Should you upgrade from Gaggia Classic Pro to Profitec Go

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 111

  • @michaelschenker8326
    @michaelschenker8326 Рік тому +38

    Just to clarify your video about the Go being a resource hog, before steaming you do indeed have to do two 5-second purges, but these purges are NOT done through the group, they are done through the steam wand. I use a pyrex measuring cup for this and once the water cools off I pour it back in the water tank. So bottom line, it doesn’t waste excess water and it doesn’t require you to empty your drip tray more often. I also upgraded from a Gaggia Classic Pro and I’m very happy with my decision, mostly because I can now drink lighter roast coffees (which I prefer) with confidence that they are being brewed at a higher temperature. There are also several programming features that I believe make this machine more pleasurable to use. And then there are the aesthetics, which of course are subjective, but I find the Go to be a more robust, more industrial and generally better looking machine than the Classic. Is it worth 2x the price? It’s still under $1,000. To me, definitely yes.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +4

      I told my wife about conserving the water out from steaming wand, she'll probably start doing it.

    • @kenroman777
      @kenroman777 Рік тому

      Where in your thoughts would you think the 5 second purges are through the group head?

    • @michaelschenker8326
      @michaelschenker8326 Рік тому +1

      @@kenroman777 I didn't think they were through the group. My understanding is that they are done through the steam wand. The video above suggested they were done through the group.

    • @seesaw7289
      @seesaw7289 Рік тому

      I appreciate your honest review and agree with you. Blind tastes with a Lamarzocco confirmed the GCP (9 bar spring, shower screen mod) taste quality.

    • @mannyr8795
      @mannyr8795 11 місяців тому

      So when do you need to purge. Every time before steaming????

  • @CoffeeAndSmoke23
    @CoffeeAndSmoke23 Рік тому +10

    I love the logical conclusion you've come to between these machines..In my experiences I've found that the biggest upgrade one could make is from single boiler vibratory pump,to a dual boiler rotary pump..The rotary pump delivers much better and consistent pressures..Coffee is so subjective and if you are a person that primarily uses the same med/dark roast beans or even the same bean period or if you primarily drink milk based drinks,then you're probably going to find that you're getting diminishing returns after spending so much more on a machine or even a grinder..
    I think that most people who fall into the category I listed would do fine with a Gaggia Classic Pro and a Smart Grinder Pro or Rancilio Rocky etc..But like I stated above,there does seem to be a significant difference between a single boiler vibratory pump machine and a dual boiler rotary pump machine..Even a heat exchanger machine is an upgrade..

    • @BikeuntilDead7
      @BikeuntilDead7 8 місяців тому

      Best coffee comment ever hands down! Italian/American espresso machine tech of 26 years approved lmao 🎉

  • @ThatOneGuy71069
    @ThatOneGuy71069 Рік тому +16

    I have it and has been the best upgrade imaginable from the classic pro. Light roast coffee comes through so much more clear! PID and pressure adjustment are HUGE quality of life upgrades. I get that not everybody will use them or understand how those small changes can have a major impact on the flavor and mouthfeel of your shots so they feel. Stepping into a completely metal water path and brass boiler with the features mentioned already and you cant find anything in this price range that even remotely compares. At this price point its hard to compete and the classic pro is not even playing the same game.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      Glad you liked it, yes with fancy beans this will definitely bring characters out from them.

    • @threehanded8853
      @threehanded8853 Рік тому

      This Modified Gaggia Classic Pro plays a better game than the Go, Daily Cortado Workflow
      ua-cam.com/video/val-K-Z_YCM/v-deo.html

  • @ponderingnugget
    @ponderingnugget Рік тому +7

    What a very honest and informative review. Thank you.

