YAIRA Fan Art Contest Overview and Predictions on Rippaverse
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
- I check out the Yaira fan art contest and make my predictions about who will win over at: rippaverse.com/
Be sure to pick up your copy of Yaira and then head on over to get the latest issue of Voluntaryist at: www.indyplanet...
#yaira #rippaverse #isom #alphacore #horseman
I love seeing these deep dives. Did you do this type of video for the other two contests?
I can definitely see your point in having Yaira in the piece. If I remember right, though, the Isom 2 contest winner didn't have Isom in it either.
I think Barkley would be my personal #1 for this.
Thanks Evan! Yes, I did a review and predictions for the past art contests too. It will be interesting to see what comes of this one! Some good pieces to pick from. Cheers! ( :
@@JackLloyd I'll have to track those down. Thanks!
@@evanwrites1513 Thank you! You can check those out in this playlist here: ua-cam.com/video/Sj9xsGYQlII/v-deo.html
45:36 this will get the grandprize. The Soskas wanted this as the cover to Yaira 2 on Twitter.
Knowing the prize is potential cover, or sequential art work. That is what I am taking into consideration with my crits. 02:40 IncredibleMrE98: Nice concept but muddy coloring. 03:22 Good, but a lot of wasted space. 03:25 Excellent. 04:50 Excellent. 05:55 Proportions are not appealing. Looks stocky. FXs are not well done. Not sure where she is. 06:13 Nice art. I wish Yaira was more of the focus. 06:51Ok, but I wish Yaira was the focus. The colors are muddy. Space isn't used well. 07:24 Well done. I like it 08:33 Good gag style. Good colors. Proportions look off on both characters. 09:23 Cool idea, but her proportions are a bit off. She looks like a teenager. White speed lines would have looked better. 10:48 Drawing and coloring are good. The angles and poses are not dynamic. 11:33 I like the style, and expression. Good use of space The costume details look rushed. The blue color is washing out all the details.11:54 Nice chibi art. Nice character expressions, and use of space. I wish Yaira had more of the focus. 13:18 Nice painter style. The use of space, and color is well executed. Nice sense of movement. 14:00 is nice, but the proportions look chibi, but I am not sure that is the intent. Nice concept and use of space. Not the best execution. Colors are not helping this piece. It may have had a better chance if it stayed black and white. 14:18 Nice concept,. Good use of space. I think the foreshortening is off. The character proportions are not appealing. The arm is thin. The hair is not flowing and she lacks expression. 15:00 Nice. A little dark but everything is well done. 15:55 Perfect. I could see this on a Yaira cover, or T-Shirt. Pro quality. 16:38 Good use of space. Good rendering. I'm just not a fan of her face. 16:55 I like the bright colors. I'm not a fan of the hyper proportions or pose. They are not appealing. 17:03 I like the drawing. The coloring is so bad it hurts the pie 17:30 Not drawing, but the coloring is super muddy. Would have looked better if you focused on the line work and inks. Would have been better if Yaira had more of the focus instead of just filling the page with characters. 17:57 Good concept. The colors were used well to section off the piece and keep Yaira the focus. Nice drawing, but not pro quality. It looks a bit like graffiti. If the lines were thinner, more details could have been added. A cleaner color style would helped. Almost there, but could have used a redo. 18:28 Ok, execution. Not a fan of the poses. Looks like a Blood Ruth cover. Yaira should be the focus not Blood Ruth. 18:53 Good drawing, but the proportions and pose are not appealing. Looks like her head could be on backwards. Coloring too is soft and muddies everything. The power FX are not appealing. Looks like she is shooting out a white goo. 19:14 It's pretty cool. I really don't like her face. Besides that it's ok. 19:42 Interesting pop art style. Not my thing, but it's interesting. Cool colors, and nice use of space. Proportions are odd, but that may be part of the pop art psychedelic look? Hands are hard to draw so I wouldn't have put it as the focus. The finger sizes are all over the place. That ring finger is tiny. 20:07 Interesting concept. Good poses, and use of space. Odd proportions, weak face expression, and muddy coloring. 20:47 Cool idea. Almost a Bruce Tim style. Good use of space and color. Face expressions, and posses could have been better. 