I think Johnny does a much better non crazy Broly. But holy hell Vic's psycho Broly is just sooo much better, the laugh and the low raspy voice gives me chills.
No offense to Johnny but the former power ranger amd ichigo does not go with broly lol vic is amd always willbe broly and I wish Monica and all them would get fired for false accusations
I love Johnny Yong Bosch. I think he's one of the best voice actors in the anime dubbing industry. That said, he doesn't fit Z Broly. Either that, or he's trying too hard to impersonate Vic Mignogna instead of giving it his own flavor because he's voiced psychotic characters before and did a fantastic job. Now Super Broly is a very different story. His Super Broly is absolutely incredible. I can't wait to see him in Super Heros.
@@guilmonbread0019 true but he does match Vic’s energy especially for base Broly specifically for me, but all they gotta do is edit the voice to sound a bit deeper to get the tone right, (for z Broly that is, they can leave him with his normal voice with super Broly)
Vic is Broly, plain and simple. He is the literal embodiment of the character. Vic even hit a new level and the Super Broly actually sounded different from Z Broly, which is insane. Johnny Yong Bosch is amazing but he is Nero and Icihigo, thats literally all I hear
He sounds like a angsty teenager, idk what people are saying about how it’s better, it’s just hard imagining a beefy beast man sounding like a teen which doesn’t fit because he’s in his late 40s
Well Johnny is okay but I think Vic still takes on BOTH Brolys (Edit: you can't be nearly 10 ft with the muscles of a monster truck and have a high voice)
@Diogo Does nowhere near appy to DragonBall, Broly is a 10ft bloodthirsty Saiyan with Bulk muscles, he deserves Vic again than some guy who screams like a Teen
While Johnny is overall a better voice for anime, he simply does NOT fit Broly... His lighter voice doesn't feel right at all with the big body. Its like watching Pica from One Piece...
Both Johnny and Victor are awesome and great in their own ways, but I also feel really sorry for Victor because of the whole allegation situation that's been going on lately. Plus, Johnny and Victor are both nice guys in real life and they stayed in character really well as they both did their jobs as actors professionally for all of us viewers alike. I have respect for both of them.
@@Bitch_senpai Goku’s an alien. Plus, Nozawa’s obviously not as spry with her voice as she was three decades ago when Z was first airing. People who don’t like her base their opinions off of her performances in the newer material.
Johnny is an incredible VA but Vic matched the evil version of Broly way better. Especially when talking normally and not screaming, he just sounds more powerful
I love johnny as a voice actor and everything hes in. But everytime I hear his broly lines(z or super) all I hear is an angry ichigo. Vic is the perfect broly for both versions
I feel like Vic fits them both more, he's done several characters that show a soft side but then also show a rage to them. He fits as the scared, child-like broly so well and the raging one too. Johnny is good in his own right, but I feel like Vic has some sort of connection with him.
Vic is known for having such a light voice (like Edward in FMA) but when he does Broly he digs deep and gives a really amazing dynamic showing how much Broly has transformed. Johnny just sounds like himself, then an angrier version of himself. The dynamic isn't there and as a result he sounds a little wimpy. I see a lot of people say Johnny is copying Vic but I'd say he isn't copying him at all. He is just doing Johnny like he always does when a Broly character needs a bit more sauce. And I say this as a huge fan of Johnny.
Vic is the true Broly! Johnny is an amazing voice actor love his voice acting work as Nero and Ichigo. He can do the soft base form super Broly voice but once Broly starts raging out his voice doesn’t fit. His Z broly voice absolutely doesn’t fit tho wish they just kept Vic for Z voice at least in the games
Vic's Z Broly Voice is GOATED💯 i can't lie i Legit marked out hearing that menacing laugh and the "Not Until You Lie Dead At My Feet" Quote from Second Coming its the way how softly and viciously cruel he says it, Too fucking epic man
When did Bosch voice these lines for these Broly movies? I know that he's the new voice actor for him but i didn't know that they redubbed the movies or whatever they did.
