You don't understand Maxwell's equations

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 158

  • @alithedazzling
    @alithedazzling  День тому +42

    note: I say 'e' instead of epsilon to describe permittivity because its visually and linguistically easier for my brain to remember English than Greek -- hope you enjoyed the video :)

  • @anas.aldadi
    @anas.aldadi День тому +24

    الله يفتح عليك ويوفقك يادكتور علي, والله فخر لنا كعرب أنه شخص مثلك باحث في ناسا, الله يقويك في طلب العلم وينفع بك وبعلمك.

  • @daringumucio2779
    @daringumucio2779 День тому +34

    I would love for you to do the wave equation video! So helpful to understanding! 🙏

  • @mrcbrcc
    @mrcbrcc День тому +21

    The story about Faraday always resonates with me because he was really just observing things in his lab (metal powder creating field lines on paper) and experimentally reached the right conclusions, without any knowledge of advanced mathematics or physics. Essentially, the opposite of Gauss, who was a great mathematician and reached all the right conclusions purely through calculus, without ever experimenting in a lab. Only many years later were other physicists able to confirm through experiments what Gauss had found through math. Personally, I find Gauss’s story more fascinating. All he used were numbers and logic, and through that, he deduced reality.

  • @evanfanous4235
    @evanfanous4235 10 годин тому +2

    You’ve changed my whole perception about equations now in a better way. Thank you for providing as much detail as possible!

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  7 годин тому

      I'm glad you're seeing the equations in a new light!

  • @chris-tt6yp
    @chris-tt6yp День тому +5

    Your videos explaining engineering formulas intuitively are the best! Please do more of these!!

  • @Delan1994
    @Delan1994 День тому +13

    Thanks for educating us Dr Ali .

  • @wissamd.salman114
    @wissamd.salman114 23 години тому +5

    Really love these videos, you took me back 16 years ago to 2nd year EE at Baghdad Univ. Fields lecturers, also i couldn't agree more with what you said about imaging and understanding simple basic physical concepts, i think it's the beauty of physics to visualise how any system works then to see it represented in maths and like oh that's how it is going.
    Finally i think Richard Feynman once said that you can measure your understanding of an object by your ability to explain it to others. And you know how to break it down and put it all together again in simple and clear way, keep it going.

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  15 годин тому

      Thanks, I'm glad you enjoyed the video! Feynman is a legend!

  • @ergo6450
    @ergo6450 6 годин тому +2

    very good video, thanks for doing it. would like to see a second part going deeper in understanding the electromagnetic waves deriving from the equations.

  • @derekmillar8032
    @derekmillar8032 День тому +4

    As someone who obtained a degree in physics and whose career path took me in a different direction, I am thoroughly enjoying your videos as a rekindling of the youthful passion I seem to still have for these subjects. Thank you!

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  День тому +1

      thats amazing! thank you for leaving this comment, made my day!

  • @MimoriaJW
    @MimoriaJW День тому +9

    This was literally what we did in class today!!!! Please make another video on the wave equations.

  • @exo-580
    @exo-580 19 годин тому +2

    i never understood what the del operator means until i did vector calculus,it is weird and you can easily get lost without a solid background in math but im proud of the way ali the dazzling tries to uncover this mystery to many.thank you for your educative content i usually enjoy,from kenya pursuing chemical engineering✌

  • @fuzailkhan9701
    @fuzailkhan9701 День тому +3

    My name is Hassan and iam from India.
    Although i've studied this topic in the same way as you explained but you are such a good explainer Ali please make videos on more advance topics i will definetly watch all your lectures also i would love to see about your intuition on wave equation.

  • @raviduprasanna6401
    @raviduprasanna6401 День тому +4

    thats crazy finally understood theory i learnt so far just to solve problem. now i see the insight of these equetion , woow
    please continue the playlist .

  • @sarveshrahate86
    @sarveshrahate86 День тому +4

    3 years of Bachelors course I did not understand Electro dynamics.
    I think i might understand now.
    Thanks.

  • @HardwareScience
    @HardwareScience День тому +7

    Yes, videos on optics please

  • @pouet4608
    @pouet4608 21 годину тому +2

    great. i will watch it a few time in loop, then come back to it after working the subject on my side. thank you! yes, a video about the wave equations would be great. thank you for your capsule!

  • @jeffmackey529
    @jeffmackey529 День тому +3

    Good start! Nice to not get bogged down in the math too much! Next run through the integral forms!

