Just watching Ningning as she conserves energy from dancing you know she’s live live. As soon as her high notes are over she goes back to dancing with more energy and only pulls back right before she sings.
Ningning is my bias but I love seeing Giselle perform live. She really thrives on stage and seems like she’s having a good time all while still selling the attitude that aespa music has.
I don't see anything wrong with their perf. They did well. If they are a bit nervous its normal. They are in a foreign country, performing live... remember they are covid babies so its fine if they get nervous in front of live audience.
And also i think they were singing live here, i can see ningning singing well because she limits her dance to save energy and you can see her face and throat kinda struggling which is a sign of live singing, but again this is just a speculation
SM NEVER deduts an artist that can't sing live... DARE anyone who know an SM artist that has debuted that can't sing... tell me their name... FYI.. even the dancing members/rap in every group they debut can sing.
Have any of you noticed how they sing live in the US performances? I think it’s bc we tend to be not to critical if something isn’t perfect when it comes to singers. I feel like Kpop groups don’t have a lot of pressure here.
thats actually totally wrong. Its just the western fans are way more critical of someone singing live or not. knetz don't care anywhere near as much as western fans when it comes to a group singing live that's all.
Way to assume Western Audience are so 'open-minded' when they're THE most critical I've seen in terms of these over the years -_- ... I love when people who don't know anything just start to generalize and these comments get likes from like-minded ignorants.. SMH !
@@originalvisual3203 This is the most accurate reason for people who don't know where Idols sing live ! In their showcases and their own Concerts, you can see them singing with just the instrumental and not the backtracks like they do in music shows.
@@Lyf4rMusic they legit don’t sing live in SK. You can tell by their choreography. They switch it up a little when they sing live. As for the open minded part, since when have we express Zeno comments to them? They are experience xenophobia in SK. By “they” I mean Ning Ning
블랙맘바 라이브로 했다는 증거 0:34 원터 '넌 언젠가부터 싱크아웃'이랑 '노이즈 같이 보여' 할 때 '넌'이랑 '보여' 부분에서 마이크 문제인지 음원이랑 다르게 고음 올라갈 때 살짝 흔들림. 1:32 닝닝 '위험한 장난을 쳐 매혹적이지만 널 부정할 밖에' 부분할 때 음원에서는 장난을 쳐~인데 영상에서는 장난을 쳐↗️라고 함. 1:58 카리나 'hey'
@@bismanaz7436 Las que mejor presencia tienen son Karina y sobretodo Ningning no se engañen, que destaque aquí más que las demás por su vestuario es otra cosa.
Let them perform so maaaany times in public/live audience and they will surely find their confidence. Aespa you did well and I am so excited to see you guys improve with so much confidence in your talents ❤️
Just watching Ningning as she conserves energy from dancing you know she’s live live. As soon as her high notes are over she goes back to dancing with more energy and only pulls back right before she sings.
Did you hear that NingNing’s highnote??? Yes that’s our main vocalist and also they prove that they can sing live
the girls are saving their energy cuz they're singing live. you can see that after ningning hit her highnote, she gave 100% for the dance. Good job!
I forgot that they were sing live.. Since their live singing is perfect!!!! GO aespaaaa
2:16 언제 봐도 좋은 닝이 고음지르고 춤합류
고음 쫙 지르고 박자 딱맞게 들어가는거 진짜 쾌감 오져요!!!!
Ningning's high note is adorably insane🔥🦋
Got goosebumps cause of their raw vocals, rap, dance and stage presence! Queens indeed!
Gooo Ningning ! My bias since their debut… ! I knew she was going to slay more and more 😍
Ningning snatch! she has this aura and presence that are really captivating
Ningning is my bias but I love seeing Giselle perform live. She really thrives on stage and seems like she’s having a good time all while still selling the attitude that aespa music has.
Our superstar NingNing!!!Really Slays the stage!!!
아니 누가 들어도 라이브잖아..
I don't see anything wrong with their perf. They did well. If they are a bit nervous its normal. They are in a foreign country, performing live... remember they are covid babies so its fine if they get nervous in front of live audience.
And also i think they were singing live here, i can see ningning singing well because she limits her dance to save energy and you can see her face and throat kinda struggling which is a sign of live singing, but again this is just a speculation
YES AGREE WITH U!!
@@myeshaazzahra5422 I am 99% sure they're singing live plus their singing has improved since the coachella event
They look so good here tho!
