Am I the only one to think that Gergiev is to Tchaikovsky's Symphonies what von Karajan is to Beethoven's? He has that passion that blows you away, sinks you into despair, elevates you to the highest places in heaven.
@@angela5094 I wouldn't say nobody, Gergiev is superb but also listen to this symphony played by SF Symphony under Michael Tilson Thomas. It is superb, I was there and saw it live.
The more I listen to Tchaikovsky, the more I can identify with him as a person. He was a genuine, insecure, brilliant man. A very real man. A man who lived a life that went against the norms of what a man should be. He was not only ahead of his time in his music, but also in society. That's what makes his music sublime. His music will truly live forever and, if there's any comfort in it for the composer himself, his music will only get more and more appreciated. Thank you, genius.
Thanks for sharing. Did you know Tchaikovsky dedicated this (Symphony No. 4 in F minor) to. Nadezhda Filaretovna von Meck (1831-1894)? She was a remarkable Russian businesswoman who left an indelible mark on the world of arts, particularly music. Beyond Tchaikovsky, she also supported other musicians, including Nikolai Rubinstein and Claude Debussy. Nadezhda von Meck’s influence extended far beyond her lifetime. Her unwavering commitment to the arts shaped the course of music history.
Yes, I learned that watching one of the documentaries on youtube. As a matter of fact, I went to a concert in Stockholm last week featuring Tchaikovsky's 4th symphony. It was incredible, an unforgettable experience. I hope to listen to any of his symphonies again, especially #4, #1 or #6.@@imhere8380
Can you believe me if I tell you I lived in St. Petersburg Russia for 7 months and only went to Mariinsky once to watch Nutcracker? At that time, I hadn't discovered the absolute genious of Tchaikovsky, even though I lived on the street named after him.@@imhere8380
In uncertain times I solemnly swear to myself to do as I am doing these few days - to listen to all Tchaikovsky's symphonies in order. One a day, not more. One a day. ☀️
Такое бывает не часто. Дирижер и оркестр едины в исполнении высших запросов звучания музыкального произведения. Они достигли этого. Великолепное исполнение. Но нельзя не заметить ту энергию музыкантов и дирижера которую они вложили,. исполняя прекрасное произведение П.И. Чайковского. Браво! Молодцы! Привет из Киева.
No one alive better with Tchaikovsky than Gergiev. That said, back when I thought the 3rd was my favorite of Tchaikovsky's symphonies, I had my mind utterly changed by Michael Stern and the Kansas City Symphony a few years ago in concert.
The sheer power of this performance is just fabulous. Aaahhh...Gergiev and his Russian composers. And let's praise also whomever was responsible for the sound. This is the 3th symphony of this cycle I listen to and I love the clarity of the sound. The strings, the brass.... What a delight to listen to. Thank you
Are you challenged???? IT is not Gergiev and "his" Russian composers! It is Russian composers and Gergiev. A genius creation is replicated by a genius conductor.
Болею короной и слушаю эту великолепную запись! Гергиев поднимает настроение, эмоции! Все дышит жизнью и хочется поскорее выздороветь и пойти в Мариинку! Спасибо маэстро и прекрасные музыканты!
Очень лю Юлю 4 симфонию п И Чайковского, красивая музыка, мелодичная, истинно русская, особенно во второй части, где слышна тема русской песни во поле березонька стоял а. Это чудо. Обожаю.
Гениальное произведение, противопоставляющее духовный мир композитора (его передают смычковые и деревянные духовые инструменты), року, судьбе.(медная группа инструментов и ударные). Но в финале произведения противопоставление перерастает в гармоничное сочетание, и этому способствует народная тема ("Во поле береза стояла"). Великолепное исполнение оркестром. Браво оркестру и дирижеру!
@@0wls1 Да! И этот факт, как нельзя лучше, соответствует теме этой симфонии. Такое впечатление, что здесь пиццикато передает какие-то секреты, тайны души. Как бы шепотом композитор, используя эту технику, сообщает нам об этих тайнах .. А.ведь так и осталась тайной причина, по которой Мекк и Чайковский не сблизились по-настоящему, хотя духовная связь была необычайно сильной.
