Ten 'MUST HAVE' Prog Albums | My REAL Favourites!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
  • Become a Patreon! / andyedwards
    Or if Patreon is not for you you can make a donation: paypal.me/Andy...
    More links you might find interesting:
    Listen to my music here: andyedwards.ba...
    Instagram: / andyedwardsdrumlessons
    My UA-cam Drum Channel: / channel
    Andy's Fusion Spotify Playlist: open.spotify.c...
    Andy's Prog Spotify Playlist: open.spotify.c...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 489

  • @Funky_Ghost
    @Funky_Ghost 3 місяці тому +23

    Camel - The Snow Goose was the seed that grew into a lot of prog bands that followed. Any list of Prog must haves MUST have Camel in it.

    • @autismguy2060
      @autismguy2060 2 місяці тому +5

      Agreed, camel is Underrated even in the prog community

    • @kirkhunter146
      @kirkhunter146 2 місяці тому

      because he thinks Latimer is not too good.

    • @wahid-lg1kk
      @wahid-lg1kk 2 місяці тому +1

      ​​@@kirkhunter146He isn't, can't stand Camel, it's derivitive and boring.

    • @lukaf2393
      @lukaf2393 Місяць тому +1

      @@wahid-lg1kk Derivative???? They influenced tons of band that came after them...

    • @wahid-lg1kk
      @wahid-lg1kk Місяць тому

      @@lukaf2393 making them derivative in the second degree

  • @ks4545
    @ks4545 3 місяці тому +7

    I love this channel and I literally can't stand most of the music Andy talks about. Lord knows I've tried, just can't do it. Still, the music history is really interesting and Andy is so damn entertaining.

    • @yellowjackboots2624
      @yellowjackboots2624 Місяць тому

      Same. A friend of mine keeps recommending songs by Zappa, Holdsworth etc. I politely listen to them all the way through, only to have my utter dislike of jazz rock/fusion reinforced 😄

    • @BillDean-hk4cj
      @BillDean-hk4cj Місяць тому +1

      Agree absolutely

  • @Soundbrigade
    @Soundbrigade 3 місяці тому +7

    My list is rather short …
    King Crimson - in the court
    Renaissance - Ashes are burning
    Moody Blues - Question of balance
    PFM - The world became the world
    Banco - Darwin
    Jethro Tull - Aqualung
    Pink Floyd - Atom heart mother

  • @brucehazen8982
    @brucehazen8982 3 місяці тому +4

    Greg Lake stated once that Trilogy was their most representative album.
    Brain Salad Surgery, in part due to its' savvy sequencing, still blows my mind though. My #1

  • @lkeslinke
    @lkeslinke 3 місяці тому +14

    My Top Ten but Only One From Each Artist:
    1) Porcupine Tree: Fear of the Black Planet.
    2) Steven Wilson: Hand.Cannot.Erase.
    3) Yes: Close to the Edge.
    4) Genesis: The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway.
    5) King Crimson: In the Court of the Crimson King.
    6) Jethro Tull: Thick as a Brick.
    7) Pink Floyd: Dark Side of the Moon.
    8) Traffic: The Low Spark of a High Heeled Boys.
    9) ELP: ELP.
    10) Riverside: Love Fear and the Time Machine.

    • @dt6949
      @dt6949 3 місяці тому +1

      Great list! 👍🏻

    • @Hiwatt100W1
      @Hiwatt100W1 3 місяці тому +1

      Really good list...I had the good fortune of seeing Genesis (with Peter Gabriel) perform The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway- I remember that as being one of the three best concerts that I've ever seen. The second was Pink Floyd performing the Dark Side of the Moon. The third was interestingly enough, Roxy Music- early. I think it was Country Life that they were supporting. This period, IMHO, was rock as a highly developed art form. Early Tull was also incredible- This Was, Stand Up, and Benefit were tremendous albums as well. My choice for Traffic was John Barelycorn, Winwood's songwriting is absolutely brilliant. Have to check out Porcupine Tree, don't know their music very well. Early Soft Machine also was brilliant- especially their work with Kevin Ayers.

    • @lkeslinke
      @lkeslinke 3 місяці тому +1

      @Magicmatty2024
      We all have opinion’s but just google search that Traffic Album under Wikipedia!
      See what they call that Traffic Album?

    • @Scottlp2
      @Scottlp2 3 місяці тому

      Good list (of the 6 I know-gotta check out the other 4). Personally I have a soft spot for “Wish you Were Here” : “did you trade a walk in part in a war, for a lead role in a cage”

    • @jeffhubbard9951
      @jeffhubbard9951 3 місяці тому

      God, I SO disagree with you about Yes. First off, I simply could never accept that the greatest Yes album wasn't a Bruford era work. And, although choosing between the Yes Album, Fragile, and Close is pretty painful, ultimately, I HAS to be Close, as it's so clearly their most virtuosic album, while also containing their most memorable extended compositions. It's the album that best defines Yes' music, and is as good an exemplar of what prog is all about as any. I really wonder why you deny it that distinction each time out?

