The Signal NASA Didn't Want to Receive from the LUCY Probe
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 лют 2023
- Join me today in the nail-biting journey of LUCY. Use my link to install Angry Birds Friends for FREE: rov.io/astrum and revel in the destruction!
Astrum merch now available!
Apparel: astrum-shop.fourthwall.com/
Metal Posters: displate.com/promo/astrum?art...
SUBSCRIBE for more videos about our other planets.
Subscribe! goo.gl/WX4iMN
Facebook! goo.gl/uaOlWW
Twitter! goo.gl/VCfejs
Instagram! / astrumspace
TikTok! / astrumspace
Astrum Spanish: bit.ly/2KmkssR
Astrum Portuguese: / @astrumbrasil
Donate!
Patreon: goo.gl/GGA5xT
Ethereum Wallet: 0x5F8cf793962ae8Df4Cba017E7A6159a104744038
Become a Patron today and support my channel! Donate link above. I can't do it without you. Thanks to those who have supported so far!
#lucy #nasa #astrum
Image Credits: NASA
Music Credits: Cinematic Amb. Piano - BlackSunAeon_Music
Clemens Ruh - This Is Our Home
E J R M - Catacomb
Jamie Bathgate - Resolve
Linus Johnsson - Isolation
Venus - Yotam Agam
We Dream of Eden - Distant Horizon
Use my link to install Angry Birds Friends for FREE: rov.io/astrum and revel in the destruction!
I will.
the least expected sponsorship
the slingshots fit the theme lol
can't believe this still exists lmao
They do be angry tho
Well I didn't expect angry birds! :D
I looked for the date this was posted thinking it was like 10 years old 😂
Same. im wondering who they think the market is watching this channel ?
Audibly laughed when angry birds showed up on screen
No XD
Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition!
I don't recall the other astronomy channels talking about LUCY very much, so this was informative. Wish I had heard about those Earth flybys. Maybe I could have seen it.
I don't know why but the topic doesn't seem to get many views, so it seems a lot of other channels avoid it. Hoping this video will buck the trend! It's a really unique probe and deserves some attention
Another channel (Dr. Becky maybe?) spoke about Lucy at the time the solar panel got stuck, but I never heard about it again.
@@astrumspace I never even knew about it until just now.
Anton Petrov seems to have covered it at least once or twice. I'm sure he'll cover it more as the mission progresses.
@@astrumspace I suppose part of it is we hear about the mission and the launch but then we hear it isn't going to reach its destination for a number of years and we sort of forget about it. It's hard to stay excited about something that isn't going to happen for 5 or 6 or ten years.
It is astonishing that the trajectories of asteroids can be known so precisely, and that the trajectory of a probe can be selected so precisely that the probe can meet a (relatively) tiny rock hurtling through space.
To me, that's one of the more incredible aspects of our technology.
You'd think in a game like Kerbal Space Program, this kind of thing wouldn't happen, but actually, I have several times allowed probes' batteries to run dry, essentially killing the otherwise immortal probe, by using time compression without making sure the probe's solar panels are in sunlight. Fortunately, in the stock game, this only affects the probe you are currently monitoring. I often spend extra credits on solar panels just to make this mistake less likely.
haha, me too, i have alot of dead probes in my kerbal history
i have done this too many times. i usually just open up the cheat menu, check unlimited electricity, open solar panels, uncheck unlimited electricity, and then close out the cheat menu. getting to that point usually takes a lot of time and i dont save often enough. if i had to go back and redo everything i probably would just close out of the game.
Read my comment above for the simple answer. $$$$ Greed !
I have had some that were dead for decades before returning close enough to the sun to charge the batteries enough to fire the engines.
@@kur0kiba Yeah, I wouldn't get the same sense of accomplishment if I did that. Solar panels are rarely too heavy or expensive to add a few more, though... and like I said, as long as you're not actively flying that ship, battery power won't tick down.
I'm not even sure I've ever heard of this mission before. After all its been through, it'll be such an amazing victory if it succeeds. God speed! We haven't forgotten you!