  • @timgerber5563
    @timgerber5563 Рік тому +6

    I think how much you will be able to enjoy the benefits of this machine depends upon how often you switch beans and want to dial them in to your taste preferences or play around with different style shots.
    If you generally are already in a good temperature range, don’t struggle with channeling and are able to pull decent shots (which also largely depends on the grinder you have), you will not see a huge increase in shot quality. However, if you struggle with channeling and shots are overly sour or bitter even though you‘re able to produce a shot according to recipe, dialing down pressure will decrease channeling and having more certainty about temperature will give you more control over shot quality.
    Still, I agree that temperature is really a lower ranked factor for me as well. I have a group thermometer on my E61 machine and also I don’t taste much of a difference as long as the temperature is not sub 88 or above 95 degrees centigrade.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +2

      Completely agree on the actual needs of individuals

  • @danielnadar75
    @danielnadar75 Місяць тому +2

    Thank you for the your honest opinion! This really helps firm my decision of buying a Gaggia Classic Pro to begin my pro-grade journey!

  • @lenso010
    @lenso010 Рік тому +2

    I upgraded my Gaggia to Ikea Thermometer to watch temp , steam wand single hole tip and 155c steam control from shadeofcoffee , 3D ABS lower drip tray from local print studio,, 9 bar spring from online seller. It is amazing now.

  • @LifestyleLab_
    @LifestyleLab_ Рік тому +5

    This is a pretty specific “review” from your limited use case.
    Implying that brewing pressure and temperature don’t impact taste is misleading to say the least. A larger boiler will take far longer to heat up, this this not surprising. Water usage on the GO is not more than any other single boiler. Purging a steam arm does not fill up a drip tray. Workflow on the GO is much faster than on a Gaggia…
    I’m just a little confused by the information you’re putting out to perspective buyers.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      Thank you for your input, yes this is indeed a "personal opinion video" based on specific usage pattern of our household, if someone else is somehow in the same shoe as me, upgrading to this machine had not improved neither the speed nor taste of espresso drinks for us.

  • @nbrikha
    @nbrikha 7 місяців тому +1

    The PID, the gauge, the OPV adjustment are all very nice features that, I agree, probably aren't that useful. For me, the selling point is the boiler size. Going from 100ml to 400ml means more pressure and for longer than my GCP. After the OPV upgrade to my GCP, keeping the boiler full at the time of steaming is a pain in my ass and I don't feel like dealing with it anymore.

  • @ItsMeJeki
    @ItsMeJeki 2 роки тому +4

    after long deliberation and going back and forth to what machine to get, I decided to go with the Rancilio Pro X BUT thanks so much for all the info you provided for us.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  2 роки тому

      I wanted to return this unit for a Pro X but customer service just ignored my return request and now I"m pass the return date...

    • @ItsMeJeki
      @ItsMeJeki 2 роки тому

      @@TheGizmoGarage ouch. I'm sure that you can still get the best out of this machine. ☺️ You have already invested on it and were able to make great shots. ☺️

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      @@ItsMeJeki Couple hundred shots later, no complain about shot quality :) Enjoy your Pro X

  • @yilinzhang3997
    @yilinzhang3997 3 місяці тому

    The most rational video about espresso machine I have ever seen. Thank you!

  • @danieldougan269
    @danieldougan269 10 місяців тому

    A PID is great, but I am not much of a tinkerer when it comes to espresso. I just want it to work normally out of the box...9 bars of pressure and an appropriate temperature every time. Set it and forget it.
    The new Evo Pro brews at 9 bars out of the box, so you don't have to mod it and risk voiding your warranty. I am not sure about the temperature since there’s no PID, but A) it's much cheaper than the Profitec Go and B) you can always add a PID later if you want to and still come out ahead in terms of cost.
    The Profitec Go looks like an excellent machine, but the price is a bit steep by comparison. If it were $700 instead of $1000, it might be worth it.

