I don't know a Quranist that says "don't follow Mohammed". The Quranists I know say "the quran is the word of Allah, therefore, whatever it says is highest authority" From my understanding, Mohammed didn't write the hadeeths. But i am still learning
@@thebookwithnotitle7687 Quran it self says it is upon Muhammad to clarify Quran to those who believe where’s that clarification of Quran from Muhammad because without that clarification Quran is not complete because Quran it self mentions there’s clarification from Muhammad Quran is a big book so the clarification of it must be somewhere right where’s that clarification?
@@Randomhandlename Doesn't mean clarification but to make it known eg. Qur'an 2.219. They ask you about wine and gambling. Say, "In them is great sin and [yet, some] benefit for people. But their sin is greater than their benefit." And they ask you what they should spend. Say, "The excess [beyond needs]." Thus Allah makes clear to you the verses [of revelation] that you might give thought. 3:187-And remember Allah took a Covenant from the People of the Book to make it known and clear to the people; but they threw it away behind their backs and purchased with it some miserable gain! and vile was the bargain they made.
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
“Say, ‘If the sea were ink for the Words of my Lord, the sea would run out before the Words of my Lord run out, even if We were to supply the same amount of ink as a supplement’” Q, 18;109
@@Randomhandlename because you will keep bragging and creating fitnah and he doesn't want to waste his time on you. Quran 18:54 from Surah al Kahf is for you: We have surely set forth in this Quran every ˹kind of˺ lesson for people, but humankind is the most argumentative of all beings.
Your beloved messager was following only the quran : …And when Our verses are recited to them as clear evidences, those who do not expect the meeting with Us say, “Bring us a Qur’an other than this or change it.” Say, [O Muhammad], “It is not for me to change it on my own accord. I only follow what is revealed to me. … (10:15). Say (O’ Muhammad), “I am not something original among the messengers, nor do I know what will be done with me or with you. I only follow what is revealed to me, and I am not but a clear warner.” (46:9) Say, [O Muhammad], “I do not tell you that I have the depositories [containing the provision] of Allah or that I know the unseen, nor do I tell you that I am an angel. I only follow what is revealed to me.” Say, “Is the blind equivalent to the seeing? Then will you not give thought?” (6:5 0). And when you, [O Muhammad], do not bring them a sign, they say, “Why have you not contrived it?” Say, “I only follow what is revealed to me from my Lord. This [Qur’an] is enlightenment from your Lord and guidance and mercy for a people who believe.” (7:203)
@@scixn69No these manipulative creatures are using this to guage where we're at in terms of our knowledge and understanding of Quran which leads us to exposing their falsehood, distortion and their corruption of Islam. M3nk twisted 59:7 for justification of hadith. Verse 5:41-42 reminds us of these corruptors. 5:41: O Messenger! Do not grieve for those who race to disbelieve-those who say, “We believe” with their tongues, but their hearts are in disbelief. Nor those among the Jews who eagerly listen to lies, attentive to those who are too arrogant to come to you. They distort the Scripture, taking rulings out of context, then say, “If this is the ruling you get ˹from Muḥammad˺, accept it. If not, beware!” Whoever Allah allows to be deluded, you can never be of any help to them against Allah. It is not Allah’s Will to purify their hearts. For them is disgrace in this world, and they will suffer a tremendous punishment in the Hereafter. 5:42: They eagerly listen to falsehood and consume forbidden gain. So if they come to you ˹O Prophet˺, either judge between them or turn away from them. If you turn away from them, they cannot harm you whatsoever. But if you judge between them, then do so with justice. Surely Allah loves those who are just.
He wasn't following only the Quran. He prayed in a way that wasn't revealed in the Quran. And that's disregarding the fact that there's no Hadith, like we know it today, at that time smh
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
This doesn’t really address the issue. Quranists accept that what the prophet pbuh instructs, however question the validity of authenticity in Hadith narration and the fact that it’s not infallible unlike the Quran.
As a german "christian" who became interested in Islam, this is exactly the conclusion i also came to. Only God knows best. I respect Mufti Menk a lot and i am not saying all hadith are wrong or should not be studied, sure, do it. But always keep it in the mind that they COULD be wrong. I am highly sceptical of the hadith though, that entire line of narration thing makes me furrow my brow i don't think i'd ever take them as a given. But only God knows best and may he guide as all among a righteous path. Peace be with you.
Some munafeqeens hypocrites claimed this To astray peuple great scholars did a greatest job in distinguishing the correct and incorrect hadith by hadith we know about praying fasting hands and how to perform them correctly
If hadees is wrong and you follow it its not your fault and allah doesnt punish you for this so follow it and you also have logical mind so you can easily find out right or wrong for ex take care of hair health and cleanliness is sunnah so what wrong in this if you follow this you get benefits.
@@muftimenkofficial mufti menk i want to follow quran and hadees but there are lots of lots thing to do so like praying seeking knowledge cleanliness feeding poor take care of father and mother and there are so many things to do how can i manage it or how can you manage so many things.
It doesn't say anywhere in the Quran to follow scriptures beside the quran, on the contrary it does say that we shouldn't follow any hadith beside the quran [45:6]. To follow and obey the messenger means to follow the quran since allah hasn't given us the message directly. Allah said in the quran we should use our intellect and not follow the scholars like sheep. That would make us no different than the Christians and jews who took their scholars and monks as lords beside Allah [9:31] (At-tawba). Allah said in the quran, that the quran is a detailed explanation of all things [12:111](Yusuf), so anything we need for our religion we can find in the quran.
@Happie Our The invention of your own scholars.... Written hundreds of years after the Death of the Prophet pbuh. Al Wahidi died around 1076? My question why is it that the vast majority of Islamic Literature were written during The Abbasid Tyranny. Why are these texts predominantly Persian? Or did the Abbasids have their own agenda? Where are the books written by the Ummayads? From a personal perspective I argue: What we call Islam today is a belief system that is heavily rooted/ influenced by Zoroastrianism, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity and Pre Islamic Arab Cultural Practices. Hence, the hundreds of Sects all discrediting each other. Just have a look any the Muslim World 2021 what do see nothing but apathy and despair? Where's the Peace? Where's the Love for Our fellow Human Beings? More, we cannot, repeat cannot compare the Quran with additional texts, the then Government endorsed Tasfirs, Hadiths, Siras, etc. Do you doubt the Quran? Isn't it enough for you? May Allah SA 🙏 Us All. Salaam, Shalom, Peace....
@Happie Our dude, i can explain the whole Quran to you if you want. But don't ask me to explain things which ARE NOT FOUND IN THE QURAN! Quran is sufficient, 16:89! 16:89 and the day we send to every nation a witness against them from themselves, and we have brought you as a witness against these. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED.
@Happie Our maybe u didn't understand me. So i will repeat myself again. I can explain the whole Quran to you if you want. But don't ask me to explain things which ARE NOT FOUND IN THE QURAN! Quran is sufficient, 16:89! 16:89 and the day we send to every nation a witness against them from themselves, and we have brought you as a witness against these. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED. 6:114 "Shall I seek other than God as a judge WHEN HE HAS SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK FULLY DETAILED?" Those to whom We have given the Book know it is sent down from your Lord with the truth; so do not be of those who have doubt. 6:115 AND THE WORD OF YOUR LORD HAS BEEN COMPLETED WITH TRUTH AND JUSTICE; there is no changing His words. He is the Hearer, the Knower. And many more verses..
@Happie Our are you stupid or what? So i will repeat myself again. I can explain the whole Quran to you if you want. But don't ask me to explain things which ARE NOT FOUND IN THE QURAN! Quran is sufficient, 16:89! 16:89 and the day we send to every nation a witness against them from themselves, and we have brought you as a witness against these. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED. 6:114 "Shall I seek other than God as a judge WHEN HE HAS SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK FULLY DETAILED?" Those to whom We have given the Book know it is sent down from your Lord with the truth; so do not be of those who have doubt. 6:115 AND THE WORD OF YOUR LORD HAS BEEN COMPLETED WITH TRUTH AND JUSTICE; there is no changing His words. He is the Hearer, the Knower. And many more verses..
Allah says at 20 places in the Quran that all external hadiths are fabrications, yet they ignore what Allah says and keep following the hadiths. They are the Quran rejectors. The Quran is Allah's Hadith and Sunnah , it's written in the Quran and Allah wants mankind to follow His Hadith and Sunnah( the Quran ) to follow Him.
Please get them for me. I am a new convert. Literally a few days old. I used to be a Christian they put Jesus in everything. So I was surprised to see Islam doing the same thing. Why do you have to mention a man every time you pray for the God who created you both to here you while being jealous that nothing should be associated with let alone used as a bargaining chip or testament to know that He is Allah?
@@bkbrown6281you will be asked about the prophet in your grave when you will be questioned The 3 questions will be: Who is your lord Who is this man (Muhammad) And what religion did you follow He (our prophet) was the best of creations and he is our prophet that we follow as in we are his ummah He will be the only prophet on the day of judgement to ask for forgiveness for his ummah while the other prophets (Jesus, Moses, Abraham) will be too scared to The ones who follow the Quran only make him out to be just the messenger as if he is a middle man and we only follow the Quran But the Quran and the teachings of our prophet go hand in hand, after all he was sent down to us as a role model and he was the best of all us Muslims; so if there’s an authentic hadeeth of how he used to act we should follow that as we want to please Allah and be the best Muslims we can. I hope this clears things up for you
@@bkbrown6281 Mentioning his name is not the issue. You can mention the fact that you follow the religion of Abraham or Muhammad in your prayers, that's fine. And God mentions the same in the Qur'an The problem is that the majority of Muslims today follow prophets Bukhari and Muslim (and others), as well the word of their scholars and take all this as divine law and commandments. This is expressly prohibited by God in the Quran when he says the Jews and Christians take their monks and scholars as their lords.
@@bkbrown6281 And this is the shirk that the majority of Muslims do today. It is part of modern mainstream Islam that we should follow the word of these people to interpret the word of God for us. If you do that, you follow THEIR word, not God's. Especially so, when they then give you additional commandments that supposedly the Prophet gave out which are not found in the Qur'an. ...Yet the Qur'an says that guidance comes only from God, not from the prophet or from anybody else. And it warns the prophet that God should strike him down dead if he were to try to guide the people with something other than what God has revealed to him in the quranic message.
I follow the Quran and the sunnah, but the thing I find hard is the prophet himself couldn’t verify the things that is now in the books of the Hadith. I follow them but that’s something that annoys me a bit. My wish is to really talk to the prophet and that he explained the Quran to me. May Allah bless all of us and lead us to the right path and heaven.
The Hadith in books are verified by many of his companions. Not just single Hadith allocated to 1 . Some Hadiths have been verified by over 40 companions. Each have their category. And their is over 10,000 authentic Hadiths.
@@haroondabbagh2869 Yeah thanks brother. I just watched a video of dr zakir naik explaining the science of the Hadith. May Allah grand you paradise and bless you
@@br4885 learn the science of hadith..often happened to quranist that they always criticised hadith but never understand how the hadith being recite, recheck, research, & challenged before its been authenticated..at least when u want to criticise some topic, make sure you know the topic well & proper..make sure you know how hadith being done through history, how narration being check, the dicipline, rule, cross reference on it being done, etc2..quranist never learn how hadith work take a look at muslim who debate christian..they research almost EVERYTHING regarding bible including their history, their concept, their literature from christian expert themselves, etc2..thats why they're debate against christian become proper & well prepared that is also why quranist will always be caught unprepared when their foundation being challenged face to face verbally..they taught when they come forward & face Muslim, it will be easy peasy because they're confident hadith can be crushed to the ground each & every time..but they forgot that they also have a very fragile belief system due to their nature of interpreting quran by just using logic..thats why its very, very hard to see any face to face debate where quranist managed to prove their belief with demonstration on how they practice with prove EXACTLY like what Allah commanded them to do, like solah, fasting or even hajj..they can only talked confidently when they're alone & no one debating them & challenge their point
Which sahaba verified it? Why didn’t the sahaaba wrote Hadiths themselves in the the presence of prophet? If it was verified then why do you have 4 different imaams with different Hadiths books, sahabas were not even present in the world when bukhari wrote Hadiths books.just Google for contradictions in Hadiths you will know how great those books are.
@@Yas0237 you are deceiving yourself. Hadith is not divine literature and it IS NOT from the prophet or any of the messengers. May God guide you to the straight path the path of those He has favored not those who incur wrath or those who are astray
Whoever is reading this, I pray that May Allah (SWT) bless you with endless happiness, fulfill all your dreams, aspirations & respond to your duas. May Allah (SWT) reward you with a home in Jannah.
hadith has prophets life,his sunnah etc...like do u believe in Mahdi or Dajjal? they r talked about in hadith and not Quran..do u believe in them??@@FaithfulIslamicReminders
@@justfootball7998 yes thats why we follow quran alone, mohamed pbuh forbidden to utter any other teachings apart from quran. So hadith is an fabrication done against the quran. [69:44] Had he uttered any other teachings. لَأَخَذنا مِنهُ بِاليَمينِ [69:45] We would have punished him. ثُمَّ لَقَطَعنا مِنهُ الوَتينَ [69:46] We would have stopped the revelations to him. فَما مِنكُم مِن أَحَدٍ عَنهُ حٰجِزينَ [69:47] None of you could have helped him. وَإِنَّهُ لَتَذكِرَةٌ لِلمُتَّقينَ [69:48] This is a reminder for the righteous. وَإِنّا لَنَعلَمُ أَنَّ مِنكُم مُكَذِّبينَ [69:49] We know; some of you are rejectors. وَإِنَّهُ لَحَسرَةٌ عَلَى الكٰفِرينَ [69:50] It is but sorrow for the disbelievers. وَإِنَّهُ لَحَقُّ اليَقينِ [69:51] It is the absolute truth
imagine, none of the hadiths were written during Muhammad’s lifetime. None of them were signed off by Muhammad. Meanwhile we have the perfect Quran. Quran is sufficient for me.
Opening comment is strawman. Most quran-only and quranist folks do not say people shouldn't follow the prophet muhammad (pbuh). In fact I have never heard this. To follow the quran is to inherently follow the messenger. Frankly nothing should be "automatic", re: from quran to hadith. We are instructed to be thoughtful and deliberate. I'm disappointed he doesn't address the quranic verses that quranists cite to support their viewpoint. He just puts forth a couple he thinks supports his own. Those to me are too open and non-specific to support his claim. I myself am more a strong "quran-first" rather than "quran-only" muslim but between them and the conventional wahabist influenced clerics I see stronger support for the former. I love and appreciate mufti menk even when we differ. I believe he's good hearted and well intentioned. That love inspires honesty and forthrightness which encourages my comment here. Please let's all speak from love for Allah (swt) and his creation inshallah.
May I ask you why you think that quran only is not the way, especially since you seem to acknowledge that there are (Sahih) Hadith that contradict the message of the Quran. I personally believe that if God says of himself that His word is free of falsehood and contradiction, it is out of question to follow a Source (Hadith) that is full of it. He could never have given an authority over this source, otherwise He would be a liar or simply not worthy of a God. Also His book is sufficient as a guidance for the believers in which no detail has been left out (6:114-115; 10:37). So why do you believe that there is a need to rely on the Hadith books for guidance?
In Quran it's written that Quran is fully ditailled nothing else is shall needed and people like Mufti Ment are spreading false knowledge perposly and not perposly please read Quran it is Fully ditailled and Lord Allah says in Quran that Quran should be understood properly so you can read it in any language but this days people just read it in Arabic even though they don't understand Arabic
HE WILL LOSE HES JOB IF HE STARTS FOLLOWING THE QURAN ALONE! THEY CHANGED THE SAHADA, SALAAT, ZAKAT, SAWM, CALENDAR, HADJ AND ADDED MANY THINGS. IF YOU ONLY KNEW SOME ARABIC AND DARE TO READ THE QURAN AND COMPARE IT WITH THE RELIGION OF BUKHARI/ALKULAYNI. QURAN IS SUFFICIENT, 16:89! 16:89 AND THE DAY WE SEND TO EVERY NATION A WITNESS AGAINST THEM FROM THEMSELVES, AND WE HAVE BROUGHT YOU AS A WITNESS AGAINST THESE. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED.
True tbh the Quran says it is a sufficient admonition. And does NOT mention the Sunnah of any Prophet, it mentions only "Sunnah of Allah". But to learn the great character of the Prophet SAWS will benefit you, he was a very very wise man! Just be careful dont believe blindly and look into the authenticity carefully
@@nadjiguemarful u can't trust books which have errors and fabrications.. It means that they are not inspired by God.. So that's why we know the ahadith are fabricated and that's why we do not follow a single hadith. Just because there are some ahadith invented that speak "good" about Muhammad, doesn't mean we should follow those books... The Quran speaks about the character of Muhammad. All we need is found in the Quran.. You can't mix truth with falsehood.
I'm not arguing with you guys anymore. No point. They call us "kafir" and "quranists" instead of acknowledging us as muslims. You can't argue with ignorance. When ALLAH says in multiple verses that the QURAN is clear/complete, and the best "Hadith" out there, then I will take what ALLAH told us and apply it to my life. One who follows the "sunnah" and hadith that clearly contradicts the QURAN, has no right to call us a "kafir." To you is your way, and to us is our way. May ALLAH guide us all. The QURAN is truly the most beautiful/clear/complete book out there and you can't dispute that. You also can't dispute that hadith is prone to mistakes because its MAN-MADE. Whereas the QURAN is the word of ALLAH, 0 mistakes and 0 contradictions.
That's right brother, arguing with these folks is pointless. Follow and apply the noble message of ALLAh SWT in your life and you're all set. They love arguing for the sake of arguments. Salam.
@Sébas Rejection is a Very strong and Misleading word.. I think Trust is more Apt.. The Quran needs no Justification, chain of narration’s etc.. The Hadith do.. The Quran is Infallible Word of Almighty.. The Hadith need to be checked for authenticity.. The Quran is superior to Hadith.. In Every Way.. Can’t compare the two.. Quran is the Article of Faith, the Hadith aren’t.. That doesn’t mean I’m Rejecting the Hadith, It’s just that I trust the Quran much more than the Hadith.. and if the two contradict each other, The Quran is the one to be Followed and Adhered to.. Hope it clears it all
Assalamualaikum brother I have been tagged this derogatory 'Qur'anist' term by people and it hurts. But the truth is, I follow the way Prophet Muhammad SAWW performed the Hajj, Salat, Saum...but the hadith are where I have troubles following. Prophet Muhammad SAWW is Rehmatullil Aalameen and al-Muallim, we must have faith in him....but the hadith, many of them are problematic and contradict Qur'an and Prophet's SAWW compassionate character
Those who claim Quran is enough and Hadeeth ain't needed will eventually be astray. Such claim are same as saying I only need the chemistry book I don't need a teacher to teach/demonstrate/explain How can any Muslim make such claim when the Prophet s.a.w was the PERFECT EXAMPLE OF QURAN. Are you claiming you can follow the Quran more than the man who Allah chose to send it to? Let that sink in...
The Quran clearly states the sole duty of the Messenger is to deliver God’s message and ayahs. Every hadith there is is narrated on the authority of Abu simon or whoever it is. Then it is further authenticated by some men you and I do not know. Sahih Bukhari has several contradictions. Doesn’t God forbid us to not follow other books? He says the Messenger follows the Quran so follow him (IN THE QURAN). Why doesn’t any single Muslim here know the Quran? If they did they would know that Mufti Menk misquoted the verse. It’s talking about distributing wealth. The fact that NOT ONE person caught this proves to me Muslims do not care about God enough to learn his book which is actually fard. Let that sink in! As for gains granted by Allah to His Messenger from the people of ˹other˺ lands, they are for Allah and the Messenger, his close relatives, orphans, the poor, and ˹needy˺ travellers so that wealth may not merely circulate among your rich. Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it. And whatever he forbids you from, leave it. And fear Allah. Surely Allah is severe in punishment
@@laylaa5445 it’s going to take time to reverse hundreds of years of tradition. I for one don’t necessarily reject hadiths, if they don’t contradict the Quran, and it helps me to pray a bit more or helps me to help other people, insha’Allah. Perhaps if we as an Ummah can find a way to incorporate everyone to find a well balanced structure of things so we can be united instead of division and arguing. But Allah(swt) knows best.