I can't really remember when. I think it was before the movie came out and when Funimation fired Vic due to some Sexual harassment or assault allegations.
I keep hearing Nero or Ichigo's voice in JYB. Its hard to see him as Broly now. Funimation would have been disgraced had they not fired Vic unfortunately. Now they need Linda Young back as Frieza.
Vic is THE Z Broly to me. Yes there is a nostalgia bias, but the inflections Vic gives Z Broly especially in the first 2 films vs his more modern, just captures the crazed Legendary Super Saiyan more. Who can forget that crazed laugh Vic did in Second Coming?
When it can down to super Broly they both honestly sound very good and can be compared subjectively and even objectively, but when it comes to Z Broly it’s night and day. victor has an incredibly sinister connection with Z broly and it’s amazing
I think Johnny works well or well enough for DBS Broly(at the very least, a better replacement than the guy RT got for Qrow). Z Broly goes to Vic all the way though.
Blame Crunchyroll (Formerly Funimation) for firing him based on hearsay with no evidence or police reports to back it up. Jamie Marchi and Monica Rial fired him because he's an outspoken and open Christian.
Its interesting, vics natural voice is much lighter and sounds thinner than Johnny's natural voice. However vics voice goes reallly deep when screaming its very impressive.
I think both do a great job. My only gripe with Johnny is his attack vocals. It's like he's going back to his days as Hollow Ichigo (My favorite fight from bleach, btw)
I will admit I didn’t really grow up with Z movies, so I haven’t watched them enough to pick up on the big differences between the two VAs that a lot people see. That being said, I think Bosch does an amazing and I really can’t tell the difference between the two especially with DBS Broly
Nothing against Johnny, I just feel that this particular type of character isn't his strong suit. Like it just feels out of place for him. He's played several characters perfectly like Vergil, Ichigo, and similar style of characters. It's just with big characters like Broly with raw and powerful voices, the voice itself has to be violent and visceral just like how Vic does it. When you hear Vic, you know it's not an actor playing Broly, that IS Broly talking.
must say both sound mint but got to say there is alot of originality with vic mignogna voices DBZ broly you get crazy, but also DBS you get a more down to earth and now Johnny Yong Bosch ..... the roar just gives me ichigo vibs now im just waiting for him to say banki love his voice but ....
Johnny is the voice of ichigo and I hear ichigo in everything he does. Not saying he’s bad or anything be his broke isn’t that bad. I just like Vic as broly better. His jovial broly sounds a bit less naive and his evil broly is ferocious.
I really like JYB as new broly since he has an innocence to his voice that fits that version of him but no way the og doesnt sound that good with Johnny.
You know what's weird Ezra still played the flash in the latest movie, but vic didn't return for super broly If Ezra can come back with all the sh*t he's done, you'd think vic would get a chance to keep his role
Vic isn’t just the far superior Broly, he has possibly my favorite English voice in Anime. Funny how other VA’s have actually assaulted people and still have their job but Vic was terminated.
Bosch sounds younger. I'm used to Bosch S Broly and Vic Z Broly (their FighterZ voices) so it sounds weird for S Broly to sound his age (48 in his movie) or for Z Broly to not sound like he's wider than I am tall
Actually it was Toei themselves that wanted Johnny. Not Funimation. Johnny originally wasn't going to take the role cause everything going on. Plus he's on good terms with Vic. But people were talking shit (funimation) saying he couldn't do it. So I think it was a few months later and after talking to Vic. He decided to show his stuff to the ones who talked shit.
2:36 THIS can only Vic do....
vic just SOUNDS crazy. i’ll forever miss vic.
Blame Jamie and Monica.
@@davidtimmer596DAMN IT!
Oh my Lord can someone tell me who’s who!???? Who did the first Broly movie ??? The original non cannon Broly movie.. who voiced that movie???
@@troyo3172 Vic Mignogna
@@mythrul9362 damn he’s the Goat🐐 went crazy when he turned legendary ss insane 🔥
the broly laugh that vic does sounds so sinister and full of pure enjoyment i love it
It's so fucking good
I think Johnny does a much better non crazy Broly.
