Detroit : then and now - 1
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2024
- This video was made by a friend of mine.
I thank him by this way! ✌
The American city of Detroit was like Paris, some people said. It had a big river, beautiful wide streets and important buildings. Then, in the 20th century, it was called ‘Motor City’ because of the number of car factories there. Workers in the car factories had good jobs and they earned good money. It wasn’t unusual to own a home, a boat and even a holiday home. In the 1950s, new highways were built and lots of people moved from the city centre to the suburbs. Life was good. But at the beginning of the 21st century, Detroit became America’s poorest big city.
In a period of fifty years, more than half the people left Detroit. Houses and buildings were empty. Poverty and crime increased. Plants and trees grew in the empty houses. What happened in Detroit?
The city’s population fell for several reasons. One reason is people moved to the suburbs in the 1950s. Another reason is that in 1967 there were terrible riots. A lot of people were scared of coming to the city. Also, the big car companies like General Motors and Chrysler had huge problems. And in 2008, the world financial crisis had a big effect on many cities, especially Detroit. Now, a lot of people in Detroit are poor. Half of the city’s families have less than 25,000 dollars a year.
In 2013, the city of Detroit was bankrupt. It was the biggest bankrupt city in American history. But then something began to change. It was a new beginning for the city. It had some money to improve small things like lights in the streets and so people felt safe. The police came quickly when there were problems. Old, empty buildings were demolished. There is now space for new buildings. And there are new businesses too. The city gave 10,000 dollars to 30 new small businesses. Now there are grocery stores, juice bars, coffee shops and even bicycle makers. Finally, the city is working again.
It's shocking to see large industrial buildings, some that take up several blocks, completely disappear and nature reclaim the land. Those buildings, and the jobs that meant so much to the people of that time totally wiped off the map. It's surreal.
Life after people.
Shockingly surreal series
Life is long and in the end, it's only with yourself
It really is a crying shame to see the entire aftermath. These were once decent and steady Jobs that were the Ticket to the Middle Class. It's highly unlikely these jobs just migrated across town ☹.
Thanks for watching!
@@surferbri5346 absolutely true!!!
As a filmmaker I am beyond impressed at how this was presented the simplicity of it and how the wipes allowed you to really take In the differences..amazing how shots of buildings can actually be moving ! Lol
All the genial things are simple.
Thanks for watching!
A whole lot of effort went into the angles and obtaining the correct heights of the after shots to make this really spectacular, I bet it took a whole lot of ingenuity and a bit of bravery too. Thanks and hope you continue to do this work in and around the metro area. Ill bet Flint would be a treasure trove as well..
Thanks for watching!
Makes you realize.... we are going backwards, not forward
Thanks for watching!
But the enemy will have you believe that we're making real social progress. They'll have you believe that weve progressed so much that weve gone to the moon
Regressives.
Yeah our culture has reached a dead end street. Heartbreaking to watch.
Exactly 💯
Great video. The folks who built all this would be rolling in their grave if they saw what it looks like today. Thanks for taking us down memory lane.
Thank you for watching.
Agreed!!!
No city can survive Tre'vone'de and Big Keisha taking over.. None has yet anyway. Two cities in Japan survived NUCLEAR BOMBS but T and BK would take em down for the full count!
Well, by that logic all architects will be rolling in there Graves in thousands of years when it all crumbles. No they will not roll in their grave. They already let go of everything
Right, no one cares about the American history. The way I feel is .... This isn't America anymore.
The best now and then I’ve ever seen!! The denigration of our cities is tragic.
It is a true tragedy...
Thanks for watching.
You don't keep up with our cities much do you? Detroit is make a huge comeback. You really should look at all the new construction and preservation projects in Detroit over the last 5 years. You should look at cities like Nashville, Austin, Miami, Phoenix, Indianapolis, Houston, Dallas, New York, Orlando, Tampa, Minneapolis, Philadelphia and many more. They are all growing with beautiful new construction projects. Even Chicago has many new projects underway.
Great video. All of these old plant buildings would be over 100 yo if still around. What manufacturers would still be using them? They were obsolete and abandoned. Of course they were torn down. There was never going to be a another use for the giant Ford or Packard plants.
By the 1920s many of the wealthiest families had already left Detroit for sprawling estates outside the city. The wealthy class still maintained positions in civic institutions, but just as once prominent church congregations moved out of the city, the people of vision had less and less of a stake in the affairs of the common resident. It was a matter of time before the middle class professional class would follow the wealthy. Increasing the administration of the city was left to people lacking in urban skills, poor choices were made. Some politicians used their influence for corruption, but few watchdogs were looking over their shoulders. The riots of 1967 had a catastrophic impact on property values. When families saw their neighborhoods being devalued, they saw little risk in abandoning the city.