@@JigglyPlatypus My brother The Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is sent as a source of guidance so you follow the guidance of the Prophet so that they further explain what the Quran has said. And it is nowhere that every Muslim MUST memorize the Holy Quran it is Fard Kafaya so please please please get your beliefs straight.
wrong.. its not that simple.. its more than that.. QURAN = THE TRUTH!! hadeeth of bukhari = LIES and SLANDER against The Prophet. Taghut of Bukhari Muslim and the other four books of LIES. books of HADEETH
@@kyedean9698 qira'at mean recitations and yes for example ملك and مالك do you believe both of them are quran? If yes how do you prove that from the Quran?
@@ockbah ?? Do i believe both of them are Quran?? Why do you assume its both? Did The Messenger received the Quran maalik and malik?? Who authorize the reading of maalik and malik?
45:6 “These are Allah’s revelations that we recite to you truthfully. In what Hadith after Allah and His revelations do they believe?” The messenger is the Quran. Come see how Mr. Mufti
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
@@Randomhandlename Believers knew how to pray before hadiths. Even after having been given a clarifying Quran verse, you still choose to believe man-told stories/hearsay/hadith. Quit trolling, who sent you, Shaytan?
@@peace_seeker5545 then tell me how you pray from beginning to end explaining each step in detail why are you silent about the clarification of Quran from the messenger as mentioned in the Quran? Do you disbelieve in that part of Quran do you have clarification of the Quran from the messenger? Quran says it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear do you disbelieve and reject this part of Quran?
Actually he did, go to the Muslim Lantern video about Hadith Rejectors and form your own opinion. It is clear in the quran that we have to obey the messenger and quran transmission is through isnads just like the hadith if you actually study it. We can tell what is fabricated and what isn't. Abrogation of verses and all that fascinating read. Quranism only makes sense if you don't ponder on the quran. The hadith were written while he sallallahu aleyhi was salam was alive. Dig deep
Salaamalaikum! Thank you for your videos i really appreciate them and love watching your content. My brother and I converted to Islam 3 years ago, Alhamdulillah! Your fellow brother from El Salvador 🇸🇻
There’s an issue in the first sentence. He said that Quran-only people say only follow the Quran and don’t follow the Prophet’s sunnah. But he assumes that the truth of Hadith and Sunnah attributed to the Prophet’s sayings and actions, respectively. Moreover, there is a strawman being made here as well. He props up the strawman that Quran-only folks don’t believe in obeying the prophet, and knocks down this strawman. Quran-only folks do believe in obeying the prophet, but they are skeptical about the Hadith and Sunnah attributed to the prophet. There is a distinction between obeying the prophet and obeying what is attributed to him.
(9:5) And when the forbidden months have passed, kill the idolaters wherever you find them and take them prisoners, and beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they repent and observe Prayer and pay the Zakat, then leave their way free. Surely, Allah is Most Forgiving, Merciful.
@@FM-kl1wv Yes. God says in chapter 2 that fighting is ordained for those who are attacked first. In other words, you have a right to fight someone who attacks you first; that’s basic self-defense. At 9:13, God says that the people to be killed at 9:5 attacked the messenger and the believers first. Not only did they attack first, they broke their covenant with the messenger and the believers. Imagine signing a peace treaty with someone and then they attack you and break the treaty; it’s a betrayal and can be an ambush. If someone is willing to betray peace treaties then one becomes highly untrustworthy in the eyes of every party, whether spectating or involved.
Logic: Quran is the basis for everything and must be accepted. Hadiths that don’t contradict the Quran you can choose to accept. But if hadiths contradict the Quran then those are dismissed. Salam
@@lostwisdom7789 u have to define Hadith , these are the sayings and teachings of Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم the weak hadiths aren’t hadiths in the first place there weak or fabricated for a reason. Because they were never the sayings of the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم but the hadiths which are actually the sayings are aligned with the Quran. And just to let you know that’s not how it’s worked out it’s authethicated based on chains and the narrator whether they are trustworthy whether they were there during the event who did hear it from and their biography it’s a whole science in the field of hadiths. But The Hadiths (Sayings/Teachings of Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) are aligned with the Quran.
@@user-br1qk6mt6kwhen it says to Obey Allah and His Messenger, can you honestly say that that ayah was going to refer to some hadiths made 200+ years after his death? By the way, I do not want to do away with hadiths they are there for a reason and Allah knows best. What our generation needs to figure out is how to assimilate every school of thought and unify ourselves. That is all I want to accomplish. And if it comes to reject all hadiths so we can unify then I am all for that. But if we can find a balanced way to incorporate every school of thought in a balanced structure of Islamic theology and ideology and we can keep the hadiths then I am for that as well. Salam
The prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was instructed to pass on the message that is the Qur'an and NOTHING but the holy Qur'an. It also says if the prophet prohibits something, it is as if Allah swt prohibited it. People take this line as a misconception. This helps us to understand that we should only follow the Qur'an. Other evidence is when in the Qur'an it says, any deviation from the Qur'an by the Prophet would result in severe punishment. The Qur'an also tells us many many times to not distinguish among the prophets for they are all equal. People nowadays put Prophet Muhamad above the rest of the messengers which is simply Idolatry. Research brothers and sisters and you will find that the Hadith and Sunnah, although they provide life lessons and what not, are merely he-said she-said. The only true instructions we need are within the holy Qur'an. Allah swt said the Qur'an is perfect, fully-detailed, and is the only thing you need for salvation. Stop calling the prophet's name during the Adhan, Stop putting the prophet's name on mosques right next to the name of Allah, and please understand that even the prophets will enter Jannah by Allah's mercy the same way that we will insha'Allah. If you want proof based on the holy Qur'an and nothing but the Qur'an please go to submission.org where you will see the mathematical miracle that actually shows us how to pray as the Qur'an intended and not how all the scholars change it today. RESEARCH please brothers and sisters and you will realize how terribly far we are from the pure religion of Islam. La illaha illa ALLAH.
@@lostwisdom7789 yes of course this would be the best course of action only IF we absolutely KNEW that when we deem a Hadith to be Sahih it is actually true. The unfortunate thing is there are hadiths that are deemed to be sahih and they are not. There is evidence from the Quran that negates any truth to some of these sahih hadiths. I know it is very disturbing and hard to believe such a thing as what I’m about to say, but the truth is even our beloved religion of Islam, which is meant to provide peace and order to the submitters of Allah swt, there lies corruption and error in places we do not even notice. Allah swt said in the Qur’an that he purposely placed enemies for the prophets just so they may trust in Allah even more so. I promise you and anyone out there, the Research is already done and available. There is truth within the Qur’an that we haven’t even reached. Miracles we do not know. Messages hidden for different times. My favorite verse in the whole Qur’an, “Over it is nineteen”. Research please.
You are misleading innocent Muslims. Allah only revealed the Quran and our Nabi's job was to deliver it to the ummah. No hadeeth no fiqh or any other man made book is required.
HE WILL LOSE HES JOB IF HE STARTS FOLLOWING THE QURAN ALONE! THEY CHANGED THE SAHADA, SALAAT, ZAKAT, SAWM, CALENDAR, HADJ AND ADDED MANY THINGS. IF YOU ONLY KNEW SOME ARABIC AND DARE TO READ THE QURAN AND COMPARE IT WITH THE RELIGION OF BUKHARI/ALKULAYNI. QURAN IS SUFFICIENT, 16:89! 16:89 AND THE DAY WE SEND TO EVERY NATION A WITNESS AGAINST THEM FROM THEMSELVES, AND WE HAVE BROUGHT YOU AS A WITNESS AGAINST THESE. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED.
if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
I'm not a Muslim but I follow and listen to every word he says and there's such wisdom such passion I just wish people would know how beautiful Islam is ❤️
@Tamina K I'm not blind everyone has their religion that they believe in but it doesn't mean you have to shut yourself out from what others believe their is wisdom in the appreciation of what others hold dear and believe in
@@HCam-xh3yb thank you so much and it's okay everyone is entitled to their opinion and that was there's I'm just grateful for people like you who are open minded and spread love we all need that in this life and thank you may Allah also bless you
Mufti didn't mention this ayah. So am mentioning it. Allah said ,"Say if you were to love Allah then follow me Allah will love you and will forgive your sins...."
Allah is sufficient to me ... As His Messenger already said ; " I only follow what was revealed to me ." ( 10 : 15 ) I fear Allah , you are insane if you don't . But you are already taking verses out of context , and lying about us .. May Allah give you what you deserve .
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
Surah 17: 18. Whoever desires the fleeting life, We expedite for him what We decide to give him, to whomever We desire. Then We consign him to Hell, where he will roast, condemned and defeated. 19. But whoever desires the Hereafter, and pursues it as it should be pursued, while he is a believer; these-their effort will be appreciated. 20. To all-these and those-We extend from the gifts of your Lord. The gifts of your Lord are not restricted. 21. See how We have favored some of them over others; yet the Hereafter is greater in ranks, and greater in favors. 22. Do not set up another god with God, lest you become condemned and damned. 23. Your Lord has commanded that you worship none but Him, and that you be good to your parents. If either of them or both of them reach old age with you, do not say to them a word of disrespect, nor scold them, but say to them kind words. 24. And lower to them the wing of humility, out of mercy, and say, “My Lord, have mercy on them, as they raised me when I was a child.” 25. Your Lord knows best what is in your minds. If you are righteous-He is Forgiving to the obedient. 26. And give the relative his rights, and the poor, and the wayfarer, and do not squander wastefully. 27. The extravagant are brethren of the devils, and the devil is ever ungrateful to his Lord. 28. But if you turn away from them, seeking mercy from your Lord which you hope for, then say to them words of comfort. 29. And do not keep your hand tied to your neck, nor spread it out fully, lest you end up liable and regretful. 30. Your Lord expands the provision for whomever He wills, and restricts it. He is fully Informed, Observant of His servants. 31. And do not kill your children for fear of poverty. We provide for them, and for you. Killing them is a grave sin. 32. And do not come near adultery. It is immoral, and an evil way. 33. And do not kill the soul which God has made sacred, except in the course of justice. If someone is killed unjustly, We have given his next of kin certain authority. But he should not be excessive in killing, for he will be supported. 34. And do not go near the orphan’s property, except with the best of intentions, until he has reached his maturity. And honor your pledge, because the pledge involves responsibility. 35. And give full measure when you measure, and weigh with accurate scales. That is fair, and the best determination. 36. And do not occupy yourself with what you have no knowledge of. The hearing, and the sight, and the brains-all these will be questioned. 37. And do not walk proudly on earth. You can neither pierce the earth, nor can you match the mountains in height. 38. The evil of all these is disliked by your Lord. 39. That is some of the wisdom your Lord has revealed to you. Do not set up with God another god, or else you will be thrown in Hell, rebuked and banished. 😁😁😁😁
SubhanaAllah! This only shows that memorizing and reciting the Quran does not mean one understands its message nor do we follow it. If Mufti Menk can stand here and mention the verse « … take what the messenger gives etc… » to support his follow-Hadiths-theory, I am sorrry to say that he is being disingenuous as he should know the CONTEXT of that verse which deals with spoils of wars! The messenger of Allah only spoke and delivered what was revealed to him as Quran! That’s it! When you follow Hadiths understand that you’re following man-made statements attributed to The Messenger… No wonder why Prophet Muhammad, ALLAH’s messenger will say in 25:30: Oh ALLAH, my people have abandoned this Quran. Stick to Quran people, these Hadiths will only bring shame and deception to you. Wasalaam
Musa (pbuh) given 1 book "The Torah", Dawood (pbuh) 1 book "The Zabur", Isa (pbuh) 1 book "The Injil", Muhammad (pbuh) 1 book "The Quran". All the Prophets followed that which was given to them by Allah SA. Using traditional understandings where are the Hadiths of Musa, Dawood or Isa? Correct! They weren't any extraneous text used by any of the prophetical figures mentioned above. Shalom! Salaam! Peace!
@@xXEbuZocktHD68Xx Perhaps I have mistaken The Talmud for another text, but doesn't it say that Jesus was born of Mary and an evil spirit, and that Jesus is in Hell, boiling in his own excrement. Isn't there also a case where Rabbis debate and overrule God on Mosaic Law, to which He concedes: "My children have defeated Me." If so, how is this from God?
The original texts have been lost/corrupted/mixed and oral tradition The real issue you don’t know how to pray If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
There is no Torah, Zabur nor Injil left, how do you expect their words to make it to the 21st century? Correct, their words could not have made it to the 21st century because their words would go against the now changed holy books. Shalom, Salam, Peace
yes i say follow Quran only... and following Quran doesn't mean you dont have to follow Prophet Muhammad (saw) ... the Quran was given to our Prophet... He (saw) taught the Quran to the people.. He never taught what Allah has not decreed to him... and hadiths are chain of narrations...one who wrote hadith he himself never saw Prophet Muhammad (saw)... Allah says in the Quran itself that the Quran is complete...
Every Hadith is narrated by someone who saw the prophet. The Quran tell you to follow hadith which is the sunnah. (Obeying the messenger. If you don’t do this You’re disobeying the Quran
@@haroondabbagh2869 no, you are indeed disobeying God, if you follow the Hadith: A Sahih Hadith contradicting 2:256 and 24:2: Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2158 Abu Umamah bin Sahl bin Hunaif narrated that on the day of siege, 'Uthman bin 'Affan stood overlooking the people, and he said: "I swear to you by Allah! You know that the Messenger of Allah (s.a.w) said: 'The blood of a Muslim man is not lawful, except for one of three (cases):Illegitimate sexual relations after Ihsan (having been married), or apostasy after Islam, or taking a life without right, for which he is killed.' By Allah! I have never committed illegitimate sexual relations, not during Jahiliyyah nor during Islam, and I have not committed apostasy since I gave my pledge to the Messenger of Allah (s.a.w), and I have not taken a life that Allah had made unlawful. So for what do you fight me?"' The Quran is a detailed revelation: 6:114-115; 10:37; 6:119; 6:126; 7:52; 9:11; 11:1; 18:54 and more. Any source of Guidance other than the Quran (e.g. Hadith) are full of contradictions: 4:82 If you believe that God's words are Truthful, Perfect and free of falsehood, then a book that is full of falsehood (be it even only one contradiction) cannot be from Him. Otherwise God is a liar that contradicts Himself and therefore not a real God.
Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day, and remembers Allah often. Al qur an. 33:21
@@a.m.hajamydeen2504where in the Quran does it refer the Sunnah to the Messenger? It’s always referred to as follow A’LLah’s Sunnah. Where is the salah you perform? Can you reference where in the Quran it says Sunnah of the Messenger? Also, reference where in hadith it has the salah instructions? And one last question. How do you perform Wudu?
@@sirchale9272 // You have asked so many questions. My first comment surah 33:21 Allah mentioned "the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example" (uswatun hasana) what is the meaning of "excellent example". Pls explain me first. Say: "If you love Allah, then follow me and Allah will love you and forgive your sins." (Surah Al `Imran: 31) What is the meaning of "follow me "
@@a.m.hajamydeen2504 25:30 The Messenger will say, “Ya Rabbi, indeed my people have abandoned the Quran.” I adhere to the Hikma, the Nur, the Huda , etc, that is in the Quran, which is A’LLah’s instructions to us through HIS servant the Prophet Muhammed. Therefore I’m not abandoning the Quran. You have chosen to abandon it, Brother/Sister bc you choose the guidelines of a unverified source over the Quran. If your Wudu is not from Quran, you have abandoned it. And that is just one example. You know the Quran is true bc A’LLah’s promise that it will be protected and that it has no contradictions. Bukhari and the 6 other books , you don’t even know who the people were. That is not protected.
with ALL due respect to the Messenger , by your logic we should Follow our Mailman who brings a letter from authority. Allah says "Follow the MESSENGER" not "The Prophet" Allah refers to BOTH consistently thorough out the Quran. The Hadith has been placed equal with the Quran, is NOT sealed, is Not protected, is Not revealed by the divine. it is Correct that following the Quran Will be following the path of the prophets-yes. So why push books written by men and hijacked by jesuits? Follow the Message. It IS sealed, locked, and protected.
The messenger's only duty is to deliver the message, so the only way to obey somebody who has one job is to accept that message. He had other duties besides being a messenger of course, such as being a warrior, a husband, the leader of a nation, but in regards to delivering Allah's revelations, he can not change them or translate them, but only deliver them.
@@yobro6053 - I agree 100%. Follow THEE MESSAGE (commands, and suggestions of Allah) When someone says, "In order to do that, you have to dress like the mailman did," or follow what his friends claim he said, it becomes more about The messenger than the message. and we have the nonsense and superstition we have today
@@restlessnative3818 Yep, and remember 'I only follow what is revealed to me, for I fear the torment of an awesome Day, if I were to disobey my Lord.' Quran, Chapter 10, verse 15 . People today are following what was revealed to the 'sahaba',what they saw ect, but you are only supposed to follow what was revealed to the rasul.
@@yobro6053 -Salaam. My theory is just as the other religions were hijacked (false christianity , judaism , etc.) Islam was attacked from the inside out. Abdul Wahab and the JESUIT creation of thousands of false hadith along w BRITISH creation of "Saudi" Arabia turned a universal way of life into a superstitious man-worship religion. The ancient Christians wrote about beings known as Archons being responsible for the spiritual hijackings. It's obvious w Islam it happened. From High Science and Philosophy to.. superstitious , cosmetic nonsense.
@Hamid Hussein right. Technically speaking there are no set times exactly like 1 o’clock, 2 o’clock etc., it only says either ends of the days, at night, etc., so technically just as long as you get your salat in within those time ranges you are good to go.
What you forget to say is that the prophet Muhammad himself prevented his people not to write anything but quran. So why people wait +150 years after he died to start saying someone told me , someone told me.....why ?
He's lying about us and Quran. We (Quran aloners) don't say "don't follow the messenger" We literally say "follow him, As his way is Quran alone." And his orders are in Quran As he ordered from it alone. / 98:5, 4:105, 3:128, 3:154. Sunni-shia Ahadith are baseless, Not for vain they were not allowed To be written in Rashidun Khaliphate, They've no based "Science of Hadith" Their "IlmarRijal" is a pick & choose Play of whom they think are right Merely picking those of status, While even Prophet didn't know Some hypocrites as said 9:101. & Bukhari isn't checked by matn, it breaks if to compare to Qur'an. And none of sunni-shia can give 4 witnesses for "Ahadith"/ 24:13, While Hafs gave 4 for his Qiraat, So Quran didn't come the same Way as those fabricated Ahadith Which were written centuries later. 59:7 is about war gains, It's only for the poor/ 59:8, Are Hadiths not for the rich? Sunnis mess up interpretations. And the duty of the messenger Is only to deliver the message, That's only Qur'an/ 5:99, 14:52. & In 4:59 there isn't said "follow" But said "obey", they mistranslate, & read 4:60, it talks of themselves Who give laws to transgressions, & 4:62 refutes Bukhari Hadith 1. 33:66 is also about obeying, And we obey and follow him. And if you read that in context You can see it's of disbelievers And sunnis always play games When we show verses like 2:170 That it's not about them but other, While see the double standards, So they now say it's about us? And next verses clarifies that It's exactly about their likes, Who obeyed their chiefs And their nobles instead, Exactly like how sunnis obey Their "Khaliphas" made up rules And their mullas who make fatwas. And next is even astonishingly clear That it's about them who invent lies About the messenger as did Jews Invent lies about Prophet Musa, And next is again clarifying that The Qur'an was given to a human Cuz Heavens, Earth and mountains Didn't take the responsibility for it But a man took, so it's sent to us, But sunnis ask "why it's not sent To a mountain, why to a man?" So that's answered in Quran, It's to expose the hypocrites and polytheists as noted there. And previous verses clarify more The hypocrites spread false rumors In Madina, just as sunnis and shias, So they didn't stop but they went on So the verse that mufti (fatwa giver) Is giving is about themselves clearly Context over and over exposes them. / 33:66, 33:64-65, 33:67-68, 33:69-71, 33:72-73, 33:60-62, 2:170-171, 31:21. Allah is enough for Muslims.
