Gardiner conducts Rameau's works

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 180

  • @georgeshannouche548
    @georgeshannouche548 11 місяців тому +5

    Rameau is fantastic and this work is fascinating what a great performance

  • @exitdogger
    @exitdogger 11 років тому +36

    When I started looking for Rameau almost nothing was available..now he is well represented and I often have felt lucky to be alive to witness this! Rameau is my Patron Saint!

    • @PMS1950
      @PMS1950 4 роки тому +5

      Fabulous music. Such elegance, style and joy. Marvellous man.

    • @starwarsjunkie7776
      @starwarsjunkie7776 Рік тому +3

      And now he is one of my favorites!!

    • @valerietaylor9615
      @valerietaylor9615 11 місяців тому +1

      I adore Rameau. His music has such panache. ⚜️

    • @pierreguinot9238
      @pierreguinot9238 10 місяців тому

      Moi pareil, exactement !!!❤

  • @MegaCirse
    @MegaCirse 2 роки тому +8

    I've clicked through so many videos, through so many incredible, weird ambient landscapes... I feel like I'm going on a train trip, seeing a succession of crazy, never-before-seen scenes from history, important, weird musics through the window as I pass... there's so much to explore. So many places to alight and dwell in the ambiences that are on offer. This stop, in particular, is brilliant

  • @pierresentenac
    @pierresentenac Рік тому +3

    Remarquable Gardiner!! Il a été en fait un précurseur qui a cru dans le génie universel de Rameau, depuis les fêtes d'Hébé son superbe Hippolyte et Aricie pour exécuter en première mondiale Les Boréades. Le spectacle merveilleux qu'il nous donne est là pour prouver sa passion pour le maitre!! Car Jean-Philippe est en fait un Magicien des sons et des harmonies mais aussi des ballets donc de la danse... tout cela est intemporel.... Bravo john Eliot et merci pour cette exceptionnelle prestation!

  • @AbnerIMAlvarado
    @AbnerIMAlvarado Рік тому +12

    00:00 Zaïs - Overture
    5:18 Dardanus - Entrée des Songes
    8:08 Dardanus - Trio des Songes 'Par un sommeil agréable'
    10:50 Dardanus - Prologue: Tambourins 1 & 2
    13:12 Les fêtes d'Hébé - Chorus 'Suivez les lois'
    16:33 Les fêtes d'Hébé - Tambourin en rondeau
    18:08 Les Boréades - Entrée de Polymnie
    22:39 Les Boréades - Air de Polymnie 'Commandez aux tendres Zéphirs'
    23:27 Les Boréades - Gavottes pour les Heures et les Zéphirs
    27:45 Platée - Air pantomime
    29:57 Platée - Rigaudons 1 & 2
    32:41 Platée - Contredanse en rondeau
    33:39 Platée - Menuets 1 & 2
    36:45 Platée - Musette
    38:06 Platée - Tambourins 1 & 2
    40:12 Hippolyte et Aricie - Suite of selected dances
    45:02 Castor et Pollux - Chorus 'Rentrez dans l'esclavage'
    46:43 Castor et Pollux - Air des démons Act 3
    48:11 Castor et Pollux - Chorus 'Brisons tous nos fers'
    50:31 Castor et Pollux - Air 'Séjour de l'éternelle paix'
    57:56 Naïs - Chaconne Act 1 Proms premiere
    1:04:27 Les Boréades - Chorus 'Jouïssons de nos beaux ans'
    1:07:33 Les Boréades - Gavottes 1 & 2
    1:11:17 Les Boréades - Contredanses 1 & 2

  • @philippefranceschi4294
    @philippefranceschi4294 6 років тому +10

    Merci Sir John Eliot Gardiner de nous ouvrir les oreilles et les yeux mais aussi l'esprit avec la musique de Jean-Philippe Rameau...