So einfühlsam die 4. Sinfonie Tschaikovskijs zu spielen kann nur einem russischen Orchester unter einem russischen Dirigenten gelingen. Ich bin begeistert!
one criticism noted of Gergiev in an comment to a earlier symphony, was that he never smiled. untrue. when he turns to the audience to take a bow he is smiling. and early in the 4th movement, he grins facing the strings on his right.
Ah, you forgot one critical thing. A Fantastically well-disciplined, accurate and transcendent orchestra full of … Russians. Not All, I know. But still, when performing these and the other great Russian Masterworks, EVERYONE’S RUSSIAN
following up on my last comment re: conductors smiling, i recall well that Solti (cso) did NOT smile at all, when he came out, and would stand, facing the orchestra for the longest time until orchestra hall was as quiet as possible. when, at the concert's end, he turned to take the wild applause from the packed house, he did smile in a lovely way. btw, this was b.e.s.o. = before the era of the standing ovation which, when i went to many concerts of the st. louis symphony which, to my semi-untrained ear, sounded just as fine as the cso under solti, etc, standing ovations became more and more frequent. good or bad. i don't know. you almost NEVER see a european audience stand. one exception, at the end of the rachmaninoff piano concerto #3, with anna federova as the solist, the audience just goes beserk, finally standing, i think to her surprise, and that of the conductor and orchestra. (sorry can't remember the exact name, i think something like the northwest germany radio orchestra. if you love rachmaninoff's concertos, there are vids of her soloing the 2nd and 3rd on youtube, and i HIGHLY recommend you watch them.
I DO NOT WHY, BUT TCHAIKOVSKY SOUNS ONLY LIKE TCHAIKOVSKY. AND SECONDLY I DO NOT KNOW WHY, HIS FOURTH SYMPHONY IS NOT COSIDERED BY AUDIENCE TO BE THE MOSY IMPRESSIVE ONE, OF THIS BRILLLIANT COMPOSER. I THINK I HAVE GOOD REASONS TO THINK SO, BUT HERE, I CANNOT TALK ABOUT SUCH A LONG AND DEEP THEME.
@@thethikboy While I still prefer Tchaikovsky to Mahler for now, Mahler and Bruckner are imo better than Tchaikovsky ones (although Tchaikovsky 6th is one my favorite symphonies). Mahler and Bruckner probably got inspired by Tchaikovsky, but their music is very different than Tchaikovsky's music. Mahler's symphonies are longer and richer, harder to like fist but then you can understand why they're better. Tchaikovsky's music is pure romantic whereas Bruckner and Mahler's music is postromantic.
Une interprétation de ces symphonies quasiment inégalée! Depuis Karrajan et le Philarmonia dans les années 50 et les enregistrements de Mavrinski on n'est pas arrivé à un tel degré de perfection magnifé par une prise de vues parfaite contrairement à celle des mêmes pour leurs concerts Schostakovitch dans la même salle. Le talent hélas mit au service d'un régime d'assassins et de mafieux! Comment un tel chef et orchestre aux pareils talents peuvent-ils soutenir l'ordure du Kremlin!
Karajan nunca ha dirigido decentemente a Tchaikovsky. Y lo que no puede olvidarse, bajo ningún concepto, son las maravillosas grabaciones en vivo de Celibidache con la Filarmónica de Munich. Auténticos milagros. Aunque he de decir que, dentro de los directores rusos, incluyendo a Mravinsky y a Svetlanov, Gergiev es con diferencia el que más me convence interpretando las sinfonías de Tchaikovsky.
May the Allah almighty reward and bless you for this wonderful jewel. Stay blessed always. May the peace, mercy and blessings of God be upon you - Salam Alaikum…
ANNA.MARTÍ.🐾🐾.BELLÍSIMA .. MARAVALLOSA DIVINA PRESÍOSA.. SINFUNÍA ( N0 4 DE STCHAKOSKY ) ÉS TRÍSTA PRÓ ADURAPLA LÁ ESTIMÚ MOLT MOLT MOLTTTT🐾🐾👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🦋🦋❤❤❤🌹🌹🥀🥀🥀🥀🥀
Beatiful Symphony by Tchiakovsky. One of my favorite symphonies. Dedicated to his Mescenas Madame Von Neck. None the less a complex symphony. THere is much to say about it in this few lines, but his biographers explain it right or wrong in great depth, like: Tchaikovsky: The Man Revealed by John Suchet; Tchaikovsky: The Man and His Music by David Brown; Tchaikovsky: The Quest for the Inner Man by Alexander Poznansky some of them focus in critizim, rather than him a muscical genius. I would just stay awy of Constatine Floros. Could not finish reading the latter.
