How people react emotionally! Alas dont they see, emotional reaction is the first problem of problems to come?! In fact everyone talking in this comment did not study (islamic) politics or warfare let alone religion. So they defame the shayk for not taking political factors in to accpunt while they have neother religion nor politics...
Let me guess, thise brothers who made comments regarding the Palestinians, that should stay and fight especially in Gaza, you guys are still in your comfy homes being keyboatd warriors. May ALLAAH rectify our affairs and keep us firm upon the path of the pious predecessors
No Actually we are the Shia of Ali ibn abi Talib and we are not in our homes like you women, we are on the front lines, just ask the Palestinians. This is treachery from traitors of the Ummah like Ive never seen before. Islam is blessed to have the Shia otherwise it would have "men" like you lot to hand over their land and women. You all should be ashamed of yourselves. I guess no more Jihad, whenever the Muslims are losing a war, we are to surrender and migrate, This is ignorance on a whole new level but im not surprised in the least, your only following the ways of your forefathers...
Allah's Land is Spacious. Didn't you see many Palestine Muslims Living in America? In Jordan? In Saudi? How they migrated? Use the efforts to good means to migrate instead of killing unarmed civilians in their festivals and making greater harms to the Muslims. The surprise attack which took place is Not permissible. It has brought Greater harms to Gaza people. Muslims should use the wisdoms. Actions of the militants are not acceptable and void of Hikmah.
@@Colby_0-3_IRL_and_title_fightsYep, especially if you don't share the same race as people in those countries, as a brazilian muslim, i will probably go to afghanistan since they only care about faith and not race, all arab states would be a bad idea for me based on the way they treat people from the subcontinent.
Jazak Allah Khair. By your permission I wish to share this on my channel, entirely for sake of ALLAH almighty and guidance to Muslims. May ALLAH reward your efforts in this world and hereafter. Kind Regards
As salaam mu alay kum waragmahtuALLAAH hi wabarakahtu ikhwaah, may ALLAAH reward you all well for keeping this channel going with beneficial knowledge. Is there a link to the audio Sheigh Al Albani mentions (may ALLAAH have mercy on him)
Allah has kept the door of Hijra open for those who are oppressed and cannot practice their deen. If the Palestinian Muslims are and were not able to defend themselves, do Defensive jihad initially and they lost , then a treaties is to be done. If not, than hijra, just Rasool sallal lahu alaihi wa sallam and his Sahabah Radhi Allahu anhum did from Makkah, Abysinia , Makkah to Madeenah
What would all the critics say about the saying of prophet s.a.w saying look at the magnificence of the Kabba and that the life a Muslim is even more precious than the kabba. Masjid al Aqsa is not important as Kabba.
@@Rabbi-Jill-kews what will you do on the day of resurrection when all the pakistans you've slandered will take from your good deeds? and if you run out, you will be given their sins?
People follow desires ...not have faith in Allah. That Allah will uplift there situation by any means.. they think if Palestinians leave they will occupy and destroy Al asqa... but forget the people of fil how Allah destroy the people of Elephants who came to destroy Kabah ..yet Allah Saved abdul mutallib the grant father of Rasool Allah .
First it wasn't a Fatwa it was the summarization of a Fatwa he already gave in clear and precise terms! How ignorant of the general people to even speak on the Scholars, with impunity like their nobility is equal! This comment section is more proof of the Nabi's Statements about the Jahil, the ignorant general people and their disdain to be guided by the noblest men and women of Islam , our Scholars. Even if the ruling is wrong he (Shaykh Al Albaani) رحم الله will still have the reward with our Lord, who amongst us here can claim that!?
Sad part is he misquoted these ayah to support the aggression of enemies. In d case of hijrah makkah was the land for both communities & none forced them to expel & it was Allah's order to rasool saw to travel. If he justify migration then where is Allah's sign that says about a country to migrate. The sheikh omit replying to answer the question to avoid any problem.
@@syedahmedosama6073 "makkah was the land for both communities" And now you omit the part where, even back then, one community oppressed the other, even as far as planned to assassinated the Prophet ﷺ
@@Hilman_Faiz Sisi of Eygpt, king of jordan and MBS of KSA clearly said to not make phalestinians 0ut of gaza and they won't let that happen putting them to eygot or jordan. You have not even seen news that you are coming here and talking about history when the eman of kuslims are not even compare to eman at the time of prophet. you can do like Ansar did they gave thier half home half properly and even one of wife for marry. you people here for speaking only not action.
There is only one passage for migration it is rafah border in gaza. It is not opened except for few hours for only trucks to pass. The fatwa is old and if shaykh was alive ans told the exact situstion of what is happening in 2023. then the fatwa would surely wont be same. Shaykh is not wrong but shaykh is not alive who in 2023 having knowledge of what is happening at border which is the only one way for gaza people to exit.
السلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته Individuals of that Ilk had and have many strange fatwas that are often convenient for the oppressors. There are many things hidden in their books which if you read it you will understand their behavior and why they are not helping Muslims being killed now. I pray that Muslims wake up and leave that sect. May Allah help the Muslims
This is a very unacceptable statement by the Sheikh . And it seems by his statement that he is giving a biased statement towards one sect while allowing the other sect to take over the place of West Bank.
@@Rabbi-Jill-kews Remember, Allah is going to ask you about the words you used for the sheikh and the accusations you made against him. Be ready to answer to Allah. May Allah guide you and us all
1. They made Hijrah to Ethiopia first 2. If medina was to be attacked were the occupants meant to defend it or were they instructed to make hijrah from it ?
the Muslims of Madinah were strong in faith, loved and loving to Allah and His rasul ﷺ. they submitted completely and divorced the dunyah and sought only the Face of their Lord. Their hearts were rectified upon the truth, and they had the physical means and the Aid of Allah, so He gave them victory over the mushrikun. Where's the people like this today? we have the people of the worldly life, the people of chasing wealth, the people of qaza, the people of sagging pants, the people of jahil traditions, the people of free-mixing, the people of riba, the people of heedlessness. May Allah save us and rectify our hearts. Palestine isn't the only country where muslims are oppressed, and while I have no knowledge of the unseen, it is seemingly not going to be the last one. Muslims in India are harmed, Muslims in Africa are harmed, Muslims in China are harmed, Muslims in France, and other countries are harmed. May the curse of Allah, His angels, and all of His believing slaves be upon His Enemies, from the ones we see and the ones we see not, but our Lord sees, For He the All-Knower of the unseen and the seen, the All-Mighty, the Most Merciful.
the time of prophet there was no restrictions in migration as we see now. now borders are guarded and closed its not easy to migrate. the fatwa is old and those who are uploading and applying to now should fear Allaah as right now even saudi arabia is trying to take out many non saudis by saudization let alome migration of non saudis in this land.
I have made a personal decision to boycott anyone (regardless of who they are)who claims or even tries to say that the palestinians are suffering because of their aqeedah and once they correct their aqeedah then everything will be fine . I personally think aqeedah is the core of our deen but should not be weaponised to advocate for genocide even if the genocide were to be carried out to non Muslims. I also think it’s a grave matter to tamper with natural human justice rights using the aqeedah argument. We know that even the best of the best went through trials inspite of their aqeedah . Some individuals have made it very difficult for the community to support the Palestinian cause and they claim it’s all for aqeedah. This is a grave mistake and should be made clear to everyone .
stop talking without knowledge and be humble. Not to mock you, but you are nobody to talk about the religion. Just stop, you will be accountable in front of Allah for what you say
@@nasriibrahim5533what do you mean their country? There is no such a thing. All land belongs to Allah and anyone who lives or was born in land ruled by kuffar should do hijra to place ruled by quran and sunnah. In the Sunnah, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “I disown every Muslim who settles among the mushrikeen.” Narrated by Abu Dawood, 2645. I myself am organizing my departure from Finland were i was born do i have right to finland? No! Im leaving even when in not being oppressed, when you are oppressed it’s mandatory to leave. Zakariya al-Ansaari al-Shaafa’i said in his book Asna al-Mataalib (4/207): It is obligatory to migrate from the kaafir lands to the Muslim lands for those who are able to do that, if they are unable to practise their religion openly. Is this not the reality in syria and palestine?
@@theunknownSoldier. You are not being rational. According to your logic, you are saying to tell the Chechens and Dagestanis to leave Russia because of Russia's crackdown on the Salafi movement. Your Hadith is also not applicable to the West Bank or Gaza. They live amongst other Muslims and are only under military occupation.