  • @arvidsson56
    @arvidsson56 3 місяці тому +7

    When talking about Yes you hinted that Rick Wakeman was less serious than the rest of the band.
    His books "Grumpy Old Rockstar" and "Further Adventures of a Grumpy Old Rockstar" are hilarious and well worth a read.

  • @corleth84
    @corleth84 3 місяці тому +28

    I'm with you on 'Trilogy'

    • @kratino
      @kratino 3 місяці тому

      🤠😁🥰

    • @robertglisson6319
      @robertglisson6319 3 місяці тому +2

      So refreshing for someone to lead off their favorites with Emerson, Lake and Palmer.

    • @SPY1964-LL
      @SPY1964-LL 5 днів тому

      Agreed. Trilogy is classy. No BJ songs etc. That was so lame....embarrassing.

  • @Saffy-yr8vo
    @Saffy-yr8vo 3 місяці тому +4

    The writing and keys Keith Emerson creates in Endless Enigma is other worldly. You can’t describe it. I’ve prob said it before here somewhere and getting forgetful so prob will again, it always makes me cry with pure emotion. He really knows how to do that. Plus everything else. I assume you’ve seen the vid of him composing it live in his big barn that got burned down on you tube? Yes of course you have, pure magic.

  • @neilparks2651
    @neilparks2651 3 місяці тому +2

    Trilogy, my first ELP purchase - the infectious brilliance of The Endless Enigma grabs me as much now as it did when I first heard it in '79.

  • @cirenosnor5768
    @cirenosnor5768 3 місяці тому +6

    Trick Of The Tail is my favorite Genesis record. Sounds like Gabriel era to me and a less demanding, easier listen

  • @johnandrew6030
    @johnandrew6030 6 днів тому

    I love the bit when you are talking about Yes and the number of LPs you got through before finding Awaken. I used to listen to the Alan Freeman Saturday rock show every Saturday and ended up buying lots of great Todd Rundgren albums before finding the live version of Just One Victory on Another Live. By then I was sold on Todd.
    God bless Fluff.

  • @PHILBUSHMASTER
    @PHILBUSHMASTER 2 місяці тому +4

    Fripp Exposure has so many guys on it Peter Gabriel, Terry Roche Vocal, Fripp produced The ROCHES hit debut album, folk, a cappella and a little Fripptronics.

    • @TheAxel65
      @TheAxel65 9 днів тому

      Don't forget Peter Hammill ☝

  • @caramanico1
    @caramanico1 2 місяці тому +1

    Somebody finally recognized Trilogy! A fantastic but never before mentioned album. It's Number One with me. The multiple shot inside cover is cool. Going For The One - same comments. Awaken is their greatet epic IMHO. I always thought that Discipline was easily the best of that trilogy. For me, ELP triple live album is an all time keeper no matter what. Yes's 9012Live is excellent.

  • @CarwynGravell
    @CarwynGravell 3 місяці тому +1

    Great choices Andy - especially Trilogy, Going for the One and Trick of the Tail - I'm pleased you mentioned it as being one of IQ's favourites as I always thought the interplay between the Martin and Mike on keyboards and guitar at their soaring best was reminiscent of the playing on this album. In fact I think I remember IQ covering Robbery, Assault and Battery on a bootleg I had of them in early 80s. Joyful stuff.

  • @daicullinane7746
    @daicullinane7746 3 місяці тому +6

    It's Dave's party and he'll cry if he wants to.

  • @zootallures6470
    @zootallures6470 3 місяці тому +8

    If you want to hear the real Dave Stewart you can listen to _National Health - Dreams Wide Awake._ The guy is from another planet.
    _Santana - Caravanserai_ is on my list.

    • @zachjohnson637
      @zachjohnson637 3 місяці тому +1

      Of Queues and Cures is in my Top 10 albums of all time (as is Bruford's One of a Kind).

    • @zootallures6470
      @zootallures6470 3 місяці тому

      @@zachjohnson637 👍 Stewart is playing on both.
      He is the most underrated musician since the first bushman started to hit two sticks together.

    • @BlueBlazer47
      @BlueBlazer47 3 місяці тому

      Glad to see Santana's prog credentials recognized.

    • @zootallures6470
      @zootallures6470 3 місяці тому +1

      @@BlueBlazer47 Unfortunately only Caravanserai and Love Devotion Surrender are prog… Let’s add even Swing of Delight.
      I’ve read a biography about Santana. In the 70s-80s he would have his clashes with CBS because he wanted to make music like this but they wanted the Latino stuff which was selling.

    • @BlueBlazer47
      @BlueBlazer47 3 місяці тому

      @@zootallures6470: Welcome too, I'd say. There are still prog elements on albums like Abraxas, even on Supernatural. I didn't know there was pressure on Carlos to be commercial. It's a pity labels do that.

