The Destruction of St. George Lithuanian Church - Shenandoah, PA

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 105

  • @zanderzig
    @zanderzig 5 років тому +14

    It is devastating to see the destruction of this significant historic monument. I only recently learned about the Catholic Church's decision to demolish this church. It is a blow to Lithuanian-American cultural heritage and the history of Lithuanian immigrant workers that lived and died in the mines to fuel America's growth as a nation. The workers and their families donated so generously to erect this church for their community and families, while earning subsistence wages in the mines. It is also disturbing to see that nothing was done to preserve the art, architectural elements, sculpture or organ. Thank you for making these photos publicly available for all to witness this sad moment.

  • @johnarminas1402
    @johnarminas1402 10 років тому +6

    Can't believe it! I used go to church there with my grandfather when I was child. He passed away years ago. I loved visiting Shenandoah when I was young. I was going to show my a son picture of the church and found this video.

  • @DianeC.
    @DianeC. 7 років тому +5

    I attended St George's Church as a child with my Babci♡ when we came to visit in the summers of my youth. It was a beautiful Church . I will miss seeing it there when ever I come to visit. This is my Home Town. .I will always remember this beautiful Church. Diane Bilewicz Clark. OHIO

  • @oliviapetusky1933
    @oliviapetusky1933 9 років тому +8

    This church meant a lot to me I went to a school really close to it its my first year not being in that school and I miss visiting that chuch for masses during school.

  • @hughsmith790
    @hughsmith790 2 роки тому +1

    When ever we lose a church in a community, we lose not only a building but the community it served. Churches have always been and will always be not only places to worship but also places for people to gather and be together as a group. Churches serve their congregations as well as their communities in so many different ways. It’s very disheartening to see a building as beautiful and historic as St George’s Lithuanian Church be demolished. It leaves a hole in the community that can never be refilled, like losing a family member or a friend. St George’s had a wonderful and rich history behind it. I’m a truly sorry that it was demolished. Architecture and the art in the building can never be replaced.

  • @PianoPlayah
    @PianoPlayah 10 років тому +7

    Breaks my heart! These are treasures we'll never get back. C
    aommunities are in ruin because our spiritual walk is in ruin, So sad to these buildings being destroyed. Probably a minimally small, aged congregation that could no longer support the building itself.

  • @TheChampionInMe
    @TheChampionInMe 14 років тому +5

    Great job making this video.
    5 STARS!

  • @SuKo000
    @SuKo000 13 років тому +2

    I am so very sad to see this beautiful church destroyed. It is the church where my Mother received her first communion and confirmation and was married. The artist who painted the ceiling used the faces of my Mother and her sisters for those of the angels (Zemalis family). I have fond memories of Shenandoah and the time I spent there as a child. Is nothing historical? What a tragedy! I found this video on Mother's day and I am crying. I do thank the photographers for being so sensitive.

  • @frsdonahue
    @frsdonahue 11 років тому +5

    How sad and empty this leaves me. I feel so bad for these precious Lithuanian people whose beautiful church this was. I see the Diocese pinched every bit of loveliness that will bring them a buck.

  • @lezmajz4677
    @lezmajz4677 4 роки тому +4

    O.K. Tears, broken hearts, sadness, meanings and everything but what ACTION this community took ? NONE ? you deserve this them

  • @pipeorganest
    @pipeorganest 11 років тому +5

    I don't get it. They save the steeples but they don't even bother to save the organ?

  • @gkniezew
    @gkniezew 11 років тому +3

    Thank you posting this...excellent piece. It was my mothers childhood church back in the 1920s and 30s back when Msgr Karalius was pastor.

  • @DianeC.
    @DianeC. 4 роки тому +2

    This is so...sad. My Babci ♡ lived around the corner and went to this church. We did also when we visited.

  • @lynnlubamersky3704
    @lynnlubamersky3704 10 років тому +3

    Thank you for making this video. I did not know that the church was destroyed. It's very very sad.

  • @marrycee
    @marrycee 14 років тому +2

    Soooooooooo sad..........my father's family was instumental in the founding of this church. Their name is on one of the bells.....what I would give for a brick, stone, piece of wood. Were there any artifacts saved? Where are the bells ? Beautiful, heartbreaking video. Thank you, Mary Strolis schulz

  • @experimentalvid
    @experimentalvid 4 роки тому +2

    My great grandfather helped build that church. Very sad to learn it’s gone!

  • @skinmaxdestroyer
    @skinmaxdestroyer 3 роки тому +4

    great work

  • @4676adam1
    @4676adam1 9 років тому +9

    I am a Lithuanian organist in California and seeing the organ destroyed was very difficult for me. I am sure someone would have taken it and installed somewhere else.