A city needs to attract the brightest and most ambitious, it needs an ethical police force, well run schools, when it lacks these things, the poorest and vulnerable will fall prey to the short sighted.
Most of Detroit's riverfront was dominated by industry. Chicago's wealthy lived in lakeside luxury dwellings, they all didn't pack up and leave because the city planners had preserved a beautiful place for them. Detroit's riverfront was filled with smoke and rusting industrial sites. A city must attract and keep the brightest and most ambitious, Detroit failed to do that.
Thanks for watching.
Chicago didn’t get blacks like Detroit did, stupid. You’ve done nothing but pontifical sophistry to avoid the actual truth.
And to lay the law down to.
Many of the wealthy did stay in the city. They lived in Palmer park, Palmer Woods, Boston Edison, Arden Park, Jefferson Avenue and Indian village. Jefferson avenue had many luxury apartments and the Whittier Hotel on the river had millionaires such as the Stroh family living in in the apartment building which connected to the hotel. I should also mention the area on the river known as Gray Haven
the idea that a City government, or any other government, has a valid "vision" for planning the future is absurd...
government is nothing more than a gang of robbers, rapists, and pillagers seeking to enrich themselves at the expense of all others; government cannot produce it can only confiscate; it makes back-room deals picking winners and losers enforcing its edicts at the barrel of a gun...
these pictures evidence the corruption, factories abandoned and then constructed miles away, even overseas, because of a better government deal; and why not abandon, after all, a billion $$$ had already been pocketed, the CEO and the worker will not suffer $0.01 of the abandonment, and the government Actors have also filled their pockets...
this is world wide prostitution of people by government teamed to corporations, they poison the land and move on to poison more and more...
why doesn't Detroit (or any other for-profit municipality) repair the destruction? because it can't, municipalities DO NOT PRODUCE, and they will not allow (at the barrel of a gun) any man or woman to move onto abandoned property without great expense (bribery)...
the people acting as government act as though they are the Master of ALL they see within the "boundaries" of "their" for profit municipal corporation...
the CONstitution was a bankster take over of the several States, and Detroit is just one of the pieces of evidence...
see RebelMadMan. o r g
It is sad to see these buildings that are no longer there or left abandoned. You don't have to be super smart to understand how Detroit went to hell. The video was well made, the eriee music was perfect. I enjoyed it!
Thanks for watching.
Just for a minute pretend I am not "super smart" and tell me how Detroit "went to hell"?
@@tomsampson8084 yeah I want to know too lol
@@tomsampson8084 I wanna know to
I'm not super smart but I'm smart enough to know the reasons why Detroit went to "hell" are complex and varied enough that even a doctoral dissertation can't adequately cover the whole thing. Ask me how I know.
Great video! What a shame to lose these pieces of history. Just one suggestion. Consider adding the name and address to each slide. Some sites I know but there are some that I don’t. Thx
We gave away the store. Between cheap labor overseas purchasing corrupt unions and very corrupt politicians as we are seeing today are decimating this country. Sad state of affairs.
Bet you did not pay more for your computer than you needed to. Start your own business and pay TOP $ for labor and administration. Bet most would be like you and pay the least for the most.
people keep saying that and nothing changes..Course voting for the dems and the republicans will assure that it continues that was..
so sad particularly the Highland Park scenes - you showed what once was an industry that not only produced transportation but works of art as well - automobiles today are nothing but monotony . Thank you for a job well done !!!
Thanks for watching!
Agree 1000per cent.
I grew up in Detroit. (I’m 50 now and still live in MI)
This is just sad.
Even where I grew up, looks like an old WW2 bombing zone that never got cleaned up and all around there, I couldn’t even drive there during the day and be sure to make it back again alive.
Whoever made this did one fkin awesome job. It’s just unbelievable.
Thanks for watching!
This video should be the standard for side-by-side photographic comparisons. Outstanding job! It is sad to see but the truth of Detroit withering away is an old story that's been going on since I was a little boy back in the 1960s. The industry moved from a centralized area (Detroit) to now different parts of our country.
Thanks for watching!
A superior collage, stunning actually. And Also hilarious- those men with their signs protesting the building. The building says OK I Will Go Away Now.