@@katgreer6113 if by struggle you mean being slightly out of breath while dancing so it doesn't sound exactly like the CD then that's normal. Lol. smh
닝닝 너무 잘해!
I'm in love with their vocals
NingNing's highnot was everything
Aespa is doing really well. They are so talented and their potential is to be admired. Hope they continue like this
옴 닝닝 하이 노트 모든 부분을 죽이는 💓💖😭🧸
The way ning ning highnote elevated the performance 🔥🔥🔥🔥
크 라이브 지렸다
라이브 너무 잘한당
OMG my baby Ningning. That highnote is perfect
Winter's voice is much stable than my mental health 😭❤️
Omg live vocal 🔥
always love confident ningning. She’s rocks the stage!
0:28 Giselle wink omg 😁😍😍
2:14 oh the way NINGNINGGGG comes on this part🔥🔥🔥
와 닝닝이 고음 미쳤다..소름이 쫙끼치네 ㅠㅠ
이거 라이브죠?? 잘하는데?? 앞으로도 자주 목소리 들려주면 좋겠당
라이브 맞습니당
라이브 맞아요 100파
네 라이브 맞아용
mics were ON
Ningning did welllllll! That highnotes were def real!!!
Im always so amazed how ning ning absolutely devours that last high note and literally jumps into the choreo like wow
와 라이브 개쩐다;; 코첼라때보다 훠어얼씬 잘함 립싱큰줄
Winter in this outfit is just😍
they really had that power rangers theme lol . i love it .!!!
the way they sound exactly the same as mv studio? only aespa spectacular vocals
100%
They sang live! I am so proud of them 😭💖
닝닝아 너무 사랑해....오래오래 무대에 잇어줘...
닝이줘 사랑해….
사이타마님
닝이줘 개잘해....2절벌스 실수할까봐 춤 살살추는거 넘 맘아프지만 센스있었다 오늘 무대매너나 퍼포나 빠짐없이 잘해따 닝닝이!!!
솔직히 닝닝이 라이브 잘하지 않나요ㅠㅠ 라이브로 까는 사람들 이해 안감..
ㅇㅏ 여기 댓글+답글 너무 힐링…. 닝닝아 사랑해 🥺😍😍😍😍😍
오우... 지젤!! 머리 돌릴 때 카리나 복붙한 것처럼 동시에 돌아가 ㄷㄷㄷㄷ
2:15 ningning good job!!!!
0:35 Winter was very nervous, but she was capable of hitting that high notes!
SM NEVER deduts an artist that can't sing live... DARE anyone who know an SM artist that has debuted that can't sing... tell me their name... FYI.. even the dancing members/rap in every group they debut can sing.
So lucky! You had great seats!
they are singing with no backtrack you all! OMG!
2:28 wow Giselle's confidence ❤❤❤
NingNing’s aura is insane
찢었다
....
1:18 giselle proved they're singing live. I LIVE FOR THEM!
2:05 better not miss this highnote part🥰🥰🥰
This quality is so good omg
Winter's outfit is the best styling I've ever seen.
Karina is so satisfying to watch every single performance!
THEY SING LIVE WITH NO BACKTRACKKKK!!!!!
Yeah I'm glad. Their dancing not really sharp here, means they have to balance their vocals.
they slayed with live vocals, and they're so gorgeous, stan aespa
ジゼルのダンスがレベルアップしてる！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！
2:27 헤드뱅잉 카리나도 개잘돌리는데 지젤도 옆에서 개시원하게 돌림ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
生歌！！！！！本当に上手
Have any of you noticed how they sing live in the US performances? I think it’s bc we tend to be not to critical if something isn’t perfect when it comes to singers. I feel like Kpop groups don’t have a lot of pressure here.
thats actually totally wrong. Its just the western fans are way more critical of someone singing live or not. knetz don't care anywhere near as much as western fans when it comes to a group singing live that's all.
@@deadcells963 you're right
Way to assume Western Audience are so 'open-minded' when they're THE most critical I've seen in terms of these over the years -_- ... I love when people who don't know anything just start to generalize and these comments get likes from like-minded ignorants.. SMH !
@@originalvisual3203 This is the most accurate reason for people who don't know where Idols sing live ! In their showcases and their own Concerts, you can see them singing with just the instrumental and not the backtracks like they do in music shows.
