Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
@@jaguar4120 girl she has nodules, sometimes she needs to lip some parts of song or even the whole song to rest, but that doesn't mean that she can't hit high notes
This is so live and only true lambs will know that. Fools are really fools to think this is lip-synced or is the album audio. Hello? There are parts in this performance where her voice cracks, beautifully. Haters or those who judge just because, I wonder why you're not famous and rich yourself, making money from records and albums. She is a living legend, vocal nodules and all. :) ♥
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
@Swami Holland that's the sound engineer's job to adjust the mic's volume because its out in the open. Also the audio is clearly filtered because you can barely hear the instrumental or the background singers so the person who filtered it from the original recording could've adjusted different parts so it sounds consistent on each note. Saying this is prerecorded and lipsynced is like saying mariah used studio tracks and sounded like this in the studio. You know damn well she's too much of a perfectionist to be satisfied with audio like this. She'd never use this to lipsync.
This is a very moving performance. You can tell that she was lost in the song and is feeling every single word of it. She was in the zone. She is a great singer because of the depths of feelings and heights of passion that she is able to access and transmit to the world, with love, like a conduit. People who just concentrate on whether she can still land a triple axel or a quadruple salchow are missing out.
Karen Anderson was just like you texting Mr well as possible in order to do is to get some sleep tonight at all times when you texting Mr and Mrs nah cards are a great many people who were not going to be taking a great many people bring you texting Mr and Mrs
Okay, so maybe you need to pay attention to what I originally said. I was speaking generally. Obviously I know this performance had prerecorded bits. I never explicitly talked about the contents of this video.
I implied that she can still give a good performance despite any off days. You don't know what I was implying so once again take your self righteous bullshit out of here.
Mariah has always been better than Whitney. Whitney will live on forever as an absolute amazing vocalist, but she never wrote a single song, nor did she compose a song. Mariah has done both on every song that is hers (covers do not count).
1. why is whitney in this anyway? 2. whitney did write songs and vocally arranged every song and even arranged the when you believe 1999 oscars performance. don’t speak if you don’t know what you’re talking about
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
Truly she is wonderful, and this is live. Although it is canned or something...but her voice is phenomenal here and the range she shows in this performance is sick.
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
How the hell you do expect mariah to sing live all the time... obviously youre not a singer... we all know how crazy of a singer she is but she needs her vocal rests
Once upon a time We swore not to say goodbye Something got a hold of us And we changed And you sat alone in pride And I sat at home and cried How'd our fairy tale just end up this way? We went round for round Til' we knocked love out We were laying in the ring Not making a sound And if that's a metaphor of you and I Why is it so hard to say goodbye? I can't wait to hate you Make you pain like I do Still can't shake you off I can't wait to break through these emotional changes Seems like such a lost cause I can't wait to face you Break you down so low there's no place left to go I can't wait to hate you, ooh This was all a phenomenon that no one could explain And I wish I could press reset and feel that feeling again I sit and press rewind And watch us every night Want to pause it but I can't make it stay We went 'round for 'round 'Til we knocked love out We were laying in the ring Not making a sound And if that's a metaphor of you and I Why is it so hard to say goodbye? I can't wait to hate you Make you pain like I do Still can't shake you off I can't wait to break through these emotional changes Seems like such a lost cause I can't wait to face you Break you down so low there's no place left to go I can't wait to hate you, ooh No need to call my phone 'Cause I changed my number today And matter fact I think I'm moving away (away) Sorry the frustrations got me feelin' a way And I just keep having one last thing to say And I just want to hold you, touch you, feel you Be near you, I miss you babe babe babe (babe babe babe) I am tired of tryin' to fake through But there is nothing I can do Boy I can't wait to hate you I can't wait to hate you Make you pain like I do Still can't shake you off I can't wait to break through these emotional changes Seems like such a lost cause I can't wait to face you Break you down so low that there's no place left to go I can't wait to hate you baby ooh I can't wait to hate you But right now I need you I can't wait to hate you I can't wait to hate you But right now I need you
If people think that this is prerecorded they are delusional...theres nothing more raw than this. You don't lip sync to an imperfect track....that makes no sense. Im tired of hearing people ignorant of music comment on this topic.