  • @Vibe77Guy
    @Vibe77Guy 14 годин тому +2

    According to the majority of the "viral math problem" videos, many people don't even understand implicit notation. Maxwell's equations are way out of their league.

  • @Zephyrr25
    @Zephyrr25 16 годин тому +1

    Thank you, i am studying GeneralPhysics for my Bachelor's, and i have heard about the maxwell equations a lot but didn't really understand them well , this year, we have a course called electromagnetic Theory that will dive deep into these equations , this video helped me understand the basics quite well .

  • @justinkane290
    @justinkane290 День тому +2

    I'm taking E&M right now and these videos are helping so much. All we do is math math math but, you're right I'm not getting an intuition for what's happening behind the curtains. Thanks for taking the the time to make these videos. I would like to see an explanation of the relativistic effects of a moving charge, I understand that the E contracts but the charge carrier drift velocity does not seem to be at relativistic speeds.

    • @euanthomas3423
      @euanthomas3423 19 годин тому

      The magnetic field produced by a moving charge is the relativistic effect of the charge. If you move along with the charge you then detect an electric field and the magnetic field disappears.

  • @charlesprabakar
    @charlesprabakar 16 годин тому +3

    Insightful -- and what I liked the most was the way you explained it with "cause and effect based explanation approach"
    And I will even go to the extent that these are the only two fundamental fields of reality (to be precise QVF) -- and everything else are just manifestations of the DUALITY exhibited by these two fields only.
    Turns out this DUALITY idea is a basis of our QVF sourced TOE, that has been developed by framing fine structure constant (FSC) as Maxwell daemon and hidden variable -- and more specifically by modelling the FSC as the regulator of QVF using our Riemann hypothesis proof called CPT(α,Φ) function -- and so, how about I present our theory to get your constructive feedback?
    First if I may explain our theory by explaining classical reality emerges or gets birthed from quantum reality under our theory
    Simply put
    -- Our CPT(α,Φ) function( aka Riemann hypothesis meta proof) is the measurement scale used by the universe to regulate/correlate the DUALITY existing between the “α governed quantum universe“ and “Φ governed classical universe”, by birthing the space-time of latter from the former again & again, using 5 HIGH-BARS, set by Wightman-Osterwalder-Schrader (the ultimate golden yardstick, as explained in detail in this article).
    www.linkedin.com/pulse/summary-our-firms-10yrs-toe-work-wa-request-world-form-prabakar-k25sc/?trackingId=HMyXjPicQRm4hcSYi3FT2g%3D%3D
    Welcome complementary POVs

  • @redalexandermadero7290
    @redalexandermadero7290 День тому +3

    Wave equation would be amazing, great video!

  • @jaggis4914
    @jaggis4914 16 годин тому +2

    Great explanation! Thanks! I wish there was UA-cam when I was in college!

  • @mcwornex2123
    @mcwornex2123 День тому +2

    Wow !This video is PHENOMENAL !

  • @girish-zc8mw
    @girish-zc8mw День тому +4

    Thank you for finally opening my eyes on how to visualise and inagine these formulae !!!

  • @Delan1994
    @Delan1994 День тому +7

    I really enjoyed this video. You should do more of these lectures. I need the learn more about wave equations and go from Maxwell’s equations

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  День тому +1

      thanks -- i'm thinking about doing more with wave equations next

    • @Delan1994
      @Delan1994 День тому

      @@alithedazzlinghi , Dr Ali how are you doing? I’m 30 years old studying electrical engineering technology at a community college. We have an university that offers a B tech degree. My question is what’s the difference between B tech and B engineering degrees and do I get the experience and knowledge needed in engineering?

  • @Achrononmaster
    @Achrononmaster 20 годин тому +1

    To solve the equations in vacuum it'd be far more efficient to write a single equation for the Faraday bivector _F_ then all four equations are in just this one: ☐F = J. (The geometric Clifford product on ☐ and _F_ ). In the spacetime Clifford algebra the ☐ operator has an inverse, so the fields can be found simply from F = ☐^-1 J. What I always felt in awe of is that in inhomogenous media electrical engineering nerds can still solve the equations numerically. Gives me a headache to even think about that programming job, as does the Navier-Stokes.

  • @HitAndMissLab
    @HitAndMissLab 22 години тому +2

    Now you need to explain what Vector potential is.

