BYU vs Utah 2013 - 6 most controversial plays
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 жов 2024
- Holding call on kick return - Q1 1:16
Norwood not touching the punt - Q2 11:28
Thorton trying to fake a PI - Q4 10:57
Tip ball after the PI - Q4 10:05
Alisa clearly not in the endzone on the touchdown - Q4 5:13
Mathews takes down Porter - Q4 0:00
University of Utah vs. Brigham Young University
September 21, 2013
It seems to me that every time these 2 teams play, there are very interesting calls and no calls...
It's hilarious that this video is supposed to be as though BYU got screwed, but it actually shows the only bad call was the one that benefited BYU
regattachampion the title only says they were controversial calls, not that by got screwed over... Sure the fans were upset but it was at BYU, what did you expect? I think you should have thought a little more before commenting...
Bruh it's a video made by a U fan titled "controversial" plays from a game the U won. It clearly wasnt meant to seem like that.
Not what I saw
Matthews was held obviously before he pulled Porter down
From a completely unbiased person that is only going of the calls and video evidence here is my opinion
1. Holding on kick return: Holding may not have been the right call but there was defiantly clipping and it should have been called back either way
2. Norwood Not touching the punt: I really don't see him touch it, and the ball does not change direction at all so it seems like a right call
3. Thorton trying to fake a PI: Didn't even see this part in the video?
4. Tip Ball after the PI: I see the pass interference before I see the tip so I think there should have been a PI flag
5. Alisa clearly not in endzone: as it says he clearly was not in, that was a bad call
6. Matthews takes down Porter: There should have been a flag for offensive pass interference but that dosen't affect anything the game would still be over
Disagree on every single one
This game was so frustrating to watch in person... a disappointment of a season, but at least Utah was slated by ESPN as an enigmatic loss.
Why is it just because somethings BYU people start judging our religious beliefs? This is about football and a rivalry not about being "mormons" or not!
and byu has beat utah way more times then utah has beat them. just to let you no
First, off. Learn to write. Second, Utah owns the lead over the history of the rivalry, clearly. Third, stop acting like the a petulant child. Lastly, you're only a "mid-major." Until you've beat the Mighty Utah Machine, then you can brag. Peace.
@Ian Peay, You must not have read up on the history of the football rivalry. Utah leads the overall football rivalry series against BYU, 62-34! There's proof on the Wikipedia. Also, every year when the Utes and cougars played in football; all of national t.v. stations have said that Utah leads the rivalry series over BYU.
Why does the PAC 12 bring their reds to every away game? This video answers that question...
#1: I don't see holding but the refs must've seen it if they called it.
#2: He didn't touch the ball.
#3: idk not on the video
#4: terrible call. all the pi was before the ball was tipped
#5: terrible call. his elbow hit the ground and the ball was clearly not in the end zone.
#6: good call. matthews brought the guy down because he is what his first name rhymes with
(BYU fan here) I like the no call on #6 because Matthews clearly does pull the defender down, but there was a bit of contact even before that that could have been called defensive holding or PI. Again, I don't think Matthews pulling the defender on top of him should be rewarded so I like the no call.
No one could tell if the ball was touched on the punt that's why the call should've stayed same as it was on the field and that was a touchdown
#4 he did touch it 2:46
I was at this game and every call was made correctly. The officials did a fantastic job only to have the dumbass byu fans throw trash like immature brats. Glad Utah has moved on to Michigan for two years, maybe Byu will grow up but I doubt it.
Ian, thats y Utah leads the series against BYU 57-34-4 and has won the last 4 games.
That ball was thrown out of bounds. Good no call.
The refs were Pac 12 affiliate. Blame your own conference for your win.
but those stupid refs called stupid calls
i guess those tithings didnt go to paying the refs. GO UTES
Kyle Hofmeister lol, I'm a BYU fan, but that was a BOMB comment. I've been laughing for a minute now! Well played my friend! 😂
What is controversial about these?!?
Ralph Wiggam so funny how hypocritical Ute fans are. When was the last time BYU thought they would ever win the National championship or even be considered for it? Probably 2001. Ute fans however thing they’ll win the pac 12 every year, yet they still have the same amount of Championships as BYU. Fuck you Utah fans
@@aternis3597 aww is somebody mad their college football team sucks :,(
@@dr.stinklenuts904 were #8 in the nation and have a heisman quarterback, I’m not mad at all bud
@@aternis3597 probably cause there are 8 total teams playing this year lmao
@@aternis3597 ha, yeah just looked at the schedule for byu this year and I wasn’t suprised to see that you guys played some colleges I’ve never heard of. The hardest opponent on there is utsa and byu still only won by 7. Put some real opponents on there and i might take you seriously
You win and you STILL whine!
#1 I can't tell. Refs usually don't call holding unless they see it.
#2 Refs right. I don't think he touched it.
#3 Not in the video.
#4 Refs wrong. The ball was not tipped, however, the PI was a little weak as Utah was completely covered so the Utah player was essentially drawing the PI instead of going for the ball so I'm OK with the outcome.
#5 Refs wrong. Elbow down before goal.
#6 Refs right. BYU was covered so he pulled him down.
NICE TRY! TREFS NWERE DEAD WORNG EVERY TIME!
