You are a brilliant communicator! I absolutely love and appreciate the methodical, step by step way you deliver information. I bet you could describe paint drying and I'd hang on to your every word!
Wow, this was SO informative!!! I loved the quiz, and wasn’t surprised I scored high on the Charlotte Mason/Unschooling approaches, which is definitely how our homeschool functions. We’re on a homestead, so my husband and I really appreciate that a lot of the learning our children do is outside on their own as they climb trees, explore nature, and spend time with our animals, but we love the SCM materials because they keep us focused on the learning that needs to be done- in short and interesting lessons and with a focus on character development. Thank you, Sonya, for this detailed, unbiased, and succinct overview on all the methods out there. I’m sharing this with all the new homeschooling Moms I know.
@@AEBaughm You'll definitely benefit from the quiz! Look in the description; it's the handout she has that you can download. Or if you go to 11:18 she gives the quiz there. It would be so beneficial for you to do that starting out your first year. I wish you the best in your homeschool journey!
Thanks so much! I jumped the gun & didn't watch all the way to that point until the next day :) I've told several people to take a watch of THIS video. Such a weird time in history, but maybe the PERFECT time to try on hs-ing for my fam
As a new homeschooling mom about to start my journey, I really appreciated this video, you helped me understand every "flavor" of homeschooling so well!
I watched this same video title recently that was published 6 years ago, so I wasn’t sure whether I wanted to watch this one “again”. But ooohhhh, I am so happy I did. You added the curriculum piece at the end that I am thankful for. Plus, it was just so helpful to hear the information again in a condensed, yet expanded way. Thank you very much.
I loved this so much. It was very helpful. And I really appreciate your information on all if the methods while keeping respect for all of the "flavors".
This was so helpful and clearly described. I think my flavor has changed and shifted. I’m going to share this video as it was informative and encouraging!
Thank you for these explanations! I've had a hard time getting away from the idea of there being a "right way," but when you frame it as working toward goals for your family and children, it just makes sense that everyone will be different in their approach.
Thank you for this clear and precise comparison and especially for the test! The test might be really helpful both for beginners in homeschooling and for those who have some experience already. And also thank you for the soft and pleasant manner of your speech - that is a real encouragement and a source of inspiration!❤
I wonder why you chose some curricula to include on the list and not others. Ambleside Online, Charlotte Mason Institute, A Modern Charlotte Mason, A Delectable Education, Sabbathmood Homeschool, Charlotte Mason Plenary, Wildwood Curriculum are well known CM options. I believe Bookshark and Build your Library are CM inspired. They definitely include living books and narration and spear dig the feast. The Good and the Beautiful combines Charlotte Mason and Traditional. Wayfarers is a Classical Charlotte Mason hybrid. I wonder where Waldorf would fall-Waldorf Essentials, Live Education, and Lavender's Blue Homeschool. It does use block scheduling and lessons are integrated, so perhaps closer to Unit Studies? But it also uses living books and narration-at first summary and then narration begins in grade 3. The first 3 years are focussed on foundational academic skills and then the subjects are added in grades 4 and up. It's very focussed on developmental concerns, so certainly more growth oriented, but more doing than CM. those early years on up also include more movement exercises than CM many of which DD has done in OT. Maybe unit studies and Charlotte Mason I wonder where Montessori would fall. in elementary the teacher or guide tells a series of stories to inspire the curiosity of the students and they do research and projects from there. there is a semi-sequential set of Math materials and some language arts that's required. No textbooks. Maybe it would be close to unschooling or unit studies or a blend of these 2? The definitely involve a lot of doing and there is a curriculum the teacher guides the students through, but the order they do things in has some flexibility. TJED and the Sudbury school are democratic methods of education. Sudbury is very much in line with unschooling. I don't know a lit about TJEd but I know it involves teachers as mentors and guides and is student interest inspired. I find it valuable to note that Classical is actually a label shared by 2 methods, Neo-classical made popular by Dorothy Sayers and the Trivium. And Ancient which emphasizes Socratic method and rhetoric. And Classical Conversations is classical in name but misses the heart of either int eh same way that Masterbooks calls itself Charlotte Mason because it uses narrative to teach math. They both borrow elements from the methods they espouse to be, but miss the mark.
