Looking back at Bron(Thomas), I can see the same phenomenon happening with other bigger bodies. My speculation is after experimentation, some have forgotten who they once were and due to being mistreated by the staff plus Prototype's influence, began developing more animalistic/feral instincts, thus becoming mute after adapting to this new behavior🤔
Catnap was the most aggressive toy to the staff. The reason he stopped appearing in the Smiling Critters cartoon, was due to his toy counterparts poppy gas having side effects on children who bought them. The employees were scared due to this, so for the majority of the time, he was kept in a cage. The developers confirmed that.
I think its even darker: what if he could actually feel being experimented on, and he was screaming the whole time, and he lost his voice for years, but then it came back, but due to losing his voice for more than a year, he forgot his original voice. He only has his toy voice: a raspy and terrifying voice. He doesn’t talk just so you won’t be able to hear him. 😱
Remember, Kissy Missy can’t talk as well, and I don’t think the scientists would have any reason to not give her a voice box. Probably being traumatised. And also, Catnap has a voice box but he only talks when he needs to. The whole time we see Huggy in chapter 1 he has no reason to speak. The first time we see him he’s pretending to be a statue, so he can’t speak. The rest of the time we see him without him trying to kill us as he is stalking us. In the chase scene Huggy seems focused on where we are going as in the story so far for chapter 1 on MOB’s channel the narrator says the vents are like a maze. So it would’ve been easy for Huggy to lose us or for us to lose Huggy. That is unless he knows the vents very well.
1. he was screaming from how painful the experiment was which broke his vocal cords. 2. the scientists accidentally ripped out his vocal cords during the experiment
@@knoahlanMute people can still make noise and utter sounds. If Huggy had a busted voice box or damaged vocal cords he wouldn't be able to communicate effectively but he could still make noises.
"He could be manipulated easily ." And remember huggy has a high level of obedience so that would explain that. Ok lemme recontext that. He could be obedient because he was controlled by prototype edit: MAMA IM TOP COMMENT TYSMMMM
8:16 due to the fact that huggy has been in playtime co for so long anyone could convince him that there is a solution to all this stress & pain but due to that very fact it's super easy to manipulate him
@@IAmThatKid0kay That can actually happen, If you don't talk for a long while you might face some problems while speaking. Some people even didn't talk for years and months which lead their voices to become completely destroyed.
this is what i think: kissy is an infant, thus, cant speak, huggy's was removed so not to expose the true intentions of Playtime Co after his temporary escape, Catnap has his voice, but doesnt talk too much, only when its really necessary, and the only reason his wasnt removed, is because despite knowing that he worships the prototype, due to catnap never really making a move (because of the HOJ plan, but the employees didnt know about it) they thought he could keep his voice since catnap didnt really try to escape or reveal the true intentions of playtime co. until the HOJ.
2:20 well if you go all the way back to chapter one you see in huggys chase scene in the vents it says on the walls things like “STOP” “TURN BACK” or “IM SORRY I HUNGER” and I assume sense Huggy is the only toy we see in chapter one that would be tall enough to write those messages and also I highly doubt that he was just an infant when experimented on because if you think about it in the game station kids think they are just playing games but they are really in secret being tested on by the people in the Bigger Body’s project and the orphan in Huggy wuggy would have had to go through said games and complete them to make a good guard to watch over the children so if an infant played those games i HIGHLY doubt that they would even be able to understand any of it. Am i wrong?
I personally think that huggy can talk but doesnt choose to like if there were scientist that yelled at him and he talked back he would be beaten or something so he kinda stopped talking but he might still initiate small conversations with a select group of people
@@neon_nexuzthere are millions of copy’s of all toys, he could have easily isolated one and took their voice box away so he couldn’t have told anyone abt the incident.. I don’t think that they would have made the prototype with so many voices I think that they knew it would get too out of hand. So I think he actually might be on to smth but it’s my opinion and I’m just saying possible stuff.
The reason why huggy cant talk is probably because of his intelligence, he knows that talking distracts him so for example in irl when your doing something important and talk at the same time you can not focus a little or more like mommy long legs she was yapping quite a bit and got off track a lil she is super intelligent and somehow she still died if she wasn't focused on saying death threats at the player, mommy would still be alive so huggy does this showing that he is more intelligence than all the toys in the factory (except 1006) this is my trash theory so yeah.
I think they could talk Why will huggy talk to the player? Kissy missy she don't need really Ability in future they could talk Or huggy wuggy is cold blooded his mind is like loyal, smart but a dangerous animal mind
I belive that some experiments can talk while other cant because some simply werent designed anatomically for talking, like bron/thomas, boxy boo and huggy wuggy(whos mouthes are just flesh and teeth, they even have tongues ) *cardboard voices are not necessarely canonic, like with DogDay
Fun fact : catnap got only 5 minutes and 15 seconds of screentime in 2 hours game of poppy playtime chapter 3 this shows hiw less screentime catnap got
Bro I am just saying that catnap should atleast get 10 minutes in 2 hour if gameplay tell me if we remove the shrine scene he is only a threat in last 10 minutes
Wasn’t huggy made to be security? What if the scientists didn’t think it was necessary for huggy to talk so they didn’t implant a voicebox in him, wich means he can’t talk just make screams like his jumpscare sound
8:06 but the prototype can speak? We hear his voice right before the catnap bossfight. In the tape. Or maeby the prototype made himself a voice box? I mean he did turn a clock in to a laser pointer😂
I think they use high pitched noises to communicate with each other but we cant hear it only because it's to high to hear. This is associated with an animal but I forgot the name. Also here is why. Remember the jumpscare of huggy wuggy? Or missy screaming? Well there high pitched kind of. If we still hear it then they could try to communicate with us.