Where is that hold on the return? I have watched this in every angle I can and I NEVER see a hold. Plus they throw the flag as soon as they see him get away from the defenders. I call foul play by the refs. I mean, it's the same guys from the horrible call in the Wisconsin vs. ASU game.
As a BYU fan who was at the game. I thought lots of these were blown calls. BUT after watching the TV cameras view i think some were the right call.
1.the hold on the kick return is questionable. There may have been holding at the back end of it but it wouldn't have affected the play. So it should have been a no call.
2. That was the right call, he didn't touch it...unfortunately.
3. That's not in the clip.
4. That was the right call, ball was tipped, but it would have been PI otherwise.
5. Sadly, barely the wrong call. Alisa had the ball back at his stomach, he may have barely broken the white line, hard to see from the angle, but unlikely.
6. This one is tough, Porter seems to get his hands on him, but they're just battling for position and Mathews pulls him out of bounds. Could have gone either way.
#5 remember it doesn't matter where the man is, it matters where the ball is. The ball has to cross the line in order for it to be a touchdown. As you clearly pointed out Alisa has the ball by his stomach. No TD. #4 I have trouble with, it's whatever the rule is. I'm more inclined to side with the commentators than the refs in a situation like this because they view these types of plays on a consistent basis, whereas the refs have to make a split second decision. Who knows maybe the guys up in the booth are right, which I tend to be more on that side, but who knows they may be wrong.
usteeler81 Yeah, I know its where the ball is, my phrasing probably didn't sound that way. It was at his stomach, I'm saying it's possibly the ball barely broke the white line before his knee touched, though I doubt it. With #4 they went back to look at the replay so it wasn't a split second decision and it showed that the ball was tipped. Split second decision it did look like a PI though. It was a smart move by Bronco.
Could have gone either way? Are you serious?
the only one that looked questionable was the touchdown where the guys elbow was clearly down before the ball crossed the line.
"When The TDS goes in the Big XII?" You're counting chickens, son, that haven't hatched. Plus, The Big XII is the weakest of the P5's!! And a conference that won't last. Also, remember the last game Taysom played Utah? Ya. He looked like he did understand the game. Just remember, when Utah wins this year's game, what will be your excuse with all those great players?
just stumbled on this video, I have never known fans to blame the refs after EVERY loss like byu fans... its always the refs fault they lost. what a joke Go Utes!
Rob Chesley lol pull your head out of your ass.
I mean, the guy that posted this is a Utah fan, so it's not like a BYU fan is complaining with this video.
Victim stories.
BYU never loses. It's always the fault of someone else.
Bro. No.
Bottom line is that PAC 12 referees did a poor job similar to what they did between Arizona State and Wisconsin a week earlier. If you watch Coach Wittingham during the game, even he was going nuts over the calls that were being made. Only AFTER the game was over that he suddenly changes his tune.
Boo hoo 😢
BYU fans are always looking for sympathy! Lets face it, BYU is scared to play big teams. The Utah State loss was a good example of their skill level.
What's Utah's record in the PAC-12 since they've got there? Both of these programs are not very good right now.
Darth Silverwolf Wow, I said BYU is bad right now. All these Utah fans have some serious rage at people they don't even know.
tischlerbmw21 byu is scared to play big teams huh then why did you stop playing us for three years
Shots fired. Utah is scared to play nobodys because they know they might lose. Pansies!
tischlerbmw21 is that why byu schedules games vs big teams every year?
I am confused as to why this Video is even here?
Controversial plays are and will remain a pain in the butt!
I will forever tell all of you that the game is what it is - to try and dispute anything after it is over is madness.
Funny, if the refs weren't helping out BYU, Utah would have but at least 40 on BYU that night. Instead of complaining, maybe BYU fans should thank the refs for not getting embarrassed that night. I hear there's a spot in D-3 open for you, BYU.
+Roy Baiamonte Doormat indeed. Fool.
BYU's too small to be a Division 3 school. Sure we might not be at the top, but the biggest mistake that people can make is sending BYU down. BYU has more students than Utah and so if you're saying based upon size, then Utah would be sent down before BYU. They do it based upon size, not how good teams are.
Why am I not suprised this video got posted. I was at that game and honestly it got annoying how many times Byu fans would scream because they thought the refs should of thrown a flag with a play. Yes there was certain plays that should of gone the other way but it's sports that's what happens sometimes. Byu had a couple chances to score in the red zone and the Utes defense stopped them. I love the holy war but after going to the game last year I think it's a great thing to not play for 2 years.
the whole 4th and 18 drive (after the 4th and 18 )in 2007 was a total joke, but im ok with it because if BYU doesn't win sometimes then what kind of rivalry would it be?
Thanks to you guys it's no longer a fun rivarly
BYU constantly gets screwed by refs. More so than any other team in college sports. Refs are prejudice against them because of their religious affiliation. And the commentators were so biased toward Utah it was sickening.
All of this is completely untrue. Byu and espn are best of friends.
Every team gets screwed by refs. Not just yours. Watch other games and you'll see it's not exclusive to byu.
I was at this game. This was frustrating.
7 in a row. Let's go Utah football!!!!
@WIll Barker. D-3? Really? get off of your Pompous Pac 12 High Horse. Your team will never be as prestigious as those like Oregon Stanford and USC.
How old are you, 12?
Huh? what does that have to do with the price of rice in china?
you just commented on a thread that is 2 years old LOL