@@Lyf4rMusic they legit don’t sing live in SK. You can tell by their choreography. They switch it up a little when they sing live. As for the open minded part, since when have we express Zeno comments to them? They are experience xenophobia in SK. By “they” I mean Ning Ning
I loveeeeee theseeee outfittssssss!!!!
The stylist needs a raise!!
WE LOVE THE LIVE SINGING also ningning looked really anxious I feel so sad for her :(
I think it was the large chunk of shoes she was standing on
I LIKE AESPA,AWESOME VOCALIST
Ningning highnote🤯
Ningning looks amazing!
THEY ARE SO STABLE OM SO PROUD OF THEM I LOVE THEM SM SM SM
2:28 Karina's hair has excellent dancing skills too !
블랙맘바 라이브로 했다는 증거
0:34 원터 '넌 언젠가부터 싱크아웃'이랑 '노이즈 같이 보여' 할 때 '넌'이랑 '보여' 부분에서 마이크 문제인지 음원이랑 다르게 고음 올라갈 때 살짝 흔들림.
1:32 닝닝 '위험한 장난을 쳐 매혹적이지만 널 부정할 밖에' 부분할 때 음원에서는 장난을 쳐~인데 영상에서는 장난을 쳐↗️라고 함.
1:58 카리나 'hey'
Also at 1:27 there’s a slight crack
이것 뿐만아니라 다른 노래에서 가사 변형해서 여기가 어디? La 이렇게 말한 거 보면 빼박 라이브
혹시 음악하시는분? 저도 라이브라는건 느끼는데요, 그런 작은 디테일까지는 ㅋㅋㅋ 대단하십니다 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
라이브ar이랑 라이브는 딱 보면 티가남 이건 생라이브는 아니고 mr깔고 그 위에 부른거임 자기 파트 부를때 춤추는거 보면 더 알기 쉬움 라이브할땐 춤동작이 좀 조심스럽거나 생략됨
I love the happiness on Giselle's face
WOWW THE FACT THAT THEY PERFORMING LIVE!!!! THE HIGH NOTES THO WOWWW
Ahhh my gigi, just enjoying and feeling the performance 🥰
Wow amzing Beautiful i love this ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💖💖💖✌✌✌✌✌
People screaming for Giselle cus they know she's a queen!
Their vocal ✨😭😭😭
I LOVE THE CROWD!!! THANK YOU MY FOR BEING THERE
Gigi is so different in front of a crowd
They did well, and are also singing live 🙂
THE FACT THAT THIS IS LIVE!!!! MIND BLOWN 🤯
The way you guys screamed for Giselle, I love it
i just realized there was like no backing vocals omg😭😭
ningning is such a queen omg i love her
Omg live vocal💖💖💖
They look so unreal. Omg
I've seen them performing the Iconic choreo part of the chorus soo many times now, but it still feels unreal how damn quickly they get down :O
WINTER IS ON ANOTHER LEVEL!!! SHE HAS THE BEST STAGE PRESENCE FOR THIS
HER FACIAL EXPRESSION IS EVERYTHING
Hhhhhh let's be honest she doesn't
@@eulalia3468 you are just jealous...say it
@@bismanaz7436 Las que mejor presencia tienen son Karina y sobretodo Ningning no se engañen, que destaque aquí más que las demás por su vestuario es otra cosa.
@@itzelayala7323 she dance better than ningning than karina lol! Haters
to haters,
go listen to ‘life's too short’
my gigi queen looks so happy yeyyy
Heck how does KArina´s hair moves so smootlhy and palces at the right spot after those head spins like it is alive???? SO pretty
*Karina is Unreal, What A Girl. I Love The Whay She Dance, What A Style* 💯
LIVE VOCALS!! 😭
Aespa vocals and stage presence always slay 💜💜💜
Let them perform so maaaany times in public/live audience and they will surely find their confidence. Aespa you did well and I am so excited to see you guys improve with so much confidence in your talents ❤️
Singing live!!!!! Our girls 💜💜💜💜💜
🔥🔥🔥🔥love it seriously
aespa is on fire~~❤️❤️
Aespa is and shall be the greatest female group in the entire history
닝닝 고음 대박..
They all looks so happy performing here.. giselle even wink to lucky My's in front.. lucky fans!
Ningning's highnote omg ..also respect to her, how can someone do black mamba drops with those freakin tall shoes on ?
La calidad de el video 😳
las amo chicas ♥️💜
Up to this day i still wonder how Karina pulls off her glorious hair-flips.