  • @paulmurphy6523
    @paulmurphy6523 Рік тому +4

    As a beginner and looking for my first espresso machine, the Profitec Go seems appealing.
    Reasons:
    1. Profitec build quality reputation.
    2. If I can set the temp and know that the pressure is correct, then it would be down to me dialing in my coffee. In this way, I could have some consistency with my shots. I understand that there are other variables.
    Thoughts on that? Are there other important factors I'm not considering or am I overstating those values as compared to the Gaggia?
    Thanks for any comments you can lend me!

    • @andrejnaumovski8622
      @andrejnaumovski8622 Рік тому +1

      You're not overstating them at all. I have the Go since October last year and the build quality is just sublime. The PID temperature control is also key for me as I often try out different coffee with different roasts and having consistent temperature and pressure, as well as the built in shot timer which I use basically every time I brew coffee.

    • @paulmurphy6523
      @paulmurphy6523 Рік тому +2

      @@andrejnaumovski8622 Thank you so much! I just got my PG and a Sette 270 grinder the other day and was dialing in yesterday. This was my first ever attempt at making my own espresso and i made a mess, lol. I finally got an OK shot. This morning, I had to adjust one more time and then I got a really nice shot and I was so excited and relieved that I could pull it off. I steamed some milk (working on that too), but made a terrific latte! I was all smiles this morning! Cheers!

    • @calangolima
      @calangolima Рік тому

      @@paulmurphy6523 did the first shot very sour? Or bitter?

    • @paulmurphy6523
      @paulmurphy6523 Рік тому

      @@calangolima First shot was bitter. I adjusted to a courser grind. Then went back and forth till I got it dialed in. I'm making consistently great shots now.
      On another note .... I just for the first time did a cleaning and it made a HUGE difference. Before, I was flushing after each shot, but the portafilter and the screen and group head area still needed a good cleaning. I was getting a bit of an unpleasant off flavor in the past two weeks, kinda sour-ish. I thought that I was not frothing my milk to a high enough temp. and it wasn't getting sweet. Turns out that cleaning was my problem. Huge difference. I'm going to do a cleaning each weekend now ... very easy to do.

  • @davethetaswegian
    @davethetaswegian Рік тому +1

    Thanks for the update, I have a Gaggia Classic Pro with a few mods but, I had been looking at the Go with a some envy. Looks like I will stick with the Gaggia, that little aluminium boiler, with a couple of powerful heating elements strapped to the side, is hard to beat for heat up time and transition to steaming.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      Better upgrade would probably be a dual boiler, unless you like playing with lighter roasting beans.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому

      @@ia9676 15 min for 2 cups of latte a day :) We have it on a timer so when we wake up it starts to pre-heat.

  • @hugemess
    @hugemess Рік тому +2

    Just wanted to say thank you for your videos. I recently bought a new machine and was choosing between the Sylvia, Bezzera Hobby and Profitech Go. I had been using a Gaggia Baby Twin for over 10 years and since I pulled uniformly great shots all this time I would probably never have upgraded. But a few weeks ago it died on me and I live in Brazil so hard to get repaired/parts. Anyway I did go with the Profitech Go and your videos were really helpful to get a feel of the machine and decide whether it was for me. It's a great machine and I'm sorry you sound disappointed in this video - hope you get a lot of good use out of it anyway.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      Enjoy your machine, it is very capable, just doesn't suit our busy lifestyle with just one beans.

    • @philipurquiza5184
      @philipurquiza5184 Рік тому

      Same thing as me, I also live in Brazil and got a Profitec Go, I'm pretty satisfied with the purchase.

    • @hugemess
      @hugemess Рік тому +1

      @@philipurquiza5184 yes me too, I brought mine back from Germany end Oct and I am very pleased indeed so far - especially since with the tax rebate I ended up paying quite a bit less than what they're selling the Gaggia Classic for here in Brazil ;-) I imagine there aren't too many Profitec Go's in Brazil yet...

