me too until I replayed video several times, then the very last "yanni", the one almost sounded like noise, sounded like laurel. btw his audio is not great on several videos anyway.
A formant is not a visualisation of a collection of sound waves. A formant is a resonance in speech, whereas I believe you mean the spectrogram shown is the visualisation of sound waves.
When I hear the original recording, I hear both at the same time. Yanny is a robotic, high pitched sound with a slower pace, while Laurel is deeper and has a faster pace. I'm also autistic so I wonder if autistic speech perception is less categorical and more objective. Probably the same reason why autistic folks are more likely to have perfect pitch than NT's.
I listened to "Yanni" on both audios even though you changed the frequencies. Is that normal? Btw, thanks for your video. It is helpful as I am taking a Psychology of Language class!
I actually am able to hear both at the same time, no matter how much the frequencies change. When I really focus on hearing one, like yanny, it's clearer than the other, but laurel is still always there. I think the frequencies are too mixed for me to have to choose one.
What if I CAN hear Laurel and Yanni simultaneously or switch between both at will? Am I imagining it? This is when they are played normally, not during the frequency manipulation examples. Great video by the way.
Lol @ the low frequencies... I heard "yanni...yanni...yanni...yanni" then he says "everyone should be team "Laurel."" Uh. About to start a paper on categorical perception though so thanks for the insight!
Lieberman et al. used the perturbation of VOT as an indication of categorical perception, however, in your example you used formant frequencies to explain this phenomenon. Is there research that uses the perturbation of formant frequencies and transitions to explain categorical perception?
heard laural on both audios loll
me too until I replayed video several times, then the very last "yanni", the one almost sounded like noise, sounded like laurel. btw his audio is not great on several videos anyway.
i think he mixed up audios. i heard laurel when supposed to hear yanni, and vice versa. tsk tsk edit your vids better dude.
A formant is not a visualisation of a collection of sound waves. A formant is a resonance in speech, whereas I believe you mean the spectrogram shown is the visualisation of sound waves.
2:48 I was still hearing Laurel
Please come back
When I hear the original recording, I hear both at the same time. Yanny is a robotic, high pitched sound with a slower pace, while Laurel is deeper and has a faster pace. I'm also autistic so I wonder if autistic speech perception is less categorical and more objective. Probably the same reason why autistic folks are more likely to have perfect pitch than NT's.
I listened to "Yanni" on both audios even though you changed the frequencies. Is that normal? Btw, thanks for your video. It is helpful as I am taking a Psychology of Language class!
i heard yanni until the very last one, which jst sounded like white noise at first, then I finallly heard as laurel, after several replays
i think he mixed up audios. i heard laurel when supposed to hear yanni, and vice versa. tsk tsk edit your vids better dude.
I heard only Laurel for both audios XD also doing this for psychology language class
I had the same but with Laurel!
Me too heard only Laurel
I only heard Laurel the whole time 🤷🏾♂️
Same!
I even tried hearing yanni but all i can hear was laurel the whole time
I actually am able to hear both at the same time, no matter how much the frequencies change. When I really focus on hearing one, like yanny, it's clearer than the other, but laurel is still always there. I think the frequencies are too mixed for me to have to choose one.
Only hear Laurel.
Thank you! This really helped me for one of my phonetics classes!
What if I CAN hear Laurel and Yanni simultaneously or switch between both at will? Am I imagining it? This is when they are played normally, not during the frequency manipulation examples. Great video by the way.
You explained it to me better than a book of cognitive psychology, thank you!
I can’t hear laurel no matter how hard I try?
Can you hear it when he alters the clip?
I never heard yanni (?)
Lol @ the low frequencies... I heard "yanni...yanni...yanni...yanni" then he says "everyone should be team "Laurel."" Uh. About to start a paper on categorical perception though so thanks for the insight!
me too.
what if you can hear both yanni and laurel
I was only hearing Yanni before this video, but after watching this, I also hear both, cause now I know what to listen for I guess?
Fantastic explanation. The best I could find. Thank you so much!
I heard yammy both , so confused :(
I never heard "yanni".
What's up with that??
Thank you
Lieberman et al. used the perturbation of VOT as an indication of categorical perception, however, in your example you used formant frequencies to explain this phenomenon. Is there research that uses the perturbation of formant frequencies and transitions to explain categorical perception?
heard both at the same tiiime in all these cases bro
"laurel" wtf how is that yani? Broken down and I still hear laurel?
I only heard Yanni, regardless of the frequency.
I still hear "yearly" 🤣
Audiologist speaking here - I LOVE ZELDA, go Navi!
the Navi reference tho
Hello there, thanks for explaining why I hear my name Yanni rather than Laurel owo, I am now popular at school because if this test T-T
I hear yari......