Fantastic job lining up the new photos with the old ones. I have seen a lot of "then and now" collections, and none of them have the angles lined up as well as these.
Such a shame, so many nice buildings turned into parking lots, or into vacant lots. As bad as the abandoned buildings look, at least they're still standing.
Thanks for watching!
Did ya notice the Ren-Cen was in both tje old and new shots? Lol!
Still good to see. I worked in a few of the old power plants. Would be cool to see them when they were completed and before they were demo'd.
Gee... Wonder why the city resembles a third world warzone. People become contortionists when trying to explain what happened... It's not rocket science. All you have to do is drive around Detroit for a few minutes and you'll notice the problem.
Thanks for watching.
The current pictures looks like we went back in time. It goes to show you that time has nothing to do with progress. It often means regressing into a dark period.
True.
Thanks for watching.
@@KristianK9755 it's not something I take pleasure in seeing. Really SAD!
Wow I've lived in Detroit all my life this is a beautiful video
Amazing before and after. Huge amount of time and effort and talent went into this. Wish my Dad was alive to see this.
Thanks for watching!
Simply mesmerizing, I watched this twice. The production values are very good and the music is haunting and lovely.
Thanks for watching!
Very well done
I second that!
Even the music is scary and depressing great video!
Heartbreaking. I weep for my old hometown.
Thanks for watching!
Never saw the slide feature in before and after photos. Love it!
Ghettos don't make thugs . Thugs make ghettos . Sad what the animals have done to the once beautiful city . 😔
Thanks for watching.
America: Where even entire cities are disposable.
Is the same over the world...
In 1987 I moved to the States, from Romania. I knew Detroit from some post cards. I was fascinated. I remember the downtown in pictures! Amazing and incredible!!
Things are changing rapidly!
I consider myself a Detroit Guy!
Exceptional video!
Good job!! 👍👍
Multamn fain de vizionare.
De unde din Romania ai plecat?
@@KristianK9755 Ultima reședință in Reșița! 😂👍
@@abelpavel9674 io-s clujean de la inceput pana in prezent,dat ma retrag la munte in 3-4 ani.
There used to be a channel called "time travel " on UA-cam that had cool videos like this with the horizontal swipe.. love this. This is the only one I've seen in years.
Thanks for watching!
Fantastic video, thank you so much for your beautiful work. It is very sad to see the 'today' version of the city... that being said, I for one want to believe that the city of Detroit will come back again. Maybe not to its full glory of what it once was, but most certainly far better than what it has become today.
Cheers
Thank you for watching!
This video was pretty fuckin cool
I'm glad you're like it.
Thanks for watching.
We're living in a dystopia.
Thanks for watching!
From a rich "Motor City" in 1920s to a "Ruin City" today, there buildings and houses falling down. It is only very sad.
What an incredible video! Seamlessly done! I could watch videos like this all day!
Me too!
Thanks for watching.
Yes!!! I was disapointed when it ended. I was enjoying it so much!
Except at 6:32, the GM Renaissance Center went back in time. :-)
Sad video but at the same time something great. Those ugly factories that used to be on the river are now gone and some great things have replaced them, like the Riverwalk. There’s a lot of positive things going on in Detroit over the last 10 years
The automotive companies gave up on us, I work automotive in metro detroit and I will say downtown detroit has done a complete 360 it is a mostly safe & fun downtown now. The outskirts of the city are rough tho.
Thanks for watching!
Lol! That last pic had the Ren-Cen in both old and new!!!😅😂😅😂😅😂 The Rec-Cen is old but not THAT old. Bwahahahaha!
Thanks for watching
Awesome KK, appreciate your historic picture research and effort to take a modern picture in same location and frame size. My Mom was a 1940's Rosie Riveter in Detroit. We determine she had a job with Hudson Motors, that was subcontracted to make bomber wings for Curtis Wright. Your Hudson building picture is likely where she worked and the first time
I ever seen it. Thanks !
Very well done
Thanks for watching.
This has to be the most incredible way to present a then and now perspective...very well done. Subbed and gave ya a like..
I have a few more videos about this theme on my channel.
Thanks for watching!
@@KristianK9755 I am definately going to watch them.
@@davemilligan1171 be my guest!
Thank you,again!
It's just so sad that people in North America buy Japanese and German cars as well as other's. Let alone using a bank teller or a cashier instead of a machine. I guess all good things come to an end.
But why do they buy Japanese & German? Out of spite? The foreign cars are better and for a while were far better. Competition has forced the US car industry to improve its products.. Stopping competition is never benifical .