  • @markbeck8384
    @markbeck8384 2 роки тому +5

    OMG Rameau was such a genius; I love this music, and it is incredibly timeless.. even modern. Thank you for this wonderful concert. For me, it is the essence of France; but a gift to the whole World.

    • @valerietaylor9615
      @valerietaylor9615 11 місяців тому

      Vive la musique de Rameau et Vive la France! ⚜️🇫🇷

  • @managerprefere
    @managerprefere 10 років тому +19

    La preuve que la musique de Rameau est non seulement intemporelle mais aussi sans frontière !!! Superbe !

  • @johncamfield284
    @johncamfield284 8 років тому +12

    How life can be put back into the marvelous music of Rameau!

  • @DanieleSRD
    @DanieleSRD 13 років тому +18

    I agree with the Maestro. This is a miracle music, there's everything inside. Thanks so much Rameau and Gardiner.

  • @ffbossy
    @ffbossy 12 років тому +5

    It's impossible to express in words how great thou art, just close your eyes and enjoy their playing

  • @Fuliginosus
    @Fuliginosus 12 років тому +11

    I agree that this should be released on DVD. I would buy it in a heartbeat. But in the meantime, it's nice to have this UA-cam version (which I play endlessly), and I thank you very much for posting!

  • @jmtappenden
    @jmtappenden 12 років тому +4

    Allez la musique tres belle et les danses tres vif de Rameau et Lully! Wonderful music.Thanks & best wishes.

  • @monsieurm6975
    @monsieurm6975 7 років тому +11

    THE champion, the brightest star of Baroque music, God I adore his works !

    • @valerietaylor9615
      @valerietaylor9615 11 місяців тому

      I adore Rameau and also Domenico Scarlatti.

  • @bigfan2710
    @bigfan2710 5 років тому +5

    Magnificent seeing Rameau's dances being danced to! Awesome!

  • @MuseDuCafe
    @MuseDuCafe 12 років тому +6

    What a fantastic performance of one of the most wonderful music of Rameau!
    All the instrumentalists, singers, and dancers. A heavenly concert.

  • @ichirofakename
    @ichirofakename 3 роки тому +1

    What a great show, what fabulous music. Rameau! Thanks for posting this great video.

  • @EPManny
    @EPManny 10 років тому +29

    At this moment....this video seems like the best thing I've ever seen and heard!!! Rameau's music is full of richness and elegance. The orchestra and conductor are flawless; the dancers so graceful. And to top it off my South African compatriots are featured. Well done to Buskaid!!!

  • @RafaelGarciaMarquez
    @RafaelGarciaMarquez 12 років тому +6

    I've been looking for this for sooooooooo long! I listened to the performance live on the radio, and when I heard there was dance as well then I was wishing so hard seeing it all.

  • @josjanssen6733
    @josjanssen6733 4 роки тому +4

    Fantastic !!!! Rameau made such exihilarating and moving music. He was one of the revolutionaries in music. It's a mind-boggling eye-opener to hear (and see) his music in this context. Wish i had been there. Must have been quite a night :-) Bravo to the good soul that uploaded this !

  • @TheNarcotricks
    @TheNarcotricks 2 роки тому +1

    Merveilleuse sélection de Gardiner
    Il y a vraiment tous les extraits que je préfère chez Rameau. Tous les morceaux atypiques :
    L'air de la matelote d'Hyppolite et Aricie, le sublimissime menuet dans le goût de vielle de Platée, la contredanse finale des Boréades.
    Que des merveilles !

  • @SusannahMacDonald
    @SusannahMacDonald 12 років тому +14

    I really enjoyed the dances - having been a participant on Baroque dance courses I can relate to them immediately.

    • @PMS1950
      @PMS1950 4 роки тому +2

      The dances are superb as are the dancers.

  • @6463538
    @6463538 10 років тому +7

    Excellent. Remarkable music, beautiful playing, magnificent dancing. Thank you for the upload.