How could you follow space news and not know about Lucy? One of her instruments uses a diamond disk and there were at least 3 months worth of Lucy in the sky with diamonds jokes 8-)
you haven't heard of it cause it's not real, like all the rest they make us believe regarding Space.
@@magalipiendel411 What is space then? Let's hear it.
@@magalipiendel411 So... you look up and see....... a projection? An image? The funny thing about all of your 'idea's tho, is that we have ideas of our own, that make perfect sense and are 100% within the known, tested, and observable laws of physics.
Did you know the NASA mission called Deep Impact?
And then they made a movie on a whole difrent concept :/
So it's understandable you may not have known.
The math and planning behind these sorts of flights always blows my mind. Just seems impossible to me, especially when I see some of the equations involved hahaha XD Huge props to the folks that work on these projects and pull off these incredible feats!
Same. So I went out and worked throuh an orbital mechanics and celestial mechanics textbook and a few instructional things.
It can get really complicated really fast because many bodies interact, but the basis is actually very easy (aside from some of the caculus required). High-G would probably require relativity but ask an expert.
@@jamegumb7298 High G and High V both.
@@jamegumb7298 No motion in our solar system requires relatively except mercury's orbit. But regardless, it's all done in computers, even back in the day (basically), so no one is really crunching numbers trying to find the specific amount of impulse required for a maneuver.
@@kindlin Managing the motion of the satelites around the Earth requires the theory of relativity.
@@samuela-aegisdottir Calculating the time between pulses of satellites for accurate GPS requires relativity. Getting your orbit to work right and move around the earth in the ellipse/circle you want does not require any consideration of Special Relativity and time/space dilation.
I am such a fan of this probe and the people who are behind it. If I can once in my life be in the control room to ... just be there. I would feel like a teenage girl at a beatles concert.
@@sirensynapse5603 okay. Maybe I went too far with that.
You didn’t go to far lol.
@@simonm.456 nah bro you’re good, it was a good analogy Lol
Bro are you in the 1960s cause I’m sorry to tell u but the Beatles are no longer together 😂
@@osamahashoor2548 It was an analogy and the Beatles were mentioned in the video.
I hadn't heard much about Lucy. Thank you for this very well produced video. I'm always fascinated by scientists planning long term goals for space crafts with such convoluted orbits. All the best Lucy ❤️
Nice! I can't sleep and this popped up. Some welcome chill science and relaxation.....& I learn something. Cheers.
Wow! Thank you for this! I didn't realize that so much drama had occurred with Lucy! What a saga and the mission has really just started. There is going to be so much perspective changing data and we will learn so much!!! Your show is wonderful and so informative! Thank You again!👍
Thank you for this, it’s easy to just give up on people with so much awful news and I guess people in general. Hearing about people that are so smart that they just want to find info in the universe makes me believe in people
I always enjoy listening to the perspective of space you present, been a fan for years. Please dont ever stop
I just want to say that I have been citing your videos in my Space Studies class all semester. I like every video I've watched, and am now an avid follower. You are an excellent source, and I appreciate all the work and research you have put into these videos, as well as the interesting way in which you present them. Thank you!
The physics and engineering behind the trajectory and build composition of this project... is just amazing.
Can’t wait for Lucy’s arrival to the Trojans! It really has been a good time for asteroid mission lately; we’ve had osiris-rex and hayabusa2, DART, LUCY… and the PSYCHE mission to a metal-rich asteroid is also still scheduled to launch later this year!
The fossil was named Lucy because the song “Lucy in the sky with diamonds” was playing on the radio at the time. So both the fossil and spacecraft have a Beatles connection
The scientifically accurate "Lucy in the sky with mostly iron and nickel" doesn't have that ring to it though
Space is a pretty hazardous place, one of the biggest problems is the effect of radiation. The variation in energy tends to cause all sorts of issues with mechanical parts, tolerates being pushed, metals tending to just weld to eachother. And then you have electronics... There is really only so much you can do to protect against stray bit flips, random components getting ionizing charges, etc. You can add some minor shielding, use chips with much wider traces and thicker transistor layers, and run at lower clock speeds; but that comes at a significant performance and energy cost.
Its really a struggle for any probe to deal with having low overall mass, but have enough protection and redundancy from the harshness of open space.