Masjidil Haram is more virtues and sacred yet the Prophet s.a.w left Makkah for Madinah to protect his life and his companions lives. Allah will take care of Masjidil Aqsa
He forgot the prophet migrated to establish the religion and to create a base to conquer makkah. Not to live as refugees under tyrant secular leaders where they can't apply there religion
Live as refugees under tyrant secular leaders? Where? This is what i know how refugees are treated in Saudi.. the land of tauhid (not secular) ua-cam.com/video/ggiRUk57Tz0/v-deo.html
may allah forgive him for this disgusting opinion. The people of makkah made hijrah out of extreme need as they were small in number and islam was young. now we have leaders and billions of muslims yet none can help us and come to our aid ? the gulf leaders have trillions and cannot even feed the ampute children in Gaza. indeed allah will give each person what they have earned for themselves. We Palestinians have honor and shame. our land is not for European jews to take. no, by allah! the land of isa and yahya and zakkariya cannot be ruled by their ones who tried to kill them. madkhalis have harmed the ummah
You just didn't listen. He said that he was not a king himself. What you are talking about is a matter of politics. Scholars are not governors, they just spend their lives learning the deen and convey the message in its proper form. There is a specific solution for people who are oppressed and who don't receive the necessary aid from authorities (for whatever reason including the passive behavior of other muslims), it is the hijrah. Moreover, your argument is just weak. Makkah didn't rightfully belong to the pagan qur'aych when Allah (swt) ordered to perform Hijrah to Madina. The muslims back then were in their right and yet they had to flee by leaving their homes and belongings. That's the definition of exile, of course you'd prefer to stay in your land but you are forced to leave. Given the current situation, the palestinians who are able to leave should leave towards muslim lands, have patience and keep in mind that the zionists will eventually lose.
so you say Palestinian Gaza should stay and get slaughtered? 90 percent are homeless more than 30.000 dead and 60.000 injured, more trauma, rapes etc. How will this help Gaza if they stay? Sheikh Albani rahimahullah was right, sheikh used Quran and Sunnah and you use emotion as opinion.
@@MysteryVault-rhthe life of a the Muslims means more (لزوال الدنيا أهون على الله من قتل رجل مسلم” (رواه الترمذي” “The destruction of the world is lighter on Allah than the killing of one Muslim man”, (Tirmidhi)
@@isafcb312 I love how you guys just quotes Hadith just to suite your view. the Hadith shows the life of a Muslim is precious not that they should abandoned their life because they face oppression on their own land. And again the Hadith just shows all Muslim countries aren't infact Islamic because if they're they would have rise up against the killings of Muslims as their life is is precious in sight of Allah
@@isafcb312 if any countries like UAE, QATAR, SAUDI ARABIA etc..... faces oppression just like the Palestinians would you just advice them to leave while the ummah just stay and watch as the oppression and killings go on??
@@MysteryVault-rhno we quote authentic Hadith and Quran when necessary, sheikh has told you sunnah of the prophet Muhammad Sallahu Alayahi Wa Salaam migrating from one area to another in a time of weakness, did they fear losing something in dunya? No they had tawakkul and knew Allah would return it or replace with better, my brothers and sisters deserve not to starve to death, be bombed, raped, tortured and labelled terrorists, if you don’t like it go live in Gaza and let the innocent out, you want it so bad that you’ll ignore sunnah and Hadith go there and die for it, but the innocent who want to live and be happy I hope Allah provides them a way out so no baby has to be slaughtered again that’s my stance and it’s backed up in the Hadith, if Allah takes Al Aqsa from us for a short time 1. He will return it back one day no doubt tawakkul 2. It should make us Muslims outside of Palestine realise how privileged we are and how much we need to rid our selves and communities of bidah and shirk for what a terrible loss, but the loss of life is more, next up don’t say you guys the Hadith if authentic from prophet Muhammad Sallahu Alayahi Wa Salaam and sheikh is giving sunnah, do not compare me to either they’re free of me and my wrong Lastly do not pass general takfir of nations, I should of started with this because you’re clearly a takfiri and therefore shouldn’t be respected however I thought those points were worth addressing before leaving, let us read Surah Al-Kahf Assalamu Alaikum
I don't think our beloved Prophet Muhamad saw would tell the Native Palestinians and all Muslims to abandon Al Aqsa Astagfirullah. We know he Black Flags riding from Khorasan won't be riding AWAY from Al Aqsa, but towards it to defend Islam. And Allah knows best.
The doors of Hijra is open. If Palestinian Muslims cannot practice the Deen and they obviously cannot defend themselves, no one's helping, make treaties, if not make hijra like Rasool sallal laahu alaihi wa sallam and his Sahabah Radhi Allahu anhum.
Our Prophet Muhammad ﷺ told the Native people of Makkah to abandon Makkah to avoid oppression from Kuffar of Quraisy and to build strength with other Muslims in Madinah.
He did not mean migration is the Entire Solution. He only meant migration as an option. And since then, Alhamdulillah Jordan have accepted around 2 million or more Palestinians
Don't judge great scholars based on their references to the Quran and Sunnah. Before passing judgment, provide a better solution if you have one in the light of the Quran and Sunnah.
@@Lzali10469 where have you studied? for seemingly your opinion is more rightly guided than the muhaddith Muhammad Nasir al-Din al-Albani, may Allah have mercy on him and make his grave spacious? now is not the time for throwing stones, its the time for returning to the haqq.
