The countries that you mentioned..Cuba, Venezuela, North Korea..those are heavily sanctioned countries. It’s not fair to mention their lack of growth without mentioning the sanctions that are crippling and holding them back.
Very correct. But this video had to do little bit of Western propaganda. In fact it can be argued that ALL socialist countries are very successful countries because despite the crippling and inhumane illegal US regime sanctions they have managed to survive and in many case even do better than the US regime. For example in Cuba the average life expectancy is almost equal to that of the US.
China was once seriosly sanctioned for decades, only because CCP led the country right and made more and more progress that the western countries have to abandon part of the sanctions. Even now China is still being sanctioned by the western countries, the Hight Tech War with US for example.
Their economies would be almost as bad without sanctions. Those countries are built on socialism, which leads to economic failure. Xi Jinping is returning China to the socialist system it had under Mao, and that's one reason it will become another failure like North Korea.
This documentary emphasises democracy as the only way to get ahead. When you have the world's largest population (India) no amount of democracy will be able to educate , feed and find employment for everyone. China got to where it is by planning and implementing and working hard towards a single goal, not by luck. China has been growing at a rapid rate over the last 4 decades and you can't call that " luck."
Agree. My own observation is that so called "China Economic Model" is actually wrong understanding of what China has been doing. China understood their backwardness and limitation and decided to work hard quietly to achieve improvement. China's way is simple. Whichever the system works for China, it would adopt it. Therefore, what they did and have been continue doing is to set reasonable targets, for the whole nation, for the province and even for each department. Everyone is trying to reach such target in time. if there is mistake, it should be immediately recognized and corrected. The important here is the Chinese system has a mechanism to recognize mistakes and apply remedies in a fast manner while the West refuse to admit their own mistakes.
@@twilight6460 Do you realize that Xi Jinping hates the policies of Deng Xiao Ping and is working to eradicate them? He believes in establishing economic policies that allow him to cling to power in the short term even though they will lead to the collapse of the Chinese economy.
One of the reason why China put controls on birth is due to cost of feeding a large population. India seemed strangely 'proud' of their large population. I think India is heading towards a disaster, with the water shortages and food inflations.
He is completely in already except that the Indian government and the West are saying nothing. Not against they have a lot to say about the collapse of China for over 30 years. 😁
The big pollution problem hadn’t solved, in 2019 yr 1,670,000 people died of disease. Grange river is polluted, no fish can survive. Shit and rubbish around hygiene is too bad.
China divides its development strategy into three steps. The first step is to solve the problem of food and clothing for the people; the second step is to bring the people's income to the income level of middle-income countries; the third step is to reach the living standards of developed countries and become a world power. China is now in the stage of moving from the second step to the third step, while India has not yet taken the first step. Therefore, it is unreasonable and unfair to compare India with China. Even Vietnam is one step ahead of India.
You are correct but according to India they are already superpower status. Amongst Indians they think they are ahead of Russia and a peer to China. So basically they think they are somewhere between second and third place.
@@davidmoss2576 All Indians thinks they are already a super power, so do you think the United States will tolerate the rise of another new challenger that is far more arrogant than China? The United States will suppress India more fiercely than it does China.
All se Asian nations will leapfrog india soon. Indonesia Laos Vietnam all have hi speed rail thanks to China. Djibouti Africa will have a space port to launch an African into space thanks to China. Yet India is the "super power" lol
The retreat of Foxcon from India is not a good indication that India will surpass China anytime soon. Labour law and education and training are the biggest problem.
So you know why they retreated? And do you know that they haven't totally scrapped the idea of their presence in India? They don't want to invest in India through a joint venture with Vedanta co. But did you know about all this before typing the comment? I wonder.🙃
@Xinnie_The_Pooh exactly! All they have stated is that they don't want to work with vedanta but want to expand in India on their own. They're bundling massive factories in Hyderabad and Bengaluru right now
actions- u mean bankrupting other poorer countries, not to mention china still heavily relies on america for its exports. not saying usa is a saint either
Corruption and no morale concept of Indians is the main problem of India. An Indian Jayant Bhandari said so. I know nothing about India and has zero interest to compare it with China. I am quoting Jayant because in the comment section of his program, most Indian agree with him and others are person attacking him without any data or evidence to counter his observation. Therefore, I believe what he said must be valid.
Comparing china and india has no meaning. Because india is not a country. It is just an administrative system created by British. Now it is look like federal , democratic but in reality it is not either federal or democratic. But china is really functioning as federal. It is a country with real one ethnic and linguistics population and it is not just an administrative system created by British to loot. There is no need to complete with china. If india really wants to uplift it's people it must accept the reality that is it is not a nation but a federation of many nations. Without this understanding speaking about development is like having a map without "you are here mark "
@elavarasand Good and very factual comment. India cannot hold. It will soon break up into many smaller countries. Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
Funnily enough, that difference has created high competition among states for economic progress and industrialization. Now every state wants better ports, more expressways and higher foreign investments. You will "see" it soon enough. The largest state, the size of Guangdong population, will be nearing 1 Trillion GDP by 2030.
And because America wants the world to believe they are still the Number 1 is the reason with the exchange rate of the dollar. In real terms china is the worldst largest economy and its median per capita income too is on the rise...I bet Science and Technology is the key metric here...No Country has achieved Tier 1 Developed Status except Japan in Asia. Saudi and other Middle East, Singapore and Korea too are categorised as Tier 2 Developed Countries as they lack the Global Appeal and Strength going from Culture to Science and Technology to many more....Japan despite its lack of many mineral resources stands tall in Scientific and Technological Strengths, Cultural Powerhouse and has Military Technologies and has a Good Economic Size. All these factors give Japan and edge..Its Human Resources are very strong..From Olympiads to Olympics to Culture to STEM fields to Humanities research, Japan does it all. Even in Music they are quite good. The Next Best Is China. This was what many were waiting as This,unlike Japan, is a Civilisation and has historically been the Powerful One. China reaching the next stage in scientific and technoligical development along with its Cultural Exports means it has arrived on the Tier 1 Zone. Only Japan, US, Italy, Spain, Germany, UK, France and a few Northern and Souther and Central European states make us Tier 1 Developed Status. Let us not even talk about hese countries social development indicators and entrepreneurial mindsets...Only China came so strong at them. Truly a Hardworking and Persevering Society with a iron grit determination to become the Number 1 in the world. It is Social Psychology after all.
We don't even have the desire to become China, india will become much better than them, okay And Indians have great faith in their hard work and by working hard they will achieve everything they want to do.
The train has already left the station... India is already too late and too little... China has already gone to another level ..India has to compete with Bangladesh ..Pakistan...Vietnam.. Indonesia.. Thailand...Cambodia and Laos ,,Africa and Latin America but unfortunately India's huge population is a liability rather than an asset...India can stop dreaming about competing with China rather than India needs to compete with other emerging markets in Latin America...Africa...ASEAN and Central Asia... Remember China speed 1 year India needs 10 years ... China speed 10 years India needs 100 years...
ASEAN is glad that India did not join RCEP ( a combined population of 2.5. Billions ) , A GDP nominal of USD 28 Billions and GDP PPP of nearly USD 40 Billions , with a nearly 900 Millions middle to high Income population , who needs India we are happy in ASEAN where China , Japan, South Korea, and even Taiwan and Hongkong are trading and investing in RCEP , Trading in RCEP is already reaching usd 1. 35 Trillions per year. ✌️🙏
If the Indians had been half smart they would take pages out of Chinese governance of large (enormous) populations with great cultural diversity, and realise that 'democracy' is a misnomer for countries lacking social justice.
India is the biggest democracy written on a piece of paper only. In reality, India is the biggest Authoritarian Country run by the Corrupted Modi! America will not allow another China competing with them. Don't forget, India is an US Lackey!
@@peanut0brain China is not a lapdog of USA. Yes, now US is trying very hard to contain China but it hasn't been successful thus far. In fact, it has backfired on the US. Of course the war is still ongoing so we'll have to wait and see who will win. However, history has shown that US lapdogs cannot overtake it's master.
@@twilight6460 yes you're right. South Korea lapdog also suffered immensely. Samsung as example followed along the yankee chip war and lost billions in usd sales (to China)
One big significant difference on India and china is about the people's mentality. The Chinese people are very competitive in nature. When ever there is a little opportunity arises the Chinese would grab it to the fullest and improve themselves. That is why many new startups emerged for the past 30 years to take opportunity on the little opening from the government. Meanwhile in India the government need to take the lead in drive the economy while the people would follow from behind. It could not work this way, It is the people who need to take the lead to drive up the economy while the government only provide some facilities to ensure it is happening
@@VanDuc-hm6sp i would not say that if i were you. Indians in Malaysia some are extremely clever. They work as doctors and lawyers but there is a stark difference on their income gap where some extremely rich and the next is extremely poor. There is nothing in the middle
Also, the Chinese would rather earn less or even lose sometimes to keep a long-term customer for years and decades while Indians seem more interested in gaining greater short-term profit even though it will mean losing the customer.
Why is Indian so concerned of China? Not a day we don't see Indians and India media talking about China. But I hardly see Chinese media and Chinese people talk about India. Inferiority complex and jealousy to see China is far ahead of India. These must be the reasonshe problem with Indians.and they are happy with mediocrity. They start feeling proud to have the fastest growing major economy even though the growth only around 6%. China was growing at 12% at its peak. India is now the world’s most populous country and its fifth largest economy. By the end of the decade, it is projected to be the third largest, behind only China and the USA. It has a vast youth population while its GDP growth outstrips other top ten economies. Its geopolitical importance is also growing amid a rapidly changing global order. India now has ambitions to become a global economic superpower. But there are serious question marks. It remains an extremely poor country, with major inequalities from female labor force participation to education. Other issues such as ethnic tensions, democratic decline and environmental damage are fraying the fabric of the Indian Republic. #IndiaEconomy #ChinaEconomy #HumanCapital 🇮🇳🇨🇳 Why can't India be an Economic Superpower like China? Find out the crucial reasons in this eye-opening video! 📊🌍 In this thought-provoking analysis, we delve into the disparities between India and China's economic growth and development. Discover the pivotal role of human capital and gender equality in shaping these nations' destinies
I agree! Only 10% of women work outside of their homes. That means a large percentage of the population is not productive. They also have society issues which are difficult to solve.
