Pérotin le Grand - Viderunt omnes - David Munrow

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 190

  • @timothyissler3815
    @timothyissler3815 4 роки тому +190

    Takes 2 minutes to get through "Viderunt", another minutes to finish "Omnes"...
    This is great.

  • @naurbro9839
    @naurbro9839 Рік тому +23

    love this so much. I remember when I had musical history class and this song was always the one we remembered the most.

    • @RobotAdoresHer
      @RobotAdoresHer 7 місяців тому +4

      Literally using this video to study for my exam tomorrow. ;>

  • @barrysmith7710
    @barrysmith7710 Рік тому +19

    Quite extraordinary to think it lasts 12 minutes, has no backbeat or accompaniment yet never loses its drive or tempo.

  • @barrysmith7734
    @barrysmith7734 2 роки тому +69

    Extraordinary, 800 years later. Should have been a single

    • @philruane5910
      @philruane5910 2 роки тому +5

      Was the first British hit song. Remnants of it on parchment have been found all over mainland Britain.

    • @barrysmith7710
      @barrysmith7710 Рік тому

      @@hlavolamm What, and have it available for posterity and for people all around the world to be able to hear it any time? And then his royalties? I think he'd be quite chuffed all told

  • @edouardchan8719
    @edouardchan8719 Рік тому +6

    there is something cheeky, lively and witty about all this, makes me believe that the medieval man had a sense of musical humour

  • @yvesmaze6078
    @yvesmaze6078 4 роки тому +16

    En 2019, l'édifice a brûlé, mais la musique qu'il fit naître est restée...

  • @clasesdemusica-profelorena6096
    @clasesdemusica-profelorena6096 2 роки тому +41

    if only I had a time machine, I would travel to a time like this, to see how they lived and them singing

    • @philruane5910
      @philruane5910 2 роки тому +4

      I would love to do that too. I’d go to the foundations of my local cathedral in Peterborough England. Its so beautiful and seriously architecturally complex. 900 years ago they did it. We cant do it the same now. …….

    • @philruane5910
      @philruane5910 2 роки тому +1

      And watching them build the cathedrals….

    • @julianholman7379
      @julianholman7379 2 роки тому +2

      Yes the 1960s when all this ancient music was being rediscovered must have been wonderful

    • @nicolascorre6830
      @nicolascorre6830 Рік тому +3

      To die of a cold, variole, or the plague. These were arch times.

    • @rsmania01
      @rsmania01 Рік тому +2

      @@nicolascorre6830at least there weren’t any pregnant men

  • @AuroraHyperborea
    @AuroraHyperborea 4 роки тому +22

    Years pass.. and I keep listening to this incredible recording

  • @MS-xp4xm
    @MS-xp4xm 4 роки тому +9

    grandissimo! perotinus! il primo grande compositore!! quando ero giovane, studiavo la musica e vivevo in siberia. ma potevo studiare solo gli spartiti di perotinus. mancavano registrazioni: anni 80. per la prima volta ho ascoltato dal vivo la musica di perotinis in germania in un festival di musica sacra. adesso perotinos é per tutti! grazie a you-tube!!

    • @ChristianJiang
      @ChristianJiang 3 роки тому

      Viveva in Siberia? Molto interessante la sua storia!

    • @MS-xp4xm
      @MS-xp4xm 3 роки тому +2

      @@ChristianJiang Sono nato in Siberia. Ho cominciato i miei studi musicali a Novosibirsk. È una grande città, dove ci sono il Teatro d'Opera Lirica più grande della Russia (novat), la filarmonica, un conservatorio, due (?) istituiti di musica e tantissime scuole di musica. Vivo in Italia da quasi 30 anni.

    • @ChristianJiang
      @ChristianJiang 3 роки тому +1

      @@MS-xp4xm Grazie mille, molto interessante. Io studio russo… Alcuni dei miei amici ora sono a Novosibirsk per poter imparare la lingua più in fretta e ho visto delle foto stupende della città. Io non sono riuscito ad andare in Russia… Sono finito a Bishkek, in Kirghizistan

    • @MS-xp4xm
      @MS-xp4xm 3 роки тому

      @@ChristianJiang Interessante!! Bravo!!!

  • @louisrelf5903
    @louisrelf5903 5 років тому +35

    I know I’m late but I want to let you know that my heart is with you, France. What a tragedy.
    Best wishes from the UK

    • @ZephaniahL
      @ZephaniahL Рік тому +2

      If only medieval musicians such as Perotin were around to fire the hearts of a new generation of crusaders to finish the job.