  • @CountBrass
    @CountBrass 3 місяці тому +1

    Great topic. Mine would look like this:
    Yes, The Yes Album
    ELP, s/t
    Gentle Giant, Free Hand
    Colosseum, The Valentyne Suite
    King Crimson, Discipline
    Genesis, A Trick of the Tail
    Chris Squire, Fish Out of Water
    Spock’s Beard, V
    Glass Hammer, The Inconsolable Secret
    Porcupine Tree, Lightbulb Sun

  • @mikeb3268
    @mikeb3268 3 місяці тому +4

    How the f*ck could you go so long without listening to Trick of the Tale?? That’s some achievement.

  • @Sennrsup
    @Sennrsup Місяць тому

    Parallels was one of my faves as a kid.

  • @smalltown2223
    @smalltown2223 3 місяці тому

    You’re absolutely bang on about Going For the One. I’ve listened to so much Yes I don’t play it anymore, but after this episode I’m going to listen to Awaken. That piece hypnotised me as a lad and still gives me goosebumps.

  • @pabzum
    @pabzum 2 місяці тому

    «Look at that cover. That’s not going to have “Awake” in it, IS IT?»
    HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

  • @thomasrichmond2413
    @thomasrichmond2413 2 місяці тому

    One of the reasons I, ( we ) love prog is the musicianship: how do these guys pull this music off live? And, therefore, my favorite albums are live:
    Welcome back my friends ( Aquatarkus )
    Yessongs ( Perpetual Change )
    Seconds Out. ( Cinema Show )
    But my favorite, hands down, is 801 live with the best cover of any tune in history. TNK

  • @ginonave8564
    @ginonave8564 Місяць тому

    I have to agree with trick of the tail. Over time, I think their best work is the post-Gabriel pre-80s shlock stuff. Dare I say …and then there were three… is my favorite.

  • @stewarttiley9683
    @stewarttiley9683 3 місяці тому +11

    Mike Oldfield episode please!?! Ommadawn is his masterpiece. Incantations! And the rarely mentioned Simon Philips epic drum solo on Crises!!! And what a guitarist!

    • @patbarr1351
      @patbarr1351 3 місяці тому +1

      Yes, those changing drum textures on *Crises* are quite a thing!

    • @DrOz-007
      @DrOz-007 3 місяці тому +2

      And Simon Philips' drumming on Discovery too! The whole album I think.

    • @chucklogan3133
      @chucklogan3133 3 місяці тому +1

      ​@@DrOz-007 For one of his most "pop" sounding albums, it's amazing how good Discovery is! Each song is so carefully crafted.

  • @timgittar
    @timgittar 3 місяці тому +1

    I never felt a connection with ‘Farewell to Kings’. My favourite Rush album has always been ‘Permanent Waves’. I feel affectionate towards it because it was the first album of theirs I heard. I had no idea music like that was possible!
    I thought side one of ‘Hemispheres’ was boring. Side two was AMAZING! That’s probably my favourite era of Rush’s work: 78-80.

    • @webbvandiver9139
      @webbvandiver9139 3 місяці тому +1

      Being a huge American Rush fan, who loves every record from FBN to GuP, FTK has always been in my top 3-4 and I stamp it as their most British sounding record. Of course I know it’s first record they recorded in the UK…but it really has that pastoral UK prog rock feel throughout…however Cygnus X-1 is in its own universe…space prog/metal?…no connection to a British sound (whatever that may be in my ears). 🤘🏻

    • @webbvandiver9139
      @webbvandiver9139 3 місяці тому +1

      And…agree with you Permanent Waves is always in my top 1-2 Rush releases. I alternate b/w PWaves, Moving Pictures and maybe surprisingly, Signals as top of the mtn.

  • @JoyDivision88
    @JoyDivision88 3 місяці тому +1

    Went to see Kevin Coyne one evening and Hatfield and The North were supporting that night. I sort of enjoyed them without being blown away as I had really gone to see KC. But something must have got to me that evening as a little while afterwards I went and bought The Rotters Club. That was 50 years ago. It is one of my all time favourite albums and they are also one of my favourite all time bands.

  • @adamodimattia
    @adamodimattia Місяць тому

    I know all the stories behind Topographic Oceans and all the critiques. But it is my favourite Yes album. It used to be Close to the Edge, but when I got older it was replaced by Topographic, which was one of my least favorite albums when I was younger :)

  • @bfaulk
    @bfaulk 2 місяці тому

    Fantastic video (and also screamingly funny!)

  • @geospot4679
    @geospot4679 2 місяці тому

    I bought Angels Egg aged 17 or whatever because the cover looked like it might be a good listen with a smoke. To this day I can't believe my luck.

  • @tableface77
    @tableface77 3 місяці тому

    Trick of the Tail has remained in my top three Genesis albums. Interchangeable with Selling England and the Lamb for top spot

  • @Tony-be4tl
    @Tony-be4tl 3 місяці тому +2

    Nursery Cryme is the pinnacle of progressive rock music. Amen

  • @Patrick-sheen
    @Patrick-sheen 3 місяці тому

    A highly informative video. I love Beat and that whole era, badly need to check out that Fripp album. Need to add Trick of the Tail to my collection also. Been addicted to Gong since discovering them here.