A superb performance and excellent audio marred by truly inept video direction. Shaky handheld cameras, lengthy dissolves that went out of fashion in the 1960's, unnecessary tracking shots. Good direction should be transparent with the viewer noticing only the music - Hannah Dorn's work with the Berlin Philharmonic is the epitome of this style.
Пишу в мае месяце 2022 года, в те времена, когда мыльный пузырь Гергиева лопнул окончательно. Удивительная вещь: Валерий последние лет 15 занимался своей деятельностью так, будто бы отрабатывал повинность или погашал кредиты. Вся вот эта избыточная активность сказывалась на качестве игры его оркестров. Те редкие видеозаписи его выступлений показывают изнеможённое и безразличное лицо, будто бы уже все повидавшее. Жалкое зрелище. Но как же он был хорош, когда отдавался музыке искренне, со всей душой, с русским задором. Как на этом видео, например. Тут он уже настоящий маэстро экстра-класса, тот самый, которого в нулевых полюбил весь мир. Жаль, мир потерял Гергиева ровно после того, как он перестал находить себя.
Undoubtedly Gergiev has excellent musical ideas. His accelerandos and dynamic, are terrific gorgeous! However, his conducting pattern is unbearable for me. Especially in the pianissimos and slow movements. It's like I almost feel the tension between the musicians.
Believe me, if he doesn't come to the concert right from the airpot, this is the conductor you wanna play with all your life. He doesn't really have a pattern , he interacts with musicians mostly by body language and pantomime.
Am I the only one to think that Gergiev is to Tchaikovsky's Symphonies what von Karajan is to Beethoven's? He has that passion that blows you away, sinks you into despair, elevates you to the highest places in heaven.
No, you are not the only one. At present Gergiev for Tchaikovsky is the number one. Nobody like him.
@@angela5094 I wouldn't say nobody, Gergiev is superb but also listen to this symphony played by SF Symphony under Michael Tilson Thomas. It is superb, I was there and saw it live.
@@BytomGirl Thank you! All suggestions are welcome.
@@angela5094 You are welcome. Find Keeping Score MTT and SF Symphony, you will be mesmerized
Gergiev is definitely a great conductor for anything Russian
The more I listen to Tchaikovsky, the more I can identify with him as a person. He was a genuine, insecure, brilliant man. A very real man. A man who lived a life that went against the norms of what a man should be. He was not only ahead of his time in his music, but also in society. That's what makes his music sublime. His music will truly live forever and, if there's any comfort in it for the composer himself, his music will only get more and more appreciated. Thank you, genius.
Thanks for sharing. Did you know Tchaikovsky dedicated this (Symphony No. 4 in F minor) to. Nadezhda Filaretovna von Meck (1831-1894)? She was a remarkable Russian businesswoman who left an indelible mark on the world of arts, particularly music.
Beyond Tchaikovsky, she also supported other musicians, including Nikolai Rubinstein and Claude Debussy. Nadezhda von Meck’s influence extended far beyond her lifetime. Her unwavering commitment to the arts shaped the course of music history.
Yes, I learned that watching one of the documentaries on youtube. As a matter of fact, I went to a concert in Stockholm last week featuring Tchaikovsky's 4th symphony. It was incredible, an unforgettable experience. I hope to listen to any of his symphonies again, especially #4, #1 or #6.@@imhere8380
Can you believe me if I tell you I lived in St. Petersburg Russia for 7 months and only went to Mariinsky once to watch Nutcracker? At that time, I hadn't discovered the absolute genious of Tchaikovsky, even though I lived on the street named after him.@@imhere8380
In uncertain times I solemnly swear to myself to do as I am doing these few days - to listen to all Tchaikovsky's symphonies in order. One a day, not more. One a day. ☀️
damn u musta been depressed after that 6th day
Такое бывает не часто. Дирижер и оркестр едины в исполнении высших запросов звучания музыкального произведения. Они достигли этого.