    • @Sundayletsplay
      @Sundayletsplay 9 місяців тому +1

      @@ZephaniahL let’s start our own? Deus vult

    • @ZephaniahL
      @ZephaniahL 9 місяців тому +2

      @@Sundayletsplay Avec plaisir!

  • @Lukasmssl
    @Lukasmssl 3 роки тому +81

    Cured my depressions

    • @philruane5910
      @philruane5910 2 роки тому +11

      Mine too. Im not religious but i often visit my local 900 year old cathedral in Peterborough. The choir there is besutiful

    • @DavidKiamba-tv8oy
      @DavidKiamba-tv8oy Рік тому

      What it's giving me a headache😂

    • @berndmensing8707
      @berndmensing8707 10 місяців тому +3

      ​@@DavidKiamba-tv8oy
      So, stay keeping with Hiphop and stuff...

    • @themaninblack1316
      @themaninblack1316 Місяць тому

      Amen amen 🙌

  • @drtee51
    @drtee51 7 років тому +62

    David Munrow was amazing with this Medieval organum. He really bought this stuff to life. What a tragic loss his death was!

    • @christianhales176
      @christianhales176 7 років тому +1

      Pirotinus? He's been dead a long time...

    • @raphael.cavalcanti3301
      @raphael.cavalcanti3301 6 років тому +5

      Christian Hales no. David Munrow

    • @philruane5910
      @philruane5910 Рік тому +4

      David Munrow got me into this. Bout six year ago Radio3 first time. I listen now to medieval music, St Cecelia choir.

    • @annamariaricci2143
      @annamariaricci2143 5 місяців тому

      ​@@philruane5910kkm⁹l9😊

  • @ellismiller9707
    @ellismiller9707 11 років тому +22

    A master work of vocal music but yet so simple

  • @Polomokipo23
    @Polomokipo23 10 років тому +40

    Eternel grandiose la musique médiévale avec Perotin Machaut Léonin Landini La Halle Le chancelier Bologna De Vitry Et tant d autres merci UA-cam.

    •  6 років тому +1

      Só faltou Von Bingen neste panteão, apesar dela ser Alemã! Abraços de um amigo do Brasil!

  • @EsWirdSandRegnen
    @EsWirdSandRegnen 9 років тому +36

    This performance is incredibly good!

  • @giulioandreetta4226
    @giulioandreetta4226 4 роки тому +57

    Perotinus, the first true composer in the modern sense, and one of my favorite musicians. Incredible how close his music appears to a certain minimalism. In fact he is a composer much loved by Steve Reich, who was inspired by him for his composition Proverb. A composer in advance of 800 years, that's not a little I would say ...

    • @yunoewig3095
      @yunoewig3095 3 роки тому +8

      He is not 800 years in advance, rather, he is timeless.

    • @MRL8770
      @MRL8770 2 роки тому +5

      I knew this reminded me of some modern compsitions, but I could put my finger on the exact example. Then as soon as you mentioned Steve Reich, it just made sense.

    • @jeanmcaneny6951
      @jeanmcaneny6951 2 роки тому +3

      I can hear it! (In Reich’s works.) Once tried to sight-sing a Perotinus work with my EM chorus - fiendishly tricky. But fantastic to hear some pros doing justice to this one.

    • @Rickriquinho
      @Rickriquinho Рік тому

      Please, don't be ridiculous!

    • @R4DZERO
      @R4DZERO 8 місяців тому

      Apparently he isn't the first, it would be Hildegard von bingen

  • @kenpokid10
    @kenpokid10 14 днів тому

    Merry Christmas to all my medieval music nerds who came to listen to this BANGER

  • @kemberleigh8680
    @kemberleigh8680 6 років тому +10

    I do enjoy this song and how beautiful it is,but having to listen to it at 8am along with 6 other songs for my music class makes me want to fall asleep with how peaceful it is.

    • @taylordiclemente5163
      @taylordiclemente5163 4 роки тому +3

      It will stick with you for the rest of your life.

    • @NoctuaOlivae
      @NoctuaOlivae 3 роки тому

      I stumbled upon this randomly so idk if all music was like this back then, but I feel like it's got a very soothing quality to it.

