Does the MACD Histogram Hold the Secret to Anticipating Trend Changes?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 33

  • @Bearnobull
    @Bearnobull 11 днів тому +4

    Great explanation of the MACD and histogram. I really like slow stochastics. Where I trade thru I used to have an oscillator with %K %D and %D slow. I modified them to use a 21 - 7 - 7 day periods. This worked very well. I always knew if the oscillator bottomed when the price bottomed at the same period one or the other would have to go lower, either the price or the oscillator and the same for a top. This made me wait because I am a swing trader using options. Of course it could always continue lower or higher but it sure kept me from an earlier entry point. They eliminated that study and only use %K and %D periods. Always a thumbs up on your videos.

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Definitely some similarities between slowed stochastics and MACD! Appreciate the feedback, D

  • @mimbaxter
    @mimbaxter 9 днів тому

    Thanks Dave. The layering in with the turn of the Histogram and then the cross looks useful and has been added to my list to think about. I do use the PPO with one extra, on the daily I have a horizontal line at 2 and weekly line at 6. I use these as a strength indicator. Once the PPO line gets close to, or above the horizontal line, then avoid the transaction as there will be likely consolidation or a pull back. Bit like the over 70 on RSI14. It is a don't buy, it does not mean sell.

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Love the comments on watching specific levels on the indicator- thanks for sharing this! D

  • @JanKowalski-yz5gq
    @JanKowalski-yz5gq 11 днів тому +1

    David . You are the Great Person.
    You know, I am the best trader. The best model for trading is Mathemathical MACD Model. I am sure You know the signal line is too high. Try to change fast line and slow line settings. It is very usefull study. 5 years of my live. Great show David. You are the best teacher of technical analysis I know.

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Appreciate the kind words! D

  • @18JRODD
    @18JRODD 10 днів тому

    I’m a huge proponent of the MACD & histogram’s ability to forecast market or price direction. The PPO is new to me though, definitely want to see how it compares to the MACD on longer time frames.

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому +1

      Way better for long-term time frames IMO. D

  • @ILIYAN.IVANOV.1972
    @ILIYAN.IVANOV.1972 8 днів тому

    Thank you very much for this great lesson, Dave! I'd wish you make more educational content like this one! 😉

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому +1

      Appreciate the feedback! Lots more to come... D

    • @ILIYAN.IVANOV.1972
      @ILIYAN.IVANOV.1972 6 днів тому

      @@DKellerCMT Thank you, Dave! D

  • @bayyoung
    @bayyoung 11 днів тому

    Great work, in part of your conversation here you mentioned scaling into a position. A great topic for a future video could be on scaling into and out of positions. From a sunny Christchurch, New Zealand. 👍

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Appreciate the suggestion! Have never been to NZ and hope to get my family there someday D

  • @dalec5109
    @dalec5109 11 днів тому

    thanks for showing the PPO today. Love your show.. from Rainy City of Vancouver, Canada ... Yea'

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Glad you enjoyed this one! Definitely entering the rainy half of the year in Seattle :) D

  • @KQQLCHEV
    @KQQLCHEV 9 днів тому

    I like the SHORTER chart layout. It's OIK to show the LONG , but switch to the SHORT for discussion ~ 😎

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Appreciate the feedback! D

  • @snakesnarroz
    @snakesnarroz 10 днів тому

    Awesome stuff. Dave is the real deal on Tech analysis. Koyfin looks good maybe a full video on it as well sometime. Wish i was at money show. Capitalism at work. If you never been it is amazing. Something for any type of trader. Teaching us all how to make and protect our money. 📈

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Just got back and the MoneyShow was a pretty awesome experience! Appreciate the feedback on a full Koyfin video. D

  • @Milhouse77BS
    @Milhouse77BS 11 днів тому +2

    I do like the MACD

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Me too! Thanks for watching D

  • @ltcolmilty
    @ltcolmilty 9 днів тому

    The change in the trend can be identified earlier by using several time periods for calculating the indicator

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Great point! This is the only the beginning..... D

  • @hopsgegangen2575
    @hopsgegangen2575 9 днів тому +1

    If many traders are using MACD, doesn't the predication just become self-fulfilling?

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Love this question, added to the mailbag, and will discuss on our next mailbag episode! D

  • @MrSummitville
    @MrSummitville 11 днів тому +1

    If you still have to wait for the cross-over, to prevent whipsaw, then what was the point of this video? MACD only works reasonably well with long trends, in a fast changing market you actually *LOSE* money.

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      For a swing-trading time frame, I'd be using indicators optimized for that approach. MACD crossovers are not the best option here. D

  • @jacqdanieles
    @jacqdanieles 10 днів тому

    👍🏻

    • @DKellerCMT
      @DKellerCMT  8 днів тому

      Thanks so much for watching! D