  • @isuckatthisgame
    @isuckatthisgame День тому +1

    I was literally studying this today and you just dropped the video. I'm a pursuing ICT engineer learning about electromagnetic fields. This helped me immensely. Thank you.

  • @alguemporai3889
    @alguemporai3889 День тому +2

    I'm from Brazil, I started college in electrical engineering three months ago, straight into the 2nd semester, next year I'll be doing the 1st semester, I'm doing very well in derivatives, due to hard work. I wish you all the success, great channel, if you could give me some tips on efficient study methods I would appreciate it

  • @EliasJackson-d5p
    @EliasJackson-d5p День тому +4

    I loved how you broke it down into pieces so that I could really understand the equations

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  День тому +2

      the system is made of its components!! if you don't understand the components you will never understand the system :)))))))

  • @TJBEATSAMV
    @TJBEATSAMV 21 годину тому +2

    Very insightful video ! Thanks !

  • @asastgens
    @asastgens 21 годину тому +3

    Can you please make a video on chain reaction.. It would be very helpful

  • @robtroman7917
    @robtroman7917 День тому +1

    The best explanation of Maxwells equations I’ve ever seen and I’ve seen a lot.

  • @Ncosta1
    @Ncosta1 День тому +1

    Just had this in my EE class. Great explanation and straight to the point. Thanks! 👍

  • @sylvesterjonas9141
    @sylvesterjonas9141 23 години тому +1

    I am inspired by your achievement as an engineer at NASA. wow.

  • @mrslave41
    @mrslave41 День тому +1

    you are an amazing teacher. maybe you can actually solve problems using these equations. so we get a better feel for them.

  • @EEShyama
    @EEShyama 4 години тому +1

    Great video Ali!!

  • @anantasadiankhan
    @anantasadiankhan День тому +3

    Great video again, would love to see a video on computational engineering

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  15 годин тому +1

      that's a great idea!

    • @anantasadiankhan
      @anantasadiankhan 15 годин тому +1

      @@alithedazzling Hey man thanks for the reply I am looking forward to your video as computational engineering is a career me and a lot my friends are considering and it is essential in a wide range of engineering and natural science disciplines.

  • @eheh5873
    @eheh5873 17 годин тому +3

    i am intrigued

  • @qaisalfarei4578
    @qaisalfarei4578 45 хвилин тому

    Thank you so much Dr. Ali for the great explanation of Maxwell’s equations.
    A note from a mathematical fact, in a function y=f(x), the cause is the independent variable x and its corresponding effect is the value y, unlike what you said.

  • @dang-x3n0t1ct
    @dang-x3n0t1ct 22 години тому +3

    Can youtube educators stop naming their titles like this, it really hurts my self esteem 😥

  • @sohamdutta4381
    @sohamdutta4381 День тому +2

    Yes please make a video on waves !!!

  • @saeedsobhani1981
    @saeedsobhani1981 День тому +2

    I’m really curious to understand how electric field, magnetic field and photons interact in quantum scales

  • @Flaystray
    @Flaystray День тому +2

    We understand the intuition just fine. What we will never know is how to solve the fucking things

  • @IamKudos
    @IamKudos День тому +2

    Maxwells equations to waves, yes!!!

  • @EmmanuelMatabaro
    @EmmanuelMatabaro День тому +2

    I'm waiting the next video of the relationship between Maxwell equations and waves

  • @woled5318
    @woled5318 День тому +2

    Great video! It was fun learning this from mechanical engineering point of view

  • @shinymew1213
    @shinymew1213 День тому +1

    I want to say thanks because your videos revolutionized the way i saw physics. instead of seeing it as rules that dictate the universe you familiarized it in a way that made me think of it in a cause and effect logic sort of way. It feels more physical to me now, not as mystical and I think I'm even more interested in physics than i previously was. all the cause effect logic I use in basically every other subject can be used in physics. any logical process or synthetization patter can be applied to physics to deepen my understanding of the world and the models we have for it. Thank you so much. I'm doing so much better and learning so much more from my physics class because of these videos. you also have a lot of good advice for engineering in general. I love your channel.

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  День тому

      thats amazing!! this is exactly why I made this video, very happy to hear it delivered the result!