    • @philruane5910
      @philruane5910 2 роки тому

      Hope it went well

  • @Alice_in_Subatomic_Land
    @Alice_in_Subatomic_Land Рік тому +9

    Vīdērunt omnēs fīnēs terræ
    salūtāre Deī nostrī.
    Jubilāte Deō, omnis terra.
    Notum fēcit Dominus salūtāre suum;
    ante conspectum gentium
    revelāvit justitiam suam.
    English
    All the ends of the earth have seen
    the prosperity of our God.
    Rejoice in the Lord, all lands.
    The Lord has made known his prosperity;
    in the sight of the nations
    he has revealed his righteousness.

  • @robcmstephens
    @robcmstephens 5 років тому +5

    Wow - just came here after hearing Voces8 at the Proms this week. I have heard David Munrow’s Instrumental stuff but i confess nothing Choral. How fantastic a sound- and of course I’m not only person to say what a loss to the world of music.

  • @pierresentenac
    @pierresentenac 6 років тому

    La beauté sonore première commence-là, avec des oeuvres comme les viderunt omnes et sederunt principes de Léonin comme de Pérotin.
    On est saisi d'une pure émotion par ces cantus firmus, ces chants célestes intemporels...
    La suite de l'ère musicale jusqu'à nos jours s'est sérieusement embourbée, engluée...
    La simplicité du chant et l'envoûtement produit sont la fibre même de notre être!
    Bien sûr, on ne peut que féliciter,admirer David Munrow qui reste la référence de ces pages musicales exceptionnelles... il nous ramène dans l'esprit, à l'époque Notre-Dame, voyage merveilleux vers ces premiers temps!

    • @rayancharafeddine4982
      @rayancharafeddine4982 5 років тому

      Personellement les pieces engluées de Bach me touche plus qu'un cantus firmus tout simple

  • @GreenLegendRan
    @GreenLegendRan 3 роки тому +4

    It's nice to see so many reflection's on Munrow and this beautiful music. It's sad to see so many people come here and only reflect on the burning of a building. It's nice to then see newer posts continuing to venerate the music.

  • @govindarajulu-kasturi9614
    @govindarajulu-kasturi9614 5 років тому +3

    Beautiful rendition.
    Thanks.

  • @ericdraven2219
    @ericdraven2219 5 років тому +4

    wish i couldve went to see something simular to this before it burnt down never got to i love this style of music folks dont understand how i can like this style of music considering the type of person i am its unexpected i love it because it puts me in a place i can meditate and release what stress overcomes me

    • @philruane5910
      @philruane5910 2 роки тому +1

      Its eternal music Eric. Sounds as fresh n relevant as it did back then. Thats why it survives.

  • @RedCloudSophie25
    @RedCloudSophie25 5 років тому +4

    Un joyau musical du Moyen Âge, le son est excellent, merci 😊

  • @florencemartinlemanach2549
    @florencemartinlemanach2549 5 років тому +8

    Comment peut-on encore croire que nous sommes plus "évolués" que les personnes de cette époque...

  • @crrkleven
    @crrkleven 6 місяців тому +4

    "Alright class, what letter comes after U?"
    0:00

  • @jesussendra6540
    @jesussendra6540 3 роки тому +3

    Todos vieron y no sé cuántas veces van y van y otra vez igual como siempre se hace imposible acudir a otra versión diferente a la del maestro Munrow: un portento.

  • @jobstludwig6197
    @jobstludwig6197 Рік тому

    Wunderbare, kraftvolle, inspirierte, geniale Musik. ❤❤❤

  • @pamelacrosson
    @pamelacrosson 7 років тому +11

    Don't understand that language but I do appreciate the music The message is the same regardless. Awesome job choirs. Amen

  • @jeremy_pln
    @jeremy_pln 4 дні тому

    Un vrai GOAT ce Pérotin

  • @lorenzodesantis7548
    @lorenzodesantis7548 2 роки тому

    Every Christmas this Is a must! Viderunt omnes fines terrae salutare Dei nostri!

  • @W.H.V.
    @W.H.V. Рік тому

    The Christmas spirit just isn't complete without it

  • @twosweethounds
    @twosweethounds 5 років тому +2

    "Vaste symphonie en pierre, pour ainsi dire ; œuvre colossale d’un homme et d’un peuple, tout ensemble une et complexe comme les Iliades et les Romanceros dont elle est sœur ; produit prodigieux de la cotisation de toutes les forces d’une époque, où sur chaque pierre on voit saillir en cent façons la fantaisie de l’ouvrier disciplinée par le génie de l’artiste ; sorte de création humaine, en un mot, puissante et féconde comme la création divine dont elle semble avoir dérobé le double caractère : variété, éternité." -Victor Hugo

  • @peaceharmony4115
    @peaceharmony4115 5 років тому +19

    With regards to the burning of Notre Dame:
    Let us not despair. The great Cathedrals have suffered fires before. Notre Dame de Paris will be rebuilt, as it has been before, as so many other ancient temples of Christianity and Christian culture have before. No great Cathedral was built within merely a few years -- most were built over the space of several centuries, with different materials and techniques, all in service of extraordinary beauty representing the glory of God.
    As we enjoy this wonderful work from Pérotin, the first great master of polyphony, let us rejoice and be grateful for all the culture and history which we have inherited.

