As an American, the casual dancing makes sense. Comparing them to One Direction, NSync, and other boys bands, these guys are great. It would be weird if they were perfect. It doesn't fit the KPop model, BUT that would not sell to general music fans in the UK, USA, etc. It's obvious they are trying to market to more than KPop fans. So, no, they don't need to work more on the dancing.
Idk, the not so perfect dancing is fine as it is. It's part of the charm. Kpop groups can sometimes be a little too perfect for my liking that I find this group a bit refreshing.
It smart for a Western boy band group. I don't think it would be accepted by locals for them to be perfect. They are going to be compared to One Direction and NSnyc, more than KPop.
It's a wonderful blend of the jpop and kpop idol pathways. They've trained hardcore and have genuine talent and skills but we get the joy of seeing them grow and improve and achieve their dreams which develops that bond with the idol like in the jpop sense.
Their singing sounded much better since the last time I heard them. I really wanted to hear the guy with the buzz cut sing he was the one, with a voice that stood out to me last time. But that's what they are trying to be just because they are different doesn't mean they shouldn't provide good singing and dancing that's why you train and if you cant handle it then you should be fired like normal boys and girls who go to audition and work hard. Because then what's the point of all the other people who gave their blood, sweat and tears to be in a kpop group just to have it so easy for a British boy band?
@@allysonwolf5721 If you follow their channel, they do vlogs and shorts each week and we've seen them do a lot of dancing shorts in the fancam style and in rehearsal rooms. They also like to sing their songs wherever they go haha. It's clear they love their work and are still working and training hard.
its giving western boy band. I didnt want to approve because when they were first announced it felt like they were trying to recreate one direction (based on pictures alone) but i found myself enjoying this. Anyways i do think they could use more dance training. not kpop level ofc but i want them to bring back nsync level dancing at least
I think they still should practice on dancing bc it's not clear on their move... So it doesn't look good when you watch at their moves... And hope SM will change their style a to z it's one of the reasons why there's smth off on them as artists... Only memorable here was the song that was chosen to them
I understand your thoughts, but most idols were training since they were kids, these guys were recruited like 2 years ago you can't hold them to the same standard.
![DEAR ALICE - Life is a Movie [Live at Saturday Mash Up!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/V7vMKvTM7pg/mqdefault.jpg)
![DEAR ALICE - Life is a Movie [Live at Saturday Mash Up!]](/img/tr.png)
Every 90s pop boyband song vibes!
순수해 보이고 활기차 보여서 좋고 노래도 엄청 잘 부르네요.대박나라.
Wowwwww i really look forward to their debut 😊
YESSS 💗
@@Janoo-97😊😊😊😊
Who know when ?
As an American, the casual dancing makes sense. Comparing them to One Direction, NSync, and other boys bands, these guys are great. It would be weird if they were perfect. It doesn't fit the KPop model, BUT that would not sell to general music fans in the UK, USA, etc. It's obvious they are trying to market to more than KPop fans. So, no, they don't need to work more on the dancing.
Good song, good voices, good harmony.👍
Idk, the not so perfect dancing is fine as it is. It's part of the charm. Kpop groups can sometimes be a little too perfect for my liking that I find this group a bit refreshing.
It smart for a Western boy band group. I don't think it would be accepted by locals for them to be perfect. They are going to be compared to One Direction and NSnyc, more than KPop.
It's a wonderful blend of the jpop and kpop idol pathways. They've trained hardcore and have genuine talent and skills but we get the joy of seeing them grow and improve and achieve their dreams which develops that bond with the idol like in the jpop sense.
Their singing sounded much better since the last time I heard them. I really wanted to hear the guy with the buzz cut sing he was the one, with a voice that stood out to me last time. But that's what they are trying to be just because they are different doesn't mean they shouldn't provide good singing and dancing that's why you train and if you cant handle it then you should be fired like normal boys and girls who go to audition and work hard. Because then what's the point of all the other people who gave their blood, sweat and tears to be in a kpop group just to have it so easy for a British boy band?
@@allysonwolf5721 If you follow their channel, they do vlogs and shorts each week and we've seen them do a lot of dancing shorts in the fancam style and in rehearsal rooms. They also like to sing their songs wherever they go haha. It's clear they love their work and are still working and training hard.
I do hope they will be a huge success! The song is so good!
Hope they're gonna have a successful debut
Finally it dropped yesss, still not the full performance tho 😢 I need Reeses verse!!
Love their energy ❤
진짜 좋다..하ㅜㅜㅜ
I am fan now .I will wait for their debut❤
Blaise’s bass harmony will be the foundation of Dear Alice’s future songs, i know it already
노래좋다
귀여워요❤
I like it already! can't wait
Awesome 👍😊
노래가 좋아요
its giving western boy band. I didnt want to approve because when they were first announced it felt like they were trying to recreate one direction (based on pictures alone) but i found myself enjoying this. Anyways i do think they could use more dance training. not kpop level ofc but i want them to bring back nsync level dancing at least
I have flashback 😢
lmao SM really teached them the perfect bow
I hope that they don't end like 1D 💔
목소리지만 감미로워요
MY BABIESS ❤️🩹
This is giving early 2000s, I don't know if it will work in 2024. Maybe the early teens will like it though.
LETSGO BOYSSS
0:45 좌측에 sm 여성 관계자분 계시네 ㅋㅋ 매의 눈 ㅋㅋㅋ
they are under SM entertainment. thats why they are there
노래 조음
when will their song be released?
@@malvinooctorano4454 There is no date yet :(
I really wish there was not a lot of dancing. They seem to be really great already with there voice and a little choreography.
0:08 부부의세계 이영애st
I think they still should practice on dancing bc it's not clear on their move... So it doesn't look good when you watch at their moves... And hope SM will change their style a to z it's one of the reasons why there's smth off on them as artists... Only memorable here was the song that was chosen to them
They are not kpop idol what do u expect
SM wasn't training these boys to be K-Pop idols. They were training them to be a UK boy band. There is a different style.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Very good song, you guys only need Korean stylist !.
Why does it look and sound like it's from a Netflix movie or something not real lol.
오~~~좋은데 빠지는데?
one d 2.0
캣츠아이에서는 느껴지지 않은 그 어색함 불쾌감이 왜 느껴지는 걸까요
음...
looks generic
딴지는 아니고...비주얼멤버가 없는게 좀 아쉬운....그래도 영국에선 먹히는 스타일인가봐요?
Meh
Crowd sucks
looks are mid. dance under mid, voice under mid. Whats this?
If u hear them live there voices are amazing, the autotune really washes it out. Look up Reese or Olly singing
But they are trying so calm down and give them a chance
Ikr... They'd work on their dancers their dance moves look even worse than tiktok dancer ... Hope SM will notice it and work additional on it
@snowminL485 dance is easiest to fix luckily
I understand your thoughts, but most idols were training since they were kids, these guys were recruited like 2 years ago you can't hold them to the same standard.
It’s not k pop though 😂😂😂😂
They had kpop training but they are a British group…. That’s the whole point
They are like KATSEYE, A2K, etc. Western group with kpop system training
Its Pop, Not Kpop but with Kpop training.
@@rard2963No. They different treatment
한국에서 최초 데뷔인가요
먼가 가사를저렇게 따닥따닥만들어놨냐