@@Lzali10469 "it’s better to stay there and protect the nobal masjid Al Aqsa" Why is it better to stay there, while the Prophet ﷺ gave example of choosing to leave Makkah and build strength with the Muslims in Madinah?
hahahaha shaykh you mean to say vacate palistine and migrate ? ok now tell me where to migrate and who is going to take them as citizen ? A person spent his 40 year muslim country but never get nationality ad they will kick him out. here now u r saying migrtion ? and by the way this is not true fatwa. A Muslim leader should send help not that they should maigrate. During the time of rasool Allah (saw) there is no muslim state so Madina is the first muslim state.. now you need pilestan muslims to estabilish another first muslim state or we already have muslim country ? May Allah forgive you shaykh, i dislike this fatwa. Allah knows best
@@Abdelqadir-f3y In the book entitled “Fatâwa sh-Chaykh Al-Albâni” (page 18 of this edition) Al-Albâni said: « السؤال : أهل الضفة الغربية هل يجوز أن يخرجوا (من أرضهم) ويهاجروا إلى بلد ثانية ؟ الجواب (الالباني): يجب أن يخرجوا… يا أخي يجب أن يخرجوا من الأرش م يتمكنوا من طرد الكافر منها إلى أرض يتمكنون فيها من القيام بشعائرهم الاسلامية. » “Question: Is it permissible for the people of Ad-Difah Al-Gharbiyyah (the unoccupied territories of Palestine) to leave their lands and emigrate to another country? Response (from Al-Albâni): It is a duty for them to leave! O my brother, it is a duty to leave a land in which we are unable to repel the disbeliever, to go to a land in which they can practice Islam.
![Is Allah Confined to a Place? [Sheikh Muhammad Naasir-ud-Deen al-Albaani]](/img/n.gif)
How people react emotionally! Alas dont they see, emotional reaction is the first problem of problems to come?! In fact everyone talking in this comment did not study (islamic) politics or warfare let alone religion. So they defame the shayk for not taking political factors in to accpunt while they have neother religion nor politics...
Jazaakallahu khairan
Let me guess, thise brothers who made comments regarding the Palestinians, that should stay and fight especially in Gaza, you guys are still in your comfy homes being keyboatd warriors. May ALLAAH rectify our affairs and keep us firm upon the path of the pious predecessors
No Actually we are the Shia of Ali ibn abi Talib and we are not in our homes like you women, we are on the front lines, just ask the Palestinians. This is treachery from traitors of the Ummah like Ive never seen before. Islam is blessed to have the Shia otherwise it would have "men" like you lot to hand over their land and women. You all should be ashamed of yourselves. I guess no more Jihad, whenever the Muslims are losing a war, we are to surrender and migrate, This is ignorance on a whole new level but im not surprised in the least, your only following the ways of your forefathers...
Your forefathers betrayed Ali ibn Abi Talib RA and al Hussein RA!!@@geemup557
the big question it's there's a place of migration for million of PALESTINIAN PEOPLE?
The place where billions of people live is the place for the Palestinians to migrate which is the vast earth of Allah the most high.
Allah's Land is Spacious. Didn't you see many Palestine Muslims Living in America? In Jordan? In Saudi? How they migrated? Use the efforts to good means to migrate instead of killing unarmed civilians in their festivals and making greater harms to the Muslims. The surprise attack which took place is Not permissible. It has brought Greater harms to Gaza people. Muslims should use the wisdoms. Actions of the militants are not acceptable and void of Hikmah.
@@samysab8540
I think he's saying that many Muslims countries are no where near as welcoming to their Muslim brothers as they should be
@@Colby_0-3_IRL_and_title_fightsYep, especially if you don't share the same race as people in those countries, as a brazilian muslim, i will probably go to afghanistan since they only care about faith and not race, all arab states would be a bad idea for me based on the way they treat people from the subcontinent.
Jazak Allah Khair. By your permission I wish to share this on my channel, entirely for sake of ALLAH almighty and guidance to Muslims. May ALLAH reward your efforts in this world and hereafter. Kind Regards
As salaam mu alay kum waragmahtuALLAAH hi wabarakahtu ikhwaah, may ALLAAH reward you all well for keeping this channel going with beneficial knowledge. Is there a link to the audio Sheigh Al Albani mentions (may ALLAAH have mercy on him)
Allah has kept the door of Hijra open for those who are oppressed and cannot practice their deen. If the Palestinian Muslims are and were not able to defend themselves, do Defensive jihad initially and they lost , then a treaties is to be done. If not, than hijra, just Rasool sallal lahu alaihi wa sallam and his Sahabah Radhi Allahu anhum did from Makkah, Abysinia , Makkah to Madeenah
Many people prefer to follow emotions and desires instead of guidance from Quran and Sunnah in times of fitnah
Or you just cowards
Abyssinia is the land of disbelievers
What would all the critics say about the saying of prophet s.a.w saying look at the magnificence of the Kabba and that the life a Muslim is even more precious than the kabba. Masjid al Aqsa is not important as Kabba.