@@elliekwong3180 They revered cows a lot more than they do their womenfolk. Once they find a way to uplift cows intellectual and productive ability to the level of women they will begin to progress.
India may someday meet China’s standards but can never surpass China in any way. By the time India has caught up to today’s China, China will eventually be so far ahead again that’s impossible for India to catch up…
@@raymonddon8875 The main reason Chinese people are hard working. When they want to do something that they will compete done it. In Chinese's mind which " time is money " and " time don't wait ". So you must catch the time right away to moving forward.
You have not mentioned the caste equation in India. Majority of influential positions are occupied by the so called higher caste who generally look down upon the vast majority of populace who are lower caste. The coherence in society (among majority hindu population) is fragmented and graded inequalities exist and any attempt to smoothen out that difference is actively discouraged. Almost all the levers of power are controlled by the higher caste who try to agrandise all the power to themselves. Such a situation never existed in china. China was more are less a monolithic country (compared to India), and Modi government did little to smoothen things out. In fact his party has accentuated the differences more and he has exasperated the society further by promoting Hindu vs Muslim, Hindu vs Christian animosity. Indians are always at war (in low key) among themselves, riches are fewer and not distributed evenly. Much of the constituent states of India are several thousand years older than the nation of India, which is the result of colonial rule. This fact has to be recognized and respected. Trying to govern India as an unitary state increase the fissure. Languages, religion, customs, vary between state to state and has to be respected. Formation of United States of India, could help and unitary india may lead to fragmentation.
India keeps saying it's the 5th largest GDP and the 2nd populous. But it's ranking is 127 in the world terms of GDP/capita behind Laos and bankrupt Sri Lanka (107) and many African countries. Please compare India with Sri Lanka or war torn Iraq(115), Lebanon (114).
There are a few roadblocks for India. Some are covered by the video, some are not. The ones that wasn't covered are: 1. many have less tolerance against different castes, religions, ethnics, gender, etc.. which cause bouts of sectarian violence (religious and ethnic) and is one the main factors of instability that lessen global businesses desire to invest much in India; 2. pollution - India is heavily polluted even without heavily industrialization somehow. Although India do have a lot of young people, such pollutions would shorten their lives and increase their medical burdens which then limit their potential in the long term; 3. lack of solid industrial base - which ties into the quality of its infrastructure building as well as quality/reliability of goods coming out of India; 4. same tech bottleneck that China is experiencing in semiconductors. Can India continuously rely on the West for high-tech goods indefinitely? 5. Political red tape & rules of law - being the largest democracy also have its political downsides and without a solid rule of law like most western democracies, rampant corruptions, backward justice system, very slow social improvements, etc. will heavily impede India's prospects in the long term; If Indian can at least mitigate the negatives of these and the ones mentioned in the video to a certain extent (say 50%), then it has a chance to catch up to China in this century.
China seems to have solved the tech bottleneck, as shown by the newest SMIC, YMTC, HiSilicon & Loongson chips. China is no more than 2 or 3 years behind the state of the art, and catching up very fast. This is what happens when you have a huge population that is well educated and highly technical, producing more scientists, technicians, engineers, and mechanics than any other country.
India has problems with all its neighbors. India annexed Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh, Punjab, etc.... Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
@@offred6013 What has Chinese maps got to do with India's incompetence? There are other reasons. Lack of hygiene, disregard for the environment, ultra-nationalism when a large chunk of the population aren't holier-than-thou classes of Hindus. When people don't see anything wrong with consuming cow urine and bathing in cow poo, you know the country won't progress.
If India is to surpass China, it will have to surpass the US as well (assuming China surpasses the US first which has been a certainty to most of economists.). What do you think the US will do to India to hold it back as has done to China?
The US attempted color revolutions in China (1989), supported Muslim terrorists in Xinjiang, attempted color revolution in Hong Kong (2019-2020), and continues to support Tibetan government in exile, along with separatist government in Taiwan province. If we look at the equivalent for India, that would be supporting independent Muslim Jammu, Kashir, & Ladakh; Sikh Khalistan; independent Sikkim; "human rights" for untouchables; and other breakaways along India's borders. The ultimate goal is constant domestic unrest, culminating in another Indian Civil War that allows the US to intervene militarily under a binding UN resolution. Ironically, if broken apart, India would almost certainly do better as a loose Confederation of small states.
India will never surpass China. Not for a thousand years. Unless they tweak the figures and publish fake news on how successful and advance India is; how abt creating an Indian Huawei for a start, assuming India have already built enough public toilets for 1.4 billion ppl?
In that case, US will let India grow. Because, it will be net positive counter to China. And many countries in the democratic camp will sign security agreements with India than US as well.
I think you are very wrong to call Cuba a failure. Cuba has been subjected to draconian sanctions and continous bullying be Anerica for many, many decades and it's a miracle that it still managed to survive!
And on top of that, That small nation with just 10 million population has produced athletic talent like no other. 254 Olympic Medals and counting...Which nation at that per capita has produced that?
Island nation that heavily relies on tourism chose to collectivize all foreign owned companies and kicked out all westerners and adopted communism failed because the west refused to trade with it. Shocker😂
I really like the fact that Westerners and Indians always compare the economy of the mouse to that of the elephant. While there are animals much closer to the mouse, such as the hamster (Pakistan), the marmot (Bangladesh), a rat (Vietnam), a guinea pig (Afghanistan). But no, they compare the incomparable India (the mouse) to the economy of the elephant (China).
India is very big and populous. So it is like a swarm of mice. The mice think the elephant will be scared of it because the mice are so mighty. Actually the elephant just wants to avoid stepping on them because it's an icky feeling.
Elephant is a metaphor used for India but Lets just say China as A Drgaon is unbeatable in many respects...The Only Non Western Civilisation to do so..Besides, Dragons arr Legendary Creatures and not Superpower creatures..
Even they cannot make a toilet properly also the road condition is something you will back in time around 80's. And dont forget indian "tech call support" is no.1 in the world 😂😂😂😅😅
The video creator clearly doesn't understand China's development model. "Authoritarian success" is a Western narrative that sidelines the essential formula for economic success. The reality is, China based their power of collective resolve, policies, and reforms. Their economy is best described as state free market capitalism coupled with socialism in development, it is technically an overall mixed economy which is the fundamental formula for it's dynamic success. China's development model is incomparible to that of other socialist countries. To compare that China will somehow collapse/fail just because other countries did because they're "authoritarian" is absolutely vacuous and flawed at best. Freedom is derivative from it's foundation. For example, if you want to live in a country free of crimes and drugs - you need laws, education, and policies to prevent them from proliferating.
Nope, they will have to reluctantly allow, as with India on its side US gets a heavy strategic advantage over China considering the geography and naval supply lines.
@@anime0965 So you think India can develop while fighting with the world's most powerful industrial country that is China ? China provides countless semifinished parts, raw materials, for India's manufacturing sectors and reasonable priced machinery for their factories. Don't forget, India benefits from US-China, otherwise there is nothing attractive to foreign investments. US, Japan, EU rather put their money in Vietnam, Thailand, and other ASEAN nations.
After reading the comments, I think India needs first a cultural Revolution... or maybe become a loose confederation of different states and then, maybe only then, India can start to compare itself to China xd Also it needs to become a really sovereign state and leave its colonial mindset in the past.
During the Qin Shi Huang period more than 2,000 years ago, China achieved the goal of having cars on the same track and books on the same text. Although it was considered a tyranny at the time, it seems to be correct in the long run. All Chinese people can speak Chinese and understand Chinese characters, which is more convenient. Communication and management, India has too many languages and is too complicated. Each state may have different laws. This has also caused doubts among foreign investors and greatly increased investment costs. They need to understand the laws and labor costs of different states. too high
The simple answer is, unlike China, India does not have a cohesive society after hundreds of years of being a British Colony and the divide-and-rule strategy of the British Empire. LKY explained the reason more than a decade ago in Singapore to an Indian Academic
@@twilight6460 LKY stopped being active before 2010. Your views are outdated. China had just surpassed Japan at that time. Compare it with today's China. India also has made huge structural changes and they will be visible by 2030.
@@twilight6460 have you been to each and every state in INDIA?????????Yes China is developed India is developing and that's it......i see in comment section people saying about pakistan which does not even have proper electricity.....like r this people being serious....do u think a country which has capacity to reach moon is a joke???then keep thinking like bokachoda jotoshob
@@Beingrighteous678check your streets, maybe lift yourself out of poverty corruption and indians that arent doing jackshit but praise the past, then we’ll talk.
@@twilight6460 india is third largest carbon emitter and will soon because second biggest emitter due to massive industrilisation and urbanization and have the second largest number of internet users on earth and biggest data consuming nation if you think underdeveloped country can be a second biggest carbon emitter and biggest data consuming nation than please have your brain check up with the good doctor doctor. India is pharmacy capital. You can come to India and can get a good treatment from India in cheap rates.
Economy and government system is not necessarily the problem, it's leadership. If you don't have great competent leaders, then the country won't do well.
the current leader is a cheat and liar, he has a fake university degree from the non-existent course, and he climbed up the political ladder because he is a great public speaker and orator. but is very cunning in nature. He doesn't have the technical knowledge or integrity to lead the country. only lies and deception, his first blunder was demonetization
Countries that lead the world in 44 critical technology* sectors: 1. China = 37 2. USA = 7 3. UK = 0 4. Germany = 0 5. Japan = 0 *In fields like defence, space, robotics, energy, the environment, biotechnology, artificial intelligence (AI), advanced materials and key quantum technology areas Source: Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI) **India leads the world in the field of cow husbandry, which is neither a technology nor critical
There was no luck involved in the case of China. It was down to work ethic and doing what's right for the people and country, as opposed to what's right for a small rich elite.
