✅ *LEARN MORE: **bit.ly/3zO8eSZ**, **amzn.to/3JF4SpP**, **bit.ly/3S2l6w5* ✅ *CLICK ❤THANKS to highlight your question &/or support the channel!* 🙏 to Keeps for sponsoring this video! Go to keeps.com/AndrewRobinson to get 50% off your first Keeps order. ✅ *If it’s in the video, it’s in the desx ☝CLICK “SHOW MORE”* ✅ *RULES: Please be respectful. NO OUTSIDE LINKS, URLs, email addresses, etc.*
so... Yes I am around. - My personal desire of Audio Reviews I'd like to hear are the differences between MC low-cost solutions and MM equivalent examples. ... I DID buy the LP140 Audio Technica that you suggested, but with INFLATION at the Grocery & my budget for a Otofone 2M-Black disappeared - so - I looked and looked and FINALLY FOUND something about 1/2 the price NAGOKI (sp) 200 mm Chartridge and have been happy. ..... But that doesn't mean I didn't find a few others maybe as worthy but costing more or less the same, but requiring a further cost by being MC that needed it's own Amp to Boost signals. ..... anyway, thanks for the continued work! - m.
I can’t imagine this channel without Kristi’s continuously developing audio journey, truly distinctive style, and ever-increasing confidence. Absolutely cannot wait for the day that Kristi just appears alone with her audio review as if it were always that way and upon conclusion looks off camera and says, “Now let’s find out what Andrew thinks…” ;)
WELLLLLL.... If you live in a New York City studio apartment like I do, a room full of gear (to show off) just doesn't cut it anymore. Almost 20 years ago, when I came back to NYC (from Oregon), I sold most of my Home Theater gear just to move. Except my PIONEER LaserDisc Player (still can't part with my 100+ LDs). Been through quite a few soundbars within that time. A humbling experience for an Audio/Cine-Phile like myself. Who was used to multiple components and speakers. So unless one has a big house and makes Da Big Bucks, SoundBars are the way to go. Especially for apartments dwellers like myself. And they have been getting better over the years for sure. I have everything hooked up to my Nakamichi. Even my old PIONEER turntable (via my LG TV's RCA ports). Again, Great Review.
Kristi gets my vote... Having two viewing rooms one a bar and the other a room full of gear I can say they each have their place. Listening to Tacata and Fugue in D minor with two 15" subs carrying the pedal notes is priceless and clear dialog on a bar is great.
My friend was using his TV speakers for years, I tried to get him on the full 5.1 channel band wagon but he wasn't willing to commit to the cost or the space. I then suggested a sound bar combo as they are small and inexpensive. He bought one and they love it. There is a HUGE demographic that has no interest in a full home theater set up, but would greatly benefit from a sound bar. TV speakers suck, and an you can get a VASTLY improved performance with a sound bar for minimal investment.
I am impressed by what can be achieved with today's soundbars. I recommend family/friends to check them out and consider them. For me, I like the look of a room full of gear.
I have the original magnifi mini and it blew me away how good it sounds. So much so, I bought the magnifi max sr for my living room and I couldn't be happier
While it is fun to have your "big" speaker / amp / receiver setup and be able to hear what you've paid for in all those purchases, there's something about a small speaker setup that sounds big, that can just put a huge smile on your face. I had my Klipsch - The Fives setup in the front of the room, along with my "big" speakers, and played them for a friend and asked him which speakers he thought he was hearing the sound from.... without hesitating, he told me there was no possible way that what he was hearing was coming from the small speakers sitting on the tv stand and it had to be the bigger speakers with the sub.... I couldn't help but grin from ear to ear when I told him he was wrong. If I hadn't purchased some new speakers recently, I would definitely be looking at a soundbar setup that I could hook everything into the tv with and just use eARC to run it all through the soundbar. Thanks for all you guys do! Kristi, I LOVE LOVE LOVE having all the links to the things you guys mention in your reviews... thank you for all of that work EVERY TIME!
I mean, I am closing on a new house soon. We will be dedicating the bottom floor to a home theater with "all the gear" but there's still the matter of televisions in the kitchen/living room and bedroom which require better sound than what any TV can muster - that's where sound bars like this make much more sense. There's no reason to set up atmos and surround sound in every room. If we're doing critical watching/listening, it will be in the theater. But, having something like this in the bedroom would be perfect for those other occasions. In this regard, it makes much more sense even than bigger or more expensive sound bars like the ambeo.
Thanks for the review! Always interested to hear the opinions of people who have heard VERY expensive gear, on more affordable home audio equipment. As someone who has a small living room with not a lot of room for equipment...I personally prefer the tiny little soundbar that can emulate a room full of gear. And for Kristi, some of your glowing reviews for soundbars opened me up to the thought of owning one myself, and how good they can sound. Thanks again.
When I was a bachelor, I switched from a Yamaha RXV592 with 5.1 speakers all over the living room to a Bose 3/2/1 system. (almost invisible in my set up back then) let's just say that the ladies were impressed.WAY more impressed. I'd take the impressive small soundbar
Hey Andrew and Kristi Any news on the reviewing Polks other 2022 lineups particularly the Magnifi Max AX SR 7.1.2. really curious how it compares to the Samsung and Ambeo.
We have a Sonos Playbar in the living room and I’m constantly amazed at the quality when we turn on a program with a solid surround mix. It has excelled in two completely different rooms. Still does not compare to the Anthem/Emo/Triad setup in the theater room but for a single box it’s VERY impressive.
I have the Cinema 600 (without surrounds). I LOVE it. My living area has a unusual lay out to say the least, and I feel that is becoming more common in city living spaces, especially rentals. To have sound as big and enjoyable as the 600 makes without having to run cables, block off floor space, and worry about harmonizing electronics to speakers, is worth its weight in gold. It may not be a $10,000 home theater, but movies come alive and the bass shakes the house - and it may even be better for music listening. If you haven't tried a soundbar in the $400+ price range yet, you may be surprised. Bad ones exist, but they are getting harder to find.
@@andrewrobinsonreviews I stumbled backward into the Cinema 600 (won it through a raffle), but have watched your review on it more than once since. Being somewhat new to the world of audio enthusiasts, watching your video and listening to the 600 helped me understand what I was hearing and begin to develop a sense of what I like/don't like. So, thank you.
Excellent and fair review as always! Really looking forward to the 2022 Magnifi Max AX SR 7.1.2 review. I'm very curious to see how it compares to the q950a and the Ambeo.
Id love to get one of these for my travel trailer! The small size would be really ideal to get first rate sound in a small space like a travel trailer.
Thanks to your review, I purchased this for a small condo. Really does do well. I also found that night mode does a good job for music. It sounds like it makes it a simple stereo sound. So, I can live with it for music and movies pretty well. I was able to get it on sale for $100 off, so it is an easy keep for a bedroom or small space.
I've got my 5.1 downstairs and my Yamaha soundbar upstairs. The Yamaha even sounds pretty good with music. It can give my Denon/ KEF system a good run for the money. I have no problem recommending soundbars to most people. In fact they are a must have for any TV. If you are listening over TV speakers, get out of the stone age and into an electronics store to see what you are missing.