Великолепное исполнение. Но нельзя не заметить ту энергию музыкантов и дирижера которую они вложили,. исполняя прекрасное произведение
П.И. Чайковского. Браво! Молодцы! Привет из Киева.
10:00 - 10:30 The most ecstatic triumphant feeling classical music has offered me, fuck the haters, 'ol tchaik is a god
Wow...the power..intensity and clarity of the horns is amazing as is the entire orchestra..
The comfort of No.4 is irreplaceable ,andincomparable
It's like my soul is being sucked away in this stellar performance
From
A corner of Tokyo
"From a norner of Tokyo":) so nice:) how are you,after 2 years? Everything is fine? Greetigns from a corner of Europe:)
No one alive better with Tchaikovsky than Gergiev.
That said, back when I thought the 3rd was my favorite of Tchaikovsky's symphonies, I had my mind utterly changed by Michael Stern and the Kansas City Symphony a few years ago in concert.
The sheer power of this performance is just fabulous. Aaahhh...Gergiev and his Russian composers. And let's praise also whomever was responsible for the sound. This is the 3th symphony of this cycle I listen to and I love the clarity of the sound. The strings, the brass.... What a delight to listen to. Thank you
I fully agree!
Are you challenged???? IT is not Gergiev and "his" Russian composers! It is Russian composers and Gergiev. A genius creation is replicated by a genius conductor.
what an epic performance
bravo as always maestro gergiev
I feel so right at heaven
Great playing and a
wonderful conductor!!!!
Болею короной и слушаю эту великолепную запись! Гергиев поднимает настроение, эмоции! Все дышит жизнью и хочется поскорее выздороветь и пойти в Мариинку! Спасибо маэстро и прекрасные музыканты!
Очень лю Юлю 4 симфонию п И Чайковского, красивая музыка, мелодичная, истинно русская, особенно во второй части, где слышна тема русской песни во поле березонька стоял а. Это чудо. Обожаю.
And in the beginning my favorite movement of 6th symphony... love the 2nd movement of 4th, true balsam for the soul
Straordinario!!!!!! La disperazione nella sua essenza.
0:58 begins | 10:05 celebration achievement | 10:37 intro | 12:56 intro | 13:54 dark | 17:09 build up
17:20 celebration | 17:49 intro | 18:48 dance | 19:10 dance | 19:34 military trumpet | 19:42 explosion
19:54 explosion combo | 20:00 end | 20:25 2nd movement
Dude!!! Finally a good quality Gergiev Tchaikovsky 4!!! Thank you!!
Bravissimo questa musica russa anche il direttore !!!!
The opening music to this video is from Tchaikovsky's 6th Symphony, 2nd Movement.
Гениальное произведение, противопоставляющее духовный мир композитора (его передают смычковые и деревянные духовые инструменты), року, судьбе.(медная группа инструментов и ударные). Но в финале произведения противопоставление перерастает в гармоничное сочетание, и этому способствует народная тема ("Во поле береза стояла"). Великолепное исполнение оркестром. Браво оркестру и дирижеру!
@@0wls1 Да! И этот факт, как нельзя лучше, соответствует теме этой симфонии. Такое впечатление, что здесь пиццикато передает какие-то секреты, тайны души. Как бы шепотом композитор, используя эту технику, сообщает нам об этих тайнах .. А.ведь так и осталась тайной причина, по которой Мекк и Чайковский не сблизились по-настоящему, хотя духовная связь была необычайно сильной.
これが観たくてずっと探していました！大好きなんです！！thank you❣️
So einfühlsam die 4. Sinfonie Tschaikovskijs zu spielen kann nur einem russischen Orchester unter einem russischen Dirigenten gelingen. Ich bin begeistert!
About as good as it gets..wonderful and exciting performance!!
Во поле березонька стояла и будет стооять навсегда!
Nice to see the maestro with a baton.
Tanta euforia!!!
Exactamente
È una novità?
one criticism noted of Gergiev in an comment to a earlier symphony, was that he never smiled. untrue. when he turns to the audience to take a bow he is smiling. and early in the 4th movement, he grins facing the strings on his right.
Meraviglioso !!! Grazie !
14:25 Basssoooooon
Spectacular! Magnificent!