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
@@jaguar4120 what this is, is a live feed of her mic which is why you can't really hear the band or the background singers behind her that well. When you watch this on your tv at home you would hear everything in balance because you are hearing all feeds and it has been mixed etc. But this is a live fed from just her mic and you can hear the live band the backing track and the background singers faintly behind her coming through her mic. I wasn't saying that Mariah might never have lip synched ever in her whole career but this is not one of those times and too often she is accused of it when it's not true. Ive seen her live numerous times and she has never lip synched. Im not some uniformed fan Im a graduate of Berklee College of Music, being a professional musician myself I know personally people who play in her band and background singers that have worked with her- her entire career. I know the difference between live, recorded background tracks and a totally prerecorded experience. this is not one
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
This is a pre recorded track. You can notice the editing in some of the mic's different hisses. Sometimes she sings over her own voice... 0:48 and we can't hear a breath when the song's lenght is really demanding it. Maybe she just sang in the beggining or/and in the very end.
Its pre-recored, some parts are sang live, you can here it when she sings over the top of it! Also some words are overlapped, unless its humanly possible to sing two words at once, its not 100% live! Not hate, love Mariah!!!
❤🤣❤🤣❤🤣❤🤣❤😂😂 MARIAH IS LYPSINCING YEAH RIGHT, THE ONLY ONE OUT THERE THAT CAN DO IT 100% LIVE... BUT NO, YOUR FAVES 1 OCTAVE OF VOICE AND AUTOTUNE, THEY DON'T . ❤😂❤😂❤😂❤😂❤😂❤
You're correct Kelly. I think people think they can't admit when Mariah lips because they're fans but I'm a huge fan and can still hear that a large chunk was just the studio acapella.
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
![[HD] Mariah Carey - H.A.T.E.U. Live at David Letterman 2009](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yUQq77IX-cI/mqdefault.jpg)
amazing whistles and her breath control has to be the best out there.
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
@@jaguar4120 girl stfu go listen to her In the 90s u dumb bitch😊her songs are hard asf so she have a right to use backing track
@@jaguar4120 girl she has nodules, sometimes she needs to lip some parts of song or even the whole song to rest, but that doesn't mean that she can't hit high notes
I can hear two whistles tho
This is so live and only true lambs will know that. Fools are really fools to think this is lip-synced or is the album audio. Hello? There are parts in this performance where her voice cracks, beautifully.
Haters or those who judge just because, I wonder why you're not famous and rich yourself, making money from records and albums.
She is a living legend, vocal nodules and all. :) ♥
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
girl u must be a fake lamb- because this is giving lip sync😭 listen to the studio version and this version 😭
@Swami Holland that's the sound engineer's job to adjust the mic's volume because its out in the open. Also the audio is clearly filtered because you can barely hear the instrumental or the background singers so the person who filtered it from the original recording could've adjusted different parts so it sounds consistent on each note.
Saying this is prerecorded and lipsynced is like saying mariah used studio tracks and sounded like this in the studio. You know damn well she's too much of a perfectionist to be satisfied with audio like this. She'd never use this to lipsync.
@@jacefreeney1387 it doesn't sound like the studio version at all wdym
She's hitting the high note as usual
T'étais déjà là y'a 8 ans??
Lipsyncing as usual
@@knuckles2587 F off
@@knuckles2587 whats the point of you looking up her performances and commenting this 😭😭
@Butterfly Era them looking up one of her lesser known performances too... thats dedication. A true lamb
This is a very moving performance. You can tell that she was lost in the song and is feeling every single word of it. She was in the zone. She is a great singer because of the depths of feelings and heights of passion that she is able to access and transmit to the world, with love, like a conduit. People who just concentrate on whether she can still land a triple axel or a quadruple salchow are missing out.
Karen Anderson was just like you texting Mr well as possible in order to do is to get some sleep tonight at all times when you texting Mr and Mrs nah cards are a great many people who were not going to be taking a great many people bring you texting Mr and Mrs
I be so nervous for her when she sings live.. this was good tho
She's a pro. She has off days but she can still nail it.
I still be nervous
Thanks for your opinion! I'll gladly take note of it.
Okay, so maybe you need to pay attention to what I originally said. I was speaking generally. Obviously I know this performance had prerecorded bits. I never explicitly talked about the contents of this video.
I implied that she can still give a good performance despite any off days. You don't know what I was implying so once again take your self righteous bullshit out of here.
I absolutely love when she does acapella, she sounds so amazing!! LYM
2:20 that whistle tone is just still amazing Way to go Mimi us TRUE fans know the truth
That's actually her head voice, she hit an F6 here
@@maximhamley6662 Whistle *
Ashley Thomspon head voice girl
@@whenxmascums It might be head voice when she does it , but I do it in whistle 😂
@@whenxmascums It sounds like her whistle register though. You can connect head to whistle, it's just harder to connect chest to whistle
I love mariah ever.
