Mysterious Ripples Inside Our Galaxy May Finally Have an Explanation
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- You can buy Universe Sandbox 2 game here: amzn.to/2yJqwU6
Hello and welcome! My name is Anton and in this video, we will talk about a new study that explains why our galaxy may have mysterious ripples inside of it.
Paper: arxiv.org/abs/...
Support this channel on Patreon to help me make this a full time job:
/ whatdamath
Space Engine is available for free here: spaceengine.org
Enjoy and please subscribe.
Twitter: / whatdamath
Facebook: / whatdamath
Twitch: / whatdamath
Bitcoins to spare? Donate them here to help this channel grow!
1GFiTKxWyEjAjZv4vsNtWTUmL53HgXBuvu
The hardware used to record these videos:
CPU: amzn.to/2LZFQCJ
Video Card: amzn.to/2M1W26C
Motherboard: amzn.to/2JYGiQQ
RAM: amzn.to/2Mwy2t4
PSU: amzn.to/2LZcrIH
Case: amzn.to/2MwJZz4
Microphone: amzn.to/2t5jTv0
Mixer: amzn.to/2JOL0oF
Recording and Editing: amzn.to/2LX6uvU
Thank you to all Patreon supporters of this channel
Specifically, great thanks to the following members:
Mark Teranishi
Mayumi
Morrison Waud
Vlad Manshin
Lilith Dawn
Daniel Rosvall
Greg Lambros
Nick Dolgy
Luminger
UnexpectedBooks.com
Richard Colombo
Bartholomew Macaluso
Jer
Lauren Smith
Michael Tiganila
Albert B Cannon
Konrad Kummli
Lyndon Riley
Michael Mitsuda
Jordan
Dave Blair
Ralph Spataro
George Williams
Shinne
Alexander Leimbeck
Jakub Glos
Johann Goergen
Henry Spadoni
Adam Lee
Jake Salo
Mercei Levi
LS Greger
Gordon Cooper
Tracy Burgess
Kai Raphahn
Sander Stols
Sergio Ruelas
Vinod Sethi
Russell Sears
Jayjay Volz
AA
Olegas Budnik
Robert Wyssbrod
Anataine Deva
Zachary Fluke
Madzor
Daniel S
RandalM
L Joseph Parker
Gary Steelman
Michael Koebel
Shelley Passage
Liam Moss
Bodo Graßmann
Steven Aiello
xyndicate
Honey Suzanne Lyons
Becky
Steven
Chase Staggs
Dale Andrew Darling
James Myers
Peter Hamrak
Niji
Matthew Lazear
Steve Wotton
Timothy Welter MD
Assaf Dar Sagol
Brian Szkotak
Mr Fluffington
Anton Reed
TBPony
Charles Nadeau
Minovsky Man
Anton Newman
George Lincoln Rockwell
Dave A
GrittyFlix
Paul Koploy
Sal Carrera
Doug Baker
Doug MacDonald
Jacob Spencer
Robert MacDonald
Rock Howard
Daniel Coleman
Vincent L. Cleaver
Veronika A. Czebe
Lee Densmore
Sir David Coyne
brian plummer
David Lewis
JohnTaylorWalker
Kyle eagle
Jon Haynes
Tarik Qassem
Claye Griffith
George Naumov
Michael J Fluharty
Howard Zhang
Hampton Tunis
Nathan Egan
Janne Vuorenpää
Lynn Johnson
Rob Law
Scary ASMR
Eric White
Ivan Gallagher
Troy Schmidt
Jordaen Davids
Greyson Flippo
Thierry Ray Jehlen Gasnier
William Warren
Bill Codair
Douglas Burns
Andrée Rosén
Chaos Gamer
Jan Šoulák
Alberto Diaz Saldana
Harry Evett
Rafael Aguila
Kearny Li
Marcin Jan
Adam Smith
Aaron Fineout
Aanand Joshi
Uwe Böhnke
Deanna Korell-Hall
Carla
Samuel Mathison
Josh Shultz
Dipen Bhattacharya
Tedd Speck
rfc1135
gene valle
david jungerman
JL Solidum
Doug Beeferman
Joseph Thompson
Sol Bergeron Beauchemin
Men I Trust
Luis M Gaytan Tovar
Brittany House
Luciano Sanchez
Lisa Stadlbauer
tom g.