DUDE I was wondering why almost nobody was talking about Huggy not talking! I am SO glad you made this video! Whenever I play Poppy Playtime I always think "...why aren't these guys talking if they did in the cut outs?" and I never thought about anything you said, that's dark...great theories though! I kind of hope he has a voice box so that in a future chapter maybe he talks. Maybe the reason why in his jumpscare the scream is so high pitched rather than that deep voice in the cut out they either messed up the voice box, something broke it, or over time it sort of rotted and it now makes a weird noise. Or it's just the jumpscare. Either way, I don't care if he just comes back and does that goofy laugh before chasing you and that's it, or if he full on talks at some point, I just wanna hear him say something. But if he doesn't, it's alright. He might not have anything to say. IF he can talk. I also want to hear people like Kissy too, the reason why I specifically said Huggy is cause he's my favorite character :). But thank you for making this video, I was WAITING so long for someone to actually make a full theory video based on this! P.S. Sorry this comment is so long but I'm gonna give you a sub just for this video!!!! :D
I think that young huggy theory might make more sense because of the movements Huggy and Kissy make, they don't have strong movement, like in PPT:C2 Kissy tries to open the door, but can't do it right. I also kinda agree with the cardboard cutout, maybe either they had voiceboxes at some point but lost them,
I personally think that they still didn’t have voices but they realized that “Wait a sec….. I don’t think this would sell too well because they can’t speak, kids like to talk. So let’s just add voices to our new project, Mommy long legs.” and that failed so they didn’t add voices to Catnap.
1. Maybe the prototype took he's voice box and huggy wuggy can only scream from his pain inside. 2. Maybe the prototype took the voice box from him and experiment to controlled his body
While this IS a good theory, I feel like since Huggy was their first experiment (I think) I feel like they didn’t use a human for him, and, maybe just body parts needed to make him move and talk, such as bones, organs, teeth (lots of them as we see), eyes, and a voice box (maybe one that isn’t developed yet, hence why he only screams.)
Plus in the most recent "break in" / "intruder" VHS tape (the first one) it mentions that huggy was designed to be a security protocol / measure to stop people breaking in the factory and it said that he performed exactly how he was designed
small theory huggy wuggy cant talk because his like the thing used to talk was messed up and maybe thats what they connect to the voice box and with the bigger bodies height it will be important to help with higher tone of speech so they don't sound like a blocked violin or the voice box suddenly broke while being amputated in to huggy wuggy thats the end of the theory
My theroy: maybe these kids/orphans were in control and tried crying for help but when staff heard about this they did surgery of the rotting body inside to remove it's larynx so it can't talk anymore, and these mascots don't know sign language since they never have social media other then the tapes. Huggy Wuggy used to be innocent and happy, UNTILL something.....or someone took control of him and made him follow orders, like he could see everything and feel everything but couldn't do anything about it
Not every experiment was perfect like Bobby and Mommy same with huggy his vocals probably didn't work that well after he was made a toy so that's probably why he was able to make sound but not talk
Dumb theory: Kissy missy makes the same noises as Huggy when she was being attacked (I know they’re practically the same experiment) and some of those noises were because of fear. Huggy also made those exact same noises hinting at him maybe being scared, why? Because if he is an infant he wouldn’t understand the full meaning of death. So, he may be scared the scientists will come back and punish him if he doesn’t do his job. Which is why he acts like it’s “Fun” to chase us.
Ok, this is not related to the vid but the word “prototype” means first time testing or smth like that, the “prototype” most likely is a first time going toy, and that we might have to fight the current one. The prototype could have been any Toy at all, there was no fur, no soft material covering him so he might be a un-Finished toy seeking revenge for the people turning him to the dark. We also know that all experiments were tested on kids, most likely meaning the so called “prototype” was a kid once and got turned to a toy. We also see that the prototype takes the killed toys away, who knows where but he might be trying to fix himself so he can be a full toy and actually get revenge on us, player. I also wanna say one last thing (this is it I promise) there are millions of copy’s of toys, all toys, and we might have not actually killed huggy, mommy, or catnap the prototype just made it seem like we did, we could have killed the prototype of each toy. This could just be the begging…..
I believe they just didn't add a speaker into the bigger bodies its because in that one vhs tape of catnap and elliot he said "is his speaker fixed yet?"
This is my theory:It look like huggy was beenig controlled by the prototype or else he would have a voice like we see with dogday he can speak to us before the little smilling critters came .After that he was under the prototype ‘s control so i think that prototype took the voices out of unimportant toys or the smilling critters just went into every toy who cant speak and they ate the boxal cords but for kissy i think she has the real smilling critters(exept catnap and dogday of course) and mabe they ate the vocal cords .u are my favorite theorist
I personally think Huggy Wuggy and some of the other toys that can’t speak were young children or infants that the prototype easily manipulates to kill or make bad decisions, like when Huggy tried to escape the factory. I think the prototype could have also removed the voice boxes of them, maybe because they disobeyed it and as a punishment it might have removed them.
