I didn't see any deduction other than with the dismount.. I can't even dispute an 8.8E... Not a wobble in sight, straight legs, pointed toes(except dismount), beautiful body shape, fluid movement. What other deduction yall see? I have nothing
Wow when I saw the tittle of the video I said, there’s no way she scored that. But watching the whole routine , I can say every tenth was deserved. Bravo 👏🏼
Instead of complaining about the score before even watching the routine (I admit II had the same reaction just seeing the score!) we should be normalizing routines like this being WORTHY of 8.8 E, because there is not nearly enough E-score differentiation happening in judging, which sucks, because that ends up making the importance of D scores inflated beyond what they were supposed to be in the open-ended code. This can absolutely be a fair 8.8 E score - her rhythm between connections is quick and fluid, her leaps are superb, and she even points her toes in elements like side aerial and back handspring which often get overlooked.
Eles tao com Dificuldades enormes, e series bem elaboradas e tem a sorte de terem umas 7 ou 8 disputando o time (o que o a Brasil infelizmente nao tem)
@@Plaspos I think Melanie still got artistry and rhythm deductions, because beam code is terrible. Manila's routine has few if any of these, and that is why it scores better. Maybe not on 8.8E at worlds, but close. Eythora got an 8.533, the highest beam E at worlds, for the same reason.
Just so refreshing to see beautiful execution, hope she gets to beam final in Paris, if she makes the team!
She won the bronze, if she did the same routine she did here, it would have been gold. ❤
I didn't see any deduction other than with the dismount.. I can't even dispute an 8.8E... Not a wobble in sight, straight legs, pointed toes(except dismount), beautiful body shape, fluid movement. What other deduction yall see? I have nothing
Wow when I saw the tittle of the video I said, there’s no way she scored that. But watching the whole routine , I can say every tenth was deserved. Bravo 👏🏼
14,800 (5.9 D - 8.8 E)
Close enough
Beautiful Valdez!
Way to go Manila!
Amazing improvement since Euros 2023 🎉
True! She's truly amazing and she's working on a new floor difficulty
The rhythm. No dead beat. Love it!
A entrada linda!! lembrando Khorkina e Dani hypolito
This routine is worth the score. Yes, both the D and E scores🎉
Instead of complaining about the score before even watching the routine (I admit II had the same reaction just seeing the score!) we should be normalizing routines like this being WORTHY of 8.8 E, because there is not nearly enough E-score differentiation happening in judging, which sucks, because that ends up making the importance of D scores inflated beyond what they were supposed to be in the open-ended code.
This can absolutely be a fair 8.8 E score - her rhythm between connections is quick and fluid, her leaps are superb, and she even points her toes in elements like side aerial and back handspring which often get overlooked.
I agree. Manila is one of the best beam workers in the world at the moment ❤
vero, l'entrata di Manila e' pazzesca
Умничка!!!
A Itália vai vir fortíssima para Paris. Acho que estão no mesmo nível do Brasil 😮
Eles tao com Dificuldades enormes, e series bem elaboradas e tem a sorte de terem umas 7 ou 8 disputando o time (o que o a Brasil infelizmente nao tem)
Do that again just for me 😊, Gold 🥇 Medalist Olympic champion 🏆 Amen
I immediately came here to hate on the judging. But alright!!! Well done!
ma chi siete voi due che parlate?
se i giudici iniqui non metteranno il bastone tra le ruote, vincera' l'oro olimpico di Parigi
5.9, 8.5
14.4
very good routine and that mount was fire but 8.8 is just overscored.
14.3 or 14.4 at the most!!!
E 8,3 D 5,9 = 14,2
Break it down
I see bent knees and stops
you really don't.
Zhou yaquin should have scored 15.6 in cottbus if this can score this high
Overscored
I'd give it to her this time tho. The leaps are superb, and virtually no wobbles whatsoever as well.
@@uravghuman still at worlds no one was breaking 8.5 E score on beam. Melanie perfect routine at team finals only got 8.3 E-score
@@Plaspos I think Melanie still got artistry and rhythm deductions, because beam code is terrible. Manila's routine has few if any of these, and that is why it scores better. Maybe not on 8.8E at worlds, but close. Eythora got an 8.533, the highest beam E at worlds, for the same reason.
Domestic scores are always overscored in every country, they're aware of that
Do that again just for me 😊, Gold 🥇 Medalist Olympic champion 🏆 Amen.