No he is not rejecting prophet, he is accepting prophet by following the Quran and avoid the inputs from others which was not supervised by Rasool nor approved by allah. So Quran itself is fulfilled.
@@marioluigi9599 @jock1 FIRST: The Quran is the word of God. SECOND: The Quran is perfect with no contradictions. THIRD: The Quran is clear and with no ambiguity. FOURTH: The Quran is straightforward with no crookedness. FIFTH: The Quran is complete. SIXTH: The Quran is fully detailed. He is the One who brought down upon you the Book containing clear-cut verses that constitute the foundation of the Book, and others which allow multiple meanings. As for those who harbour deviation in their hearts, they pursue the multiple-meaning verses, seeking to cause discord and seeking to interpret it, but none know its true interpretation except God. And those well founded in knowledge say, "We believe in it, all of it is from our Lord." But none will remember except those who possess intelligence. 3:7 They almost diverted you from what We revealed to you so that you would fabricate something else and attribute it to Us, and then they would have considered you a friend. And had We not made you stand firm, you almost leaned towards them a little. And in that case, We would have made you taste double in life and double in death, and you would have found no one to support you against Us. 17:73-75 A revelation (Quran) from the Lord of the worlds. Had he falsely attributed any sayings to Us, We would have grabbed him by the right, and We would have severed his aorta. None of you would be able to prevent it. 69:43-47 We did not leave anything out of the Book. 6:38 Shall I seek other than God as a lawmaker when it is He who has brought down to you the Book fully detailed? 6:114 The Word of your Lord has been completed, in truth and justice. None can change His words. He is the Hearer, the Knowledgeable. 6:115 This is not a fabricated hadith, but an authentication of what came before it, a detailed account of all things, and guidance and mercy for people who believe. 12:111 We brought the Book down to you providing explanations for all things, guidance, mercy, and good news for the Submitters. 16:89 Those who seek Truth, will see truth. Those who don’t know what they believe in and wanna follow traditions will do that with pride as like rest. I put all my trust,gracious and gratitude only to Allah and obeying Muhammad by only believing Quran Word by Word.
@@dearcath Quran was released because previous scriptures got corrupted. Now if you follow Hadith which is not directly the words of Allah, and there's doubt that those Hadiths are accurate, quite our prophet didn't write them himself. Hadiths were narrated by people after his death. 250 years after his death. So yeah it's safer not to follow anything contradictory that will not lead us to the straight path. Islam is all about straight path
Mufti Menk is way off! It is clear for anyone who has a brain, that there is no evidence that Prophet Mohammed quoted anything in the Man Made Hadith! ALLAH clearly forbids any book other than what he reveals. When ALLAH says obey the messenger, he was directly talking to the companions of the prophet and his army that followed him at the time! For example, It is the Prophet who will decide when to go to war, or how much money each person would get from the war booty. So basically ALLAH is instructing the people to not argue with the Prophet. But when it comes to Religion, there can be no other Religion except what ALLAH reveals!
@@trollgegael Yes, over! Notice whenever theres a discrepancy between hadith and Quran (there are many instances this occurs), they supercede/abrogate Quran verses in favor of hadith.
@@trollgegael every hadith supporter vehemently shouts "show us how do you give zakaat (charity), how do you pray, how to perform hajj (pilgrimage) etc. Zakaat: There are many many many verses detailing zakaat in Quran and I must admit the Qurans guidance is very practical as opposed to hadith. They need hadith to detail zakaat is 2.5%, Quran doesn't state a precentage. Do you see how the set percentage method contains fallacies? Prayer/Hajj: These are detailed in the Quran aswell. Furthermore, the Quran doesnt order stoning or human inflicted death sentence punishments in general. These judicial matters are innovations afterthefact. Then theres the additional items declared haraam due to the hadith in contrast to Quran which doesn't declare these items as haraam ie: dogs, music, portraits in homes ect (list is substantially long). Quran states its a Book of Truth, Guidance, Justice, Mercy and Truth. Furthermore it states Its Clear and contains explanation of All things. Now to say any outside source is required to further supplement the Quran is an oxymoron; a direct contradiction of the Qurans Message.
When God is mentioned alone, then shudder the hearts of those who believe not in the Hereafter, but when those apart from Him are mentioned behold, they rejoice (Qur’an 39:45)
@@Ox1326 The shahada should be "la ilaha il allah wa aslamto lek ya rab al alamin." "There is no deity except for God, and I submit to you, oh Lord of the worlds." Because this is what Abraham said according to 2:131.
This video is very wrong.. Taking Quran verses out of context and falsely equating hadith with the Prophet himself... Follow the Quran it's the only divinely sanctioned source of Islamic guidance.
There is a huge amount of work and many people who were responsible for studying the authenticity of hadiths. And these people were not people who easily write comments on youtube or easily create a youtube channel...
This is how we assign each prophet an enemy, human devils and jinn, drawing inspiration from embellished and deceptive words. If your Lord had willed, they would not have done it. Leave them and what they make up. (Quran: 6: 112) Shall I seek another source of laws than God, when He is the One who sent this detailed Scripture down upon you? Those to whom We have given the scripture know that it came down from your Lord with the truth. So don't be among the skeptics. And the word of your Lord is fulfilled in all truth and righteousness. No one can change His words. He is the Audient, the Omniscient. (Quran: 6: 114-115) And so that the hearts of those who disbelieve in the Hereafter will bow down to it, so that they may take pleasure in it, and acquire what they accomplish. (Quran: 6: 113) And the Messenger said, "Lord, my people really took this Quran for a neglected thing!" (Quran: 25:30) These are the verses of God which We recite to you in all truth. So what hadith, after God and his verses, will they believe? (Quran: 45: 6). (also: 7: 185, 77:50 and 31: 6)
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
@@Randomhandlename The Quran is guidance for the believers. The Sunnah(practices of a lot of people during the prophet's time) is how a believer should practice the religion based on dozens of generations dating back to the prophet's time. Hadiths however are 'stories' gathered hundreds of years after the prophet SAL's passing. Muslims believe in the holy Quran(the message of god through his messenger) and do things how early muslims used to do them during the prophet's time. The rest are hearsay/stories(hadiths). (Quran: 45: 6) (Bismillah Al Rahman Al Raheem) These are the verses of God which We recite to you in all truth. So what hadith(stories), after God and his verses, will they believe?
@@peace_seeker5545 notice how you went completely off topic and didn’t address the points I brought up and did not answer the questions and another lie and propaganda from people like you Hadiths were being written down and memorised at the time of the messenger how come you take some history as facts and reject other as false what criteria are you hypocrites using? Do you have the clarification of Quran from the messenger Quran mentions that do you have it? That’s why you don’t know how to pray do you have the clarification of Quran from the messenger? Quran says it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear
@@Randomhandlenameok so then why do we have Sura 9:122. Where it tells the believers to devote themselves to the study of the Deen of the Quran so they can inform the Believers on their return of what to be aware of, what they can and can’t do, how to perform duties? So that they may be enlightened and admonished? The Prophet was clearly with them when that verse was revealed. Why didn’t the Prophet just teach it? Why are the Believers at his time being commanded to study the deen? Explain that verse, Brother/ Sister.
The Holy Quran is fully detailed, easy to under to understand , it is clear. The Holy Quran is easy memorize. What other books are going to put your faith on other than The Holy Quran. It is the truth. It is for the righteous.
We need the Sunnah for the Quran Jews do not worship Ezra “The Jews say, "Ezra is the son of Allah "; and the Christians say, "The Messiah is the son of Allah." That is their statement from their mouths; they imitate the saying of those who disbelieved [before them]. May Allah destroy them; how are they deluded?” Quran 9:30
@@somonsomon8244 that is no different than people like you who think that you aren’t following your forefathers This is how the different sects say that their hadiths are authentic: “Umm so we have chains of narrations... and Trust me Bro.”
Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) said, “Whoever could get one rak`a (of the Fajr prayer) before sunrise, he has got the (morning) prayer and whoever could get one rak`a of the `Asr prayer before sunset, he has got the (`Asr) prayer.” {Sahih al-Bukhari 579}
Quran tell us it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear, where’s his clarification of Quran? If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
There are some verses in the Quran that are not applicable for us today. Such as these ones: 49:2 "O believers! Do not raise your voices above the voice of the Prophet, nor speak loudly to him as you do to one another" 33:53 "O believers! Do not enter the homes of the Prophet without permission ˹and if invited˺ for a meal, do not ˹come too early and˺ linger until the meal is ready. But if you are invited, then enter ˹on time˺. Once you have eaten, then go on your way, and do not stay for casual talk." So how do we not raise our voice to the Prophet today? How do we not go to his home uninvited? The answer is that these laws were for the people who were living with him when he was alive, tho we can still take the teaching of manners in those verses but we cannot follow everything that's mentioned in there. So I would say that "follow the messenger" is the same, as a former Quran only Muslim, I will tell you that Quranists don't say to ignore and disobey the Prophet, rather they reject the books of hadith as authentic and consider them unnecessary, like the Bible. They would not refuse to obey the messenger if he was still alive.
He misrepresented what quranist believe. Yes we are instructed to follow only the Quran and prophet muhammad, and no one else. Prophet Muhammad's words are in the Quran and they begin with SAY. NOWHERE IN THE QURAN ARE THE HADITHS OR LATER WRITERS MENTIONED. The Quran is very clear about this everything we need is in the Quran and there is nothing else. Islam is easy. The Quran is easily understood. There is no question of its authenticity, there is no finger pointing about authentic hadiths or not authentic, and there is no finger pointing about which madhab is correct. Islam was given to us by Allah, and it is meant to be easy. It was never meant to be divided up into sects like today.
How do you know what Allah swt wants and dosnt want.. what a clueless comment.. Stop interpreting things as you fit when you dont have proper knowledge
Mohammed said somethings outside the quran and even explained some of the vocabulary of the quran and people witnessed the context of the ayats like in Surah al Masad it says "abi lahab" and when it was revealed people knew who was abi lahab because they witnessed him while Mohammed was revealing the Surah vocally, so they understood it fully (basically they witnessed the context). All I am saying is learn Islam from a scholar who is from ahl Sunna wa al jama'a or at least give it a chance then reject it if you wish. there was a group in Afghanistan that also used to reject hadith and used to explain the Quran using their "own version of Arabic" not knowing it was revealed with a different Arabic that is 1400 years old and after some time they started understanding it in a very different way and even did some questionable things that were never done by Mohammed and his companions nor by Muslims throughout history. May Allah guide us all
The Prophet Muhammad was the first 'Quranist' brothers and sisters, for he followed Qur'an and only Quran, nothing else! This is what Allah revealed to him. Think about it very carefully and logically and you'll see it makes sense. So these people who say they are guided who follow hadiths are not following or obeying the messenger but some others.
Alhamdulillah, A’LLah is truly the One who guides. Alhamdulillah , I have also come to the realization of our Ummah’s folly. What does A’LLah call a Quranist in the Quran? Ahlul Kitab. A’LLah is the Haqq. Salaam to you and to my true family of the Believers of the Quran.
Correction brother if you don't mind Prophet was a prophet for the Bani Israel in the style of the previous prophets and the last one in that chain , explaining to them the corruption of the Torah and getting them to make the transition to the Quran Muhammad was a messenger for those whose forefathers were not warned I e not from Bani Israel these people are called mumineen, the ones who already believed in Allah and his scriptures and understand tawheed are called those who have believed Believed 👈 pass tense ( ayyuhal latheena amanu ) Believers 👈 presant, future tense ( mumineen ) It's a shame how many people don't know this even myself for 2 decades Wasn't Muhammads job to explain the Quran in totality he was a messenger, his job was to deliver the messenge and fight for it's revelation and to preserve it through the people which he did
And Allah tells us that our Prophet PBUH is an example to follow, which means to follow him in actions. Our Prophet demonstrated how to obey the commandments and we are to follow him as per Allah's commandments.
@@areejshams3253 You've already got the commandments in Qur'an. You aren't told to follow the prophet's actions you are told to follow and obey the messenger. Following the messenger means obeying the Qur'an. So it's the Qur'an you have to follow.. nowhere does the Qur'an say follow the actions of the prophet Muhammad.
And what Allah restored to His Messenger from the people of the towns - it is for Allah and for the Messenger and for [his] near relatives and orphans and the [stranded] traveler - so that it will not be a perpetual distribution among the rich from among you. And whatever the Messenger has given you - take; and what he has forbidden you - refrain from. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty. - 59:7 This verse is talking about war booty and its distribution not hadith or sunnah. This is what happens when people take verses out of context. Please open your eyes folks.
Well said, This mufty/mullah knows well the true meaning of the verse but he deliberately did not read all of it to mislead people in order to guide them onto Satan’s path... All sunny/Shia mullahs deliberately misguide from the path of Allah swt.
And Allah said in the quran . We sent not a messenger, but to be obeyed, in accordance with the will of Allah. If they had only, when they were unjust to themselves, come unto thee (o Prophet) and asked Allah's forgiveness, and the Messenger had asked forgiveness for them, they would have found Allah indeed Oft-returning, Most Merciful. . But no, by the Lord, they can have no (real) Faith, until they make thee (o Prophet) judge in all disputes between them, and find in their souls no resistance against Thy decisions, but accept them with the fullest conviction. (4-64/65) . . This is what happens when people are either unaware or ignorant of the language of the Quran or the depths of the Quranic verses. And Imam Qurtubi writes in the exegesis of these verses (59:7) and this is the view of the vast majority of the companions of the prophet and the scholars and i am unaware of a single scholarly source or a source from the early muslim period or sahaba who confined the meaning to just fai' . وما آتاكم الرسول فخذوه وما نهاكم عنه فانتهوا أي ما أعطاكم من مال الغنيمة فخذوه ، وما نهاكم عنه من الأخذ والغلول فانتهوا ; قاله الحسن وغيره . السدي : ما أعطاكم من مال الفيء فاقبلوه ، وما منعكم منه فلا تطلبوه . وقال ابن جريج : ما آتاكم من طاعتي فافعلوه ، وما نهاكم عنه من معصيتي فاجتنبوه . الماوردي : وقيل إنه محمول على العموم في جميع أوامره ونواهيه ; لا يأمر إلا بصلاح ولا ينهى إلا عن فساد .قلت : هذا هو معنى القول الذي قبله . فهي ثلاثة أقوال .قال المهدوي : قوله تعالى : وما آتاكم الرسول فخذوه وما نهاكم عنه فانتهوا هذا يوجب أن كل ما أمر به النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم أمر من الله تعالى ...... .قوله تعالى : وما آتاكم الرسول فخذوه وإن جاء بلفظ الإيتاء وهو المناولة فإن معناه الأمر .وما نهاكم عنه فانتهوا فقابله بالنهي ، ولا يقابل النهي إلا بالأمر ; والدليل على فهم ذلك ما ذكرناه قبل مع قوله عليه الصلاة والسلام : " إذا أمرتكم بأمر فأتوا منه ما استطعتم ، وإذا نهيتكم عن شيء فاجتنبوه " . وقال الكلبي : إنها نزلت في رؤساء المسلمين ، قالوا فيما ظهر عليه رسول الله من أموال المشركين : يا رسول الله ، خذ صفيك والربع ، ودعنا والباقي ; فهكذا كنا نفعل في الجاهلية . وأنشدوه :لك المرباع منها والصفاياوحكمك والنشيطة والفضولفأنزل الله تعالى هذه الآية .قوله تعالى : واتقوا الله أي عذاب الله ، إنه شديد لمن عصاه . وقيل : اتقوا الله في أوامره ونواهيه فلا تضيعوها .إن الله شديد العقاب لمن خالف ما أمره به . . the point being and the same is explained by . "Although the verse was revealed in connection with fai', its words are general. They are not specific to wealth. They cover all the commands as well. Hence, the generalized meaning of the verse is that whatever the Holy Prophet ﷺ gives to a person, be it wealth, any other grant or any command, the people must show their willingness to accept it. And whatever he forbids them, they should stay away from it. . Many of the Companions took the generalized sense of the verse, and on the basis of it, they took the Holy Prophet's ﷺ commandment as binding as the Qur'anic commandment. Qurtubi said that in this verse the antonym of ata [ gives ] is naha [ forbids ]. This shows that the verb ata [ gives ] is used in the sense of amara [ commands ] which is the direct antonym of naha [ forbids ]. The Qur'an, instead of using the direct opposite of naha [ forbids ] which is amara [ commands ], employed the verb ` ata [ gives ] presumably to embrace the context of the subject-matter where the verse occurs, that is, the disbursement of fai' property." . And Allah knows best . May Allah open your heart.
And these people are 100% right, allah never mentioned that you have to follow another book or sunnah , nor prophet ever said any person to write a book, so how could we believe a book which is writen 200 years after prophet, not confirmed by any sahaba nor by prophet nor by allah himself
So glad to see so many Quran only Muslims in the comments 🙂 However, remember that we must all respect one another and avoid dividing into sects, as Allah tells us. Sunnis and Shias might be misguided in some aspects but they are still Muslim. All of us are human and we are all misguided in some aspects. May Allah guide all of us to the true path!
Well you have 73 to choose from... . Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2640 Narrated Abu Hurairah: that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: "The Jews split into seventy-one sects, or seventy-two sects, and the Christians similarly, and my Ummah will split into seventy-three sects." Classification: Hasan (Good)
Quran only are not Muslims If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
@@Randomhandlename Dentist: Go take a seat in the waiting room You: Should I sit with my legs crossed or spread out? Should my arms be folded or resting on my knees? Should I close my eyes or do they have to be open? Am I allowed to lean forward or does my head have to be resting back? Which direction should I be facing? Should I sit on my own or with someone else? Please someone give me a hadith to explain what the dentist wants me to do! 'If Quran by itself is so detailed' I love how you accuse me of kuffr and then literally commit it yourself with this sentence. "Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail?" And those to whom We gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters." 6:114 There's no point responding to you any further because at this point you're not arguing with me, you're arguing with the ayahs of the Quran. May Allah guide you and peace.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah we are not commanded in the Quran to go to the dentist and we will not be held accountable if we don’t go to the dentist or do other things which are not obligatory ritually but for prayer we will be and it’s obligatory upon us to pray so you’re telling me Allah didn’t tell us how to pray? This is what happens when you don’t follow Quran completely and skip some of it or not believe in some it Quran says it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear which is why you don’t know how to pray so funny how do you pray? You don’t even know I said Quran by itself because that’s what you believe while skipping and not believing in the verse of Quran where Quran mentions it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear which is why you don’t know how to pray because you don’t follow Quran completely that’s why you don’t know how to pray you’re struggling you don’t know how to pray you can’t tell me how you pray from beginning to end each step in detail because you don’t believe in the verse of Quran where it tells you it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear how come you can’t tell me how you pray I asked you if you knew you would’ve answered So funny
@@Randomhandlename It is not upon the messenger to make the Quran clear. Allah makes the Quran clear and the messenger recites. "And when We read it, follow thou the reading;" 75:18 "We shall be responsible for its explanation." 75:19
So you’re saying that the Quran is incomplete? Do you stand to object to A’LLah Al’Hakeem’s statement in 6:38 and 6:114 that nothing has been omitted from the Book and that everything in it is without a doubt explained in full detail? Brothers and Sisters, come back to the Quran. You will gain A’LLah’s forgiveness. The Book is meant for each one of Al’Rahman’s servants , so we can connect to Our Rabb. The Shahada in the Quran is only for A’LLah. No other name should be joined with His. Only A’LLah’s name should be glorified in Salah and in Masjids. They have steered us away from Sole Worship which belongs to A’LLah Alone. Salah, Wudu, prayer timings and prayers are all in the Book of Guidance. There are no complete compilation prayers in hadiths.
The quran is the revelation if you don’t know Mufti: ““19. Say (O Muhammad ): "What thing is the most great in witness?" Say: "Allah (the Most Great!) is Witness between me and you; this Qur'an has been revealed to me that I may therewith warn you and whomsoever it may reach. Can you verily bear witness that besides Allah there are other aliha (gods)?" Say "I bear no (such) witness!" Say: "But in truth He (Allah) is the only one Ilah (God). And truly I am innocent of what you join in worship with Him."S6/19 Sone people are champions of twisting everything….