Stop slandering scholars! This is an opinion! He is not a ruler and obviously will not act as one!
This is not slander akhi
@@soldierof-allah11 to the commenter btw
Allahuakbar the ilm he has !!!
let me guess, pakistani right?
@@Rabbi-Jill-kewswhat's wrong
@@TawhidCodex Pakistanis are the biggest boot kickers
@@Rabbi-Jill-kews have some manners in this comment section please.
@@Rabbi-Jill-kews what will you do on the day of resurrection when all the pakistans you've slandered will take from your good deeds? and if you run out, you will be given their sins?
و عليكم السلام و رحمة الله وبركاته
People follow desires ...not have faith in Allah. That Allah will uplift there situation by any means.. they think if Palestinians leave they will occupy and destroy Al asqa... but forget the people of fil how Allah destroy the people of Elephants who came to destroy Kabah ..yet Allah Saved abdul mutallib the grant father of Rasool Allah .
Just reflect cowardness, we don't follow Abdul Mutholib
Where is the casette”tapes?
كثير من الناس يتبعون هواهم
Where it's fatwa is written?
Gaza is like madinah..not makkah
With time this fatwa is a terrible fatwa but I can understand his concern for the lives of the people
What makes it terrible
Like its their fault whats on them now for not listening to the advices of the scolar. It could be taken like this.
First it wasn't a Fatwa it was the summarization of a Fatwa he already gave in clear and precise terms! How ignorant of the general people to even speak on the Scholars, with impunity like their nobility is equal! This comment section is more proof of the Nabi's Statements about the Jahil, the ignorant general people and their disdain to be guided by the noblest men and women of Islam , our Scholars. Even if the ruling is wrong he (Shaykh Al Albaani) رحم الله will still have the reward with our Lord, who amongst us here can claim that!?
There's alot you 'don't' understand, stop advancing yourself to the front of the "Men of Understanding"
we are speaking about migration of 2 million people not 1000 people which was in time of Prophet.
Sad part is he misquoted these ayah to support the aggression of enemies. In d case of hijrah makkah was the land for both communities & none forced them to expel & it was Allah's order to rasool saw to travel. If he justify migration then where is Allah's sign that says about a country to migrate. The sheikh omit replying to answer the question to avoid any problem.
Madinah back then can take 1000 refugees.
Muslim Countries nowadays Muslim countries can absolutely take 2 million refugees.
@@syedahmedosama6073 "makkah was the land for both communities"
And now you omit the part where, even back then, one community oppressed the other, even as far as planned to assassinated the Prophet ﷺ
@@Hilman_Faiz but no muslim country is ready to take them as refugees.
@@Hilman_Faiz Sisi of Eygpt, king of jordan and MBS of KSA clearly said to not make phalestinians 0ut of gaza and they won't let that happen putting them to eygot or jordan. You have not even seen news that you are coming here and talking about history when the eman of kuslims are not even compare to eman at the time of prophet. you can do like Ansar did they gave thier half home half properly and even one of wife for marry. you people here for speaking only not action.
There is only one passage for migration it is rafah border in gaza. It is not opened except for few hours for only trucks to pass. The fatwa is old and if shaykh was alive ans told the exact situstion of what is happening in 2023. then the fatwa would surely wont be same. Shaykh is not wrong but shaykh is not alive who in 2023 having knowledge of what is happening at border which is the only one way for gaza people to exit.
السلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته
Individuals of that Ilk had and have many strange fatwas that are often convenient for the oppressors. There are many things hidden in their books which if you read it you will understand their behavior and why they are not helping Muslims being killed now. I pray that Muslims wake up and leave that sect. May Allah help the Muslims
Yet you can’t prove they are not in accordance with Quran and Sunnah, you can only make claims and accusations
@@Randomhandlenameyou just justify your cowardness by using Al Qur'an and sunnah
@@andreannomattona493 show us how I am doing that, instead of making empty claims
Von welche Fatwas redest du?
This is a very unacceptable statement by the Sheikh . And it seems by his statement that he is giving a biased statement towards one sect while allowing the other sect to take over the place of West Bank.
Shut ur mouth .. he’s the shaykh not u
May Allah pardon you and guide you, brother
Did Allah tell the muhajireen to move out of Makkah because he wanted the other "sect" to take over Makkah?