Read my comment above for the simple answer. $$$$ Greed.
I previously knew practically none of this... Thanks Alex... Great content! 🐥
Superb research and animation, as has come to be characteristic of your channel, Alex. It is such a treat to attend one of your chats about Space and the Universe!
Only you could have made angry birds sound this appealing! Lol I love it! This was a great video on Lucy. I can’t wait to see future updates
It's fitting the first official visit of spacecraft Lucy was the asteroid Donald Johanson, as he is the best known of the team of three paleoanthropologists who discovered the fossil they named Lucy.
Still not up there with more democratic naming policies.... like Probey McProbe (for example)
They probably named the asteroid that way after chosing it as Lucy's goal. It's quite possible that it had just a number as a name before it was chosen for the mission.
@@matthewyabsley Gear up, you're about to learn in the video, DiNozzo.
Great video, Alex. You explained everything very well and gave me a better understanding of this mission. A mission that was overshadowed by all the dramas with the James Webb and eventual launch. Loved the romance of photographing the home of the original 'Lucy' by her significantly advanced namesake. Cheers and congratulation to all involved in this mission.
Always enjoy seeing how craft act and respond and fixes like a partial opening of the second solar panel, it has some vary precarious orbits dipping into our satellite debris fields as it approaches earth and back out on the gravitational sling shot maneuvers .. Thanks for the run though on Lucy the satellite missions in deeper parts of space ..
9:50 damn i thought space force is just a meme before lmao
I'm glad NASA scientists are a lot smarter than me. Seriously impressed by what they can do.
Well just you wait until the next couple generations take their place, you'll be blown away by how they can TikTok 🙄
All they do is Computer Generated Images.
No one is smarter than anyone you just need to be passionate and patient
@@Yusuf-cg4zt Astronauts are simply actors. We've never been to space.
@@luxmysterium assuming they are actors , theres lots of other fields you can study
When the fossil Lucy was discovered, Johannson specifically named it after the song that he said was heard playing that day.
Considering the speeds needed for interplantary travel within our solar system. Combined with the fact that space is far from empty. It's a wonder that most of our probes aren't destroyed mid-flight by micro-meteorites.
And that's not counting all the other hazards that raise their head when you leave the safety of earth.
'Space," [the Hitchhiker's Guide] says, "is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly hugely mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space.'
Are you drinking paint again?
You have a truly lovely voice and delivery- it’s a pleasure to listen to. Thank you Di. 🙏👍
PS I hope we are still around to see the results of Lucy’s mission - the first being 2025 and 2027 … fingers crossed !
The science behind those trajectories is truly mind blowing.
Just the process of thought alone! Imagine the math equation (s)!!
All these scientific excursions are a testament to the ingenuity and dedication these folks have for scientific discovery, the mathematical feats involved are mind blowing and they have my utmost respect!
Wonderful! I remember when ULA launched Lucy a couple years ago, everyone seemed really excited about it but I had wondered why it was named “Lucy”. I had just assumed that NASA made up an acronym, as they usually do, to come up with a catchy name. I could have googled it, I guess - but I just never did. Then your video gave a nice explanation - I had heard about the fossilized humanoid being named “Lucy” but I never made the connection before I saw this. What a brilliant explanation!
The entire video was just wonderful. I’ve subscribed and look forward to more. I’m retired now but worked in aerospace for many years; I always felt like one of the luckiest people on Earth, because I got to do my passion as a career… and I got paid to do it! It was so much fun. I do miss it. I guess I could still consult, but I am kind of enjoying retirement a little too much…
Cheers from New Orleans, Louisiana!
Im sure it is pronounced LUCKY
I only wish you had included a note that Donald Johanson was the anthropologist who discovered Lucy in Ethiopia, hence the asteroid Donaldjohanson which "looks weird"!
Someone three million years ago had no clue what impact they would have on the future. May they rest in peace.
Scary ... or amazing part, is that it was we back then looking up, very proud we have made it into space. :-)
You know you've succeeded when an already popular company sponsors you
Ngl that sponsor plug was the last thing I expected. I would be less surprised to see this channel sponsored by Nike
Fantastic video. Keep them coming love your stuff 👍
the fact that it discovered two new objects and its so far from its destination is incredible and shows how little we know still of our vast universe
The poor mission operators are getting Galileo flashbacks. Deployables are really hard to do exactly right. That's why JWST had such skepticism before launch and is so impressive after deployment.