Arp Lee
Lisette Ramos-Voigt
Rs Wlms
Reynir Örn Bachmann Guðmundsson
Márton Fülöp
Check the Patreon page to join.
You’re killing it with your videos. Thank you so much and please keep going
Great video. It would be amazing to see how the Milky Way looks like from Andromeda.
He breifly showed a view of the Milky Way from the Large Magellanic Cloud once and it was beautiful.
I was there yesterday. I would say small, very small.
@@SyriusStarMultimedia
R u Sirius? :/
Matt Lynn Very. I don’t joke about science.
Interesting theory, it's better than my explanation that Sagittarius A drank too many ethanol nebulae and was doing a bit of drunk driving on a galactic scale.
Great vid Anton! I curious about how the central black hole from such a massive dark matter galaxy ( Ant 2) affects our milky way black hole and how they differ
@phuc ewe woah... Bit of a mind fart right there.. How can something be darker than something without light?
Anton your amazing and very intelligent . Thx for always making amazing educational and fun videos. Your a high inspiration not just for me but for everyone who watches. Keep on the path of making these videos and never stop. Thx!!!!
Almost 300k subs. I hope you get it at the end of this week buddy. You are awesome
Goku and beerus was sparing again. Damnit
Always love tuning into your videos man. Always something new, and always interesting! Keep up the great work man!
Again Anton...
Excellent video!
See you on the flip side.
I’ve been watching your channel since you had about 10k subs, and I still enjoy this due to the simplicity of his videos! Thanks Anton 👍🏽
Bro, would you make some space Merch? Help support ur channel ya know
hey Anton I love your channel, been binge watching/catching up but I always keep wondering how do astronomers know how much dark matter there is anywhere in this case that small galaxy? ...maybe a vid idea
What would the night sky look like if you live in a planet orbiting a star in ANT2?
Yes, we have to give her respect. 'you've got ripples darling not wrinkles'.
Born To Late To Explore The World
Too Early to explore the universe
Born Just In Time to watch Wonderful Anton and Browse Dank Memes
I urge the people who watch his videos EVERY DAY, like me, just give they guy a buck a month. I feel obligated because of his dedication and how often I watch his videos. It’s the least we can do. Keep chuggin Anton.
Is Anton the Bob Ross of Space?
Or is Bob Ross the Anton of Art?
Clever 😊
I saw him painting.A remarkable man l think, didnt know about him until recently 😊
It's not a real scientific paper until it's been on with Anton. _Published?_
Ehh, a few people skimmed it. _Anton?_
Now that's an accomplishment :-)
I've learned recently that our solar system resides on a spire off shoot which may have been a collision such as you alluded to in your video. The wave like structures are reminiscent of (possible very large) gravitational waves.
Antlia 2 is the pebble that landed in our galactic pond.
I have been accused of spacing out. But never before has anyone ever told me to space out. 🤤
Back to back amazing videos. Thanks anton
Every video completely changes my perspective on the universe.
I get goosebumps just listening to the amazing facts that you share keep on doing the good work
THERE WE GOOOO THAT WHAT DA MATH INTRO😂😂🤟🏾
I want to have a beer with Anton, man.
Your videos are so educational and awesome..😍😅
Agree very much
If dark matter affects galaxies, did we ever observe dark matter affecting planetary orbits around other stars?
The ripple pattern looks just like the illustrations of spiraling gravity waves emanating from the collision process of two blackholes.
'Seriously I think Anton should sell T-shirts with his face on it the front and a slogan that reads "Space out!"
Good idea
Dha ! This really needs to be explained.
It looks like the heliospheric sheath of our solar system. It looks like a rose fanning out.
The best way to think about galaxies for me is the how networks form (just like computer science network theory). Some are centralized (Milky Way / Andromeda), some are de-centralized (in a merging process or in a process or breaking), some are totally distributed and look like peer to peer networks (Magellanic Cloud for example).
Even more fun is if we find out it was in some way 'engineered' :)
After watching this video I am wondering how different would our sky look if we were further out on the edge of the galaxy? Would we see less stars in parts of the sky?
what is the time scale of these collisions?
Thanks Anton... you are great!
I kept waiting for our host to jump into full Bullwinkle voice or for Rocky to jump into frame. Just kidding, loved the video
Oh... you put "RIPPLES" and here I thought it said "NIPPLES"...