  • @bloodgrss
    @bloodgrss 11 років тому +7

    He is certainly somewhat of a musical 'deity' to me...
    One of the great spirits of musical beauty and achievement, whose sound goes right to the heart and soul!

    • @openmusic3904
      @openmusic3904 6 років тому +3

      For me Rameau is the musical equivalent of a nymph king. Enchanting, ethereal, fleeting, and the embodiment of grace and beauty, as if the music is suspended in midair.

  • @SusannahMacDonald
    @SusannahMacDonald 12 років тому +4

    Brilliant! Endlessly inventive as ever.

  • @leilasesmero5910
    @leilasesmero5910 4 роки тому +2

    I usually surf a lot and not always wait for the end, but this one is worth listening to until the end....

  • @Allanfearn
    @Allanfearn 12 років тому +6

    There are three outstanding documents of the rediscovery of Rameau's stage music - Nadia Boulanger's 1950 LP, Gardiners late 1970's Prom performance of Les Boreades, and this 2007 Prom, which must be one of the greatest of all Proms. At the moment, this is the only one freely available in any form. When you compare it with the currently available DVD of Les Paladins there's no doubt at all who gets their Rameau right and who has no idea how to. The BBC should get this on to DVD now.

  • @yves921
    @yves921 7 років тому +7

    Bel hommage de Gardiner à Rameau, bravo !

  • @voltaire1377
    @voltaire1377 11 років тому +4

    vive notre grand Rameau national!...

  • @jlapierremusic
    @jlapierremusic 9 років тому +15

    I find it fascinating how the rhythm and overall feel of both the traditional African dancing and the baroque French music go together so well. It just goes to prove how art is universal, and it serves the same purpose no matter when or where we are.

  • @whatgivesit
    @whatgivesit 9 місяців тому +1

    Prom 03 - In memoriam Margaret Fairbairn (d.20/5/07 aged 99), supporter of the Monteverdi Choir and Orchestra
    19:00 Sun 15 Jul 2007 Royal Albert Hall
    Jean‐Philippe Rameau
    ZaïsOverture
    DardanusEntrée des Songes Act 4 Proms premiere
    DardanusTrio des Songes 'Par un sommeil agréable' Act 4 Proms premiere
    DardanusPrologue: Tambourins 1 & 2
    Les fêtes d'HébéChorus 'Suivez les lois' Act 3 Proms premiere
    Les fêtes d'HébéTambourin en rondeau
    Les BoréadesEntrée de Polymnie Act 4
    Les BoréadesAir de Polymnie 'Commandez aux tendres Zéphirs' Act 4
    Les BoréadesGavottes pour les Heures et les Zéphirs Act 4
    PlatéeAir pantomime
    PlatéeRigaudons 1 & 2
    PlatéeContredanse en rondeau
    PlatéeMenuets 1 & 2
    PlatéeMusette
    PlatéeTambourins 1 & 2
    Hippolyte et AricieSuite of selected dances
    Castor et PolluxChorus 'Rentrez dans l'esclavage' Act 3
    Castor et PolluxAir des démons Act 3
    Castor et PolluxChorus 'Brisons tous nos fers' Act 3
    Castor et PolluxAir 'Séjour de l'éternelle paix' Act 4
    NaïsChaconne Act 1 Proms premiere
    Les BoréadesChorus 'Jouïssons de nos beaux ans' Act 3
    Les BoréadesGavottes 1 & 2 Act 3
    Les BoréadesContredanses 1 & 2 Act 5
    Performers
    Matthew Brook
    bass
    Monteverdi Choir
    Sir John Eliot Gardiner
    conductor
    Nicholas Mulroy
    counter-tenor
    Anders J. Dahlin
    counter-tenor
    English Baroque Soloists
    Compagnie Roussat-Lubek
    Julia Doyle
    soprano
    Lawrence Wallington
    bass-baritone
    Katherine Fuge
    soprano
    Rosemary Nalden
    director
    Buskaid Soweto String Ensemble
    Dance For All
    Marc Molomot
    counter-tenor

  • @PMS1950
    @PMS1950 8 років тому +8

    Rameau's music so beautifully performed by dancers and musicians. It inspires and gives meaning, purpose and joy to life.