    • @calangolima
      @calangolima Рік тому

      Oi Hugo? Como você comprou uma profitec go no brazil? Comprei uma, mas fora e trouxe

    • @calangolima
      @calangolima Рік тому +1

      @@hugemess eu vi aqui, desculpe. Eu ia comprar uma
      Silvia v2, mas desisti. Preferi compra a profitec mesmo. O preço da silvia seria ainda maior. O Brasil é um caso sério… haha!

  • @ziplepingouin1186
    @ziplepingouin1186 Рік тому +1

    ....interesting review, after the honeymoon period.... XD .... Appreciate the honesty! ;-) So basically, what you're saying is buy whatever good quality coffee machine is on sale, use good coffee and grinder.... experiment a bit and you'll get great coffee.... no need to get into the "equipment rabbit hole".... Thanks for the review!

  • @IchigoSpaz
    @IchigoSpaz Рік тому +1

    This helped, thanks! I'll stick with my Gaggia.

  • @Runnerdude84
    @Runnerdude84 Рік тому +2

    Have you had any performance issues with the GO (as far as things not working properly or service related)? I think I'm going to go with the GO over the GCP. I'm sure either would work fine, but I like the thought that as I get more experienced at my espresso making that the GO will be able to grow with me better than the Gaggia. Your input is appreciated.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      No performance issue with Go as of today, dead reliable.

  • @thecomicsarereal
    @thecomicsarereal Місяць тому

    My friend, your use case is extremely narrow: “I only use one kind of coffee bean ever.” Then yes, of course the profiteC PID is useless to you because you don’t need pro level adjustments. The PID is meant for prosumers who want to dry different types of roasts every day or week and need more control to limit variables and achieve dialed in consistency. There are very few people that are going to buy an E61 format brewer to just prepare the same bag of beans from Costco for eternity.

  • @yttean98
    @yttean98 10 місяців тому +1

    If you surf the YT you will find there is chap who owned a Profitec he was not happy with it and downgraded to Gaggia Pro. Now he is happy with is Gaggia Pro. End of story.

  • @sskoczzsskoczz4150
    @sskoczzsskoczz4150 Рік тому

    Thank you for sharing your honest thoughts! I’m a sage berista express owner considering upgrading. If I would only know will coffee taste better?😅

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому

      That's very subjective and really depending's on a lot of factors: roast level/freshness, grinder quality, grinding size. For us... No our shots tasted the same between Gaggia and Profitec, but from a entry level automatic machine to manual espresso machines, I'd say you will in general elevate the espresso taste due to the fact they use proper size portafilters.

  • @MarshaSharkey
    @MarshaSharkey Місяць тому

    Haggis classic produces richer fuller coffee flavor. I’ve only had the profited pro 2 weeks. Still a learning curve. Good machine but not better so far

  • @LumiLunar
    @LumiLunar Рік тому

    Can you not sell the Profitec Go back and buy the Gaggia Classic Pro? The Profitec costs more. Unless you’re worried about selling it at a loss but it should be more than enough to buy the Classic Pro again.
    It’s only been a few months so I don’t think you’ll be selling it for much of a loss.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому

      Selling will definitely lose money, it makes great shots just takes bit longer so best option for us is to just keep till next upgrade

  • @DarkKnight-yc8nw
    @DarkKnight-yc8nw Рік тому

    Thank you very much for making my life easier

  • @sykskysyk
    @sykskysyk Рік тому +1

    Do you notice a bend in the middle bottom of the machine? I think there's a design flaw with how the drip tray shell attaches to the body of the main unit. It's built like a toaster using formed sheet metal, so the weight from the front of the unit is torquing against the somewhat thin metal that the tray shell is screwed into.

    • @NativeNewYorker66
      @NativeNewYorker66 Рік тому

      What exactly is happening to your Profitec Go? Have you contacted Profitec or your reseller? I have one and noticed that when I put the Portafilter in and turn it, the top of the machine kind of twists as if the metal cabinet might not be thick/strong enough. I had a Rancilio Silvia v2 prior to upgrading and it was built like a tank.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      My gaggia classic pro also twists, I think it's just the design of the espresso machines in general.