I have never heard of Lucy (the probe) before, so this video was very informative for me. It is an amazing story of human ingenuity.
Fascinating, and nail-biting too! Thanks very much!
Interesting to see that both times LUCY will pass through the Trojan asteroids, it will be moving opposite their direction of orbit. So the interactions will be very brief flybys.
New Horizons got a good view of Arrokoth, and seeing as both probes use basically the same camera, I'm hoping for good things from these flybys!
I watched the animation on wiki and it seems to me that Lucy is moving in a similar direction as the Troyan Asteroid when passing thourgh. And it makes sense to me as the Toyans are moving in the same direction as Earth and Lucy is also moving in the same direction as Earth, somethink it needs to speed up by passing by.
Its motion will be prograde, but slower than the Trojans, giving encounter velocities of a few km/s, much like every other asteroid flyby.
The launch of a space craft is like a launch of a bird
…
That’s what I was REALLY afraid to hear the first moment. Anyways, thank you Alex! You’re truly a wonderful person. Uuuhhhh great vid anyways
Terrific information and a great video!
Thanks for giving me more to read about.
I love how happy he sounds about all this
I hope it will be not too far into the future that we will be able to repair crafts that have such malfunctions. As LUCY came near Earth several times before venturing out to the orbit of the trojans, a team of astronauts or robots could have intercepted it and done repairs. Much like the space shuttle had service missions to the Hubble telescope. As long as one can safely approach and match the direction and velocity of the probe, it should be possible. But of course the velocity would be very high, so we might have to develop an entirely new generation of spacecraft to manage that.
Read my comment above for the simple answer. $$$$ Greed.
I'm surprised that the narrator didn't mention the fact that the asteroid Donald Johansson is named after one of the discoverers of the fossil of Lucy. My 49 yo memory remembered the his name when he first began this narrative. Now I'm wondering if the asteroid was just named once this mission began, or if it already was named. My guess would be the former.
This has to be one of the best channels on UA-cam I love space
350 km is insanely close! The ISS is up around 400km, and they could have easily waved at each other.
Unfortunately had Lucy waved back it would have been bad news about its solar panel...
@astrumspace
A correction to your video, the satellite around Polymele was not discovered by Lucy, but instead by a group know as the southwest research institute. They observed using 60 ground based telescopes this star to provide a map you actually used in your video.
Appreciate your work and love the video.
I was wondernig about that because the "map" (11:57) looked like taken by numerous cameras from differnet places. That is possible on Earth, but not by a single probe. Thank for confiming my estimate. I feel clever now:-)
One small correction to your correction, SwRI isn’t a group, it’s a company/think tank. For my mechanical engineering senior design project I worked with one of their teams.
I thought it seemed odd that Lucy--designed for near-object observations--would be well equiped to observe distant transits. This explanation makes far more sense.
Great mission update, thanks! 🎉❤
Wow, I had not heard of this mission before. What a great mission to follow.
You have some really interesting stuff on this channel
I'm very excited to see what the Lucy probe will bring to our view. The number of targets is crazy, at a whopping 10! (152830 Dinkinesh will be the first on 1st November 2023, you forgot to include it.)
The Lucy Mission is really unusual. Especially it's flight Path relative to Jupiter. Got very Confused when i first saw it xd
It's also very long for a planned mission length.
@@SonicBoone56 True. a mission so long could even reach dwarf planets in the kuiper belt such as Ixion.
If one counts in all the satellites, the number isn't very impressive. All missions to Jupiter and Saturn took snapshots and more of a large number of moons orbiting these gas giants. So Pioneer 10 and 11, Voyager 1 and 2, Cassini, Galileo, Juno etc. all had more targets as long as we count in all satellites.
@@havareriksen1004 Hm. you got a good point there. But i think Alex was prob referring to the amount of Flyby's in one single mission, and not just pictures taken from far away like these probes did with these (mostly) tiny moonlets.