  • @costrow3100
    @costrow3100 3 роки тому +1

    Love the part at the beginning of hour one. The part with the little boy in the middle of it is quite indicative of the world trying to work from home right now with cats, dogs and children in the middle of zoom meetings.

  • @Atys44
    @Atys44 12 років тому +6

    A great concert. Music of infinite grace and a divine beauty. It is music that charms the senses so that she seems to have been composed in the gods of Olympus. But it is Rameau, one of the gods who composed music.

  • @bernadettebelmejdoub4542
    @bernadettebelmejdoub4542 10 років тому +2

    Un Grand Monsieur , à qui on dit : " Mille mercis! "

  • @agonludmilla
    @agonludmilla 11 років тому +2

    SIMPLY EXTRAORDINARY - FANTASTIC WORK.

  • @palfab962ify
    @palfab962ify 7 років тому +2

    best UA-cam video ever IMHO...early music with a modern twist....great mix of cultures...#oneworld

  • @ac8907
    @ac8907 6 років тому +2

    Bravo, beau travail

  • @RenaissanceShe
    @RenaissanceShe 4 роки тому +1

    Magical. I so loved this.

  • @anthonyaveray1324
    @anthonyaveray1324 10 місяців тому

    Marvellous entertainment and such precision and polish

  • @marcin8942
    @marcin8942 11 років тому +2

    Amazing, what a lovely performance!

  • @72mahler
    @72mahler 12 років тому +1

    Gardiner? Indubbiamente il migliore al mondo in questo repertorio! "Entra" nella musica e la fa vivere!

    • @ritanicosia
      @ritanicosia 4 роки тому

      E vi riesce perfettamente 👍

  • @kn9ioutom
    @kn9ioutom 9 років тому +2

    EXCELLENT RAMEAU !!!!

  • @paacer
    @paacer 6 років тому

    What a beautiful piece of music at 13:12 with two wonderful soloists plus the choir .

  • @bloodgrss
    @bloodgrss 11 років тому +2

    None better in this music today...what a fabulous concert of Great music....under-appreciated from its time until about 50 years ago...
    Not a bad reason to be alive today !
    P.S.- the sour notes referred to below on the French hoboy are meant to be-a Rameau equivalent of dissonance- inherent in the music for the story of Zais....

  • @hectorjeg
    @hectorjeg 13 років тому +1

    This is just fantastic!!!
    Gardiner should come back to Rameau's operas, obviously; what he's doing sounds just like the way it should be done

  • @rolandoribes6758
    @rolandoribes6758 3 роки тому

    QUE HALLAZGO!!!! LITERALMENTE, ESTOY BAILANDO !MARAVILLOSO DE PRINCIPIO A FIN!

  • @jesuslozanofuentes5123
    @jesuslozanofuentes5123 2 роки тому

    Magnífico concierto gracias

  • @jockrangeos
    @jockrangeos 12 років тому +1

    John Eliot Gardiner, le plus français des britaniques ! Son amour de la musique française prend ici toute sa dimension avec ces airs du Grand Rameau dans une mise en scène que n'aurait pas renié Louis XIV.

  • @franck19671
    @franck19671 12 років тому +1

    merci c'est magnifique!

  • @capezyo
    @capezyo 10 років тому +1

    Fantastic!!!

  • @brigittegarnier7388
    @brigittegarnier7388 11 років тому +1

    Rameau ? : l'un des plus grands mélodistes de tous les temps. Et ça c'est une merveille, merci messieurs les Anglais : tirez donc les premiers !

  • @CPYV78
    @CPYV78 12 років тому +1

    Quel bonheur !

