Seeing as Ben has played before I think he's the Cylon because he would know in these games the best way to do it is to not really overtly cause any chaos but to instead spread confusion and distrust.
Based on facial expressions, I would deem Ben and Lewis the most suspicious. But Mark is pretty suspicious based on his actions or lack there of. Pretty sure that Lewis is the starting cylon at least.
In a skill check cards from the Destiny deck are added first, so when using Investigative Committee players get to see them before playing their cards.
Ben is looking more and more shifty. He's pushing the mark and tom are cylons thing a bit too hard and maybe its just me but the way his eyes shift around the room is off. Also Lewis seems to be rather quiet and seems as though he's thinking hard about something.
Lewis is SUPER obvious. The way he blames everyone as soon as people start casting blame on someone, the way he's acting, his voice, the way he is asking about the things Cylons can do, and I swear he's literally asking about how to sabotage everything, and say things that are terrible ideas if your goal is to save the ship. Ben is only suspicious to me because he hasn't noticed how obvious Lewis is.
My money is on Ben being a Cylon. It's just so suspicious of how fast and heavily he pointed all of the fingers in the room to Mark for absolutely no reason.
actually one of the best plays as a cylon is to wait and let the humans tear themselves apart the destiny deck will more often than not cause enough chaos.
I remember a time where I was a Cylon and I spent the whole game helping the Humans. Everyone thought I was Human, so they ended up throwing the only other pilot in the brig and I was like "haha! I never really was on your side!" and then I blew up FTL, the hangar, and the gun batteries in the middle of an ambush. I made so many friends mad that day, but it was worth it.
Pyrion and ben are the only people I dont suspect. Isn't it odd that I only don't suspect two people? And there are only two cylons... hmm, anyways, merry christmas!
Its Ben and Pyrion, calling it now. They're way too accusatory and Ben is always looking shift, like just his body language and his fiddling. Pyrion knows how to bluff though, he's been playing really well by making sure he has little cards so he can run with the excuse that he can't help rather than he has nothing helpful. The other three have helped far too much.
Lewis and Mark are for sure Cylons, and I'm not sure about Mark. But Lewis is doing his classic Traitor behavior, and is even asking about game rules, things cylons can do, and so on and so forth. I will be shocked if Lewis is not a Cylon. But I'm sure Pyrion and Ben aren't cylons.
Seriously Lewis is even accusing random people who isn't himself. Just casting blame on everyone else. Lewis is so suspicious, how did Ben not notice this? XD That makes me suspect Ben more, because Lewis is so obviously the Cylon that it's ridiculous.
spoilers for the last episode of this just watched the last one came back to this episode to see if anyone got it right and you were the only person on the episode 3 comments to call out both Cylons and at this moment you have "one" like, gg general public, gg (also howell2010, you have mad Cylon guessing skills, well done)
Totally Ben and Tom. Ben is tossing a ton of accusations and has done a few shady things, like looking directly at the failure aspects a few times, and tossing Hulmes in the brig right off. And Tom is too quiet.
Ben has been very helpful, and he is always trying to figure out who the baddies are. which isn't something you would expect from a cylon. But he is a veteran so.
I reckon it's Pyrion. As Ben said himself it's a good plan for a cylon to get rid of all his cards and then spend each turn saying they can't help cos they don't have any.
If Ben's a Cylon, he's played it poorly. The exec order on him should've been prison, prison, brig lock, win (although that's very harsh in someone's first game, so he may have avoided it for that reason). Also that combination is almost certainly impossible since a purple or red was put in as a negative in this episode, chief doesn't draw either colour and Ben put 4 cards in, which would mean net 0 at best (and the Cylons are behind and really needed the humans to fail that check), and he only draws 1 purple per turn at most (we haven't seen ben's draws though, and he's either been forgetting his ability to draw a card on every crisis or using it wrong and drawing his cards at the start of the turn) Basically, since someone sabotaged the check from Pyrion and Mark (lewis draws red and purple but didn't put in), it can't be Ben and Tom. After the jump Pyrion is extremely suspicious tbh, and may just be letting Mark take the blame. I wouldn't be surprised if it's lewis, too. It could still be Tom, though.
I agree. Unless Ben is deliberately not trying to win as the cylon to make it fun for the humans, he has too much experience to have performed so poorly.