The original Polk Mini was the most impressive consumer electronics products I have ever owned (considering value and all). The fact that it is to 30% the width seemingly doesn’t limit the stage at all. I have the AX in another room and it likely ties the original ‘wow’ record. I would note that $449 is a great value. BUT the original mini has been around for a few years and can be had for insane prices ($150-175ish or even less) which is clearly significantly bellow half the price of the AX. Proof that this (our hosts) is a solid marriage would be the better half chiming in toward the end in defense of the original mini. it DOES do MUCH more than simply enhance dialogue. The subwoofers are identical and both do exactly as described regarding depending on the sub for deeper midrange. The midrange-sub integration was a very very intelligent point about both systems that I have certainly observed owning both….I just never really thought about it in that way. Party in the back? Not this time. Sub to the front. I’ve Banged with Olufsen and Ambeoed at a friends home. Over the years I’ve Viziod my budget, multi-roomed w/ Sonos Barbara and 7.1 book tower shelved with Onkyo and cables. No need for a paragraph to say ‘I’ve heard fancy shit.’ I guess I couldn’t help myself. Both of these sound great. Born and raised in the Silicon Valley I hate supporting Amazon in all ways. With that said if you see the original Magnifi Mini used (as it’s been around long enough for this to be common) and in ‘very good’ or ‘good’ condition…..regardless of your tax bracket status the football and wireless sub at $170ish is MADNESS. Like amphetamine fueled midwestern used car salesmen tv commercial CRAZY DEALS CLICK NOW WE GIVEN IT AWAY level value. It’s that great. Vizio can’t make a decent TV but they do nice things with budget soundbars. However that $150-250 spent toward either Polk is exponentially more potent, quality, versatile and like a weight training football of some kind. Don’t blow out your shoulder. Good review. Remember just because they send it doesn’t mean you can’t say it sucks. You know there is a sponsored review disease going around. So far so good. 👍🏻
I currently have the original mini but im considering upgrading because of airplay and atmos. But it terms of sound quality is the AX better than the original? i ask because it seems the AX has only 3 mid range drivers instead of 4 like the original
Sound bars are here to stay, like it or not. I think it's incredibly satisfying to have someone marvel at how good a sound bar sounds given its respective size. I also think a lot of people would be hard pressed to discern a difference between discrete audio channels and an all in one solution like a sound bar. What I think sound bars offer more than anything is a higher acceptability factor from significant others. I can tell you my wife hates the look of speakers. She doesn't even go into my basement because she hates looking at them. 🤷 I've added my sound bars on my other TV's, though, by using added mounting brackets to the TV wall mount and they just become an addition to the TV. She doesn't mind this view at all. I don't know where I'm going with this comment, so I'll cut it short. Sound bars are a fantastic invention that pumps out way higher fidelity audio in a much more space friendly package and for that reason, I think they aren't going anywhere and people shouldn't turn their noses up at them, but instead root for continued innovation in that product sector.
While your channel has opened my eyes to how impressive soundbars can be (3 drivers that sound like 15? What is this magic??) I still haven't encountered one that made me think "I not only need that, but I want it over a traditional pair or suite of speakers." I guess I'm just too old school. Big room full of gear all the way! That said, in high school I would have loved this thing atop my 9" TV.
There's an E in MavErick (1st popup) 🙂 My room is full of STUFF (11.1) but we'll be moving into a RV for a couple years while building a new home. This is where the sound bar setup shines. I sold our old RV with an LG setup. Thanks!
I've just purchased the LG éclair soundbar to go with my LG C1 55 inch TV I have a 2 bedroom apartment so this I feel is perfect for me it arrives on Sat just in time for the MW2 beta
I had a pair of B&O RL45.2 and i change my main setup for a Soundbar 500 with the bass Module 500. Much more compact and asethetic! With ADAPTiQ, the bar understands my room, the listening is easier! No regrets making the switch to a soundbar, but a keep my stereo setup for a another room!
I'll say this, having moved from Texas to New Jersey, carrying all that gear has a price....not including the anxiety of disassembling, packing and then trusting movers to not destroy all of it. These Sound Bar Reviews are making me look back at your other reviews and it's making me reconsider an auditioning of the LG SP9.
This sound bar is truly impressive. I experimented with the sound modes and agree that 3D mode is THE mode to use if you want a dynamic cinema experience. It blows me away especially when I crank it past 50%. My friends thought I was playing a trick on them with hidden speakers Something that stuck out to me was Kristis comment on dialog not being great. I had a similar “issue” and found that my wife and I prefer movie mode for most of our TV watching in the evenings. Movie mode seems to boost the subtle details and dialog especially at lower volumes compared to the mighty and dynamic 3D mode. Going from 3D mode to movie mode reminds me of setting Dynamic range setting to “Normal” on my Yamaha receiver in my man cave. Night mode works well too but kills a bit too much of the bass imho
QOTD: I find the smaller devices more impressive. I think both soundbars and full sized systems have their place. One big advantage of soundbars is easier integration, which should result in more folks getting a better home audio experience. As someone whom doesn't always love the value proposition of soundbars compared to flexibility and upgrade paths of more components, I am genuinely curious to hear some of these models for myself. So yes I think your channel is doing its job, and doing so in the most entertaining way. Also loved that you had to get one more jab in at marantz.
Not to ride the fence on this one but they’re both impressive for different reasons. For someone like me, I kitted out my office (work from home so I’m in there ALOT) with a 55” C1 oled with my Klipsch the fives and a Klipsch sub. In that room it’s an amazing combo that truly rocks and is amazing for movies. That said now that I’m starting the living room I’m at a loss… I’m not a baller or anything but I want a nice, versatile media experience. Gaming, movies, music and sports. Every time I think I’m set there’s something else that seems like a better option lol. As of now I was pretty set on a Polk reserve system with two R700s two R900 height modules two r200 surrounds the R400 center and an svs 1000 for the hip hop and r&b as well as feeling like Godzilla is stomping through my living room lol. That said I was set on last years Klipsch reference line (hard to beat money wise), set on a focal chora system similar to the Polk and even the Sony AH-9 set up seemed tempting. There are so many good things out these days, it’s easy to not really know where to go, especially when starting from scratch (no av receiver yet either and that’s a whole other wormhole lol) basically it’s all impressive haha.
Awesome review! Only thing that I would have liked you to review is the connectivity capabilities, such as Alexa integration or interaction and how that works, specially since you mentioned the music listening features. But thank you for your fantastic review - this really helped me decide what to purchase.
I purchased the system yesterday. My only interest is to improve dialog clarity and still have some sound quality. For this, I am happy with the purchase. Thanks for the review.
As a mostly recovered audiophile myself and a custom AV pro for over two decades (accustomed to $100K custom home theaters), I would prefer to impress my friends with tiny sound-bar roaring a giant sound in a double blind sound-off 😎 I find it outrageously fascinating how the laws of physics are reliably “broken” time and time again by the manufacturers.
ok so my husband is the reason i am into this hobby. He set up a theater room for us and it is by all means a room full of STUFF. (Wife approved of course) However, In our bedroom, we have a Samsung Sound Bar with wireless rear speakers and i must say i do prefer the non cluttered look over a bunch of equipment everywhere.
I think sounds bars are great for the common joe. The room full of equipment is for those who really want to take sound to another level both are good in there own way.
I found it refurb for $350 and $150 for SR2 and I'm very pleased. The SR2 surrounds make a big improvement. Yes, Mini AX is much better than TV speakers, if only because you add a sub, but surrounds for 5.1 and "Fake Atmos" are a must. It's so easy to setup and configure etc. So $500+ tax all in, I'm very glad. Small footprint and clean install with wireless, it's a win.
hi, I`m wondering about to buy the same, Mini AX and SR2 surrounds...can You tell me how this "Fake Atmos" is working? I want to buy it only of movies and wondering if this small thing will works good or maybe I should better look for some bigger Polka or Samsung?
@@marcinmarcin4811 I would say stock center and sub add dimension but incapable of surround or ATMOS in any way. Adding SR2 surrounds makes for a 5.1 feel but very little to no Ceiling bounce on my standard 8 ft ceilings. It's no ATMOS compared to a full setup.
I have a stereo Samsung sound bar 180w rms and a 5.1.4 HT system in the same room. When I do not want to fire up the HT system, the sound bar does a good job. I have some Pro-ject box 5 s2 on the way for the front and rear channels. Your top review peaked my interest, in Australia no green🙁. You and Kristi, your reviews are enjoyable to watch cheers.
Great to see what Polk is doing. Any plans to review their signature elite ( I own the signature speakers that are no longer around it seems) speakers down the road? Thanks for the great video. The speaker looks so small compared to your TV lol. Less is more as I grow older, so yeah if I could get something that sounds like my room full of gear with one speaker or 2 instead of 5.1.2, then yes. 100%.