I'm loving all of that black. She made me think about cat woman❤💕. She sang like an angel💞💕
Queen Mariah 💖
Beautiful ❤️ #1 always then and now
Not sure about the entire song but at 2:29 she just tears through that last verse and it’s absolutely live. It sounds emotional and very real.
definitely live!!!
It's so FUCKING live !!!!!!
No it's not. It's lipped
Mariah has always been better than Whitney. Whitney will live on forever as an absolute amazing vocalist, but she never wrote a single song, nor did she compose a song. Mariah has done both on every song that is hers (covers do not count).
userfriendlynewmodel I was thinking the same.
1. why is whitney in this anyway? 2. whitney did write songs and vocally arranged every song and even arranged the when you believe 1999 oscars performance. don’t speak if you don’t know what you’re talking about
genius.
Sweet singing 💕..🎶
Queen❤
Beautiful!!!!
love her, always will
this is her live and he stripped away the instrumental which is why there are odd tonal qualities to her voice
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
@@jaguar4120 child stfu
Truly she is wonderful, and this is live. Although it is canned or something...but her voice is phenomenal here and the range she shows in this performance is sick.
she sounds amazing!
In fact It's not Acapella it's the creator of the video who has lowered the background music That's all !! lol...But MC was Good Anyway ;)
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
@@jaguar4120 stfu
@@jaguar4120 she said it in the first half of the 90s ahahah but nodules just makes ur voice tired so sometimes lipping is just better
How the hell you do expect mariah to sing live all the time... obviously youre not a singer... we all know how crazy of a singer she is but she needs her vocal rests
i feel like an angel cries when listening to this song
People say they can't hear her breathe , but I can .... soooo , where is the lip sync again ?
exactly
Lol is wrong with people you can Literally hear her breath in every note
This was so live people will always just find a problem whit M.C because she is so good
Amazing
Wonderfull
Once upon a time
We swore not to say goodbye
Something got a hold of us
And we changed
And you sat alone in pride
And I sat at home and cried
How'd our fairy tale just end up this way?
We went round for round
Til' we knocked love out
We were laying in the ring
Not making a sound
And if that's a metaphor of you and I
Why is it so hard to say goodbye?
I can't wait to hate you
Make you pain like I do
Still can't shake you off
I can't wait to break through these emotional changes
Seems like such a lost cause
I can't wait to face you
Break you down so low there's no place left to go
I can't wait to hate you, ooh
This was all a phenomenon that no one could explain
And I wish I could press reset and feel that feeling again
I sit and press rewind
And watch us every night
Want to pause it but I can't make it stay
We went 'round for 'round
'Til we knocked love out
We were laying in the ring
Not making a sound
And if that's a metaphor of you and I
Why is it so hard to say goodbye?
I can't wait to hate you
Make you pain like I do
Still can't shake you off
I can't wait to break through these emotional changes
Seems like such a lost cause
I can't wait to face you
Break you down so low there's no place left to go
I can't wait to hate you, ooh
No need to call my phone
'Cause I changed my number today
And matter fact I think I'm moving away (away)
Sorry the frustrations got me feelin' a way
And I just keep having one last thing to say
And I just want to hold you, touch you, feel you
Be near you, I miss you babe babe babe (babe babe babe)
I am tired of tryin' to fake through
But there is nothing I can do
Boy I can't wait to hate you
I can't wait to hate you
Make you pain like I do
Still can't shake you off
I can't wait to break through these emotional changes
Seems like such a lost cause
I can't wait to face you
Break you down so low that there's no place left to go
I can't wait to hate you baby ooh
I can't wait to hate you
But right now I need you
I can't wait to hate you
I can't wait to hate you
But right now I need you
She looks like straight outta Charmbracelet era here like 2003...
Mariah Carey's voice is an instrument.
wow her voice is so unique
beautiful!
i love mariah
la amo!!!!
If people think that this is prerecorded they are delusional...theres nothing more raw than this. You don't lip sync to an imperfect track....that makes no sense. Im tired of hearing people ignorant of music comment on this topic.