Following the messenger doesnt mean we have to follow the hadith. The prophet preached only the Quran and nothing else for religious belief. So when we follow the quran we are obeying the messenger. It is people who follow hadith who are disobeying the messenger.
@@Athawriand may you ask Allah to guide you :) I hope one day you will realise that Allah and the messenger want us to follow the Quran only because thats what the prophet preached from Allah. Not hadith :)
Just verify hadith using Qu'ran. If the hadith doesn't go against Qu'ran then that means it could be a hadith. Then we check the actual reliability. If it goes against it isn't a hadith. Simple. A lot of the signs of the day of judgement are written in hadith. While Umar (May Allah be pleased with him) is said to have burnt hadith books. As the Ummayad caliphate began. They didn't put Islamic laws in place and didn't really care about the people. Reliability of hadith had gotten so bad that Umar II had to officially make a reliable hadith book
@@thegamerkhan when you start to take the Quran seriously and you realise that Allah so many times says that the book is complete and fully detailed and that you should not follow any other book you then start to notice that the concept of hadith goes against the whole Quran.
Allah told the rasul in the quran to say, 'i only follow what is revealed to ME' So how in the world do people think these hadiths were revealed to the messenger when it' written by these people in their own words ? Ridiculous.
Well People, in fact, men „prove“ that there are authentic hadith. I highly respect you and learn a lot of you but I kindly disagree with you here. The Quran says at very many points that the quran is complete and god has not forgotten a single thing. Maybe you can listen to sunnah in a „spiritual“ way if it helps, but as soon as you get judged by not for example praying like the mainstream Muslims than it is getting dangerous in the peace within the Muslim community.
@@notaknot3768 No, not at all. In fact I love men. But I won't listen to men who are telling me how THEY believe women should act, eat, pray, live. Greetings.
TRY READING QURAN It says you follow the Sunnah of Allah. Not ONCE does it say Sunnah of the Prophet or of Muhammad or of anybody else. You must have never read the Quran
I honestly would prefer a discussion between a "Quranist", a "Shia" and a "Sunni". Each believes in his heart that he is rightly guided and the rest are in error. I LOVE the Mufti for Allah swt, but he flattens and simplifies the Quranist's logic for his argument here. So I would LOVE for a discussion to be had where all sides present their proofs so we can review and settle it or come close. May Allah guide us. Ameen.
@Abdul Manan Zargar Those in authority means what? Is there a difference between messenger and prophet? What is the lesson of 68:4 and 33:53? Plenty of evidence in the Quran that it's complete, clear, fully detailed, best tafseer. Don't use any other hadith. You are saying otherwise....
(9:5) And when the forbidden months have passed, kill the idolaters wherever you find them and take them prisoners, and beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they repent and observe Prayer and pay the Zakat, then leave their way free. Surely, Allah is Most Forgiving, Merciful.
Quran says it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Hadeeth bans music when Quran never mentions it. How can music be banned? Music that praise Allah and music that’s talks about life and poverty not bad rap language is banned only comes from hadith
They cite verse 59:7: "...take what Messenger gives and refrain from what her forbids" as a source of justifyiny hadith. This verse is in reference to distribution of goods from a perticular event. Allah makes their intentions clear in verses 3:78 and 5:41-42, see below: 3:78 "And indeed, there is among them a party who alter the Scripture with their tongues so you may think it is from the Scripture, but it is not from the Scripture. And they say, "This is from Allāh," but it is not from Allāh. And they speak untruth about Allāh while they know". 59:7 "And what Allāh restored to His Messenger from the people of the towns - it is for Allāh and for the Messenger and for near relatives and orphans and the needy and the [stranded] traveler - so that it will not be a perpetual distribution among the rich from among you. And whatever the Messenger has given you - take; and what he has forbidden you - refrain from. And fear Allāh; indeed, Allāh is severe in penalty". They somehow are convinced and try to push the narrative this verse implies hadith but Allah makes it clear in 5:41-42 what their intentions are: 5:41 "O Messenger, let them not grieve you who hasten into disbelief of those who say, "We believe" with their mouths, but their hearts believe not, and from among the Jews. [They are] avid listeners to falsehood, listening to another people who have not come to you. They distort words beyond their [proper] places [i.e., usages], saying, "If you are given this, take it; but if you are not given it, then beware." But he for whom Allāh intends fitnah - never will you possess [power to do] for him a thing against Allāh. Those are the ones for whom Allāh does not intend to purify their hearts. For them in this world is disgrace, and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment". 5:42 "[They are] avid listeners to falsehood, devourers of [what is] unlawful. So if they come to you, [O Muḥammad], judge between them or turn away from them. And if you turn away from them - never will they harm you at all. And if you judge, judge between them with justice. Indeed, Allāh loves those who act justly".
@@CCP-Lies they are very illogical and manipulative. They mock and ridicule the Quran in justification of hadith. I embraced Islam after thoroughly studying, scrutinizing and critically examining the Quran and came to the conclusion this is the Right Path. The hadith is a distortion of Islam and diversion from the Path of God. I've come to realize the biggest enemies of Islam are those who identify with the religion as so called 'muslims' - we are these fortold of these hypocrites in the Quran itself. Evidently, they could not alter the Quran so they created hadith, in which it goes to great lengths to associate with the religion.
1 st comment Nabi kareem Mohammad Mustafa Sallahu-alye-he-wasallam was muallim (who taught us قرآن not only give it to us as a book ) so there should be a way how he taught sahabas Qur'an so to follow Qur'an we have to follow that also
Arabic was not created for Quran by Allah so that prophet should teach it to sahabas. Allah revealed the Quran in people’s language Arabic so that they can understand. So there was no need of prophet to teach Arabic to anyone.
When I read the verse in the Quran that says the sun sets in a muddy spring I swallowed the fact that Islam is a man made religion even tho i really want it to be true because the Quran is Arabic and I’m an Arab but at the same time I didn’t runaway from the truth and I accept it , في بلاوي راح يكرهوني بسبب هذا التعليق بس خليهم ، راح افتح عيونهم للواقع لمحبتي لهم
Sir I had miscarriage today my husband was by my side in restroom he saw me my pain and he saw the baby fall he said ya Allah mercy us help us just pray for me I know Allah has best plans ya Allah
May Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta’Ala have mercy upon you and your husband and grant you ease and patience dear sister. May you both be reunited with your baby in Jannatul firdous. Ameen ❤️
Which prophet will you be hiding behind on the day of judgement?? Who’s ummah are you from? When he (Muhammad) will be asking Allah for forgiveness for his ummah I’m sure you will be in the crowd behind him. Or will you be standing all alone by yourself and intercede for yourself? It will only be one of the questions in your grave, you will be asked “who is this man” (Muhammad) if you didn’t follow his teachings or care about him do you think your heart will allow you to answer? May Allah guide you Insha’Allah
Quran 4:59 - O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.
@@Loveofasufi so how do you pray? How and when do you do hajj? How much and when do you pay zakat? Do you even pray? How do you do wuda? What about Islamic laws? You clearly just want to go clubbing
@@yous2244 things that arent mentioned in the Quran is not worth knowing, also God says our salat is supposed to stop you from doing evil things, I pray standing, say 3-4 lines in my own language such as god has no son, god has no partners, god is alone, god helps you during your hardships etc, salat is remembrance of God.❤️ This way instead of saying it in Arabic where I don't understand a single thing, I get the message and the guidance!
Ridiculous.. Very first verse he brought like saying whatever messenger brought bla bla.. Out context doing people... Shame on those who follow hadith and in the end they definitely reject QURAN..
These are the verses of Allah which we recite to you in Truth. So in what HADITHS besides Allah and His verses will they believe?! Damn every sinful liar! -Quran 45:6-7
Quran is the word of Allah as well the Bible, as the Quran itself testify. I believe in Allah and his Word is overall. The hadiths which are authentic 100% can be helpful as support, but overall are the sacred scriptures, Surah 5:48 (just an example). No excuses
The Quran does NOT need the support of any further scriptures......especially Hadeeth sayings. Neither Allah or our beloved Profit authenticated Hadeeth literature. Allah does however mention Hadeeth in the Quran in the context that the Quran is Allah's Hadeeth that we should be following .......and not the unauthenticated Hadeeth scribed Approx. 200 to 300 years after the departure of our Profit.
The Bible is not the word of Allah. The word of Allah came through Prophet Isa at the time, the Bible is a compilation of the gospels of his companions. They are essentially the equivalent of hadiths. The equivalent of the Quran for Christian would be the sayings and teachings of Jesus, which are compiled within some of the Bible verses, but are not the Bible itself, making it hard or impossible to follow with 100% certainty on which verse is authentic, and which is not.
God revealed the Quran and it is perfect and complete; God has perfected all things. [Quran 6:19] Say, "Whose testimony is the greatest?" Say, "God's. He is the witness between me and you that this Quran has been inspired to me, to preach it to you and whomever it reaches. Indeed, you bear witness that there are other gods beside God." Say, "I do not testify as you do; there is only one god, and I disown your idolatry." [Quran 6:38] We did not leave anything out of this book. [Quran 7:52] We have given them a scripture that is fully detailed, with knowledge, guidance, and mercy for the people who believe. [Quran 10:37] This Quran could not possibly be authored by other than God. It confirms all previous messages, and provides a fully detailed scripture. It is infallible, for it comes from the Lord of the universe. [Quran 12:111] In their history, there is a lesson for those who possess intelligence. This is not fabricated Hadith; this (Quran) confirms all previous scriptures, provides the details of everything, and is a beacon and mercy for those who believe. The Quran proclaims that the Quran is complete, perfect, and fully detailed. Verses 6:114-115 explain to us what "fully detailed" means. The Quran is fully detailed for religious law and "complete in truth and justice." [Quran 6:114] Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed? Those who received the scripture recognize that it has been revealed from your Lord, truthfully. You shall not harbor any doubt. [Quran 6:115] The word of your Lord is complete, in truth and justice. Nothing shall abrogate His words. He is the Hearer, the Omniscient. Hadiths contradicts with Quran because Quran is perfect. Allah says Quran is all we need. Quran it self is the sunnah and hadith.
Assalaamu alaikum Mufti Sir,Believe me I was searching for this answer since 5 to 6 yrs to reply to such ppl who comes under this category but I couldn't do out of lack of knowledge (ie) though I know but not having any authentic proofs which u mentioned here.Jzk Allah khairan kaseerah U 've guided me whenever I need any guidance either thru ur videos or daily advisory notes. KEEP Going Sir and STAY BLESSED 😊
This person is a hypocrite and a liar who wants to lead you astray and trades in religion, so how can you believe him? He even cut off the verse distributing spoils from its context! I once believed these impostors and believed in the Sunnah, but after referring to the Qur’an, you will know that God did not send down a revelation other than the Qur’an, and that it is complete, detailed, and clear. And the messenger is nothing but an amount of the message.
Mufti menk plz don’t tell Allah how he should have framed verses. There are various Quranic verses which Allah puts it in a repeatable way. There is no separate meaning if Allah separates it. Allah says in Quran that a person with less imaan will try to dig in the meaning of verses which he cannot understand. So Quran should always be taken at face value with the intention of understanding it rather than deciding it. Its not an encrypted book that people should have special knowledge to understand it.
Al-Jasiyah 45:6 تِلْكَ ءَايَٰتُ ٱللَّهِ نَتْلُوهَا عَلَيْكَ بِٱلْحَقِّۖ فَبِأَىِّ حَدِيثٍۭ بَعْدَ ٱللَّهِ وَءَايَٰتِهِۦ يُؤْمِنُونَ These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement after Allah and His verses will they believe?
They say Quran is complete and we don't need hadiths... Well yeah Quran is complete in it's own way just like the example of a beautiful poetry which is complete in it's own but still you need a interpretation or original understanding of that poetry because it can be interprete in many ways, and the one who can give the best interpretation or understanding of that quote or poetry is it's creator, and as for the Quran Allah gave the responsibility of it to explain it to others to Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, Alhamdullilah! #IOFAVidz007👈
@@counterdebate in the Quran. Muslims r told to. Follow. Wat the prophet brought to us. Nd stop wat he told us to stop doing. Simple answer. On the basis of this vid
"They abandoned the judgement of their Lord and took hadiths for their religion; and they claim that they have obtained knowledge other than from the Koran . . . They believed in a book which was not from God, written by the hands of men; they then attributed it to the Messenger of God."
God have mercy on my soul. Don't allow me follow a false design. Choose for me the right path. Ameen
Ameen
Assalamualaikum Brother please read the Quran you will understand that Islam is the truth
@@thalblankson4002 isnt youtube banned in china?
Ameen
Ameeen 🤲🏻
I don't know a Quranist that says "don't follow Mohammed".
The Quranists I know say "the quran is the word of Allah, therefore, whatever it says is highest authority"
From my understanding, Mohammed didn't write the hadeeths. But i am still learning
Correct
mohammed was just a messenger. Full stop. These so called muslims idolize him like a God thus rejected God's
@@thebookwithnotitle7687 Quran it self says it is upon Muhammad to clarify Quran to those who believe where’s that clarification of Quran from Muhammad because without that clarification Quran is not complete because Quran it self mentions there’s clarification from Muhammad Quran is a big book so the clarification of it must be somewhere right where’s that clarification?
@@Randomhandlename Doesn't mean clarification but to make it known eg. Qur'an 2.219.
They ask you about wine and gambling. Say, "In them is great sin and [yet, some] benefit for people. But their sin is greater than their benefit." And they ask you what they should spend. Say, "The excess [beyond needs]." Thus Allah makes clear to you the verses [of revelation] that you might give thought.
3:187-And remember Allah took a Covenant from the People of the Book to make it known and clear to the people; but they threw it away behind their backs and purchased with it some miserable gain! and vile was the bargain they made.
@@Randomhandlename If it doesn't mention it then why seek it.
"The sole duty of the messenger is the delivery, and God knows what you reveal and what you conceal" Q, 5:99
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t
Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
“Say, ‘If the sea were ink for the Words of my Lord, the sea would run out before the Words of my Lord run out, even if We were to supply the same amount of ink as a supplement’” Q, 18;109
@@HouseSubmission you didn’t answer my questions or address my points
@@Randomhandlename because you will keep bragging and creating fitnah and he doesn't want to waste his time on you.
Quran 18:54 from Surah al Kahf is for you:
We have surely set forth in this Quran every ˹kind of˺ lesson for people, but humankind is the most argumentative of all beings.
Your beloved messager was following only the quran :
…And when Our verses are recited to them as clear evidences, those who do not expect the meeting with Us say, “Bring us a Qur’an other than this or change it.” Say, [O Muhammad], “It is not for me to change it on my own accord. I only follow what is revealed to me. … (10:15).
Say (O’ Muhammad), “I am not something original among the messengers, nor do I know what will be done with me or with you. I only follow what is revealed to me, and I am not but a clear warner.” (46:9)
Say, [O Muhammad], “I do not tell you that I have the depositories [containing the provision] of Allah or that I know the unseen, nor do I tell you that I am an angel. I only follow what is revealed to me.” Say, “Is the blind equivalent to the seeing? Then will you not give thought?” (6:5 0).
And when you, [O Muhammad], do not bring them a sign, they say, “Why have you not contrived it?” Say, “I only follow what is revealed to me from my Lord. This [Qur’an] is enlightenment from your Lord and guidance and mercy for a people who believe.” (7:203)
Exactly.
Sangat tepat !
Salafists are burning
@@scixn69No these manipulative creatures are using this to guage where we're at in terms of our knowledge and understanding of Quran which leads us to exposing their falsehood, distortion and their corruption of Islam.
M3nk twisted 59:7 for justification of hadith. Verse 5:41-42 reminds us of these corruptors.
5:41:
O Messenger! Do not grieve for those who race to disbelieve-those who say, “We believe” with their tongues, but their hearts are in disbelief. Nor those among the Jews who eagerly listen to lies, attentive to those who are too arrogant to come to you. They distort the Scripture, taking rulings out of context, then say, “If this is the ruling you get ˹from Muḥammad˺, accept it. If not, beware!” Whoever Allah allows to be deluded, you can never be of any help to them against Allah. It is not Allah’s Will to purify their hearts. For them is disgrace in this world, and they will suffer a tremendous punishment in the Hereafter.
5:42:
They eagerly listen to falsehood and consume forbidden gain. So if they come to you ˹O Prophet˺, either judge between them or turn away from them. If you turn away from them, they cannot harm you whatsoever. But if you judge between them, then do so with justice. Surely Allah loves those who are just.
He wasn't following only the Quran. He prayed in a way that wasn't revealed in the Quran. And that's disregarding the fact that there's no Hadith, like we know it today, at that time smh
In the Judgment day what if Allah ask you 'Is the Quran sufficient for you?' What would you answer???
👍👍
Bother I think they will be asked about Bukhari , muslim.😂😂
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t
Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
@@Randomhandlename please shut up. Stop creating fitnah.
This doesn’t really address the issue. Quranists accept that what the prophet pbuh instructs, however question the validity of authenticity in Hadith narration and the fact that it’s not infallible unlike the Quran.
As a german "christian" who became interested in Islam, this is exactly the conclusion i also came to. Only God knows best. I respect Mufti Menk a lot and i am not saying all hadith are wrong or should not be studied, sure, do it. But always keep it in the mind that they COULD be wrong. I am highly sceptical of the hadith though, that entire line of narration thing makes me furrow my brow i don't think i'd ever take them as a given. But only God knows best and may he guide as all among a righteous path. Peace be with you.
It's a very short video. Did you hear the whole thing? Listen to it if you haven't. Perhaps you missed something.
Some munafeqeens hypocrites claimed this To astray peuple great scholars did a greatest job in distinguishing the correct and incorrect hadith by hadith we know about praying fasting hands and how to perform them correctly
If hadees is wrong and you follow it its not your fault and allah doesnt punish you for this so follow it and you also have logical mind so you can easily find out right or wrong for ex take care of hair health and cleanliness is sunnah so what wrong in this if you follow this you get benefits.
@@muftimenkofficial mufti menk i want to follow quran and hadees but there are lots of lots thing to do so like praying seeking knowledge cleanliness feeding poor take care of father and mother and there are so many things to do how can i manage it or how can you manage so many things.
It doesn't say anywhere in the Quran to follow scriptures beside the quran, on the contrary it does say that we shouldn't follow any hadith beside the quran [45:6]. To follow and obey the messenger means to follow the quran since allah hasn't given us the message directly. Allah said in the quran we should use our intellect and not follow the scholars like sheep. That would make us no different than the Christians and jews who took their scholars and monks as lords beside Allah [9:31] (At-tawba). Allah said in the quran, that the quran is a detailed explanation of all things [12:111](Yusuf), so anything we need for our religion we can find in the quran.
I choose Quran any day anytime, a gift from God directly to me.
It is sufficient for me no matter how you said it is not.
Correct! Quran 100%. That's the guidance given to ud by Allah SA period.
@Happie Our
The invention of your own scholars.... Written hundreds of years after the Death of the Prophet pbuh. Al Wahidi died around 1076? My question why is it that the vast majority of Islamic Literature were written during The Abbasid Tyranny. Why are these texts predominantly Persian? Or did the Abbasids have their own agenda? Where are the books written by the Ummayads?
From a personal perspective I argue:
What we call Islam today is a belief system that is heavily rooted/ influenced by Zoroastrianism, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity and Pre Islamic Arab Cultural Practices. Hence, the hundreds of Sects all discrediting each other. Just have a look any the Muslim World 2021 what do see nothing but apathy and despair? Where's the Peace? Where's the Love for Our fellow Human Beings?
More, we cannot, repeat cannot compare the Quran with additional texts, the then Government endorsed Tasfirs, Hadiths, Siras, etc. Do you doubt the Quran? Isn't it enough for you?
May Allah SA 🙏 Us All. Salaam, Shalom, Peace....
@Happie Our dude, i can explain the whole Quran to you if you want. But don't ask me to explain things which ARE NOT FOUND IN THE QURAN!
Quran is sufficient, 16:89!
16:89 and the day we send to every nation a witness against them from themselves, and we have brought you as a witness against these. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED.