    • @swaglord5909
      @swaglord5909 4 роки тому +1

      nobody cares shut the fuck up

    • @acuppatea7366
      @acuppatea7366 4 роки тому +4

      @@swaglord5909 Just because the internet makes you anonymous doesn't mean you can go around being a jerk to people.. Sensibility and respect are greatly appreciated qualities.

    • @swaglord5909
      @swaglord5909 4 роки тому +1

      @@acuppatea7366 haha fire make big church go brrr

  • @petegarvey9224
    @petegarvey9224 4 роки тому +7

    Classic performance: as noted below, always great life in Munrow's performances. Most since are rather too slow for me.

  • @jordan3461
    @jordan3461 8 років тому +5

    no estaba destinado a ser comprendido, ya que eran textos que todos los monjes conocían: más bien se buscaba una conexión mística y espiritual en voces comunes conjuntas, cada cual ejecutando su parte en proporciones matemáticas y plásticas perfectas; era una suerte de "mantra" cristiano...

  • @taylordiclemente5163
    @taylordiclemente5163 4 роки тому +1

    It doesn't get any better.

  • @Calm.Serene.
    @Calm.Serene. 3 роки тому +3

    I hate that the first thing that came to mind while listening to this was Peter Griffin’s laughter.

  • @gabordobrocsi5368
    @gabordobrocsi5368 26 днів тому

    Danke!

  • @anguscos4506
    @anguscos4506 3 роки тому +6

    Que people coming from adam neely

  • @philruane5910
    @philruane5910 2 роки тому +1

    Good for your soul this

  • @foliabadinerie
    @foliabadinerie 6 років тому +3

    ¡Sublime! Gracias por compartir.

  • @seanmarshall7529
    @seanmarshall7529 4 роки тому

    I just discovered David munrow.... perotin.... a while back.. but such an interesting interpretation, specially the Sederunt principes.. took me a while to find out that what I was listening to was sung by David's people. what I question is the choice of this mode of singing. Viz Gilles Binchois, whose Notre Dam Mass is non plus ultra, chose a different approach to Perotin... more of an antique Mediterranean.. shout nasal screech.

    • @taylordiclemente5163
      @taylordiclemente5163 4 роки тому +1

      Educated guesses, all...

    • @seanmarshall7529
      @seanmarshall7529 4 роки тому +1

      @@taylordiclemente5163 artistic choices

    • @philruane5910
      @philruane5910 Рік тому

      How is this not perfect?

    • @seanmarshall7529
      @seanmarshall7529 Рік тому +1

      @@philruane5910 why should it be? What is perfection? The Swiss wanted to produce one of their famous cheeses with the utmost attention to cleanlines. I think it was a gruyere which has tiny bubbles... Well they produced cheeses without any bubbles... Imperfection is a cool thing, perfection does not belong to our world...

  • @myguitardidyermom212
    @myguitardidyermom212 4 місяці тому

    In my mind, I aways associate God's presence with cool humid morings in a forest, after a spring rain just as the warmth of sun starts evaporating the moisturbut before the heat of the day has settled in. Life is bustling everwhere after spending it's proverbial 3 days in the tomb of winter, in the green vegetation and the singing birds and the sizzling voices of the bees and the other insects. A raggedy spiderweb with trapped drops of dew shining like diamands in the sunshine
    This performance sounds exactly like like that

  • @jouanardgil1292
    @jouanardgil1292 8 років тому +8

    La question de savoir si un Dieu existe ou pas est finalement très subsidiaire. Le génie de l'animal humain suffit à nous réjouir et à susciter notre admiration. Il se peut même qu'il soit allé jusqu'à en susciter l'existence virtuelle, de ce Dieu qu'il aurait ainsi créé à sa propre image, selon son meilleur profil, à lui, Primate prodigieux.

    • @michella1913
      @michella1913 7 років тому +3

      J'espère du fond du cœur qu'un jour Dieu vous enverra les grâces nécessaires à vous faire ouvrir les yeux.

