With 20 seconds left in the game, red or yellow don't really matter. Now what happens with the "review board" or whatever it's called after the game with respect to a ban, that matters.
@@martinfeldman2529 that link states the sanction for tripping is a penalty. It doesn't describe the factors where an additional yellow or red card applies. E.g. it also states the sanction for a high tackle is a penalty, but it doesn't distinguish between an accidental high tackle, where the tackle starts on the chest but the arm rides up, and a deliberate swinging forearm to the face. One is a penalty only, the other would warrant an immediate red.
How did the green 17 manage to stay on? Dangerous grubby player..he's in everything and the clips only 5 minutes long.. stupid dangerous play at the breakdown and scrum..
Yeah thought that myself, you always get players like that, in the thick of all the pushing and fights yet he doesn’t do his own job right during play, typical chancer
Dirty bastard with the trip, hate seeing that in Rugby, the game is over, no hope of a losing bonus point and out with the leg for a sinister trip, red card ref
That’s rugby! Being send off for fighting but then without a single shred of back talk to the referee walking off the field shoulder to shoulder. I’m a girl but I LOVE RUGBY!!!! 🏉💚🤍🧡🏉
😂😂 Last time I was sent off, was for punching my opposite number for persistently barging me in the line-out. Found out the following week, he was a Church of Scotland Minister 😱😱😱
@@scooters47 If you start to give penalties away after the captain has told you to channel that aggression in the right way. Your own team will let you know all about it.
@@spencertaylor303 it's not about how badly he landed, it's that his upper body is lower. Although looks like tackled player really milked it but that's hard to prove unfortunately
@@usr7941 Lower player milked it for sure but the onus is not on the ball carrier but the tackler in this case. Honestly, the league wants tacklers to assume the bulk of the responsibility in a tackle situation, but it DOES take two to tango, to coin a phrase. I wait for the day when a call like that is reversed because the player did milk it. But how could one tell?
@INDIANFUKINGALLTHEWHITEGIRLS Disagree. Watch the video. He sized the guy's pace and speed up before extending his leg. Watch his eye movements and body language. He was static, not advancing forward at the guy. He was a static obstacle and he showed deliberate intent. I stand by my position.
@@kevingeorge8203 No, it builds black eyes, and the need for revenge. Keep the game clean. Any "biff" in games I control sees a plyer binned for 10 mins. And I don't care how many I have to bin.
Wtf is going on with the new tackling rules ?! I know they want to protect players but come on !! In few years tackling will be illegal. I'm a rugby player and I choose to play that game knowing the risks. Like boxing or MMA.
@@numadread1 I play touch for that reason but, in the IRB's view, better tackling technique in the seniors leads to better tackling in the juniors and kids. And THAT's the big issue. To the leaders of the game, the seniors must, MUST set the example for the juniors and the kids. I don't agree, per se, but I do see their point.
@@BigBlack81 I'm all for better tackling techniques but the speed of the game is insane (wich is good) and sometimes shit happened. They just need the VAR to see if it's intentional or not. But nowadays red cards and disciplinary actions are flying. I mean the first yellow card is bullshit. I'm alrightish with the rest.
timmo491 um. Honestly don’t know what to say to that. The tackler lifted his legs above the horizontal making it dangerous and illegal. There isn’t much to it, not really any argument against that
Rory Banks “Over the horizontal” is not mentioned in the tackle laws or in the lifting tackle directive. The correct application of both law and directive is that if you lift a player in a tackle you become responsible for their safe landing. Blue 14 in my view did achieve this: even without Green 11 using his arm to break his fall, he would have landed on his back. This really should be, at most, a penalty to green.
Probably the only way to make the cl/rabo direct/guiness/magners/pro12/pro14 or whatever hell the name is now, is to allow a few digs like ice hockey. The rugby itself is pretty terrible
They want the tackle to be done safely and correctly every time. They're going to use the cards to get it through players heads that safety is first in the modern game. Can it go too far? I think in that instance it did, but I get their point. It's the tackles people think are harmless that are actually the ones which do the most damage, and the IRB wants it out of the game.
the sponsors should take their names of these teams ...disgraceful...... reminds me of the pro rugby games where there is no respect for the love of the game .......this is bad ......