But holy hell Vic's psycho Broly is just sooo much better, the laugh and the low raspy voice gives me chills.
Johnny is one of the best VA's we have and ik ill probably like him as Broly since he's so talented but Broly and Vic go together. Forever.
I'm not feeling his saiyan roars at all with Johnny
@@MrZayJamesyeah same, I can’t it reminds me of a angsty teen, at least a teen broly trying
@@Mat_mep its Deadweight from Devil May (Become a) Deadweight
johnny sucks
Slam dunk!
Its crazy how the same guy who voiced fucking Broly sang the English version for Dan Dan Kokoro Hikareteku💀
And dbz kai too 💀 like how coulde he voice a crazy evil saiyan and sing those happy hype light songs
2:43 Oh god Vic that was amazing!
I like them both as DBS Broly but Vic takes Z Broly with ease
I think Vic’s better for a more brutal version like Z and Johnnys better for the gentle giant super version
@@jdingonyama agreed, Johnny as Z Broly sounds...wrong
@@shelf_manager yeah. Don’t get me wrong I love Johnny but his voice is too soothing? To be Z Broly
Johnny uses the same voice for both even though they are very different characters and there personalities deserve different voices
Idk, I like both for Johnny, well for base Z Broly atleast, because LSSJ Broly is more to Vic
You can’t replace Vic the legend himself
No offense to Johnny but the former power ranger amd ichigo does not go with broly lol vic is amd always willbe broly and I wish Monica and all them would get fired for false accusations
No one can replicate that eerie tone of Vic’s voice
I love Johnny Yong Bosch. I think he's one of the best voice actors in the anime dubbing industry. That said, he doesn't fit Z Broly. Either that, or he's trying too hard to impersonate Vic Mignogna instead of giving it his own flavor because he's voiced psychotic characters before and did a fantastic job. Now Super Broly is a very different story. His Super Broly is absolutely incredible. I can't wait to see him in Super Heros.
I can. Still boycotting them. Can't support that shit company.
Johnny Yong Bosch's voice isn't deep enough to match Broly.
@@guilmonbread0019 true but he does match Vic’s energy especially for base Broly specifically for me, but all they gotta do is edit the voice to sound a bit deeper to get the tone right, (for z Broly that is, they can leave him with his normal voice with super Broly)
I think it's because broly in Z is WAY more menacing and vic shows that while Johnny has a more innocent tone fitting the less enraged broly.
Vic himself did pass the torch to Johnny and knows that he won’t backstab him
Vic mignogna's OG broly gave me chills what a ruthless character.
If Johnny tries not doing a Vic impression he might pull it off
Fancy seeing you hear
Agreed
Idk I think he sounds pretty good
His screams sounds too much like he's trying to voice act ichigo
@@crimsonsomethingi wonder why
Vic is Broly, plain and simple. He is the literal embodiment of the character. Vic even hit a new level and the Super Broly actually sounded different from Z Broly, which is insane.
Johnny Yong Bosch is amazing but he is Nero and Icihigo, thats literally all I hear
Johnny's much better as DBS Broly than Z Broly, but Vic's better as both
it's shame about the whole situation with him regardless
He sounds like a angsty teenager, idk what people are saying about how it’s better, it’s just hard imagining a beefy beast man sounding like a teen which doesn’t fit because he’s in his late 40s
@@Mat_mep Broly is a teen
@@another3166 Broly is the same age as Goku and Vegeta lol
Shut up fake fan jyb broly voice is just terrible i mean if he can voice broly i can do it to
@@another3166 broly and goku were legit born on the same day did you not watch the movies lmao
Vic is just so good as broly
Vic Migongna would be an amazing Venom Using his broly voice.
