I know lots of people have said Donnie's version is better, but I think that all depends on who your favorite is. We need a neutral party opinion. For me this is definitely the best version, but Joey was, is, and will always be my favorite. His voice is so powerful. I adore him.
Love the original version but this is probably my favorite of the two, the original obviously has sentimental value but Joey's version has so much more emotion I felt every word and not being rude but he obviously has a better voice than Donnie.
Huh...It took me a minute but I do like this version better. But then...after Donnie snubbed me at my 1st VIP with the guys this summer and Joey was incredibly sweet and warm...I love everything Joe more than Donnie now.
wow this sounds like a completely new song! the original is a classic... sorry joe! but i wasn't that crazy for the version donnie does in the concert either!
Donnie makes it more fun as it should always be. Joe's version is ok, but it sounds like something from the 60s. Joey certainly has a better voice, though. Maybe he's trying to show off his voice too much.
I love this version much,much more than the original!And his voice is so amazing...
I love Joey singing this song this way... Great performance!!! Fantastic!!!!!!! :)
this is such an amazing version, if he sang this years ago, there would have been lots of hearts breaking just like there is now whenever we watch it!
I know lots of people have said Donnie's version is better, but I think that all depends on who your favorite is. We need a neutral party opinion. For me this is definitely the best version, but Joey was, is, and will always be my favorite. His voice is so powerful. I adore him.
this song gets me everytime!
Wow, 14 days after this video was uploaded I was born! 😲
wow...i would love to hear them re-record this song using this arrangement...
such a beautiful song...
Oh my god he is amazing! And this is like amazing, and um yeah I love Joe Mcintyre. :)
omg im a 14 yr old fan too!!
i was them in omaha i love them....
I love this version!!!:) I hate to say it, but I love it even more than the original version with Donnie!:)
So talented🔥
acctually i LOVE this version..
Loveee u Jooooeeee!! Great sexy song u had made...was, is and will always be Joey girl..thanks for sharing!
I have always loved Donnie & Joe, but this version is just down-right SEXY! Makes me melt!
Joe is such a heartbreaker.
Love this version. Great job Joe!
- a Jordan girl
Joey rocking donnies song awesome
You can get this arrangement on the live One Too Many CD.
Love the original version but this is probably my favorite of the two, the original obviously has sentimental value but Joey's version has so much more emotion I felt every word and not being rude but he obviously has a better voice than Donnie.
so agree
2:06=dead the man is beautiful and his voice sure as hell is beautiful too.
the way he says "with you" at 2:26. DEAD.
daaaaaaaaaaamn this IS alot better then the old verson
He. Is. SMOKIN! Yummehh!!! ;D
WIKED SONG..!!
cruel..
i like both..
Beautiful, love that version! plus he's hot!
dont know..
they are both great..
wow.... beautiful! Still like Donnie's version too though! :)
Huh...It took me a minute but I do like this version better. But then...after Donnie snubbed me at my 1st VIP with the guys this summer and Joey was incredibly sweet and warm...I love everything Joe more than Donnie now.
wow this sounds like a completely new song! the original is a classic... sorry joe! but i wasn't that crazy for the version donnie does in the concert either!
Joe Mac
Donnie makes it more fun as it should always be. Joe's version is ok, but it sounds like something from the 60s. Joey certainly has a better voice, though. Maybe he's trying to show off his voice too much.
Not digging the tight shirt or tight jeans....gotta love 2001!!!
Love Joe, but Donnie's better