  • @grahamnunn8998
    @grahamnunn8998 3 місяці тому

    Picked up a secondhand copy of Rotter's Club in Burgess Hill Market in the early 80s. Life changing, in particular Richard Sinclair's vocals and Dave Stewart's keyboards.
    Dave Stewart writes for Sound on Sound (his articles have made me laugh for years) and does a lot of arranging. I love that he is still with Barbara Gaskin, the ultimate prog couple.

  • @Saffy-yr8vo
    @Saffy-yr8vo 3 місяці тому

    Andy have you seen the vid on by a youngish lad titled ‘Why Keith Emerson was Important?’ I haven't watched it for a while but remember thinking his content on him was great. Hope it’s still there.

  • @WorseReviews
    @WorseReviews 2 місяці тому

    Here's my list!
    Yes - Fragile (1971)
    Yes - The Yes Album (1971)
    Pink Floyd - Obscured by Clouds (1972)
    Yes - Close to the Edge (1972)
    Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here (1975)
    Rush - Caress of Steel (1975)
    Rush - Fly By Night (1975)
    Rush - 2112 (1976)
    Pink Floyd - The Wall (1979)
    Rush - Moving Pictures (1981)

  • @psychicdriver4229
    @psychicdriver4229 3 місяці тому

    Talking
    Heads showed crimson the way into the eighties... It's been a while since I've heard that frip solo album, but you really inspired me to put it on.😅

  • @James-hd4ms
    @James-hd4ms 3 місяці тому

    A “must have” prog album? Never thought I’d hear that.

  • @ronbo11
    @ronbo11 3 місяці тому

    "Dirty Rock Beggar" sounds like a concept album that Jethro Tull might have done back in the day! I get the title track confused with The Kinks' "Rock and Roll Cities" in my mind's ear just for the vocal rhythm and the way they roll off the tongue.

  • @MODAC
    @MODAC 3 місяці тому +1

    What about Renaissance???

  • @johndrx165
    @johndrx165 3 місяці тому

    Trilogy is amazing! Just got into Gong this year and missing 2 of the Trilogy. I like the live Genesis album w/ Peter. Got Farewell to Kings on LP. Great list!

  • @TheGlssr60
    @TheGlssr60 3 місяці тому

    "Going For The One" is my favorite Yes album and I've got them all. "Turn of the Century" is possibly my favorite song of all time, I guess because I'm a bit of a romantic. But "Wondrous Stories" is the song that got me into Yes. I heard it on the radio and I was "I have to have this." At that time there was no Google. So I was calling the local rock radio station trying to find out what album it was from. They didn't know. So, I saw "Tales From Topographic Oceans" in the store and although WS wasn't listed I thought "Tales" "Stories" there's gotta be a connection. There wasn't. But there was no returns back then so I listened to TFTO over and over. And as I may have mentioned before, I was able to help JA with the lyrics on "Ritual" when I saw him solo some years ago. I was really glad to see you list this album even if we don't entirely agree on the tracks. One more thing: I don't think the title track fits with the rest of the album. Similarly to how "Hold On Tight" doesn't fit with the rest of the vastly underrated "Time" album by Electric Light Orchestra.

  • @vissersvet
    @vissersvet 3 місяці тому

    As an album, CttE is the best, imo. But I couldn't agree more that the best Yes track, and arguably the best progrock track /ever/, is indeed 'Awaken'. Yes yes yes yes YESSSS!!! Must have listened to it a couple of hundred times now, past 47 years, made love on it once with my sweetest sweetheart -- it's just out of this world. Thanks a bunch for this video!

  • @stevesmith3990
    @stevesmith3990 3 місяці тому +2

    Yes, Awaken is the greatest.😊

  • @derekbiggerstaff
    @derekbiggerstaff 3 місяці тому

    Do You Like It Here Now, Are You Settling In?-Man
    Best prog. album!

  • @willemmoller6736
    @willemmoller6736 3 місяці тому +1

    Trilogy is my fave ELP album too

  • @ewenchalmers8658
    @ewenchalmers8658 Місяць тому

    A cinema show would be interesting, and, for giggles, see if you can poach one of Pardo's minions, Davy Gallagher from North Upon North England. He's very knowledgable and entertaining.

  • @ethanhitchcock5431
    @ethanhitchcock5431 3 місяці тому

    King Crimson DISCIPLINE !

  • @edgarbaumann6002
    @edgarbaumann6002 3 місяці тому

    Another great video!

  • @JonnyDee123
    @JonnyDee123 3 місяці тому

    Re inside sleeve of GFTO. Look at them there. Yes. A great bunch of lads.

  • @chanjurban
    @chanjurban 3 місяці тому

    Gather round kids, it's story time with Andy!