I bought a Magnify mini for the bedroom a few years ago and was immediately impressed. Aside from the tweeters being close together, it provides excellent, mostly full-range sound. Though the small sub doesn't shake the house like my Cinema 600 sub does, it still provides accurate, present low frequencies. Small as it is, it still has HDMI-arc and Bluetooth functionality. I must agree, that it's better for TV and movies, than it is for music. All said, it's a great, solid performer in a small package. The "ax" looks as though it's a worthy successor, but not enough to warrant upgrading from the mini... IMHO. Thanks for a good review! With regard to your question: The small soundbar is GREAT in the bedroom, where WAF rules. In the den, the Klipsch Cinema 600 is much more appropriate with it's width and powerful sub. I've had a 7.1 system in the past and for my needs, it simply wasn't worth it.... speakers everywhere, big receiver, etc. The Cinema 600 provides all the immersive sound I want for movies in a small, simple, uncluttered package. Well, that big sub isn't exactly easy to hide or ignore. Since my serious stereo system is in the same room with it's speakers an dual subs.... the less imposing soundbar system is all the more appreciated.
Tried the JBL Soundbar 5.1 as Kristi liked it for the voice clarity. It is not very clear so we will try either this one or the MAX version that allows you to adjust it.
It's a big improvement generally on the previous Magnifi Mini which seriously lacked timbre especially with music, but while it's nice that it can decode Dolby Digital, Atmos and DTS: X there's nothing really very "surround" about the setup. It creates an impressive soundstage for your screen area but the rears and ceiling channels are indistinguishable from the front channels except for a non-specific effect of big room ambiance. Still a really nice sound for such a compact unit but don't expect the sound of a helicopter flying overhead to magically come from somewhere above you for example despite what Polk advertises, or you'll just be disappointed.
Considering something compact for my desk. How would this compare to PC speakers like the Audioengines or Klipsch Promodia (heritage and non-heritage). Anyone been able to compare them pls?
I got one of these for about $300 for a small room. It's nice, and the sub is great, but I can't say I have noticed a good 3D effect yet. Maybe because I keep it around 30 volume? Either way, pretty good for the price I paid.
I've had soundbars for over 20 years now and they have come a very long way. I think once they started introducing upfiring speakers it has changed the game and now more recently Dolby atmos. It's no question that now is the time to transition over. Right now I have the q900a with rears and it sounds good. Buy I'm looking to get the 95qr but when it goes further down in price.
It’s nice to have options, soundbar for those who want better sound with ease of use , or go all out with separate components and speakers. Even with turntables including Bluetooth connection can be added to a soundbar as an option to enjoy vinyl . If your happy with a simple soundbar no need to go all audiophile. Depending who you ask and circumstances no right answer to the QOTD only opinions. Appreciate your reviews.
I'm surprised you haven't already done a review on this! but better late than never. this thing is tiny but mighty, though technically it's the subwoofer that does the heavy lifting
The virtual surround bit is a moot point considering the original uses their patented SDA technology and supports Dolby 5.1. Meaning it already has decent virtual surround. The true leg up the AX has is the wireless satellite speakers that turn it into a true surround system. Or at the very least a hybrid.
My dad just purchased one of these and has been telling me how good it sounds (after giving me back the bar he was borrowing from me). He said the dialog enhancement is really good because I hate people doing current sound mixing. It would work well in my living room since I have my sub up by my hearth. He said the 3d is really good at the wide but lacks some height. Can I set up 2 Bluetooth speakers for a L and R channel instead of rear? Our living room just doesn't have a great way to do rear sound.
I would take a room full of gear….only…it kinda depends on your home. For me it’s impossible to fill it with gear so a bar would be the best, just finding the best (reasonable priced one) that does both music and movies great
@Andrew Robinson Well, to answer your question, I could have chosen to answer your question in a more direct fashion however I'd rather choose a different approach here. Been following your channel a long time now and you have adopted a different route to reviewing the products compared to the ones that you used to review couple of years ago. You have opened yourself up to new technology based all-in-one home theatre products, soundbars etc.. So, now, to answer your question, like you mentioned in one of your reviews, even when it comes to two-channel bookshelf speakers, hi-fi systems, powered-speakers is the future. Similarly, in home theatre field I think this is the kind of future we are looking forward to. Polk Maginifi mini AX is an excellent starting point for any HT enthusiast. For a more hardcore enthusiast, I would probably suggest Sony HT A9. I know you were pretty impressed with that system too 🙂 Similarly, in the two channel set-up, one can probably start things off with SVS Prime Wireless Pro Powered speakers and then work their way up to KEF LS50 Wireless II and then given the space and budget could go up to LS60s. This is the future aka Future-fi. 10-20 yrs ago, people had more space to play with and discrete systems made total sense. Hell, I still have discrete two channel set-up and discrete Home theatre setup. But in the last couple of years, i have started leaning more towards powered/active speaker setups and Magnifi-like setups for HT solutions. Simply because space is a limitation we are all facing now. Hope that answers your question. It was an interesting and a practical one 👍✌️ As always, excellent review buddy 🙏 keep them coming. God bless ✌️
I like to tinker too much to have a soundbar in our main home theater, but if you happen to have multiple tvs and can't stand the horrible speakers they come with soundbars can save the day. I've watched Nightmare before Christmas in the kids playroom 5 times in the last 4 days, I'm so happy we've got the little soundbar in there.
@@KristiWright My son has been deeply invested in the Sonos infrastructure for about 4 years now - even using them in at least one of the restaurants in which he’s part owner. While it’s certainly easy to understand the appeal - particularly if you want music throughout the house and anywhere in the yard within range of your wifi - the sonics of even the ARC and Sub are, how can is say diplomatically - meh? While his 75” Sony X80 series TV deceivers a pretty decent picture, what I’ve heard from his rig so far hasn’t inspired my to replace my 7.2 HT system. Thanks to a couple of your earlier reviews, I recently acquired a BlueSound Node for an upstairs system that is now streaming only, and so far no complaints; although at a certain age (70) I’m finding there’s a much longer learning curve to all the functionality - such as wireless streaming from shared PC/Mac libraries - it has to offer.
Hello Andrew and Kristi. As always, I love your reviews of all thing audio and visual. In response to your question about considering a sound bar . . . . yes I now feel that the tech is that good that I would consider one. I currently have a 5.1 setup with descrete speakers and an AV receiver which are 10 years old. However, I don't think my wife will let me start cutting holes in ceiling for some Atmos speakers. I am very much looking forward to you doing a review of the new Sennheiser Ambeo Plus soundbar (and sub, hopefully!) as I feel it could be the sound bar to replace my current system.
I was looking for some information on an Emotiva mini-xa-100 yesterday, and I found a video on YT. Who was in that video? A seemingly on the edge of having his soul crushed Mr. Andrew Robinson. You can tell how much you love what you do now just by the tone change in your voice. It was a fun little time capsule. Glad you are here though. Be well Andrew and Kristi.
Great review! Seems to be an amazing small (WAF-covered 😉) but affordable Atmos soundbar! Allthough I own a great 2-way system with my tv, this could be a nice add-on for movies only. p.s.: Would be interesting to have a ranking overview of soundbars tested to keep up.
This small soundbars like the eclair and this magnifi mini for me are great options for bedroom TVs. I've seen people put big Samsung soundbars and it takes too much space this is a great solution for a small room. Too bad that you didn't had the LG at hand because they look pretty similar too but for me this one is great for a bedroom TV and might wait till the holidays and pick one up.
I purchased both the Polk MagniFi Mini Ax and the JBL Bar 500. I’m still performing sound checks between the two but having such a difficult time noticing the differences. Both being the same price point I’m torn. Any specs or features that I’m missing that one unit has versus the other?
Update: If you like more bass and will be using the system for more than just tv/movies I’d recommend the JBL. The only issue I’ve noticed with the JBL is the Bluetooth is sometimes spotty. The Polk MagniFi mini AX sounds incredible, but I do see what was mentioned in the review about dialogue. Also, I cannot place the subwoofer next to the couch or behind furniture, it has to be place to the L or R of the tv. I’m leaning towards the JBL
This review was incredibly helpful and convinced me to purchase the Mini AX. I watched "The Fall Guy" on it last night, and the experience was fantastic. I had read that the subwoofer was bass-heavy, and that is definitely true. I have mine set to "Movie" mode with the bass adjusted to -2. To manage the downward-firing bass and avoid disturbing my neighbors, I also bought the "Auralex Acoustics SubDude-II Subwoofer Acoustic Isolation Platform" from Amazon. This is an absolute must if you’re renting an apartment, and I believe it also helps direct the sound more effectively. I have a lot of 5.1 and Atmos content, and I’m considering adding the SR2 satellite speakers to my setup. Does anyone have thoughts on these? Additionally, what stands have people used for their satellite speakers? Thanks!
