the audience singing along with them in foreign land makes me cry, i'm proud of you guys for dearly supporting our gorgeous four ladies, thank you for listening while they are singing live
Holy Ningning and Winter with their live vocals, this is beautiful. Also, hands down to the dancers because they are amazing in general, let's go Selene and Kaylar!!!
Ningning is born to perform like even her name though! Just like beyoncé madonna also ning has a very unique name because she is meant to be popular!!!
Y'all know next level was an actual hit the moment you see how the crowd was singing even the Korean parts.. This is so enjoyable am happy they're finally surrounded by actual crowd that sing along with them.. Next level is my favourite stage of their gma stages so far
i'm loving this trend of giselle asking karina "where we at?" at the bridge and karina responding with wherever they're performing. so far we have "where we at?" and "COACHELLA!", "LA!", and now we have "NEW YORK!". it reminds me of how in snsd's genie, tiffany used to give a shout out to whatever city they were performing in at the bridge. i.e. instead of "DJ put it back on" she'd say "_____ put it back on!"
Karina truly ate this one 🤧 Her being a captivatingly good dancer and top-tier stage presence, plus stunning body and visual ❤️ I'd never seen one idol this perfect til I saw Karina for the first time.
Actually i saw aespa’s insta story and the crowd was mostly females from the view they showed. Makes sense because the fanchants sounds more like females lmao
I'm literally confused I saw everyone criticize aespa for lacking stage presence but when I watch those performances they're great especially Giselle she has great stage presence
And they hate it when people praise their stage presence that's how threatened they are 🤣 they keep on dragging aespa with live singing when their favs can even sing properly while standing
Its good to see that they have back up dancers to shoulder some of the dance so they could focus on their vocals and stage presence. We can see the big improvement on their performance. I'M SCREAMING!
4세대 아이돌의 특징중 하나가, 팬데믹동안 카메라 앞에 단독으로 서는 기회가 많아서 미디어 퍼포먼스에만 집중한 나머지, 스테이지 연출에서 스펙타클이나 역동감이 부족한 점임. 그런 점에 대한 비판도 많았는데, 이 무대보니 처음으로 댄서도 투입하고 라이브로 부르는 구간도 만들고 변화를 줬네. 비판을 의식하는거보니 앞으로의 변화가 기대됨!
Abit unstable, off and changing key from the original and You'll know they're sing live when they always touch their mic. Not just aespa but all group too. I personally think only girls performance isn't live here
Ningning singing live is so beautiful and impressive. It sounds so auto-tune like that the people keep saying “omg its lip-syncing” no they’re just that impressive bitches. Also I love how ningning was just chillin’ and having the time of her live with the dancers and the audience. I wish SM would just let her be herself.
![[FANCAM] 220222 트와이스 (TWICE) Concert 4th World Tour III Texas Encore Medley](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eh0gGatLuCg/mqdefault.jpg)
I am so impressed with Karina's self-confidence here. And no surprise it's SM water, they slayed live singing
the audience singing along with them in foreign land makes me cry, i'm proud of you guys for dearly supporting our gorgeous four ladies, thank you for listening while they are singing live
Holy Ningning and Winter with their live vocals, this is beautiful. Also, hands down to the dancers because they are amazing in general, let's go Selene and Kaylar!!!
Slay Ningningieeeee 😍😍😍🔥
NINGNING SLAYED
Ning Ning has a strong stage presence. You can see that she believes she's THE queen lol btw did they perform Savage?
No. Just 3songs
@@fachrudinmahmud8509 4 song. Next level, illusion, life too short and girls
@@syaa2034 ah iya.. I forgot...
They also performed Black Mamba. I was there, but I was so excited that i forgot to film.
@@lpiersivey4313 OMG I'm sure it was awesome!
3:17 it made me smile when GISELLE turned to the dancer and danced together
Ikr that's so cute
So down to earth
I didn't notice it but it was so sweet thank you for pointing that out
She is sweetest💜
Yeah I saw that too 💞
Winter's voice is everything. Her voice is much stable than my mental health 😭
SM feeds them CDs and "SM water" they can sing live to the point they're often mistaken to be lip-syncing
Winter an Ningning showing they're singing live with their high notes at the end, slay Queens 👑
My faves! Love them!
NO LIVE !!!!!! 립싱크
@@하이연-c7c There is a very loud backtrack but you can clearly hear them singing on top of it in certain parts (like the 1st postchorus)
@@하이연-c7c 너무 잘하니깐 이젠 라이브를 해도 의심을 받네..
@@하이연-c7c how do you know... Thats live.. Thats why you have to cleaning ur ears every second.. So you can hear... Deafffffff
1:48 u can clearly hear ning ning singing live! and the rest of the members too omg
yes theyre singing live for black mamba, next level, and lifes to short. but prerecord for the rest
They obviously can sing and have great vocals but for some reason they do it not often. But this stage was great!!!