@@bahrain7274 albani isnt an sheikh he have no 3ilm like the wahabi dogs of Amerika who destroyed Arab and Islamic nation
@@Rabbi-Jill-kews Remember, Allah is going to ask you about the words you used for the sheikh and the accusations you made against him. Be ready to answer to Allah. May Allah guide you and us all
1. They made Hijrah to Ethiopia first
2. If medina was to be attacked were the occupants meant to defend it or were they instructed to make hijrah from it ?
the Muslims of Madinah were strong in faith, loved and loving to Allah and His rasul ﷺ. they submitted completely and divorced the dunyah and sought only the Face of their Lord. Their hearts were rectified upon the truth, and they had the physical means and the Aid of Allah, so He gave them victory over the mushrikun.
Where's the people like this today? we have the people of the worldly life, the people of chasing wealth, the people of qaza, the people of sagging pants, the people of jahil traditions, the people of free-mixing, the people of riba, the people of heedlessness. May Allah save us and rectify our hearts.
Palestine isn't the only country where muslims are oppressed, and while I have no knowledge of the unseen, it is seemingly not going to be the last one. Muslims in India are harmed, Muslims in Africa are harmed, Muslims in China are harmed, Muslims in France, and other countries are harmed.
May the curse of Allah, His angels, and all of His believing slaves be upon His Enemies, from the ones we see and the ones we see not, but our Lord sees, For He the All-Knower of the unseen and the seen, the All-Mighty, the Most Merciful.
@@user-eq5rt3cv9b all these words used as scapegoat so u don't have to stand with the Islamic resistance
@user-eq5rt3cv9b Muslims weren't instructed to migrate from madina they wee instructed to defend it
@@mrlesta i forgive you for the lie you've told about me.
@@user-eq5rt3cv9b do u stand with islamic resistance in palestune ?
the time of prophet there was no restrictions in migration as we see now. now borders are guarded and closed its not easy to migrate. the fatwa is old and those who are uploading and applying to now should fear Allaah as right now even saudi arabia is trying to take out many non saudis by saudization let alome migration of non saudis in this land.
I have made a personal decision to boycott anyone (regardless of who they are)who claims or even tries to say that the palestinians are suffering because of their aqeedah and once they correct their aqeedah then everything will be fine . I personally think aqeedah is the core of our deen but should not be weaponised to advocate for genocide even if the genocide were to be carried out to non Muslims. I also think it’s a grave matter to tamper with natural human justice rights using the aqeedah argument. We know that even the best of the best went through trials inspite of their aqeedah . Some individuals have made it very difficult for the community to support the Palestinian cause and they claim it’s all for aqeedah. This is a grave mistake and should be made clear to everyone .
stop talking without knowledge and be humble. Not to mock you, but you are nobody to talk about the religion. Just stop, you will be accountable in front of Allah for what you say
Like your said its your opinion, not the reality
@@iliasb2761 What is the reality? Should the Syrian Sunnis leave their country because the Alawites oppress them?
@@nasriibrahim5533what do you mean their country? There is no such a thing. All land belongs to Allah and anyone who lives or was born in land ruled by kuffar should do hijra to place ruled by quran and sunnah. In the Sunnah, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “I disown every Muslim who settles among the mushrikeen.” Narrated by Abu Dawood, 2645. I myself am organizing my departure from Finland were i was born do i have right to finland? No! Im leaving even when in not being oppressed, when you are oppressed it’s mandatory to leave. Zakariya al-Ansaari al-Shaafa’i said in his book Asna al-Mataalib (4/207):
It is obligatory to migrate from the kaafir lands to the Muslim lands for those who are able to do that, if they are unable to practise their religion openly.
Is this not the reality in syria and palestine?
@@theunknownSoldier. You are not being rational. According to your logic, you are saying to tell the Chechens and Dagestanis to leave Russia because of Russia's crackdown on the Salafi movement. Your Hadith is also not applicable to the West Bank or Gaza. They live amongst other Muslims and are only under military occupation.
The sheikh is excellent on all other matters but not Palestine or Arab rulers. Even a kid would wonder what he is talking about here.
The issue of Palestine is the issue between the army of dajjal (iblis) and the army of prophet Isa , it’s not to be owned by embedded scholars
Jordan is NOT AT ALL in likeliness to Madina
if all the palestinians emigrate then wouldnt the jews destroy al aqsa?
Correct Answer
What about Masjid E Aqsa
Masjidil Haram is more virtues and sacred yet the Prophet s.a.w left Makkah for Madinah to protect his life and his companions lives.