@Happie Our maybe u didn't understand me. So i will repeat myself again. I can explain the whole Quran to you if you want. But don't ask me to explain things which ARE NOT FOUND IN THE QURAN!
Quran is sufficient, 16:89!
16:89 and the day we send to every nation a witness against them from themselves, and we have brought you as a witness against these. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED.
6:114 "Shall I seek other than God as a judge WHEN HE HAS SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK FULLY DETAILED?" Those to whom We have given the Book know it is sent down from your Lord with the truth; so do not be of those who have doubt.
6:115 AND THE WORD OF YOUR LORD HAS BEEN COMPLETED WITH TRUTH AND JUSTICE; there is no changing His words. He is the Hearer, the Knower.
And many more verses..
@Happie Our are you stupid or what? So i will repeat myself again. I can explain the whole Quran to you if you want. But don't ask me to explain things which ARE NOT FOUND IN THE QURAN!
Quran is sufficient, 16:89!
16:89 and the day we send to every nation a witness against them from themselves, and we have brought you as a witness against these. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED.
6:114 "Shall I seek other than God as a judge WHEN HE HAS SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK FULLY DETAILED?" Those to whom We have given the Book know it is sent down from your Lord with the truth; so do not be of those who have doubt.
6:115 AND THE WORD OF YOUR LORD HAS BEEN COMPLETED WITH TRUTH AND JUSTICE; there is no changing His words. He is the Hearer, the Knower.
And many more verses..
Allah says at 20 places in the Quran that all external hadiths are fabrications, yet they ignore what Allah says and keep following the hadiths. They are the Quran rejectors.
The Quran is Allah's Hadith and Sunnah , it's written in the Quran and Allah wants mankind to follow His Hadith and Sunnah( the Quran ) to follow Him.
Please get them for me. I am a new convert. Literally a few days old. I used to be a Christian they put Jesus in everything. So I was surprised to see Islam doing the same thing. Why do you have to mention a man every time you pray for the God who created you both to here you while being jealous that nothing should be associated with let alone used as a bargaining chip or testament to know that He is Allah?
@@bkbrown6281you will be asked about the prophet in your grave when you will be questioned
The 3 questions will be:
Who is your lord
Who is this man (Muhammad)
And what religion did you follow
He (our prophet) was the best of creations and he is our prophet that we follow as in we are his ummah
He will be the only prophet on the day of judgement to ask for forgiveness for his ummah while the other prophets (Jesus, Moses, Abraham) will be too scared to
The ones who follow the Quran only make him out to be just the messenger as if he is a middle man and we only follow the Quran
But the Quran and the teachings of our prophet go hand in hand, after all he was sent down to us as a role model and he was the best of all us Muslims; so if there’s an authentic hadeeth of how he used to act we should follow that as we want to please Allah and be the best Muslims we can.
I hope this clears things up for you
@@bkbrown6281 Mentioning his name is not the issue. You can mention the fact that you follow the religion of Abraham or Muhammad in your prayers, that's fine. And God mentions the same in the Qur'an
The problem is that the majority of Muslims today follow prophets Bukhari and Muslim (and others), as well the word of their scholars and take all this as divine law and commandments. This is expressly prohibited by God in the Quran when he says the Jews and Christians take their monks and scholars as their lords.
@@bkbrown6281 And this is the shirk that the majority of Muslims do today. It is part of modern mainstream Islam that we should follow the word of these people to interpret the word of God for us.
If you do that, you follow THEIR word, not God's. Especially so, when they then give you additional commandments that supposedly the Prophet gave out which are not found in the Qur'an.
...Yet the Qur'an says that guidance comes only from God, not from the prophet or from anybody else. And it warns the prophet that God should strike him down dead if he were to try to guide the people with something other than what God has revealed to him in the quranic message.
Please point out those 20 places to me. I would like to learn.
I follow the Quran and the sunnah, but the thing I find hard is the prophet himself couldn’t verify the things that is now in the books of the Hadith. I follow them but that’s something that annoys me a bit. My wish is to really talk to the prophet and that he explained the Quran to me. May Allah bless all of us and lead us to the right path and heaven.
The Hadith in books are verified by many of his companions. Not just single Hadith allocated to 1 .
Some Hadiths have been verified by over 40 companions.
Each have their category. And their is over 10,000 authentic Hadiths.
@@haroondabbagh2869 Yeah thanks brother. I just watched a video of dr zakir naik explaining the science of the Hadith. May Allah grand you paradise and bless you
@@br4885 learn the science of hadith..often happened to quranist that they always criticised hadith but never understand how the hadith being recite, recheck, research, & challenged before its been authenticated..at least when u want to criticise some topic, make sure you know the topic well & proper..make sure you know how hadith being done through history, how narration being check, the dicipline, rule, cross reference on it being done, etc2..quranist never learn how hadith work
take a look at muslim who debate christian..they research almost EVERYTHING regarding bible including their history, their concept, their literature from christian expert themselves, etc2..thats why they're debate against christian become proper & well prepared
that is also why quranist will always be caught unprepared when their foundation being challenged face to face verbally..they taught when they come forward & face Muslim, it will be easy peasy because they're confident hadith can be crushed to the ground each & every time..but they forgot that they also have a very fragile belief system due to their nature of interpreting quran by just using logic..thats why its very, very hard to see any face to face debate where quranist managed to prove their belief with demonstration on how they practice with prove EXACTLY like what Allah commanded them to do, like solah, fasting or even hajj..they can only talked confidently when they're alone & no one debating them & challenge their point
Which sahaba verified it? Why didn’t the sahaaba wrote Hadiths themselves in the the presence of prophet? If it was verified then why do you have 4 different imaams with different Hadiths books, sahabas were not even present in the world when bukhari wrote Hadiths books.just Google for contradictions in Hadiths you will know how great those books are.
@@Yas0237 you are deceiving yourself. Hadith is not divine literature and it IS NOT from the prophet or any of the messengers. May God guide you to the straight path the path of those He has favored not those who incur wrath or those who are astray
Whoever is reading this, I pray that May Allah (SWT) bless you with endless happiness, fulfill all your dreams, aspirations & respond to your duas. May Allah (SWT) reward you with a home in Jannah.
Quran alone ❤❤❤
hadith is required
@@justfootball7998 hadith came at 9th century. Prophet lived in 6th century. Im following Prophet path by following the quran
hadith has prophets life,his sunnah etc...like do u believe in Mahdi or Dajjal? they r talked about in hadith and not Quran..do u believe in them??@@FaithfulIslamicReminders
we have to obey Allah and his Messenger
@@justfootball7998 yes thats why we follow quran alone, mohamed pbuh forbidden to utter any other teachings apart from quran. So hadith is an fabrication done against the quran.
[69:44] Had he uttered any other teachings. لَأَخَذنا مِنهُ بِاليَمينِ [69:45] We would have punished him. ثُمَّ لَقَطَعنا مِنهُ الوَتينَ [69:46] We would have stopped the revelations to him. فَما مِنكُم مِن أَحَدٍ عَنهُ حٰجِزينَ [69:47] None of you could have helped him. وَإِنَّهُ لَتَذكِرَةٌ لِلمُتَّقينَ [69:48] This is a reminder for the righteous. وَإِنّا لَنَعلَمُ أَنَّ مِنكُم مُكَذِّبينَ [69:49] We know; some of you are rejectors. وَإِنَّهُ لَحَسرَةٌ عَلَى الكٰفِرينَ [69:50] It is but sorrow for the disbelievers. وَإِنَّهُ لَحَقُّ اليَقينِ [69:51] It is the absolute truth
imagine, none of the hadiths were written during Muhammad’s lifetime. None of them were signed off by Muhammad.
Meanwhile we have the perfect Quran.
Quran is sufficient for me.
Opening comment is strawman. Most quran-only and quranist folks do not say people shouldn't follow the prophet muhammad (pbuh). In fact I have never heard this. To follow the quran is to inherently follow the messenger.
Frankly nothing should be "automatic", re: from quran to hadith. We are instructed to be thoughtful and deliberate.
I'm disappointed he doesn't address the quranic verses that quranists cite to support their viewpoint. He just puts forth a couple he thinks supports his own. Those to me are too open and non-specific to support his claim.
I myself am more a strong "quran-first" rather than "quran-only" muslim but between them and the conventional wahabist influenced clerics I see stronger support for the former.
I love and appreciate mufti menk even when we differ. I believe he's good hearted and well intentioned. That love inspires honesty and forthrightness which encourages my comment here. Please let's all speak from love for Allah (swt) and his creation inshallah.
May I ask you why you think that quran only is not the way, especially since you seem to acknowledge that there are (Sahih) Hadith that contradict the message of the Quran.
I personally believe that if God says of himself that His word is free of falsehood and contradiction, it is out of question to follow a Source (Hadith) that is full of it. He could never have given an authority over this source, otherwise He would be a liar or simply not worthy of a God.
Also His book is sufficient as a guidance for the believers in which no detail has been left out (6:114-115; 10:37). So why do you believe that there is a need to rely on the Hadith books for guidance?
@@AKhair-fc6pm i agree with you. I was objecting to the mischaracterization of quran-only folks.
@@AKhair-fc6pm which Hadiths contradict the Quran? Quran tells us it is upon the messenger of to make the Quran clear nice try
Hadith is not directly from Angel from Allah. It is from people. You can’t go wrong with just the Quran, nothing in there will lead you astray.
In Quran it's written that Quran is fully ditailled nothing else is shall needed and people like Mufti Ment are spreading false knowledge perposly and not perposly please read Quran it is Fully ditailled and Lord Allah says in Quran that Quran should be understood properly so you can read it in any language but this days people just read it in Arabic even though they don't understand Arabic
you wont know how to pray without the hadith, end of discussion right there
HE WILL LOSE HES JOB IF HE STARTS FOLLOWING THE QURAN ALONE! THEY CHANGED THE SAHADA, SALAAT, ZAKAT, SAWM, CALENDAR, HADJ AND ADDED MANY THINGS. IF YOU ONLY KNEW SOME ARABIC AND DARE TO READ THE QURAN AND COMPARE IT WITH THE RELIGION OF BUKHARI/ALKULAYNI.
QURAN IS SUFFICIENT, 16:89!
16:89 AND THE DAY WE SEND TO EVERY NATION A WITNESS AGAINST THEM FROM THEMSELVES, AND WE HAVE BROUGHT YOU AS A WITNESS AGAINST THESE. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED.
True tbh the Quran says it is a sufficient admonition. And does NOT mention the Sunnah of any Prophet, it mentions only "Sunnah of Allah". But to learn the great character of the Prophet SAWS will benefit you, he was a very very wise man! Just be careful dont believe blindly and look into the authenticity carefully
@@nadjiguemarful u can't trust books which have errors and fabrications.. It means that they are not inspired by God.. So that's why we know the ahadith are fabricated and that's why we do not follow a single hadith.
Just because there are some ahadith invented that speak "good" about Muhammad, doesn't mean we should follow those books...
The Quran speaks about the character of Muhammad. All we need is found in the Quran.. You can't mix truth with falsehood.
I'm not arguing with you guys anymore. No point. They call us "kafir" and "quranists" instead of acknowledging us as muslims. You can't argue with ignorance. When ALLAH says in multiple verses that the QURAN is clear/complete, and the best "Hadith" out there, then I will take what ALLAH told us and apply it to my life. One who follows the "sunnah" and hadith that clearly contradicts the QURAN, has no right to call us a "kafir." To you is your way, and to us is our way. May ALLAH guide us all. The QURAN is truly the most beautiful/clear/complete book out there and you can't dispute that. You also can't dispute that hadith is prone to mistakes because its MAN-MADE. Whereas the QURAN is the word of ALLAH, 0 mistakes and 0 contradictions.
That's right brother, arguing with these folks is pointless. Follow and apply the noble message of ALLAh SWT in your life and you're all set. They love arguing for the sake of arguments.
Salam.
@Sébas Rejection is a Very strong and Misleading word.. I think Trust is more Apt.. The Quran needs no Justification, chain of narration’s etc.. The Hadith do.. The Quran is Infallible Word of Almighty.. The Hadith need to be checked for authenticity.. The Quran is superior to Hadith.. In Every Way.. Can’t compare the two.. Quran is the Article of Faith, the Hadith aren’t.. That doesn’t mean I’m Rejecting the Hadith, It’s just that I trust the Quran much more than the Hadith.. and if the two contradict each other, The Quran is the one to be Followed and Adhered to.. Hope it clears it all
Assalamualaikum brother
I have been tagged this derogatory 'Qur'anist' term by people and it hurts. But the truth is, I follow the way Prophet Muhammad SAWW performed the Hajj, Salat, Saum...but the hadith are where I have troubles following. Prophet Muhammad SAWW is Rehmatullil Aalameen and al-Muallim, we must have faith in him....but the hadith, many of them are problematic and contradict Qur'an and Prophet's SAWW compassionate character
Then they say rejecting Hadith is rejecting Quran even though they can’t find a single unambiguous verse that says follow other sources.
@@billybro1403Oh I saw you in another video. Sorry if I misunderstood you as a Hadith follower.
Those who claim Quran is enough and Hadeeth ain't needed will eventually be astray.
Such claim are same as saying I only need the chemistry book I don't need a teacher to teach/demonstrate/explain
How can any Muslim make such claim when the Prophet s.a.w was the PERFECT EXAMPLE OF QURAN.
Are you claiming you can follow the Quran more than the man who Allah chose to send it to?
Let that sink in...
Never thought of it this way brother
Words of wisdom 👏👏 SubhanAllah
The Quran clearly states the sole duty of the Messenger is to deliver God’s message and ayahs. Every hadith there is is narrated on the authority of Abu simon or whoever it is. Then it is further authenticated by some men you and I do not know. Sahih Bukhari has several contradictions. Doesn’t God forbid us to not follow other books? He says the Messenger follows the Quran so follow him (IN THE QURAN).
Why doesn’t any single Muslim here know the Quran? If they did they would know that Mufti Menk misquoted the verse. It’s talking about distributing wealth. The fact that NOT ONE person caught this proves to me Muslims do not care about God enough to learn his book which is actually fard.
Let that sink in!
As for gains granted by Allah to His Messenger from the people of ˹other˺ lands, they are for Allah and the Messenger, his close relatives, orphans, the poor, and ˹needy˺ travellers so that wealth may not merely circulate among your rich. Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it. And whatever he forbids you from, leave it. And fear Allah. Surely Allah is severe in punishment
@@laylaa5445 it’s going to take time to reverse hundreds of years of tradition. I for one don’t necessarily reject hadiths, if they don’t contradict the Quran, and it helps me to pray a bit more or helps me to help other people, insha’Allah. Perhaps if we as an Ummah can find a way to incorporate everyone to find a well balanced structure of things so we can be united instead of division and arguing. But Allah(swt) knows best.
@@JigglyPlatypus My brother The Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is sent as a source of guidance so you follow the guidance of the Prophet so that they further explain what the Quran has said. And it is nowhere that every Muslim MUST memorize the Holy Quran it is Fard Kafaya so please please please get your beliefs straight.
Quran = Word of God
Hadith = Words of humans
Simple
wrong.. its not that simple.. its more than that.. QURAN = THE TRUTH!! hadeeth of bukhari = LIES and SLANDER against The Prophet.
Taghut of Bukhari Muslim and the other four books of LIES. books of HADEETH
@@kyedean9698 do you believe in the qira'at?
@@ockbah Qiraat?? Which qiraat?? Maalik and malik?? The seven ahruf? Is that it?
Pardon my ignorance, what do you mean by "do you believe in qiraat"?
@@kyedean9698 qira'at mean recitations and yes for example ملك and مالك do you believe both of them are quran? If yes how do you prove that from the Quran?
@@ockbah ?? Do i believe both of them are Quran??
Why do you assume its both? Did The Messenger received the Quran maalik and malik??
Who authorize the reading of maalik and malik?
45:6 “These are Allah’s revelations that we recite to you truthfully. In what Hadith after Allah and His revelations do they believe?”
The messenger is the Quran. Come see how Mr. Mufti
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t
Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
@@Randomhandlename i 100% agree with u brother, pls send me the verses
@@Randomhandlename Believers knew how to pray before hadiths. Even after having been given a clarifying Quran verse, you still choose to believe man-told stories/hearsay/hadith. Quit trolling, who sent you, Shaytan?
@@peace_seeker5545 then tell me how you pray from beginning to end explaining each step in detail why are you silent about the clarification of Quran from the messenger as mentioned in the Quran? Do you disbelieve in that part of Quran do you have clarification of the Quran from the messenger? Quran says it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear do you disbelieve and reject this part of Quran?
Its not that i dont believe in Allah, its a concern because Allah never told us to follow the Hadeeth. Its the same cycle as the Torah and Talmud.
obey ALLAH and sunnah of Prophet
@@justfootball7998 so you think the Quran is not Mohammed’s (saw) Sunna but a Book from a man that Never Met the Prophet is?
@@473REEalhamdulillah people are waking up
Allah subhanahu wata’ala told us everything we need to know in the quran
Actually he did, go to the Muslim Lantern video about Hadith Rejectors and form your own opinion. It is clear in the quran that we have to obey the messenger and quran transmission is through isnads just like the hadith if you actually study it. We can tell what is fabricated and what isn't. Abrogation of verses and all that fascinating read.
Quranism only makes sense if you don't ponder on the quran. The hadith were written while he sallallahu aleyhi was salam was alive. Dig deep
Should we then believe Paul was a messenger too if we are to follow people outside the prophet?
By the way we need to stop calling each other Sunnis or Shias etc., we are only Muslims. That is all
Yes brother shia sunni created by humans only be MUSLIMS
Absolutely correct
جزاك الله خيرا.. لكن ماذا نسمي من يسب الصحابة وامهات المؤمنين ويطعن فيهم 🌷
The thing is Shia and Sunni are different. Thus, one should clearly state which is which to avoid confusion.
ua-cam.com/video/rdktL7-esW0/v-deo.html
Salaamalaikum! Thank you for your videos i really appreciate them and love watching your content.
My brother and I converted to Islam 3 years ago, Alhamdulillah!
Your fellow brother from El Salvador 🇸🇻
وَعَلَيْكُمْ السَّلاَمُ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ
Peace I hope for your sake u stay away from Hadiiths n stuff
Salaam u aliykum amigo may Allah bless you and your family in this world and the next ameen
There’s an issue in the first sentence. He said that Quran-only people say only follow the Quran and don’t follow the Prophet’s sunnah. But he assumes that the truth of Hadith and Sunnah attributed to the Prophet’s sayings and actions, respectively. Moreover, there is a strawman being made here as well. He props up the strawman that Quran-only folks don’t believe in obeying the prophet, and knocks down this strawman. Quran-only folks do believe in obeying the prophet, but they are skeptical about the Hadith and Sunnah attributed to the prophet. There is a distinction between obeying the prophet and obeying what is attributed to him.
(9:5) And when the forbidden months have passed, kill the idolaters wherever you find them and take them prisoners, and beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they repent and observe Prayer and pay the Zakat, then leave their way free. Surely, Allah is Most Forgiving, Merciful.
Can you explain the verse 9:5 without using hadith?
@@FM-kl1wv Yes. God says in chapter 2 that fighting is ordained for those who are attacked first. In other words, you have a right to fight someone who attacks you first; that’s basic self-defense. At 9:13, God says that the people to be killed at 9:5 attacked the messenger and the believers first. Not only did they attack first, they broke their covenant with the messenger and the believers. Imagine signing a peace treaty with someone and then they attack you and break the treaty; it’s a betrayal and can be an ambush. If someone is willing to betray peace treaties then one becomes highly untrustworthy in the eyes of every party, whether spectating or involved.
@@FM-kl1wv 9:13
@@Lightbulb909 it talks about a treaty which they have to keep, so if they break the treaty you can kill them?
Logic: Quran is the basis for everything and must be accepted. Hadiths that don’t contradict the Quran you can choose to accept. But if hadiths contradict the Quran then those are dismissed. Salam
There’s not a single authethic, that contradicts the Quran. The Quran and authethic and Sunna always goes together.
@@user-br1qk6mt6k well said
@@user-br1qk6mt6k Reason why scholars had to “authenticate” it was because some hadiths contradicted the Quran.