Huggy and Boxy Were Early Experiments, therefore they really coudn't talk whereas mommy and catnap were created when the scientists knew how to create living toys better, so I hope that explains it
I think it's simpler for the reason the toys can't speak; when they were being turned into toys, the scientists accidentally injured or broke their voice box, causing them to be unable to speak
Here is my theory: the reason buggy does not speak is either because he was one of the first experiments and trials with the bigger bodies initiative and that means there was simply no technology and enough trails. My other thought is that huggy and kissy were siblings or very good friends, we can see the likely hood because when poppy mentioned that the protagonist killed huggy on the elevator in chapter three, kissys body language changes and she looks sad. This could mean that huggy and kissy would once communicate with each other and playtime co did not want to let other children know about these experiments until it was time. So they shut them up so no information could be leaked. Sorry it’s a lot
Wow these theories make sense and they are on par with mine. I often wondered why is it that Huggy and Kissy cannot talk but the others can. Perhaps toys like Catnap are equipped with a voice box and others are not. Huggy's face is forever marred by that permanent smile of his. Catnap doesn't have any teeth and neither does Mommy Long Legs or Poppy, even the Prototype may not be equipped with teeth so maybe the scientists equipped them with speech, especially when they are forced to interact with the children. It is dark to think that the scientists may have removed their voices because of their roles in the factory. It's quite disturbing the more you think about it. I also believed that trauma may have been a key factor to why as well. Experimentation is agony and will forever be etched into your head. PTSD is a powerful thing that can forever screw up your mind and soul. Which is why I can't help but feel bad for all the toys even when they they try to kill you. Their lives have been destroyed.
The first theory seems very probable considering Huggy Wuggy has a tie around his neck just like in many baby photos and the way his body is shaped looks like the average toy a baby would have, long legs and arms. Huggy Wuggy and some other characters also have ruffles around their hands just like a baby’s toy.
Alr quick theory: What if Huggy Wuggy was forced not to talk because of what he knew like think about it who was the one who escape and almost actually made it huggy, and even though this doesn’t prove it I think that a small difference proves it, huggy wuggy is intelligent enough to understand the prototype meaning that his voice was most likely taken away by playtime as you can see the voice box is how they talk but for huggy wuggy. If you look at huggy wuggys neck you see a ribbon, maybe that’s how the stole his voice box from his neck which would explain why he has that on.
I think huggy's human counterpart isn't traumatized, I think we haven't seen him talk because in every situation we saw him in he didn't need to talk, when we see him on the podium he probably was plotting to act like he was just a prop and then move out when the player isn't looking. when he had the key he was probably the one that rewired the cords to blow a fuse when the player interacts with the hand screen beforehand and then whip out the key so that the player goes into the electrical room giving huggy the chance to leave. when we see his arm outside of the door he was trying to lead the player deeper into the factory were it would be harder to escape, because he knew the player would think "what was that" and follow him out of curiosity. when we see him peaking out of the blue vent he was probably making sure that the player was doing what he wanted, talking would blow his cover. when he's chasing after the player he didn't want to waste breath by talking and he wanted to completely focus on catching the player. and why would he want to talk when he was falling? I think the only secret huggy is hiding is that he is smarter then he looks.
My theory is that huggy was a young boy who visited the factory with is family and since the toy was made before the bigger body, I guess he loved the huggy wuggy doll and the scientists noticed. So maybe they used him for the experiment and he was probably traumatized that he was separated from his family. His family could've been used for other experiments, like the prototype.
Imagine if during the catnap fight poppy came over Ollie’s phone and yelled “Theodore” and catnap just snapped and locked in and she said “don’t trust the prototype, he’s using you as a weapon, he just wants to kill you” that would be crazy
The only thing that makes sense to me is that they are traumatised, and are selectively mute, or they do not have a good voice box. The infant theory does not make too much sense to me, since infants do not have much/any control over there body.
theory - what if huggy doesnt speak because of the factor of the factory where huggy first appeared is dark and alone with no other toys there supporting the fact that huggy could have lost his voice due to him not talking relatively because he has been there alone since a long time and the loneliness of the main part of the factory supports that huggy could have developed ptsd since hes an orphan and can knows the pain of being alone giving him severe trauma of left out and this supports it that huggy is obeidient and controllable because he only wants a family / friends
Fun huggy fact:he talks in the chapter 1 trailer of poppy playtime here are some of his line “give me a big squeeze” “i promise i wont bite” “does someone need a hug?”
Oh my dear sweet Lord, if this is the reason why Huggy Wuggy doesn't talk I can definitely see why the Hour of Joy went down...who would want to be used and mistreated like that?
huggy without a voice maybe they only use his voice for voicelines on the cardboard cutouts only or they dont want him to speak so he can warn the kids to get out or something like that idk about catnap, poppy, and mommy longlegs.