    • @sykskysyk
      @sykskysyk Рік тому +1

      I ended up going through two units with severely bent sheet metal on the drip tray attachment points. Third unit was ordered from a different vendor and didn't have the same issue. There may have been damage from shipping. I notice the portafilter mount is not completely level, but functionally the machine has been fine for a few months.

  • @EastbayGolfer
    @EastbayGolfer 2 роки тому +2

    No, only a double boiler will give the consistency. The heat exhange machine and is better for pulling a lot of shots but temperature stability is not a good as dual boiler.
    Gaggia pro will deliver the same results as the Go. Look at the Profitec Pro 300.

  • @tomhunter91
    @tomhunter91 Рік тому

    Upgraded from a 10 year old baby gaggia and love it

  • @mr_knight4701
    @mr_knight4701 Рік тому

    in your opinion classic evo pro is very nice upgrade and its better to buy it?
    and if you want choose best entry level machine between this machines, which of them is?
    gaggia classic evo pro
    rancilio silvia v6
    bezzera new hoby
    beville bambino plus
    ecm casa v

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому

      Evo pro without much thinking it’s easy convenient and affordable. Bambino looks nice and I would probably bought it for office desk if my work doesn’t have free coffee

  • @davidchiu1296
    @davidchiu1296 Рік тому

    I understand you say the Gaggia takes 3-4mins to warm up. How long does the profitec go actually take?

    • @hugemess
      @hugemess Рік тому +1

      just tested and mine took 7.5 mins.

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому

      At least 7 min in warm weather, probably longer in colder weather.

  • @ChristopherMichaelR
    @ChristopherMichaelR Рік тому

    Personally I think it is only worth it it to upgrade to the Go if you're experimenting with lots of different coffees. Having the ability to change opv on the fly and temperature will be perfect for light roasts/single origins. If you drink the same coffee bean every single day just stick to the gaggia classic.

  • @shayaanimran3522
    @shayaanimran3522 Рік тому

    I currently have a sage/breville barista express and I’m thinking the upgrade.. which machine would you recommend?

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому

      Both will be great. If you want simplicity, get the Gaggia, if you are a espresso snob and fancy better build quality and more temperature stability for more consistent espresso shots, get the Profitec Go (or spend more and get a dual boiler setup)

  • @snapphanen
    @snapphanen Рік тому

    I'm looking to buy the profitec go. Already have niche grinder but no machine (still on moka pot). I'm looking for an option that will last me 7 or 10 years. Does this machine have potential? Does it feel sturdy enough?

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      It has potential, but my drip tray on this machine fall apart only after a few months... Internals seems to be durable and all parts are easily replaceable so yes, it does have potential to last 7-10 years with proper care.

  • @JosephPostorino
    @JosephPostorino 11 місяців тому

    Hey! I just got a Go and saw your previous video about upgrades you were doing to the machine right away. You mention at the beginning of the video that you reverted back to some of the stock items but I was curious which specific upgrades you reverted back on and why? I know this is a year old video but hoping you see this. Thanks!

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  11 місяців тому

      I switched between the stock shower plate and the IMS, and also found the stock Profitec Go double basket makes consistent shots. Kept the silicon ring on there vs the stock rubber one.

  • @scooterv
    @scooterv Рік тому

    In the video you seem you seem to be saying upgrading the gasket and shower screen did not improve performance but did they make it worse? Why did you go back to the OEM parts?

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +2

      Gasket helped putting in portafilter easier, shower screen didn't make a difference, I put them back in my drawer, may pull them out and put on the machine at a later time. Shower screen do look nice though.

  • @TheBattlemaster007
    @TheBattlemaster007 Рік тому

    Would you say if the Profitec was out when you got the Gaggia would you have still bought the Gaggia?