  • @AndrzejFornal-b6h
    @AndrzejFornal-b6h 2 місяці тому

    A The Strawbs,BJH,Fruupp,Renaissance,Egg,Magna Carta,Art Bears,Spring,Raw Material,Tonton Macoute,Affinity,Arcadium,Pavlov's Dog!?

  • @user-mad7max11dystopia
    @user-mad7max11dystopia 3 місяці тому

    All Rush albums had ancient lyrics that were indeed written by prog scribes and then beamed down to Sir Peart and translated from ancient tongues by Ayn Rand so that we may know of the Panacea and understand the caress of steel the king felt when Bastille Day got its start. But to be in a small city in the shadow of the Great Smoky Mountains and to witness the 2112 album complete with the accompanying backstory the size of an IMAX screen was definitely a wonderful reason to share Colombian Gold with a few thousand of your equally stoned new found friends as we all discovered music while Alex tuned his guitar. But he actually didn’t because that was missing from the set list for some reason. Check the All the Worlds A Stage live album and it’s not there either.

  • @chaosme1ster
    @chaosme1ster 3 місяці тому

    Amazing… if I'd made such a list, it would have (almost) been 1-on-1 identical. No bickering about irrelevant details. Even Fripp's Exposure… And yes, "Awaken" is the ultimate prog track indeed. At times it still can bring tears to my eyes. Check out Jon's rendition with Todmodile (Iceland). Somehow his voice is even better than on the original… a bit of a rough edge that came with age probably.

    • @chaosme1ster
      @chaosme1ster 3 місяці тому

      I just realised: only thing *really* missing is a Van Der Graaf record. Not sure if I can forgive you… I'll give it some thought :).

  • @pattardn
    @pattardn 3 місяці тому

    The Hatfield's "Mumps" is probably my fave of all in all.

  • @patbarr1351
    @patbarr1351 3 місяці тому

    OK, God bless Andy and his love for Yes' "Awaken," although it normally puts me to sleep (maybe time for a revisit?). For me, the greatest '70's-era progressive music track is "Down By the Sea" on The Strawbs' *Bursting at the Seams.* (Something about those weeping widows clutching their shawls as the ocean crashes around them.) I agree that Genesis' *A Trick of the Tail* is magic; maybe it's the fate of that poor squonk!

    • @richardsinger01
      @richardsinger01 3 місяці тому

      You can't sleep to Awaken! It's not exactly ambient.

  • @koszim
    @koszim 3 місяці тому

    My Top Ten...
    1 Dark side of the moon-Pink Floyd
    2 Wish you were here-Pink Floyd
    3 Power and the passion-Eloy
    4 Animals-Pink Floyd
    5 Dawn-Eloy
    6 Up The Downstair-Porcupine tree
    7 Mirage-Camel
    8 You all look the same to me-Archive
    9 Floating-Eloy
    10 Breathless-Camel

  • @kzustang
    @kzustang 3 місяці тому +1

    ELP Trilogy is the best of the ELPs. The cover is not great but it's my favorite album by them. Don't worry about it. You're alright.

  • @ianwhite6812
    @ianwhite6812 3 місяці тому

    +1 on Trick of the Tail. Big Gabriel era fanboy, and can't listen to Collins era post Duke, but Trick was the first I bought with my own pocket money.

  • @pierrefournier5892
    @pierrefournier5892 3 місяці тому

    Love your picking Exposure by Robert Fripp!

  • @AlmostEthical
    @AlmostEthical 3 місяці тому

    I enjoy a lot of those albums and many mentioned by others. Some probably consider Crime of the Century to poppy, but it's a desert island disc for me. Other "neglected" pieces of utter brilliance:
    Focus's - Hamburger Concerto ... predominantly instrumental works don't tend to cut through for many. My highlight: title track
    Manfred Mann's Solar Fire ... prog rock with strong classic rock musicianship ... maybe not flash enough for some. My highlight: Father of Day, Father of Night
    Steve Hillage's Motivation Radio ... yes, he's a quirky new age kinda guy, but the music ... My highlight: Radio
    Gong's Shamal ... always in the shadow of Pot head Pixie's and Pierre's fusion, but it doesn't deserve to be. My highlight: Cat in Clark's Shoes or Chandra

  • @AndrzejFornal-b6h
    @AndrzejFornal-b6h 2 місяці тому

    Mam je wszystkie na winylu!

  • @jeffreytaylor6257
    @jeffreytaylor6257 3 місяці тому

    GFTO is one of the great guitar albums if its time.
    JT

  • @Leo_ofRedKeep
    @Leo_ofRedKeep 3 місяці тому

    Are we getting a "10 must hate prog albums" next?

  • @marlachristensen2076
    @marlachristensen2076 3 місяці тому

    Oh, it is YOU again!

  • @joetodaro4183
    @joetodaro4183 3 місяці тому

    Yes terrific album despite the "Knights who say Ni" cover.

  • @richardedwards5310
    @richardedwards5310 3 місяці тому

    Amazon has 2 of those Zappa Sampler LPs for $25.