Well, I do agree with you, saying that why huggy Wuggy and Kissy missy are mute with no with the cat never say, knocking his voice box removed, but maybe they were just too scared
I feel bad for the toys initially because they were made into toys against their will and they were to young to defend themselves so I can see why the hour of joy would be the only time where they can take revenge on the staff and plus this relates to FNAF in so many ways image them being in the same universe that'd be cool
Wasn't there a YT short from MOB that had them torturing a Huggy doll, he did say "I'm a baby." That has stuck with me now since how Huggy has left an impact since his debut in 2021.
"Catnap walks around with his voice box perfectly intact"
Catnap: T̵ ̴H̷ ̵E̵ ̸P̷ ̶R̴ ̷O̴ ̷T̷ ̴O̷ ̷T̴ ̴Y̷ ̴P̸ ̷E̷ ̸W̸ ̶I̸ ̶L̴ ̷L̷ ̵S̷ ̶A̵ ̷V̶ ̸E̴ ̸U̴ ̸S̵
3:57
leave playcare or i will find you.
Cat nap walks around with his voice box perfectly intact for real life.
Catnap in the game was literally like
꒒ꍟꍏ꒦ꍟ ꉣ꒒ꍏꐞꏳꍏꋪꍟ ꂦꋪ ꀤꂵ ꏳꂦꂵꀤꂚꁅ ꎇꂦꋪ ꐞꂦꀎ
L̵͚͍̣͉̺͕͖̍̆̂̀͊́E̴̮̍͑Ą̵̘͎̮͉̰̥̩̔̏̈́͛̓̓̂͝V̶̖́̀̿̐̄̈́́̆̍͗̄E̸̜̙͕̠̯̰͗̍͆̿̿̀̔̿͗̊̕̕͜ ̴̡̛̛̻͙̝̞͉͑̌͑͒̋̍̓͝P̶̢̼͂͋͛͛̽̿̓̀͋̄̀̀Ĺ̶̙̫̤͕̥̣̽̂͗͗̑̓͠Ȃ̴͔͙̝̘͔͚̪̯̿̍͐̔̊̄͆̈́̄Ȳ̸̢̫̣̟͙̰͍͋̈́̾́̾̓̃̓̇̽C̶̭̽̈͒̀̈́͛̽̚Á̶͖͎̗̤͚̋̊̑̕͜͜͝R̵̨͖̹̈́̊̈̎̀͊͠͝Ḙ̴̩͍̳̙͕̏̋̋̽͐̑͠͝ ̸̛̥͈̯̜̤͌͂̾̀̃͂̓̏̒͝ͅO̸̧̦͙̫̫̘̻̺͓̫̭̼̿̈̐͐̅̕̚R̷̢̫̪͚̥͎̖̣̼̲̍̅̂͐̇̐̑̄ ̷̹̤͙̩̰͕̯̓̓̽̾̚͜Ì̵̹͈̫̉͂́M̴̺̊́̈́̊̈̀ ̶̧͍͔̖͚͈͍̫͊̏̈́̈̃̋͋͘͝C̶͎͉̮̕O̵̡̼̗̥͓̙̐̎̕͝͝͝M̷͉̳̜̬̞͇͋͑̏̈́̅͑̇̊̚͘Ǐ̶̛̮̙͍̜̜̋̈̐̆̉̃̑N̴͍̻̖̗͂͊̍͒͊̑͊͒̑͐̚͝Ģ̸̡̢̡̤͚̲͉͔̭͔̺̏͌͊͊͘ ̶̢̤͕̞͇̾̽̉̋͐F̵̡̨̛̲̳͔̥̫̩̱̱͓̑̊̉̓̄̕ͅǪ̵̹̫͙̱̗̐̆͗͘͝R̷̢̤͍̯̦͚̙̳͈̅͊ͅ ̶̛̪̜͓͎͉̹̪̪̹̾͊̈̔͐̀̕͜͝Ỹ̸̛̭̳̙͉̥͚͇̬̯̺͛̏͌̇͐̾̔̽Ȏ̸̢̬͉̗̙͕̇̒̾̐̀̔͘̕͘
Rewatched this and that is honestly a horrific thought. Making toddlers into toys is absolutely something playtime co would do.
its so sad that thats true
Yes it is true😢😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
They had nurseries for infants so... they seemed prepared to use *babies* for their experiments.
That’s messed up
@@Greenkitten45that’s even more messed up
Looking back at Bron(Thomas), I can see the same phenomenon happening with other bigger bodies. My speculation is after experimentation, some have forgotten who they once were and due to being mistreated by the staff plus Prototype's influence, began developing more animalistic/feral instincts, thus becoming mute after adapting to this new behavior🤔
Catnap was the most aggressive toy to the staff. The reason he stopped appearing in the Smiling Critters cartoon, was due to his toy counterparts poppy gas having side effects on children who bought them. The employees were scared due to this, so for the majority of the time, he was kept in a cage. The developers confirmed that.
I think its even darker: what if he could actually feel being experimented on, and he was screaming the whole time, and he lost his voice for years, but then it came back, but due to losing his voice for more than a year, he forgot his original voice. He only has his toy voice: a raspy and terrifying voice. He doesn’t talk just so you won’t be able to hear him. 😱
Omg this is the most likes I’ve ever gotten
DUDE I'M GONNA THINK ABT THAT NOW. TY FOR THE WONDERFUL THEORYYYYYYYY
😮😮
That is perfect mob games should add that into a sheet in chapter 4 or something
I feel he doesn’t speak because he’s either traumatized which is understandable and he’s also really young when he was an orphan
Or, third option, the scientists/technicians failed to integrate a voice box.