No wonder less and less people are watching the Pro14 them first two yellow cards was so pointless. Sucked all the fun and entertainment out of the game.
Keith O'Shea along with the word “edinburgh” in the title name why the hell would edinburgh want to start a fight when there up by 30 points makes absolutely no sense clearly connacht were pissed off they were dominated at the scrum and around the field and there frustration boiled over
Uk rugby seems to be teams of foreign mercanary players playing for money.. its lost itself like football has to money.. its violence fighting and ugly
#1 14 Blue is probably fortunate the player chose to protect himself. If that player goes where the original lift was probably intended, that card is red for a spear tackle. #3 Double yellows correct for the reason the touch judge noted. #4 Not sure of the Laws on this one, but if it's similar to soccer in this regard, that's a clear Red. He was away and that was a FLAGRANT PROFESSIONAL FOUL.
![Referee Mathieu Raynal attempts to control rapidly degrading game. [Sale vs Connacht '19]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IDAHnLKDJBc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Referee Mathieu Raynal attempts to control rapidly degrading game. [Sale vs Connacht '19]](/img/tr.png)
Love the sportsmanship in the to guys that shock hands ran off together
Honestly the best thing about this was that there were four cards and not one of them needed a several minute TMO intervention
That’s rare for the pro 14 lol
And that the entire team didn't jump.on and scream in the refs face like a football match
That leg trip at the end was never a yellow. It was a nailed on straight red.
yep definately
How that’s not a red and 3 match ban is beyond me
Agreed
With 20 seconds left in the game, red or yellow don't really matter.
Now what happens with the "review board" or whatever it's called after the game with respect to a ban, that matters.
Maybe, not disagreeing. But how, on the laws, is it a red? Definitely a yellow, but I just don’t know which law makes it a red.
I love how players give each other the business then after walk off shaking hands and off to the pub for a pint after the game...You gotta love rugby.
Should be red for the trip...commentator trying to excuse it by saying its instinct!
nomatesman it’s poor defence skills, he got beat easily
Apparently it is a yellow.
laws.worldrugby.org/?law=9&language=EN
No. 12 under Dangerous Play
@@martinfeldman2529 that link states the sanction for tripping is a penalty. It doesn't describe the factors where an additional yellow or red card applies. E.g. it also states the sanction for a high tackle is a penalty, but it doesn't distinguish between an accidental high tackle, where the tackle starts on the chest but the arm rides up, and a deliberate swinging forearm to the face. One is a penalty only, the other would warrant an immediate red.
Ya
At the end should’ve been a red and penalty try
And a two-game suspension.
Man of the match... I'd of given it to the Ref!!! 👍
How did the green 17 manage to stay on? Dangerous grubby player..he's in everything and the clips only 5 minutes long.. stupid dangerous play at the breakdown and scrum..
He knew he fell. XD #heisagrub
Yeah thought that myself, you always get players like that, in the thick of all the pushing and fights yet he doesn’t do his own job right during play, typical chancer
He's the cementhead sub they throw in to protect the good player when they are getting drubbed and there's no hope of a win.
Began as union, ended as league.
Yellow for a trip! RED any day for me, I saw a team mate’s career finished from a leg break from a trip 😡
01:47 - "I KNOW I fell!"
01:50 - Falling. With STYLE. LOL XD #WTFDUDE
Dirty bastard with the trip, hate seeing that in Rugby, the game is over, no hope of a losing bonus point and out with the leg for a sinister trip, red card ref
They knew it was their last chance of a barney before lockdown.
I'd just like to see a live game again.
The worst thing is the trip, dirty c***!! No place for that in rugby. Straight red in my opinion and ban for life.
Well, maybe not for life, but at least until he has learned to play the game properly, or until he get past being 13 years old, mentally.