Allah will take care of Masjidil Aqsa
He forgot the prophet migrated to establish the religion and to create a base to conquer makkah. Not to live as refugees under tyrant secular leaders where they can't apply there religion
you loser
Live as refugees under tyrant secular leaders? Where?
This is what i know how refugees are treated in Saudi.. the land of tauhid (not secular)
ua-cam.com/video/ggiRUk57Tz0/v-deo.html
What if he means same, to migrate until the creation of a stronger base of which muslims can regain victory of palestine over.
@@abdulhamid2000. 100%🧠
@@abdulhamid2000.Migrate to where?
may allah forgive him for this disgusting opinion. The people of makkah made hijrah out of extreme need as they were small in number and islam was young. now we have leaders and billions of muslims yet none can help us and come to our aid ? the gulf leaders have trillions and cannot even feed the ampute children in Gaza. indeed allah will give each person what they have earned for themselves. We Palestinians have honor and shame. our land is not for European jews to take. no, by allah! the land of isa and yahya and zakkariya cannot be ruled by their ones who tried to kill them. madkhalis have harmed the ummah
You just didn't listen. He said that he was not a king himself. What you are talking about is a matter of politics. Scholars are not governors, they just spend their lives learning the deen and convey the message in its proper form. There is a specific solution for people who are oppressed and who don't receive the necessary aid from authorities (for whatever reason including the passive behavior of other muslims), it is the hijrah. Moreover, your argument is just weak. Makkah didn't rightfully belong to the pagan qur'aych when Allah (swt) ordered to perform Hijrah to Madina. The muslims back then were in their right and yet they had to flee by leaving their homes and belongings. That's the definition of exile, of course you'd prefer to stay in your land but you are forced to leave. Given the current situation, the palestinians who are able to leave should leave towards muslim lands, have patience and keep in mind that the zionists will eventually lose.
so you say Palestinian Gaza should stay and get slaughtered? 90 percent are homeless more than 30.000 dead and 60.000 injured, more trauma, rapes etc. How will this help Gaza if they stay? Sheikh Albani rahimahullah was right, sheikh used Quran and Sunnah and you use emotion as opinion.
@@halim7725 What about the sahaba who did hijrah to Dar-ul Kufr(Abyssinia)?
@@Qu.Z. Egypt, Jordan, Qatar, Lebanon and many other Muslim nations said they will not accept them
@@nasriibrahim5533I return the question to you: what about it ? How is it related to the topic ?
Al-albani ok you know this are salafia
What
Before there were no borders. HHijra is not practical
Many Palestinians already migrated to other islamic countries such as Qatar, UAE, Saudi and some even migrated to as far as Malaysia
@@infj5196 Those are refugees
@@nasriibrahim5533refugees migrate meaning “ leaving one region to another”. Refugee is an immigrant who has been forced to migrate.
@@theunknownSoldier. No Muslim nation will accept the Palestinians. All Arab nations have also stated their intentions of not accepting them.
So, you are saying that Allah, who has pre-eternal knowledge, gave us advice that isnt practical?
No other solution please migrate to other land why do you stay in a place where you are not free?..
If they migrate what do you think would happen to al-aqsa??
@@MysteryVault-rhthe life of a the Muslims means more
(لزوال الدنيا أهون على الله من قتل رجل مسلم” (رواه الترمذي”
“The destruction of the world is lighter on Allah than the killing of one Muslim man”, (Tirmidhi)
@@isafcb312 I love how you guys just quotes Hadith just to suite your view.
the Hadith shows the life of a Muslim is precious not that they should abandoned their life because they face oppression on their own land.
And again the Hadith just shows all Muslim countries aren't infact Islamic because if they're they would have rise up against the killings of Muslims as their life is is precious in sight of Allah
@@isafcb312 if any countries like UAE, QATAR, SAUDI ARABIA etc..... faces oppression just like the Palestinians would you just advice them to leave while the ummah just stay and watch as the oppression and killings go on??
@@MysteryVault-rhno we quote authentic Hadith and Quran when necessary, sheikh has told you sunnah of the prophet Muhammad Sallahu Alayahi Wa Salaam migrating from one area to another in a time of weakness, did they fear losing something in dunya? No they had tawakkul and knew Allah would return it or replace with better, my brothers and sisters deserve not to starve to death, be bombed, raped, tortured and labelled terrorists, if you don’t like it go live in Gaza and let the innocent out, you want it so bad that you’ll ignore sunnah and Hadith go there and die for it, but the innocent who want to live and be happy I hope Allah provides them a way out so no baby has to be slaughtered again that’s my stance and it’s backed up in the Hadith, if Allah takes Al Aqsa from us for a short time 1. He will return it back one day no doubt tawakkul 2. It should make us Muslims outside of Palestine realise how privileged we are and how much we need to rid our selves and communities of bidah and shirk for what a terrible loss, but the loss of life is more, next up don’t say you guys the Hadith if authentic from prophet Muhammad Sallahu Alayahi Wa Salaam and sheikh is giving sunnah, do not compare me to either they’re free of me and my wrong
Lastly do not pass general takfir of nations, I should of started with this because you’re clearly a takfiri and therefore shouldn’t be respected however I thought those points were worth addressing before leaving, let us read Surah Al-Kahf Assalamu Alaikum
There is no hijrat from Darul Islam.