Remember, Kissy Missy can’t talk as well, and I don’t think the scientists would have any reason to not give her a voice box. Probably being traumatised. And also, Catnap has a voice box but he only talks when he needs to. The whole time we see Huggy in chapter 1 he has no reason to speak. The first time we see him he’s pretending to be a statue, so he can’t speak. The rest of the time we see him without him trying to kill us as he is stalking us. In the chase scene Huggy seems focused on where we are going as in the story so far for chapter 1 on MOB’s channel the narrator says the vents are like a maze. So it would’ve been easy for Huggy to lose us or for us to lose Huggy. That is unless he knows the vents very well.
Wait then why does Poppy talk?@@Mayday23019
Good point
1. he was screaming from how painful the experiment was which broke his vocal cords. 2. the scientists accidentally ripped out his vocal cords during the experiment
Great theory!
Well he screams when he jumpscares you, it's clear he is able to make noise.
@@knoahlanMute people can still make noise and utter sounds. If Huggy had a busted voice box or damaged vocal cords he wouldn't be able to communicate effectively but he could still make noises.
@@Greenkitten45 true
If that happened that would be brutal
"He could be manipulated easily ." And remember huggy has a high level of obedience so that would explain that. Ok lemme recontext that. He could be obedient because he was controlled by prototype
edit: MAMA IM TOP COMMENT TYSMMMM
Huh neat maybe if I meet him I can ask for a hug
Ok.......?
Oh my-so true
OMG COME HERE LET ME EAT YOU KITSUNE(I’m joking) 0:16
@@Lavendergaming-rainbowfriends you’d die
8:16 due to the fact that huggy has been in playtime co for so long anyone could convince him that there is a solution to all this stress & pain but due to that very fact it's super easy to manipulate him
I got a theory
What if since he had his mouth closed every single day just being a statue he must have forgotten how to speak
(My lil sis just said that btw) are you sure about that?
@@IAmThatKid0kay That can actually happen, If you don't talk for a long while you might face some problems while speaking. Some people even didn't talk for years and months which lead their voices to become completely destroyed.
@@AfifAanaya1011 oof damn. That sucks
@IAmFromUk2024
Yea a guy didn't talk to his wife for a year and had speaking problems I think
but thats just a theory, A GAME THEORY
this is what i think: kissy is an infant, thus, cant speak, huggy's was removed so not to expose the true intentions of Playtime Co after his temporary escape, Catnap has his voice, but doesnt talk too much, only when its really necessary, and the only reason his wasnt removed, is because despite knowing that he worships the prototype, due to catnap never really making a move (because of the HOJ plan, but the employees didnt know about it) they thought he could keep his voice since catnap didnt really try to escape or reveal the true intentions of playtime co. until the HOJ.
2:20 well if you go all the way back to chapter one you see in huggys chase scene in the vents it says on the walls things like “STOP” “TURN BACK” or “IM SORRY I HUNGER” and I assume sense Huggy is the only toy we see in chapter one that would be tall enough to write those messages and also I highly doubt that he was just an infant when experimented on because if you think about it in the game station kids think they are just playing games but they are really in secret being tested on by the people in the Bigger Body’s project and the orphan in Huggy wuggy would have had to go through said games and complete them to make a good guard to watch over the children so if an infant played those games i HIGHLY doubt that they would even be able to understand any of it. Am i wrong?
I personally think that huggy can talk but doesnt choose to like if there were scientist that yelled at him and he talked back he would be beaten or something so he kinda stopped talking but he might still initiate small conversations with a select group of people
Maybe huggy wuggys voice box was taken by the prototype you know the prototype hss multiple voices?
hmm good idea
The prototype can mimic voices he doesn't take them.
@@neon_nexuzthere are millions of copy’s of all toys, he could have easily isolated one and took their voice box away so he couldn’t have told anyone abt the incident.. I don’t think that they would have made the prototype with so many voices I think that they knew it would get too out of hand. So I think he actually might be on to smth but it’s my opinion and I’m just saying possible stuff.
That sounds like a smart theory, good job
Possible
The reason why huggy cant talk is probably because of his intelligence, he knows that talking distracts him so for example in irl when your doing something important and talk at the same time you can not focus a little or more like mommy long legs she was yapping quite a bit and got off track a lil she is super intelligent and somehow she still died if she wasn't focused on saying death threats at the player, mommy would still be alive so huggy does this showing that he is more intelligence than all the toys in the factory (except 1006) this is my trash theory so yeah.
Good Theory!
I think they could talk
Why will huggy talk to the player?
Kissy missy she don't need really
Ability in future they could talk
Or huggy wuggy is cold blooded his mind is like loyal, smart but a dangerous animal mind
I belive that some experiments can talk while other cant because some simply werent designed anatomically for talking, like bron/thomas, boxy boo and huggy wuggy(whos mouthes are just flesh and teeth, they even have tongues )
*cardboard voices are not necessarely canonic, like with DogDay
This is a top tier explanation of the topic
Bro you need an award
Fun fact : catnap got only 5 minutes and 15 seconds of screentime in 2 hours game of poppy playtime chapter 3 this shows hiw less screentime catnap got
Nightmare huggy only got 2 mins
He was a secondary villian carnap was the main villian so he should have gotten more screentime
@@priyankashami1673 it was done to give the illusion that catnap is ALWAYS watching you, but doesn't want to reveal himself.