I don’t know what other rugby supporters think of this behaviour but personally I think it’s embarrassing
-5:07 made me laugh. Blue 14 is like 'yea you come on bro.. pft shit maybe not'
Best sport on the planet.
That’s rugby! Being send off for fighting but then without a single shred of back talk to the referee walking off the field shoulder to shoulder. I’m a girl but I LOVE RUGBY!!!!
🏉💚🤍🧡🏉
It shouldn’t matter if ur a girl, you don’t need to justify yourself. You go girl
I love rugby too ❤️
😂😂 Last time I was sent off, was for punching my opposite number for persistently barging me in the line-out. Found out the following week, he was a Church of Scotland Minister 😱😱😱
@@cnoc500 should not matter in the game
Some of these youngsters really should carry handbags!
Very good refereeing in fairness
What was wrong with the first one?
Guy was tipped over the horizontal. Automatic yellow
Nz 70s 80s had this sort of business.
Dear Oh Dear RED !!!
Hit him!
Phill, 'e ain't worth it!!!
Billy, your faaaaaamily!
Vinaka Sau...🇫🇯🇫🇯☝️☝️
Heck who'd be a ref ?
MVP??? The Referee😉
The first sequence smelt bad...the ref should have done more than the yellow.
First tackle was fine? No? He's barely horizontal.
Neighbors so excited. Normal
Oh no Eroni Sau..
The ref had lost control of this game and the players knew it, very unprofessional on their part, !
He needed to have a chat with the captain's at the start.
When the Adrenaline is running you trend to ignore all the early instructions,ìt becomes the survival of the fittest
@@scooters47 If you start to give penalties away after the captain has told you to channel that aggression in the right way. Your own team will let you know all about it.
@@dangriff12 Give awaytoo many pernalties and the coach will pull you off and you get to warm the bench for a long time.
Good to see the celts fighting amongst each other😀
Nothing wrong with the first tackle
Nothing wrong with yellow card for a tip tackle
Usr he didn’t land bad he landed on his hand and his legs didn’t go over his head.
@@spencertaylor303 it's not about how badly he landed, it's that his upper body is lower.
Although looks like tackled player really milked it but that's hard to prove unfortunately
@@usr7941 Lower player milked it for sure but the onus is not on the ball carrier but the tackler in this case. Honestly, the league wants tacklers to assume the bulk of the responsibility in a tackle situation, but it DOES take two to tango, to coin a phrase. I wait for the day when a call like that is reversed because the player did milk it. But how could one tell?
Handbags
What a fucking crock these new tackle rules.
The trip was a red..what a disgrace for rugby..
Utter. Complete. Total. One of the worst trips EVER. Red and multi-game ban, honestly. We don't want that in the game.
@INDIANFUKINGALLTHEWHITEGIRLS Disagree. Watch the video. He sized the guy's pace and speed up before extending his leg. Watch his eye movements and body language. He was static, not advancing forward at the guy. He was a static obstacle and he showed deliberate intent. I stand by my position.
Not a single punch thrown......bring back the biff 👍
so you find entertainment in violence. go watch UFC or boxing.
@@n0wsinn love a bit of violence me, builds character
Gone are the olden days, when rugby was a mans game
@@kevingeorge8203 No, it builds black eyes, and the need for revenge. Keep the game clean. Any "biff" in games I control sees a plyer binned for 10 mins. And I don't care how many I have to bin.
first yellow was a shit call
I thought there won’t be aloud to play rugby in 2020
Wtf is going on with the new tackling rules ?! I know they want to protect players but come on !! In few years tackling will be illegal. I'm a rugby player and I choose to play that game knowing the risks. Like boxing or MMA.
some professional rugby players prefer living longer and not having brainissues.
@@Booyabeatbox in that case you play 7 or rugby without tackles. And I don't say that to troll. You got a choice.
@@numadread1 I play touch for that reason but, in the IRB's view, better tackling technique in the seniors leads to better tackling in the juniors and kids. And THAT's the big issue. To the leaders of the game, the seniors must, MUST set the example for the juniors and the kids. I don't agree, per se, but I do see their point.