American hubris
And to think Detroit was once a decent beautiful city until the trash took over!!
I really love seeing the Uniroyal tire plant at the very end of that video. that building that my dad worked all his life is long gone and so is he.😢
Thanks for watching!
@@KristianK9755 I worked there, too, and fortunately still here..
What a brilliant before and after slide show, I like the replay back again. Please! keep making content like this.
THank you for the good words and thank you for watching!
Third world people make third world environments
Thanks for watching
So sad; and the music was perfect.😟😟
Thanks for watching!
A unique video. Good job....
Thanks for watching!
A state of the art city with the highest standard of living for it's nearly 2 million inhabitants to a video game with 600k lumbering humanoids.
Thanks juice!
Thanks to those lumbering humanoids.
In a way, it’s good to see nature reclaim the land, but I think a tree is just a tree. It’s a shame that those beautiful old buildings weren’t maintained and repurposed.
It would have been very interesting to be born in 1900, or 1910, 1920, 1930,...you get the idea. Life was slower, people appreciated things then.
Another times...but good times!
I would gladly pay more for products that were manufactured in the US, to see these industries come back and employing even just a few hundred people would be so wonderful.
The Jeep Grand Cherokee and Dodge Durango are still made in Detroit.
Back in the day when it was so easy to jump into the middle class without having to be a millionaire
So sad in our modern days we couldn't keep those structures intact,if people came back,they wouldn't recognize it,not many was removed for true growth,just total neglect!shame on the city and money that probably was stolen
Thanks for watching!
Full circle, back to earth. Can you imagine the majority of Detroit becoming farm land again? Someone with smarts and money could make this happen.
Musk!
kick the human animals out and introduce food AND energy independence!
@@Joedirt3349 say it louder for the ones in the back
When you kick the animals out, start with Washington.
Go ahead Karen. You pay the land taxes, you put in the new soil, you put in the fencing to keep thieves from taking the product in the middle of the night...
@@billhosko7723 Bill the thieves have migrated into the suburbs to systematically destroy that area next.
So tragic and so beautiful
In the same time!
Thanks for watching!
i prefer looking at an abandoned building than a parking lot. Even if the building is empty and rotting its still cool piece of history back when buildings still had architecture
Thanks for watching.
Respect to whom put this master peace together
Great video, but very disappointed at the lack of historical preservation that should have taken place! If I could have saved these buildings, I would have! Architecture was so much better then, than what it is now...😪
Thanks for watching!
Блестящая работа! 👍Но очень печально это видеть.
My home tpwn, I'm 76 so saw most of the before, sad to see the after. Thank you, great picture's, great memories
Surprised that it was one one location that I didn't know Wow
Which one
Fantastic video--well done!
Thanks for watching!
It is great to see what we once had and sad to think of what we are now.
Thanks for watching!
Amazing content. 👏👏👏
It is called progress...I worked downtown during the 1967 riots....the place was on fire...left and never returned.
Thanks for watching!
The people who built these absolute monuments would be ticked to see them gone.
Excellent job of matching up the angles and heights just right. I find these old images fascinating and I always like to see what buildings still exist.
Clever photography
Thanks for watching!
Saw a great side by side photo piece showing Detroit and Hiroshima in late summer 1945. And below it, Hiroshima and Detroit in, I think 2010 with the headline-"Now who won this F-ing war?" Powerful!
Thanks for watching!
The building of the freeways, VHA loans for returning WW2 veterans, the ageing of Detroit housing, and, yes, the loss of assembly line jobs were ALL factors in the free fall. But, also, the city has a cold, dreary climate except from late Spring through early Fall. A lot of folks prefer to live in the Sunbelt.
Definitely agree!
Absolutely depressing to see these buildings either in total disrepair or just gone
I agree.
Thanks for watching.
Incredible. Lived in the region my entire life. I know many of the looks but even the ones i did is never seen perfectly matched to what was there as it was. I get the time, skill and effort to find and adjust but more likely to to each site and perfectly match up perspective for the now picture. Thank you
Thank you for watching.
This is an amazing video -- I recognize how hard it is to match vantage points, camera angles and lens distortion in "then and now" photos. I also love the way the image cuts back to the original for a second time before moving on. It makes the difference between then and now all the more stunning. Hope to see more of Detroit here -- from the looks of it, I'm not sure I would want to vacation there.
Thanks for watching!
You have to be really trying to run a city into the ground to do what’s been done to this place. It’s like playing sim city backwards. How fast can you destroy a prosperous city. We need to find out the mayors names and make sure there remembered for this feat.