Bro I am just saying that catnap should atleast get 10 minutes in 2 hour if gameplay tell me if we remove the shrine scene he is only a threat in last 10 minutes
He only got 10 second of screentime in home sweet home
I think Huggy as a kid was shy and doesn't like to talk.
Nope they took it voice
no stupid kissy not talk too
Wasn’t huggy made to be security? What if the scientists didn’t think it was necessary for huggy to talk so they didn’t implant a voicebox in him, wich means he can’t talk just make screams like his jumpscare sound
This editing is CRAZY. Bro deserves more subscribers than 19.7K. That editing is worth at least 100K subs fr fr.
Love the use of the Puppet master music :D
Ngl huggy and kissy together and seeing them smile upclose is so cute❤️
Oh come on play co had to have had some kind of line, there evil but experimenting on literal infant’s is a whole other level
Exactly
0:47 candy actually can talk! She talks about candy and repeatedly says yum when chasing you. (I think)
I think I know. The reason the mute toys will never wanna talk is because they're stubborn and don't feel like talking.
“The truth behind the silence is more unsettling than you can imagine”
Me: “his throat was slit by a metal spatula”
(Iykyk)
Huggy once said “I will hug you until you pop!”
7:25 the scream sounds like help
So true
8:06 but the prototype can speak? We hear his voice right before the catnap bossfight. In the tape. Or maeby the prototype made himself a voice box? I mean he did turn a clock in to a laser pointer😂
0:44 dog day speaks
"And the ruined critters"
He didn't mention dog day
@@michaelwynn2273 omfg HES A RUINED CRITTER
I think they use high pitched noises to communicate with each other but we cant hear it only because it's to high to hear. This is associated with an animal but I forgot the name. Also here is why. Remember the jumpscare of huggy wuggy? Or missy screaming? Well there high pitched kind of. If we still hear it then they could try to communicate with us.
banshee?
IM NOT FIRST !!! Why this Video is so good… ?
Love your videos bro!!! Not many people talk about this!! Great work keep it up!!
DUDE I was wondering why almost nobody was talking about Huggy not talking! I am SO glad you made this video! Whenever I play Poppy Playtime I always think "...why aren't these guys talking if they did in the cut outs?" and I never thought about anything you said, that's dark...great theories though! I kind of hope he has a voice box so that in a future chapter maybe he talks. Maybe the reason why in his jumpscare the scream is so high pitched rather than that deep voice in the cut out they either messed up the voice box, something broke it, or over time it sort of rotted and it now makes a weird noise. Or it's just the jumpscare. Either way, I don't care if he just comes back and does that goofy laugh before chasing you and that's it, or if he full on talks at some point, I just wanna hear him say something. But if he doesn't, it's alright. He might not have anything to say. IF he can talk. I also want to hear people like Kissy too, the reason why I specifically said Huggy is cause he's my favorite character :). But thank you for making this video, I was WAITING so long for someone to actually make a full theory video based on this! P.S. Sorry this comment is so long but I'm gonna give you a sub just for this video!!!! :D
I think that young huggy theory might make more sense because of the movements Huggy and Kissy make, they don't have strong movement, like in PPT:C2 Kissy tries to open the door, but can't do it right. I also kinda agree with the cardboard cutout, maybe either they had voiceboxes at some point but lost them,
Maybe it was just a survival kind of thing? They just stopped speaking being more quiet to hunt or to hide from being hunting??
I personally think that they still didn’t have voices but they realized that “Wait a sec….. I don’t think this would sell too well because they can’t speak, kids like to talk. So let’s just add voices to our new project, Mommy long legs.” and that failed so they didn’t add voices to Catnap.
In project playtime Huggy talks
No that was the Prototype talking
@@diypropsmodels7064 it was never confirmed to be the prototype, it could be someone else entirely
The prototype will save us
Maybe their voices were put in the cutouts which explains catnaps not working and dogday sounding differantly when we find him?
4:23 just like casca
1. Maybe the prototype took he's voice box and huggy wuggy can only scream from his pain inside. 2. Maybe the prototype took the voice box from him and experiment to controlled his body
While this IS a good theory, I feel like since Huggy was their first experiment (I think) I feel like they didn’t use a human for him, and, maybe just body parts needed to make him move and talk, such as bones, organs, teeth (lots of them as we see), eyes, and a voice box (maybe one that isn’t developed yet, hence why he only screams.)
I think it’s the trauma one where if they say some really traumatic stuff they just didn’t talk
Got another theory on why: the toys where not properly finished yet
Plus in the most recent "break in" / "intruder" VHS tape (the first one) it mentions that huggy was designed to be a security protocol / measure to stop people breaking in the factory and it said that he performed exactly how he was designed
small theory huggy wuggy cant talk because his like the thing used to talk was messed up and maybe thats what they connect to the voice box and with the bigger bodies height it will be important to help with higher tone of speech so they don't sound like a blocked violin or the voice box suddenly broke while being amputated in to huggy wuggy thats the end of the theory
You really have some great videos. Thank you for another one!