There was video doing Broly as venom
Well Johnny is okay but I think Vic still takes on BOTH Brolys
(Edit: you can't be nearly 10 ft with the muscles of a monster truck and have a high voice)
Agreed
I fully 1000000% agree woth you same thing woth gohan (sayn saga to the cell saga)
Listen to Brock Lesnar speak
@@glydoughnut9432 Thats Brock Lesnar (real man) VS the voice of an anime Demon saiyan. Not the same topic
@Diogo Does nowhere near appy to DragonBall, Broly is a 10ft bloodthirsty Saiyan with Bulk muscles, he deserves Vic again than some guy who screams like a Teen
While Johnny is overall a better voice for anime, he simply does NOT fit Broly...
His lighter voice doesn't feel right at all with the big body.
Its like watching Pica from One Piece...
Pica form one piece….. be serious he is the best option to replace Vic
@@hellodigitalworld8224 Stfu. No he isn't.
@hellodigitalworld8224 no one is better than vic, but johnny was the best replacement
Vic sounds better he has a more mature roar and scream tbh
I think Johnny would fit DBS Broly.
and Vic would fit DBZ Broly, but I miss Vic.
When Johnny's voicing broly he just sounds like Ichigo but Vic will forever remain a legend
Both Johnny and Victor are awesome and great in their own ways, but I also feel really sorry for Victor because of the whole allegation situation that's been going on lately.
Plus, Johnny and Victor are both nice guys in real life and they stayed in character really well as they both did their jobs as actors professionally for all of us viewers alike. I have respect for both of them.
I can’t imagine a beefy giant of a man to kinda sound like angry teenager, it kinda doesn’t fit with it, especially when he’s in his 40s
Meanwhile Goku sub lol
@@Bitch_senpai thing is, his voice actress is like twice his age😂
They age differently
@@Bitch_senpai Goku’s an alien. Plus, Nozawa’s obviously not as spry with her voice as she was three decades ago when Z was first airing. People who don’t like her base their opinions off of her performances in the newer material.
I actually really like Johnnys screaming and battle noise nails that stuff, the speaking can use abit more gravel in the voice
Johnny is an incredible VA but Vic matched the evil version of Broly way better. Especially when talking normally and not screaming, he just sounds more powerful
Nobody else does broly like Vic, literally unreplacable, the best in the world
That line will forever be ingrained in my brain "Not until you lay dead at my feet"
I love johnny as a voice actor and everything hes in. But everytime I hear his broly lines(z or super) all I hear is an angry ichigo. Vic is the perfect broly for both versions
Johnny is one of my all time favourite VA's, but god damn it.. it can be hard not to hear Ichigo sometimes
Or Vash the Stampede
I agree. Johnny to me is always going to be Ichigo.
Vic will always to me be Broly. Never has a voice fit a character so perfectly.
I feel like Vic fits them both more, he's done several characters that show a soft side but then also show a rage to them. He fits as the scared, child-like broly so well and the raging one too. Johnny is good in his own right, but I feel like Vic has some sort of connection with him.
Vic is known for having such a light voice (like Edward in FMA) but when he does Broly he digs deep and gives a really amazing dynamic showing how much Broly has transformed. Johnny just sounds like himself, then an angrier version of himself. The dynamic isn't there and as a result he sounds a little wimpy. I see a lot of people say Johnny is copying Vic but I'd say he isn't copying him at all. He is just doing Johnny like he always does when a Broly character needs a bit more sauce. And I say this as a huge fan of Johnny.
Also, Vic gave Johnny his blessing.
Vic is the true Broly! Johnny is an amazing voice actor love his voice acting work as Nero and Ichigo. He can do the soft base form super Broly voice but once Broly starts raging out his voice doesn’t fit. His Z broly voice absolutely doesn’t fit tho wish they just kept Vic for Z voice at least in the games
They need to bring Vic back. He’s just the best at Broly.
Thank you so much for adding the voice lines from Legends and Dokkan Battle!