    • @Gioagla
      @Gioagla 8 років тому

      +4676adam1 Actually i m shocked ....a masterpiece gone

    • @PreservationEnthusiast
      @PreservationEnthusiast 5 років тому +1

      @@Gioagla I enjoyed watching the destruction of this church. Great video!

    • @jujubebeproductions4351
      @jujubebeproductions4351 4 роки тому +1

      @@PreservationEnthusiast On the day of judgement you will rot in hell

    • @jasondennison9669
      @jasondennison9669 3 роки тому +1

      I agree. Would have been a beautifyl3 organ for another church😭

    • @kellymeadows353
      @kellymeadows353 3 роки тому

      @@PreservationEnthusiast you are not alone! Love this!🖤

  • @Cameo477
    @Cameo477 12 років тому +1

    Outstanding. But so sad..... Nice work for the pictures and video

  • @bernU1963
    @bernU1963 12 років тому +3

    OMG this broke my heart..I have tears in my eyes watching this...what is going on in this world anymore??? so sad...

    • @Strongerthandirt8695
      @Strongerthandirt8695 2 роки тому

      I have tears as well....went there many times visiting our Grandparents and family. Such a beautiful memory. Thank you for making this video! xo

  • @tomgurecki1204
    @tomgurecki1204 10 років тому +5

    They could have just removed the parts that they said were dangerous. So what's left? An empty lot which is of no use to Shenandoah. Anybody paying property taxes on the lot? I doubt it. VERY SAD.

  • @cheriep1846
    @cheriep1846 6 років тому +2

    So terrible. This is where my grandfather and great-uncle were baptized. :(

  • @kristinepfs
    @kristinepfs Рік тому

    This was truly a loss. I have only driven into Shenandoah once since the destruction of this church and the town just looks wrong without it.

  • @mackhopper
    @mackhopper 2 роки тому

    There are a myriad of reasons why I am no longer Catholic. The fact that the church has ZERO institutional compassion (to the point of it being almost spiteful and cruel) is yet another of those reasons. To coldly tear down something that respects an entire community is case in point.

  • @dannyzad17
    @dannyzad17 14 років тому +1

    What ever became of the beautiful windows, furnishings and other great peices of this church??

  • @dannyzad17
    @dannyzad17 10 років тому +3

    This is so sad to see a beautiful church gone due to peoples ignorance. What became of the angels that sat atop the church? And the windows and bells etc??

    • @PreservationEnthusiast
      @PreservationEnthusiast 9 років тому +2

      Danny Zadrazil Everything was smashed up and scrapped.

    • @NicoleClarkAKPoptart
      @NicoleClarkAKPoptart 8 років тому

      That's unfortunate...usually they try to save as many relics as possible and relocate them. Must not have been practical in this case. :( The destruction of the organ is heartbreaking...there are many enthusiasts out there who probably would have enjoyed a restoration project.
      Glad to see that gorgeous stained glass window was saved.

    • @PreservationEnthusiast
      @PreservationEnthusiast 8 років тому +3

      Nicole Clark We must smash up all the stuff from the old religions!

    • @CaptainDonut0
      @CaptainDonut0 5 років тому +1

      @@PreservationEnthusiast We Lithuanians are a hadry people. more attack on our identity then we can count and we dispite our roman catolic religion still celebrate all are pagan celebration even the catedral in the current capital of Lithuania was build on on the site where our pagain temple of thunderstorm. so the Lithuanians will survive.

    • @PreservationEnthusiast
      @PreservationEnthusiast 5 років тому +3

      @@CaptainDonut0 Religions will still be smashed asunder. They are not good for mankind.

  • @dannyzad17
    @dannyzad17 14 років тому +1

    What happened to those 2 beautiful Angels that sat gracefully atop Saint George's Church above the front entrance??

  • @dergneau
    @dergneau 12 років тому +3

    Il n'y à pas de mots pour décrire cela quel honte

  • @forrestcreek1598
    @forrestcreek1598 5 років тому

    The music in this video is titled, “The Sad Trio” by Kevin MacLeod. A very fitting song for a sad video showing a very beautiful church being demolished. From what I read In my research of this building the Allentown, PA diocese never did own this church. It was built buy the Lithuanians of Shenandoah, PA and they maintained it, not the diocese. The Arch Diocese of Allentown never paid anything for its upkeep, renovations, basically nothing. How they got to make the decision to demolish it, I’ll never know. It belonged to the Lithuanian community of Shenandoah not the Allentown Diocese. What at very tragic loss to the community it must have been. The organ alone would cost about a million dollars be todays standards. They should have had the sense to at least sell or give it to another church.