I'm so happy for them , Giselle looks so excited people are cheering and singing
Ningning be like: Im done with the "SM perfection thing". Now, hear me sing live! 🤭
winterrrr
Ningning slayyy
Ningning is born to perform like even her name though! Just like beyoncé madonna also ning has a very unique name because she is meant to be popular!!!
ningning in Filipino language means "shine". she's born to shine just like her name
@@mcgradyazul5667 so true see!!! Her name is for superstars
shiNing Yizhuo
Giselle and Ningning stage presence got so much better! So proud of my girls
Y'all know next level was an actual hit the moment you see how the crowd was singing even the Korean parts.. This is so enjoyable am happy they're finally surrounded by actual crowd that sing along with them.. Next level is my favourite stage of their gma stages so far
So true it makes me incredibly happy
닝닝 이제 여유롭게 잘하네 역시 경험이 답이었나? 성장하는 모습 멋있다.
AESPA LIVE SINGING IS ON THE NEXT LEVEL👏
Ningning performance always my favourite
Winter smiling at her backup dancers... she's so cute
i'm loving this trend of giselle asking karina "where we at?" at the bridge and karina responding with wherever they're performing. so far we have "where we at?" and "COACHELLA!", "LA!", and now we have "NEW YORK!". it reminds me of how in snsd's genie, tiffany used to give a shout out to whatever city they were performing in at the bridge. i.e. instead of "DJ put it back on" she'd say "_____ put it back on!"
Karina truly ate this one 🤧 Her being a captivatingly good dancer and top-tier stage presence, plus stunning body and visual ❤️ I'd never seen one idol this perfect til I saw Karina for the first time.
i cant keep my eyes off ningning she ateeee
BTS가 왜 No.1인지 ..확실히 비교되네....
미국 아침방송에 행사뛰러 간건 아닐건디....
참 성의없다......ㅉㅉ
애스파 영상만 올라왔다하면 닝닝 올려치기 귀신같네ㄷㄷ
Omg lol the whole crowd is mostly filled with guys
Are Aespa fans mostly male?
its mostly gay men
@@kumbachaserr what ?
@@jeannedemba6120 usa kpop fans are mostly lgbt
Actually i saw aespa’s insta story and the crowd was mostly females from the view they showed. Makes sense because the fanchants sounds more like females lmao
3:38 Ningning is living its so cute 😭
I'm literally confused I saw everyone criticize aespa for lacking stage presence but when I watch those performances they're great especially Giselle she has great stage presence
cuz they are the most popular 4th generation female group now, of course a lot of people wanna take them down.
And they hate it when people praise their stage presence that's how threatened they are 🤣 they keep on dragging aespa with live singing when their favs can even sing properly while standing
My eyes only for ninging!😍
me too
Winter...her dance..just..stealing the show for me
the cheers at the beginning are so loud
stable queens i love them sm
WINNTTTEEERRR HAVE MERCY
WINTER SLAY
Winter killing it!! Yes queen🧡
ning ning's energy is overflowing omg !
블핑 바턴이어받을 주자인줄 알았어
엄청나게 클줄 알았어 ㅠㅠ 근데 현재는 ㅠㅠ 다른 걸그룹한테 다 따라잡힌듯싶어, 맘이,,않조아
miss ningning stage presence and confidence always shines through ✨
CARALHO NINGNING PERFEIÇÃAO
ningning best girl
2:51 I love the moment, people love this song so much and the interaction is cute overloaded
So legendary! The queens of 4 gen dancing to there hit legendary song ‘NEXT LEVEL’ will truly be remembered! IM A PROUD MY!!!!!!!
Its good to see that they have back up dancers to shoulder some of the dance so they could focus on their vocals and stage presence. We can see the big improvement on their performance. I'M SCREAMING!
My girl ningning improved so much in stage presence n she become confident now 💜💜💜💜
4세대 아이돌의 특징중 하나가, 팬데믹동안 카메라 앞에 단독으로 서는 기회가 많아서 미디어 퍼포먼스에만 집중한 나머지, 스테이지 연출에서 스펙타클이나 역동감이 부족한 점임. 그런 점에 대한 비판도 많았는데, 이 무대보니 처음으로 댄서도 투입하고 라이브로 부르는 구간도 만들고 변화를 줬네. 비판을 의식하는거보니 앞으로의 변화가 기대됨!
WINTER 🤍
why NINGNING so pretty
Wow, Aespa is fantastic.. I love Winter!!!!
love ningning！！！！
I'm so glad they didn't make them do playback like with the festivals. It's so unnecessary when they can sing this good!!!