    • @clementjb
      @clementjb 6 років тому

      Jouanard: Bien dit, élégamment.

    • @tunat6106
      @tunat6106 6 років тому

      Etre ou ne pas être ? Telle est la substantifique moelle cosmogonique unissant l'irréconciliable au sein du coeur de l'homme, écrasé par la dialectique métaphysique de l'humain et de l'animal réuni enfin par Jesus-Christ de Nazareth notre sauveur jusqu'au septs trompettes sonnant le bout de l'éternité à l'heure ou le ciel et la terre seront balayés par un tourbillon, faisant frémir les pêcheurs (ainsi que les charcutiers)

  • @Lukasmssl
    @Lukasmssl 3 роки тому +1

    I Listen to this when im lonely

  • @MatteoPizzarello
    @MatteoPizzarello 10 місяців тому

    I would liek to use this for a hsort film for a competition do you know who should I ask for the copyright permission?

  • @wftjet
    @wftjet 6 місяців тому

    You can hear how Christmas carols like In dulci jubilo come from this style

  • @tomschneider9052
    @tomschneider9052 9 років тому +5

    I want the lyrics pls :) love that song~so deep♡

    • @nylonius
      @nylonius 8 років тому +13

      "Viderunt omnes fines terreae salutare Dei nostri: Jubilate Deos omnia terra. - Notum fecit Dominus salutare suum; ante conspectum gentium revelavit justitiam suam."

  • @danielegarella3409
    @danielegarella3409 Рік тому

    semplicemente perfetto

  • @annebomba
    @annebomba 5 років тому +9

    Such beauty. . . . Gone up in flames :(

  • @florencemartinlemanach2549
    @florencemartinlemanach2549 5 років тому +1

    Allégresse et énergie pures

  • @marystandinger9498
    @marystandinger9498 4 роки тому +24

    This shit slaps

  • @SmoofPro
    @SmoofPro 5 років тому +39

    Listening during the horrifying scenes of Notre-Dames de Paris on fire...

    • @twosweethounds
      @twosweethounds 5 років тому +2

      "Viderunt omnes fines terrae -- All the ends of the earth have seen." Indeed.

  • @philruane5910
    @philruane5910 Рік тому

    At what church/cathedral were the accompany photos taken? Thanks.

    • @Liam-vu6uv
      @Liam-vu6uv Рік тому +1

      Notre Dame in Paris France

  • @Lukasmssl
    @Lukasmssl 3 роки тому

    Thats history Right there

  • @Oliver_twist00
    @Oliver_twist00 5 місяців тому +1

    my girlfriend says gregorian chats go hard as fuck, didnt believe her till this

  • @sofiavirgilio6055
    @sofiavirgilio6055 4 роки тому +1

    Lindo demais❤️

  • @Lukasmssl
    @Lukasmssl 3 роки тому

    I LOVE IT

  • @Yarglish
    @Yarglish 5 років тому

    superbe !

  • @fareskazou256
    @fareskazou256 3 роки тому +11

    I'm eleven years old but I like this music

  • @philruane5910
    @philruane5910 Рік тому

    This is the time i give myself,

  • @danielmiller7191
    @danielmiller7191 5 років тому +17

    Who else is listening as the Cathedral of Notre Dame burns? :'(

    • @charlestimbrell1728
      @charlestimbrell1728 5 років тому +2

      Listening now...an amazing spiritual experience.....

    • @samuelmamdouh
      @samuelmamdouh 5 років тому +2

      So sad

    • @Popesize
      @Popesize 5 років тому

      Notre Dame is so much more than just a Cathedral. It's also Art, history, relics and treasures. And that is why it must be rebuilt! Such symbols of grandness on both earth and in Heaven, can not, shall not, be a ruin! It will prevail through time!

  • @philruane5910
    @philruane5910 Рік тому +1

    If you like this music, i like you.

  • @titusbonditafichazo5327
    @titusbonditafichazo5327 4 роки тому

    *Mencionado en el gran libro "temas de cultura musical" de Carrillo*

  • @anthonyjackalone1846
    @anthonyjackalone1846 26 днів тому

    MUS350- Western Classcial Music pre-1750 brought me here.

    • @Tracotel
      @Tracotel  26 днів тому

      What is 'MUS350- Western Classcial Music pre-1750'?