Amazing video as always my dude
Haha dark nipples
Well, it is the Milky Way...
I start my day with your video
Dauk Mattaz?.... What about the Total Mass of all that ElectroMagnetically- charged Dust encompassing the Galaxy and where's the evidence of "DarkMatter?"
Dee James
Exactly.... from planets to dust, plasma, gas, and electromagnetic interaction. They more than make up the missing mass. Dork mutters is just ridiculous.
Ring around rosy,
Pocket full of posy,
... but its space,
where do we fall,
and where is the down?
But did you know Ruffles have ridges?
Whoever figures out what dark matter is will win the Nobel Prize.
In contrast, if someone figures out a way to cool a bucket full (5+ liter) of boiling water to room temperature in an instance, say in less than 10s, he'll be able to become a billionaire overnight.
@@aniksamiurrahman6365 does rapid cooling technology have such a large market potential?
@@zodammit Have you done it already and still broke?
@@aniksamiurrahman6365 no, i just cant think of massive market potential for that, but ive never thought about it before
I know what it is! It’s a made up filler to keep the gravitational model at the forefront of astronomy because general relativity falls out when explaining the motions of the stars in galaxies and clusters as well as the Big Bang. Lucky we have wonderful mathematicians to create imaginary variables or general relativity would be in trouble. The weak force we call gravity is the force they are banking on to explain what we see.
Love your videos Anton!
I learn more here, from Anton, than any paid education endeavor.
“...THIS professor...” lol playing it safe
Love this channel thanks anton
The explanation is in the fact that other life exists and that they are extremely powerful hamon users
+Ovi 113 i love how toxic the internet is.
I see the buzzword gang is all here.
+Peter Houle lol
I literally just came from the “Coda breaks into your house to use your microwave while singing fighting gold” video
I hope The Milky Way has good collision insurance coverage, the dents obviously didn't just buff out.
Great as usual. Thanks
I'm skeptical about any hypothesis that relies on dark matter. Anyhow, great video as aways Anton.
@@renocicchi7346 That's my point, it's to useful. It's used very casually to explain away anything we don't understand about the workings gravity and to fill in the darkness left behind by our primitive technology and the flaws in observational methods.
I am sorry to interrupt but I agree and I have a better........ Truth
It's very hard for sciencists to figure out anything true because they don't understand the nature our this universe.
They usually look for something that interrupts time... As if time exists as particles while it's just movement relativity
First ! Thank you for sharing updates in research. Always a pleasure watching.
actually your not first, your fifth
@@Wm7forthewin Your Toxic...
+Tobby Jean how?
Well done!
Anton talks about travelling in the southern hemisphere
Me: boi I love in the southern hemisphere
Best channel on youtube!
You know u like this content. Smash that 👍LIKE👍 button when the video starts cuz u know u will forget. 🤔
Jesus Christ I try not to think about dark matter being solved. It always seems so far away....
Its amazing how you disappear and show up on the side of the screen....
Magic 😊
Our milky way galaxy IS IT SPINNING COUNTERCLOCKWISE? SO ALL THE STARS IS THERE A PLANETS ORBITING AROUND EACH STARs? LIKE OUR SUn?I WONDER IF ALL THE PLANETS SPINNING COUNTERCLOCKWISE TOO? THIS IS VERY INTERESTING VIDEO ANTON!!! I really love it......
Venus spins clockwise. A Venetian day is also longer than a year. We don't really know why.
WOW! VERY INTERESTING!! I THINK IT IS...thank you so much for the answers... NOW ITS VERY CLEAR TO ME AND ALL MY FRIENDS ASKING....