Sole capturing
All I can say is WOW
1 st movement finale is amazing. Look at all these trumpets
Great masterwork and astonishing conductor
Ah, you forgot one critical thing. A Fantastically well-disciplined, accurate and transcendent orchestra full of … Russians. Not All, I know. But still, when performing these and the other great Russian Masterworks, EVERYONE’S RUSSIAN
beautiful performance.
Beautiful!
excelente versión, muchas gracias
Hola profe Ricardo yo estudié con usted hace varios años en el Liceo 5 de Macul. Fue una bonita época! Saludos profe desde Santiago
following up on my last comment re: conductors smiling, i recall well that Solti (cso) did NOT smile at all, when he came out, and would stand, facing the orchestra for the longest time until orchestra hall was as quiet as possible. when, at the concert's end, he turned to take the wild applause from the packed house, he did smile in a lovely way. btw, this was b.e.s.o. = before the era of the standing ovation which, when i went to many concerts of the st. louis symphony which, to my semi-untrained ear, sounded just as fine as the cso under solti, etc, standing ovations became more and more frequent. good or bad. i don't know. you almost NEVER see a european audience stand. one exception, at the end of the rachmaninoff piano concerto #3, with anna federova as the solist, the audience just goes beserk, finally standing, i think to her surprise, and that of the conductor and orchestra. (sorry can't remember the exact name, i think something like the northwest germany radio orchestra. if you love rachmaninoff's concertos, there are vids of her soloing the 2nd and 3rd on youtube, and i HIGHLY recommend you watch them.
Not true!! Soldi smiled plenty!
Amazing!
Браво!!!
Amazing
I DO NOT WHY, BUT TCHAIKOVSKY SOUNS ONLY LIKE TCHAIKOVSKY. AND SECONDLY I DO NOT KNOW WHY, HIS FOURTH SYMPHONY IS NOT COSIDERED BY AUDIENCE TO BE THE MOSY IMPRESSIVE ONE, OF THIS BRILLLIANT COMPOSER. I THINK I HAVE GOOD REASONS TO THINK SO, BUT HERE, I CANNOT TALK ABOUT SUCH A LONG AND DEEP THEME.
The full cavalry charge with cannon!!
Wonderful!
Inexplicable. Heart lifting.
Это не❤❤п онятое чудо!❤❤
Next to the 6th the 4th is the best symphony by a Romantic composer.
Listen to Mahler and Bruckner
@@Dylonely42 Mahler isn't possible without Tchaikovsky. Bruckner? Fake.
@@thethikboy What ???
@@Dylonely42 Tchaikovsky provided the impetus for late Romanticism which Mahler embodies. Bruckner is shallow and derivative.
@@thethikboy While I still prefer Tchaikovsky to Mahler for now, Mahler and Bruckner are imo better than Tchaikovsky ones (although Tchaikovsky 6th is one my favorite symphonies). Mahler and Bruckner probably got inspired by Tchaikovsky, but their music is very different than Tchaikovsky's music. Mahler's symphonies are longer and richer, harder to like fist but then you can understand why they're better. Tchaikovsky's music is pure romantic whereas Bruckner and Mahler's music is postromantic.
Очень нравится Andantino ,просто волшебная мелодия!
Maestro Gergiev😍😍😍😍😍👏👏👏👏👏👌👌👌👌👌
Une interprétation de ces symphonies quasiment inégalée! Depuis Karrajan et le Philarmonia dans les années 50 et les enregistrements de Mavrinski on n'est pas arrivé à un tel degré de perfection magnifé par une prise de vues parfaite contrairement à celle des mêmes pour leurs concerts Schostakovitch dans la même salle.
Le talent hélas mit au service d'un régime d'assassins et de mafieux!
Comment un tel chef et orchestre aux pareils talents peuvent-ils soutenir l'ordure du Kremlin!
Karajan nunca ha dirigido decentemente a Tchaikovsky. Y lo que no puede olvidarse, bajo ningún concepto, son las maravillosas grabaciones en vivo de Celibidache con la Filarmónica de Munich. Auténticos milagros. Aunque he de decir que, dentro de los directores rusos, incluyendo a Mravinsky y a Svetlanov, Gergiev es con diferencia el que más me convence interpretando las sinfonías de Tchaikovsky.
Браво!!!❤
May the Allah almighty reward and bless you for this wonderful jewel.