Well, the only bit of luck China had was the Sino-Soviet split that led to the US stopping to actively trying to destroy China and opened business possibilities.
Oh yes there is luck. The Soviet lead us to ally china. Then the middle east distracted us for 30 years. Even now both Russia and middle east are still distracting. You can argue that these distractions are inevitable given us policies; however the timing is still lucky.
From 2019~2022, the export from inland provinces of China grew faster than India, Vietnam and Mexico combined where most reviewer and politics thought the manufacturing industry relocation would go.
Adding on, the other reason that was India’s bureaucracy & red tapes for doing businesses is really a non starter. Especially with the many laws & regulations involving central, state & provincial government’s approval. They can change the law and regulations at any time in the name to protect India’s interest. Finally, India’s caste system & elite community is very much exist in background and has a very big part in any business venture.
@@eskay2012 The Union of states is the power of India's growth. Each state competing for its own self sufficiency. The laws for starting businesses and attracting investments from foreign companies is now a competition among states especially south Indian states. Caste system is dead long ago. Companies need labour and migrants from poor states come to richer states irrespective of any caste or religion.
Don't forget China had gone through huge pain in its reform of 80s 90s and early 00s: a large number of factories went bankrunpcy and millions lost jobs or retired early, as result of adopting foreign investment and technology to level up its industry. Does Indian politician have the courage to do so? Most likely not.
India cannot achieve what china as in china its autocratic , meanwhile you cannot fathom the political complexity India has 100+ political party , centre has 1 and all states have different with main agenda of corruption , and all party is coalition which means more difficulty , also gov can't change laws or take away land by force as there will be vast protest. just think of farmer law which was there for helping farmers but we saw huge protest bloodshed as they don't want change , Just imagine the huge slums of Mumbai gov wants to remove them and relocate but oppositions don't let that happen , Fed up with nonsenses in india , But despite all these india shall shine at its own page
The documentry was going so well, when he suggested China's economy will go down due to labour shortage. What rubbish. All advanced countries don't need that many worker. . Just look at the car industry, batteries, all the food industry, farming etc.
It's an insult to the Chinese to compare them to India; first of all, India needs to build a comprehensive sewerage network so that no one poop on the roads & bushes again. Next, they need to provide clean water to wash themselves after they poop. Can you suggest getting the above mentioned built first? We Chinese are very different from other races. Am not going into that at length bcos you won't understand anyway. In any case, no nation on earth can emulate China's success totally nor surpass it in any way. Quality of government leaders and utmost integrity are very critical factors and the practice of meritocracy is only possible in Communist China. It's a dictatorship that works really hard for its people. Sounds cruel, right?
When China’s young are well educated including those from the countryside, there will never be shortage of young talents to take the country to the next level in the next generation. Growing old workforce will not be an immediate issue. It might not even be an issue in the future. Liken to Singapore’a low birth rate, an issue that’s quite well ratified with many government incentives and the inauguration of many new citizens.
India has not had Mao Zedong and Deng Xiaoping. Big countries have to reform their farming society to earn its first bucket of gold. Without a thorough land revolution, it's impossible to set free huge amount of population which is necessary for industrialization.
Another problem is that its own young and educated are either trying to get out of India (bringing its baggage with it too) or continue to perpetuate the bad “habits” and corruption continues forever. Lastly, Indian elites and educated and the rest in society must stop imitating the “British Raj & Colonial period” on its own People especially on the Poor.
A country with 200 parties and 400 languages was not easy to lead and manage. Not even the late Lee Kuan Yew had any idea whatsoever to handle such a complecated country.
No India or China. You forgot ASEAN . Tremendous growth prospects here. Because everything sanctions in west can be assembled in ASEAN to avoid humongous import duty. China India and ASEAN will pull the financial centre of world to asia
The elimination of democracy as practced now with clever honest leaders, true meritocracy, lack of curruption, universal education, healthcare need to be achieved with good environmental standards for success.
India also suffer from irreparable ethnic divisions: just take Muslims, Sikhs, Tamils, Parsees, etc. & Hindus with their caste system. India can be broken up into smaller nations. That might well happen.
Because these ethnic minorities didn't belong to this country before UK invaded this land....UK always left trouble to her former colonies!Shame on them!
This century is a century of talent, not manpower. Today's manufacturing industry has been replaced by robots. Including taxi drivers who will soon be replaced by autonomous driving. Labor-intensive industries will no longer need workers. India's overpopulation is a liability, not an asset. I think the author still needs to improve.
India economy should be compared to US economy, not China. India economy must overtake US economy to become No.2, China will be No.1 by that time but will US allow India to be No.2.?
Jayant Bandhari, an investor of Indian origin: When people ask me "should I invest in India? I tell them : Don,t bother. Go to East Asia(Jp,chin,Sk,Tw,Hk,Sg) Note that all these countries and regions have all been greatly influenced by Chinese culture and confucianism.
Whoever this guy is, he is stupid. You could have gotten over 25% CAGR returns per year from 2013 till today, if you have invested carefully in Indian equity. He is the one missing out on mega-returns.
@@twilight6460 Oh boy, why so much hate for India for just some assembly plants? Just don't buy apple products and don't talk about it. Let the rest of the world do as they please.
Astute reporting. A few dissenting voices amongst the many that hailed India as the next China or even greater than China. A lot of hype no doubt promoted by the West as a counter weight to China. India as a nation is deeply divided by its cast system that discriminates its own people by skin color, language, race and beliefs. The north and the south simmers with racist differences (the Aryans, the Dravidians, the Sikhs, etc.) and disagreement over the use of Hindi as the national language. It is an 'artificial' nation, a time bomb waiting to explode.
Sir all these are excuses. The fact is indian politicians are so power hungry and corrupt to the core that it can never achieve any result with this kind of intimidating and extortionist system whatever we say and it has become very bad in last 5 years. A country where people celebrate demonetisation just becoz it will hit richer can never become prosper
😂lol caste system. India is not using that word much. Its you guys that keep reminding us that we have castes. When was the last time anyone was asked about his caste for a job interview!!
@@arjunraj823So true man. Castism is disappearing at a rapid pace and these guys keep on grinding on the same thing. It's like a propaganda😅. No one even thinks of dravidians or Aryans.
Small landmass? India is 7th largest country in the world. India has about the same size of fertile land as China. Unlike India, its China who has barren desert on like 40% of its land. India has much better geography than Japan or Netherlands(both more densely populated) with more than 40% flat lands.
In the past 3000 years of human history, did India ever surpass China one time? why? Indian is overconfident to its capability without looking back its history😂
In the past 3000 years, India was always ahead of China. Europeans came looking for India not China. Why ?? Because the wealth of India was world renowned. Native Americans are called Red Indians and not Red Chinese because of this reason. Nobody cared about China. It was just a country that existed East of India. Chinese were mostly rice farmers for most of history. They have no influence on the world. But Indian wealth, philosophy, culture, civilization is world renowned. From Central Asia to India to South East Asia to China to Japan and Korean, Indian culture influenced everyone. This is why even the Chinese study Buddha. So India was always ahead of China. China should not become too arrogant because of American factories in China. Without becoming America's junior partner China would never have an economy.
@@asmirann3636 lol your lack of education is showing. China had contact with Europe through the silk road long before the British took over India. China made contact with the Africans before Europe started apartheid. China's economy has always been world #1 for 2000 years, while granted, India was #2. There were European missionaries and officials in China's courts working as painters and these are well known in history books. British went to India and easily took over the nation, because the Indian people were already so divided against each other. The 8 allied nations tried to take over China but failed even while China was at it's weakest during the dying Qing Dynasty AND while fighting the Japanese. Imagine being so proud of being colonised and your race being used as a racial term by the ignorant anglo saxxons to call another race they just massacred - Red Indians. Hahaha. There is absolutely no comparison so why don't you stop speaking out of your ass.
as long as one steps in cow pats ,,having rats sitting next to you ,and monkeys evrywhere not a chance and then theres the untouchables and othe religious obsticles problems need solving
China is not a one party autocracy. China has at least 7 political parties and they are all legitimate and have elected representative in the China Parliament. Stick to the facts.
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
If I were an Indian I would feel ashamed to compare India with China. The gap in every sector of the two countries where China is very far ahead is just too wide to mention and more so to even want to compare. Please do not ever bring up this subject of comparison again. If you do, it shows you have been living in the jungle for the past 30 years. ndia cannot even build enough toilet as a human basic right for his people as the link provide here {what a shame} #opendefecation Latest report from IMF on China contribution to the world economy.According to the IMF’s World Economic Outlook (WEO) report in October, global economic output is forecast to expand by 3% this year, to which China is expected to contribute 0.9 percentage point, Barnett said. He made the remarks at a launch of the publication in Beijing last Friday. The event was organised by the IMF Resident Representative Office in China and the International Monetary Institute at the Renmin University of China. By comparison, the United States is forecast to contribute 0.3 percentage point while India’s contribution might be 0.5 percentage point, Barnett told China Daily on the sidelines of the event. On 2024, China is forecast to contribute 0.8 percentage point of the 2.9% global growth, just under one-third and still higher than 0.2 percentage point of the United States and 0.5 percentage point of India, he said. The WEO, published lastTuesday, has lowered the 2023 economic growth forecast for China to 5% from 5.2%, citing the pressures brought by the weakness in the real estate sector
Both countries have more than 1.4 billion population and most populated in the world. There are surveyed that shown the results below: Worker productivity: Chinese is 1.6 of Indian. Which meant 60% higher than Indian. Average IQ for both countries comparison. Chinese 104, India 76 Women in workforce: China 61%, India 23% Education ranking in the world: China at 22. India at 32.
