I first heard this song live in a theatre concert by Renaissance, which led directly into "Ashes Are Burning", as on the album. Very surreal experience - Annie's vocalization was much more vibrant in person. John's concert piano parts are recognizable, as they are Debussy's "The Engulfed Cathedral", also on Tomita's album.
Renaissance practically created the chick Celtic genre. This was released in 1972 and it's easy to picture Tony Banks listening to it with a smile on his face.
@@lemming9984 let's start at 2:35, If you're saying that's not the progenitor of female Celtic music as a genre, you're arguing for the sake of arguing. I'm sticking to my guns on Renaissance being a huge influence in creating that genre. Loreena McKennitt for example is in the age range that would have been influenced by Renaissance. Why don't you call her up and ask her?.
A beautifully moving song from my favorite band. Always pleased when you react to a Renaissance song, JP. Suggest you try "Spare Some Love" and " Bound for Infinity" from their Prologue album. "Midas Man" from the Novella album is a short melodic drama that gets under your skin.
Thanks for making me want to play some Renaissance albums! I've loved them for almost 50 years. I saw them at a local club several years ago and it was such a thrill to finally see Annie Haslam in person. I got to talk to her after the show and she was so nice. (This is the same club where I got to meet Maddy Pryor so it's kind of like hallowed ground to me!)
I forgot how fantastic this is. It's been a long time since I listened to this album, having been really into it during the '80s. It's bringing a tear to my eye because I like this so much. Absolutely wonderful. Thanks for sharing. I'm so glad you like it. This whole album is SO great.
I never had this album, and was unfamiliar with this song, which threatened to drag a little, until Annie came and shook my chakras awake. Apres, all was great, and the ending, bookended well, as you said, and was of a contemporary nature, as opposed to la nature de l'introit. Always room for Renaissance. A newer version of Renaissance can be found in Dead Can Dance, with Lisa Gerrard. They don't do bad songs either.
You think this track is beautiful? You ain't heard anything yet. Ocean Gypsy, Black Flame, Opening Out & Day Of The Dreamer (natural double shot) and the best double shot in all music history, Can You Hear Me? & The Sisters take up all of side 1 of Novella. Renaissance has lots of beautiful songs, so you got a lot of catching up to do.
That voice again! I don't think the band really needed anything more. I think I'll imagine to myself that it's all about Grimsby, since some of my people came from near Grimsby, and got jobs on the lifeboats that had to row out there, instead of head for port when a storm came up. Makes it more "personal" (even though one doesn't have more than a romanticized link to the people going back before 150 years ago, in their now alien worlds we're busy losing touch with.)
It's sort of a forgotten track by the group which is a shame. Yes, the piece is nicely bookended by the Debussy piano piece, "Sunken Cathedral". I think you're hearing a Harmonium in the middle section.
I am a Renaissance fan so I am not happy to be disappointed. I think it was missed opportunity. The lyrics had almost the potential of a song like Rammstein's Ohne Dich or their own, Ashes Burning. I was not pulled in with this one. Yes, Annie's voice is always good but she is capable of more. (Hit like for your reviewing more Renaissance.)
Haven't heard this album in a long time. I'd forgotten how expansive this song is. It's easy to pass it off as a cheap attempt at a prog suite, but it's all so well done that it's hard to complain.
best part is the keyboard intro and outro, which is taken note for note from de bussy ,engulfed cathedral. the rest is twee twaddle and nothing. Think ,the same year joni mitchell released for the roses, with cold blue steel and barangrill! wow ! no comparison. More joni please, Grreat channel btw.
Justin, Judie Tzuke's still on the line but the signal 's fading... She had Annie Haslam's hair and a Voice that could melt hearts. The proggy boys behind her? ...well u decide! Judie 'll show u a sunset that's 4 sure. Just For You JP. Heaven Can Wait.
Minor Renaissance perhaps but still pointing towards the band's excellence in vocals, piano and arrangements but...the piano piece is apparently largely Debussy's 'La Cathedrale Engloutie' and I don't think this is Annie's best vocal performance - unusually for her a couple of notes are pitchy or warbly but that could easily have been solved with a different take. Still magnificent and sets up Ashes are Burning in the way that Horizons does Supper's Ready.
I remember them. I didn't really find the female lead singer's voice exceptional ( subjective opinion only), in an era not far removed from Joan Baez, and Judy Collins.; maybe a bit lacking in richness of tone to my ears.
Annie's voice is perfection
More Renaissance is always welcome!
I first heard this song live in a theatre concert by Renaissance, which led directly into "Ashes Are Burning", as on the album. Very surreal experience - Annie's vocalization was much more vibrant in person. John's concert piano parts are recognizable, as they are Debussy's "The Engulfed Cathedral", also on Tomita's album.
JP and Renaissance: a golden combination
Renaissance practically created the chick Celtic genre. This was released in 1972 and it's easy to picture Tony Banks listening to it with a smile on his face.
...only there's nothing Celtic about Renaissance's music!
@@lemming9984 whatever you say
@@Chuckles.. Examples of Celtic Rock - RunRig and Horslips.