  • @popalis
    @popalis  14 років тому

    The black on the bell towers was a netting to hold the granite blocks in place and prevent them from falling.

  • @dannyzad17
    @dannyzad17 14 років тому +1

    This video brings tears to my eyes. To see such a gorgeous house of God destroyed....ugh............. Does anyone know what became of its beautiful interior furnishings, windows, bells, and instruments?? I'd really appreciate knowing that... I'd love to also know more about Saint George's. please let me know

  • @Waynebob68
    @Waynebob68 8 років тому +3

    Sad day indeed

  • @jerrysmith7449
    @jerrysmith7449 5 років тому

    The question I don’t see here is “Why?”.

  • @Eccoriens80
    @Eccoriens80 8 років тому +2

    En Lithuanie aussi ?!!...même le buffet d'orgue est éventré, quel massacre ! Pendant que la Russie reconstruit et embellit ses églises, ça c'est un comble !
    EU = new USSR ... with flowers, ecology and Champagne !

  • @jk8429
    @jk8429 13 років тому

    @Zumipali2 I agree... I couldn't believe the organ went down with the building!!

  • @popalis
    @popalis  13 років тому +1

    thank you evreybody

  • @1889annie
    @1889annie 13 років тому

    My screen is blurry and my keyboard is wet. How could the diocese justify this destruction?

  • @dannyzad17
    @dannyzad17 13 років тому +1

    @jk8429 I Agree with you. I cant believe they destroyed the organ. It could have been saved ! ! I wonder what they did with all the things they did save?

  • @vivitar45
    @vivitar45 13 років тому +1

    at least some one save that nice round window

  • @VLHHWOOD1626
    @VLHHWOOD1626 12 років тому

    I think it is a shame that the statues and religious art work was not removed and saved. As far as the structure is concerned, I wish they would demolish each and every one of those hideous looking old gothic structures. how on earth people ever got the idea that building dark foreboding looking structures would be a fitting tribute to God, I will ever know.

  • @theoctobercountry
    @theoctobercountry 11 років тому

    Um, you DO realise that it was the church that owned the building that was responsible for it's destruction, right? Shameful, in my opinion---the building should have been preserved, even if it were no longer going to be used as a church.

  • @Cameo477
    @Cameo477 12 років тому

    Very sad Video. I'm from Québec, and Lot's of chuches are demolished. Where are we going?

  • @georgefilippello7972
    @georgefilippello7972 3 роки тому

    And why did they demolish this jewel?

  • @CubanodePlacetas
    @CubanodePlacetas 12 років тому

    Why was the church destroyed?

  • @jpengen
    @jpengen 13 років тому

    So very painful to watch...the photography is stunning.

  • @JimTopsecret
    @JimTopsecret 8 років тому

    did the Church catch fire? I didn't know

  • @Benajsa
    @Benajsa 10 років тому +1

    at lease that pipe organ could be sold !!!

  • @eurasia2070
    @eurasia2070 9 років тому +1

    Please. If you demolish this church with these mass on stones, recycle these and build new walls for noise insulation or other houses. These stones are rare.

  • @CSTCFL
    @CSTCFL 14 років тому

    OUTRAGEOUS! What about Our Lady of The Angels Cathrdal in LA ? That church is hideous and a clear example of the "Spirit of Vatican II".

  • @vahakna
    @vahakna 13 років тому

    They should landmarking all history old church buildings

  • @irenagrant-koch7159
    @irenagrant-koch7159 5 років тому

    Sounds like an act of hate. Who was responsible?

  • @14253PF54
    @14253PF54 13 років тому +1

    THIS IS A VERY BUSTARD ACTION,!!! I HOPE AND WANT TO SEE DESTROY A BISHOP'S HOUSE!!! DAMNED!!!

  • @popalis
    @popalis  13 років тому +1

    my dad made that

  • @dergneau
    @dergneau 12 років тому +1

    C'est honteux de démolir une église rien que parce qu'elle se délabre un peu en belgique ont les désacralises sa veut dire arreter de faire des messes dedant et ont en fais un café ou une boite ou une salle mais ont ne les démolit pas!!!! Quel honte...