@@Volkfire Charlotte Mason Method isn't religious, no method is. Philosophy y can be-CM was Anglican, Montessori was Catholic with Hindu influence, Steiner was an anthroposophist and their religion seeps through because its part of who they are, but they aren't preaching it. The curricula vary, . Wildwood Curriculum advertises them selves as secular. I couldn't say about the others.
As a new homeschooling family, this video was very informative and helpful. Thank you for the quiz which was very helpful! Thank you for taking the time to give information on all approaches.
Thank you so much for this helpful video! You are so great at explaining things in a very simple, thorough way! I appreciate your time to record this for all the newbies out there! :)
I desire the ready to go method. Thanks Simply Charlotte Mason for your lesson plans, I love them! I was thinking of a 6th flavor. It’s more for younger kids, Montessori. I’d like to see a video doing a comparison of those two methods too.
I think I have been doing a little bit of everything altogether all this time without me knowing how they are called. Hahaha This is ssssuupppeeerrr helpful for me, I have a toddler he jumps from one topic to another, yet he wants to do something about each one. He also wants to kinda memorize them like the days of week, months, planets. He seems to sometimes want to narrate about them (even if he cannot say so much just yet), he wants to find (hence, I try hard to make them - no choice haha) coloring books or pictures about the topics he is interested in. Reciting or enumerating them does not seem to satisfy him. He wants to sometimes go outside just to see how the moon or starts really look like. So sometimes, I really want to think he leads the topics and pacing of learning as of now yet he wants a whhhooollle lot of variety.
One of the most important aspects of Classical Style, which you missed mentioning, is that the parents spend a couple hours each day READING TO ALL THE CHILDREN. So, in the bagpipes example, not only would the young children be memorizing rote facts about bagpipes, they would also be listening to Mom (or Dad) read books that talk about bagpipes.
Thanks so much for another great video. I appreciate how neutral you are to the various “flavors” of homeschooling. I have one suggestion to improve the quiz: I noticed that there were more answers that would lead to more T's (7) vs Unit (4) or even Living or Unschooling (5 each). A more balanced quiz should probably lead to an even amount of potential answers to each of the 5 flavors. Other than that, I love your videos. They have been so beneficial.
I’m surprised I had more SM than unit study. I’m changing for my youngest because she is so active and loves to read even more than my three older daughters who did mostly Traditional .My oldest is a sophomore in college in Music Ed, my second, who graduated this Spring is not interested in college but my third, who graduates next Spring wants to go to college.
This is a wonderful video. I didn't know traditional and classical methods weren't the same thing. Also (kind of random) I'm wondering if Sonya happens to know ASL?
Hi, Now that you have an idea of what your homeschooling style is, you can try it out with your family and see how it goes! The beauty of homeschool is you can adapt and change gears if you feel that something is not working well for your family.
Thank you! That was just what I was looking for. I do have a question though: is it possible to homeschool while still sending your child to school? As in when, for social acceptability and because of college requirements, you have to send your child to school, but you are dissatisfied with what's being taught and how it's getting taught?
While we do not recommend requiring your student to complete both a traditional school load and a homeschooling load, Sonya discusses ways to use Charlotte's method when you don't homeschool here: ua-cam.com/video/L-b3Ynv2Jug/v-deo.html
I have a question about the book of centuries. I watched your video on them, but didn't see which century to start with. You did mention BC, but how far back do we go?
We start our Book of Centuries resources at Creation, then move forward from there. In the early BC centuries there is less to record, but as you get into time periods around Ancient Egypt where we have better dates, there is more to enter. Our Basic Book of Centuries free download starts at 4000 BC, based on the dates in Ussher's Annals of the World. The My Book of Centuries book starts a Creation - 3001 BC.