Thank you! I really enjoyed this
Top notch research and storytelling thank you
Your videos are so well assembled, good work.
Amazing and impressing what stunning manoevres can be executed with unmanned probes. I am very keen and hope to live long to learn all the new discoveries which may be expected.
There is no need for the expensive and dangerous efforts to bring man to the cosmic regions at our present stage of exploration. Let the probes do the job. The better we learn to apply AI the more we will be able to have all this work done by robots.
I agree! If human presence is so imparative, then there's plenty left for man and woman to do on the moon. Probes are so much more efficient and have already given us incredible and valuable information.
Read my post above ... for " Reason's " for such Failure's .
Until this video I had not heard of Lucy which is a suprise to me since I keep an eye on stuff like this. That said when I saw the video & its name & its mission my 1st instint was to think why they called it Lucy (see history & the movie Lucy) but then you explained why its Named Lucy & the name fits for both reasons in my humble non scientific opinion.
Thank you for this well presented informative video
fascinating, i didn't even know about Lucy & the android belts that Lucy is visiting, she certainly has got some exploring to do.
Angry Birds 💀
Always interesting to watch the outer space.
The sciences and mathematics that go into these types of group endeavors will always be completely awesome to me.
Well narrated . Thanks 🙏
Thank you Angry Birds.
videos like this remind me just how much better off the world would be if it was run by scientists and professors, rather than... well... you know.
Yeah. Because covid was a masterpiece of modern fascism- i mean science
Superb report. Thank you so much
I can't EVEN wrap my brain around all the mathematics involved in planning this mission 😳!!!!
(Orbital Mechanics wise alone)
really top notch visuals on this channel
Meanwhile, Voyager recently beamed back a signal from an unknown source. After decoding the data, it was translated into English, and the message was frightening.
“Greetings Earthlings. We have been trying for decades to reach with an important message about your car’s extended warranty.”
As Lucy came so close on its first flyby, could we have visually checked it out?
Another Excellent video! Thank You!
👍🏽👍🏽
The astroid with Pollimoly does actually have a name at least an unofficial one. It's named Shaun I was just on a trip to try and find its orbit (lookup Lucy occultation) as it could be dangerous to Lucy if it's not found. The data should actually come in within about a week or so and then we'll know its exact orbit. Also Lucy didn't find Sean it was a small group of astronomers working with the Lucy program on the ground. Interesting how it's done and would honestly make a pretty good video.
its Polymele and its moon is nicknamed Shaun, named after that one cartoon sheep.
@@KingdomOfSaulo unfortunately I don't believe so. I don't remember exactly what it's named after but it has something to do with the Lucy fossil.
A missão Lucy ...uma missão atribulada, além dos asteróides ainda tem que ultrapassar a quantidade de lixo a rodear a Terra!! Já não seria hora das agências espaciais fazerem uma limpeza?!! Preferiram formar uma guarda do espaço?! Bem sempre é menos caro...Quanto a viagem, numa curvas e contracurvas até aos asteróides errantes!! Não sabia destas atribulações...excelente vídeo!!
Collect all that material & put it thru a bubble jet constructor making a Dyson Belt
@@curtiskretzer8898 Ala the Dyson vacuum cleaner company?
It was cool working on modifying the launch pads for the Delta rockets.
Excellent as always, thank you
Thanks for posting this up Astrum.
Never realised that Space Force was for real, I've seen the very expensive but not too funny US comedy series with the great Steve Carrol but never realised that there was an actual Space Force.
Perhaps SF's 1st mission will be to take out some of the 47,000 IFO (identified flying objects) which will make it safer for all the newer traffic like Elon Musk's belt of 200 Starlink satellites.
I also dod not know that the Space Force exists. I thought it was just Trump's empty promise.
@@samuela-aegisdottir yeah, a part of the air force did orbital tracking among other things, and they just split it into its own branch. No clue why.
@@Raeilgunne Pretending to accomplish things, basically
Hello, thanks for the interesting and beautiful video! Great channel! Good luck!👍
What humans have achieved in science is jaw dropping. What they can do with these machines in space is spectacular. Slingshot around planet's millions of miles away is downright scientific magic, respect to all these people who have achieved this5and more. 👏👌☘️
Those manuevers were incredible!