I used to hate soundbars and then ran across a DefTech Studio Micro on Marketplace for $250. Picked it up and it works really well for my bedroom TV watching and occasional music listening. But I have other full systems in the house for movies and music.
Riddle me this, small sound bars are always AC powered, and battery/portable speakers are optimized for music, not movie watching. So what would you guys recommend as a portable battery powered solution to match with a battery powered projector for camping outdoors movie nights? Something in this small form factor, battery powered and with low Bluetooth latency would get my money in the blink of an eye
Hands down, if there is an option to have a sound bar and wireless surrounds (too bad you didn't get to review those) that provided a 5.1 surround experience, I'd have no qualms about investing. Especially at a sub-1k price point. My wife would likely be happy with it as well. Less mess, fewer wires.
got the magnifi mini and im impressed, got it for cheaper price too at amazon 3yrs ago, i dnt know if ax is really an upgrade in terms of sound quality.
I've been debating looking into a soundbar to replace my 5.0 setup (own a condo, being nice to neighbors by not getting--nor needing--a sub). Mainly because our rear channels are on stands behind the couch and we have cats. My hesitation is being disappointed by sound and going through the process of a return. On the flip side, if I like the soundbar, the hassle of selling the receiver and 5 speakers is the other possibility that gives me pause.
Think I may be in a common situation. With a growing family I've got lots of hifi gear now on storage. The economy of returns on picking up a HTinaB that does it well versus putting all my stuff back out is appealing... Happy wife happy life....
I've been running the original Magnifi mini for close to 3 years now. I actually got it at Walmart close out for something like $139.99 (thanks Slickdeals) I like it, it's a little weird with not turning on sometimes with the power on the tv and constantly I have to change inputs or turn it off when it loses Dolby processing which happens often. Kinda of annoying but not terrible. I turned the bass down 2 notches and same with the dialogue. Just seemed a bit tipped up on both for me, especially the bass. Probably because my main room I use a sealed box sub (REL) and the polk seemed a bit much out of the box setting. Other than that for the price I enjoy it, fits well in that room with the small form factor.
Could anyone help me which is the best mode for Magnifi mini Ax with SR2 surround cause when I put 3D or movie or music mode, couldn’t hear anything from SR2 surround. So pls advice. Thanks
I believe for the surround speakers to actually work you have to be watching content that supports 5.1 or Dolby atoms. If it’s not one of those then the surround speakers won’t make a sound. Try getting a top Netflix plan or whatever service that supports that audio and you should be able to hear it.
Ok, you talked me into purchasing this. I was very happy with it’s performance, however, 2 weeks in the sub has begun to make a loud “popping” noise that is extremely annoying. Apparently not uncommon. I’m taking it back.
We're trying! Starting to wonder if the new ownership has turned them into another company that's only good at sending out press releases. Really hoping that's not the case!
@@KristiWright hope you’ll get their new Ambeo Sub with the Ambeo Soundbar Plus. Seems to be an amazing new combination! I am looking forward to your review.
I recently rewatched (yes I rewatch your vids.. they're that good lol) your Klipsch Cinema 600 Sound Bar 3.1 review and was close to pulling the trigger to get one.. but now I'm considering the Polk. Recommendation which one? I have a small living room but a high ceiling and like Christi I have issues with voices. So, I think I'm leaning towards the Polk over Klipsch.
I am considering also both .. Cinema 600 seems to have louder sound than Polk but Atmos Audio from Polk seems to be better for movies … I plan to use it 80% Movies /20% Music. What would you choose ?
I actually switched back to a discrete 5.1 system but with a twist. I have the Enclave CineHome II. Bought this used at a good deal and it is game changer for me because they are wireless. The sound is impressive and easy to set up. These are WISA certified speakers. I don't have cut outs or subwoofer drops in this system which was a problem when using my LG SN10YG soundbar with the rear speaker kit. Using any WISA speakers, you can upgrade to a 7.1 or 5.1.2 Atmos setup but I have not tried this yet (considering the cost right now for additional speakers). Also, my 2020 LG tv is WISA certified but I prefer using the system with ARC/eARC. So I'm curious if you have thoughts on WISA speakers and the Soundsend/Axiim transmitter. Platin Audio just announced their 5.1.2 wireless Atmos system which is interesting as well but expensive! Thanks for the content by the way! 🙌
I'm just watching this now. Has there been any updates or new options? I have a 17' Casita fiberglass camper. I need s small sound bar/system, for an obviously small space that won't break the bank. Any suggestions?
I will probably buy this product for my study/library/office/guest room combo room. I am pulling the trigger on the Beosound stage gold tone for the tv room. Until I can afford an upgrade to the beolab 28s for my main music system going to be hanging on to my peachtree amp and ls50s fed by an ifi stream and fluance rt 85. My receiver, fancy dac, phono stage and sub (not a huge bass head) will soon be available on audio mart haha. I will hang on to my Beosound level for music in the rest of the house/deck.
So to answer your question: yeah I love the idea of simplification through soundbars. It’s a similar reason to why I traded tcl 8 series for a frame 2022 - the style/convenience of less stuff while still getting a picture quality that 10 years ago me would have been amazed by is compelling. Keeps the peace with my design minded better half as well.
✅ *LEARN MORE: **bit.ly/3zO8eSZ**, **amzn.to/3JF4SpP**, **bit.ly/3S2l6w5*
✅ *CLICK ❤THANKS to highlight your question &/or support the channel!*
🙏 to Keeps for sponsoring this video! Go to keeps.com/AndrewRobinson to get 50% off your first Keeps order.
✅ *If it’s in the video, it’s in the desx ☝CLICK “SHOW MORE”*
✅ *RULES: Please be respectful. NO OUTSIDE LINKS, URLs, email addresses, etc.*
so... Yes I am around. - My personal desire of Audio Reviews I'd like to hear are the differences between MC low-cost solutions and MM equivalent examples.
... I DID buy the LP140 Audio Technica that you suggested, but with INFLATION at the Grocery & my budget for a Otofone 2M-Black disappeared - so - I looked and looked and FINALLY FOUND something about 1/2 the price NAGOKI (sp) 200 mm Chartridge and have been happy.
..... But that doesn't mean I didn't find a few others maybe as worthy but costing more or less the same, but requiring a further cost by being MC that needed it's own Amp to Boost signals.
..... anyway, thanks for the continued work! - m.
@@Labor_Jones Great to see you around. I'm glad you found a cartridge that's working for you.
I can’t imagine this channel without Kristi’s continuously developing audio journey, truly distinctive style, and ever-increasing confidence. Absolutely cannot wait for the day that Kristi just appears alone with her audio review as if it were always that way and upon conclusion looks off camera and says, “Now let’s find out what Andrew thinks…” ;)
WELLLLLL....
If you live in a New York City studio apartment like I do, a room full of gear (to show off) just doesn't cut it anymore.
Almost 20 years ago, when I came back to NYC (from Oregon), I sold most of my Home Theater gear just to move. Except my PIONEER LaserDisc Player (still can't part with my 100+ LDs). Been through quite a few soundbars within that time. A humbling experience for an Audio/Cine-Phile like myself. Who was used to multiple components and speakers.
So unless one has a big house and makes Da Big Bucks, SoundBars are the way to go. Especially for apartments dwellers like myself.
And they have been getting better over the years for sure.
I have everything hooked up to my Nakamichi.
Even my old PIONEER turntable (via my LG TV's RCA ports).
Again,
Great Review.
Kristi gets my vote... Having two viewing rooms one a bar and the other a room full of gear I can say they each have their place. Listening to Tacata and Fugue in D minor with two 15" subs carrying the pedal notes is priceless and clear dialog on a bar is great.