  • @DOBEAGAIN
    @DOBEAGAIN Рік тому +3

    Not studying Rameau is like not studying Newton

  • @jockrangeos
    @jockrangeos 12 років тому +1

    John Eliot Gardiner, the most French of british people ! His love of French music takes on its full dimension with these tunes in the Great Rameau staging would not have denied that Louis XIV.

  • @AscanioInAlba1
    @AscanioInAlba1 12 років тому +1

    Allanfearn (below) is correct. This needs to be released on DVD. I watched this programme enraptured with the sheer beauty of Rameau's music as always (what a vital boundary-pusher he was!) and the inspired modern dance. I get quite dewy-eyed over the sequences from 18.00 and 57.55.

  • @TheArtsBookstoregr
    @TheArtsBookstoregr 11 років тому +2

    GREAT!!!

  • @Mistersoccer2009
    @Mistersoccer2009 12 років тому +3

    It really is an accident finding this work by Rameau ! Rich, so rich ...
    Francois Glasman

  • @64carlo
    @64carlo 13 років тому +1

    ...and some people still think that classical music is boring ...viva Tudor, Daniele, Rameau and all those musicians who bring to us this giant of the music and alchemist of the human soul. Thanks!!!

  • @JamesPollMaine59
    @JamesPollMaine59 5 років тому +8

    The performance is sublime. The three ring circus staging was often distracting and not a welcome compliment to Rameau's genius.

  • @Tarunchik
    @Tarunchik 7 років тому +1

    класс!!! браво!

  • @johnwagstaffe1610
    @johnwagstaffe1610 9 років тому +1

    This is wonderful stuff Wags

  • @PauloProença-n9b
    @PauloProença-n9b Рік тому +3

    A dança atrapalha a música, desconcentra...infelizmente, Não sei o que vocês acham sobre isso, e como era na época, né..mas a apresentação dos dançarinos ficou 'competindo' com algumas partes da música - a orquestra fica esquecida lá no fundo, tocando pro bailarinos dançarem....

  • @bloodgrss
    @bloodgrss 12 років тому +2

    One of those concerts I would most like to have been too--and a Prom at that! Would this could be done in every major music center...wonderful......

  • @costrow3100
    @costrow3100 3 роки тому

    I love Baroque music and dance. It was so modern compared to formulaic Italian opera. The Paris National opera has a version of Rameau’s Les Sauvages that is insanely wonderful. It has millions of views. It’s pure joy. I hope Mostly Mozart does some Rameau new world type pop ups around Lincoln Center.

  • @pegaso232323
    @pegaso232323 2 роки тому

    Las coreografias serían del momento o son actuales? Muy interesante, no conocía a este autor. Las melodías son hermosas, me trasladan a bellos jardines y pájaros por todos lados, las letras son hermosas y tranquilizadoras. Vaya autor, un placer conocerlo

  • @BogdanKrawalski
    @BogdanKrawalski 6 років тому +2

    Where I can get a copy in HD from this amazing concert?

  • @micheldaillet8144
    @micheldaillet8144 4 роки тому

    I can't believe such a high quality show was programmed on a publicly-funded channel

  • @AdrianoAnderson
    @AdrianoAnderson 8 років тому +1

    Beautifully... but not in HD(520P) :(

  • @mothbyte98
    @mothbyte98 9 років тому

    Muchísimos intentos inaguantables con la "comedia". No los pude soportar.

  • @johnandmarylouwilde7882
    @johnandmarylouwilde7882 2 роки тому +1

    To paraphrase Chuck Berry, "Roll over Bach".

  • @JPConnolly2
    @JPConnolly2 12 років тому

    I've never heard this group sound better than at 48:11--50:20.

  • @DaveyL1954
    @DaveyL1954 7 років тому +1

    I saw this for the first time when it was broadcast on British television. I tend to be immensely purist, (i'm getting on these days) but I watch this, and I am elated that the art of dance and Rameau's beautiful music can be combined with a modern homage to Baroque movement dance and it work so well. I must be mellowing. I do hope not. Here's something else I've observed. Imagine for one moment that Sir Jphn Elliot G, is not the conductor, but is brought on to the rostrum and told to dance to the music. I see him dancing only and I love what he does. And coincidentally, the orchestra follows him. Try it.