    • @christineduflos1543
      @christineduflos1543 6 років тому

      Rouspi production vhp il ni a plus dargent pour les renover il ni plus beaucoup de chretiens qui von a leglise c qui les renplace ce son des eglise devangil , ou des athees, ou des mosquet il y aura de plus en plus mosquet avec les migrants qui arrives en masses qui sinstal....pourquoi avons nous quitter nos eglise s que nous somme plus croiyans ??????? C vrais quil ni a plus de miracle

  • @VLHHWOOD1626
    @VLHHWOOD1626 12 років тому +3

    Some look spooky and foreboding; most look like evil castles and others look downright satanic, especially in their latter years when the stone begins to darken and the domes and steeples turn a hideous looking green. The churches constructed today are much more cheery and welcoming and are a far better tribute to God and his love.

    • @skinmaxdestroyer
      @skinmaxdestroyer 3 роки тому +4

      yes it's true, many are ugly and expensive to maintain, they must be destroyed

    • @matmabira
      @matmabira 3 роки тому +4

      yes it's exact
      from the outside it's horrible, it's not beautiful, ugly
      the one in the video is horrible, it's fine to destroy it, it's a good deed

    • @kevcrossboots
      @kevcrossboots 3 роки тому +3

      fallait la détruite elle était moche MDR

    • @kellymeadows353
      @kellymeadows353 3 роки тому +2

      Too expensive to maintain, continues to deteriorate, becomes a safety hazard, not good. Destroy before this can happen

  • @askinlad
    @askinlad 13 років тому

    Are you so short of land over there ? don't you want anything for the next generation to enjoy. Why not use the building for something else? libery, gum, apartments, gallery, theatre, education centre ,restaurant/bar/dance club, even use it as a supermarket. Thats whot thay do in England.

  • @Cameo477
    @Cameo477 12 років тому

    Ca me rend très triste de voir où en ai rendu la société. On démoli les églises..... Que reste t'il? Je vous invite à aller voir un video que j'ai fait. Simplement tapez Église St-Julien Démolie pour voir le vidéo. Merci

  • @marksmyth6018
    @marksmyth6018 6 років тому +3

    Thank goodness the world is cleaning up these disgusting Bronze Age myths. Hopefully soon this will be just an embarrassing page in humanity's history. I really hope we all break free from the horrible evil of christianity.

    • @gambosix6
      @gambosix6 4 роки тому +1

      There IS evil in the men and women in Christianity and G-D will be their judge -but not in Christ; Our Savior, Redeemer, Lord of Lord, King of Kings.

    • @skinmaxdestroyer
      @skinmaxdestroyer 3 роки тому +4

      the problem is ALL religions !

    • @matmabira
      @matmabira 3 роки тому +4

      @@skinmaxdestroyer i agree ;-)

    • @kellymeadows353
      @kellymeadows353 3 роки тому

      @@gambosix6 Religions, All Religions are the problem....mankind with thier dogmas and greed have contaminated everything

  • @Sohave
    @Sohave 13 років тому

    So wastefull! they should have dismantled it instead of just tearing it down complete with all the ornaments and materials inside. So manny god materials for future cheap and charming building just crushed.

  • @maureenbaier8881
    @maureenbaier8881 Рік тому

    Eine schöne Kirche und wen sie Renovirt werden wer sie noch schöner gewesen scherde😢

  • @blargkliggle1121
    @blargkliggle1121 6 років тому +1

    What a hideous amalgamation of stylization, a cheap copy of the grand Gothic cathedrals of Europe.

    • @peterzhang7739
      @peterzhang7739 6 років тому

      Blarg Kliggle i

    • @gambosix6
      @gambosix6 4 роки тому

      but that's all they could afford. /coal miners bringing their tithes to honor G-D. Where would they find the architectural genius to design it properly?

  • @louantbuhagiar
    @louantbuhagiar 9 років тому +2

    shame on you

  • @erikriza7165
    @erikriza7165 2 роки тому

    and Jesus wept

  • @bettyprice6316
    @bettyprice6316 5 років тому

    Vandalism

  • @marektmachowski
    @marektmachowski 9 років тому +3

    Terrible. Shameful.

    • @tylerethan2796
      @tylerethan2796 9 років тому

      my grandfather's church was on fire 2 😫😫😫😫😫

  • @arnaldovinagre4350
    @arnaldovinagre4350 6 років тому +2

    Pure evil!!!!!

  • @apopalis
    @apopalis 11 років тому +5

    I love u dad u are awesome p.s I'm his son

  • @theoctobercountry
    @theoctobercountry 11 років тому +3

    Um, you DO realise that it was the church that owned the building that was responsible for it's destruction, right? Shameful, in my opinion---the building should have been preserved, even if it were no longer going to be used as a church.

    • @mackhopper
      @mackhopper 2 роки тому

      The Diocese owns everything and can close a Parish on a whim of a Bishop or Arch Bishop. you DO reali(z)e this, right?