My friend was using his TV speakers for years, I tried to get him on the full 5.1 channel band wagon but he wasn't willing to commit to the cost or the space. I then suggested a sound bar combo as they are small and inexpensive. He bought one and they love it. There is a HUGE demographic that has no interest in a full home theater set up, but would greatly benefit from a sound bar. TV speakers suck, and an you can get a VASTLY improved performance with a sound bar for minimal investment.
Plus, they are typically a lot easier to set up and operate. Thanks for watching!
I am impressed by what can be achieved with today's soundbars. I recommend family/friends to check them out and consider them. For me, I like the look of a room full of gear.
Love that you and Kristi review all kinds of products!! Thank you always!
We try and be as inclusive as possible and keep it fun and fresh! Thanks for tuning in!
We love that you join us for the variety!
I have the original magnifi mini and it blew me away how good it sounds. So much so, I bought the magnifi max sr for my living room and I couldn't be happier
Appreciate you sharing your experience with us! It's an impressive solution for sure!
We can't wait to test the full size bars that Polk just announced. Hopefully we don't have to wait too long! Thanks for watching.
@@KristiWright ooh wasn't aware they announced new sound bars. I'm a bit of a Polk fan now so I'll definitely check them out
@@MrMegatron85 Yep. As always, links are in the desx! New Polk Max bars:
Magnifi Max AX SR: bit.ly/3xmZB11
Magnifi Max AX: bit.ly/3qzDdh9
While it is fun to have your "big" speaker / amp / receiver setup and be able to hear what you've paid for in all those purchases, there's something about a small speaker setup that sounds big, that can just put a huge smile on your face. I had my Klipsch - The Fives setup in the front of the room, along with my "big" speakers, and played them for a friend and asked him which speakers he thought he was hearing the sound from.... without hesitating, he told me there was no possible way that what he was hearing was coming from the small speakers sitting on the tv stand and it had to be the bigger speakers with the sub.... I couldn't help but grin from ear to ear when I told him he was wrong. If I hadn't purchased some new speakers recently, I would definitely be looking at a soundbar setup that I could hook everything into the tv with and just use eARC to run it all through the soundbar. Thanks for all you guys do! Kristi, I LOVE LOVE LOVE having all the links to the things you guys mention in your reviews... thank you for all of that work EVERY TIME!
😍 The psychology of sound!
I would definitely consider this solution. I'm over having gear for gears sake
I mean, I am closing on a new house soon. We will be dedicating the bottom floor to a home theater with "all the gear" but there's still the matter of televisions in the kitchen/living room and bedroom which require better sound than what any TV can muster - that's where sound bars like this make much more sense. There's no reason to set up atmos and surround sound in every room. If we're doing critical watching/listening, it will be in the theater. But, having something like this in the bedroom would be perfect for those other occasions. In this regard, it makes much more sense even than bigger or more expensive sound bars like the ambeo.
Thanks for the review! Always interested to hear the opinions of people who have heard VERY expensive gear, on more affordable home audio equipment. As someone who has a small living room with not a lot of room for equipment...I personally prefer the tiny little soundbar that can emulate a room full of gear. And for Kristi, some of your glowing reviews for soundbars opened me up to the thought of owning one myself, and how good they can sound. Thanks again.
When I was a bachelor, I switched from a Yamaha RXV592 with 5.1 speakers all over the living room to a Bose 3/2/1 system. (almost invisible in my set up back then) let's just say that the ladies were impressed.WAY more impressed. I'd take the impressive small soundbar
Hey Andrew and Kristi
Any news on the reviewing Polks other 2022 lineups particularly the Magnifi Max AX SR 7.1.2. really curious how it compares to the Samsung and Ambeo.
Shout to Arvin Olano, one of our favorite UA-camrs and his famous "Nobody asked" line. If you are into interior design, he's a lot of fun to watch.
I cannot wait to see his new house!
We have a Sonos Playbar in the living room and I’m constantly amazed at the quality when we turn on a program with a solid surround mix. It has excelled in two completely different rooms. Still does not compare to the Anthem/Emo/Triad setup in the theater room but for a single box it’s VERY impressive.
I have the Cinema 600 (without surrounds). I LOVE it. My living area has a unusual lay out to say the least, and I feel that is becoming more common in city living spaces, especially rentals. To have sound as big and enjoyable as the 600 makes without having to run cables, block off floor space, and worry about harmonizing electronics to speakers, is worth its weight in gold.
It may not be a $10,000 home theater, but movies come alive and the bass shakes the house - and it may even be better for music listening. If you haven't tried a soundbar in the $400+ price range yet, you may be surprised. Bad ones exist, but they are getting harder to find.
The Cinema 600 is a great bar and only recently got replaced as our reference bar by the JBL mentioned in this video.
@@andrewrobinsonreviews I stumbled backward into the Cinema 600 (won it through a raffle), but have watched your review on it more than once since. Being somewhat new to the world of audio enthusiasts, watching your video and listening to the 600 helped me understand what I was hearing and begin to develop a sense of what I like/don't like. So, thank you.
if I like more movies than music would the Polk magnifi mini AX be better than Klipsch Cinema 600?
Excellent and fair review as always! Really looking forward to the 2022 Magnifi Max AX SR 7.1.2 review. I'm very curious to see how it compares to the q950a and the Ambeo.
Id love to get one of these for my travel trailer! The small size would be really ideal to get first rate sound in a small space like a travel trailer.
Thanks to your review, I purchased this for a small condo. Really does do well. I also found that night mode does a good job for music. It sounds like it makes it a simple stereo sound. So, I can live with it for music and movies pretty well. I was able to get it on sale for $100 off, so it is an easy keep for a bedroom or small space.
I've got my 5.1 downstairs and my Yamaha soundbar upstairs. The Yamaha even sounds pretty good with music. It can give my Denon/ KEF system a good run for the money. I have no problem recommending soundbars to most people. In fact they are a must have for any TV. If you are listening over TV speakers, get out of the stone age and into an electronics store to see what you are missing.
The original Polk Mini was the most impressive consumer electronics products I have ever owned (considering value and all). The fact that it is to 30% the width seemingly doesn’t limit the stage at all.
I have the AX in another room and it likely ties the original ‘wow’ record. I would note that $449 is a great value.
BUT the original mini has been around for a few years and can be had for insane prices ($150-175ish or even less) which is clearly significantly bellow half the price of the AX.
Proof that this (our hosts) is a solid marriage would be the better half chiming in toward the end in defense of the original mini. it DOES do MUCH more than simply enhance dialogue. The subwoofers are identical and both do exactly as described regarding depending on the sub for deeper midrange.
The midrange-sub integration was a very very intelligent point about both systems that I have certainly observed owning both….I just never really thought about it in that way. Party in the back? Not this time. Sub to the front.
I’ve Banged with Olufsen and Ambeoed at a friends home. Over the years I’ve Viziod my budget, multi-roomed w/ Sonos Barbara and 7.1 book tower shelved with Onkyo and cables.
No need for a paragraph to say ‘I’ve heard fancy shit.’ I guess I couldn’t help myself. Both of these sound great.
Born and raised in the Silicon Valley I hate supporting Amazon in all ways. With that said if you see the original Magnifi Mini used (as it’s been around long enough for this to be common) and in ‘very good’ or ‘good’ condition…..regardless of your tax bracket status the football and wireless sub at $170ish is MADNESS. Like amphetamine fueled midwestern used car salesmen tv commercial CRAZY DEALS CLICK NOW WE GIVEN IT AWAY level value.
It’s that great. Vizio can’t make a decent TV but they do nice things with budget soundbars. However that $150-250 spent toward either Polk is exponentially more potent, quality, versatile and like a weight training football of some kind. Don’t blow out your shoulder.
Good review. Remember just because they send it doesn’t mean you can’t say it sucks. You know there is a sponsored review disease going around. So far so good. 👍🏻
I currently have the original mini but im considering upgrading because of airplay and atmos. But it terms of sound quality is the AX better than the original? i ask because it seems the AX has only 3 mid range drivers instead of 4 like the original
Sound bars are here to stay, like it or not. I think it's incredibly satisfying to have someone marvel at how good a sound bar sounds given its respective size. I also think a lot of people would be hard pressed to discern a difference between discrete audio channels and an all in one solution like a sound bar.
