I've wanted an open world Sonic game for years. What I think would be the best way to do it is to set the game on an island like those mentioned in the Genesis era games (South Island, Westside Island, etc). You're given a large island to explore and it's made up of 6 or 7 large zones. The focus is on exploring the island's zones & uncovering secrets while also being able to run across the zones at high speed. As Sonic, your goal is to find the star posts, which work kind of like shrines in Zelda Breath of the Wild & Tears of the Kingdom. You collect rings to build up enough energy for the star posts to open portals to the Special Zone where you complete challenges for Chaos Emeralds. That's just my rough idea for how I'd want the game to play out.
IMO, Sonic Utopia is the ideal for Sonic open world design and Sonic GT is a great template for what modern Sonic stages should be like. Things are a little too spread out, but with some refinement, excellent games could come from both concepts.
I agree; likewise, the two games would be what the ENTIRE game is like, and builds South Island with it's respective zones - Green Hill(s) (Sonic 1 Genesis; Sonic 1 Game Gear; Sonic 2 Game Gear; Sonic 1 Pilot; Sonic Mania Plus) Tokyo City (Sonic 1 Pilot) Bridge (Sonic 1 Game Gear) Marble (Sonic 1 Genesis) Moon Rock (Sonic 1 Genesis Shinsaku build / Kawarino; Sonic 1 Pilot) Under Ground (Sonic 2 Game Gear) Labyrinth (Sonic 1 Genesis) Auric East (Sonic 1 Genesis Shinsaku build / Kawarino; Sonic 1 Pilot) Spring Yard (Sonic 1 Genesis) Sky High (Sonic 2 Game Gear) Jungle (Sonic 1 Game Gear) Star Light (Sonic 1 Genesis) Gimmick Mountain (Sonic 2 Game Gear) Scrap Brain (Sonic 1 Genesis) Sky Base (Sonic 1 Game Gear) Scrambled Egg (Sonic 2 Game Gear) Crystal Egg (Sonic 2 Game Gear)
@@IncrediBurch sabes que sería genial?,un juego online en 3D,un juego de mundo abierto donde se podía hacer lo que quisiera,ser cualquier personaje,algo como dragon ball xenoverse,pero con más libertad
It better be great. I want sonic to succeed and be the greatest. I believe sonic and his series will find the big bright light in the tunnel with sonic frontiers. We gotta keep supporting and loving sonic as much as we can with our love and amazing fan projects such as these fan games right here. Giving up is never the answer. Sonic would never give up.
Sonic GT is the most favorabble for my opinion. This should havbeen the number 1. Even tho it is short with tghe story and gameplay. Still feels like a compleeted game
The second game gave me the thought that it would be cool to dynamically switch the ground textures based on speed. The streaks in the grass help sell the speed but can look off standing still
Si los creadores de estos fangames leen esto,seré onesto con todos................................quisiera que los mismísimos de sega los contrataran,es un trabajo bien hecho,pulido,incluso se que pueden mejorar mas,más, que estaría genial que tuvieran un modo historia,multijugador y online
When videos like these pop up in my recommended feed, it always reminds me that most fans have no fucking idea what they actually want in a "good" sonic game and are just as bad or only a smidge better at game design than Sega. Edit: i will not elaborate any further
And also to be fair frontiers is the one here that looks more polished and fun, im guessing you have not played frontiers and u have only seen the gameplay
@@jkveri2002 That is why i'm saying this. To give devs of these games my impression from their games, so they know where to go next with their stuff, if they ever gonna make their games happen in the future. Cause, there is a lot of fan made games like these, that never seen the full release.
If you want open world sonic games to be effective, you should put objectives within that world similar to Sonic JAM. Sonic JAM was a small environment but had a set amount of things you could do in that world. Sonic Utopia imo would fit well for that kind of style of gameplay.
No no no! You can't allow the player to keep playing while you explain how to play the game. You have to assume your audience is dumb and keep abruptly interupting the game play by pausing it every 20 seconds.
@@Sonic_Beyond Then why the other version, which for some reason dissappeared from the internet, runned at 60 FPS perfectly fine on normal graphics ? Because on this version, my PC lags at 20fps on minimum graphics.