  • @heliconn
    @heliconn Рік тому +1

    18:10

  • @MrYorickJenkins
    @MrYorickJenkins 11 років тому +4

    Rameau's compositions seem to be enjoying something of a revival. I would like to think that an increased popularity for Baroque music in general is part of a reaction to Jacobinism, that fanatical doctrine which has been responsible for untold misery down to the present day.

  • @daniloughini8295
    @daniloughini8295 11 років тому

    musica canto dança:
    Gardiner conducts Rameau's works

  • @samuelcabellogonzalez7590
    @samuelcabellogonzalez7590 3 роки тому

    Does somebody know the names of the movements of each pieces?

    • @user-gy8zs3sv8y
      @user-gy8zs3sv8y 2 роки тому

      Yes, but the list is quite long so ask what piece you want and I Will tell you. It begins with Zaïs overture...

  • @diogocaldeira4811
    @diogocaldeira4811 4 роки тому

    Is there a list of the soudtracks here?

  • @thesaucegroup1877
    @thesaucegroup1877 3 роки тому +1

    48:00 22:39 45:00 1:04:28

  • @suzanabramyan1598
    @suzanabramyan1598 3 роки тому

    Who are the dancers?

  • @mjarail
    @mjarail 6 років тому

    Some of the dancers seem to be hung up about something. 17:30

  • @suzanabramyan1598
    @suzanabramyan1598 5 років тому

    Heart

  • @patrickguillaume5130
    @patrickguillaume5130 6 років тому +1

    Perfide Albion, cette fois c'est Rameau qu'ils assassinent !

    • @jeremydarmien5969
      @jeremydarmien5969 4 роки тому +2

      La musique est impeccable mais la mise en scène contemporaine, avec rires gras à l'appui est effectivement traumatisante...

    • @user-gy8zs3sv8y
      @user-gy8zs3sv8y 2 роки тому

      Et ces mines outrées françaises ? Comment sont elles ? ...
      Tout aussi traumatisantes ! :D

  • @berlinbetty3337
    @berlinbetty3337 7 років тому

    So sorry, I mean 1971-4. Gin and It a trifle large tonight!

  • @MrAlex84006
    @MrAlex84006 11 років тому

    Can I here danser Nataly Gay or Uta Gruber?

  • @bernadettebelmejdoub4542
    @bernadettebelmejdoub4542 10 років тому

    Quels sont les noms des chanteurs , please ? Thanks .

    • @pentacolo1968
      @pentacolo1968 10 років тому +1

      www.bbc.co.uk/proms/archive/search/2000s/2007/july-15/12707

  • @wp9554
    @wp9554 3 роки тому +3

    Magnifique interprétation. quel dommage cependant que l'air d'entrée de Polymnie , air sublime s'il en est, soit galvaudé par une farce clownesque. ..

  • @Gabofele_Nthwane
    @Gabofele_Nthwane 3 роки тому

    Par
    If i could catch you

  • @macanudo1808
    @macanudo1808 4 роки тому

    prinippe .

  • @Badmintonforall
    @Badmintonforall 5 років тому +6

    Fine music, grotesque staging... with stupid laughes 18:45

  • @cochardable
    @cochardable 4 роки тому

    when a english Gardiner plays "le grand siècle "

  • @BogdanKrawalski
    @BogdanKrawalski 6 років тому +1

    "Suivez les lois"

  • @sibionic
    @sibionic 12 років тому +2

    Owww! That oboe trill at 3.12 is horrible!

  • @sibionic
    @sibionic 12 років тому +2

    The choreography doesn't add to it - the score is amazing enough

    • @ichirofakename
      @ichirofakename 3 роки тому +1

      I take your point, but no harm in giving the eyes something to focus on.