No, I said it isn't both ben and tom. It's also definitely not both Tom and Lewis. I don't think it's Ben, and I think it's most likely to be Pyrion tbh. It's almost certainly one of Pyrion and Tom, and probably not both. My top suspects would be Pyrion and Lewis. We can't tell for certain it's not Ben because we haven't seen that he hasn't drawn purple (because there are cuts every time anyone draws for turn, and I haven't seen him draw for each crisis like he should), but it's also very unlikely because he put 3 cards into the check. At most that's about -2, which is a pretty risky play as destiny could've saved humans (I think that the purple is a 5 but there's only one 1 in there), but it's very unlikely that it is him. Based on that check I'd say it's Lewis and Pyrion. With Pyrion letting Mark take the blame for the failed check and Lewis unable to contribute. That's assuming the Cylons are competent, though.
Idk, but i think pyrion is not one, probably not ben i think it could be Tom or Mark that is the second one, probably Mark, so ill put my money on Mark and Lewis
The real Cylon was all the friends we lost along the way.
This is my favorite board game so far on Games Night! Please play more in future or on stream!
So say we all!
IT'S Definitely Zylus.
And sjin, he is waiting the perfect moment for the epic troll
Cesar Sanchez My balls are telling me.
yea when ben got himself out of prison zylus said he had a card who coudl do that too, but didnt use it to not fail 5:17.
Mark: "Pyrion is pretty clever and, .."
Pyrion: "That is a lie..."
Seeing as Ben has played before I think he's the Cylon because he would know in these games the best way to do it is to not really overtly cause any chaos but to instead spread confusion and distrust.
Based on facial expressions, I would deem Ben and Lewis the most suspicious. But Mark is pretty suspicious based on his actions or lack there of. Pretty sure that Lewis is the starting cylon at least.
Hinzerhaus I suspect Lewis because he's been completely unremarkable the whole game so far.
In a skill check cards from the Destiny deck are added first, so when using Investigative Committee players get to see them before playing their cards.
Pyrion's hat is awesome
This game is awesome to watch, hope you do more sometime!
wonderful editing and play
Ben is looking more and more shifty. He's pushing the mark and tom are cylons thing a bit too hard and maybe its just me but the way his eyes shift around the room is off.
Also Lewis seems to be rather quiet and seems as though he's thinking hard about something.
Lewis is SUPER obvious. The way he blames everyone as soon as people start casting blame on someone, the way he's acting, his voice, the way he is asking about the things Cylons can do, and I swear he's literally asking about how to sabotage everything, and say things that are terrible ideas if your goal is to save the ship.
Ben is only suspicious to me because he hasn't noticed how obvious Lewis is.
My money is on Ben being a Cylon. It's just so suspicious of how fast and heavily he pointed all of the fingers in the room to Mark for absolutely no reason.
That glass of water has all the luck.
This is such a great game.
My two cents is that the cylons are among those that haven't played before, because the cylon plays don't feel big enough.
actually one of the best plays as a cylon is to wait and let the humans tear themselves apart the destiny deck will more often than not cause enough chaos.
Fair
I remember a time where I was a Cylon and I spent the whole game helping the Humans. Everyone thought I was Human, so they ended up throwing the only other pilot in the brig and I was like "haha! I never really was on your side!" and then I blew up FTL, the hangar, and the gun batteries in the middle of an ambush.
I made so many friends mad that day, but it was worth it.
Pyrion and ben are the only people I dont suspect. Isn't it odd that I only don't suspect two people? And there are only two cylons... hmm, anyways, merry christmas!
So 99% that Ben's a Cylon from the beginning of the game. I think Lewis might have become one after the Sleeper phase.
Authorize brutal force is only to be used when the heavy raider has landed. You could have saved the card for later.
Its Ben and Pyrion, calling it now. They're way too accusatory and Ben is always looking shift, like just his body language and his fiddling. Pyrion knows how to bluff though, he's been playing really well by making sure he has little cards so he can run with the excuse that he can't help rather than he has nothing helpful. The other three have helped far too much.
Ben was looking very sus in this episode whilst putting the blame on Mark.
Lewis and Mark are for sure Cylons, and I'm not sure about Mark. But Lewis is doing his classic Traitor behavior, and is even asking about game rules, things cylons can do, and so on and so forth. I will be shocked if Lewis is not a Cylon.
But I'm sure Pyrion and Ben aren't cylons.
Seriously Lewis is even accusing random people who isn't himself. Just casting blame on everyone else. Lewis is so suspicious, how did Ben not notice this? XD
That makes me suspect Ben more, because Lewis is so obviously the Cylon that it's ridiculous.
spoilers for the last episode of this
just watched the last one came back to this episode to see if anyone got it right and you were the only person on the episode 3 comments to call out both Cylons and at this moment you have "one" like, gg general public, gg (also howell2010, you have mad Cylon guessing skills, well done)
Thanks for indulging me!