N represents unschooling. You can learn more by downloading the handout found here: simplycharlottemason.com/events-speaking/five-flavors-of-homeschooling/
I would greatly disagree with the mom who told you about unschooling. That's just not true. Unschooling is about teaching and training your child HOW to find answers to their questions and help them understand the process of gaining the information they need just as an adult would find information to learn. Unschoolers are not against curriculum. It depends on what your child is trying to do and if they determine curriculum or an instructor is necessary to achieve what they're trying to achieve. The parent is considered a resource manager along with strewing (sprinkling in what the parent would like to expose the child to).
Yeah, it is hard to do a 'test' of styles. It's like classical, people think it's all quizzes and grilling but in reality, it is about learning how to research when young and manipulate ideas in the teen/young adult years. There is a reason so many of the Enlightenment era thinkers were classically trained and sought classical education for their children.
I would buy all audiobooks read by you. I love how you can annunciate everything you say
Yes! I second that! What a contrast to what we normally hear! This is one reason we use the CM method.
Yes!! Great enunciation!!!
Yes agreed.... she is a beautiful speaker...so clear, enthusiastic and not patronising!
I've been wanting that. Please!
Yes!!
This is off topic, but that is a good color for you.
You are a brilliant communicator! I absolutely love and appreciate the methodical, step by step way you deliver information. I bet you could describe paint drying and I'd hang on to your every word!
Wow, this was SO informative!!! I loved the quiz, and wasn’t surprised I scored high on the Charlotte Mason/Unschooling approaches, which is definitely how our homeschool functions. We’re on a homestead, so my husband and I really appreciate that a lot of the learning our children do is outside on their own as they climb trees, explore nature, and spend time with our animals, but we love the SCM materials because they keep us focused on the learning that needs to be done- in short and interesting lessons and with a focus on character development.
Thank you, Sonya, for this detailed, unbiased, and succinct overview on all the methods out there. I’m sharing this with all the new homeschooling Moms I know.
Where do you find the quiz? I'm a potentially a new homeschool parent & very interested!
@@AEBaughm You'll definitely benefit from the quiz! Look in the description; it's the handout she has that you can download. Or if you go to 11:18 she gives the quiz there. It would be so beneficial for you to do that starting out your first year. I wish you the best in your homeschool journey!
Thanks so much! I jumped the gun & didn't watch all the way to that point until the next day :) I've told several people to take a watch of THIS video. Such a weird time in history, but maybe the PERFECT time to try on hs-ing for my fam
Yay! This is going to be great! Sonya is a wonderful presenter. I have been a homeschooler for 21 years and I still learn great things from Sonya
As a new homeschooling mom about to start my journey, I really appreciated this video, you helped me understand every "flavor" of homeschooling so well!
So glad this was helpful to you!
I watched this same video title recently that was published 6 years ago, so I wasn’t sure whether I wanted to watch this one “again”. But ooohhhh, I am so happy I did. You added the curriculum piece at the end that I am thankful for. Plus, it was just so helpful to hear the information again in a condensed, yet expanded way. Thank you very much.
I loved this so much. It was very helpful. And I really appreciate your information on all if the methods while keeping respect for all of the "flavors".
What a wonderful speaking voice! This was very informative. Thank you.
You are so welcome!
This was so helpful and clearly described. I think my flavor has changed and shifted. I’m going to share this video as it was informative and encouraging!
These videos are so informative and inspiring. The presenter's style is pleasant, and I feel that her voice is very calming
Thank you for this video! You've done a great job presenting the different flavours with clarity and grace.
Thank you for these explanations! I've had a hard time getting away from the idea of there being a "right way," but when you frame it as working toward goals for your family and children, it just makes sense that everyone will be different in their approach.
Absolutely! Thank you for joining us and participating in this conversation!
This was an absolutely lovely video! Thank you so much for your articulate help! I’m going to share
I think I lean towards a pretty eclectic style!
It is a helpful starting off point for us all to understand which approach fits us best!
Thank you for this clear and precise comparison and especially for the test! The test might be really helpful both for beginners in homeschooling and for those who have some experience already.