What I think sound bars offer more than anything is a higher acceptability factor from significant others. I can tell you my wife hates the look of speakers. She doesn't even go into my basement because she hates looking at them. 🤷 I've added my sound bars on my other TV's, though, by using added mounting brackets to the TV wall mount and they just become an addition to the TV. She doesn't mind this view at all.
I don't know where I'm going with this comment, so I'll cut it short. Sound bars are a fantastic invention that pumps out way higher fidelity audio in a much more space friendly package and for that reason, I think they aren't going anywhere and people shouldn't turn their noses up at them, but instead root for continued innovation in that product sector.
While your channel has opened my eyes to how impressive soundbars can be (3 drivers that sound like 15? What is this magic??) I still haven't encountered one that made me think "I not only need that, but I want it over a traditional pair or suite of speakers." I guess I'm just too old school. Big room full of gear all the way!
That said, in high school I would have loved this thing atop my 9" TV.
There's an E in MavErick (1st popup) 🙂 My room is full of STUFF (11.1) but we'll be moving into a RV for a couple years while building a new home. This is where the sound bar setup shines. I sold our old RV with an LG setup. Thanks!
I've just purchased the LG éclair soundbar to go with my LG C1 55 inch TV I have a 2 bedroom apartment so this I feel is perfect for me it arrives on Sat just in time for the MW2 beta
I had a pair of B&O RL45.2 and i change my main setup for a Soundbar 500 with the bass Module 500. Much more compact and asethetic! With ADAPTiQ, the bar understands my room, the listening is easier!
No regrets making the switch to a soundbar, but a keep my stereo setup for a another room!
I'll say this, having moved from Texas to New Jersey, carrying all that gear has a price....not including the anxiety of disassembling, packing and then trusting movers to not destroy all of it. These Sound Bar Reviews are making me look back at your other reviews and it's making me reconsider an auditioning of the LG SP9.
They are a heck of a lot easier to transport that is for sure! I'd look at this bit.ly/3OS72nG over the LG.
@@KristiWright Thanks for the recommendation. I'll be checking this out.
I would consider a soundbar for a secondary room as a way to try it out low risk.. Maybe the master bedroom? after hearing your reviews
This sound bar is truly impressive. I experimented with the sound modes and agree that 3D mode is THE mode to use if you want a dynamic cinema experience. It blows me away especially when I crank it past 50%. My friends thought I was playing a trick on them with hidden speakers
Something that stuck out to me was Kristis comment on dialog not being great. I had a similar “issue” and found that my wife and I prefer movie mode for most of our TV watching in the evenings. Movie mode seems to boost the subtle details and dialog especially at lower volumes compared to the mighty and dynamic 3D mode.
Going from 3D mode to movie mode reminds me of setting Dynamic range setting to “Normal” on my Yamaha receiver in my man cave. Night mode works well too but kills a bit too much of the bass imho
QOTD: I find the smaller devices more impressive. I think both soundbars and full sized systems have their place. One big advantage of soundbars is easier integration, which should result in more folks getting a better home audio experience. As someone whom doesn't always love the value proposition of soundbars compared to flexibility and upgrade paths of more components, I am genuinely curious to hear some of these models for myself. So yes I think your channel is doing its job, and doing so in the most entertaining way. Also loved that you had to get one more jab in at marantz.
Not to ride the fence on this one but they’re both impressive for different reasons. For someone like me, I kitted out my office (work from home so I’m in there ALOT) with a 55” C1 oled with my Klipsch the fives and a Klipsch sub. In that room it’s an amazing combo that truly rocks and is amazing for movies. That said now that I’m starting the living room I’m at a loss… I’m not a baller or anything but I want a nice, versatile media experience. Gaming, movies, music and sports. Every time I think I’m set there’s something else that seems like a better option lol. As of now I was pretty set on a Polk reserve system with two R700s two R900 height modules two r200 surrounds the R400 center and an svs 1000 for the hip hop and r&b as well as feeling like Godzilla is stomping through my living room lol. That said I was set on last years Klipsch reference line (hard to beat money wise), set on a focal chora system similar to the Polk and even the Sony AH-9 set up seemed tempting. There are so many good things out these days, it’s easy to not really know where to go, especially when starting from scratch (no av receiver yet either and that’s a whole other wormhole lol) basically it’s all impressive haha.
ROOM FULL OF GEAR......great video ....thanks !
Awesome review! Only thing that I would have liked you to review is the connectivity capabilities, such as Alexa integration or interaction and how that works, specially since you mentioned the music listening features. But thank you for your fantastic review - this really helped me decide what to purchase.
The magnifi max ax can handle lossless dolby trueHD and dts X which is a killer feature for soundbars. Is it the same for the mini ax ?
I purchased the system yesterday. My only interest is to improve dialog clarity and still have some sound quality. For this, I am happy with the purchase. Thanks for the review.
As a mostly recovered audiophile myself and a custom AV pro for over two decades (accustomed to $100K custom home theaters), I would prefer to impress my friends with tiny sound-bar roaring a giant sound in a double blind sound-off 😎
I find it outrageously fascinating how the laws of physics are reliably “broken” time and time again by the manufacturers.
ok so my husband is the reason i am into this hobby. He set up a theater room for us and it is by all means a room full of STUFF. (Wife approved of course) However, In our bedroom, we have a Samsung Sound Bar with wireless rear speakers and i must say i do prefer the non cluttered look over a bunch of equipment everywhere.
I often feel the same, Jennifer. Welcome and thanks for watching!
I think sounds bars are great for the common joe. The room full of equipment is for those who really want to take sound to another level both are good in there own way.
I found it refurb for $350 and $150 for SR2 and I'm very pleased. The SR2 surrounds make a big improvement. Yes, Mini AX is much better than TV speakers, if only because you add a sub, but surrounds for 5.1 and "Fake Atmos" are a must. It's so easy to setup and configure etc. So $500+ tax all in, I'm very glad. Small footprint and clean install with wireless, it's a win.
hi, I`m wondering about to buy the same, Mini AX and SR2 surrounds...can You tell me how this "Fake Atmos" is working? I want to buy it only of movies and wondering if this small thing will works good or maybe I should better look for some bigger Polka or Samsung?
@@marcinmarcin4811 I would say stock center and sub add dimension but incapable of surround or ATMOS in any way. Adding SR2 surrounds makes for a 5.1 feel but very little to no Ceiling bounce on my standard 8 ft ceilings. It's no ATMOS compared to a full setup.
When you change volume, does it show the number on the display?
Thanks Andrew for your review! I am using right now the Magnifi Mini and think about upgrading to AX, Worth it?
I have a stereo Samsung sound bar 180w rms and a 5.1.4 HT system in the same room. When I do not want to fire up the HT system, the sound bar does a good job. I have some Pro-ject box 5 s2 on the way for the front and rear channels. Your top review peaked my interest, in Australia no green🙁. You and Kristi, your reviews are enjoyable to watch cheers.
Great to see what Polk is doing. Any plans to review their signature elite ( I own the signature speakers that are no longer around it seems) speakers down the road? Thanks for the great video. The speaker looks so small compared to your TV lol. Less is more as I grow older, so yeah if I could get something that sounds like my room full of gear with one speaker or 2 instead of 5.1.2, then yes. 100%.
I bought a Magnify mini for the bedroom a few years ago and was immediately impressed.
Aside from the tweeters being close together, it provides excellent, mostly full-range sound. Though the small sub doesn't shake the house like my Cinema 600 sub does, it still provides accurate, present low frequencies. Small as it is, it still has HDMI-arc and Bluetooth functionality.
I must agree, that it's better for TV and movies, than it is for music.
All said, it's a great, solid performer in a small package.
The "ax" looks as though it's a worthy successor, but not enough to warrant upgrading from the mini... IMHO.
Thanks for a good review!
With regard to your question:
The small soundbar is GREAT in the bedroom, where WAF rules.