21:14 I think the drawing is ok. It's just boring. Good use of space. Bland pose, and facial expression. Soft coloring, and uninspired FX. 21:35 OK Blood Ruth piece, but this is a Yaira art contest. So I would just DQ this. 23:48 Good art. Alpha Core guy looks a bit too young. Space could have been used better around the bottom. Figures could have filled up more of the space. Happy color was not used. Better to not have color than to be judged on bad colors. 24:21 Cool art piece. Nice concept, pose, and use of color. I wish we could have seen something that showed off comic art skills. 25:35 Cool art. The drawing, proportions, and colors are good. Not very dynamic, but it works.26:15 I see the Walking Dead homage. Nice idea, but it could have been executed better. The pose is boring, and the colors are flat. 26:44 This is exciting. Nice drawing, use of space, pose, and use of color. I could see this winning. 27:15 Nice black and white portrait, but it just shows the arts can draw a face. 27:33 Very expressive face. Dynamic pose. Good use of space. Nice shade rendering. If this was inked, and colored I think it would be a contender. 28:08 Nice concept. Drawings are good, but the execution is off. The line wight is too heavy, and most areas are so busy, the inks muddy the details. Needs better line weight, and coloring to make this pop. 28:39 Exciting character art. Interesting expressions, and cool poses. With what is presented the artist knows how to draw characters. I wish I could see his background skills. Excellent, but I'd like to see more. 29:28 Looks like a good drawing with bad inking. The hair is dynamic, and the logo looks cool, but portraits are not good gauges of comic artist skills. 29:51 Mission accomplished. Nice pose, drawing, use of space, and coloring. The proportion's are average , but that's not necessarily a bad thing. Everything the artist attempted turned out well, but is it captivating enough to stick with them? 30:52 It's a cool art style. My only issues are with her face. It's a bit masculine for me. It could be more appealing. Also the coloring is a bit flat. It could pop more. 31: 40 Nice proportions. Boring pose, and weak colors. Everything is lost in the black. 32:00 I like this. The colors could be better, but everything else is A+ work.32:42 Almost looks like a stain glass window. Good use of color and space. Doesn't look like comic art.33:03 Nice coloring. Very painterly rendering. Interesting to look .Not sure how they will feel about the anime style. 33:13 Muddy colors, odd proportions and pose.33:26 good composition and use of space. Face isnt appealing. 33:37 Interesting. Needs a more appealing face, but this is different in a good way. Not sure if this style could work with color. 34:10 Cool concept. The rendering of the ice is nice. The pose is boring, no facial expressions, and the backgrounds have no sense of space. They look like they could be Kaiju fighting. At a glance it looks ok, but when you really look at it none of it makes sense. 34:57 Interesting, but no Yaira. So I would DQ this. 35:17 Cool concept. Nice drawing, and coloring. The pose is boring. The background looks rushed. It has a nice Adam Huges feel to the art. Just not as expressive. 36:43 Good, but suffers from flat coloring. Yaira could have big slightly larger. Would have looked better if her hair flowed more. 36:49 The capturing of the likeness with few lines reminds me of Adam Huges art. Nice concept, use of space, and coloring. May be a bit too safe since it is based on the actress. 37:55 It's doesn't show comic skills. Interesting color FX, but it drowns out the line work. The pose is boring.
Wow! Very detailed coverage. Good feedback.
@@JackLloyd I missed the chance to respond live in the chat. So I just posted my thoughts in the comment.
I'll work on that color depth fa sure 🤙
Keep at it!
44:10 i am glad you are not a judge in this contest. 😑 One of the pieces you dismissed will actually win. The Soskas and Canaan were beaming over it ans called it the winner on Twitter.
Dude there's more uploaded since this. Please review those
Every drawing you guys pick never win , I would tell any artist to take you guys opinion with a grain of salt.
"Winning" does not mean "best art." Artists get disqualified for a number of reasons, and certain styles are picked that may not be the best form.
My analysis is purely on most professional and aesthetic.
It cannot factor reasons for disqualification or internal needs.