  • @SuSaNa_PT
    @SuSaNa_PT 3 місяці тому

    A vídeo of your guilty pleasures would be fun

    • @grahamnunn8998
      @grahamnunn8998 3 місяці тому

      and probably banned straight away!

  • @jandenbrok9574
    @jandenbrok9574 3 місяці тому +1

    I was hoping for your favourite Jethro Tull album.

    • @AndyEdwardsDrummer
      @AndyEdwardsDrummer  3 місяці тому

      Stand Up or Songs from the Wood...If I had them on vinyl then I would. My copy of Stand Up is on cassette and in my shed somewhere!

    • @jandenbrok9574
      @jandenbrok9574 3 місяці тому

      Thank you, Andy. JT is my favourite after Yes and Zappa, but their best album? My candidates: Aqualung, Benefit, Minstrel in the Gallery, War Child, Songs from the Wood, and Heavy Horses. All wonderful!

  • @claytonchaney9171
    @claytonchaney9171 3 місяці тому

    love Gong

    • @claytonchaney9171
      @claytonchaney9171 3 місяці тому

      Just found out that I am a year older than you are....I discovered these through older brothers of friends....we were not around when it went down....after the fact....regognize.....

  • @henrywest7217
    @henrywest7217 3 місяці тому

    So you're a movie buff as well? Interesting. I'll keep that in mind for future comments.

  • @RicardoRMartinelli
    @RicardoRMartinelli 3 місяці тому

    before the tube I did 18 shows that were broadcast in brazilian national television channel 2

  • @TheSoundpoet
    @TheSoundpoet 3 місяці тому

    Hi Andy, what are your thoughts on the Safety by Numbers album by Crack the Sky? Nuclear Apathy is one of my favorite progressive rock songs of all time.

  • @Coolmore362
    @Coolmore362 3 місяці тому +1

    The first Genesis album I bought was Trick of the Tail , the 1st Yes album I bought was Going for the one , I was only a teenager at the time , Seconds Out the first live album I ever bought and still my favourite live album by any artist . Always a pleasure to hear someone talk about music so passionately even if I’ve not heard some of the music being talked about .

  • @hugogomes7146
    @hugogomes7146 3 місяці тому

    If you start making videos about films i will become a patreon 😂
    nice video!

  • @Chadovarius
    @Chadovarius 3 місяці тому

    19:45 haha don’t forget the “chicken vindaloo, rice pilau, papadums, bhindi bhaji, Bombay aloo, and a paratha” 😂

  • @joegrant413
    @joegrant413 3 місяці тому +1

    You are progressively continuing to get my attention on the prog front ;) BTW, special thx for telling me about Gong.
    Don't know if this merits a top 10 list, but it'd be great to hear your thoughts on the top prog instrumental moments. We could all have unimind peak moment together. Fer instance - the synth beginning of Eleventh Earl of Mar. Or the beginning of the organ solo of Roundabout. For me, it's often synth on classic prog that is the most memorable.

  • @AnthonySella-i7e
    @AnthonySella-i7e 12 днів тому

    what about captain beyond

  • @AndrewjWilson
    @AndrewjWilson 3 місяці тому

    Neil Peart Moustache maybe influenced by Jamie Muir 😊

  • @gokhanaya
    @gokhanaya 3 місяці тому

    (speaking of Dave Stewart) you really need to check out Khan's Space Shanty. If at some point in time you did and was not impressed, pls try again... and again.. and again :) PLUS, surely Steve Hillage's first solo album (which very roughly is the unreleased but mostly already composed second Khan album)

  • @DanielMcGrath1969
    @DanielMcGrath1969 3 місяці тому

    Andy! I've got a shocker for you! I figured that the guy on Classic Album Review was maybe 68 or so.... then a few days ago I thought well he might only be 60...I watched his Zep Mud shark episode and he stated he was a 50-year-old man bringing up teenage daughters! That would make him 5 years younger than us! Is this physically possible? What am I missing? Cigarettes? A fisherman exposed to the elements. Please explain.

    • @AndyEdwardsDrummer
      @AndyEdwardsDrummer  3 місяці тому

      He does look a bit like a weathered fisherman doesn't he. His name is Barry Robinson

    • @DanielMcGrath1969
      @DanielMcGrath1969 3 місяці тому

      If he's 50 I'm 29! What do you of the Vai-Belew reimagining of '80's Crimson?

    • @DanielMcGrath1969
      @DanielMcGrath1969 3 місяці тому

      The jean Tierny episode was quite profound. I've always believed female beauty has always been a biological reality seen through a male's eyes. Fertility is beauty in the evolution of our species. Hourglass figure-round eyes-full lips-etc. I am now 54 and can still see that females are at their full physical flower between 14-22. Just the facts man.

    • @DanielMcGrath1969
      @DanielMcGrath1969 3 місяці тому

      I did some research...The little bald guy Benny Hill used to pat on the head was only 36...While Benny was only gay! Ha!

