The 14 years old me like B1A4 so much. I wished I can go to their tour one day. I listened to their song almost everyday. But then I manage to get in the university I wanted to, my life was so busy I stop listening to their song. But now, right now. My third year in uni life, I looking back to their song cause I missed them so much. And I found out that there are only 3 of them left. I was so sad 😭😭😭 I'm so sorry for not being there for you all. I regret it!! They're losing fans all around the world 😭 most of their fan r getting married, go to the university, having a carrier, working. But right now, I promise you. I will support you more at the future 😭
모든게 영원할 순 없겠지 하지만 너희가 목표를 향해가고 목표에 도달해있을때까지도 우린 영원히 함께일거야 신우야.. 그동안 맏형으로서 얼마나 마음고생이 심했을까.. 5인조를 못본다는게 우린 너무나 슬프지만 우리가 이렇게 슬픈만큼 너흰 얼마나 마음고생이 심할까.. 끝까지 응원할게 비원에이포가 결국 해체하는날이 오더라도 행복한추억으로 남은건 똑같으니까.. 우린 행복한추억을 갖고있으니 행복해 사랑해 B1A4
이 팬미팅을 준비하면서 팬분들께 어떻게 말을 전해야할까 얼마나 고민이 됐을까 바나들도 5명에서 3명이 된 오빠들을 보면서 마음이 아팠지만 맏형으로서 그 5명을 지켜내지 못했다고 생각하면서 동우가 얼마나 스스로를 자책했을까 생각하면 눈물이 눈앞을 가려 그럼에도 불구하고 아직 여전히 그 자리를 지키고 있어줘서 너무 고마워 남은 동생들에게 버팀목이 되어주고자 힘들어도 티 못내고 굳건히 버티고 있었을 동우에게 고맙다고 고생했다고 어떤 일이 있어도 바나들이 곁에 있을테니 같이 이겨내가자고 꼭 얘기해주고 싶다 동우도 들이도 찬이도 바나 곁에 남아줘서 고마워 앞으로 오래 보자 사랑해
I'm so sorry for crying at night so.. sorry for not listening to their songs earlier sorry for everything... all i wish as Singapore's fan is to wish them the very best next time when pandemic stabilizes lets meet. ive been learning cooking from past videos from them too..but right now besides pandemic fans may want to hear good news from them besides work related..hope to hear good news soon..we dont say goodbye we miss you come back safely sandeul prince fans miss you serve safely dont fall sick dont get hurt fans miss you remember the fans letters the chicken the ramen we really miss you and at night if you miss your brothers give them a short call will do.. remember dont get hurt dont fall sick stay safe we miss you b1a4 forever hwaiting..come back safely all....time will fly by ... 2 years , 4 years, 6 years , 8 years, second decade, third decade by then all of us will have families and im waiting for that day.. come back safely all....temporary...rest.. is for a longer road ahead.. take care and be safe .. love you all..we dont know what future awaits so we have to say b1a4 and banas happy graduation no matter where we are by the time oppa finishes military banas might disappear but always hold on to the fact that you guys had awesome memories and that will not change....always remember why this group was your motivation and use this to move up in life
A year had passed... and I still hate JY & Baro for leaving. No matter what is the reason, for me they are just being selfish! To B1A4, the saddest time had passed. It is time to rise and shine again ❤.
@@sophiaahn6537 they still in b1a4 they just left the company. But it is hard for them to promote together with their different schedule so we don't know when they will promote together again :(
@@fayedorabella I saw in their IG that Baro and JY still follow the other members, but the remaining 3 unfollowed them :(( I hope if they ever comeback as ot5, there are no hard feelings :((
You can't hate and call someone selfish just because they're trying to follow their dreams. Yes, it's really disappointing and still hurts a lot but they're in no way, shape or form selfish for deciding to leave. Because if you're being realistic they can't remain just as 'Idols' for the rest of their career. At some point they would have needed to follow their own paths and more focused on their individual activities if they're to stay in this industry for long. Yes, they could have stayed together and still be able to follow their own dreams but we don't know even half of what goes on behind the screen. As a true fan, I think it's only right that we respect their decision and continue to support them as group or individual although we might be a bit disappointed. And let's be clear that they left the company not the group.