  • @julierodriguez7593
    @julierodriguez7593 9 років тому +10

    all the ends of the earth have seen the salvation of our god praise god all the earth the lord has made known his salvation before the face of the people he has revealed his justice

  • @ashleyetienne5301
    @ashleyetienne5301 4 роки тому

    hermosa

  • @philruane5575
    @philruane5575 3 роки тому

    Englands first national number one in the hit parade.

  • @Liam-vl9cy
    @Liam-vl9cy 4 роки тому +5

    i come from school who else

  • @Lukasmssl
    @Lukasmssl 3 роки тому

    🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @jl8217
    @jl8217 Місяць тому

    Written in 1198....

  • @TheAuralab
    @TheAuralab 4 роки тому

    💚

  • @osyntjustmz6670
    @osyntjustmz6670 6 років тому +2

    G kiffe le clip

  • @ronnieparkerscott6223
    @ronnieparkerscott6223 4 роки тому +1

    ...and nobody played synthesizer...

  • @Lukasmssl
    @Lukasmssl 3 роки тому

    VEST THING I EVER HEARD

  • @concars1234
    @concars1234 5 років тому +1

    Jubilate Deo, omnis terra

  • @andreavillegas6719
    @andreavillegas6719 9 років тому +2

    Discantus !!

    • @iJimjerk
      @iJimjerk 6 років тому +1

      It's not discantus

  • @Бьюти-э2я
    @Бьюти-э2я 4 роки тому

    👍👍

  • @philruane5575
    @philruane5575 3 роки тому

    The rose window

  • @florencemartinlemanach2549
    @florencemartinlemanach2549 5 років тому

    merci !

  • @hankbellows
    @hankbellows 6 років тому +1

    Why are there so many frenchmen in the comments?

  • @robinrehlinghaus1944
    @robinrehlinghaus1944 3 роки тому +2

    Hihihihihihi, hihihihihi, hihihihihi...

  • @Silentium141
    @Silentium141 6 років тому

    Vase de Noces

  • @Lukasmssl
    @Lukasmssl 3 роки тому

    Deep

  • @grasonpeterson8305
    @grasonpeterson8305 28 днів тому

    Viiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii

  • @hernansoto7392
    @hernansoto7392 3 роки тому +2

    Minecraft

  • @flamone2107
    @flamone2107 4 роки тому

    se lat détant

  • @iulius482
    @iulius482 6 років тому +4

    steve reich ha ha

    • @whistlepixie
      @whistlepixie 5 років тому

      Actually Terry Riley's 'In C' was on the same programme as this in a concert I was once involved in (Melbourne, 2012)...

  • @gomar8407
    @gomar8407 6 років тому

    trolour

  • @benjaminsh4882
    @benjaminsh4882 5 років тому

  • @janusxvi1377
    @janusxvi1377 5 років тому

    Hehehehehe DE

  • @swaglord5909
    @swaglord5909 5 років тому

    Hihihihi hii hii

  • @marie-odileledanois2078
    @marie-odileledanois2078 5 років тому +1

    Se taire et écouter.

  • @plasticsamalt6633
    @plasticsamalt6633 5 років тому +1

    פרנק זאפה יותר טוב

  • @karl7108
    @karl7108 9 років тому +2

    Cold, occasionally dissonant beyond authenticity, "modernized".

    • @azerty200893
      @azerty200893 9 років тому +2

      +Karl What do you mean ?

    • @domainofthesun4400
      @domainofthesun4400 9 років тому +2

      +Karl can you explain your comment for us non musicians? Can you point us to what you believe to be a more authentic performance? (on YT or wherever we can hear it)

    • @karl7108
      @karl7108 9 років тому +1

      Susan A. Greetings Susan. Thank You for Your question. Aggressive dissonance does not belong to authentic spiritual music. This performance sounds occasionally even chaotic, what definitely does not reflect authentic harmony in spiritual music. Best regards.

    • @karl7108
      @karl7108 9 років тому

      ***** Please compare it to other, authentic medieval works.

    • @domainofthesun4400
      @domainofthesun4400 9 років тому +2

      +Karl Thanks for taking the time to reply. As a nonmusician I'm not able to detect what you believe to be chaotic. If it's not too much trouble are you able to point to what is a better performance in your view? I'm sincerely interested in the question of authenticity, but I have no musical education apart from many, many years of listening. This performance does have a harsh quality which I frankly enjoy, because I enjoy being disturbed (at times) by music, but perhaps that is the wrong response for music like this to elicit. Thanks again

  • @ActuallyJozu
    @ActuallyJozu 2 роки тому +1

    This shit slaps