Well, what if Catnap speaks because he killed everyone who tried to mute him?
Also with this theory of them being young, when kissy missy was trying to open the gate she fails multiple times.
My theroy: maybe these kids/orphans were in control and tried crying for help but when staff heard about this they did surgery of the rotting body inside to remove it's larynx so it can't talk anymore, and these mascots don't know sign language since they never have social media other then the tapes. Huggy Wuggy used to be innocent and happy, UNTILL something.....or someone took control of him and made him follow orders, like he could see everything and feel everything but couldn't do anything about it
Best ppt creator rn
Not every experiment was perfect like Bobby and Mommy same with huggy his vocals probably didn't work that well after he was made a toy so that's probably why he was able to make sound but not talk
Dumb theory: Kissy missy makes the same noises as Huggy when she was being attacked (I know they’re practically the same experiment) and some of those noises were because of fear. Huggy also made those exact same noises hinting at him maybe being scared, why? Because if he is an infant he wouldn’t understand the full meaning of death. So, he may be scared the scientists will come back and punish him if he doesn’t do his job. Which is why he acts like it’s “Fun” to chase us.
Ok, this is not related to the vid but the word “prototype” means first time testing or smth like that, the “prototype” most likely is a first time going toy, and that we might have to fight the current one. The prototype could have been any Toy at all, there was no fur, no soft material covering him so he might be a un-Finished toy seeking revenge for the people turning him to the dark. We also know that all experiments were tested on kids, most likely meaning the so called “prototype” was a kid once and got turned to a toy. We also see that the prototype takes the killed toys away, who knows where but he might be trying to fix himself so he can be a full toy and actually get revenge on us, player. I also wanna say one last thing (this is it I promise) there are millions of copy’s of toys, all toys, and we might have not actually killed huggy, mommy, or catnap the prototype just made it seem like we did, we could have killed the prototype of each toy. This could just be the begging…..
I believe they just didn't add a speaker into the bigger bodies its because in that one vhs tape of catnap and elliot he said "is his speaker fixed yet?"
I assumed the reason Huggy Wuggy never talked was just because he didn't want to bite his tongue all those sharp teeth.
This is my theory:It look like huggy was beenig controlled by the prototype or else he would have a voice like we see with dogday he can speak to us before the little smilling critters came .After that he was under the prototype ‘s control so i think that prototype took the voices out of unimportant toys or the smilling critters just went into every toy who cant speak and they ate the boxal cords but for kissy i think she has the real smilling critters(exept catnap and dogday of course) and mabe they ate the vocal cords .u are my favorite theorist
Awesome video ❤
mabye huggy and kissy as kids didn't like to talk that much
1:00 bro i spit out my lemonaid and started fucking laughing the theory was so sudden and random 😭🙏
I think he doesn't talk bc he is traumatiezd,like,they tuned him into a toy?As a child!?That is soooooo messed up
Candy cat talks!
Catnap was actually around 5 when he was experiemented on so him not knowing to speak as much is understandable
I personally think Huggy Wuggy and some of the other toys that can’t speak were young children or infants that the prototype easily manipulates to kill or make bad decisions, like when Huggy tried to escape the factory. I think the prototype could have also removed the voice boxes of them, maybe because they disobeyed it and as a punishment it might have removed them.
Huggy and Boxy Were Early Experiments, therefore they really coudn't talk whereas mommy and catnap were created when the scientists knew how to create living toys better, so I hope that explains it
2:21 Welp, it’s no longer a theory, but cannon! They said Huggy was made as like a security guard for the factory in their newest video.
I think it's simpler for the reason the toys can't speak; when they were being turned into toys, the scientists accidentally injured or broke their voice box, causing them to be unable to speak
Hold on… this makes sense, what if huggy wuggy is that baby that was found in Elliot Ludwig’s apartment…oh god that’s dark
He can speak he doesn’t in game because he is a toy right? They didn’t add a voice box but in mob interanment he gives huggy and kissy a voice
Here is my theory: the reason buggy does not speak is either because he was one of the first experiments and trials with the bigger bodies initiative and that means there was simply no technology and enough trails. My other thought is that huggy and kissy were siblings or very good friends, we can see the likely hood because when poppy mentioned that the protagonist killed huggy on the elevator in chapter three, kissys body language changes and she looks sad. This could mean that huggy and kissy would once communicate with each other and playtime co did not want to let other children know about these experiments until it was time. So they shut them up so no information could be leaked.
Sorry it’s a lot
But if technology was a problem then how could Elliot build playcare
When Huggy jumpscares you it looks like he’s excited so he probably didn’t know how to talk and he screamed in joy for something to eat after so long
Good Theory!!!!🎉🎉🎉🎉
answer me this who made the cardborad cut outs and who added the vicoes of angony like in the simling criters?
wait what if the prototype made them but just added audio like screaming and vhs tapes as in his master plan to lore the player
Greatest theory
Springlock failure
Wow these theories make sense and they are on par with mine. I often wondered why is it that Huggy and Kissy cannot talk but the others can. Perhaps toys like Catnap are equipped with a voice box and others are not. Huggy's face is forever marred by that permanent smile of his. Catnap doesn't have any teeth and neither does Mommy Long Legs or Poppy, even the Prototype may not be equipped with teeth so maybe the scientists equipped them with speech, especially when they are forced to interact with the children. It is dark to think that the scientists may have removed their voices because of their roles in the factory. It's quite disturbing the more you think about it. I also believed that trauma may have been a key factor to why as well. Experimentation is agony and will forever be etched into your head. PTSD is a powerful thing that can forever screw up your mind and soul. Which is why I can't help but feel bad for all the toys even when they they try to kill you. Their lives have been destroyed.