As the smaller dimmer galaxy passed though our galaxy it stole electrons because the center is more positive than the edges of the Milky Way. So it became negatively charged. There is actually a theory that negative charge pulls in neutral matter. It is a very week field. So negative charge generates "negative pressure" and the response of space-time is by weak anti-gravity. In total, the pull in will win against the anti - gravity. The pulling in effect depends on Force = GQ/srqt(8Pi G Epsilon0)r^2, Q is charge, G is Newton's constant, Epsilon0 is the permittivity of vaccum and r is distance. The force is actually 2 * GQ/srqt(8Pi G Epsilon0)r^2 and anti-gravity acts in the opposite direction -GQ/srqt(8Pi G Epsilon0)r^2. At least large portion of the Dark Matter effect is not WIMPS or SUSY particles but it is also not a pull by electrons. If the edges of a galaxy are more negative than the center and it rotates, a warp drive appears towards its center. So it is an electro-gravitational effect. The theory describes matter differently than in QFT. Matter is actually fields that prohibit geodesic motion in space-time. Gravity is simply the response of space-time to that disturbance. The reason for this prohibition can be viewed as misaligned Causal Sets. The original paper was published in IOPScience June 2017, Electro-gravity via Geometric Chronon Field by Eytan Suchard. Since then Appendix B was corrected and so is (35) in the original paper. One of the outcomes is a good assessment of the Fine Structure Constant. There is an unpublished paper too, which is even better. It corrects bracket typos and gives a better explanation of electro-gravity in the sub-atomic level. The quantum building blocks of the theory are realization events of space-time. Where these events are misaligned you see matter.
And I are the only person wondering how they know exactly how galaxies look like because they are so large and scale light from one end of the Galaxy is much older than the other end. To know what a Galaxy looks like at any given moment would require putting together a lot of data on movement
Very interesting.
“Space out and as always bye bye” shouldn’t it be: “and as always space out, bye bye” ???
Is it possible that if our solar system passes thru a patch (cloud perhaps) of dark matter that it would be detectable or even cause disruptions to the ort cloud and send a comet storm to earth?
Why are galaxies colliding period? There is so much space (pun intended) out there they shouldnt be gravitational attracted to each other. Unless, there is something else we cant see.
Difficult..... We have our " local group" of galaxies, which are presumably held together somehow.... Maybe groups of galaxies are expanding away from each other while these groups hang together...... So much we still don't know, that's what makes astronomy the most interesting of sciences..... Still so much to do, even for the amateur.
Super cool!
I thought the thumbnail said Our Galaxy Has Hippies...
Why does the Milky Way look like water going down a drain? Is the whole galaxy going down the tubes?! :'D
Fascinating
but then if a galaxy made almost entirely of dark matter collided and fused with our own Milky Way ,l assume a high percentage of all that dark matter became part of our galaxy if we can determine how the motion of stars was affected by its presence comparing before and after we could potentially know the how the increased mass of dark matter affected the motion of starts within our galaxy or may be move a step closer to understanding what dark matter actually is
That's a great idea! But I doubt it would be possible to get an accurate idea of the before motion from millions of years ago.
How else can 1 explain the frozen food inside the esophagus of a Wooly Mammoth?!? It’s a Flash Freeze that happens after the earth’s atmosphere is blasted away by a “Mini-Nova”.
0:01 The ripples (spiral arms) are compression waves
Really interesting! 😃
Anton, I love your videos and watch every day. But I must object to the 'new' version that eliminates 'dark matter' from the rotational vectors acting on not only the center, but all the way to the periphery of galaxies, falsely showing the much slower motion of stars as one leaves the center. How can we make statements about a 'dark matter' galaxy causing ripples when your preferred simulation does not factor in the discrepancy in angular motion of stars further from the center, and how this affected the rippling? I am sure that factors we do not yet understand cause the unexpected speed of peripheral stars, so I will use 'dark matter' as a place-holder for what we will eventually discover is the reason for it. Simulations should, as least, include the obvious effects verified by observation even if we don't know exactly how they are generated. It will be difficult to credit the simulations that do not include this observed effect. Can we agree that the programmers found it cumbersome and extremely difficult to simulate this effect, but that it should be included in any simulations that purport to mimic reality?
It's hard to take dark matter seriously if no one can find it. They've been looking now for, what, 50 years?
it took 100 years to confirm Einsteins theory of relativity, be patient
It took 1200 years to comfirm UY Scuti Size.
The name dark matter is a misnomer. It Should be called "missing energy"
it's so dark that you can't see it lol
@@glasstuna no it shold be called dark gravity since all that we can observe from it is gravity
Please explain to me how we know that it has dark matter when we can't see nor detect dark matter?
Ripples is the universal way of how energy propagates. It wasn't a collision. Ups, better sprint to the next phone booth.
So which Galaxy was our solar system in originally?
We don't know and probably never will. Unless we get unbelievably lucky.
What causes the solar system to ride up and down crossing the galactic plane like a merry go round horse?