Stay blessed always.
May the peace, mercy and blessings of God be upon you - Salam Alaikum…
shooo shoooo... go away
What a pity Gergiev lost his job due to political issues, he is truly a great conductor.
Trombone sections:
1:12
at the beginning of the third movement it is crazy
THE CYMBAL PLAYER IS SUBLIME
ANNA.MARTÍ.🐾🐾.BELLÍSIMA ..
MARAVALLOSA DIVINA PRESÍOSA..
SINFUNÍA ( N0 4 DE STCHAKOSKY )
ÉS TRÍSTA PRÓ ADURAPLA LÁ ESTIMÚ
MOLT MOLT MOLTTTT🐾🐾👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🦋🦋❤❤❤🌹🌹🥀🥀🥀🥀🥀
Валера ЛУЧШИЙ
19 40....amazing
que churito
👌
Barenboim still rules.
33:45
Qué impresionante era la manera de componer de este señor. Logra separar tu alma.
Beatiful Symphony by Tchiakovsky. One of my favorite symphonies. Dedicated to his Mescenas Madame Von Neck. None the less a complex symphony. THere is much to say about it in this few lines, but his biographers explain it right or wrong in great depth, like: Tchaikovsky: The Man Revealed by John Suchet; Tchaikovsky: The Man and His Music by David Brown; Tchaikovsky: The Quest for the Inner Man by Alexander Poznansky some of them focus in critizim, rather than him a muscical genius. I would just stay awy of Constatine Floros. Could not finish reading the latter.
As expected Mariinsky renders a great interpretation of the 4th Symphonie and under his direction the orchestra does an extremly good job 👏👏
❤️❤️❤️
Anyone remember what the piece is in the intro to this video? I know I've played it but am stuck...
💐🙏❤🙌🌲
Also Mariss Jansons was greatest with Tchaikovsky ! and he had studied with Mravinskij too
A superb performance and excellent audio marred by truly inept video direction. Shaky handheld cameras, lengthy dissolves that went out of fashion in the 1960's, unnecessary tracking shots. Good direction should be transparent with the viewer noticing only the music - Hannah Dorn's work with the Berlin Philharmonic is the epitome of this style.
Close your eyes. Problem solved. :) It's music; the performance and the audio are everything. The video is incidental.
4:29
Came here from Classic FM
19:38 - Ahí tienen su explicación lógica, tanto que piden una...
THE GREAT COMPOSİTÖRS A
LSO THAN NOT GREAT İN THE WORLD LİSTENER I HAVE MAGİC
18:46 horn cracks a note, just barely :)
so this is where Shostakovich got the idea for the ending of his 4th symphony ......... just kidding
A lot of confusion due to a deficient sound register, in my opinion!
Пишу в мае месяце 2022 года, в те времена, когда мыльный пузырь Гергиева лопнул окончательно. Удивительная вещь: Валерий последние лет 15 занимался своей деятельностью так, будто бы отрабатывал повинность или погашал кредиты. Вся вот эта избыточная активность сказывалась на качестве игры его оркестров. Те редкие видеозаписи его выступлений показывают изнеможённое и безразличное лицо, будто бы уже все повидавшее. Жалкое зрелище. Но как же он был хорош, когда отдавался музыке искренне, со всей душой, с русским задором. Как на этом видео, например. Тут он уже настоящий маэстро экстра-класса, тот самый, которого в нулевых полюбил весь мир. Жаль, мир потерял Гергиева ровно после того, как он перестал находить себя.
Undoubtedly Gergiev has excellent musical ideas. His accelerandos and dynamic, are terrific gorgeous! However, his conducting pattern is unbearable for me. Especially in the pianissimos and slow movements. It's like I almost feel the tension between the musicians.
Believe me, if he doesn't come to the concert right from the airpot, this is the conductor you wanna play with all your life. He doesn't really have a pattern , he interacts with musicians mostly by body language and pantomime.
Io ho suonato Kovancina e Tchaikovsky col maestro. Non è assolutamente vero che ci sia tensione ma, bensì, concentrazione. È molto differente.
早くロシア皇帝プーチンと悪縁を切って、素晴らしい演奏を聞かせて下さい！
Not one of Tchaikovsky’s better symphonies actually a lot of nonsense music
33:14