And also thank you for the soft and pleasant manner of your speech - that is a real encouragement and a source of inspiration!❤
Glad it was helpful! Thank you for your kid words!
I wonder why you chose some curricula to include on the list and not others. Ambleside Online, Charlotte Mason Institute, A Modern Charlotte Mason, A Delectable Education, Sabbathmood Homeschool, Charlotte Mason Plenary, Wildwood Curriculum are well known CM options.
I believe Bookshark and Build your Library are CM inspired. They definitely include living books and narration and spear dig the feast.
The Good and the Beautiful combines Charlotte Mason and Traditional. Wayfarers is a Classical Charlotte Mason hybrid.
I wonder where Waldorf would fall-Waldorf Essentials, Live Education, and Lavender's Blue Homeschool. It does use block scheduling and lessons are integrated, so perhaps closer to Unit Studies? But it also uses living books and narration-at first summary and then narration begins in grade 3. The first 3 years are focussed on foundational academic skills and then the subjects are added in grades 4 and up. It's very focussed on developmental concerns, so certainly more growth oriented, but more doing than CM. those early years on up also include more movement exercises than CM many of which DD has done in OT. Maybe unit studies and Charlotte Mason
I wonder where Montessori would fall. in elementary the teacher or guide tells a series of stories to inspire the curiosity of the students and they do research and projects from there. there is a semi-sequential set of Math materials and some language arts that's required. No textbooks. Maybe it would be close to unschooling or unit studies or a blend of these 2? The definitely involve a lot of doing and there is a curriculum the teacher guides the students through, but the order they do things in has some flexibility.
TJED and the Sudbury school are democratic methods of education. Sudbury is very much in line with unschooling. I don't know a lit about TJEd but I know it involves teachers as mentors and guides and is student interest inspired.
I find it valuable to note that Classical is actually a label shared by 2 methods, Neo-classical made popular by Dorothy Sayers and the Trivium. And Ancient which emphasizes Socratic method and rhetoric. And Classical Conversations is classical in name but misses the heart of either int eh same way that Masterbooks calls itself Charlotte Mason because it uses narrative to teach math. They both borrow elements from the methods they espouse to be, but miss the mark.
@@Volkfire Charlotte Mason Method isn't religious, no method is. Philosophy y can be-CM was Anglican, Montessori was Catholic with Hindu influence, Steiner was an anthroposophist and their religion seeps through because its part of who they are, but they aren't preaching it. The curricula vary, . Wildwood Curriculum advertises them selves as secular. I couldn't say about the others.
As a new homeschooling family, this video was very informative and helpful. Thank you for the quiz which was very helpful! Thank you for taking the time to give information on all approaches.
Very helpful as I prepare for my first year of homeschooling. Thank you!
Very informative and helpful. Thank you so much for taking time to record this.
You are very welcome, so glad that it has helped you.
This is a lifesaver explanation. Thank you.
Thank you sooooo much! This has calmed many of fears.
Thank you so much for this helpful video! You are so great at explaining things in a very simple, thorough way! I appreciate your time to record this for all the newbies out there! :)
I desire the ready to go method. Thanks Simply Charlotte Mason for your lesson plans, I love them! I was thinking of a 6th flavor. It’s more for younger kids, Montessori. I’d like to see a video doing a comparison of those two methods too.
There are others as well, like Waldorf. But I feel the 5 she discusses were a fair cross section of the main homeschooling options.
Thank you so much your video, it helped me through a very overwhelming time to choose a curriculum. THANKFUL
This video is so helpful! Thank you!
You are welcome!
I think I have been doing a little bit of everything altogether all this time without me knowing how they are called. Hahaha This is ssssuupppeeerrr helpful for me, I have a toddler he jumps from one topic to another, yet he wants to do something about each one. He also wants to kinda memorize them like the days of week, months, planets. He seems to sometimes want to narrate about them (even if he cannot say so much just yet), he wants to find (hence, I try hard to make them - no choice haha) coloring books or pictures about the topics he is interested in. Reciting or enumerating them does not seem to satisfy him. He wants to sometimes go outside just to see how the moon or starts really look like. So sometimes, I really want to think he leads the topics and pacing of learning as of now yet he wants a whhhooollle lot of variety.