@@paulo547 this is happening to me too i think this is because the game is defaulting to your integrated graphics idk how to fix it because the game is a batch file and not an exe file
Green Hill Act 2, Utopia, and GT all look significantly better than Frontiers. Sega needs to take a page with what they did with Mania and have such hardcore fans make their 3D open world Sonic game.
i could say i tried to play GHP zone,level looks great.but wait! controling spindash and jump with mouse?!! you really? thats fucked of all game.just why:D
I've wanted an open world Sonic game for years. What I think would be the best way to do it is to set the game on an island like those mentioned in the Genesis era games (South Island, Westside Island, etc). You're given a large island to explore and it's made up of 6 or 7 large zones. The focus is on exploring the island's zones & uncovering secrets while also being able to run across the zones at high speed. As Sonic, your goal is to find the star posts, which work kind of like shrines in Zelda Breath of the Wild & Tears of the Kingdom. You collect rings to build up enough energy for the star posts to open portals to the Special Zone where you complete challenges for Chaos Emeralds. That's just my rough idea for how I'd want the game to play out.
.....
SMART
IMO, Sonic Utopia is the ideal for Sonic open world design and Sonic GT is a great template for what modern Sonic stages should be like. Things are a little too spread out, but with some refinement, excellent games could come from both concepts.
I agree; likewise, the two games would be what the ENTIRE game is like, and builds South Island with it's respective zones -
Green Hill(s) (Sonic 1 Genesis; Sonic 1 Game Gear; Sonic 2 Game Gear; Sonic 1 Pilot; Sonic Mania Plus)
Tokyo City (Sonic 1 Pilot)
Bridge (Sonic 1 Game Gear)
Marble (Sonic 1 Genesis)
Moon Rock (Sonic 1 Genesis Shinsaku build / Kawarino; Sonic 1 Pilot)
Under Ground (Sonic 2 Game Gear)
Labyrinth (Sonic 1 Genesis)
Auric East (Sonic 1 Genesis Shinsaku build / Kawarino; Sonic 1 Pilot)
Spring Yard (Sonic 1 Genesis)
Sky High (Sonic 2 Game Gear)
Jungle (Sonic 1 Game Gear)
Star Light (Sonic 1 Genesis)
Gimmick Mountain (Sonic 2 Game Gear)
Scrap Brain (Sonic 1 Genesis)
Sky Base (Sonic 1 Game Gear)
Scrambled Egg (Sonic 2 Game Gear)
Crystal Egg (Sonic 2 Game Gear)
@@IncrediBurch sabes que sería genial?,un juego online en 3D,un juego de mundo abierto donde se podía hacer lo que quisiera,ser cualquier personaje,algo como dragon ball xenoverse,pero con más libertad
8:15
8:15
8:15
All I can think of in 14:53 is the song “Nintendo Hire This Man”
14:55 Love song ❤️
Sonic bumper is the most peacefully music i have ever heard it is so peaceful❤❤❤
I hope we see gameplay of Sonic Frontiers soon
Me too
It better be great. I want sonic to succeed and be the greatest. I believe sonic and his series will find the big bright light in the tunnel with sonic frontiers. We gotta keep supporting and loving sonic as much as we can with our love and amazing fan projects such as these fan games right here. Giving up is never the answer. Sonic would never give up.
Goodly we will
Maybe after the movie on tailstube
How's it
bumper engine is cool but it would fry my laptop like an egg
15:03 this sense of speed is awesome
Sonic GT is the most favorabble for my opinion. This should havbeen the number 1. Even tho it is short with tghe story and gameplay. Still feels like a compleeted game
The second game gave me the thought that it would be cool to dynamically switch the ground textures based on speed. The streaks in the grass help sell the speed but can look off standing still
Sonic Utopia reminds me of N64 era. That would have been a game changer back then!
Pretty cool these days too, though.
Sonic GT looks the funnest.
Or the, er, Saturn
@@rooty I just outed myself 😪
Sonic GT is so much fun with the momentum stuff
Amazing video 👍
I hope we see official Sonic games that have these mechanics. A official 2D sonic game in 3d
And make it feel like a Saturn game, as well as being a spiritual successor to Sonic Mania.
Si los creadores de estos fangames leen esto,seré onesto con todos................................quisiera que los mismísimos de sega los contrataran,es un trabajo bien hecho,pulido,incluso se que pueden mejorar mas,más, que estaría genial que tuvieran un modo historia,multijugador y online
Sonic beyond,si lees esto,me harías el favor de mandar este mensaje a los creadores de los fangames?
Sonic gdk honestly looks beautiful
This is a work of art.
the music of sonic bumper makes me feel so nostalgia.
Where can I get these?
Why hasn't Sega hired some of these guys?
When videos like these pop up in my recommended feed, it always reminds me that most fans have no fucking idea what they actually want in a "good" sonic game and are just as bad or only a smidge better at game design than Sega.