To know what the Galaxy actually looks like at any given moment would require putting together a lot of data galaxies are so large that the light from one end of the Galaxy is much older than the other the Stars will have moved by the time the light from one end of the Galaxy would even get to the other end of the Galaxy
Now that's a run-on sentence.
Thanks, Dr. Doofenschmirtz!
A Galaxy is a really large washing machine that eats your sox
Anton, I have a question. If we ask where the center of our universe is, the answer is that we (Earth) are the center. I understand that we can't see beyond 13.8 billion light years, but if the universe is hundreds of billions of light years in size and we are toward a far edge, then 1. we are not the center, somewhere else is. 2. Could we determine this at some time or not? 3. I am not planning a long trip, just curious.
@Larry Nobles The issue of the "observable universe" is complicated by the Big Bang Expansion which is pushing (almost) everything apart from everything else and is accelerating. At the time of of the BB there was no matter, only energy at stupendous temperatures. The matter only came into being (a bit) as things cooled down enough for the forces of nature to split from each other and do their creative thing. There is therefore no centre from which we are all expanding. Essentially everywhere is the centre and we are constrained by the speed of light as to what light has had time to reach us from distant parts. If we choose to consider ourselves as the centre we can see (visible light, radio waves, x-rays etc) out to just over 43.5 billion light-years so the observable diameter is just over 96 billion light-years. Unless we can beat the light speed limit, we're not likely to be able to see more -including an edge- any time soon, sadly.
@@Sparky-vj2dq Thank you for answering my question.
Energy in distribution and transformation
This collision will become just a footnotes in that Galaxy looong history, you'll see..
The answer is dark matter. The new go-to answer when you don't really know.
Yes, it is. And also: collisions. In fact, it seems to be collisions all the way down.
lol, true
@@rameyzamora1018 Well. We're all here because of our ancestors' collisions so there's that.
Did Antlia 2 slingshot around the black hole in the center of the Milky Way?
is the audio out of sync?
Merci
Ripples in the DARK MATTER???
RipPLeS iN tHe MaTTer DaRk
3 billion years ago we faced a galactic collision, in 4 billion years we’ll face another by adramoda... damn, the milky way is getting beat up.
Marthlake
I swear I’ve seen you in like, at least 5 other videos I’ve watched. Btw, fire emblem was a childhood favorite.
+Nayeli Aguilar ya, i’m all over the internet.
Anton what do you think the about the Plasma Universe Theory? It seems to question intelligently the existence of dark matter, dark energy, and the fundamental beliefs most cosmologists and astrophysicists hold about the nature of gravity. I have not heard you comment at all about this. I understand it is highly controversial. I certainly don't miss your episodes.
Alberto Diaz Saldana Well, it’s not so much controversial as it is outright wrong. Plasma Universe is a theory that was worked up in the 1960s, but it was rejected for numerous reasons. The most obvious issue is that it doesn’t fit our observations of the universe. Much like Electric Universe, it’s now just a pseudoscientific tinfoil hat concept.
Time for anorther asmr
“Electric Universe” is the search term you are looking for.
magnetic fields do not have mass. Go back to school
Dark matter it what??? this didn't tell me anything
Audio is off :S
It feels like they put dark matter into anything they don’t understand lol
The Dr.s name is Sukanya Chakrabarti.
All these assumptions... we don't even know if dark matter exist ffs... Maybe we should first prove or disprove the existence of dark matter, before we use it to "prove" other theories ?
Dark Matter has already been proved using Einstein's Theory of Relativity. We just don't know what it really is, It definitely exists and there are indirect Proofs of it (Through Gravitational Lensing).
@@melodicnostalgic3823 "It definitely exists" ?! No it doesn't. For example Erik Verlinde's theory of Emergent Gravity is proof that not all physicists believe dark matter is necessary to explain the cosmos. So no, there is no consensus in the science community that dark matter exists or not.
@@melodicnostalgic3823 Also I remind you of the following statement: "It is scientific only to say what is more likely and what less likely, and not to be proving all the time the possible and impossible." ;-)
lol, may I remind you you opened your comment with "Dark Matter has already been proved using Einstein's Theory of Relativity."... no sense in quoting Feinman when you do it yourself ;-)
Da church of space ology
Could the Sun have been created in another galaxy and captured by Milky Way in some sort of galactic collision?
Yes, but we'll probably never know.