@@lostwisdom7789 u have to define Hadith , these are the sayings and teachings of Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم the weak hadiths aren’t hadiths in the first place there weak or fabricated for a reason. Because they were never the sayings of the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم but the hadiths which are actually the sayings are aligned with the Quran. And just to let you know that’s not how it’s worked out it’s authethicated based on chains and the narrator whether they are trustworthy whether they were there during the event who did hear it from and their biography it’s a whole science in the field of hadiths. But The Hadiths (Sayings/Teachings of Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) are aligned with the Quran.
@@user-br1qk6mt6kwhen it says to Obey Allah and His Messenger, can you honestly say that that ayah was going to refer to some hadiths made 200+ years after his death? By the way, I do not want to do away with hadiths they are there for a reason and Allah knows best. What our generation needs to figure out is how to assimilate every school of thought and unify ourselves. That is all I want to accomplish. And if it comes to reject all hadiths so we can unify then I am all for that. But if we can find a balanced way to incorporate every school of thought in a balanced structure of Islamic theology and ideology and we can keep the hadiths then I am for that as well. Salam
The prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was instructed to pass on the message that is the Qur'an and NOTHING but the holy Qur'an. It also says if the prophet prohibits something, it is as if Allah swt prohibited it. People take this line as a misconception. This helps us to understand that we should only follow the Qur'an. Other evidence is when in the Qur'an it says, any deviation from the Qur'an by the Prophet would result in severe punishment. The Qur'an also tells us many many times to not distinguish among the prophets for they are all equal. People nowadays put Prophet Muhamad above the rest of the messengers which is simply Idolatry. Research brothers and sisters and you will find that the Hadith and Sunnah, although they provide life lessons and what not, are merely he-said she-said. The only true instructions we need are within the holy Qur'an. Allah swt said the Qur'an is perfect, fully-detailed, and is the only thing you need for salvation. Stop calling the prophet's name during the Adhan, Stop putting the prophet's name on mosques right next to the name of Allah, and please understand that even the prophets will enter Jannah by Allah's mercy the same way that we will insha'Allah. If you want proof based on the holy Qur'an and nothing but the Qur'an please go to submission.org where you will see the mathematical miracle that actually shows us how to pray as the Qur'an intended and not how all the scholars change it today. RESEARCH please brothers and sisters and you will realize how terribly far we are from the pure religion of Islam. La illaha illa ALLAH.
I agree with you brother. But at the same time, the hadiths have their place and we should find a middle ground to unite the Ummah once more!!!!!!!
@@lostwisdom7789 yes of course this would be the best course of action only IF we absolutely KNEW that when we deem a Hadith to be Sahih it is actually true. The unfortunate thing is there are hadiths that are deemed to be sahih and they are not. There is evidence from the Quran that negates any truth to some of these sahih hadiths. I know it is very disturbing and hard to believe such a thing as what I’m about to say, but the truth is even our beloved religion of Islam, which is meant to provide peace and order to the submitters of Allah swt, there lies corruption and error in places we do not even notice. Allah swt said in the Qur’an that he purposely placed enemies for the prophets just so they may trust in Allah even more so. I promise you and anyone out there, the Research is already done and available. There is truth within the Qur’an that we haven’t even reached. Miracles we do not know. Messages hidden for different times. My favorite verse in the whole Qur’an, “Over it is nineteen”. Research please.
@@lostwisdom7789 most hadeeth are simply LIES about the prophet, the messenger and above all, LIES about The Creator. Hadeeth Qudsi is the worst!
Excellent ❤️❤️
@@kyedean9698 thanks, I’ll look into it
You are misleading innocent Muslims. Allah only revealed the Quran and our Nabi's job was to deliver it to the ummah. No hadeeth no fiqh or any other man made book is required.
HE WILL LOSE HES JOB IF HE STARTS FOLLOWING THE QURAN ALONE! THEY CHANGED THE SAHADA, SALAAT, ZAKAT, SAWM, CALENDAR, HADJ AND ADDED MANY THINGS. IF YOU ONLY KNEW SOME ARABIC AND DARE TO READ THE QURAN AND COMPARE IT WITH THE RELIGION OF BUKHARI/ALKULAYNI.
QURAN IS SUFFICIENT, 16:89!
16:89 AND THE DAY WE SEND TO EVERY NATION A WITNESS AGAINST THEM FROM THEMSELVES, AND WE HAVE BROUGHT YOU AS A WITNESS AGAINST THESE. AND WE HAVE SENT DOWN TO YOU THE BOOK AS A CLARIFICATION FOR ALL THINGS, AND A GUIDANCE AND A MERCY AND GOOD TIDINGS TO THOSE WHO HAVE SUBMITTED.
Preach brother! Preach!
o Yeah !
If he turns to Allah alone , he wil be indeed in danger ! I know many women which are probably too scared of their community .
BROTHER, please could you send me the verses in the Quran on how to do Salah and how to do wudu and ghusul
if Quran is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
When Allah alone is mentioned they frown. When Quran alone is mentioned they frown.
may Allah guide you
Because they are Mushriks
@@bdndella69You frownded. Why when your God and his book was mentioned?
@@bdndella69 You proved him right lol.
I'm not a Muslim but I follow and listen to every word he says and there's such wisdom such passion I just wish people would know how beautiful Islam is ❤️
@Tamina K I'm not blind everyone has their religion that they believe in but it doesn't mean you have to shut yourself out from what others believe their is wisdom in the appreciation of what others hold dear and believe in
@@tafsirislamicreminders6298 thank you Abdul i will have a listen 👏
@@kelvinwaruri180 Sorry Kelvin, some people don’t realize their rudeness can drive others away! May Allah Bless and guide you
@@HCam-xh3yb thank you so much and it's okay everyone is entitled to their opinion and that was there's I'm just grateful for people like you who are open minded and spread love we all need that in this life and thank you may Allah also bless you
Welcome to Islam please it lead you paradise I beg you
Mufti didn't mention this ayah. So am mentioning it. Allah said ,"Say if you were to love Allah then follow me Allah will love you and will forgive your sins...."
I honestly didn't expect a heart. JazakAllah Khair😇😇😊
@Shaik Abdus Salaam In Surah Al Imran. ayah 31
Follow me because he sallahu Allah Salam is Following the Quran and showing everyone how to apply it to their lives.
@Nyilas Karod Wa Iyak
@@mushrafulislam9113 how would you receive the message unless you followed him silly.
Allah is sufficient to me ... As His Messenger already said ;
" I only follow what was revealed to me ." ( 10 : 15 ) I fear Allah , you are insane if you don't . But you are already taking verses out of context , and lying about us .. May Allah give you what you deserve .
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t
Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
Surah 17:
18. Whoever desires the fleeting life, We expedite for him what We decide to give him, to whomever We desire. Then We consign him to Hell, where he will roast, condemned and defeated.
19. But whoever desires the Hereafter, and pursues it as it should be pursued, while he is a believer; these-their effort will be appreciated.
20. To all-these and those-We extend from the gifts of your Lord. The gifts of your Lord are not restricted.
21. See how We have favored some of them over others; yet the Hereafter is greater in ranks, and greater in favors.
22. Do not set up another god with God, lest you become condemned and damned.
23. Your Lord has commanded that you worship none but Him, and that you be good to your parents. If either of them or both of them reach old age with you, do not say to them a word of disrespect, nor scold them, but say to them kind words.
24. And lower to them the wing of humility, out of mercy, and say, “My Lord, have mercy on them, as they raised me when I was a child.”
25. Your Lord knows best what is in your minds. If you are righteous-He is Forgiving to the obedient.
26. And give the relative his rights, and the poor, and the wayfarer, and do not squander wastefully.
27. The extravagant are brethren of the devils, and the devil is ever ungrateful to his Lord.
28. But if you turn away from them, seeking mercy from your Lord which you hope for, then say to them words of comfort.
29. And do not keep your hand tied to your neck, nor spread it out fully, lest you end up liable and regretful.
30. Your Lord expands the provision for whomever He wills, and restricts it. He is fully Informed, Observant of His servants.
31. And do not kill your children for fear of poverty. We provide for them, and for you. Killing them is a grave sin.
32. And do not come near adultery. It is immoral, and an evil way.
33. And do not kill the soul which God has made sacred, except in the course of justice. If someone is killed unjustly, We have given his next of kin certain authority. But he should not be excessive in killing, for he will be supported.
34. And do not go near the orphan’s property, except with the best of intentions, until he has reached his maturity. And honor your pledge, because the pledge involves responsibility.
35. And give full measure when you measure, and weigh with accurate scales. That is fair, and the best determination.
36. And do not occupy yourself with what you have no knowledge of. The hearing, and the sight, and the brains-all these will be questioned.
37. And do not walk proudly on earth. You can neither pierce the earth, nor can you match the mountains in height.
38. The evil of all these is disliked by your Lord.
39. That is some of the wisdom your Lord has revealed to you. Do not set up with God another god, or else you will be thrown in Hell, rebuked and banished.
😁😁😁😁
SubhanaAllah!
This only shows that memorizing and reciting the Quran does not mean one understands its message nor do we follow it.
If Mufti Menk can stand here and mention the verse « … take what the messenger gives etc… » to support his follow-Hadiths-theory, I am sorrry to say that he is being disingenuous as he should know the CONTEXT of that verse which deals with spoils of wars!
The messenger of Allah only spoke and delivered what was revealed to him as Quran! That’s it! When you follow Hadiths understand that you’re following man-made statements attributed to The Messenger…
No wonder why Prophet Muhammad, ALLAH’s messenger will say in 25:30: Oh ALLAH, my people have abandoned this Quran.
Stick to Quran people, these Hadiths will only bring shame and deception to you.
Wasalaam
Only the rightious believers will heed your call brother. Worry not about the hypocrites and deniers.
Salam.
@@peace_seeker5545 Sunnis and shias are idol worshippers.
Musa (pbuh) given 1 book "The Torah", Dawood (pbuh) 1 book "The Zabur", Isa (pbuh) 1 book "The Injil", Muhammad (pbuh) 1 book "The Quran". All the Prophets followed that which was given to them by Allah SA. Using traditional understandings where are the Hadiths of Musa, Dawood or Isa?
Correct! They weren't any extraneous text used by any of the prophetical figures mentioned above. Shalom! Salaam! Peace!
A lot of people forget Book 1 are the Scrolls of Ibrahim.
Have you ever heard of the Talmud?
@@xXEbuZocktHD68Xx Perhaps I have mistaken The Talmud for another text, but doesn't it say that Jesus was born of Mary and an evil spirit, and that Jesus is in Hell, boiling in his own excrement. Isn't there also a case where Rabbis debate and overrule God on Mosaic Law, to which He concedes: "My children have defeated Me."
If so, how is this from God?
The original texts have been lost/corrupted/mixed and oral tradition
The real issue you don’t know how to pray
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
There is no Torah, Zabur nor Injil left, how do you expect their words to make it to the 21st century?
Correct, their words could not have made it to the 21st century because their words would go against the now changed holy books. Shalom, Salam, Peace
yes i say follow Quran only... and following Quran doesn't mean you dont have to follow Prophet Muhammad (saw) ... the Quran was given to our Prophet... He (saw) taught the Quran to the people.. He never taught what Allah has not decreed to him... and hadiths are chain of narrations...one who wrote hadith he himself never saw Prophet Muhammad (saw)... Allah says in the Quran itself that the Quran is complete...
Every Hadith is narrated by someone who saw the prophet.
The Quran tell you to follow hadith which is the sunnah. (Obeying the messenger.
If you don’t do this
You’re disobeying the Quran
@@haroondabbagh2869 no, you are indeed disobeying God, if you follow the Hadith:
A Sahih Hadith contradicting 2:256 and 24:2:
Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2158
Abu Umamah bin Sahl bin Hunaif narrated that on the day of siege, 'Uthman bin 'Affan stood overlooking the people, and he said:
"I swear to you by Allah! You know that the Messenger of Allah (s.a.w) said: 'The blood of a Muslim man is not lawful, except for one of three (cases):Illegitimate sexual relations after Ihsan (having been married), or apostasy after Islam, or taking a life without right, for which he is killed.' By Allah! I have never committed illegitimate sexual relations, not during Jahiliyyah nor during Islam, and I have not committed apostasy since I gave my pledge to the Messenger of Allah (s.a.w), and I have not taken a life that Allah had made unlawful. So for what do you fight me?"'
The Quran is a detailed revelation: 6:114-115; 10:37; 6:119; 6:126; 7:52; 9:11; 11:1; 18:54 and more.
Any source of Guidance other than the Quran (e.g. Hadith) are full of contradictions: 4:82
If you believe that God's words are Truthful, Perfect and free of falsehood, then a book that is full of falsehood (be it even only one contradiction) cannot be from Him. Otherwise God is a liar that contradicts Himself and therefore not a real God.
@@haroondabbagh2869 the hadith was written down after the Prophet PBUH's death... so how are you even sure if its 100% reliable?
Exactly! Do not let the shaytan led you astray !
@@haroondabbagh2869 no the Quran does not tell you to follow the hadith
This is the equivalent of Menk saying something like: "No... don't trust JUST the quran, also trust me and the other muftis"
Nah he is saying to trust the prophet as Quran commands you
@@chailouai3084 does "trust the Prophet" mean to trust "hadiths" which were written after the Prophet's death?
@@ExtremeCrafter Quran as well was compiled after prophet's death so what's your point?
@@ExtremeCrafter and its interesting how hadith rejectors are always ignorant on history of quranic compilation
@@chailouai3084 people wrote down the verses before, it was compiled after his death.
Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day, and remembers Allah often. Al qur an. 33:21
And how do you perform Wudu? And salah? Are you following A’LLah and His Messenger?
Yes
I follow Sunnath e Rasoolullah.
@@a.m.hajamydeen2504where in the Quran does it refer the Sunnah to the Messenger? It’s always referred to as follow A’LLah’s Sunnah. Where is the salah you perform?
Can you reference where in the Quran it says Sunnah of the Messenger?
Also, reference where in hadith it has the salah instructions?
And one last question. How do you perform Wudu?
@@sirchale9272 //
You have asked so many questions.
My first comment surah 33:21 Allah mentioned "the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example" (uswatun hasana) what is the meaning of "excellent example". Pls explain me first.
Say: "If you love Allah, then follow me and Allah will love you and forgive your sins." (Surah Al `Imran: 31)
What is the meaning of "follow me "
@@a.m.hajamydeen2504 25:30 The Messenger will say, “Ya Rabbi, indeed my people have abandoned the Quran.” I adhere to the Hikma, the Nur, the Huda , etc, that is in the Quran, which is A’LLah’s instructions to us through HIS servant the Prophet Muhammed. Therefore I’m not abandoning the Quran. You have chosen to abandon it, Brother/Sister bc you choose the guidelines of a unverified source over the Quran.
If your Wudu is not from Quran, you have abandoned it. And that is just one example. You know the Quran is true bc A’LLah’s promise that it will be protected and that it has no contradictions.
Bukhari and the 6 other books , you don’t even know who the people were. That is not protected.
with ALL due respect to the Messenger , by your logic we should Follow our Mailman who brings a letter from authority. Allah says "Follow the MESSENGER" not "The Prophet" Allah refers to BOTH consistently thorough out the Quran. The Hadith has been placed equal with the Quran, is NOT sealed, is Not protected, is Not revealed by the divine. it is Correct that following the Quran Will be following the path of the prophets-yes. So why push books written by men and hijacked by jesuits? Follow the Message. It IS sealed, locked, and protected.
The messenger's only duty is to deliver the message, so the only way to obey somebody who has one job is to accept that message.
He had other duties besides being a messenger of course, such as being a warrior, a husband, the leader of a nation, but in regards to delivering Allah's revelations, he can not change them or translate them, but only deliver them.
@@yobro6053 - I agree 100%. Follow THEE MESSAGE (commands, and suggestions of Allah) When someone says, "In order to do that, you have to dress like the mailman did," or follow what his friends claim he said, it becomes more about The messenger than the message. and we have the nonsense and superstition we have today
@@restlessnative3818 Yep, and remember 'I only follow what is revealed to me, for I fear the torment of an awesome Day, if I were to disobey my Lord.' Quran, Chapter 10, verse 15 . People today are following what was revealed to the 'sahaba',what they saw ect, but you are only supposed to follow what was revealed to the rasul.
@@yobro6053 -Salaam. My theory is just as the other religions were hijacked (false christianity , judaism , etc.) Islam was attacked from the inside out. Abdul Wahab and the JESUIT creation of thousands of false hadith along w BRITISH creation of "Saudi" Arabia turned a universal way of life into a superstitious man-worship religion. The ancient Christians wrote about beings known as Archons being responsible for the spiritual hijackings. It's obvious w Islam it happened. From High Science and Philosophy to.. superstitious , cosmetic nonsense.
@@restlessnative3818 exactly I believe in this theory as well! All praise belongs to the Almighty. I am so happy others see through the deception.
hadith has given rise to both Hypocrites and Extremists within Islam. Allah sent down the Book in which is balance. Allah knows best.
@Hamid Hussein right. Technically speaking there are no set times exactly like 1 o’clock, 2 o’clock etc., it only says either ends of the days, at night, etc., so technically just as long as you get your salat in within those time ranges you are good to go.
@Hamid Hussein brother guidance is only from Allah. By your statement Shia also follow the Hadith because they pray at those times.
What you forget to say is that the prophet Muhammad himself prevented his people not to write anything but quran. So why people wait +150 years after he died to start saying someone told me , someone told me.....why ?
Yeah bro i find that hadith in sahih muslim 3004
He's lying about us and Quran.
We (Quran aloners) don't say
"don't follow the messenger"
We literally say "follow him,
As his way is Quran alone."
And his orders are in Quran
As he ordered from it alone.
/ 98:5, 4:105, 3:128, 3:154.
Sunni-shia Ahadith are baseless,
Not for vain they were not allowed
To be written in Rashidun Khaliphate,
They've no based "Science of Hadith"
Their "IlmarRijal" is a pick & choose
Play of whom they think are right
Merely picking those of status,
While even Prophet didn't know
Some hypocrites as said 9:101.
& Bukhari isn't checked by matn,
it breaks if to compare to Qur'an.
And none of sunni-shia can give
4 witnesses for "Ahadith"/ 24:13,
While Hafs gave 4 for his Qiraat,
So Quran didn't come the same
Way as those fabricated Ahadith
Which were written centuries later.
59:7 is about war gains,
It's only for the poor/ 59:8,
Are Hadiths not for the rich?
Sunnis mess up interpretations.
And the duty of the messenger
Is only to deliver the message,
That's only Qur'an/ 5:99, 14:52.
& In 4:59 there isn't said "follow"
But said "obey", they mistranslate,
& read 4:60, it talks of themselves
Who give laws to transgressions,
& 4:62 refutes Bukhari Hadith 1.
33:66 is also about obeying,
And we obey and follow him.
And if you read that in context
You can see it's of disbelievers
And sunnis always play games
When we show verses like 2:170
That it's not about them but other,
While see the double standards,
So they now say it's about us?
And next verses clarifies that
It's exactly about their likes,
Who obeyed their chiefs
And their nobles instead,
Exactly like how sunnis obey
Their "Khaliphas" made up rules
And their mullas who make fatwas.
And next is even astonishingly clear
That it's about them who invent lies
About the messenger as did Jews
Invent lies about Prophet Musa,
And next is again clarifying that
The Qur'an was given to a human
Cuz Heavens, Earth and mountains
Didn't take the responsibility for it
But a man took, so it's sent to us,
But sunnis ask "why it's not sent
To a mountain, why to a man?"
So that's answered in Quran,
It's to expose the hypocrites
and polytheists as noted there.
And previous verses clarify more
The hypocrites spread false rumors
In Madina, just as sunnis and shias,
So they didn't stop but they went on
So the verse that mufti (fatwa giver)
Is giving is about themselves clearly
Context over and over exposes them.
/ 33:66, 33:64-65, 33:67-68, 33:69-71,
33:72-73, 33:60-62, 2:170-171, 31:21.
Allah is enough for Muslims.
I'm a God only Muslim. In the beginning and before all creation.
Hadiths rejection is not sunnah rejection
Quran is complete. The rasul (Messenger) delivered the message (Quran), following the messenger is following the quran ONLY.