![[FULL] 💚B1A4💚에 갇혀 버린다 해도 REWIND💞 | GOT7 영재의 친한친구 | MBC 240117 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6dWzjCfc9pA/mqdefault.jpg)
이번에 컴백하고 이거 다시 보니 진짜 신우산들 공찬에게 너무 고맙네 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 비포해줘서 고마워
몇년이 지났는데 아직도 눈물 나와.. 팬들도 이렇게 속상한데 멤버들은 얼마나 속상했을까...
다 무뎌졌다고 생각했는데 아직도 디플영상 보면 눈물이 바로 쏟아져..ㅜㅜ신우 산들 공찬 오빠 그룹 지켜줘서 너무 고마워❤
The 14 years old me like B1A4 so much. I wished I can go to their tour one day. I listened to their song almost everyday. But then I manage to get in the university I wanted to, my life was so busy I stop listening to their song. But now, right now. My third year in uni life, I looking back to their song cause I missed them so much. And I found out that there are only 3 of them left. I was so sad 😭😭😭 I'm so sorry for not being there for you all. I regret it!! They're losing fans all around the world 😭 most of their fan r getting married, go to the university, having a carrier, working. But right now, I promise you. I will support you more at the future 😭
고마워 잘 버텨줘서 비원에이포 이름을 이렇게 지켜주어서 정말정말 고마워
몇년이 지나도 이 영상은 내 눈물버튼이네…지금은 너무너무 행복하지만 이 영상만 보면 눈물 주르륵😭😭
모든게 영원할 순 없겠지 하지만 너희가 목표를 향해가고 목표에 도달해있을때까지도 우린 영원히 함께일거야
신우야.. 그동안 맏형으로서 얼마나 마음고생이 심했을까..
5인조를 못본다는게 우린 너무나 슬프지만
우리가 이렇게 슬픈만큼 너흰 얼마나 마음고생이 심할까..
끝까지 응원할게 비원에이포가 결국 해체하는날이 오더라도
행복한추억으로 남은건 똑같으니까.. 우린 행복한추억을 갖고있으니 행복해
사랑해 B1A4
동방신기형들 찢어질 때에도 슬펐지만 B1A4형들도 찢어질 때에도 진짜 슬펐다... 신우형 말대로 이렇게 될 줄 몰랐어...
I turned my head after JY left.. but now i regret it.. im supporting B1A4 as three from now.
오궁...울 시누 어쩌나...맘이 넘 아프다 😢😢😢 시누야 맘이 넘 짠해 건강하게 씩씩하게 잘하고 늠름한 모습으로 돌아와 울 이쁜시누야 사랑한다 행복하자☺☺☺💖💖
2023년까지 힘내줘서 고맙다💚 곧 산들이까지 완전체 기대할게💚
이 팬미팅을 준비하면서 팬분들께 어떻게 말을 전해야할까 얼마나 고민이 됐을까
바나들도 5명에서 3명이 된 오빠들을 보면서 마음이 아팠지만 맏형으로서 그 5명을 지켜내지 못했다고 생각하면서 동우가 얼마나 스스로를 자책했을까 생각하면 눈물이 눈앞을 가려
그럼에도 불구하고 아직 여전히 그 자리를 지키고 있어줘서 너무 고마워
남은 동생들에게 버팀목이 되어주고자 힘들어도 티 못내고 굳건히 버티고 있었을 동우에게 고맙다고 고생했다고 어떤 일이 있어도 바나들이 곁에 있을테니 같이 이겨내가자고 꼭 얘기해주고 싶다
동우도 들이도 찬이도 바나 곁에 남아줘서 고마워 앞으로 오래 보자 사랑해
행복했으면 좋겠어요 진짜로!!
지금은3명이지만 5명이 노래부를수잇는날이 올거야 슬퍼하지마
진짜 B1A4 화이팅..