  • @marlachristensen2076
    @marlachristensen2076 3 місяці тому

    Your fave "Canterberry Rock" is a 'Hatfield and the North' ? Does not compute...

  • @MarkAS56
    @MarkAS56 3 місяці тому

    Where Eagles Dare is awesome

  • @andymedley5458
    @andymedley5458 3 місяці тому

    No Tull?

  • @roberttee9790
    @roberttee9790 3 місяці тому +29

    You tossed Close to the Edge on the floor?
    Blasphemy!
    Fellow YES fans . . .
    WE RIDE AT DAWN!!
    Got worked up
    Haven't watched entire vid yet. 😎

    • @zootallures6470
      @zootallures6470 3 місяці тому

      He tossed it on soft cushions.
      Watch Monty Python - Soft cushions

    • @BlueBlazer47
      @BlueBlazer47 3 місяці тому +2

      @roberttee9790: It's ok, you can redirect your ire to those of us who (marginally) prefer Fragile!😄

    • @michaelirons1609
      @michaelirons1609 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@BlueBlazer47And/or Relayer and Going for the One...

    • @wahid-lg1kk
      @wahid-lg1kk 2 місяці тому +2

      @@BlueBlazer47 Fragile is exactly equal to Close to the Edge

    • @BlueBlazer47
      @BlueBlazer47 2 місяці тому

      @@wahid-lg1kk: Yes, I'd agree overall.

  • @mutant_blues
    @mutant_blues 3 місяці тому +26

    Hatfield and the North debut
    Magma - Mëkanïk Dëstruktïẁ Kömmandöh
    Ange - Le Cimetière des arlequins
    Matching Mole's Little Red Record
    Manfred Mann's Earth Band -Nightingales & Bombers
    Pink Floyd - Atom Heart Mother
    Area debut
    Henry Cow - LegEnd
    Steve Hillage - L
    King Crimson - Red

    • @BlueBlazer47
      @BlueBlazer47 3 місяці тому +1

      Must hear Henry Cow soon. Not only is the name a nice contrast with Blodwyn Pig, but I had an Uncle Henry who looked very like a cow!

    • @noefossati9868
      @noefossati9868 22 дні тому

      AREA AREA AREA - Arbeit macht frei

  • @sciwiz57
    @sciwiz57 2 місяці тому +7

    I have to have “Thick as a Brick” in there - masterpiece

  • @Playthatsolo
    @Playthatsolo 3 місяці тому +5

    I got as far as Gong, paused, went and listened to the Radio Gnome Invisible trilogy for the first time, then listened again, then read and watched everything I could find about this period of Gong, became a huge fan, then returned to this video and watched the rest. Thanks Andy!

  • @eightrodway
    @eightrodway 3 місяці тому +11

    We both love Gong You. Do you also appreciate Fish Rising by Steve Hillage? Fantastic! (I also like Angel's Egg.)

  • @delorangeade
    @delorangeade 3 місяці тому +30

    The importance of Tommy Vance to a generation of UK music listeners cannot be overstated.

    • @lw1zfog
      @lw1zfog 3 місяці тому +2

      ‘ROCK ! ..... with Tommy Vance !!!’

    • @grahamnunn8998
      @grahamnunn8998 3 місяці тому +2

      The listeners top 10 was like a buyer's guide before UA-cam.

    • @sealisa1398
      @sealisa1398 3 місяці тому +1

      Likewise here in NYC was Scott Muni.

    • @BlueBlazer47
      @BlueBlazer47 3 місяці тому +3

      Very true. Tommy really got behind Yes' Drama album, and I recently discovered he was spot-on. It's a brilliant album. He was a champion of prog rock, but also very much other kinds of rock. Gillan was a band he played a lot - they were a kind of punky AND proggy take on the Deep Purple sound. Tommy Vance was also a nice guy. I got through to the show once when he was filling in for Fluff, and we had a great chat which he mentioned after the session. RiP Tommy and Fluff.

    • @delorangeade
      @delorangeade 3 місяці тому +2

      @@BlueBlazer47 The very first Friday Rock Show was a two hour live performance from Yes, which came as a shock to me tuning in for John Peel. Gillan was a band I particularly loved, I've actually been listening to them quite a lot recently. I thought they were the most interesting band to come out of Deep Purple. I still have a box of tapes somewhere with concerts recorded from Tommy Vance's and Fluff's shows.

  • @losendos8963
    @losendos8963 3 місяці тому +9

    A Trick of the Tail was the first Genesis album I ever heard. Genesis became my favorite band and Trick of the Tail, to this day, is my favorite musical album - period....dont even have to ponder..... Love your channel.

  • @markanderson1313
    @markanderson1313 3 місяці тому +10

    Andy ! GENTLE GIANT has to be in that list, come on !

  • @simonhodgetts6530
    @simonhodgetts6530 3 місяці тому +21

    Womblng Songs (1973) is a must have - a concept album about environmentalist furry creatures who lived underground.

    • @adude9882
      @adude9882 3 місяці тому +3

      The Wombles invented jazz.