May Almighty Allah Have Mercy on us all and also forgives us our Sins The once we Knows and the Others we Dosent Ameen 😭😭🤲🙏🏻
I'm Qur'an only Muslim. I reject Sunni, Shia, Shafi, Hanafi etc. Please don't argue with me. Let Allah judge me.
You refuse to follow the Prophet. You are going against Quran
No he is not rejecting prophet, he is accepting prophet by following the Quran and avoid the inputs from others which was not supervised by Rasool nor approved by allah. So Quran itself is fulfilled.
@@Kannadipaarvai No you follow Allah by following Quran, but everybody knows you follow the prophets by following his narrations and actions.
@@marioluigi9599 @jock1
FIRST: The Quran is the word of God.
SECOND: The Quran is perfect with no contradictions.
THIRD: The Quran is clear and with no ambiguity.
FOURTH: The Quran is straightforward with no crookedness.
FIFTH: The Quran is complete.
SIXTH: The Quran is fully detailed.
He is the One who brought down upon you the Book containing clear-cut verses that constitute the foundation of the Book, and others which allow multiple meanings. As for those who harbour deviation in their hearts, they pursue the multiple-meaning verses, seeking to cause discord and seeking to interpret it, but none know its true interpretation except God. And those well founded in knowledge say, "We believe in it, all of it is from our Lord." But none will remember except those who possess intelligence. 3:7
They almost diverted you from what We revealed to you so that you would fabricate something else and attribute it to Us, and then they would have considered you a friend.
And had We not made you stand firm, you almost leaned towards them a little.
And in that case, We would have made you taste double in life and double in death, and you would have found no one to support you against Us. 17:73-75
A revelation (Quran) from the Lord of the worlds.
Had he falsely attributed any sayings to Us,
We would have grabbed him by the right,
and We would have severed his aorta.
None of you would be able to prevent it. 69:43-47
We did not leave anything out of the Book. 6:38
Shall I seek other than God as a lawmaker when it is He who has brought down to you the Book fully detailed? 6:114
The Word of your Lord has been completed, in truth and justice. None can change His words. He is the Hearer, the Knowledgeable. 6:115
This is not a fabricated hadith, but an authentication of what came before it, a detailed account of all things, and guidance and mercy for people who believe. 12:111
We brought the Book down to you providing explanations for all things, guidance, mercy, and good news for the Submitters. 16:89
Those who seek Truth, will see truth. Those who don’t know what they believe in and wanna follow traditions will do that with pride as like rest. I put all my trust,gracious and gratitude only to Allah and obeying Muhammad by only believing Quran Word by Word.
You can follow just the Quran because we follow the prophet (saw) this way anyway
So many Muslims committing shirk without even knowing it … please stick to the Quran only.
How exactly are they commiting shirk? I thought all the muslims only praised Allah and Allah only?
@@dearcath Quran was released because previous scriptures got corrupted.
Now if you follow Hadith which is not directly the words of Allah, and there's doubt that those Hadiths are accurate, quite our prophet didn't write them himself. Hadiths were narrated by people after his death. 250 years after his death. So yeah it's safer not to follow anything contradictory that will not lead us to the straight path. Islam is all about straight path
Okay if you dont wanna follow hadiths Then how are you going to pray.@muniaisworthit
@@cc_islxmic easily. Did Allah tell you to pray like that. Or did man.
Some have ears yet don't listen, and eyes that don't see and hearts that don't heed
Mufti Menk is way off! It is clear for anyone who has a brain, that there is no evidence that Prophet Mohammed quoted anything in the Man Made Hadith! ALLAH clearly forbids any book other than what he reveals. When ALLAH says obey the messenger, he was directly talking to the companions of the prophet and his army that followed him at the time! For example, It is the Prophet who will decide when to go to war, or how much money each person would get from the war booty. So basically ALLAH is instructing the people to not argue with the Prophet. But when it comes to Religion, there can be no other Religion except what ALLAH reveals!
تِلْكَ آيَاتُ اللَّهِ نَتْلُوهَا عَلَيْكَ بِالْحَقِّ ۖ فَبِأَيِّ حَدِيثٍ بَعْدَ اللَّهِ وَآيَاتِهِ يُؤْمِنُونَ (6)
you are calling muslims to follow words of some people over the word of Allah!
not over
@@trollgegael Yes, over!
Notice whenever theres a discrepancy between hadith and Quran (there are many instances this occurs), they supercede/abrogate Quran verses in favor of hadith.
@@jimmybeam1550 where does the hadith overlap the quran?
@@trollgegael every hadith supporter vehemently shouts "show us how do you give zakaat (charity), how do you pray, how to perform hajj (pilgrimage) etc.
Zakaat:
There are many many many verses detailing zakaat in Quran and I must admit the Qurans guidance is very practical as opposed to hadith. They need hadith to detail zakaat is 2.5%, Quran doesn't state a precentage. Do you see how the set percentage method contains fallacies?
Prayer/Hajj:
These are detailed in the Quran aswell.
Furthermore, the Quran doesnt order stoning or human inflicted death sentence punishments in general. These judicial matters are innovations afterthefact. Then theres the additional items declared haraam due to the hadith in contrast to Quran which doesn't declare these items as haraam ie: dogs, music, portraits in homes ect (list is substantially long).
Quran states its a Book of Truth, Guidance, Justice, Mercy and Truth. Furthermore it states Its Clear and contains explanation of All things. Now to say any outside source is required to further supplement the Quran is an oxymoron; a direct contradiction of the Qurans Message.
La ilaha illallah mohammadur rasoolallah.
When God is mentioned alone, then shudder the hearts of those who believe not in the Hereafter, but when those apart from Him are mentioned behold, they rejoice (Qur’an 39:45)
idol worshipper. you should not mention other names next to god. you're becoming like christians who always mention jesus instead of god alone
@@Ox1326 The shahada should be "la ilaha il allah wa aslamto lek ya rab al alamin." "There is no deity except for God, and I submit to you, oh Lord of the worlds." Because this is what Abraham said according to 2:131.
@@eliasziad7864 That’s one way to say it 👍🏾
This video is very wrong.. Taking Quran verses out of context and falsely equating hadith with the Prophet himself... Follow the Quran it's the only divinely sanctioned source of Islamic guidance.
Are you scholars of knowledge? Better than them knows everything about quran? You're an apostate!
How do you pray?
@flexer how do jews and Christians pray?
He is wrong the Quran does not say follow other Hadith. It says follow Quran
Prophet muhamad message is the quran not the hadith
Also it's not easy for a common person to ascertain if the hadith is authentic or not.
There is a huge amount of work and many people who were responsible for studying the authenticity of hadiths. And these people were not people who easily write comments on youtube or easily create a youtube channel...
This is how we assign each prophet an enemy, human devils and jinn, drawing inspiration from embellished and deceptive words. If your Lord had willed, they would not have done it. Leave them and what they make up. (Quran: 6: 112)
Shall I seek another source of laws than God, when He is the One who sent this detailed Scripture down upon you? Those to whom We have given the scripture know that it came down from your Lord with the truth. So don't be among the skeptics. And the word of your Lord is fulfilled in all truth and righteousness. No one can change His words. He is the Audient, the Omniscient. (Quran: 6: 114-115)
And so that the hearts of those who disbelieve in the Hereafter will bow down to it, so that they may take pleasure in it, and acquire what they accomplish. (Quran: 6: 113)
And the Messenger said, "Lord, my people really took this Quran for a neglected thing!" (Quran: 25:30)
These are the verses of God which We recite to you in all truth. So what hadith, after God and his verses, will they believe? (Quran: 45: 6). (also: 7: 185, 77:50 and 31: 6)
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Quran mentions prophet is given wisdom and Quran where’s the wisdom from prophet do you have it? no you don’t
Quran mentions it is upon prophet to make clear the Quran where’s that at do you have it? No you don’t
@@Randomhandlename The Quran is guidance for the believers. The Sunnah(practices of a lot of people during the prophet's time) is how a believer should practice the religion based on dozens of generations dating back to the prophet's time.
Hadiths however are 'stories' gathered hundreds of years after the prophet SAL's passing. Muslims believe in the holy Quran(the message of god through his messenger) and do things how early muslims used to do them during the prophet's time. The rest are hearsay/stories(hadiths).
(Quran: 45: 6)
(Bismillah Al Rahman Al Raheem)
These are the verses of God which We recite to you in all truth. So what hadith(stories), after God and his verses, will they believe?
@@peace_seeker5545 notice how you went completely off topic and didn’t address the points I brought up and did not answer the questions and another lie and propaganda from people like you Hadiths were being written down and memorised at the time of the messenger how come you take some history as facts and reject other as false what criteria are you hypocrites using?
Do you have the clarification of Quran from the messenger Quran mentions that do you have it? That’s why you don’t know how to pray do you have the clarification of Quran from the messenger? Quran says it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear
@@Randomhandlenameok so then why do we have Sura 9:122. Where it tells the believers to devote themselves to the study of the Deen of the Quran so they can inform the Believers on their return of what to be aware of, what they can and can’t do, how to perform duties? So that they may be enlightened and admonished? The Prophet was clearly with them when that verse was revealed. Why didn’t the Prophet just teach it? Why are the Believers at his time being commanded to study the deen? Explain that verse, Brother/ Sister.
The Holy Quran is fully detailed, easy to under to understand , it is clear. The Holy Quran is easy memorize. What other books are going to put your faith on other than The Holy Quran. It is the truth. It is for the righteous.
We need the Sunnah for the Quran Jews do not worship Ezra “The Jews say, "Ezra is the son of Allah "; and the Christians say, "The Messiah is the son of Allah." That is their statement from their mouths; they imitate the saying of those who disbelieved [before them]. May Allah destroy them; how are they deluded?” Quran 9:30
@@somonsomon8244 There is Only ONE GOD ! ONE ! And HE is not a man !
@@adrianabonitaaziz No one said he was a man here
@@somonsomon8244 that is no different than people like you who think that you aren’t following your forefathers
This is how the different sects say that their hadiths are authentic:
“Umm so we have chains of narrations... and Trust me Bro.”
I agree, so many say they follow it but reject it by following other books. I'm trying to tell the truth
Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) said, “Whoever could get one rak`a (of the Fajr prayer) before sunrise, he has got the (morning) prayer and whoever could get one rak`a of the `Asr prayer before sunset, he has got the (`Asr) prayer.” {Sahih al-Bukhari 579}
Muhammad did bring the Hadith! The messenger followed the sunnah of the Quran. The Quran is the best Hadith.
Quran tell us it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear, where’s his clarification of Quran?
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
@@Randomhandlename ocd disorder
There are some verses in the Quran that are not applicable for us today. Such as these ones:
49:2
"O believers! Do not raise your voices above the voice of the Prophet, nor speak loudly to him as you do to one another"
33:53
"O believers! Do not enter the homes of the Prophet without permission ˹and if invited˺ for a meal, do not ˹come too early and˺ linger until the meal is ready. But if you are invited, then enter ˹on time˺. Once you have eaten, then go on your way, and do not stay for casual talk."
So how do we not raise our voice to the Prophet today? How do we not go to his home uninvited? The answer is that these laws were for the people who were living with him when he was alive, tho we can still take the teaching of manners in those verses but we cannot follow everything that's mentioned in there. So I would say that "follow the messenger" is the same, as a former Quran only Muslim, I will tell you that Quranists don't say to ignore and disobey the Prophet, rather they reject the books of hadith as authentic and consider them unnecessary, like the Bible. They would not refuse to obey the messenger if he was still alive.
Where does it say prophet? What translation are you reading?
He misrepresented what quranist believe. Yes we are instructed to follow only the Quran and prophet muhammad, and no one else. Prophet Muhammad's words are in the Quran and they begin with SAY. NOWHERE IN THE QURAN ARE THE HADITHS OR LATER WRITERS MENTIONED. The Quran is very clear about this everything we need is in the Quran and there is nothing else. Islam is easy. The Quran is easily understood. There is no question of its authenticity, there is no finger pointing about authentic hadiths or not authentic, and there is no finger pointing about which madhab is correct. Islam was given to us by Allah, and it is meant to be easy. It was never meant to be divided up into sects like today.
The Quran is all you need. Allah wanted you to follow the messenger while he was alive. He did not say follow the messengers messengers.
How do you know what Allah swt wants and dosnt want..
what a clueless comment..
Stop interpreting things as you fit when you dont have proper knowledge
Mohammed said somethings outside the quran and even explained some of the vocabulary of the quran and people witnessed the context of the ayats like in Surah al Masad it says "abi lahab" and when it was revealed people knew who was abi lahab because they witnessed him while Mohammed was revealing the Surah vocally, so they understood it fully (basically they witnessed the context). All I am saying is learn Islam from a scholar who is from ahl Sunna wa al jama'a or at least give it a chance then reject it if you wish. there was a group in Afghanistan that also used to reject hadith and used to explain the Quran using their "own version of Arabic" not knowing it was revealed with a different Arabic that is 1400 years old and after some time they started understanding it in a very different way and even did some questionable things that were never done by Mohammed and his companions nor by Muslims throughout history. May Allah guide us all
Muslim trinity, Quran, hadith and sunna.
God is One and so is His book.
Enough said.
Hadith is our teacher to learn the Quran, argument end
Holy Quran is words of Allah
Hadiths are NOT words of Allah
The Prophet Muhammad was the first 'Quranist' brothers and sisters, for he followed Qur'an and only Quran, nothing else! This is what Allah revealed to him. Think about it very carefully and logically and you'll see it makes sense.
So these people who say they are guided who follow hadiths are not following or obeying the messenger but some others.
This is a simple fact indeed. Sadly some people want a cosy religion, instead of the inconvenient truth.
Alhamdulillah, A’LLah is truly the One who guides. Alhamdulillah , I have also come to the realization of our Ummah’s folly.
What does A’LLah call a Quranist in the Quran? Ahlul Kitab. A’LLah is the Haqq. Salaam to you and to my true family of the Believers of the Quran.
Correction brother if you don't mind
Prophet was a prophet for the Bani Israel in the style of the previous prophets and the last one in that chain , explaining to them the corruption of the Torah and getting them to make the transition to the Quran
Muhammad was a messenger for those whose forefathers were not warned I e not from Bani Israel these people are called mumineen, the ones who already believed in Allah and his scriptures and understand tawheed are called those who have believed
Believed 👈 pass tense ( ayyuhal latheena amanu )
Believers 👈 presant, future tense ( mumineen )
It's a shame how many people don't know this even myself for 2 decades
Wasn't Muhammads job to explain the Quran in totality he was a messenger, his job was to deliver the messenge and fight for it's revelation and to preserve it through the people which he did
And Allah tells us that our Prophet PBUH is an example to follow, which means to follow him in actions. Our Prophet demonstrated how to obey the commandments and we are to follow him as per Allah's commandments.
@@areejshams3253 You've already got the commandments in Qur'an. You aren't told to follow the prophet's actions you are told to follow and obey the messenger. Following the messenger means obeying the Qur'an. So it's the Qur'an you have to follow.. nowhere does the Qur'an say follow the actions of the prophet Muhammad.
And what Allah restored to His Messenger from the people of the towns - it is for Allah and for the Messenger and for [his] near relatives and orphans and the [stranded] traveler - so that it will not be a perpetual distribution among the rich from among you. And whatever the Messenger has given you - take; and what he has forbidden you - refrain from. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty. - 59:7
This verse is talking about war booty and its distribution not hadith or sunnah. This is what happens when people take verses out of context. Please open your eyes folks.
Well said,
This mufty/mullah knows well the true meaning of the verse but he deliberately did not read all of it to mislead people in order to guide them onto Satan’s path...
All sunny/Shia mullahs deliberately misguide from the path of Allah swt.
yup preach brother
@@McAroni52 And you are misguiding nobody 😅
And Allah said in the quran
.
We sent not a messenger, but to be obeyed, in accordance with the will of Allah. If they had only, when they were unjust to themselves, come unto thee (o Prophet) and asked Allah's forgiveness, and the Messenger had asked forgiveness for them, they would have found Allah indeed Oft-returning, Most Merciful.
.
But no, by the Lord, they can have no (real) Faith, until they make thee (o Prophet) judge in all disputes between them, and find in their souls no resistance against Thy decisions, but accept them with the fullest conviction. (4-64/65)
.
.
This is what happens when people are either unaware or ignorant of the language of the Quran or the depths of the Quranic verses. And Imam Qurtubi writes in the exegesis of these verses (59:7) and this is the view of the vast majority of the companions of the prophet and the scholars and i am unaware of a single scholarly source or a source from the early muslim period or sahaba who confined the meaning to just fai'
.
وما آتاكم الرسول فخذوه وما نهاكم عنه فانتهوا أي ما أعطاكم من مال الغنيمة فخذوه ، وما نهاكم عنه من الأخذ والغلول فانتهوا ; قاله الحسن وغيره . السدي : ما أعطاكم من مال الفيء فاقبلوه ، وما منعكم منه فلا تطلبوه . وقال ابن جريج : ما آتاكم من طاعتي فافعلوه ، وما نهاكم عنه من معصيتي فاجتنبوه . الماوردي : وقيل إنه محمول على العموم في جميع أوامره ونواهيه ; لا يأمر إلا بصلاح ولا ينهى إلا عن فساد .قلت : هذا هو معنى القول الذي قبله . فهي ثلاثة أقوال .قال المهدوي : قوله تعالى : وما آتاكم الرسول فخذوه وما نهاكم عنه فانتهوا هذا يوجب أن كل ما أمر به النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم أمر من الله تعالى
......
.قوله تعالى : وما آتاكم الرسول فخذوه وإن جاء بلفظ الإيتاء وهو المناولة فإن معناه الأمر .وما نهاكم عنه فانتهوا فقابله بالنهي ، ولا يقابل النهي إلا بالأمر ; والدليل على فهم ذلك ما ذكرناه قبل مع قوله عليه الصلاة والسلام : " إذا أمرتكم بأمر فأتوا منه ما استطعتم ، وإذا نهيتكم عن شيء فاجتنبوه " . وقال الكلبي : إنها نزلت في رؤساء المسلمين ، قالوا فيما ظهر عليه رسول الله من أموال المشركين : يا رسول الله ، خذ صفيك والربع ، ودعنا والباقي ; فهكذا كنا نفعل في الجاهلية . وأنشدوه :لك المرباع منها والصفاياوحكمك والنشيطة والفضولفأنزل الله تعالى هذه الآية .قوله تعالى : واتقوا الله أي عذاب الله ، إنه شديد لمن عصاه . وقيل : اتقوا الله في أوامره ونواهيه فلا تضيعوها .إن الله شديد العقاب لمن خالف ما أمره به .
.
the point being and the same is explained by
.
"Although the verse was revealed in connection with fai', its words are general. They are not specific to wealth. They cover all the commands as well. Hence, the generalized meaning of the verse is that whatever the Holy Prophet ﷺ gives to a person, be it wealth, any other grant or any command, the people must show their willingness to accept it. And whatever he forbids them, they should stay away from it.
.
Many of the Companions took the generalized sense of the verse, and on the basis of it, they took the Holy Prophet's ﷺ commandment as binding as the Qur'anic commandment. Qurtubi said that in this verse the antonym of ata [ gives ] is naha [ forbids ]. This shows that the verb ata [ gives ] is used in the sense of amara [ commands ] which is the direct antonym of naha [ forbids ]. The Qur'an, instead of using the direct opposite of naha [ forbids ] which is amara [ commands ], employed the verb ` ata [ gives ] presumably to embrace the context of the subject-matter where the verse occurs, that is, the disbursement of fai' property."
.
And Allah knows best
.
May Allah open your heart.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 All Praises to God ! Alhamdulillah !
And these people are 100% right, allah never mentioned that you have to follow another book or sunnah , nor prophet ever said any person to write a book, so how could we believe a book which is writen 200 years after prophet, not confirmed by any sahaba nor by prophet nor by allah himself
So glad to see so many Quran only Muslims in the comments 🙂
However, remember that we must all respect one another and avoid dividing into sects, as Allah tells us. Sunnis and Shias might be misguided in some aspects but they are still Muslim. All of us are human and we are all misguided in some aspects. May Allah guide all of us to the true path!