You forgot xenoverse 2 voice lines
Vic's Z Broly Voice is GOATED💯 i can't lie i Legit marked out hearing that menacing laugh and the "Not Until You Lie Dead At My Feet" Quote from Second Coming its the way how softly and viciously cruel he says it, Too fucking epic man
Bosch doesn't sound good in Z broly. He sounds like a teenage Brody than a adult broly
As Z Broly, he doesn't sound evil.
I’m glad somebody said it!
Vic is just superior
everytime i hear johnnys voice it always reminds me of his role as nero in dmc 4 n 5. i just cant unhear it, too iconic
Vic has that slight bass in his voice that fits Broly so well.
Vic is Broly forever
Love both VAs but Vic on top
When did Bosch voice these lines for these Broly movies? I know that he's the new voice actor for him but i didn't know that they redubbed the movies or whatever they did.
I can't really remember when. I think it was before the movie came out and when Funimation fired Vic due to some Sexual harassment or assault allegations.
He didn't. Only in the DragonBall Fighter Z game. Bosch voice the DBS Broly in the game
I like Johnny as the new voice for broly still sad about the whole Vic situation
I keep hearing Nero or Ichigo's voice in JYB. Its hard to see him as Broly now. Funimation would have been disgraced had they not fired Vic unfortunately. Now they need Linda Young back as Frieza.
Dbs broly
“You shouldn’t say those things about my father.”
Dbz broly
*Cutely flattens father and throws him out of the atmosphere*
Vic's voice just inarguably has the most Bass and straight up menace.
Vic is so much better it’s not even close 🥱🥱
Vic is THE Z Broly to me. Yes there is a nostalgia bias, but the inflections Vic gives Z Broly especially in the first 2 films vs his more modern, just captures the crazed Legendary Super Saiyan more. Who can forget that crazed laugh Vic did in Second Coming?
Both voices are good. Johnny Yong Bosch’s voice has a bit more aggression to it, and Vic Mignogna’s voice sounds more calmer.
Man I LOVE Johnny, but fr please bring back Vic for Broly!!!!! He's iconic!!!
Vic is Broly.
Laughing
Screaming
Talking
Everything.
Dialogue wise: They both have their own thing and their both great.
Battle Cries and yells: The OG wins.
When it can down to super Broly they both honestly sound very good and can be compared subjectively and even objectively, but when it comes to Z Broly it’s night and day. victor has an incredibly sinister connection with Z broly and it’s amazing
I think Johnny works well or well enough for DBS Broly(at the very least, a better replacement than the guy RT got for Qrow). Z Broly goes to Vic all the way though.
Vic Mignona broly voice was so perfectly adapted
VIC MIGNOGNA hands down no debate!!
Why vic's super broly voice is so sexy and when when he speaks his normal voice he just sounds so sweet i could get diabetes. ❤
There's no denying that Johnny is an amazing talent. But in my opinion Vic and broly are just synonymous with each other at this point.
Whenever Johnny screams i just hear Nero lmao
Vic just has the perfect grumble
Jonny voice is too light or high pitch
I will forever miss Vic Mignogna, both as Broly and as Qrow Braunwen
Blame Crunchyroll (Formerly Funimation) for firing him based on hearsay with no evidence or police reports to back it up. Jamie Marchi and Monica Rial fired him because he's an outspoken and open Christian.
Broly is Vic, Vic is Broly. That's how it will always be.
Its interesting, vics natural voice is much lighter and sounds thinner than Johnny's natural voice. However vics voice goes reallly deep when screaming its very impressive.
