Well, I'm fan of Minnie, and comparing this to other songs were Minnie barely had lines(She had 2 in hann if I remember well, 3 or 4 in latata and 2 we're the same so yeah-), it's okay. But yeah, pretty unfair
@@whitephoenix2484 yes , she improved her stage presence and thats good but her vocals hasnt improved. Or at least , its just isnt big enough to be noticeable
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc i think she did tbh , her pronounciation got slightly better and her range also got better. Confidence also takes part in her vocals and now that she is more confident she has slightly improved her vocals. But mostly stage presence , Shuhua hasnt improved all that much on singing ability
I love Minnie and her vocals, not to mention Soyeon's rap, but even I agree that Soojin's lines should have been taken by Yuqi and Miyeon, they literally shared the one same part in the original song
@@seosoojinstan actually she is great in korean now and did sing soojin lines in hwaa and oh my god there is literally no reason she couldnt have done them now... shes improved alot in korean and deserved soojins lines more then the people who ALREADY had a shit load of lines soyeon and minnie DID NOT need anymore lines then they already had, the company couldve at least gave soojins 3 lines to the 3 members who didnt have any lines like shuhua yuqi and miyeon.
In my opinion should have been like this 0:29 Should've been Shuhua's part 1:34 I think Soyeon singing this part is okay 2:09 I think it would be cool if every member was singing this part like a voice combination but it would sound bad then 3:11 Yuqi would slay this part in my opinion
Imo idle didn’t gave the line w/o any reason. You know how Soyeon gives a lot of importance in voice/line/vibe. I think they shared it w who was more able to « recreate » soojin’s energy in each line. 🙂 we still gonna listen to OT6 and ONLY OT6 tho 🤍
Minnie gets too many lines... and Yuqi & Miyeon always the shortest and most repetitive parts thier vocals are being wasted... and Soyeon should give some of her vocal lines to the others and fucos more on rapping
positions de acordo com as linhas OT5 e OT6 OT5 Miyeon: Main to Sub vocalist,Visual Minnie: Main to supreme Vocalist,Dancer Soyeon:Main rapper,sub to lead vocalist,Lead dancer and Leader Yuqi:Lead to guia vocalist,Main dancer Shuhua: Background Vocalist, Visual,Maknae Ot6 Miyeon:Main Vocalist,Visual Minnie:Main vocalist soojin: Lead rapper,Sub vocalist,main dancer Soyeon:Leader,Main rapper,Vocalist, Center Yuqi: Lead rapper,Lead vocal and Lead dancer Shuhua: Visual and maknae and vocalist
They should have given Soojin's post chorus to Miyeon, atleast that have been a lil more fair or they could have given the post chorus to Yuqi and the outro to Miyeon
@@ariana.chanel_ that she was kicked out of the group and even the members miss her. i dont find a reason why we should start erasing her from her own songs
@@cottoncandyflavouredicecream it’s not like the fan did it Gidle themselves did the performance covering soojins lines, plus the ot6 version is still Available I don’t find it odd how they are doing it without her it’s not like their gonna hold back from performing those songs just bc of soojin
Original ver - so fair
This ver - so unfair
I agree
I agree too much
Well, I'm fan of Minnie, and comparing this to other songs were Minnie barely had lines(She had 2 in hann if I remember well, 3 or 4 in latata and 2 we're the same so yeah-), it's okay. But yeah, pretty unfair
All soojin part covered by Minnie exclude at second verse by Soyeon
I wish they'd give Soojin's closing line to Shuhua instead of havingMinnie sing it again but other than that, it's pretty good I'd say.
Shuhua is to afraid and not a good vocal she probably didnt want it anyway
@@beroliceberry1224 youre wrong lol shuhua literally did soojins oh my god line and hwaa lines SOOOO good no reason she couldnt also do lion
@@blondeshuhua_ shuhua didn't improve, we just didn't hear her sing fully before
@@whitephoenix2484 yes , she improved her stage presence and thats good but her vocals hasnt improved. Or at least , its just isnt big enough to be noticeable
@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc i think she did tbh , her pronounciation got slightly better and her range also got better. Confidence also takes part in her vocals and now that she is more confident she has slightly improved her vocals. But mostly stage presence , Shuhua hasnt improved all that much on singing ability
I love Minnie and her vocals, not to mention Soyeon's rap, but even I agree that Soojin's lines should have been taken by Yuqi and Miyeon, they literally shared the one same part in the original song
I love it!!! the girls slayed and sound amazing as always!
ot6 forever sorry not sorry :P
yes
miss soojin
You know they should've give Soojin's lines to Miyeon or Yuqi even if they are 5 now Miyeon is still the least in everything
Миëн слабая запаха не смеши
@@K_op518 what
@@icxuna I'm saying she's not weak
@@K_op518 when did I ever say anyone is weak?