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
@@jaguar4120 what this is, is a live feed of her mic which is why you can't really hear the band or the background singers behind her that well. When you watch this on your tv at home you would hear everything in balance because you are hearing all feeds and it has been mixed etc. But this is a live fed from just her mic and you can hear the live band the backing track and the background singers faintly behind her coming through her mic. I wasn't saying that Mariah might never have lip synched ever in her whole career but this is not one of those times and too often she is accused of it when it's not true. Ive seen her live numerous times and she has never lip synched. Im not some uniformed fan Im a graduate of Berklee College of Music, being a professional musician myself I know personally people who play in her band and background singers that have worked with her- her entire career. I know the difference between live, recorded background tracks and a totally prerecorded experience. this is not one
2:15 are you ready guys..
Is it the mic making her voice sound weird when she goes up high? Strange.
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
This is a pre recorded track. You can notice the editing in some of the mic's different hisses. Sometimes she sings over her own voice... 0:48 and we can't hear a breath when the song's lenght is really demanding it. Maybe she just sang in the beggining or/and in the very end.
That's called stripping the audio. This is live
yes, same at 0:54 ("why...") no breath sound when it's clear it happened.
Caio Batista Its just the studio version not pre-recorded
Agree. I'm a die-hard lamb and this is definitely pre-recorded. But it's all good cuz mimi slayed this
what program did you use to get this audio?
@1MCLover
AGREED - AWESOME!!! She sounds great
Linda
the whistles :D
Simplesmente amooooo
awesome...love her
Jordan Parke listen from a fan for 23 years it\s so f******ing live
Ao cold
look up Acapella in the dictionnary
true.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
❤z❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Its pre-recored, some parts are sang live, you can here it when she sings over the top of it! Also some words are overlapped, unless its humanly possible to sing two words at once, its not 100% live! Not hate, love Mariah!!!
Sam Thompson Alabama in
Sam Thompson Alabama
If you listen to her singing you will realise why she didn't take any breathe🤣 🤣👍👍👍she's so awesome
@SpongeMPCGirl of course I don't mind :) :) People should learn more about Mariah's voice and vocal health before judging her!
Do Mariah still sing Live. I don't know 😢
😍😍😍😍😇😇😇😇👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
No if it was prerecorded she'd have put in good notes for the very few that are off, she's great.
now let a fool say she lips sync !!!!!!
FUCK YEAS MARIAH!
Is that her leather jacket form the 1996 daydream tour???
Isso não live nem aqui nem na China, é notável que foi editando por fãs pra dizer que é ao vivo.
infelizmente :(
Tá viajando isso é ao vivo cheio de imperfeições na voz dela eu tenho todos os micfeeds desse dia ..
Then where is she lipping?
This is not the album audio.... And tbh Mariah Carey is the only female artist that can sound amazing even in her worst vocal state.
u used your comment to put this hater in its place, i hope you dont mind
😳😬
this is mariah not whitney, then how they can be alike?
Lipped.
2:17-2:29 WTF?? o.O : S
I love MC big fan! But this is lipped! Its been pre-recorded, you can tell, she stands so close to the microphone and slips up in places!
Anyone please show me how to do acapella of a live song like this? Or please make one for I Want to Know What Love Is on Alan Carr show
still wont be like whitney singing acapella
Can she be lip syncing an accapella song... Does it sound lipped, fool
❤🤣❤🤣❤🤣❤🤣❤😂😂
MARIAH IS LYPSINCING
YEAH RIGHT, THE ONLY ONE OUT THERE THAT CAN DO IT 100% LIVE... BUT NO, YOUR FAVES 1 OCTAVE OF VOICE AND AUTOTUNE, THEY DON'T .
❤😂❤😂❤😂❤😂❤😂❤
This is the original album vocal...not live at all.
Real fans will know that this is lipped
Gianmarco Giuli yup lol
Yup not singing live.
She lip syncing some of it
She is lipsycying to the whole song. Lol... 🙄
Not live at all...I can't even 👂the wind blow!!😂😂
its live girl.. its just stripped ..
You're correct Kelly. I think people think they can't admit when Mariah lips because they're fans but I'm a huge fan and can still hear that a large chunk was just the studio acapella.
Sorry to break hearts, but this is lip-synced...
Sorry to break your heart but you're an idiot...
Yes she was. The funny thing about Mariah is that she says that she never lip syncs but that is a huge lie. Of course she has a beautiful voice. But she does uses backtrack or uses the raw vocals from the studio version to act like she is singing live. Lol... But Mariah is a Diva. She will never admit it. I'm not hating on her. I love her music. 🙄🤣🥰
@@jaguar4120 The only time Mariah said she doesn't lip sync was in the 90s because her voice was in such great shape.
It’s fake...