Education ranking is way off. If you look at the last PISA education assessment in 2018, China (B-S-J-Z) ranked #1, whereas India (TN) ranked #72 out of 73. Global Hunger Index: China ranked 0 (no hunger) where India ranked #111 out of 125
China is Meritocratic NOT Autocratic! There is big difference between the two! And India will never surpass China, unless it goes through its own socialist revolution, which I dont see happening any time soon
The workforce problem of India is, once young people got educated, they will move to countries like US and Canada, while many Chinese young students are blocked by those countries’ strict immigration policies and they will have to go back to China. That’s how Americans help!
China today is a result of a few thousand years of continuoss civilization. It has not happened over the last few decades. Even the Mongols who come from a nomadic culture settled in China when they experience the quality and sophistication of the Chinese culture. China has a long history of gathering experience in managing and looking after a large population. If this is not the case their population would not have grown to this scale. China wasn't waiting for Carl Marks to save them or for that matter democracy especially introduced to them from the west when all can see it is not even skin deep and has become a meaningless word not even a fig leaf. I don't think India can manage to rise as China has bcs Britain introduced the divide and rule policy "democracy" and abolished their ruling system which has been evolving over a few thousand years. Noteworthy to say Churchill past away still not believing that Gandi wasn't being given food, secretly, while he was on his hunger strike! It is worth noting China and India two great civilization over five thousand years bordering each other never waged war against each other but the contrary they cooperated. But in the present "democracy" in India means India is worried about China and not about America who has been dropping bombs in Asia as if its running out of fashion. Whilst China is only worried about America building a base on its border in India overlooking China.
The big stumbling blocks to India's rapid progress are religious fanaticism,, burgeoning population, corrupt short sighted politicians who instead of addressing these problems tries to take advantage of it by making lop sided laws to create votebanks and encouraging mai-baap sarkar where politicians give themselves powers to grant or withhold favours. The Judiciary where the individuals are interested in grandstanding rather than address speedy justice.
China already become developed country (china doesn't admit it), India still developing country. India has a more poor peoples,bad working culture,bad goverment policy for business,etc. Still long way to catch up china.
The problem is India dosent have jobs in urban areas and thats is hampering rapid urbanization. We have massive unemployment problem. So even if government stop rural welfare schems they will not be able to move into urban areas
You just humiliated the Soviet Union. There is no comparison possible. The USSR is not the vassal of the USA, in addition it faced America and surpassed it in space, weapons and nuclear power. While India absolutely does not outperform any of the poor neighboring countries.
The countries that you mentioned..Cuba, Venezuela, North Korea..those are heavily sanctioned countries. It’s not fair to mention their lack of growth without mentioning the sanctions that are crippling and holding them back.
Very correct. But this video had to do little bit of Western propaganda. In fact it can be argued that ALL socialist countries are very successful countries because despite the crippling and inhumane illegal US regime sanctions they have managed to survive and in many case even do better than the US regime. For example in Cuba the average life expectancy is almost equal to that of the US.
@@thecomment9489 This video is obviously Pro- India !
@@thecomment9489 true. Cuba in spite of 60 years of sanctions is doing better than nearby Haiti which is "protected and helped" by the US.
China was once seriosly sanctioned for decades, only because CCP led the country right and made more and more progress that the western countries have to abandon part of the sanctions. Even now China is still being sanctioned by the western countries, the Hight Tech War with US for example.
Their economies would be almost as bad without sanctions. Those countries are built on socialism, which leads to economic failure. Xi Jinping is returning China to the socialist system it had under Mao, and that's one reason it will become another failure like North Korea.
Singapore former prime Minister LKY said "India is the country of the future where the future NEVER arrives"... Enough said!
That was a good statement that I didnt come across before. Can cite source? Thanks!
I love to quote LKY too.
LKY : They don't cast their votes, they vote their caste
Quote from Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
@@Praetorian157A I cited u my source . It's from LKY of Singapore . Look up some of his maybe black white old videos
Another LKY quote : Never put India and China in the same breath.
This documentary emphasises democracy as the only way to get ahead. When you have the world's largest population (India) no amount of democracy will be able to educate , feed and find employment for everyone.
China got to where it is by planning and implementing and working hard towards a single goal, not by luck.
China has been growing at a rapid rate over the last 4 decades and you can't call that " luck."
Agree. My own observation is that so called "China Economic Model" is actually wrong understanding of what China has been doing. China understood their backwardness and limitation and decided to work hard quietly to achieve improvement. China's way is simple. Whichever the system works for China, it would adopt it. Therefore, what they did and have been continue doing is to set reasonable targets, for the whole nation, for the province and even for each department. Everyone is trying to reach such target in time. if there is mistake, it should be immediately recognized and corrected. The important here is the Chinese system has a mechanism to recognize mistakes and apply remedies in a fast manner while the West refuse to admit their own mistakes.
Deng Xiaoping : It doesn't matter if it's a white cat or black cat, as it catches mice, it's a good cat
@@harryzhang3111 Any validity in what you say applies to the past. China is now in the beginning stages of an economic death spiral.
@@twilight6460 Do you realize that Xi Jinping hates the policies of Deng Xiao Ping and is working to eradicate them? He believes in establishing economic policies that allow him to cling to power in the short term even though they will lead to the collapse of the Chinese economy.
China is successful because the Chinese government has been planning its development direction for the next 10 or even 20 years.
China walk and work silenly and get great achievement while India talk about great achievement before they even start
😂😂
So true 😂
This technique is called democratic power in India's infinity dream. 😄
True, Indiana are big braggarts with nothing of substance
The major high tech industry in India are call centers
One of the reason why China put controls on birth is due to cost of feeding a large population.
India seemed strangely 'proud' of their large population. I think India is heading towards a disaster, with the water shortages and food inflations.
He is completely in already except that the Indian government and the West are saying nothing. Not against they have a lot to say about the collapse of China for over 30 years. 😁
True
One china policy is biting back 😂😂
@@offred6013so how the eff u control population growth, Mr smart arse? You want to learn from Israh3ll by gen0cide?
The big pollution problem hadn’t solved, in 2019 yr 1,670,000 people died of disease. Grange river is polluted, no fish can survive. Shit and rubbish around hygiene is too bad.
China divides its development strategy into three steps. The first step is to solve the problem of food and clothing for the people; the second step is to bring the people's income to the income level of middle-income countries; the third step is to reach the living standards of developed countries and become a world power. China is now in the stage of moving from the second step to the third step, while India has not yet taken the first step. Therefore, it is unreasonable and unfair to compare India with China. Even Vietnam is one step ahead of India.
You are correct but according to India they are already superpower status. Amongst Indians they think they are ahead of Russia and a peer to China. So basically they think they are somewhere between second and third place.
@@davidmoss2576 All Indians thinks they are already a super power, so do you think the United States will tolerate the rise of another new challenger that is far more arrogant than China? The United States will suppress India more fiercely than it does China.
China is an open air jail.
All People in China merely subjects without any dignity in their lives.
😂😂😂
All se Asian nations will leapfrog india soon. Indonesia Laos Vietnam all have hi speed rail thanks to China. Djibouti Africa will have a space port to launch an African into space thanks to China. Yet India is the "super power" lol
@@davidmoss2576India is a super power in scamming and rape. Hence the Indians know they are already a super power. 😂😂😂
The retreat of Foxcon from India is not a good indication that India will surpass China anytime soon. Labour law and education and training are the biggest problem.
Leave Taiwan alone
Impossible to catch up
Foxconn hasn’t retreated, infact they have expanded… their semicon factory is also in the works
So you know why they retreated? And do you know that they haven't totally scrapped the idea of their presence in India?
They don't want to invest in India through a joint venture with Vedanta co.
But did you know about all this before typing the comment? I wonder.🙃
@Xinnie_The_Pooh exactly! All they have stated is that they don't want to work with vedanta but want to expand in India on their own. They're bundling massive factories in Hyderabad and Bengaluru right now
The main difference between China🇨🇳 and India🇮🇳 :
Indian leaders are busy with words while Chinese leaders are busy with actions
Indians talk, Chinese walk
actions- u mean bankrupting other poorer countries, not to mention china still heavily relies on america for its exports. not saying usa is a saint either
You will see the "talk" in next 5 years. Return to this comment then.
@@anime0965 *:* _"You will see the "talk" in next 5 years. Return to this comment then"_ *
@@anime0965 *:* _"You will see the "talk" in next 5 years. Return to this comment then"_ *
Corruption and no morale concept of Indians is the main problem of India. An Indian Jayant Bhandari said so. I know nothing about India and has zero interest to compare it with China. I am quoting Jayant because in the comment section of his program, most Indian agree with him and others are person attacking him without any data or evidence to counter his observation. Therefore, I believe what he said must be valid.
Spot...on
This is very true
Indians lQ :78
Chinese lQ :108
😂😂😂😂😂😂
He quoted his own real life experiences and those that made public headlines, he is now based in Canada.
Jayant bhindari gave up his indian citizenship decades ago😂😂😂.
He is as Indian as Pakistanis r 😂😂
Comparing china and india has no meaning. Because india is not a country. It is just an administrative system created by British. Now it is look like federal , democratic but in reality it is not either federal or democratic. But china is really functioning as federal. It is a country with real one ethnic and linguistics population and it is not just an administrative system created by British to loot. There is no need to complete with china. If india really wants to uplift it's people it must accept the reality that is it is not a nation but a federation of many nations. Without this understanding speaking about development is like having a map without "you are here mark "
😂😂
@elavarasand
Good and very factual comment. India cannot hold. It will soon break up into many smaller countries.
Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
我是中国人，上面对中国有误解，中国有56个民族而不是单一民族（不过汉族人口占90%以上），也不是联邦制而是中央集权制国家，国家法律在各省份自治区基本统一。
Funnily enough, that difference has created high competition among states for economic progress and industrialization. Now every state wants better ports, more expressways and higher foreign investments. You will "see" it soon enough. The largest state, the size of Guangdong population, will be nearing 1 Trillion GDP by 2030.