Source
Hijrah is obligatory if you can't live in peace and practice your religion.
Mecca is not darl islam?
I don't think our beloved Prophet Muhamad saw would tell the Native Palestinians and all Muslims to abandon Al Aqsa Astagfirullah. We know he Black Flags riding from Khorasan won't be riding AWAY from Al Aqsa, but towards it to defend Islam. And Allah knows best.
All hadith about the black flags are very weak
The doors of Hijra is open. If Palestinian Muslims cannot practice the Deen and they obviously cannot defend themselves, no one's helping, make treaties, if not make hijra like Rasool sallal laahu alaihi wa sallam and his Sahabah Radhi Allahu anhum.
Our Prophet Muhammad ﷺ told the Native people of Makkah to abandon Makkah to avoid oppression from Kuffar of Quraisy and to build strength with other Muslims in Madinah.
Sheikh Al bani (RA) is wrong on this one
He did not mean migration is the Entire Solution. He only meant migration as an option. And since then, Alhamdulillah Jordan have accepted around 2 million or more Palestinians
Don't judge great scholars based on their references to the Quran and Sunnah. Before passing judgment, provide a better solution if you have one in the light of the Quran and Sunnah.
@@aask1986it’s better to stay there and protect the nobal masjid Al Aqsa
@@Lzali10469
where have you studied? for seemingly your opinion is more rightly guided than the muhaddith Muhammad Nasir al-Din al-Albani, may Allah have mercy on him and make his grave spacious?
now is not the time for throwing stones, its the time for returning to the haqq.
@@Lzali10469 "it’s better to stay there and protect the nobal masjid Al Aqsa"
Why is it better to stay there, while the Prophet ﷺ gave example of choosing to leave Makkah and build strength with the Muslims in Madinah?
hahahaha shaykh you mean to say vacate palistine and migrate ? ok now tell me where to migrate and who is going to take them as citizen ? A person spent his 40 year muslim country but never get nationality ad they will kick him out. here now u r saying migrtion ? and by the way this is not true fatwa. A Muslim leader should send help not that they should maigrate. During the time of rasool Allah (saw) there is no muslim state so Madina is the first muslim state.. now you need pilestan muslims to estabilish another first muslim state or we already have muslim country ? May Allah forgive you shaykh, i dislike this fatwa. Allah knows best
Didn't u hear, he said he is not a king/ ruler that he should send help.
I do not know anyone yet to be more foolish than you, the joke though is, that you do not perceive it.
@@user-yj5sj5nf6sHere we are talking about millions, not a few hundred.
Again shaykh Al albani is a great Zionist!!!
Dont speak insult to him
@@Antidemocracy45 he is a Zionist and an ally of Israel and Daesh. We fight them
@@muhammadhaydar3073just avoid saying such and such about him hes a salafi scholar and muhadith
Give me a proof, if you do not, and will never, then knows the day of jugment that you deserve what you will have
@@Abdelqadir-f3y In the book entitled “Fatâwa sh-Chaykh Al-Albâni” (page 18 of this edition) Al-Albâni said:
« السؤال : أهل الضفة الغربية هل يجوز أن يخرجوا (من أرضهم) ويهاجروا إلى بلد ثانية ؟
الجواب (الالباني): يجب أن يخرجوا… يا أخي يجب أن يخرجوا من الأرش م يتمكنوا من طرد الكافر منها إلى أرض يتمكنون فيها من القيام بشعائرهم الاسلامية. »
“Question: Is it permissible for the people of Ad-Difah Al-Gharbiyyah (the unoccupied territories of Palestine) to leave their lands and emigrate to another country?
Response (from Al-Albâni): It is a duty for them to leave! O my brother, it is a duty to leave a land in which we are unable to repel the disbeliever, to go to a land in which they can practice Islam.
The sheikh is in his own world, fatwaring out of touch, giving false examples and condoning genocide
Dont say that just respect him
Hence proved that he too was a Madkhali like bin Baaz.
Subhanallah. How can bin Baz and Al Albani be followers of their student?
Why do people enjoy slandering scholars?