Thanks for watching.
I have to honestly say, in my own opinion, the empty lot is far better than the decaying building.
Thanks for watching!
It’s sad the way Detroit looks now it’s getting better slowly but yo go from what Detroit used to look like to this is truly sad
There is probably enough salvageable brick in Detroit to pave a 4 lane hi way around the world......and beyond.
Not enough Copper pipe to do a House.All that has been stolen.
Thanks for watching!
This is the heart of USA and Industrialization. Cars are a metaphor of the classic American culture. The death of Detroit, Flint, etc. is the beginning of human surplus. Amazing moment when Moore asked Roger, in Roger and me, if he did not feel bad about closing the factories destroying the legendary automobile culture, and Roger answer, No, because business are business...
Most of the people who worked in those buildings are long gone as are the cars they produced.
True.
Thanks for watching!
Sad to see. Most of these building are artifacts of American history and assembly line production! They should be preserved as museums, not unfortunately examples of urban decay. It’s too bad they couldn’t have been preserved to be a time capsule of Detroit’s history.
Gee, 60 years of unbroken blue policies, where's the utopia? Baltimore, Chicago, San Fran, Portland, St Louis, Minneapolis, Seattle.....?
Not everything can be explained away by "red" vs "blue" political dogma. What about states like MS, LA, AL, AR? Unbroken "red" policies for 60 years and still mired in poverty, poor education, high unemployment, and the highest levels of per capita federal assistance in the US. Residents & jobs are fleeing ruby red Missouri just as quickly as NY & CA.
@@lbputzer please give me your source for the crime, poverty, and misery in "red" cities. Because I'm betting those are blue counties or cities in red states. Show me a city or county with 6 decades of unbroken red policy makers that has declined this way.
Beautiful. What were the buildings though? Where are/were they?
A lot of these shots are of the Packard plant.
That means that companies like Google and UA-cam can reach the same fate also.Sylicon Valley can wind up like Detroit, also.
San Francisco is starting to fall bad. Tech companies coming to Texas, other red states. Sadly, in the future, those places will end up the same as well 😔
@@coolfool2100 Tesla just moved its engineering dept from Texas back to California. Tech talent mostly in California. I doubt your prediction...
@@kinkiesse7736 I sure hope so. I want those companies out of my state
@@coolfool2100 Why...? You know Texas State gov is fighting hard to bring those companies to the state to bring high paying jobs. The future is tech...I sure hope you're aware of that. ..
@@kinkiesse7736 cause I don’t want California social values imposed on my state by the people who flock here. Duh
Excellent presentation.
America going into a decline. America is on her death bed. Once young and vibrant. Full of ambition. Hope. Dreams. Dedication. Now gone fraile. The days of a man giving his word as a promise is all but gone.
Thanks for watching.
Sorry to have to admit that you are right.
Would've been nice to have street and location of these buildings! I've seen these some of them but not all ppl are from Detroit!
I'm not from Detroit also.
Thanks for watching.
Very well done and nicely thought out. Detroit went from the stove making center in the 19th century to the car producing center in the 20th century and created a fairly good life for those employed in the auto industry. Maybe, you wouldn't get rich but at least you had a shot at fulfilling the American Dream---work hard, save a little,maybe get a house, and provide a good future for your kids. The dangers of a "one industry" economy.
Good grief. You Karens ALWAYS have such foresight. Pfft
Basically typical American Blue City now....
Thanks for watching.
Is there a societal collapse happening? Yes, I think so.
I feel the same...
No,just things moved...Detroit once and today in other part of world...
☹️ Well done!
Sometimes reality is twice as spooky as the scariest ghost story ever told. Think of all those jobs and families POOF there gone.
Born in 1955 things have changed a lot not only the structures and things that I have seen but the people yes the people their beliefs and thoughts are a lot different from back in the days when I was young?
Yes they are.
Thanks for watching.
What a disastrous change this city has had
Thanks for watching!
Never say Detroit isn't eco friendly!
Thanks for watching.
Love your work and this is coming from someone whose great grandparents were living in the city 150 years ago 👍
Thanks for watching.
Very cool!
Such beautiful homes, buildings, a vibrant city; what a shame it has become.
This is a great video! I love stuff like this. I know approximately where these places are/were but it would be great to include addresses or a map or something to show more specifically where they were located.
Sad. So much built up only to be destroyed. People need more respect for their community. It's sickening.
wow, thanks NAFTA & globalisation
u think america could win WW2 if it were like this ?