@@twilight6460tu kya Jayant Bhandari ka speaker hai😂 Jo Har jagah bhauk raha hai
If 🇨🇳 doesn't unseat 🇺🇸 economically no country will do that. India will never be or replace China...
China passed the US economically a decade ago by PPP metric (internal cost vs variable ForEx rate).
We don't want to be china .... Beacuse we are indians.
And because America wants the world to believe they are still the Number 1 is the reason with the exchange rate of the dollar. In real terms china is the worldst largest economy and its median per capita income too is on the rise...I bet Science and Technology is the key metric here...No Country has achieved Tier 1 Developed Status except Japan in Asia. Saudi and other Middle East, Singapore and Korea too are categorised as Tier 2 Developed Countries as they lack the Global Appeal and Strength going from Culture to Science and Technology to many more....Japan despite its lack of many mineral resources stands tall in Scientific and Technological Strengths, Cultural Powerhouse and has Military Technologies and has a Good Economic Size. All these factors give Japan and edge..Its Human Resources are very strong..From Olympiads to Olympics to Culture to STEM fields to Humanities research, Japan does it all. Even in Music they are quite good.
The Next Best Is China. This was what many were waiting as This,unlike Japan, is a Civilisation and has historically been the Powerful One. China reaching the next stage in scientific and technoligical development along with its Cultural Exports means it has arrived on the Tier 1 Zone. Only Japan, US, Italy, Spain, Germany, UK, France and a few Northern and Souther and Central European states make us Tier 1 Developed Status. Let us not even talk about hese countries social development indicators and entrepreneurial mindsets...Only China came so strong at them. Truly a Hardworking and Persevering Society with a iron grit determination to become the Number 1 in the world. It is Social Psychology after all.
True❤
We don't even have the desire to become China, india will become much better than them, okay And Indians have great faith in their hard work and by working hard they will achieve everything they want to do.
The train has already left the station... India is already too late and too little... China has already gone to another level ..India has to compete with Bangladesh ..Pakistan...Vietnam.. Indonesia.. Thailand...Cambodia and Laos ,,Africa and Latin America but unfortunately India's huge population is a liability rather than an asset...India can stop dreaming about competing with China rather than India needs to compete with other emerging markets in Latin America...Africa...ASEAN and Central Asia... Remember China speed 1 year India needs 10 years ... China speed 10 years India needs 100 years...
ASEAN is glad that India did not join RCEP ( a combined population of 2.5. Billions ) , A GDP nominal of USD 28 Billions and GDP PPP of nearly USD 40 Billions , with a nearly 900 Millions middle to high Income population , who needs India we are happy in ASEAN where China , Japan, South Korea, and even Taiwan and Hongkong are trading and investing in RCEP , Trading in RCEP is already reaching usd 1. 35 Trillions per year. ✌️🙏
If the Indians had been half smart they would take pages out of Chinese governance of large (enormous) populations with great cultural diversity, and realise that 'democracy' is a misnomer for countries lacking social justice.
@@Steve-so7ukBla, Bla, Bla...Indians doesn't even have a toilet at home!
corrections RCEP Estimated GDP nominal is usd 36 Trillions and GDP PPP is usd 48 Trillions
India is the biggest democracy written on a piece of paper only. In reality, India is the biggest Authoritarian Country run by the Corrupted Modi!
America will not allow another China competing with them. Don't forget, India is an US Lackey!
As an American lapdog, India will not be allowed to surpass its master. That's all I have to say. 😅
Examples are japan and now China
@@peanut0brain
China is not a lapdog of USA. Yes, now US is trying very hard to contain China but it hasn't been successful thus far. In fact, it has backfired on the US. Of course the war is still ongoing so we'll have to wait and see who will win. However, history has shown that US lapdogs cannot overtake it's master.
@@peanut0brain Also Germany! America really took Germany down hard by destroying Nordstream.
@@peanut0brain Japan is, but China is not a US lapdog
@@twilight6460 yes you're right. South Korea lapdog also suffered immensely. Samsung as example followed along the yankee chip war and lost billions in usd sales (to China)
One big significant difference on India and china is about the people's mentality. The Chinese people are very competitive in nature. When ever there is a little opportunity arises the Chinese would grab it to the fullest and improve themselves. That is why many new startups emerged for the past 30 years to take opportunity on the little opening from the government. Meanwhile in India the government need to take the lead in drive the economy while the people would follow from behind. It could not work this way, It is the people who need to take the lead to drive up the economy while the government only provide some facilities to ensure it is happening
Indians lQ :78
Chinese lQ :108
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@VanDuc-hm6sp i would not say that if i were you. Indians in Malaysia some are extremely clever. They work as doctors and lawyers but there is a stark difference on their income gap where some extremely rich and the next is extremely poor. There is nothing in the middle
They could not even build toilets 🚽🚽
Also, the Chinese would rather earn less or even lose sometimes to keep a long-term customer for years and decades while Indians seem more interested in gaining greater short-term profit even though it will mean losing the customer.
@@kawings only 2% indians are smart🤣🤣 the rest are Keleng Mabok🤣🤣🤣
Why is Indian so concerned of China? Not a day we don't see Indians and India media talking about China. But I hardly see Chinese media and Chinese people talk about India. Inferiority complex and jealousy to see China is far ahead of India. These must be the reasonshe problem with Indians.and they are happy with mediocrity. They start feeling proud to have the fastest growing major economy even though the growth only around 6%. China was growing at 12% at its peak.
India is now the world’s most populous country and its fifth largest economy. By the end of the decade, it is projected to be the third largest, behind only China and the USA. It has a vast youth population while its GDP growth outstrips other top ten economies. Its geopolitical importance is also growing amid a rapidly changing global order.
India now has ambitions to become a global economic superpower. But there are serious question marks. It remains an extremely poor country, with major inequalities from female labor force participation to education. Other issues such as ethnic tensions, democratic decline and environmental damage are fraying the fabric of the Indian Republic.
#IndiaEconomy #ChinaEconomy #HumanCapital
🇮🇳🇨🇳 Why can't India be an Economic Superpower like China? Find out the crucial reasons in this eye-opening video! 📊🌍
In this thought-provoking analysis, we delve into the disparities between India and China's economic growth and development. Discover the pivotal role of human capital and gender equality in shaping these nations' destinies
So right my friend, everthing you said was sport-on.
Indians lQ :78
Chinese lQ :108
😂😂😂😂😂😂
I agree! Only 10% of women work outside of their homes. That means a large percentage of the population is not productive. They also have society issues which are difficult to solve.
@@elliekwong3180 They revered cows a lot more than they do their womenfolk. Once they find a way to uplift cows intellectual and productive ability to the level of women they will begin to progress.
China talks about the USA. India doesn't matter at all to China.
India may someday meet China’s standards but can never surpass China in any way. By the time India has caught up to today’s China, China will eventually be so far ahead again that’s impossible for India to catch up…
amen & well said!
china too rich, smart & powerful... much love for china from usa!
Cows in the library, how to progress?
@@raymonddon8875 The main reason Chinese people are hard working. When they want to do something that they will compete done it. In Chinese's mind which " time is money " and " time don't wait ". So you must catch the time right away to moving forward.
Forget about China maybe it will catch up with US one day
Chinese idiom: master in dreams, maid in reality. 小姐的心，丫鬟的命
How beautiful !
Yup just like its a maid for US
The recent move of Apple IPhone moving back to China shows that India just isn't up to it, despitr what America wants!
Lol, it never went back. They don't want to do business with Vivanta. Apple is expanding its operations in India.
You have not mentioned the caste equation in India. Majority of influential positions are occupied by the so called higher caste who generally look down upon the vast majority of populace who are lower caste. The coherence in society (among majority hindu population) is fragmented and graded inequalities exist and any attempt to smoothen out that difference is actively discouraged. Almost all the levers of power are controlled by the higher caste who try to agrandise all the power to themselves. Such a situation never existed in china. China was more are less a monolithic country (compared to India), and Modi government did little to smoothen things out. In fact his party has accentuated the differences more and he has exasperated the society further by promoting Hindu vs Muslim, Hindu vs Christian animosity. Indians are always at war (in low key) among themselves, riches are fewer and not distributed evenly. Much of the constituent states of India are several thousand years older than the nation of India, which is the result of colonial rule. This fact has to be recognized and respected. Trying to govern India as an unitary state increase the fissure. Languages, religion, customs, vary between state to state and has to be respected. Formation of United States of India, could help and unitary india may lead to fragmentation.
India keeps saying it's the 5th largest GDP and the 2nd populous. But it's ranking is 127 in the world terms of GDP/capita behind Laos and bankrupt Sri Lanka (107) and many African countries. Please compare India with Sri Lanka or war torn Iraq(115), Lebanon (114).
India ald become the most populous country
India is #1 in number of people dying of diarrhea each year. Over 600,000 Indians died of diarrhea last year, over 4x the next worst country.
@@widodoakrom3938 quantity no quality
@@widodoakrom3938 if China include Hong Kong and Macao is still ahead of India. (let's not even open the Taiwan can of worms)
@@johnsmith-cw3wo wrong still India ald head of china in term of population
Chinese people are the most diligent people in the world. Even if they encounter difficulties, they will stand up quickly.
There are a few roadblocks for India. Some are covered by the video, some are not. The ones that wasn't covered are:
1. many have less tolerance against different castes, religions, ethnics, gender, etc.. which cause bouts of sectarian violence (religious and ethnic) and is one the main factors of instability that lessen global businesses desire to invest much in India;
2. pollution - India is heavily polluted even without heavily industrialization somehow. Although India do have a lot of young people, such pollutions would shorten their lives and increase their medical burdens which then limit their potential in the long term;
3. lack of solid industrial base - which ties into the quality of its infrastructure building as well as quality/reliability of goods coming out of India;
4. same tech bottleneck that China is experiencing in semiconductors. Can India continuously rely on the West for high-tech goods indefinitely?