The first theory seems very probable considering Huggy Wuggy has a tie around his neck just like in many baby photos and the way his body is shaped looks like the average toy a baby would have, long legs and arms. Huggy Wuggy and some other characters also have ruffles around their hands just like a baby’s toy.
Alr quick theory: What if Huggy Wuggy was forced not to talk because of what he knew like think about it who was the one who escape and almost actually made it huggy, and even though this doesn’t prove it I think that a small difference proves it, huggy wuggy is intelligent enough to understand the prototype meaning that his voice was most likely taken away by playtime as you can see the voice box is how they talk but for huggy wuggy. If you look at huggy wuggys neck you see a ribbon, maybe that’s how the stole his voice box from his neck which would explain why he has that on.
I think huggy's human counterpart isn't traumatized, I think we haven't seen him talk because in every situation we saw him in he didn't need to talk, when we see him on the podium he probably was plotting to act like he was just a prop and then move out when the player isn't looking. when he had the key he was probably the one that rewired the cords to blow a fuse when the player interacts with the hand screen beforehand and then whip out the key so that the player goes into the electrical room giving huggy the chance to leave. when we see his arm outside of the door he was trying to lead the player deeper into the factory were it would be harder to escape, because he knew the player would think "what was that" and follow him out of curiosity. when we see him peaking out of the blue vent he was probably making sure that the player was doing what he wanted, talking would blow his cover. when he's chasing after the player he didn't want to waste breath by talking and he wanted to completely focus on catching the player. and why would he want to talk when he was falling? I think the only secret huggy is hiding is that he is smarter then he looks.
Huggy being a infant is kinda because huggy walks like he just learned how to walk
My theory is that huggy was a young boy who visited the factory with is family and since the toy was made before the bigger body, I guess he loved the huggy wuggy doll and the scientists noticed. So maybe they used him for the experiment and he was probably traumatized that he was separated from his family.
His family could've been used for other experiments, like the prototype.
Probablly Huggy and Kissy never had an voice, cus' if they open their mouths.... it isn't going to end well
Imagine if during the catnap fight poppy came over Ollie’s phone and yelled “Theodore” and catnap just snapped and locked in and she said “don’t trust the prototype, he’s using you as a weapon, he just wants to kill you” that would be crazy
The only thing that makes sense to me is that they are traumatised, and are selectively mute, or they do not have a good voice box.
The infant theory does not make too much sense to me, since infants do not have much/any control over there body.
In project playtime I think prototype has the voice because when you are a monster he will say " PUT THEM IN THE PIPE"
maybe the prototype is like...
Prototype : hey huggy if you do that i'll give you a hug
Huggy : YES SIR
AHADHDXAXHRAXHRRAHR yeah maybe-
Mat pat:Do I smell...LORE!?
Think you for about my game
theory -
what if huggy doesnt speak because of the factor of the factory where huggy first appeared is dark and alone with no other toys there supporting the fact that huggy could have lost his voice due to him not talking relatively because he has been there alone since a long time and the loneliness of the main part of the factory supports that huggy could have developed ptsd since hes an orphan and can knows the pain of being alone giving him severe trauma of left out and this supports it that huggy is obeidient and controllable because he only wants a family / friends
Fun huggy fact:he talks in the chapter 1 trailer of poppy playtime here are some of his line “give me a big squeeze” “i promise i wont bite” “does someone need a hug?”
The smiling critters chewed his voice box
Oh my dear sweet Lord, if this is the reason why Huggy Wuggy doesn't talk I can definitely see why the Hour of Joy went down...who would want to be used and mistreated like that?
Huggy and kissy can speak in the carbord cut out but not when you see them in reality 😮😮😮
huggy without a voice maybe they only use his voice for voicelines on the cardboard cutouts only or they dont want him to speak so he can warn the kids to get out or something like that idk about catnap, poppy, and mommy longlegs.
Erm actually the Ruined critters giggle 🤓☝️
It’s also to note that the toys get more intelligent, CatNap responds to his human name “Theo”
Well, I do agree with you, saying that why huggy Wuggy and Kissy missy are mute with no with the cat never say, knocking his voice box removed, but maybe they were just too scared
I feel bad for the toys initially because they were made into toys against their will and they were to young to defend themselves so I can see why the hour of joy would be the only time where they can take revenge on the staff and plus this relates to FNAF in so many ways image them being in the same universe that'd be cool
Wasn't there a YT short from MOB that had them torturing a Huggy doll, he did say "I'm a baby."
That has stuck with me now since how Huggy has left an impact since his debut in 2021.
5:53 adding on to that, the prototype could have stabbed out their voice boxes and threatened them