    • @ModoBro
      @ModoBro 3 місяці тому +6

      Stafford Bingley Hall circa '73. Amazing gig. Orinoco's stage dives were legendary

    • @seethroughhead505
      @seethroughhead505 3 місяці тому

      Have you heard 'The Myths & Legends of Merton Womble and his Journey To The Centre of the Earth'? Think I'm joking? ua-cam.com/video/MXBA2hAj-EU/v-deo.html

    • @BrennanYoung
      @BrennanYoung 3 місяці тому +3

      @@ModoBro they could have been huge. So sad about Wellington's drug problems

    • @paulbrookes413
      @paulbrookes413 3 місяці тому +1

      FISH says he owes everything to MacWomble !

  • @jrtruth1
    @jrtruth1 3 місяці тому +7

    Andy Edwards message to all youtube channels, "video editing is for suckers!!!" Or maybe, just maybe, Andy has a genius way of commenting on how a lot of ProgRock albums meander around in an elliptical manner that eventually drives many people crazy?

  • @peterbadham3080
    @peterbadham3080 3 місяці тому +9

    A mention for Todd Rungren would be nice

    • @julianbarber4708
      @julianbarber4708 2 місяці тому

      A Wizard, A True Star is an epic album!

    • @vordman
      @vordman 25 днів тому

      Yeah, Todd Rungren. His production work on XTC's Skylarking is phenomenal. One of the greatest albums ever imho.

  • @simpleman5688
    @simpleman5688 3 місяці тому +16

    Voyage of the Acolyte.

  • @guidoroemer81
    @guidoroemer81 3 місяці тому +7

    The Rotters' Club is also a novel by Jonathan Coe. It's a beautiful book a sort of coming of age story about a group of friends. At one point in the story the boys taste changes from prog rock to punk. Coe knows a lot about music. It' also very funny.

  • @chrisdelisle3954
    @chrisdelisle3954 3 місяці тому +6

    My favorites (in no particular order)
    1) Rush - A Farewell To Kings
    2) Rush - Hemispheres
    3) Yes - The Yes Album
    4) Yes - Fragile
    5) King Crimson - In The Court of the Crimson King
    6) King Crimson - Red
    7) Genesis - Selling England By The Pound
    8) Genesis - The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway
    9) Pink Floyd - Dark Side Of The Moon
    10) Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here
    I mean, it's not an original list. Not a single deep cut among them. But it's a true list.

    • @vordman
      @vordman 25 днів тому

      Good list, I've got most of those. I'd have found a place for Close To The Edge though 👍

  • @frankpentangeli7945
    @frankpentangeli7945 3 місяці тому +6

    When it comes to prog I'm pretty mainstream. My 10 favourites are:
    King Crimson: In the Court of the Crimson King
    Yes: Fragile
    Genesis: Selling England by the Pound
    Emerson, Lake & Palmer: Trilogy
    Rush: A Farewell to Kings
    Pink Floyd: Wish You Were Here
    The Moody Blues: On the Threshold of a Dream
    Jethro Tull: Thick as a Brick
    Strawbs: Hero and Heroine
    Frank Zappa & The Mothers of Invention: One Size Fits All
    Other prog albums I love:
    Yes: The Yes Album
    Yes: Close to the Edge
    Yes: Relayer
    Genesis: A Trick of the Tail
    Genesis: Wind & Wuthering
    Genesis: The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
    Rush: 2112
    Rush: Hemispheres
    Pink Floyd: Animals
    Pink Floyd: The Dark Side of the Moon
    Pink Floyd: Meddle
    The Moody Blues: Every Good Boy Deserves Favour
    The Moody Blues: A Question of Balance
    The Moody Blues: To Our Children's Children's Children
    Gentle Giant: Three Friends
    Gentle Giant: Octopus
    Gentle Giant: Acquiring the Taste
    Jethro Tull: Aqualung
    Jethro Tull: Songs from the Wood
    Frank Zappa: Apostrophe
    Frank Zappa & The Mothers / Captain Beefheart: Bongo Fury
    Frank Zappa & The Mothers: Over-Nite Sensation
    Strawbs: Nomadness
    Strawbs: From the Witchwood
    Electric Light Orchestra: Face the Music
    Electric Light Orchestra: Eldorado
    Van der Graaf Generator: Godbluff

  • @tomrobinson5776
    @tomrobinson5776 3 місяці тому +6

    Nice to see The Rotters Club on this list. One of my favorite albums of all time. Mumps is a masterpiece. That acapella opening is gorgeous.

  • @magenta6
    @magenta6 3 місяці тому +7

    Interesting Fact: The last 15 seconds of Trilogy was used during the late 70's early 80's as the theme music for NZBC's 6 O'Clock News. Of course most Kiwis have no idea who Emerson Lake and Palmer were.

    • @artboy57
      @artboy57 3 місяці тому

      That's so funny! One of the local news channels in Norfolk,Va. used the last bit from "Living Sin' as their news intro. I forget which years, but was at least '74-'75.