I would declare 11 GK's but play them all over the pitch so then on defending corners i have 11 people who can handle the ball/catch the ball. What a stupid question from Andy...
Surely if you could choose how many goalkeepers you could have, you would register 11 goal keepers so every player could catch the ball from set pieces when defending but then would still be able to play other positions. It could also mean players could rotate when tired if playing a high line.
If the goalkeepers are aloud to go up with the defence, you'd play 11 goalkeepers, and then just let them go forward, so that when your defending anyone can pick up the ball
i think that if teams have more than one gk then they would probabaly play with 2 and one would be a "faslse gk"who would play like a cb or fullback with possesion and defending could probably just still play as a defender closer to goal. on set pieces tho it would be interesting having two gks to cover both sides like on a penalty for example
2 GK is definitely better without a doubt. They’d just play him at CB but can use his hands in the box. Imagine Liverpool with Alisson in goal and Van Dijk can use his hands inside the box when he need to, or Arsenal with 4 CBs AND Saliba can use his hands inside the box, it’s crazy.
Weighing in on the 2 GK debate, quite simply list one of your defenders as a GK in the Matchday squad. Play as a normal defender, but no need to worry about handball when you go to block I do also think you’re underrating ho good 2 GKs on the line would be (or 1 on the line, 1 just behind the line to avoid playing people onside). As long as their communication is good, play like a 2-2-4-3 and the opponent probably still isn’t scoring
Did James do 2 position changes? Miyama (originally LM -> CM) and Olise (originally RM -> CAM)? Or is it because Miyama is an icon and then it doesn’t matter?
I think playing 2 gk's would be a good tactic for weaker teams trying to park the bus against strong opposition. Imagine you have all 11 players in your defensive third, but two gk's to cover different angles or distances. But, would you not then just play with 11 goalkeepers (10 of them being actual outfield players who have gloves on), and then never concede from in the box again because everyone can drop down and use their hands? Would be impossible to score corners against a team where everyone can jump and catch the ball, legally.
Idk about Andy but I played 5 games with Di Natale in div 2 and got 3 assists and one lucky goal. Played 5 games with Le Sommer and got her 2 hat tricks so yeah save your mil.
Gotta love people getting pressed about 2 groups of horrible people with twisted values killing each other, as if one set of terrorists and killers are more innocent than the other one 😂😂
With those rules you should just make everyone a goalie so everyone can use their hands on corners etc. why wouldnt you make vvd a goalie? He csn just play like he always does and then smacks balls away aswell.
I think most would want the game to be more entertaining, and goals are a huge part of it. Having 2 goalies would significantly cut down the number of goals scored. I wouldn’t want that…
just pick 11 gk's and give the 10 usual outfield players their normal positions again with a gk shirt on so they can use their hands in the box if needed
21:19 "Ancient Israel" I didn't realize Andy was a genocide supporter. I remember Andy and ChrisMD kept going on about Qatar and the world cup, yet so interesting these youtubers are quite when it comes to a literal genocide. I guess middle easterners aren't human to these people.
Yeah hate to break the fun but you'd need rules on where goalies can go on the pitch. Otherwise you just pick 11 goalies, give Salah a pair of gloves so when he is in his own box, he can make saves too. Just doesn't work
Am I stupid, wouldn't you just have all 11 players as a goalkeeper? There's no drawback to being a GK, don't you just have the bonus of being able to use your hands. For e.g, when Luis Suarez did the handball in the 2010 WC, that wouldn't have been a penalty if he counted as a GK
Raya better than neuer with his feet? Forgetting that guardiola wanted to Play neuer in midfield for a Game because he was that good on The Ball but Bayern refused because they didnt want to look like they didnt take the Opponent seriously
It’s almost day 11 Asian Andy
Asian Andy 😂
@ nickname from lockdown sbsd if you were wondering 😂
Forget the ItsJames Trading Method, someone's gotta seriously study the ItsJames Upload Schedule
10:04 Andy loves it
I would declare 11 GK's but play them all over the pitch so then on defending corners i have 11 people who can handle the ball/catch the ball. What a stupid question from Andy...
Would only work against arsenal lad
@@kenzie9094 wdym.... any current team exactly as they are but with the keepers kit on.
@ConPlexVAL was making a joke on how arsenal only scored on corners against man u...
How neither of them realised it's literally just 11 a side but no hand balls in the box... I had to skip through it as it hurt my brain xD
10:05 Hes got the OPness 😂, im said asian andy didnt catch that
Raging that it’s half ten 😂 been waiting all day on this!
James likes to cater to audiences time zones around the world I believe🤷♂️👌
We almost got two episodes in one day
Surely if you could choose how many goalkeepers you could have, you would register 11 goal keepers so every player could catch the ball from set pieces when defending but then would still be able to play other positions. It could also mean players could rotate when tired if playing a high line.
People have work in the morning, Jimmy.
If the goalkeepers are aloud to go up with the defence, you'd play 11 goalkeepers, and then just let them go forward, so that when your defending anyone can pick up the ball
i think that if teams have more than one gk then they would probabaly play with 2 and one would be a "faslse gk"who would play like a cb or fullback with possesion and defending could probably just still play as a defender closer to goal. on set pieces tho it would be interesting having two gks to cover both sides like on a penalty for example
20 years old still look forward to watching every sbsd episode. Such a good series
same here, 22 now but have watched these since 13
Ederson would be absolutely unbelievable in a 2 gk formation
2 GK is definitely better without a doubt. They’d just play him at CB but can use his hands in the box. Imagine Liverpool with Alisson in goal and Van Dijk can use his hands inside the box when he need to, or Arsenal with 4 CBs AND Saliba can use his hands inside the box, it’s crazy.