Vic the goat
I think both do a great job. My only gripe with Johnny is his attack vocals. It's like he's going back to his days as Hollow Ichigo (My favorite fight from bleach, btw)
I will always miss Vic
I will admit I didn’t really grow up with Z movies, so I haven’t watched them enough to pick up on the big differences between the two VAs that a lot people see. That being said, I think Bosch does an amazing and I really can’t tell the difference between the two especially with DBS Broly
Vic is really good at that Broly voice
I think they're both great Broly VCs
I didn't know Nero from (Devil may cry 5) / Ichigo from (Bleach) were doing Broly try outs 🤣🤣. U have to love Johnny Yong
I like Vic's screams and laughs as Broly better, But when both Johnny and Vic do the speaking voice that a similar
Love my boi Johnny Yong Bosch yeah this is a good change not gonna sweat it
Vic is my broly forever 😢
Nothing against Johnny, I just feel that this particular type of character isn't his strong suit. Like it just feels out of place for him. He's played several characters perfectly like Vergil, Ichigo, and similar style of characters. It's just with big characters like Broly with raw and powerful voices, the voice itself has to be violent and visceral just like how Vic does it. When you hear Vic, you know it's not an actor playing Broly, that IS Broly talking.
Johnny voices Nero, not Vergil
He's also Lelouch
I don't think Johnny chose this role out of his own will. I think Funimation are the ones that approached him. Just my theory
@@whiterabbit8243 Vic gave Johnny his blessing.
must say both sound mint but got to say there is alot of originality with vic mignogna voices DBZ broly you get crazy, but also DBS you get a more down to earth and now Johnny Yong Bosch ..... the roar just gives me ichigo vibs now im just waiting for him to say banki love his voice but ....
Johnny is the voice of ichigo and I hear ichigo in everything he does. Not saying he’s bad or anything be his broke isn’t that bad. I just like Vic as broly better. His jovial broly sounds a bit less naive and his evil broly is ferocious.
Sad that we live in a world where people get canceled Vic will forever be broly no one does it better
I have massive respect to both broly VA but I personally think vic is the perfect z broly and none can replace him
I was today years old when I found out this broly shares a voice actor with Jonathan Joestar
Vic is too good😊
Vic is coming to my city in a week, so I'm definitely taking my SH figuarts broly to get signed
Johnny sounds good as Super Broly and I love Vic for Z Broly
I really like JYB as new broly since he has an innocence to his voice that fits that version of him but no way the og doesnt sound that good with Johnny.
Vic Mignogna's Broly is like a mix of Frank Welker's Megatron and Hugo Weaving's Megatron.
You know what's weird
Ezra still played the flash in the latest movie, but vic didn't return for super broly
If Ezra can come back with all the sh*t he's done, you'd think vic would get a chance to keep his role
Vic isn’t just the far superior Broly, he has possibly my favorite English voice in Anime. Funny how other VA’s have actually assaulted people and still have their job but Vic was terminated.
Johnny is a fucking legend, Nero, ichigo and broly. Holy shit is this guy good
He was also the black Power Ranger
VIC FOR PRESIDENT
2:29 😢
Honestly, they made the right decision by changing Broly in DBS, Johnny’s voice sounds like if DBZ Broly was young.
that's crazy. I remembered that Nero is voiced by Johnny and now when I hear broly it sounds like Nero.
Bosch sounds younger.
I'm used to Bosch S Broly and Vic Z Broly (their FighterZ voices) so it sounds weird for S Broly to sound his age (48 in his movie) or for Z Broly to not sound like he's wider than I am tall
Who would’ve known, a Power Ranger was also a scary ass Saiyan.
It made me laugh so hard when Johnny got the role. It figures they'd pick someone I CANT be mad about lol. Well played Cuntimation, well played.
Actually it was Toei themselves that wanted Johnny. Not Funimation. Johnny originally wasn't going to take the role cause everything going on. Plus he's on good terms with Vic. But people were talking shit (funimation) saying he couldn't do it. So I think it was a few months later and after talking to Vic. He decided to show his stuff to the ones who talked shit.
Did Vic voice Super Broly in Xenoverse 2? The yelling ones with Vic highlighted sound exactly like ones in Xenoverse 2
Johnny’s a great VA, he’ll do a great job. Still infuriated over what happened to Vic though.
1:11 LL limited broly popping his quirk skill be like
I actually really like Johnny as Super Broly.
Broly deserves a slightly deeper voice. Something that vic has only done
Love Johnny Young Bosh, but whenever I hear his Broly I'm constantly expecting a Getsuga Tensho or Bankai.