5. Political red tape & rules of law - being the largest democracy also have its political downsides and without a solid rule of law like most western democracies, rampant corruptions, backward justice system, very slow social improvements, etc. will heavily impede India's prospects in the long term;
If Indian can at least mitigate the negatives of these and the ones mentioned in the video to a certain extent (say 50%), then it has a chance to catch up to China in this century.
If China can learn to make proper maps China might be taken seriously😂😂
@@offred6013 not everything is about China. This is about India
China seems to have solved the tech bottleneck, as shown by the newest SMIC, YMTC, HiSilicon & Loongson chips. China is no more than 2 or 3 years behind the state of the art, and catching up very fast. This is what happens when you have a huge population that is well educated and highly technical, producing more scientists, technicians, engineers, and mechanics than any other country.
India has problems with all its neighbors. India annexed Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh, Punjab, etc....
Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
@@offred6013 What has Chinese maps got to do with India's incompetence? There are other reasons. Lack of hygiene, disregard for the environment, ultra-nationalism when a large chunk of the population aren't holier-than-thou classes of Hindus. When people don't see anything wrong with consuming cow urine and bathing in cow poo, you know the country won't progress.
If India is to surpass China, it will have to surpass the US as well (assuming China surpasses the US first which has been a certainty to most of economists.). What do you think the US will do to India to hold it back as has done to China?
US will sanction India back to the stone age
The US attempted color revolutions in China (1989), supported Muslim terrorists in Xinjiang, attempted color revolution in Hong Kong (2019-2020), and continues to support Tibetan government in exile, along with separatist government in Taiwan province. If we look at the equivalent for India, that would be supporting independent Muslim Jammu, Kashir, & Ladakh; Sikh Khalistan; independent Sikkim; "human rights" for untouchables; and other breakaways along India's borders. The ultimate goal is constant domestic unrest, culminating in another Indian Civil War that allows the US to intervene militarily under a binding UN resolution.
Ironically, if broken apart, India would almost certainly do better as a loose Confederation of small states.
美國仍然會利用印度
India will never surpass China. Not for a thousand years. Unless they tweak the figures and publish fake news on how successful and advance India is; how abt creating an Indian Huawei for a start, assuming India have already built enough public toilets for 1.4 billion ppl?
In that case, US will let India grow. Because, it will be net positive counter to China. And many countries in the democratic camp will sign security agreements with India than US as well.
Lift the sanctions on Cuba, NK, Venezuela and see if they can thrive without USA's constant interference
I think you are very wrong to call Cuba a failure. Cuba has been subjected to draconian sanctions and continous bullying be Anerica for many, many decades and it's a miracle that it still managed to survive!
And on top of that, That small nation with just 10 million population has produced athletic talent like no other. 254 Olympic Medals and counting...Which nation at that per capita has produced that?
100% agree 💪
Island nation that heavily relies on tourism chose to collectivize all foreign owned companies and kicked out all westerners and adopted communism failed because the west refused to trade with it. Shocker😂
@@Leviathan762-zh4lqBut despite all that, China's HDI didn't catch up to Cuba's until a few years back.
I really like the fact that Westerners and Indians always compare the economy of the mouse to that of the elephant. While there are animals much closer to the mouse, such as the hamster (Pakistan), the marmot (Bangladesh), a rat (Vietnam), a guinea pig (Afghanistan). But no, they compare the incomparable India (the mouse) to the economy of the elephant (China).
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
India is very big and populous. So it is like a swarm of mice.
The mice think the elephant will be scared of it because the mice are so mighty. Actually the elephant just wants to avoid stepping on them because it's an icky feeling.
Nah, India is an elephant... a big, dumb, lazy elephant. China is a mighty dragon who has finally awakened after a century.
Good analogy and funny 😆
Elephant is a metaphor used for India but Lets just say China as A Drgaon is unbeatable in many respects...The Only Non Western Civilisation to do so..Besides, Dragons arr Legendary Creatures and not Superpower creatures..
Even they cannot make a toilet properly also the road condition is something you will back in time around 80's. And dont forget indian "tech call support" is no.1 in the world 😂😂😂😅😅
That is why india china bilateral trade 150 billion 😮
The video creator clearly doesn't understand China's development model. "Authoritarian success" is a Western narrative that sidelines the essential formula for economic success. The reality is, China based their power of collective resolve, policies, and reforms. Their economy is best described as state free market capitalism coupled with socialism in development, it is technically an overall mixed economy which is the fundamental formula for it's dynamic success. China's development model is incomparible to that of other socialist countries. To compare that China will somehow collapse/fail just because other countries did because they're "authoritarian" is absolutely vacuous and flawed at best. Freedom is derivative from it's foundation. For example, if you want to live in a country free of crimes and drugs - you need laws, education, and policies to prevent them from proliferating.
其實最大的差異在中央政府的有效控制，中國歷來強盛時候都是這樣，免去內耗
子龙，中国大陆是华侨建起来的 大陆只会大炼钢方法 糟蹋倒退沉沦
这也是为什么西方经济学在中国屡屡失败，中国崩溃论屡屡破产的原因。
@@ritawinson1101 你的认识仍然有局限性。一党专政并非党内没有斗争，只是外界不了解罢了1譬如毛泽东的文化大革命，这是毛泽东，林彪，张春桥等一派坚持走共产主义路线 对阵 刘少奇，邓小平等希望改革派的路线斗争，很遗憾毛泽东一派胜出造成了十年的发展停滞 2 在1989年，又在走资本主义道路（胡耀邦，赵紫阳派）还是走一贯的计划经济模式社会主义道路（陈云，李先念，胡乔木派）以及所谓的有中国特色的社会主义道路（邓小平等）激烈的斗争，邓小平派胜出得到了改革开放 3 是2012的斗争中，习派胜出，推出了中国标准2035和一带一路倡议以及绿色能源革命诸多脚踏实地的指导思想，这些都是党内集体智慧的结晶，绝非某一个领导人拍脑袋凭空想出来的😀
外国人哪里知道这些
It's just market Socialism, an alien concept to Indians.
The US already learned it’s lesson, there is no way the US will let India get that powerful
Nope, they will have to reluctantly allow, as with India on its side US gets a heavy strategic advantage over China considering the geography and naval supply lines.
@@anime0965
So you think India can develop while fighting with the world's most powerful industrial country that is China ?
China provides countless semifinished parts, raw materials, for India's manufacturing sectors and reasonable priced machinery for their factories.
Don't forget, India benefits from US-China, otherwise there is nothing attractive to foreign investments.
US, Japan, EU rather put their money in Vietnam, Thailand, and other ASEAN nations.
After reading the comments, I think India needs first a cultural Revolution... or maybe become a loose confederation of different states and then, maybe only then, India can start to compare itself to China xd
Also it needs to become a really sovereign state and leave its colonial mindset in the past.
Right
During the Qin Shi Huang period more than 2,000 years ago, China achieved the goal of having cars on the same track and books on the same text. Although it was considered a tyranny at the time, it seems to be correct in the long run. All Chinese people can speak Chinese and understand Chinese characters, which is more convenient. Communication and management, India has too many languages and is too complicated. Each state may have different laws. This has also caused doubts among foreign investors and greatly increased investment costs. They need to understand the laws and labor costs of different states. too high
The simple answer is, unlike China, India does not have a cohesive society after hundreds of years of being a British Colony and the divide-and-rule strategy of the British Empire. LKY explained the reason more than a decade ago in Singapore to an Indian Academic
LKY : They don't cast their votes, they vote their caste
The Indian Academic asked LKY how to govern India and be as successful as Singapore. LKY just shook his head@@twilight6460
没有英国的殖民就没有印度这个国家，硬生生被英国殖民者拼凑出来的领土。
@@twilight6460 LKY stopped being active before 2010. Your views are outdated. China had just surpassed Japan at that time. Compare it with today's China. India also has made huge structural changes and they will be visible by 2030.
LKY is long dead. India of 2010s was far worse than today's India. You will see soon enough.
China is almost a developed country. So there is no comparison of India and china now. China is developed and India is developing.
India is not developing. India is under developed
@@twilight6460 have you been to each and every state in INDIA?????????Yes China is developed India is developing and that's it......i see in comment section people saying about pakistan which does not even have proper electricity.....like r this people being serious....do u think a country which has capacity to reach moon is a joke???then keep thinking like bokachoda jotoshob
@@Beingrighteous678check your streets, maybe lift yourself out of poverty corruption and indians that arent doing jackshit but praise the past, then we’ll talk.
@@twilight6460 india is third largest carbon emitter and will soon because second biggest emitter due to massive industrilisation and urbanization and have the second largest number of internet users on earth and biggest data consuming nation if you think underdeveloped country can be a second biggest carbon emitter and biggest data consuming nation than please have your brain check up with the good doctor doctor. India is pharmacy capital. You can come to India and can get a good treatment from India in cheap rates.
@@twilight6460bro creating his own happiness
Economy and government system is not necessarily the problem, it's leadership. If you don't have great competent leaders, then the country won't do well.
That's one reason China is in deep trouble. The only good person in China's government, Li Kequiang, is now gone.
The leadership now has never been better
lol@@productivity23
the current leader is a cheat and liar, he has a fake university degree from the non-existent course, and he climbed up the political ladder because he is a great public speaker and orator. but is very cunning in nature. He doesn't have the technical knowledge or integrity to lead the country. only lies and deception, his first blunder was demonetization
china is just too rich, smart and powerful... much love for china from usa!
china is the future...
Yes. 961 billionaires in China compared to 680 in America.
its all china now...@@DK-ev9dg
china # 1@@DK-ev9dg
CHINA WILL BE SMALL IN FUTURTE
China:work hard. India:talk loud.