Well you have 73 to choose from...
.
Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2640
Narrated Abu Hurairah: that the Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: "The Jews split into seventy-one sects, or seventy-two sects, and the Christians similarly, and my Ummah will split into seventy-three sects."
Classification: Hasan (Good)
Quran only are not Muslims
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
@@Randomhandlename
Dentist: Go take a seat in the waiting room
You: Should I sit with my legs crossed or spread out? Should my arms be folded or resting on my knees? Should I close my eyes or do they have to be open? Am I allowed to lean forward or does my head have to be resting back? Which direction should I be facing? Should I sit on my own or with someone else? Please someone give me a hadith to explain what the dentist wants me to do!
'If Quran by itself is so detailed'
I love how you accuse me of kuffr and then literally commit it yourself with this sentence.
"Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail?" And those to whom We gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters." 6:114
There's no point responding to you any further because at this point you're not arguing with me, you're arguing with the ayahs of the Quran.
May Allah guide you and peace.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah we are not commanded in the Quran to go to the dentist and we will not be held accountable if we don’t go to the dentist or do other things which are not obligatory ritually but for prayer we will be and it’s obligatory upon us to pray so you’re telling me Allah didn’t tell us how to pray? This is what happens when you don’t follow Quran completely and skip some of it or not believe in some it Quran says it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear which is why you don’t know how to pray so funny how do you pray? You don’t even know
I said Quran by itself because that’s what you believe while skipping and not believing in the verse of Quran where Quran mentions it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear which is why you don’t know how to pray because you don’t follow Quran completely that’s why you don’t know how to pray you’re struggling you don’t know how to pray you can’t tell me how you pray from beginning to end each step in detail because you don’t believe in the verse of Quran where it tells you it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear how come you can’t tell me how you pray I asked you if you knew you would’ve answered
So funny
@@Randomhandlename It is not upon the messenger to make the Quran clear. Allah makes the Quran clear and the messenger recites.
"And when We read it, follow thou the reading;" 75:18
"We shall be responsible for its explanation." 75:19
So you’re saying that the Quran is incomplete? Do you stand to object to A’LLah Al’Hakeem’s statement in 6:38 and 6:114 that nothing has been omitted from the Book and that everything in it is without a doubt explained in full detail?
Brothers and Sisters, come back to the Quran. You will gain A’LLah’s forgiveness. The Book is meant for each one of Al’Rahman’s servants , so we can connect to Our Rabb. The Shahada in the Quran is only for A’LLah. No other name should be joined with His. Only A’LLah’s name should be glorified in Salah and in Masjids. They have steered us away from Sole Worship which belongs to A’LLah Alone.
Salah, Wudu, prayer timings and prayers are all in the Book of Guidance. There are no complete compilation prayers in hadiths.
You are absolutely right 👍
The quran is the revelation if you don’t know Mufti:
““19. Say (O Muhammad ): "What thing is the most great in witness?" Say: "Allah (the Most Great!) is Witness between me and you; this Qur'an has been revealed to me that I may therewith warn you and whomsoever it may reach. Can you verily bear witness that besides Allah there are other aliha (gods)?" Say "I bear no (such) witness!" Say: "But in truth He (Allah) is the only one Ilah (God). And truly I am innocent of what you join in worship with Him."S6/19
Sone people are champions of twisting everything….
There are a lot who follows just the Quran. But I feel good when I follow them both.
Islam should be followed as how Allah has asked you to follow. And not by what makes you feel good
What I meant was the sunna 👍
No, nowadays most of Muslims follow hadith and not the Quran. You must follow the book of Allah (Quran)
@@blubber6490 Hadiths are for clarification
Following the messenger doesnt mean we have to follow the hadith. The prophet preached only the Quran and nothing else for religious belief. So when we follow the quran we are obeying the messenger. It is people who follow hadith who are disobeying the messenger.
may Allah guide you
@@Athawriand may you ask Allah to guide you :) I hope one day you will realise that Allah and the messenger want us to follow the Quran only because thats what the prophet preached from Allah. Not hadith :)
Just verify hadith using Qu'ran. If the hadith doesn't go against Qu'ran then that means it could be a hadith. Then we check the actual reliability. If it goes against it isn't a hadith. Simple. A lot of the signs of the day of judgement are written in hadith. While Umar (May Allah be pleased with him) is said to have burnt hadith books. As the Ummayad caliphate began. They didn't put Islamic laws in place and didn't really care about the people. Reliability of hadith had gotten so bad that Umar II had to officially make a reliable hadith book
@@thegamerkhan when you start to take the Quran seriously and you realise that Allah so many times says that the book is complete and fully detailed and that you should not follow any other book you then start to notice that the concept of hadith goes against the whole Quran.
Allah told the rasul in the quran to say, 'i only follow what is revealed to ME'
So how in the world do people think these hadiths were revealed to the messenger when it' written by these people in their own words ? Ridiculous.
Yes, followed the Messenger in his lifetime.
Well People, in fact, men „prove“ that there are authentic hadith. I highly respect you and learn a lot of you but I kindly disagree with you here. The Quran says at very many points that the quran is complete and god has not forgotten a single thing. Maybe you can listen to sunnah in a „spiritual“ way if it helps, but as soon as you get judged by not for example praying like the mainstream Muslims than it is getting dangerous in the peace within the Muslim community.
Do you realize the quran was compiled by men as well ?
@@chailouai3084 I dont know about that. The only thing I know is that it adresses men in the first place.
@@berfons7127 huh ?
@@berfons7127 umm you have something against men?
@@notaknot3768 No, not at all. In fact I love men. But I won't listen to men who are telling me how THEY believe women should act, eat, pray, live. Greetings.
May Allah swt bless you All . Ameen 🤲🏼
Bismillah
Astaghfirullah wa atubu ilaihi
❤ and follow :
Qur'an and sunnah Rasul sallalahu alaihi wassalam
TRY READING QURAN
It says you follow the
Sunnah of Allah.
Not ONCE does it say Sunnah of the Prophet or of Muhammad or of anybody else.
You must have never read the Quran
I honestly would prefer a discussion between a "Quranist", a "Shia" and a "Sunni". Each believes in his heart that he is rightly guided and the rest are in error. I LOVE the Mufti for Allah swt, but he flattens and simplifies the Quranist's logic for his argument here. So I would LOVE for a discussion to be had where all sides present their proofs so we can review and settle it or come close. May Allah guide us. Ameen.
@Abdul Manan Zargar Those in authority means what? Is there a difference between messenger and prophet? What is the lesson of 68:4 and 33:53? Plenty of evidence in the Quran that it's complete, clear, fully detailed, best tafseer. Don't use any other hadith. You are saying otherwise....
(9:5) And when the forbidden months have passed, kill the idolaters wherever you find them and take them prisoners, and beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they repent and observe Prayer and pay the Zakat, then leave their way free. Surely, Allah is Most Forgiving, Merciful.
The verse 9:5 says to kill the non believers. Can someone explain this without using any hadith?
Quran says it is upon the messenger to make the Quran clear
If Quran by itself is so detailed can you give me a verse where it mentions if the eyes should be closed or open if a person should look up or down and when bowing should the hands be on the knees or not should the feet be apart or closed when prostrating and what should be recited during all parts of salah give me clear verses that mention of instructions for all these actions clearly while in salah or performing salah…
Hadeeth bans music when Quran never mentions it. How can music be banned? Music that praise Allah and music that’s talks about life and poverty not bad rap language is banned only comes from hadith
They cite verse 59:7: "...take what Messenger gives and refrain from what her forbids" as a source of justifyiny hadith. This verse is in reference to distribution of goods from a perticular event. Allah makes their intentions clear in verses 3:78 and 5:41-42, see below:
3:78
"And indeed, there is among them a party who alter the Scripture with their tongues so you may think it is from the Scripture, but it is not from the Scripture. And they say, "This is from Allāh," but it is not from Allāh. And they speak untruth about Allāh while they know".
59:7
"And what Allāh restored to His Messenger from the people of the towns - it is for Allāh and for the Messenger and for near relatives and orphans and the needy and the [stranded] traveler - so that it will not be a perpetual distribution among the rich from among you. And whatever the Messenger has given you - take; and what he has forbidden you - refrain from. And fear Allāh; indeed, Allāh is severe in penalty".
They somehow are convinced and try to push the narrative this verse implies hadith but Allah makes it clear in 5:41-42 what their intentions are:
5:41
"O Messenger, let them not grieve you who hasten into disbelief of those who say, "We believe" with their mouths, but their hearts believe not, and from among the Jews. [They are] avid listeners to falsehood, listening to another people who have not come to you. They distort words beyond their [proper] places [i.e., usages], saying, "If you are given this, take it; but if you are not given it, then beware." But he for whom Allāh intends fitnah - never will you possess [power to do] for him a thing against Allāh. Those are the ones for whom Allāh does not intend to purify their hearts. For them in this world is disgrace, and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment".
5:42
"[They are] avid listeners to falsehood, devourers of [what is] unlawful. So if they come to you, [O Muḥammad], judge between them or turn away from them. And if you turn away from them - never will they harm you at all. And if you judge, judge between them with justice. Indeed, Allāh loves those who act justly".
@@jimmybeam1550haditheens can't debate with a quranist that has critical thinking ability.
@@CCP-Lies they are very illogical and manipulative. They mock and ridicule the Quran in justification of hadith. I embraced Islam after thoroughly studying, scrutinizing and critically examining the Quran and came to the conclusion this is the Right Path. The hadith is a distortion of Islam and diversion from the Path of God. I've come to realize the biggest enemies of Islam are those who identify with the religion as so called 'muslims' - we are these fortold of these hypocrites in the Quran itself.
Evidently, they could not alter the Quran so they created hadith, in which it goes to great lengths to associate with the religion.
تِلۡکَ اٰیٰتُ اللّٰہِ نَتۡلُوۡہَا عَلَیۡکَ بِالۡحَقِّ ۖ فَبِاَیِّ حَدِیۡثٍۭ بَعۡدَ اللّٰہِ وَاٰیٰتِہٖ یُؤۡمِنُوۡنَ
1 st comment
Nabi kareem Mohammad Mustafa Sallahu-alye-he-wasallam was muallim (who taught us قرآن not only give it to us as a book ) so there should be a way how he taught sahabas Qur'an so to follow Qur'an we have to follow that also
@@mohamadfazli5575 🙄😂😂😒😵
@@mohamadfazli5575 he means that he made sure that message of Quran n Quran itself in preserved form reach us
Arabic was not created for Quran by Allah so that prophet should teach it to sahabas. Allah revealed the Quran in people’s language Arabic so that they can understand. So there was no need of prophet to teach Arabic to anyone.
He is a Great Speaker Mashallah!
Indeed, he is Ma sha Allah
When I read the verse in the Quran that says the sun sets in a muddy spring I swallowed the fact that Islam is a man made religion even tho i really want it to be true because the Quran is Arabic and I’m an Arab but at the same time I didn’t runaway from the truth and I accept it , في بلاوي راح يكرهوني بسبب هذا التعليق بس خليهم ، راح افتح عيونهم للواقع لمحبتي لهم
Sun sets behind a building from my perspective.
It’s perspective not actual.
Sir I had miscarriage today my husband was by my side in restroom he saw me my pain and he saw the baby fall he said ya Allah mercy us help us just pray for me I know Allah has best plans ya Allah
May Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta’Ala have mercy upon you and your husband and grant you ease and patience dear sister. May you both be reunited with your baby in Jannatul firdous. Ameen ❤️
May Allah (swt) help you please.
Stop folllowing false literature
La ilaha il Allah....... That's it. Were you expecting more? You won't find it. You won't find in me a mushrik, with the Mercy of God.
Which prophet will you be hiding behind on the day of judgement?? Who’s ummah are you from? When he (Muhammad) will be asking Allah for forgiveness for his ummah I’m sure you will be in the crowd behind him.
Or will you be standing all alone by yourself and intercede for yourself?
It will only be one of the questions in your grave, you will be asked “who is this man” (Muhammad) if you didn’t follow his teachings or care about him do you think your heart will allow you to answer?
May Allah guide you Insha’Allah
اَوَلَمۡ یَنۡظُرُوۡا فِیۡ مَلَکُوۡتِ السَّمٰوٰتِ وَالۡاَرۡضِ وَمَا خَلَقَ اللّٰہُ مِنۡ شَیۡءٍ وَّاَنۡ عَسٰۤی اَنۡ یَّکُوۡنَ قَدِ اقۡتَرَبَ اَجَلُہُمۡ ۖ فَبِاَیِّ حَدِیۡثٍۭ بَعۡدَہٗ یُؤۡمِنُوۡنَ
Quran 4:59 - O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.
@@Chud1234 what about those in authority among you?
@@Loveofasufi so how do you pray? How and when do you do hajj? How much and when do you pay zakat? Do you even pray? How do you do wuda? What about Islamic laws? You clearly just want to go clubbing
@@yous2244 things that arent mentioned in the Quran is not worth knowing, also God says our salat is supposed to stop you from doing evil things, I pray standing, say 3-4 lines in my own language such as god has no son, god has no partners, god is alone, god helps you during your hardships etc, salat is remembrance of God.❤️ This way instead of saying it in Arabic where I don't understand a single thing, I get the message and the guidance!
@@wolfblockstrike2924 I pray while swimming and counting sheep
@@wolfblockstrike2924 and I can say without a shadow of doubt, you certainly haven't even read the Quran.
The term Quranist refers to anyone who rejects hadith and sunna and follows Quran Alone as per 17:46.
تِلْكَ آيَاتُ اللَّهِ نَتْلُوهَا عَلَيْكَ بِالْحَقِّ ۖ فَبِأَيِّ حَدِيثٍ بَعْدَ اللَّهِ وَآيَاتِهِ يُؤْمِنُونَ (6)
Thank you
Ridiculous.. Very first verse he brought like saying whatever messenger brought bla bla.. Out context doing people... Shame on those who follow hadith and in the end they definitely reject QURAN..
These are the verses of Allah which we recite to you in Truth. So in what HADITHS besides Allah and His verses will they believe?! Damn every sinful liar! -Quran 45:6-7
@say-subhanAllah-alhamdhulillah capitalization doesn’t exist in Arabic. In Arabic it simply means Hadiths capitalized or not. SubhanAllah
Quran is the word of Allah as well the Bible, as the Quran itself testify. I believe in Allah and his Word is overall.
The hadiths which are authentic 100% can be helpful as support, but overall are the sacred scriptures, Surah 5:48 (just an example). No excuses
The Quran does NOT need the support of any further scriptures......especially Hadeeth sayings. Neither Allah or our beloved Profit authenticated Hadeeth literature. Allah does however mention Hadeeth in the Quran in the context that the Quran is Allah's Hadeeth that we should be following .......and not the unauthenticated Hadeeth scribed Approx. 200 to 300 years after the departure of our Profit.
The Bible is not the word of Allah. The word of Allah came through Prophet Isa at the time, the Bible is a compilation of the gospels of his companions.
They are essentially the equivalent of hadiths.
The equivalent of the Quran for Christian would be the sayings and teachings of Jesus, which are compiled within some of the Bible verses, but are not the Bible itself, making it hard or impossible to follow with 100% certainty on which verse is authentic, and which is not.
God revealed the Quran and it is perfect and complete; God has perfected all things.
[Quran 6:19] Say, "Whose testimony is the greatest?" Say, "God's. He is the witness between me and you that this Quran has been inspired to me, to preach it to you and whomever it reaches. Indeed, you bear witness that there are other gods beside God." Say, "I do not testify as you do; there is only one god, and I disown your idolatry."
[Quran 6:38] We did not leave anything out of this book.
[Quran 7:52] We have given them a scripture that is fully detailed, with knowledge, guidance, and mercy for the people who believe.
[Quran 10:37] This Quran could not possibly be authored by other than God. It confirms all previous messages, and provides a fully detailed scripture. It is infallible, for it comes from the Lord of the universe.
[Quran 12:111] In their history, there is a lesson for those who possess intelligence. This is not fabricated Hadith; this (Quran) confirms all previous scriptures, provides the details of everything, and is a beacon and mercy for those who believe.
The Quran proclaims that the Quran is complete, perfect, and fully detailed. Verses 6:114-115 explain to us what "fully detailed" means. The Quran is fully detailed for religious law and "complete in truth and justice."
[Quran 6:114] Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed? Those who received the scripture recognize that it has been revealed from your Lord, truthfully. You shall not harbor any doubt.
[Quran 6:115] The word of your Lord is complete, in truth and justice. Nothing shall abrogate His words. He is the Hearer, the Omniscient.
Hadiths contradicts with Quran because Quran is perfect. Allah says Quran is all we need. Quran it self is the sunnah and hadith.
Assalaamu alaikum Mufti Sir,Believe me I was searching for this answer since 5 to 6 yrs to reply to such ppl who comes under this category but I couldn't do out of lack of knowledge (ie) though I know but not having any authentic proofs which u mentioned here.Jzk Allah khairan kaseerah
U 've guided me whenever I need any guidance either thru ur videos or daily advisory notes. KEEP Going Sir and STAY BLESSED 😊
@@mohamadfazli5575
Inshaa Allah Brother.
Jzk Allahu khairan kaseerah
This person is a hypocrite and a liar who wants to lead you astray and trades in religion, so how can you believe him?
He even cut off the verse distributing spoils from its context!
I once believed these impostors and believed in the Sunnah, but after referring to the Qur’an, you will know that God did not send down a revelation other than the Qur’an, and that it is complete, detailed, and clear.
And the messenger is nothing but an amount of the message.
@@asmaaabdinasir1742 So is the messenger nothing more than a mailman?
@@marioluigi9599
If the great message of God, which the Messenger pushed and strove to send, does not mean anything to you, then this is your problem
@@asmaaabdinasir1742 Are you crazy? Of course it means something to me
I only asked if he's nothing more than a mailman to you
Allah u akbar may allah give you jannah
Mufti menk plz don’t tell Allah how he should have framed verses. There are various Quranic verses which Allah puts it in a repeatable way. There is no separate meaning if Allah separates it. Allah says in Quran that a person with less imaan will try to dig in the meaning of verses which he cannot understand. So Quran should always be taken at face value with the intention of understanding it rather than deciding it. Its not an encrypted book that people should have special knowledge to understand it.
Al-Jasiyah 45:6
تِلْكَ ءَايَٰتُ ٱللَّهِ نَتْلُوهَا عَلَيْكَ بِٱلْحَقِّۖ فَبِأَىِّ حَدِيثٍۭ بَعْدَ ٱللَّهِ وَءَايَٰتِهِۦ يُؤْمِنُونَ
These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement after Allah and His verses will they believe?
Please don't translate "hadith" as "statement". You cover up and mislead people thereby. People know what hadith means.
Talmud, Paul, "Sahih" hadiths.. History repeats itself
Subhanallah! Jazakallahu Khaira Mufti Menk, May Allah Guide us All. Ameen....
They say Quran is complete and we don't need hadiths... Well yeah Quran is complete in it's own way just like the example of a beautiful poetry which is complete in it's own but still you need a interpretation or original understanding of that poetry because it can be interprete in many ways, and the one who can give the best interpretation or understanding of that quote or poetry is it's creator, and as for the Quran Allah gave the responsibility of it to explain it to others to Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, Alhamdullilah!
#IOFAVidz007👈
So what you are saying is when the Quran says its a Clear message and that it is not poetry that it is...
Yess i agree 👍
In the Quran it’s says we. Need to follow. Wat the prophet. Brought with him. Nd stop wat he told us to stop doing. Here’s the answer.
@@counterdebate in the Quran. Muslims r told to. Follow. Wat the prophet brought to us. Nd stop wat he told us to stop doing. Simple answer. On the basis of this vid
@@ikrammohiuddin1100 sorry brother your English is no clear enough for me to understand what you are askng
Quran is complete, in which there is no doubt. I follow Allah, not man.
Messenger was saying follow Quran, they is no mention that Quran says follow man made Hadith, stop spreading your Sunni Shia hate
"They abandoned the judgement of their Lord and took hadiths for their religion; and they claim that they have obtained knowledge other than from the Koran . . . They believed in a book which was not from God, written by the hands of men; they then attributed it to the Messenger of God."