@@lemming9984 let's start at 2:35, If you're saying that's not the progenitor of female Celtic music as a genre, you're arguing for the sake of arguing. I'm sticking to my guns on Renaissance being a huge influence in creating that genre. Loreena McKennitt for example is in the age range that would have been influenced by Renaissance. Why don't you call her up and ask her?.
@@Chuckles.. 💋
Beautiful song and Annie really touches you with her vocals.
A beautifully moving song from my favorite band. Always pleased when you react to a Renaissance song, JP. Suggest you try "Spare Some Love" and " Bound for Infinity" from their Prologue album. "Midas Man" from the Novella album is a short melodic drama that gets under your skin.
A truly beautiful piece. Too often overlooked.
Thanks for making me want to play some Renaissance albums! I've loved them for almost 50 years. I saw them at a local club several years ago and it was such a thrill to finally see Annie Haslam in person. I got to talk to her after the show and she was so nice. (This is the same club where I got to meet Maddy Pryor so it's kind of like hallowed ground to me!)
I forgot how fantastic this is. It's been a long time since I listened to this album, having been really into it during the '80s. It's bringing a tear to my eye because I like this so much. Absolutely wonderful. Thanks for sharing. I'm so glad you like it. This whole album is SO great.
Annie’s voice soothes my soul no matter what kind of day I’m having. Wow!! Lovely!!!
I never had this album, and was unfamiliar with this song, which threatened to drag a little, until Annie came and shook my chakras awake. Apres, all was great, and the ending, bookended well, as you said, and was of a contemporary nature, as opposed to la nature de l'introit. Always room for Renaissance. A newer version of Renaissance can be found in Dead Can Dance, with Lisa Gerrard. They don't do bad songs either.
Beautiful discovery…. I listened to this band now for the first time
You think this track is beautiful? You ain't heard anything yet. Ocean Gypsy, Black Flame, Opening Out & Day Of The Dreamer (natural double shot) and the best double shot in all music history, Can You Hear Me? & The Sisters take up all of side 1 of Novella. Renaissance has lots of beautiful songs, so you got a lot of catching up to do.
Oh, Renaissance! 🥰
One off my favorite track. Thank you
Renaissance, yay 🙂
Wonderful band. The piano intro is a piece by Claude Debussy, if I'm not mistaken.
Yes, "Sunken Cathedral"
Wow. Haven't listened to that in years. Amazing track., beautifully constructed and performed. Thanks, JP.
That voice again! I don't think the band really needed anything more. I think I'll imagine to myself that it's all about Grimsby, since some of my people came from near Grimsby, and got jobs on the lifeboats that had to row out there, instead of head for port when a storm came up. Makes it more "personal" (even though one doesn't have more than a romanticized link to the people going back before 150 years ago, in their now alien worlds we're busy losing touch with.)
It's sort of a forgotten track by the group which is a shame. Yes, the piece is nicely bookended by the Debussy piano piece, "Sunken Cathedral". I think you're hearing a Harmonium in the middle section.
Great to see Renaissance listened to once again.
I am a Renaissance fan so I am not happy to be disappointed. I think it was missed opportunity. The lyrics had almost the potential of a song like Rammstein's Ohne Dich or their own, Ashes Burning. I was not pulled in with this one. Yes, Annie's voice is always good but she is capable of more. (Hit like for your reviewing more Renaissance.)
Haven't heard this album in a long time. I'd forgotten how expansive this song is. It's easy to pass it off as a cheap attempt at a prog suite, but it's all so well done that it's hard to complain.
Loved it. Saw them open for Hacketr-s band in 2011.
It certainly painted a picture. Renaissance one of my new faves along with Spock's, IQ, plus selected Strawbs and Ellesmere.
Great tune, never heard it before. ❤Just love Annie.
best part is the keyboard intro and outro, which is taken note for note from de bussy ,engulfed cathedral. the rest is twee twaddle and nothing. Think ,the same year joni mitchell released for the roses, with cold blue steel and barangrill! wow ! no comparison. More joni please, Grreat channel btw.
Justin, Judie Tzuke's still on the line but the signal 's fading... She had Annie Haslam's hair and a Voice that could melt hearts. The proggy boys behind her? ...well u decide! Judie 'll show u a sunset that's 4 sure. Just For You JP. Heaven Can Wait.
Oh Annie...
Minor Renaissance perhaps but still pointing towards the band's excellence in vocals, piano and arrangements but...the piano piece is apparently largely Debussy's 'La Cathedrale Engloutie' and I don't think this is Annie's best vocal performance - unusually for her a couple of notes are pitchy or warbly but that could easily have been solved with a different take. Still magnificent and sets up Ashes are Burning in the way that Horizons does Supper's Ready.
If you like Renaissance, you may like October Project. Annie Haslam does.
Yes, please react to their song "Bury My Lovely" or "Take Me As I Am". You won't regret either one. Mary Fahl's voice is exceptionally unique.
Not familiar with Renaissance ... the piano didn't do much for me but lyric is evocative and the lady's voice is enormously charming.
* sigh *
Woo-hoo
I remember them. I didn't really find the female lead singer's voice exceptional ( subjective opinion only), in an era not far removed from Joan Baez, and Judy Collins.; maybe a bit lacking in richness of tone to my ears.