  • @gustavodelgadillo7758
    @gustavodelgadillo7758 День тому +1

    Superb explanation, would love to see the wave equation explained at this same accessibility and quality

  • @Fallen-kv7zh
    @Fallen-kv7zh День тому +1

    i'm still in 10th standard , so i'm still pretty new to maxwell's equations. seeing this video, i feel, i have a more deeper understanding, that will be further supported by deeper reading and understanding. the video was simple and easy to understand, thanks!

  • @afrateam6241
    @afrateam6241 День тому +2

    Just Make more contents like this , teach your knowledge in this way.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @Yah2x
    @Yah2x День тому +2

    Great video! Would love to see more!

  • @BhaveshKumar-07
    @BhaveshKumar-07 День тому

    Thanks for clearfying the Physics Doubt ❤

  • @afrateam6241
    @afrateam6241 День тому +2

    Those moments of aha in your video doctor Ali wich blown my mind: equation is function.
    "+" notation acts like or gate.

  • @ruanholtzhausen4000
    @ruanholtzhausen4000 17 годин тому +2

    As a 15y old, yes I don't understamd these equations.

  • @434mp
    @434mp 11 годин тому +2

    You're right, I don't

  • @ChasSimpson
    @ChasSimpson День тому +2

    Great explanation! Thanks❤

  • @Govi-fu1ti
    @Govi-fu1ti День тому +2

    Thankyou very much for great content ❤❤❤

  • @jamesperdue8558
    @jamesperdue8558 14 годин тому +1

    Question: What do you think a student can do independently to learn concepts deeply and intuitively like this?
    I'm in electromagnetics right now and I love learning this way. But my professor is just a "solve the problems" type guy and our textbook is really really obtuse, even for a textbook. It's turning a subject I was looking forward to and expected to love into something I dread.
    As always, love the content and thanks for everything. I'm a junior EE and have been watching you since the start. I've been struggling lately and I always find your videos encouraging.

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  13 годин тому

      watch as many youtube videos about the topic and try to see diffferetn angles

  • @ruslan8820
    @ruslan8820 7 годин тому +2

    as usual, amazing content!

  • @primoanimation
    @primoanimation 7 годин тому +2

    Why EM waves once they meet with otjer EM waves, they follow their path and dont create new EM fields?

  • @achyuthansanal
    @achyuthansanal День тому +1

    Wonderful vid, man. Thanks for the simple, intuitive explanation.

  • @soundlikemagic
    @soundlikemagic 18 годин тому +2

    I saw the component of the equation describing speed of light in the last equation , what does that mean ? i.e m0E0 i.e product of permeability and permeativity of free space.

  • @ReyAmv
    @ReyAmv День тому +3

    Good explanation keep at it bro 👏🏻

  • @shardeepeters3949
    @shardeepeters3949 День тому +1

    Please continue with the wave equation. I'm curious how it all comes together.

  • @johnlongo6587
    @johnlongo6587 День тому +3

    Please talk about wave equation in a separate video!!

    • @Alex-mh4lt
      @Alex-mh4lt 11 годин тому

      Yeah I'd love to see it

  • @sharfaneaxmed4317
    @sharfaneaxmed4317 14 годин тому +1

    As a guy who is struggling electromagnetic wave course i would like the next video will be wave

  • @dihydrogenmonoxide6748
    @dihydrogenmonoxide6748 День тому +2

    I would appreciate a video on the wave equation thing

  • @kriswillems5661
    @kriswillems5661 День тому +1

    I like the integral notations. I think they are way more intuitive.

  • @transparentworld4093
    @transparentworld4093 День тому +2

    Thank you Dr Ali.

  • @rwharrington87
    @rwharrington87 День тому

    Welp, you just gave me the motivation to plow through the last 10 calculus 3 lectures that introduce vector fields and curl. Thanks!

  • @vrangarajan605
    @vrangarajan605 День тому +1

    Wonderful explanation !!

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  День тому

      glad you enjoyed it!

    • @vrangarajan605
      @vrangarajan605 День тому

      Looking forward to a video on Electromagnetic waves and why they travel

  • @EmmanuelMatabaro
    @EmmanuelMatabaro День тому +1

    Thanks for your service 👏👏

  • @RRajashekar-fp7vh
    @RRajashekar-fp7vh 40 хвилин тому

    The wave equation too is welcome

  • @sumitmandal3901
    @sumitmandal3901 День тому +1

    Dr Ali. Thank you so much. Please make a video on Wave equation. Not mathy , but concepty.. Like you make, intuitive type. Thanks in advance.