And I mean, Lewis couldn't be more obvious if he had a giant sign above his head saying "CYLON"
Totally Ben and Tom. Ben is tossing a ton of accusations and has done a few shady things, like looking directly at the failure aspects a few times, and tossing Hulmes in the brig right off. And Tom is too quiet.
So there's Ben. He's a Cylon.
And Lewis, he's also a Cylon. But he's not the same Cylon as Ben.
don't forget Tom, he is also a seperate Cylon to Ben and Lewis.
you left out Pyrion, the greatest Cylon of them all! Cylon boss to Ben, Tom, Lewis, and Mark.... they are all Cylons!
Have a good day love the yogscast
So Pyrion feels the least likely to be a cylon, whereas definitely either Mark or Ben are cylons.
Ben has been very helpful, and he is always trying to figure out who the baddies are. which isn't something you would expect from a cylon. But he is a veteran so.
Well if it's not Ben then it's Mark. But if it's not Mark then it's Ben.
Kakunapod he accuses Mark a lot. Classic deflection tactic
I mean I accuse mark a lot and I'm not even playing haha
I reckon it's Pyrion. As Ben said himself it's a good plan for a cylon to get rid of all his cards and then spend each turn saying they can't help cos they don't have any.
Ben can draw any skill card, ‘i dont draw purples’ and no one points it out gah damnit
23:03 Is that Mr.Popcorn?
Yeees more trouble in Galactica town!
they came from, behind
Tom n Ben. Called tom in the first episode, and the second ones definitely ben
If Ben's a Cylon, he's played it poorly. The exec order on him should've been prison, prison, brig lock, win (although that's very harsh in someone's first game, so he may have avoided it for that reason). Also that combination is almost certainly impossible since a purple or red was put in as a negative in this episode, chief doesn't draw either colour and Ben put 4 cards in, which would mean net 0 at best (and the Cylons are behind and really needed the humans to fail that check), and he only draws 1 purple per turn at most (we haven't seen ben's draws though, and he's either been forgetting his ability to draw a card on every crisis or using it wrong and drawing his cards at the start of the turn)
Basically, since someone sabotaged the check from Pyrion and Mark (lewis draws red and purple but didn't put in), it can't be Ben and Tom. After the jump Pyrion is extremely suspicious tbh, and may just be letting Mark take the blame.
I wouldn't be surprised if it's lewis, too. It could still be Tom, though.
So what you're saying is. It could be any of them. Glad we got you here Columbo. We never would've figured it out otherwise.
I agree. Unless Ben is deliberately not trying to win as the cylon to make it fun for the humans, he has too much experience to have performed so poorly.
No, I said it isn't both ben and tom. It's also definitely not both Tom and Lewis. I don't think it's Ben, and I think it's most likely to be Pyrion tbh. It's almost certainly one of Pyrion and Tom, and probably not both. My top suspects would be Pyrion and Lewis.
We can't tell for certain it's not Ben because we haven't seen that he hasn't drawn purple (because there are cuts every time anyone draws for turn, and I haven't seen him draw for each crisis like he should), but it's also very unlikely because he put 3 cards into the check. At most that's about -2, which is a pretty risky play as destiny could've saved humans (I think that the purple is a 5 but there's only one 1 in there), but it's very unlikely that it is him.
Based on that check I'd say it's Lewis and Pyrion. With Pyrion letting Mark take the blame for the failed check and Lewis unable to contribute. That's assuming the Cylons are competent, though.
Why didn't Lewis use his special on Besieged?
cokersatm Because he is a Cylon
He may have forgotten this is the yogscast
If I remember correctly he already used it to remove the card that would've made them lose morale after mark was released from the brig
you guys should defo do the ps4 phone games
Now that they kinda know what their doing, I would love to see another game of this!
Is Mark wearing an achievement hunter shirt?
Bens a defo cylon
IT'S BEN
choo choo
Ahh..destiny in first - even on the investigative cmte.
you are not allowed to say what was on any card you secretly saw
what the hell?
you cant scout and say "I SAW SURROUNDED"
I think lewis is a sylon!
Felix Underland And who do you think are the cylons?
Idk, but i think pyrion is not one, probably not ben i think it could be Tom or Mark that is the second one, probably Mark, so ill put my money on Mark and Lewis
not first
So it’s totally Ben and Pyrion
Mark is very high strung and annoying x)
first
Fucking spoilers in the comments, and you can't even avoid them because UA-cam just absolutely has to push the top one within view.
Jokie155 Wait till the end to read comments? Or do you mean spoilers for the show?
third