Chillin with dat 6pm upload. Preciate brother
If they would allow 2 goalies, in todays meta. It would be Courtois on the Line and Allison as the 1 on 1 keeper.
Wheres day 2?
been waiting ages for this, hope alls well lads
Smart team James, Andy had no chance
Weighing in on the 2 GK debate, quite simply list one of your defenders as a GK in the Matchday squad. Play as a normal defender, but no need to worry about handball when you go to block
I do also think you’re underrating ho good 2 GKs on the line would be (or 1 on the line, 1 just behind the line to avoid playing people onside). As long as their communication is good, play like a 2-2-4-3 and the opponent probably still isn’t scoring
De Natalie and Provedel some of the GOATs of all time
Did James do 2 position changes? Miyama (originally LM -> CM) and Olise (originally RM -> CAM)? Or is it because Miyama is an icon and then it doesn’t matter?
Icons don’t count and can play wherever 👍
And endo he's cdm but he put him cm
@@kenzie9094 cdm to cm has never been a special change bro
@@theofficialdanny182 alright :), ty
I think playing 2 gk's would be a good tactic for weaker teams trying to park the bus against strong opposition. Imagine you have all 11 players in your defensive third, but two gk's to cover different angles or distances.
But, would you not then just play with 11 goalkeepers (10 of them being actual outfield players who have gloves on), and then never concede from in the box again because everyone can drop down and use their hands? Would be impossible to score corners against a team where everyone can jump and catch the ball, legally.
How would you go around with penalties with the 2 goalie rule? Would only 1 be able to save or do you get to use both keepers?
These lads need to set an alarm for how much they're wafflin on. this two gk convo went for way too long lmao
SBSD isn't for you mate
di Natale would have been the best choice for SBSD advent. His name literally translates to Christmas
Mental chat. You’d just say Virgil you can handle the ball lad.
Also did Andy describe Rafa leio as having Irish genitals
2 GK would make parking the bus into Parking the Space Shuttle.
10:03 what???!!!!!
How was Olise allowed and endo aren’t they both position changes? Aren’t they allowed one
At this rate just do 11 keepers. Play regular positions but you all can use your hands in the box.
9:07 OG? She’s only been on the game since last year 😂
If they would allow 2 goalies, the meta would be to have one of the centre back in a goalie kit so that player can use his hands i the penalty area!
Idk about Andy but I played 5 games with Di Natale in div 2 and got 3 assists and one lucky goal. Played 5 games with Le Sommer and got her 2 hat tricks so yeah save your mil.
21:22 Really Andy? "Ancient Israel"? I thought this guy was for "human rights", what a snake.
Gotta love people getting pressed about 2 groups of horrible people with twisted values killing each other, as if one set of terrorists and killers are more innocent than the other one 😂😂
Coming from a goalie, more than one at a time would be a nightmare
Just in time James
With those rules you should just make everyone a goalie so everyone can use their hands on corners etc. why wouldnt you make vvd a goalie? He csn just play like he always does and then smacks balls away aswell.
I think most would want the game to be more entertaining, and goals are a huge part of it. Having 2 goalies would significantly cut down the number of goals scored. I wouldn’t want that…
James loves a late upload
just pick 11 gk's and give the 10 usual outfield players their normal positions again with a gk shirt on so they can use their hands in the box if needed
23:05 😂😂😂😂
Openis is crazy
wow, leave it to the last minute to put up.
Ito was a huge layup, how did Andy miss that?
21:19 "Ancient Israel" I didn't realize Andy was a genocide supporter. I remember Andy and ChrisMD kept going on about Qatar and the world cup, yet so interesting these youtubers are quite when it comes to a literal genocide. I guess middle easterners aren't human to these people.
Here we go 😮💨
Two goalies would be funny at first, but I think barely anyone would score anymore, making the game a lot less fun to watch 😅
since they built theyr squads , ive been in the shop for 20 minutes and its still 1:0 and 8 minutes in , wtf
Yeah hate to break the fun but you'd need rules on where goalies can go on the pitch. Otherwise you just pick 11 goalies, give Salah a pair of gloves so when he is in his own box, he can make saves too. Just doesn't work
OPness 🤣
THE O PENISH
Where’s Day 2?
(I’m tired of this joke but I’ve gotten this far, I might as well finish the advent)
11 goalkeepers and just play a normal formation except everyone can pick it up in the box
The one rule in football I'd change would be American penalties. Penalties are too easy and would be much more entertaining seeing a 1v1
Lets not talk about how many people skipped Andy's stupid goalkeeper meta talk
Am I stupid, wouldn't you just have all 11 players as a goalkeeper? There's no drawback to being a GK, don't you just have the bonus of being able to use your hands. For e.g, when Luis Suarez did the handball in the 2010 WC, that wouldn't have been a penalty if he counted as a GK
5:22 why can’t you make your whole team play normally but call them all goalies and then have the whole team be able to use there hands
Raya better than neuer with his feet? Forgetting that guardiola wanted to Play neuer in midfield for a Game because he was that good on The Ball but Bayern refused because they didnt want to look like they didnt take the Opponent seriously
With multiple GKs, why would'nt you make your whole team goalies and just let them go to their normal positions?
really nice team
1130 in Norway ffs
Ederson is a CDM playing in goal anyways. Terrible actual Goalkeeper
it‘s day 11 bruh
For me provedel is the best gk in the game.
I've got the special theo and leao untradeable
Arsenal would score lesson corners with 2 keepers against then😂
cant belive i had to listen to the stupid question of all time
Yes sir 🔥🫡
First pics 8.03
Bring Auzio!!!
Bloody he’ll James late one mate
way to late ruined advent calendar
😂 I've still got 4 chocolates to open in my advent clanandar. It's ruined, might as well throw it in the bin
First