@@BigBlack81 I'm all for better tackling techniques but the speed of the game is insane (wich is good) and sometimes shit happened. They just need the VAR to see if it's intentional or not. But nowadays red cards and disciplinary actions are flying. I mean the first yellow card is bullshit. I'm alrightish with the rest.
The first tackle is absolutely nothing.
He lifted him over the horizontal. That’s illegal
@@rorybanks2223 he was already horizontal dur
timmo491 um. Honestly don’t know what to say to that. The tackler lifted his legs above the horizontal making it dangerous and illegal. There isn’t much to it, not really any argument against that
@@rorybanks2223 he wasnt tipped from the vertical end of
Rory Banks “Over the horizontal” is not mentioned in the tackle laws or in the lifting tackle directive. The correct application of both law and directive is that if you lift a player in a tackle you become responsible for their safe landing. Blue 14 in my view did achieve this: even without Green 11 using his arm to break his fall, he would have landed on his back. This really should be, at most, a penalty to green.
handbags
That us why, boys and girls, you Do not mix rugby with soccer.
Milked it
Never a tip. Tackled play was looking for it
Bro in our schools game we got 11 yellows and 2 red between the two teams 😂
Um I agree with the commentator it is purely instinct to try everything to stop someone scoring
Halen Mahia nothing instinctive about trip a player on a rugby pitch .. it’s dirty dangerous foul play
Your opinions
Probably the only way to make the cl/rabo direct/guiness/magners/pro12/pro14 or whatever hell the name is now, is to allow a few digs like ice hockey. The rugby itself is pretty terrible
The world has gone mad. That first one just isn't a yellow card. Grow up.
They want the tackle to be done safely and correctly every time. They're going to use the cards to get it through players heads that safety is first in the modern game. Can it go too far? I think in that instance it did, but I get their point. It's the tackles people think are harmless that are actually the ones which do the most damage, and the IRB wants it out of the game.
Connaught were bad lol.
the sponsors should take their names of these teams ...disgraceful...... reminds me of the pro rugby games where there is no respect for the love of the game .......this is bad ......
Wise talk ..
Is it one of your favorite game
Professionals.. and people pay for this shitshow
The croud may kive it neck and head inhuries will suck later in life
M
Roid rage maybe?
Rugby has become to soft. A yellow card for the first tackle is crazy!
No wonder less and less people are watching the Pro14 them first two yellow cards was so pointless. Sucked all the fun and entertainment out of the game.
This Isis what happens when you have a weak referee officiating...
The Pro14 really sealed their own caliphate choosing him as ref
banjoarefood Underrated comment
The ref. should have been given a red card.
Looks like he had one..
John lewis, so you are an expert. Then why are you not out there reffing the game, or are you justthe normal keyboard dumbass.
Could have predicted a Scottish team would be involved
Ok
Yeah I guessed the same thing mate, by reading the word ‘Edinburgh’ in the title
Keith O'Shea along with the word “edinburgh” in the title name why the hell would edinburgh want to start a fight when there up by 30 points makes absolutely no sense clearly connacht were pissed off they were dominated at the scrum and around the field and there frustration boiled over
@@boom4301 *They're
Snake _ cheers pal a month after i make a small youtube comment you bother correcting my spelling of 1 word😂
Uk rugby seems to be teams of foreign mercanary players playing for money.. its lost itself like football has to money.. its violence fighting and ugly
Connacht is in Ireland
mob of thugs , stay of the steroids , just play this wonderful game .
Soft ref killing the game
Watta whack call this sport going soft asf the first yellow wasnt even suppose to be a card
#1 14 Blue is probably fortunate the player chose to protect himself. If that player goes where the original lift was probably intended, that card is red for a spear tackle.
#3 Double yellows correct for the reason the touch judge noted.
#4 Not sure of the Laws on this one, but if it's similar to soccer in this regard, that's a clear Red. He was away and that was a FLAGRANT PROFESSIONAL FOUL.
Handbags