Good information!
One of the most important aspects of Classical Style, which you missed mentioning, is that the parents spend a couple hours each day READING TO ALL THE CHILDREN. So, in the bagpipes example, not only would the young children be memorizing rote facts about bagpipes, they would also be listening to Mom (or Dad) read books that talk about bagpipes.
Thank you for joining in the conversation on different homeschooling styles!
Thanks so much for another great video. I appreciate how neutral you are to the various “flavors” of homeschooling. I have one suggestion to improve the quiz: I noticed that there were more answers that would lead to more T's (7) vs Unit (4) or even Living or Unschooling (5 each). A more balanced quiz should probably lead to an even amount of potential answers to each of the 5 flavors.
Other than that, I love your videos. They have been so beneficial.
I scored a 4 for unschooling and a 5 for CM. Interesting. I guess they are more similar than I thought.
This is informative and so well stated. Thank you!
This was very helpful.. thank you!
I’m surprised I had more SM than unit study. I’m changing for my youngest because she is so active and loves to read even more than my three older daughters who did mostly Traditional .My oldest is a sophomore in college in Music Ed, my second, who graduated this Spring is not interested in college but my third, who graduates next Spring wants to go to college.
Priceless video!
Thank you!
Great video !
Which flavor does “Creative Curriculum” belong? How about the Montessori School?
This is a wonderful video. I didn't know traditional and classical methods weren't the same thing. Also (kind of random) I'm wondering if Sonya happens to know ASL?
I got Charlotte mason unschooler
But thats how i want to teach, it might not he best way how my kids learn.
Hi, Now that you have an idea of what your homeschooling style is, you can try it out with your family and see how it goes! The beauty of homeschool is you can adapt and change gears if you feel that something is not working well for your family.
Thank you! That was just what I was looking for. I do have a question though: is it possible to homeschool while still sending your child to school? As in when, for social acceptability and because of college requirements, you have to send your child to school, but you are dissatisfied with what's being taught and how it's getting taught?
While we do not recommend requiring your student to complete both a traditional school load and a homeschooling load, Sonya discusses ways to use Charlotte's method when you don't homeschool here: ua-cam.com/video/L-b3Ynv2Jug/v-deo.html
@@SimplyCharlotteMason thank you ❤️
More than anything, this UA-cam channel has made me want children
Children are great! ♥️
Now I’m hungry and not sure how to combine classical and Charlotte mason
I have a question about the book of centuries. I watched your video on them, but didn't see which century to start with. You did mention BC, but how far back do we go?
We start our Book of Centuries resources at Creation, then move forward from there. In the early BC centuries there is less to record, but as you get into time periods around Ancient Egypt where we have better dates, there is more to enter. Our Basic Book of Centuries free download starts at 4000 BC, based on the dates in Ussher's Annals of the World. The My Book of Centuries book starts a Creation - 3001 BC.
@@SimplyCharlotteMason Thank you so much. I am looking forward to starting one of these with my kids this year.
great video. thankyou so much. got lots of N. what exactly was it?
N represents unschooling. You can learn more by downloading the handout found here: simplycharlottemason.com/events-speaking/five-flavors-of-homeschooling/
I would greatly disagree with the mom who told you about unschooling. That's just not true. Unschooling is about teaching and training your child HOW to find answers to their questions and help them understand the process of gaining the information they need just as an adult would find information to learn. Unschoolers are not against curriculum. It depends on what your child is trying to do and if they determine curriculum or an instructor is necessary to achieve what they're trying to achieve.
The parent is considered a resource manager along with strewing (sprinkling in what the parent would like to expose the child to).
Yeah, it is hard to do a 'test' of styles. It's like classical, people think it's all quizzes and grilling but in reality, it is about learning how to research when young and manipulate ideas in the teen/young adult years. There is a reason so many of the Enlightenment era thinkers were classically trained and sought classical education for their children.