    • @user-gy8zs3sv8y
      @user-gy8zs3sv8y 2 роки тому

      Rameau did compose it for dance wether you like it or not

    • @sibionic
      @sibionic 2 роки тому +1

      @@user-gy8zs3sv8y but it's perfectly possible to get into the score
      without dancers being involved, as you do every time you listen to a CD or whatever.

  • @janoscsorba5714
    @janoscsorba5714 6 років тому +1

    Dance is a good and refrishing idea here,but accompanying movements may divert attention from the music and at last You do not know,whether success is written ti music or dancers' accomplishments.But today favorized accumulating experiences,next time perhaps everybody needs to see sights of naked women musicians

    • @user-gy8zs3sv8y
      @user-gy8zs3sv8y 2 роки тому

      Yes but this is dance music, Rameau conceived it as danse music ...

  • @berlinbetty3337
    @berlinbetty3337 7 років тому

    Well this performance has certainly split opinions! Surely Rameau would have loved this display of esoteric wit in the dancers, and those in charge of Louis XV's court entertainments would have paid a premium for the African dancers - surely an exotic 18thC coup at Versailles!
    BTW GJ, were you at Cambridge between 1997-4? Apologies if I have the wrong gent.

  • @violinhunter2
    @violinhunter2 6 років тому +1

    ...And to think I am related to this genius Rameau. Was all his music composed for the "nobility"? I dislike the fact that this looks like a political show - it might not be but it looks like it. The music is great nonetheless.

    • @violinhunter2
      @violinhunter2 6 років тому

      ...If they wanted to make a "statement" they should have had the dancers dance nude all the way through. Perhaps they got shy? Who knows?

    • @nvrlm
      @nvrlm 4 роки тому

      How is this a political show? I’m just wondering

    • @violinhunter2
      @violinhunter2 4 роки тому +1

      @@nvrlm All that silly dancing.....

    • @nvrlm
      @nvrlm 4 роки тому

      violinhunter2 please enlighten me if you dont mind

    • @user-gy8zs3sv8y
      @user-gy8zs3sv8y 2 роки тому +1

      This music was made and dedicated for both body and soul !

  • @aulos52
    @aulos52 8 років тому

    Les brillants défenseurs de la brillante musique française sont (aussi) anglais!! Gardiner, Christie....N'ont ils donc rien à défendre de l'autre côté du prude chanel?? Paradoxe ;-)

    • @GillesCorevenCoreven
      @GillesCorevenCoreven 6 років тому

      Bernard Beutter William Christie est très surestimé.Ses interprétations trop souvent manquent de dynamique sonore.Sans accents, elles se trainent et ennuient.

    • @65jaypee
      @65jaypee 4 роки тому

      Christie est un Américain...

  • @labananiere
    @labananiere 8 років тому +4

    Chorégraphie complètement nulle, pourquoi enlaidir ainsi les femmes, très contentes de mettre des abominables pantalons?
    Ceci dit en prenant de la musique de Rameau, la beauté pour les oreilles est assuré, écouter en coupant l'image.
    Bravo les musiciens, on en redemande...

    • @josegimenezperez1025
      @josegimenezperez1025 8 років тому

      +andré rasemont Oui mais? la musique = extraordinaire.Mon Diu!

    • @ac8907
      @ac8907 6 років тому

      Pas d'accord

    • @ac8907
      @ac8907 6 років тому

      Je précise : je trouve que la chorégraphie est bonne, elle allie de la modernité avec la musique de Rameau

    • @user-gy8zs3sv8y
      @user-gy8zs3sv8y 2 роки тому

      Mais ! La musique de Rameau est moderne ! Ses rythmes et syncopes, son expressivité, son expressionnisme presque sont très moderne !

  • @maucor3122
    @maucor3122 11 років тому

    estos se copiaron de la coreografia diseñada para las presentaciones de w. christie