bringing back Muslims to practicing again alhamdulilah and they produce most ulema and graduates like Daniel haqiqajou said
Do u follow deen or ur desires? It’s not permissible to upload videos even if niqabi.
It is absolutely permissible. Don't spread lies about Islam.
@@Shimayeel123-_-provide your evidence
@@EmalZ-b8y u made the claim burden of proof is on you
@@EmalZ-b8yUh give ur evidence !!
@@kaisardawg4389 i lessen his burden, surah an Nur ayah 31
And tell the believing women to reduce [some] of their vision and guard their private parts and not expose their adornment except that which [necessarily] appears thereof and to wrap [a portion of] their headcovers over their chests and not expose their adornment [i.e., beauty] except to their husbands, their fathers, their husbands' fathers, their sons, their husbands' sons, their brothers, their brothers' sons, their sisters' sons, their women, that which their right hands possess [i.e., slaves], or those male attendants having no physical desire, or children who are not yet aware of the private aspects of women. And let them not stamp their feet to make known what they conceal of their adornment. And turn to Allāh in repentance, all of you, O believers, that you might succeed.
Islam always treating women poorly lol
No, it's men - certain men treat women badly in every culture
@@MH-bf4uu have you read the quran lol?
Respectfully my Muslims sisters, I have to agree. Covering yourself and then coming on screen might not seem like a contradiction to you but it is. You can still do dawah in person.
Don't watch them. Simply lower your gaze
@@MH-bf4uuI agree, if they cant handle seeing a woman in full hijab then they should lower their gaze like they've been commanded. Also I thought women werent supposed to look at men either, so if we dont have female speaks how are we supposed to get knowledge
They're both in two different extreme and wrong