Edit: i will not elaborate any further
Of course you're not gonna elaborate any further, you straight up don't have a point 🤣
Frontiers now exists because of one of these games
I've played 4 out of 5 of them worth playing
Where's that Chemical Plant Zone cover from?
Sonic Utopia ftw 🙌
What was the music used in the Lost Lake part?
ua-cam.com/video/cB4_TN_sGrY/v-deo.html
Bumper engine is my favorite
Literally all of these look more fun and polished than Sonic Frontiers
This comment is a lie
Sonic Gt was the only wan that was well developed and nice, the rest were ass and a open source engine
When I'm in 'the most ungrateful fanbase' competition and my opponent is the sonic community
And also to be fair frontiers is the one here that looks more polished and fun, im guessing you have not played frontiers and u have only seen the gameplay
@@Simon11679 bro it's fifty bucks why would I think of it
Yeah, open and empty world games where is nothing to do besides running around. But yeah, best of them would be Sonic Utopia. I really like that one.
These are just for testing purposes. Are you REALLY thinking that an open world Sonic game would look like this?! xDDDDDDDDD
@@jkveri2002 That is why i'm saying this. To give devs of these games my impression from their games, so they know where to go next with their stuff, if they ever gonna make their games happen in the future. Cause, there is a lot of fan made games like these, that never seen the full release.
If you want open world sonic games to be effective, you should put objectives within that world similar to Sonic JAM. Sonic JAM was a small environment but had a set amount of things you could do in that world. Sonic Utopia imo would fit well for that kind of style of gameplay.
@@jkveri2002 Well actually...
I would love to give one of these games a spin!
No pun intended
Omg its FLOPPA🖐
14:57 Sonic Frontiers familiar
You are the reason why that I have sonic the Hedgehog in my profile picture
as musicas dos segundos atos de sonic são sempre as melhores
the third game isnt there no more. i cant download it
No no no! You can't allow the player to keep playing while you explain how to play the game. You have to assume your audience is dumb and keep abruptly interupting the game play by pausing it every 20 seconds.
Sonic Bumper is Sonic Frontiers but a fan game
the second one is deadass sonic while high
Make 5 amazing Online Sonic Fan Games
Why a 1 stage of a sonic fan game is better than 3 new modern sonic stages😑
sonic bumper engine open world wont open
5 years ago and then the Rethe problem isn't the only thing you
as a Mac player I sadly say I've played none of these :(
Yeah, you need a powerful pc to play these
Sonic GT ain't open world, the levels are just super massive with so much routes
my utopia is NOT like that i cant turn my camera and the peel out looks better in this video then mine
Yeah but is that the actual name for the first one
Yes
@Sonic_Beyond thank you, you deserve subscribble
There is any for mobile?
This GHP Act 2 version is different. And for some reason, this version lags af on my PC, can someone have an explanation?
Probably because your PC can’t handle it.
@@Sonic_Beyond Then why the other version, which for some reason dissappeared from the internet, runned at 60 FPS perfectly fine on normal graphics ? Because on this version, my PC lags at 20fps on minimum graphics.
Hmm… idk then, that’s really weird.
@@Sonic_Beyond Oh well... Thanks anyway.
@@paulo547 this is happening to me too i think this is because the game is defaulting to your integrated graphics idk how to fix it because the game is a batch file and not an exe file
No we have an actual Open World Sonic Game next year
When he rolls while boosting it gets me rolling get it?
The first ones after effects didn’t looked too great
Only real sonic fans clicked this
How do u even play it?
I think the lost world one was sonic rangers!😡
Frontiers😩
I didn’t want to edit it…
Sonic souls was so good
It looks like the Sonic Frontiers team just saw the Sonic Bumper Engine and ripped it...
Peço por favor para me enviar o link do jogo eu adorei ☺️
Green Hill Act 2, Utopia, and GT all look significantly better than Frontiers. Sega needs to take a page with what they did with Mania and have such hardcore fans make their 3D open world Sonic game.
Yea but the sonic bumper engine had the fastest running speed
why does the first one look's like he's in roblox?
How?
Because its from 2016
Game name?
Sonic100
I don’t really think open world fits sonic
Its has potential. Just needs to be executed better
Are they free
Yes. What Sonic fan-game you have to pay for? It’s illegal to do that
@@Sonic_Beyond ok thanks
Batman UA-cam Batman
esto me salio traducido xd
Download
Sonic gt is Not a open world sonic Fangame
Uhh Names
i could say i tried to play GHP zone,level looks great.but wait! controling spindash and jump with mouse?!! you really? thats fucked of all game.just why:D
SONIC
Cool
#sonicutopia