I love B1A4
I can't hold my tears. This is too much. My heart. I love u my boys~ B1A4 All the Way! BANA Fighting!
midnight crying like your previous last goodbye song no matter decades 2 decades 3 we will miss you all.... goodbye for now
너무슬퍼하지마세요 행복한 날이 올거야
It's truly heartbreaking when I read the news 😟 Seeing them like this is truly heartbreaking 💔
come back here for a good cry whenever i need
It's still hurt
I'm so sorry for crying at night so.. sorry for not listening to their songs earlier sorry for everything... all i wish as Singapore's fan is to wish them the very best next time when pandemic stabilizes lets meet. ive been learning cooking from past videos from them too..but right now besides pandemic fans may want to hear good news from them besides work related..hope to hear good news soon..we dont say goodbye we miss you come back safely sandeul prince fans miss you serve safely dont fall sick dont get hurt fans miss you remember the fans letters the chicken the ramen we really miss you and at night if you miss your brothers give them a short call will do.. remember dont get hurt dont fall sick stay safe we miss you b1a4 forever hwaiting..come back safely all....time will fly by ... 2 years , 4 years, 6 years , 8 years, second decade, third decade by then all of us will have families and im waiting for that day.. come back safely all....temporary...rest.. is for a longer road ahead.. take care and be safe .. love you all..we dont know what future awaits so we have to say b1a4 and banas happy graduation no matter where we are by the time oppa finishes military banas might disappear but always hold on to the fact that you guys had awesome memories and that will not change....always remember why this group was your motivation and use this to move up in life
Thank you soo much for uploading this vid.
A year had passed... and I still hate JY & Baro for leaving. No matter what is the reason, for me they are just being selfish! To B1A4, the saddest time had passed. It is time to rise and shine again ❤.
Im confused with the situation but jinyoung and baro still have b1a4 in their instagram bio?
@@sophiaahn6537 they still in b1a4 they just left the company. But it is hard for them to promote together with their different schedule so we don't know when they will promote together again :(
@@fayedorabella I saw in their IG that Baro and JY still follow the other members, but the remaining 3 unfollowed them :(( I hope if they ever comeback as ot5, there are no hard feelings :((
@@sophiaahn6537 yaa i hope whatever going on between them will be sorted out.
You can't hate and call someone selfish just because they're trying to follow their dreams. Yes, it's really disappointing and still hurts a lot but they're in no way, shape or form selfish for deciding to leave. Because if you're being realistic they can't remain just as 'Idols' for the rest of their career. At some point they would have needed to follow their own paths and more focused on their individual activities if they're to stay in this industry for long. Yes, they could have stayed together and still be able to follow their own dreams but we don't know even half of what goes on behind the screen. As a true fan, I think it's only right that we respect their decision and continue to support them as group or individual although we might be a bit disappointed.
And let's be clear that they left the company not the group.
비포 영원히 행복하자.....!
When b1a4 left my heart was painful but this reminded me of my grandma it’s even more painful
私は、皆さんと違ってファンになるのが遅すぎた。こんなに3人が苦しんでいた事を知らなかった。今笑顔でいられるのは、乗り越えたって事だね✌️
can anyone please add an english subtitle?
I wanna.eng sub
😍😍😍
😭😭😭😭
But anytime you need me you know where to find me maknae ah
*어느누구도 잘못없어 ㅠㅠ*
Eng subs plzz🙏🙏
리더가 나가버려서 ㅠㅠ
Eng sub plzzz.....
Wanna go eat wanna bake with me wanna exercise with me?hmmm puppy?
Puppy misses ducky already hmmm?
Sandeul serve well
Honestly they can’t have a good enough reason to do *this* to their former members smh
i am sorry in advance but what do you mean?
연기해서 드라마 잘안된다면 그래도 바로와진영이가 팀를 나가쓸까?
계약기간 마치고 나간건데 튄거냐 비웅띤아? 그리고 한번 선택한 직업을 죽을때까지 하라는 보장없어 꼴통아😂 너 게임 좋아한다면 70살까지 프로게이머하다 뒤질거여?