I thought you were going to start the video by saying launching a rocket isn’t as easy as launching today’s sponsor, Angry Birds 😂
Thanks for Angry birds for sponsoring this video...
What year is this?
I love astrum videos ...i even wait for new videos to upload
This is very cool, I just watched a NOVA episode related to this mission, and here it is again on the interwebs
Whenever I think my job is too difficult I will watch this. Holy shmoly.
NASA always seems to be at their best when things go wrong . 😀
definitely great information, honestly didn't even know about Lucy or if I did wasn't big news. I know they wanted to study more of the asteroids.
Love the vids you make!
Why did they leave such a very small margin of error regarding the amount of energy they got from the two solar panels versus what they needed?
Read my comment above for the simple answer. $$$$ Greed.
@@paystar3436 Greed??? I would have thought more panels would be greedy. Not fewer panels.
@@MrStringybark Ah huge amounts of taxpayer money spent. The less panels means the Builders took the money and delivered LESS NOT MORE by not shopping around for better hardware and tech deals... and paying themselves way too much for design services that FAILED . gET IT yet ?
@@paystar3436 An absolute cynic and pessimist would say.
I still don't get why they named it Lucy. Lucy has been mired in controversy ever since the first parts of it were discovered in 74. Like, there are better, more complete examples of early man that (probably) weren't pieced together from various chimpanzee bones and a human skull. They don't have catchy names though.
There are still plenty of astronomers, astrophysicists, and greek deities to choose from. Lucy the jigsaw proto-human kinda sticks out in that regard. Or maybe there's precedent for this kind of name?
I don't really know why NASA names things as they do, but given the nature of the mission, Lucy is a fair enough name since she is the most famous of all of our ancestral fossils, at least among the general public. It doesn't hurt that Australopithecus Lucy was literally named for the Beatles song "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds". For me at least, it sort of works on a number of levels.
Lucy is only "mired in controversy" among people who aren't paleontologists. The Lucy specimen herself (AL-288-1) consists of pieces that were all found together in the same locality at the same time -- she is not some random assemblage of bits from different species. She is also not the only specimen of _A. afarensis_ , just the most complete individual.
I have googled the "controversy" about Lucy and it seems to me that the only people who have a problem with Lucy are creationists. Since astronomers are not creationists, I don't see a reason why not to name a probe by the name of the most famous hominid.
i love the animation, it repeats everytime 😵💫
I'm sad I forgot about Lucy, I live in Western Australia and would have loved to see Lucy pass over, we don't get many astronomical events here.
Of all the parameters NASA could have figured out, but didn't, is how to send someone up to Lucy to fix something as simple as a malfunctioning lanyard. It's a pity nobody had the forethought to get a space capsule capable of reaching Lucy and fixing it's issue in space, before it went anywhere.
No human has ever gone beyond the moon. It'd be reckless to send a human (at this point in history) into interplanetary space just to fix a probe.
@@iceboi5983 Also a new probe would probably be less expensive than a full manned repair mission capable of reaching speeds higher than escape velocity
@@iceboi5983 Robotic DEVICES that could do repairs is too economical for money hungry Space Biz Companies to be interested in. Get it yet ?
@@paystar3436 NASA is a government agency. They literally operate at a loss, try again.
@@iceboi5983 The repairs would be made when the craft was on one of its earthly flybys, but matching the speed would be a big problem.
Times like this I wish that we had an active "outpost" space station in orbit around Earth. Something like the ISS but designed specifically for the maintenance and checkup of missions. The solar panel problem on Lucy could have easily been spotted and potentially even rectified if we at least had eyes on the problem.
Angry birds brings back memories
It’s a shame it’s gonna take a looong time to get any results
Thx nicly told. i finally learned why sling shots work it uses the motion of the planet AND gravity. The planet pulls the space craft along its orbit. I never under stond why. If you just use gravity you would loose all speed again escaping it again
Well done. Lucy has a fine voice in you.
I'd rather Angry Birds than yet more Raid Shadow Legends or League Of Legends or Legends Legends Legendary Legends 😂
angry birds???