Should we ban offensive words? | Josie Pagani | The Common Room

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 18

  • @HunkyMan777
    @HunkyMan777 Рік тому +6

    People just need to be less precious. Get a backone

  • @matt-nz3739
    @matt-nz3739 Рік тому +1

    Our society has gotten bad, whatever you say or even write about, will offend somebody or some person, no matter what age group or school you talk to about. If people can't leave books as written as they were intended for their original purposes, then what are the next generation going to learn???
    PC gone mad and beyond!!!!
    Matt

  • @DAVE6821
    @DAVE6821 Рік тому +2

    Where will this stop.
    I remember reading these books to my kids when they were full of adventure
    Books of the past should be left alone
    If it's that bad, if the author or publisher feels the need to make people need for inclusive, the author should write another book with a different name.
    Humans need to make there own decisions

  • @waynepike4337
    @waynepike4337 Рік тому +3

    What a load of BS.

  • @barefootonasandybeach638
    @barefootonasandybeach638 Рік тому

    You can’t give offence, you can only take it. The fact that you may not like a word shouldn’t be grounds for others to cease using it.

  • @sue.F
    @sue.F Рік тому +3

    This so-called sensitivity is anti progressive. As if the assault on the artistic integrity of the author is not harm enough, sanitising literature is an insidious form of re-writing history and without understanding how we got here we cannot navigate a path forward.

  • @rodmccourt3665
    @rodmccourt3665 Рік тому +2

    While I understand the sentiment of this piece, I do feel that it is rather misleading. The implication from Josie is that we will have no choice but to buy the edited versions of Dahl's books. This is not the case, as Puffin will be releasing the old unedited versions in parallel, providing a choice of whichever version you wish to purchase. This is hardly an attack on free speech, the mere fact that we are able to discuss it on this platform is further evidence that we are able to think and speak freely. I, myself, prefer the original versions of the Dahl books and will be reading them to my grandchildren in due course. I am very grateful that I live in a world where I am free to choose. So, come on people, let's stop overreacting to this imaginary threat to our freedoms and focus on issues that really matter.

  • @kungfutzu3779
    @kungfutzu3779 Рік тому

    what did the national library do with the books?

  • @bobgillis1137
    @bobgillis1137 Рік тому +1

    Sure. But while we are at it, I would like to add the word "The" to the list of banned words.
    It clearly contains the priveledged and repressive word "he" inside it.

  • @gregg7617
    @gregg7617 Рік тому

    NO !
    Because when you do , you change the context of sentences ,
    Causing misunderstanding !!

  • @Noote54
    @Noote54 Рік тому +1

    Well put

  • @julian4548
    @julian4548 Рік тому

    Sticks and stones …..

  • @tatjanakane503
    @tatjanakane503 11 місяців тому

    Definitely not

  • @tatjanakane503
    @tatjanakane503 Рік тому

    God, no!

  • @bennichols1113
    @bennichols1113 4 місяці тому

    Long video when the answer is just no.

  • @bennichols1113
    @bennichols1113 Рік тому

    No. Dont make magic words. Its an excuse for violence.