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      Yes I probably would bought Gaggia based on our needs: we are not picky about timing or grinding we just want to drink our latte and go to work 😅

  • @jstones9872
    @jstones9872 Рік тому

    why not just go with a superauto machine?

  • @outdoorsman8498
    @outdoorsman8498 Рік тому +1

    Thank-you

  • @JKTF476
    @JKTF476 Рік тому

    I would like to see the cost of the pro compared to a gaggia upgraded to the same specs

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому +1

      Upgrades requires drilling and modifications... Probably around $200-300 difference. The Pro is pretty much perfect from get go without fancy upgrades.

  • @stdnt3463
    @stdnt3463 2 роки тому

    Have you updated you Gaggia? Or just use it as it is from a shop?

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  2 роки тому

      Use as-is with no OPV/PID or any other upgrades, still loving it as is though.

  • @XCRunner88
    @XCRunner88 2 роки тому

    Does it not heat up fast enough between shots? Or does it not heat up fast enough initially?

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  2 роки тому

      Recovery is very quick between shots. It takes longer to heat-up during initial start up. We usually have it on Alexa controlled outlet so first thing when we wake up is to have it turned on to heat up. But with Gaggia, we just turn it up when we ready to make the shots, and it's ready usually in less than 3 min.

  • @sAmiZZle82
    @sAmiZZle82 Рік тому

    Well said. To me this machine is overpriced for what it offers. With the Profitec you pay for the name and build quality. But you don't see that in the cup. This leaves it in no-man's-land between a Gaggia and a Lelit MaraX. The latter which upgrades you up to an HX machine with flow control and can be had for only a little bit more money than the Profitec.

    • @Lunaorbit82
      @Lunaorbit82 7 місяців тому

      Not a little bit where I’m from. The Lelit Mara is $3800 NZD the Profitec Go is $2000 NZD. They produce exactly the same shots. Steaming is better on the Mara and it has a hot water dispenser. It would probably do better at 3+ back to back milk drinks. Go has better build quality, an accurate PID with timer and heats up in 30% of the time. The Mara is simply not worth the extra $. For me it’s the Profitec Go or just all out for a Bianca.

  • @domodoeslife4741
    @domodoeslife4741 Рік тому

    Can you comment on temperature surfing on the GCP, that seems to be one of the main complaints?

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому

      When we had GCP never noticed any difference in taste, although we were mostly drinking Latte made using the espresso shots instead of drinking straight shots.

  • @gipht1
    @gipht1 Рік тому

    Any suggestions on coffee grinder for the gaggia? I was looking in the eureka mignonette note price range - thanks
    !

    • @precisionsoundworksstudio
      @precisionsoundworksstudio Рік тому +1

      I was told that the Eureka Mignon Facile is a nice grinder.

    • @Runnerdude84
      @Runnerdude84 Рік тому +1

      Look at the Turin PF64E- It's just for espresso and is an awesome single dose grinder

  • @outdoorsman8498
    @outdoorsman8498 Рік тому

    Does the gaggia classic pro take way longer to heat up like 18 min vs 5 min

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому

      No, gaggia classic pro heats up to ready to brew in less than 4 min.

    • @outdoorsman8498
      @outdoorsman8498 Рік тому

      @lireviews is it harder to keep consistent temp with the gaggia, I hear people say the pid is nice for consistency between brews

  • @felipegarcia05189
    @felipegarcia05189 Рік тому

    Thanks

  • @publicname515
    @publicname515 Рік тому

    How do you dispense hot water for an Americano?

    • @TheGizmoGarage
      @TheGizmoGarage  Рік тому

      You press brew button without a portafilter attached while putting a cup under brew head

  • @davidcarlin3850
    @davidcarlin3850 17 днів тому

    Get the New Move product

  • @bobyahatovich
    @bobyahatovich Рік тому +1

    Thank you for saving me $1000 🎉🎉🎉