Cry harder
he's spitting facts .Why u just offended?I am also Indian ,just accept the fact and work hard.@@priyanshuraturi5987
Countries that lead the world in 44 critical technology* sectors:
1. China = 37
2. USA = 7
3. UK = 0
4. Germany = 0
5. Japan = 0
*In fields like defence, space, robotics, energy, the environment, biotechnology, artificial intelligence (AI), advanced materials and key quantum technology areas
Source: Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI)
**India leads the world in the field of cow husbandry, which is neither a technology nor critical
Nope Brazil or USA is the ones who lead in cow husbandry
😂😂😂 What is cow husbandry😭😭
They are also loyal vassals of the west
Poodle 🐩 lapdogs of the West
There was no luck involved in the case of China. It was down to work ethic and doing what's right for the people and country, as opposed to what's right for a small rich elite.
Well, the only bit of luck China had was the Sino-Soviet split that led to the US stopping to actively trying to destroy China and opened business possibilities.
Oh yes there is luck. The Soviet lead us to ally china. Then the middle east distracted us for 30 years. Even now both Russia and middle east are still distracting. You can argue that these distractions are inevitable given us policies; however the timing is still lucky.
Rich Indians look up to Britain, adores the English n accept that they will always service the Empire..
Lol😂no one gives a damn about your britains existence
Let me say. UK warning India cannot open it economy and must wait for 1 hundreds years. Okay
From 2019~2022, the export from inland provinces of China grew faster than India, Vietnam and Mexico combined where most reviewer and politics thought the manufacturing industry relocation would go.
Adding on, the other reason that was India’s bureaucracy & red tapes for doing businesses is really a non starter. Especially with the many laws & regulations involving central, state & provincial government’s approval. They can change the law and regulations at any time in the name to protect India’s interest. Finally, India’s caste system & elite community is very much exist in background and has a very big part in any business venture.
incredible! superpower! india! ended _DE JURE_ Licence Raj and replaced it *with a FULL BLOWN OPEN KLEPTOCRACY.*
Meanwhile India heading to 4 trillion gdp and foreign companies even Tesla planning to set up new plant in India.
@arjunraj823 just wait and see…..
@@eskay2012 The Union of states is the power of India's growth. Each state competing for its own self sufficiency. The laws for starting businesses and attracting investments from foreign companies is now a competition among states especially south Indian states. Caste system is dead long ago. Companies need labour and migrants from poor states come to richer states irrespective of any caste or religion.
Don't forget China had gone through huge pain in its reform of 80s 90s and early 00s: a large number of factories went bankrunpcy and millions lost jobs or retired early, as result of adopting foreign investment and technology to level up its industry. Does Indian politician have the courage to do so? Most likely not.
中国在做和以前一样的事，为了发展互联网AI和新能源，淘汰了一堆传统行业，大量人破产。房地产崩坏。但是AI智能和新能源汽车得到大发展
India cannot achieve what china as in china its autocratic , meanwhile you cannot fathom the political complexity India has 100+ political party , centre has 1 and all states have different with main agenda of corruption , and all party is coalition which means more difficulty , also gov can't change laws or take away land by force as there will be vast protest. just think of farmer law which was there for helping farmers but we saw huge protest bloodshed as they don't want change , Just imagine the huge slums of Mumbai gov wants to remove them and relocate but oppositions don't let that happen , Fed up with nonsenses in india , But despite all these india shall shine at its own page
@@FutureAITrend Sure. India won't be next China, but for sure it will be next India.
The documentry was going so well, when he suggested China's economy will go down due to labour shortage. What rubbish. All advanced countries don't need that many worker. . Just look at the car industry, batteries, all the food industry, farming etc.
Why? Listen to Professor Jayant Bhandari.
India has a caste system that prevents talent to flourish.
I have never seen a Chinese UA-cam video bashing India or Indians. I do see lots of Indian channels bashing, hating China. Why is that?
Jealous
因为中国把印度笑话。
The inferior needs to act superior...
Under Modi, it was the opposite, spending money on war toys, executing Muslim and mistreat women…
Lol😂 completely wrong
It's an insult to the Chinese to compare them to India; first of all, India needs to build a comprehensive sewerage network so that no one poop on the roads & bushes again. Next, they need to provide clean water to wash themselves after they poop. Can you suggest getting the above mentioned built first? We Chinese are very different from other races. Am not going into that at length bcos you won't understand anyway. In any case, no nation on earth can emulate China's success totally nor surpass it in any way. Quality of government leaders and utmost integrity are very critical factors and the practice of meritocracy is only possible in Communist China. It's a dictatorship that works really hard for its people. Sounds cruel, right?
Even if you go 4000 years in future india will have more slums and somalia will be singapore
Hahaha nice dream there’s slums in China wmao 😂😂😂
Forget 4,000 years, come back here in 2030.
@@anime0965 it do not matter. Indian mind is in prison. These fools still building temples in USA for human face gods.
When China’s young are well educated including those from the countryside, there will never be shortage of young talents to take the country to the next level in the next generation.
Growing old workforce will not be an immediate issue. It might not even be an issue in the future.
Liken to Singapore’a low birth rate, an issue that’s quite well ratified with many government incentives and the inauguration of many new citizens.
India has not had Mao Zedong and Deng Xiaoping. Big countries have to reform their farming society to earn its first bucket of gold. Without a thorough land revolution, it's impossible to set free huge amount of population which is necessary for industrialization.
Another problem is that its own young and educated are either trying to get out of India (bringing its baggage with it too) or continue to perpetuate the bad “habits” and corruption continues forever. Lastly, Indian elites and educated and the rest in society must stop imitating the “British Raj & Colonial period” on its own People especially on the Poor.
China has gradually become more like East Asian economies such as Japan, South Korea and Hong Kong. The next level of India is Mexico or Philippines
Absolutely agree
It is not openly acknowledged but India is covertly a colony of the West and gets by on whatever work they outsource
A country with 200 parties and 400 languages was not easy to lead and manage.
Not even the late Lee Kuan Yew had any idea whatsoever to handle such a complecated country.
By the time India reaches China 🇨🇳 stage, China 🇨🇳 would have moved more another 30 years ahead
Man...for India reaching only China's current stage is ENOUGH for me.....but only with the Keralian government. I am Bengali though.
So difficult now for international investors to trust India when countries who use internet see a stereotype about Indians as scammers.
No India or China. You forgot ASEAN . Tremendous growth prospects here. Because everything sanctions in west can be assembled in ASEAN to avoid humongous import duty. China India and ASEAN will pull the financial centre of world to asia
The elimination of democracy as practced now with clever honest leaders, true meritocracy, lack of curruption, universal education, healthcare need to be achieved with good environmental standards for success.
China telah membuktikan.
India also suffer from irreparable ethnic divisions: just take Muslims, Sikhs, Tamils, Parsees, etc. & Hindus with their caste system. India can be broken up into smaller nations. That might well happen.
Caste system is worse than communism.
The CIA can easily make it happen if they are given instructions by the US government
Because these ethnic minorities didn't belong to this country before UK invaded this land....UK always left trouble to her former colonies!Shame on them!
Tianmen Square 😂😂
@@offred6013We all knew Tianmen Square was a colour revolution funded by Indian's master >US...Amitabha!
This century is a century of talent, not manpower.
Today's manufacturing industry has been replaced by robots.
Including taxi drivers who will soon be replaced by autonomous driving.
Labor-intensive industries will no longer need workers.
India's overpopulation is a liability, not an asset.
I think the author still needs to improve.
India may not be the next China. But America could be the next India. 😂😂😂
Large population may not be a good thing. That was why china had the one child policy to reduce the number of people.
so many factors not covered but mentioned in the comments that definitely show india will never overtake china.😊
India economy should be compared to US economy, not China. India economy must overtake US economy to become No.2, China will be No.1 by that time but will US allow India to be No.2.?
True
US will sanction India back to the stone age
Jayant Bandhari, an investor of Indian origin:
When people ask me "should I invest in India? I tell them : Don,t bother. Go to East Asia(Jp,chin,Sk,Tw,Hk,Sg)
Note that all these countries and regions have all been greatly influenced by Chinese culture and confucianism.
Yep. I watched that too. He even said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
Whoever this guy is, he is stupid. You could have gotten over 25% CAGR returns per year from 2013 till today, if you have invested carefully in Indian equity. He is the one missing out on mega-returns.
@@twilight6460 That is about as likely as China taking over Taiwan peacefully.
Took
US regime's inhumane decades of Sanction the reason why N. Korea ,Cuba, Venezuela has economic failure not the way you had portrayed in this vlog !
Apple moved phone factory to india...phones not up to standard..apple now only sells them in inda nobody else will buy them
Even many Indians don't buy them even if they could afford the price
@@twilight6460 Oh boy, why so much hate for India for just some assembly plants? Just don't buy apple products and don't talk about it. Let the rest of the world do as they please.
Astute reporting. A few dissenting voices amongst the many that hailed India as the next China or even greater than China. A lot of hype no doubt promoted by the West as a counter weight to China.
India as a nation is deeply divided by its cast system that discriminates its own people by skin color, language, race and beliefs. The north and the south simmers with racist differences (the Aryans, the Dravidians, the Sikhs, etc.) and disagreement over the use of Hindi as the national language. It is an 'artificial' nation, a time bomb waiting to explode.
Sir all these are excuses. The fact is indian politicians are so power hungry and corrupt to the core that it can never achieve any result with this kind of intimidating and extortionist system whatever we say and it has become very bad in last 5 years. A country where people celebrate demonetisation just becoz it will hit richer can never become prosper
😂lol caste system. India is not using that word much. Its you guys that keep reminding us that we have castes. When was the last time anyone was asked about his caste for a job interview!!
@@arjunraj823So true man. Castism is disappearing at a rapid pace and these guys keep on grinding on the same thing.
It's like a propaganda😅. No one even thinks of dravidians or Aryans.
India will be the next Pakistan more like.