  • @AhmedIsmail-z4i
    @AhmedIsmail-z4i День тому

    As always , sensational , keep going eng. Ali

  • @ososonaso
    @ososonaso День тому +2

    Thanks Ali for such an amazing way of delivering knowledge!

  • @arefalimohammadi
    @arefalimohammadi День тому

    Thank you so much dear Dr.Ali for your brilliant explaining.
    I never understood Maxwell's equations , just solved math stuff

  • @bhargavpotdar3771
    @bhargavpotdar3771 День тому +1

    turns out....i DO understand maxwells equations.....glad i didnt learn anything wrong or half right.........also pls make a video on wave equation derived from this

  • @ruslan8820
    @ruslan8820 7 годин тому +1

    Ali, I started learning C++, can u make video about it, what u thoughts and advises, who started from scratches learning C

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  7 годин тому +1

      very cool -- syntax a bit tough but once you get the hang of it its a great language

    • @ruslan8820
      @ruslan8820 7 годин тому

      @@alithedazzling ok) thank u

  • @kelvintichana5169
    @kelvintichana5169 День тому

    Love these videos! Wish I watched it while I was still in school

  • @skiu_skiu
    @skiu_skiu День тому

    Great video as usual Dr Ali; I had one question. As a first year EE major I was had a question about 12:28. To my understanding changing electric fields are described as AC current. Knowing this, would there then be moments in time with no magnetic field? How does this, if at all, effect communications or any piece of electronics you are creating? This video was super helpful by the way, thank you!

  • @colin7035
    @colin7035 День тому

    Amazing video! I have a chemical engineering degree but still try to learn equations on a deeper level! Please maybe a video on matrixes? I know what rows and columns are but like how to understand them like you explained in the video.

  • @buruhtempatan3360
    @buruhtempatan3360 День тому +1

    wish you can explain mechanical stuff like dynamics,thermo etc also :(

  • @katiatzo
    @katiatzo День тому +1

    Thank you!

  • @haideralikhan5947
    @haideralikhan5947 День тому

    You are a very good teacher

  • @mrslave41
    @mrslave41 День тому +1

    why did you say that the magnetic and electric waves induce each other? you can just say that they are independent of each other. what's the difference?

  • @tobiahbower1951
    @tobiahbower1951 День тому +1

    amazing video, please derive the wave equation from 3 and 4 !!

  • @Styggson
    @Styggson День тому

    I fscking love the way you educate. keep it up!

  • @falcommaster
    @falcommaster 3 години тому

    Hi, I’m 17, I live in the Netherlands, and I’m having trouble choosing between Electrical Engineering(2), Applied Physics(1), Biomedical Engineering(3), and Chemical Engineering(4) So i want to know what Is the best option in the Netherlands? (the numbers mean how high it is on my list)

  • @kevinlaverge2769
    @kevinlaverge2769 День тому

    Can you make a video of all maxwell 20 equations. Certainly these of the scalar component and mechanica stress vector of the scalar component? Please?

    • @alithedazzling
      @alithedazzling  День тому

      man, maxwell simplified it to 4 exactly so I don't have to do that haha

  • @dadoubidou7251
    @dadoubidou7251 День тому

    Thanks that was a great video. You inspired me trying to use this cause-conséquence view or équation. Havé a great day

  • @thiagovieira9377
    @thiagovieira9377 День тому

    8:25 you can conclude another thing too. You know that you cant have a magnetic monopole, but you have magnetic objects that have one part as the north and other as the south.... how can you have an object that is a source and a "sink" ... with the magnetic field going out and coming back to the material, so the field lines are closed. At the same way you can conclude for the electro case that the lines are open.

  • @NameAhmad182
    @NameAhmad182 День тому

    Ali can you make a video explaining the meaning of integral equations cause i really don t know it's meaning i only know the soloving part
    Like in / f(x) dx why dx not dy or not dx÷dy

  • @TheOne-jq4lf
    @TheOne-jq4lf День тому +1

    Do a video about wave equation pls

  • @konstantinoskonstantinidis1945

    do they hold per point, ie the faraday law describes the change of the magnetic field at a point A equals the curl of the electric field at A?

  • @ayoubaitouaaziz9177
    @ayoubaitouaaziz9177 День тому +1

    best teatcher

  • @SafiaBegam-f5b
    @SafiaBegam-f5b 18 годин тому

    U look so much like our head boy from 2yrs back