아리아나 그란데도 스타디움에서 그리디 라이브 하면서 죽을려고 하더라...음도 안 맞고 ...그래도 다 이해해준다.
야외에서 라이브 힘들다는거 다 안다. 라이브는 너무 부담갖을 필요없다 현장감있는 라이브 자체가 중요한거지..
NINGNING !!
닌닝? 목소리 카랑카랑한게 좋쿠만
Their vocals 💘
Winter is born with autotune 🔥
The crowd 💘
Aespa SLAYING.
Ningning ate it up all without crumbs. 💕💕💫💥💥
3:17 Giselle having fun with dancer
No puedo dejar de ver a Karina y a NingNing y luego sus voces fua 😍
Can't take off my eyes from ningning 😍😘😱
옛날에는 사람들이 가수와 함께 응원하고 노래 따라 부르고 박수치고 그랬는데ㅠ 요즘엔 다들 휴대폰으로 찍기 바쁘네요...
객석에서 모두들 저러고 있으면 가수들도 좀 무섭겠다
æspa are so talented idols! I'm so proud being a MY!
와 떼창 뭐야 미쵸따
아 생각 하니깐 ㅈㄴ 징그럽다 ;;; 내앞에 있는 사람들이 자기 폰들고 나를 녹화 하는 거잖아 ㅡㅡ 저 녹화한 영상을 '에스파봄 ' 하고 지 꺼에 올릴꺼고 .... 얼마나 신경 쓰이고 스트레스 일까...
윈터만 집중해서 여러번 봤다.
전에는 예쁘고 귀여웠는데 이젠 멋있기도 하네
Ningning slaying as always
2:23 닝닝 춤 재평가 시급.. 진짜 물흐르듯이 추네
2:30 워킹이 시발 레전드임
닝닝은 원래 괜찮았음 지젤이 별로였지
@@sunglee3935 지젤왜요ㅠㅠ 늘어서 잘하던데
@@kim-mh8fd 요새 잘함? 세비지까지는 다른맴버들하고 차이가 많이 나던데 흉내만 내는거 같고 각이 있는 느낌이 안듬
@@sunglee3935 네 잘하던데
그래도 잘했어요 천천히잘하면 되요 지젤
윈터 목상태가 별로네;; 고음이 안돼;;
NinNing's hair does a good job and Winter's stage presence got better.
미국 반응이 아주 좋네요...^^
네 반응좋아요 인기많아요
NING NING ❤❤❤
The fan chants gave me chills 🥺🥺 The energy is so good
Abit unstable, off and changing key from the original and You'll know they're sing live when they always touch their mic. Not just aespa but all group too. I personally think only girls performance isn't live here
they're all recoding, if I were there I would jump my soul out
2:50 지젤 귀엽
무대 퍼포먼스를 좀 더 올리면 좋을것 같다. 전체적인 안무하는 것이 약해어 아쉬웠음
wow...Ning ning becomes better & better, her stage performance just so great.
Ning ning is so attractive..
They're vocals omg so amazing!!
Bae ninging!
3:17 Giselle vibing with a dancer then After Karina too soo funny !
Ningning singing live is so beautiful and impressive. It sounds so auto-tune like that the people keep saying “omg its lip-syncing” no they’re just that impressive bitches. Also I love how ningning was just chillin’ and having the time of her live with the dancers and the audience. I wish SM would just let her be herself.
You can see in NingNing's and Giselle's face that they are enjoying to perform live.
닝닝 긴장안하니 제대로 실력 나오네
Karina visual ,winter ningning voice, and Giselle rappers OMG🖤
man those smiles and interactions with the backup dancers were so wholesome and cute
에스파가 미국내 입지가 저정도구나 ㄷㄷ 엄청나네 🇰🇷 👍
Karina always slayss
they're more confident now than on coachella, its really nervous for the first time performing with audiemce
westernes love ningning
SM SHOULD LET THEM SING LIVE MORE.
it's live it's live!
I love you KARINA QUEEN👑💕🎶🔊 QUEENS AESPA
KARINA, NINGNING,WINTER, GISELLE 👑💕👑🎤🎶
떼창 미쳐따ㅎㅎ
라이브하는 우리 에스파 너무 멋지고 따라서 불러주는 팬들 분들도 짱 멋짐♡
라이브라니요.. ;
라이브 뒷부분만 한거 같은데요
전체 라이브 아닌듯요
That's why I love SM artists. they are all true artist and cool
라이브 굿
Love the audience participation of "next level" at the beginning, then it went all quiet when the Korean lyrics came on 😂👍🤗
에스파 다 좋은데 중국멤버는 이제 정리 하자
언제 중국코인 빨러 도망갈지 모른다
우리 눈의 여왕, 윈터!