Next Afghanistan
@@twilight6460bat eye lover
Dream on
Besides everything else, it would be a huge disaster for India to have such a large population in such a small landmass.
Don't worry, global warming is going to reduce India's population in the coming years. Just watch and see.
Small landmass? India is 7th largest country in the world. India has about the same size of fertile land as China. Unlike India, its China who has barren desert on like 40% of its land.
India has much better geography than Japan or Netherlands(both more densely populated) with more than 40% flat lands.
@@anime0965 China is currently only about 25% desert, due to a multi-decade afforestation / de-desertification program that's getting good results.
Indian likes to dream🐍
Ur Chinese moms get with Indian men we ur fathers 😂
Ur fav food chenk😂
Being chinese must be painful
In the past 3000 years of human history, did India ever surpass China one time? why? Indian is overconfident to its capability without looking back its history😂
In the past 3000 years, India was always ahead of China.
Europeans came looking for India not China. Why ?? Because the wealth of India was world renowned.
Native Americans are called Red Indians and not Red Chinese because of this reason. Nobody cared about China. It was just a country that existed East of India.
Chinese were mostly rice farmers for most of history. They have no influence on the world.
But Indian wealth, philosophy, culture, civilization is world renowned. From Central Asia to India to South East Asia to China to Japan and Korean, Indian culture influenced everyone. This is why even the Chinese study Buddha.
So India was always ahead of China. China should not become too arrogant because of American factories in China. Without becoming America's junior partner China would never have an economy.
So wise and also smart you are!
Lol
@@asmirann3636source trust me bro
@@asmirann3636 lol your lack of education is showing. China had contact with Europe through the silk road long before the British took over India. China made contact with the Africans before Europe started apartheid. China's economy has always been world #1 for 2000 years, while granted, India was #2. There were European missionaries and officials in China's courts working as painters and these are well known in history books. British went to India and easily took over the nation, because the Indian people were already so divided against each other. The 8 allied nations tried to take over China but failed even while China was at it's weakest during the dying Qing Dynasty AND while fighting the Japanese. Imagine being so proud of being colonised and your race being used as a racial term by the ignorant anglo saxxons to call another race they just massacred - Red Indians. Hahaha. There is absolutely no comparison so why don't you stop speaking out of your ass.
India is India, China is China. Both are unique and different. This is a very simple truth. So don't ask silly questions.
先于中国，墨西哥、巴西、阿根廷、印度、印度尼西亚等国都有潜力、机会、条件成为世界工厂，成为发达国家，为什么只有中国成功？最重要两点原因，一是人，二是制度！
Well said!
Two things India has to do to move forward (1) The caste system and (2) the master-servant mentality, i.e. still looking at the whites as Gods.
They forever worship white men
India needs four pillars service oriented system, social security, quality education and fair taxation system.
When i mean social security it is not only food and energy but safety eg woman in most of the cities dont feel safe
Not only woman man RE robbed day light@@NJBJ007
as long as one steps in cow pats ,,having rats sitting next to you ,and monkeys evrywhere not a chance and then theres the untouchables and othe religious obsticles problems need solving
In China u eat that 😂😂😂
the next China is.........CHINA , not poor india
Indian democracy and bureaucracy helps china greatly
I have NEVER seen any product that says " Made in India".
China is not a one party autocracy.
China has at least 7 political parties and they are all legitimate and have elected representative in the China Parliament.
Stick to the facts.
1 reason says it all. Chinese Communist Party have continuity wheras Indian Democratic Parties have disruption/elections every 5 years.
Democracy sucks
BUT SIR MY INDIA IS THE REAL SUPERPOWER NUMBER ONE🤗🇮🇳 WE HAVE THE BEST INFRASTRUCTURE AND HIGHSPEED RAIL 🤗🇮🇳 MEANWHILE IN CHINA PEOPLE STILL RIDE RICKSHAW EVERYWHERE AND THEY ALSO POOR DONT HAVE CAR . THIS WHY IM SO LUCKY LIVE IN SUPER INDIA THE CLEANEST COUNTRY IN THE WORLD 🇮🇳🤗 , WE NEVER SCAM! WE GIVE RESPECT TO ALL WOMEN THEY CAN WALK SAFELY ALONE AT NIGHT AND WE HAVE CLEAN FOOD AND TOILET EVERYWHERE 🇮🇳🤗🚽, I KNOW MANY POOR PEOPLE JEALOUS WITH SUPER RICH INDIA 🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
DEMOCRACY IS WEAKNESS
YEP.
DEMOCRACY SUCKS
@fuzzywuzzy0549No where it works... China soon be overtaking US 🤡... keep coping
If I were an Indian I would feel ashamed to compare India with China. The gap in every sector of the two countries where China is very far ahead is just too wide to mention and more so to even want to compare. Please do not ever bring up this subject of comparison again. If you do, it shows you have been living in the jungle for the past 30 years. ndia cannot even build enough toilet as a human basic right for his people as the link provide here {what a shame} #opendefecation Latest report from IMF on China contribution to the world economy.According to the IMF’s World Economic Outlook (WEO) report in October, global economic output is forecast to expand by 3% this year, to which China is expected to contribute 0.9 percentage point, Barnett said.
He made the remarks at a launch of the publication in Beijing last Friday. The event was organised by the IMF Resident Representative Office in China and the International Monetary Institute at the Renmin University of China.
By comparison, the United States is forecast to contribute 0.3 percentage point while India’s contribution might be 0.5 percentage point, Barnett told China Daily on the sidelines of the event.
On 2024, China is forecast to contribute 0.8 percentage point of the 2.9% global growth, just under one-third and still higher than 0.2 percentage point of the United States and 0.5 percentage point of India, he said.
The WEO, published lastTuesday, has lowered the 2023 economic growth forecast for China to 5% from 5.2%, citing the pressures brought by the weakness in the real estate sector
Both countries have more than 1.4 billion population and most populated in the world.
There are surveyed that shown the results below:
Worker productivity:
Chinese is 1.6 of Indian. Which meant 60% higher than Indian.
Average IQ for both countries comparison.
Chinese 104, India 76
Women in workforce:
China 61%, India 23%
Education ranking in the world:
China at 22. India at 32.
Education ranking is way off. If you look at the last PISA education assessment in 2018, China (B-S-J-Z) ranked #1, whereas India (TN) ranked #72 out of 73.
Global Hunger Index: China ranked 0 (no hunger) where India ranked #111 out of 125
Great and truthful comments 👍🏼👍👍🏾👍🏻
China is Meritocratic NOT Autocratic! There is big difference between the two! And India will never surpass China, unless it goes through its own socialist revolution, which I dont see happening any time soon
India will be the next Bangladesh
Next Afghanistan
@@twilight64601967😂
@@twilight6460China is next egg wee eating capital 😂
The workforce problem of India is, once young people got educated, they will move to countries like US and Canada, while many Chinese young students are blocked by those countries’ strict immigration policies and they will have to go back to China. That’s how Americans help!
Ethnic and religious division is deepening in India which may lead to problems for India.
Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
@@twilight6460Because india is black
@@twilight6460 I wish India to be a peaceful country.
China today is a result of a few thousand years of continuoss civilization. It has not happened over the last few decades. Even the Mongols who come from a nomadic culture settled in China when they experience the quality and sophistication of the Chinese culture. China has a long history of gathering experience in managing and looking after a large population. If this is not the case their population would not have grown to this scale. China wasn't waiting for Carl Marks to save them or for that matter democracy especially introduced to them from the west when all can see it is not even skin deep and has become a meaningless word not even a fig leaf.
I don't think India can manage to rise as China has bcs Britain introduced the divide and rule policy "democracy" and abolished their ruling system which has been evolving over a few thousand years. Noteworthy to say Churchill past away still not believing that Gandi wasn't being given food, secretly, while he was on his hunger strike!
It is worth noting China and India two great civilization over five thousand years bordering each other never waged war against each other but the contrary they cooperated. But in the present "democracy" in India means India is worried about China and not about America who has been dropping bombs in Asia as if its running out of fashion. Whilst China is only worried about America building a base on its border in India overlooking China.
India will be the next Bharat.
The big stumbling blocks to India's rapid progress are religious fanaticism,, burgeoning population, corrupt short sighted politicians who instead of addressing these problems tries to take advantage of it by making lop sided laws to create votebanks and encouraging mai-baap sarkar where politicians give themselves powers to grant or withhold favours. The Judiciary where the individuals are interested in grandstanding rather than address speedy justice.
China already become developed country (china doesn't admit it), India still developing country. India has a more poor peoples,bad working culture,bad goverment policy for business,etc. Still long way to catch up china.
China is developing , average GDP is not higher enough
The problem is India dosent have jobs in urban areas and thats is hampering rapid urbanization. We have massive unemployment problem. So even if government stop rural welfare schems they will not be able to move into urban areas
For anyone wondering why the comments are like this, this comment section is a case study of the typical thought process of the chinese people.
Wdym? They are racist
Though India cannot be the next China but she can easily be the next Soviet Union; broken up into fifteen nations.😂😂😂😂
😂😂
You just humiliated the Soviet Union. There is no comparison possible. The USSR is not the vassal of the USA, in addition it faced America and surpassed it in space, weapons and nuclear power. While India absolutely does not outperform any of the poor neighboring countries.
Indians lQ :78
Chinese lQ :108
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lol
Jayant Bhandari an Indian himself said : India will eventually disintegrate into many smaller countries
印度比中国更先进一些：印度人在未发展民型时，排放的污染已经超过了处于成熟期的中国。印度人在经济处于第五位时，心里想的已经是什么时候能够超过第二名，成为第一名。
印度人思维总是走在中国人前面：中国人会等驴子拉完磨才会杀掉，而印度人在驴子还没拉完时就已经杀掉了（华为，小米，OV等在印度建厂没几年就被以各种理由没收财产，印度人产业建立起来了吗？）
哈哈哈哈哈