The OT6 Line Distribution is better
not too much
1:05 when a member already hits 30 secs while a member isn't singing yet
👁️👄👁️
Everglow 2.0
@@j.h.o.o.f.f.i.c.i.a.l😂😂😂😂😂😂So funny
seriously ? they gave Soojin's lines to the ones who already sing the most...
I don't know if I have to remember, but Shuhua is afraid to sing because he suffered in the Hann era because of so much hate she took
@@seosoojinstan actually she is great in korean now and did sing soojin lines in hwaa and oh my god there is literally no reason she couldnt have done them now... shes improved alot in korean and deserved soojins lines more then the people who ALREADY had a shit load of lines
soyeon and minnie DID NOT need anymore lines then they already had, the company couldve at least gave soojins 3 lines to the 3 members who didnt have any lines like shuhua yuqi and miyeon.
@@jupiterunknown1363 thx
Shuhua directly sang after Soojin previously........
@@smpsmp3808 that one line was not soojins only line.
Soojin leaving made unfair songs really fair and fair songs so unfair
In my opinion should have been like this
0:29 Should've been Shuhua's part
1:34 I think Soyeon singing this part is okay
2:09 I think it would be cool if every member was singing this part like a voice combination but it would sound bad then
3:11 Yuqi would slay this part in my opinion
miyeon being sub-vocalist and soyeon being lead-vocalist👁️👄👁️
Wdym?
@@StarNayeon_ don't you get it??
@@jaeeun0-0 is it because of the line Distribution?
@@StarNayeon_ yass obviously??
Miyeon has a part in all chorus and another at the end
so basically ot5 ld's is giving sj lines to those who already got the most lines so the gap is bigger
*"Eh oh" was sung by Yuqi after each chorus.*
Minnir voice so good line
Imo idle didn’t gave the line w/o any reason. You know how Soyeon gives a lot of importance in voice/line/vibe. I think they shared it w who was more able to « recreate » soojin’s energy in each line. 🙂 we still gonna listen to OT6 and ONLY OT6 tho 🤍
Minnie gets too many lines... and Yuqi & Miyeon always the shortest and most repetitive parts thier vocals are being wasted... and Soyeon should give some of her vocal lines to the others and fucos more on rapping
Shuhua for once gets DECENT lines and you complain about the others? Damned if you do, damned if you don't, ffs...
@@raidenthenctzenwithinsomni4961 PREECH
Facts
@@raidenthenctzenwithinsomni4961 you're gonna tell me this is still fair???
3:12 imagine Yuqi having this part, she would slay
positions de acordo com as linhas OT5 e OT6
OT5
Miyeon: Main to Sub vocalist,Visual
Minnie: Main to supreme Vocalist,Dancer
Soyeon:Main rapper,sub to lead vocalist,Lead dancer and Leader
Yuqi:Lead to guia vocalist,Main dancer
Shuhua: Background Vocalist, Visual,Maknae
Ot6
Miyeon:Main Vocalist,Visual
Minnie:Main vocalist
soojin: Lead rapper,Sub vocalist,main dancer
Soyeon:Leader,Main rapper,Vocalist, Center
Yuqi: Lead rapper,Lead vocal and Lead dancer
Shuhua: Visual and maknae and vocalist
Nice
No one:
Shuhua:Putanginamo(Iykyk
They should have given Soojin's post chorus to Miyeon, atleast that have been a lil more fair or they could have given the post chorus to Yuqi and the outro to Miyeon
Ot6 very better than ot 5
Ya parece solo de Minnie.
0:29 tenía que haber sido de shuhua 😢
Why give Soojin's lines to 💲l⛎✝️✝️y Minnie and w♓🅾️®️3️⃣ Soyeon? She had 4 strophes (two verses, one chorus and outro), could have given them to Miyeon and Yuqi. Or given the verses to them two, the chorus to Shuhua or Soyeon and the outro to Minnie instead of focusing on two 🅱️ℹ️✝️©️♓3️⃣💲
That last part shoulda gone to Yuqi 😡
why do yall feel the urge to erase soojins image so bad...
wdym?
@@ariana.chanel_ that she was kicked out of the group and even the members miss her. i dont find a reason why we should start erasing her from her own songs
@@cottoncandyflavouredicecream it’s not like the fan did it Gidle themselves did the performance covering soojins lines, plus the ot6 version is still Available I don’t find it odd how they are doing it without her it’s not like their gonna hold back from performing those songs just bc of soojin
Con soyeon làm main vocal được rồi
Que horrible distribución 😑