In the den, the Klipsch Cinema 600 is much more appropriate with it's width and powerful sub.
I've had a 7.1 system in the past and for my needs, it simply wasn't worth it.... speakers everywhere, big receiver, etc. The Cinema 600 provides all the immersive sound I want for movies in a small, simple, uncluttered package. Well, that big sub isn't exactly easy to hide or ignore.
Since my serious stereo system is in the same room with it's speakers an dual subs.... the less imposing soundbar system is all the more appreciated.
Tried the JBL Soundbar 5.1 as Kristi liked it for the voice clarity. It is not very clear so we will try either this one or the MAX version that allows you to adjust it.
Am I going to lose a lot of the vertical sound stage with a single slant vaulted ceiling?
It's a big improvement generally on the previous Magnifi Mini which seriously lacked timbre especially with music, but while it's nice that it can decode Dolby Digital, Atmos and DTS: X there's nothing really very "surround" about the setup. It creates an impressive soundstage for your screen area but the rears and ceiling channels are indistinguishable from the front channels except for a non-specific effect of big room ambiance. Still a really nice sound for such a compact unit but don't expect the sound of a helicopter flying overhead to magically come from somewhere above you for example despite what Polk advertises, or you'll just be disappointed.
Considering something compact for my desk. How would this compare to PC speakers like the Audioengines or Klipsch Promodia (heritage and non-heritage). Anyone been able to compare them pls?
I got one of these for about $300 for a small room. It's nice, and the sub is great, but I can't say I have noticed a good 3D effect yet. Maybe because I keep it around 30 volume? Either way, pretty good for the price I paid.
I've had soundbars for over 20 years now and they have come a very long way. I think once they started introducing upfiring speakers it has changed the game and now more recently Dolby atmos. It's no question that now is the time to transition over. Right now I have the q900a with rears and it sounds good. Buy I'm looking to get the 95qr but when it goes further down in price.
It’s nice to have options, soundbar for those who want better sound with ease of use , or go all out with separate components and speakers.
Even with turntables including Bluetooth connection can be added to a soundbar as an option to enjoy vinyl . If your happy with a simple soundbar no need to go all audiophile. Depending who you ask and circumstances no right answer to the QOTD only opinions. Appreciate your reviews.
I'm surprised you haven't already done a review on this! but better late than never. this thing is tiny but mighty, though technically it's the subwoofer that does the heavy lifting
What is the difference between the ax and the magnifi mini
The virtual surround bit is a moot point considering the original uses their patented SDA technology and supports Dolby 5.1. Meaning it already has decent virtual surround. The true leg up the AX has is the wireless satellite speakers that turn it into a true surround system. Or at the very least a hybrid.
My dad just purchased one of these and has been telling me how good it sounds (after giving me back the bar he was borrowing from me). He said the dialog enhancement is really good because I hate people doing current sound mixing. It would work well in my living room since I have my sub up by my hearth. He said the 3d is really good at the wide but lacks some height. Can I set up 2 Bluetooth speakers for a L and R channel instead of rear? Our living room just doesn't have a great way to do rear sound.
Interested in magnifimax ax..$599.00 at BB but no reviews..most Polk soundbars have no available treble adjustment.
I would take a room full of gear….only…it kinda depends on your home. For me it’s impossible to fill it with gear so a bar would be the best, just finding the best (reasonable priced one) that does both music and movies great
The only Polk speakers I've owned are the fx40i as rear and surrounds in a 7.1 set up. They had a bipole and tripole switch. Really good!
Wll it be better for music listening compared to old Magnifi Mini model? Or only difference is more spacious sound in movies?
Great to see love for Polk.
Hey Andrew!! Could you please review the POLK MagniFi Max AX SR???? Thanks buddy!
@Andrew Robinson
Well, to answer your question, I could have chosen to answer your question in a more direct fashion however I'd rather choose a different approach here.
Been following your channel a long time now and you have adopted a different route to reviewing the products compared to the ones that you used to review couple of years ago.
You have opened yourself up to new technology based all-in-one home theatre products, soundbars etc..
So, now, to answer your question, like you mentioned in one of your reviews, even when it comes to two-channel bookshelf speakers, hi-fi systems, powered-speakers is the future.
Similarly, in home theatre field I think this is the kind of future we are looking forward to.
Polk Maginifi mini AX is an excellent starting point for any HT enthusiast.
For a more hardcore enthusiast, I would probably suggest Sony HT A9. I know you were pretty impressed with that system too 🙂
Similarly, in the two channel set-up, one can probably start things off with SVS Prime Wireless Pro Powered speakers and then work their way up to KEF LS50 Wireless II and then given the space and budget could go up to LS60s.
This is the future aka Future-fi.
10-20 yrs ago, people had more space to play with and discrete systems made total sense.
Hell, I still have discrete two channel set-up and discrete Home theatre setup.
But in the last couple of years, i have started leaning more towards powered/active speaker setups and Magnifi-like setups for HT solutions. Simply because space is a limitation we are all facing now.
Hope that answers your question. It was an interesting and a practical one 👍✌️
As always, excellent review buddy 🙏 keep them coming. God bless ✌️
I like to tinker too much to have a soundbar in our main home theater, but if you happen to have multiple tvs and can't stand the horrible speakers they come with soundbars can save the day. I've watched Nightmare before Christmas in the kids playroom 5 times in the last 4 days, I'm so happy we've got the little soundbar in there.
Even this review is old, I still found it useful as I was looking for something small for my daughter's dorm room.
Thank you.
Is it really worth the money
Sonos placing ads on the channel is the epitome of irony.
@@zachariahadams ...when you want to reach the audience, but you're scared of a real review. #advertise
@@KristiWright TRUTH BOMB!
@@KristiWright My son has been deeply invested in the Sonos infrastructure for about 4 years now - even using them in at least one of the restaurants in which he’s part owner. While it’s certainly easy to understand the appeal - particularly if you want music throughout the house and anywhere in the yard within range of your wifi - the sonics of even the ARC and Sub are, how can is say diplomatically - meh? While his 75” Sony X80 series TV deceivers a pretty decent picture, what I’ve heard from his rig so far hasn’t inspired my to replace my 7.2 HT system.
Thanks to a couple of your earlier reviews, I recently acquired a BlueSound Node for an upstairs system that is now streaming only, and so far no complaints; although at a certain age (70) I’m finding there’s a much longer learning curve to all the functionality - such as wireless streaming from shared PC/Mac libraries - it has to offer.
Hello Andrew and Kristi. As always, I love your reviews of all thing audio and visual. In response to your question about considering a sound bar . . . . yes I now feel that the tech is that good that I would consider one. I currently have a 5.1 setup with descrete speakers and an AV receiver which are 10 years old. However, I don't think my wife will let me start cutting holes in ceiling for some Atmos speakers. I am very much looking forward to you doing a review of the new Sennheiser Ambeo Plus soundbar (and sub, hopefully!) as I feel it could be the sound bar to replace my current system.
We've requested one but not sure our emails are getting through to anyone.
How does the polk magnifi max compare to the senheiser ambeo mini?
Hi Andrew and Kristi what sound bar would you guys recommend?budget is 800-1700 usd
Stay tuned to the channel Jepjep if you're looking a bit more upmarket 😉
I would start here: bit.ly/3OS72nG / amzn.to/3ck5Aws.
@@KristiWright thanks 🙏
@@andrewrobinsonreviews I’m always tuned in to your channel. Sometimes too much…
I was looking for some information on an Emotiva mini-xa-100 yesterday, and I found a video on YT. Who was in that video? A seemingly on the edge of having his soul crushed Mr. Andrew Robinson. You can tell how much you love what you do now just by the tone change in your voice. It was a fun little time capsule. Glad you are here though. Be well Andrew and Kristi.
Great review! Seems to be an amazing small (WAF-covered 😉) but affordable Atmos soundbar! Allthough I own a great 2-way system with my tv, this could be a nice add-on for movies only. p.s.: Would be interesting to have a ranking overview of soundbars tested to keep up.
What is the difference between the mini an mini ax
The Eames looks so damn good.... Just gorgeous.
Thanks, Gabe. We love it!
This small soundbars like the eclair and this magnifi mini for me are great options for bedroom TVs. I've seen people put big Samsung soundbars and it takes too much space this is a great solution for a small room. Too bad that you didn't had the LG at hand because they look pretty similar too but for me this one is great for a bedroom TV and might wait till the holidays and pick one up.
How would you compare it to the Bose 600 with or without the Bose bass module 500? Thanks a lot
I purchased both the Polk MagniFi Mini Ax and the JBL Bar 500. I’m still performing sound checks between the two but having such a difficult time noticing the differences. Both being the same price point I’m torn. Any specs or features that I’m missing that one unit has versus the other?
Update: If you like more bass and will be using the system for more than just tv/movies I’d recommend the JBL. The only issue I’ve noticed with the JBL is the Bluetooth is sometimes spotty.
The Polk MagniFi mini AX sounds incredible, but I do see what was mentioned in the review about dialogue. Also, I cannot place the subwoofer next to the couch or behind furniture, it has to be place to the L or R of the tv. I’m leaning towards the JBL
This review was incredibly helpful and convinced me to purchase the Mini AX. I watched "The Fall Guy" on it last night, and the experience was fantastic. I had read that the subwoofer was bass-heavy, and that is definitely true. I have mine set to "Movie" mode with the bass adjusted to -2. To manage the downward-firing bass and avoid disturbing my neighbors, I also bought the "Auralex Acoustics SubDude-II Subwoofer Acoustic Isolation Platform" from Amazon. This is an absolute must if you’re renting an apartment, and I believe it also helps direct the sound more effectively.
I have a lot of 5.1 and Atmos content, and I’m considering adding the SR2 satellite speakers to my setup. Does anyone have thoughts on these? Additionally, what stands have people used for their satellite speakers? Thanks!
Had bought this is 2019, had issues with sub losing connection and a constant white noise from rear speakers.
I used to hate soundbars and then ran across a DefTech Studio Micro on Marketplace for $250. Picked it up and it works really well for my bedroom TV watching and occasional music listening. But I have other full systems in the house for movies and music.
Which is better this or the samsung q800b?
Riddle me this, small sound bars are always AC powered, and battery/portable speakers are optimized for music, not movie watching. So what would you guys recommend as a portable battery powered solution to match with a battery powered projector for camping outdoors movie nights?
Something in this small form factor, battery powered and with low Bluetooth latency would get my money in the blink of an eye
Hands down, if there is an option to have a sound bar and wireless surrounds (too bad you didn't get to review those) that provided a 5.1 surround experience, I'd have no qualms about investing. Especially at a sub-1k price point. My wife would likely be happy with it as well. Less mess, fewer wires.
Any thoughts on the new Polk MAGNIFI MAX AX?
Sounds like this sound bar would an interesting investment.
got the magnifi mini and im impressed, got it for cheaper price too at amazon 3yrs ago, i dnt know if ax is really an upgrade in terms of sound quality.
We've heard both and believe it is an upgrade. A comparison is made in the video for your reference.
I've been debating looking into a soundbar to replace my 5.0 setup (own a condo, being nice to neighbors by not getting--nor needing--a sub). Mainly because our rear channels are on stands behind the couch and we have cats. My hesitation is being disappointed by sound and going through the process of a return. On the flip side, if I like the soundbar, the hassle of selling the receiver and 5 speakers is the other possibility that gives me pause.
We use this amzn.to/3bt6HpT set up without the surrounds all the time and don't feel like we are missing too much.
Think I may be in a common situation. With a growing family I've got lots of hifi gear now on storage. The economy of returns on picking up a HTinaB that does it well versus putting all my stuff back out is appealing... Happy wife happy life....
I've been running the original Magnifi mini for close to 3 years now. I actually got it at Walmart close out for something like $139.99 (thanks Slickdeals)
I like it, it's a little weird with not turning on sometimes with the power on the tv and constantly I have to change inputs or turn it off when it loses Dolby processing which happens often. Kinda of annoying but not terrible. I turned the bass down 2 notches and same with the dialogue. Just seemed a bit tipped up on both for me, especially the bass. Probably because my main room I use a sealed box sub (REL) and the polk seemed a bit much out of the box setting. Other than that for the price I enjoy it, fits well in that room with the small form factor.
A spouse friendly soundbar!! Righteous.
Good morning!
Could anyone help me which is the best mode for Magnifi mini Ax with SR2 surround cause when I put 3D or movie or music mode, couldn’t hear anything from SR2 surround. So pls advice. Thanks
I believe for the surround speakers to actually work you have to be watching content that supports 5.1 or Dolby atoms. If it’s not one of those then the surround speakers won’t make a sound. Try getting a top Netflix plan or whatever service that supports that audio and you should be able to hear it.
Ok, you talked me into purchasing this. I was very happy with it’s performance, however, 2 weeks in the sub has begun to make a loud “popping” noise that is extremely annoying. Apparently not uncommon. I’m taking it back.
Apple says that the newest Apple TV 4K doesn't support Dolby Atmos through ARC/eARC. What player did you use to demo the movies shown in the video?
We have an AppleTV 4K however it is not the latest generation model that was announced or put on sale a few months ago.
Hey Andrew , I am interested in this system, my query is , if I add surround units, do they pass on Atmos experience or not ?
Thanks.
Saw the teaser on Instagram and was secretly hoping it was the new Ambeo sound bar. Guess the wait continues :p (still great review tho)
We're trying! Starting to wonder if the new ownership has turned them into another company that's only good at sending out press releases. Really hoping that's not the case!
@@KristiWright hope you’ll get their new Ambeo Sub with the Ambeo Soundbar Plus. Seems to be an amazing new combination! I am looking forward to your review.
Active speakers or soundbar for convenience to connect to bedroom TV? Beam 2, Polk mini ax, Klipsch 5s or mission lx connect? Or anything else?
I recently rewatched (yes I rewatch your vids.. they're that good lol) your Klipsch Cinema 600 Sound Bar 3.1 review and was close to pulling the trigger to get one.. but now I'm considering the Polk. Recommendation which one? I have a small living room but a high ceiling and like Christi I have issues with voices. So, I think I'm leaning towards the Polk over Klipsch.
I am considering also both .. Cinema 600 seems to have louder sound than Polk but Atmos Audio from Polk seems to be better for movies … I plan to use it 80% Movies /20% Music. What would you choose ?
I actually switched back to a discrete 5.1 system but with a twist.
I have the Enclave CineHome II. Bought this used at a good deal and it is game changer for me because they are wireless.
The sound is impressive and easy to set up. These are WISA certified speakers. I don't have cut outs or subwoofer drops in this system which was a problem when using my LG SN10YG soundbar with the rear speaker kit.
Using any WISA speakers, you can upgrade to a 7.1 or 5.1.2 Atmos setup but I have not tried this yet (considering the cost right now for additional speakers).
Also, my 2020 LG tv is WISA certified but I prefer using the system with ARC/eARC.
So I'm curious if you have thoughts on WISA speakers and the Soundsend/Axiim transmitter.
Platin Audio just announced their 5.1.2 wireless Atmos system which is interesting as well but expensive!
Thanks for the content by the way! 🙌
I'm just watching this now. Has there been any updates or new options? I have a 17' Casita fiberglass camper. I need s small sound bar/system, for an obviously small space that won't break the bank. Any suggestions?
I will probably buy this product for my study/library/office/guest room combo room. I am pulling the trigger on the Beosound stage gold tone for the tv room. Until I can afford an upgrade to the beolab 28s for my main music system going to be hanging on to my peachtree amp and ls50s fed by an ifi stream and fluance rt 85. My receiver, fancy dac, phono stage and sub (not a huge bass head) will soon be available on audio mart haha. I will hang on to my Beosound level for music in the rest of the house/deck.
So to answer your question: yeah I love the idea of simplification through soundbars. It’s a similar reason to why I traded tcl 8 series for a frame 2022 - the style/convenience of less stuff while still getting a picture quality that 10 years ago me would have been amazed by is compelling. Keeps the peace with my design minded better half as well.
Hey Andrew can you please so the max ax sr that would be awesome